Why this is an extremist Government

The cancellation of the announced tax cuts for 2008, which can only be seen as a particularly spiteful act, reminds me of how this Government is such an extremist one. And I use that word carefully and only in relation to their tax policy.

Jordan Carter argued last week that Labour Governments will always spend more than National Governments, and hence this is why they will not reduce tax.

But this paints the situation as black and white – almost a fundamentalist approach to fiscal matters. And the truth is in almost every other developed country in the world it is about shades of grey.

Since 1999 the economy has grown by $52.3 billion. That’s a 48.8% increase. Even allowing for inflation it has increased (to Dec 2006) by $25.1 billion or a 24.6% increase.

Now as one would expect, as the economy grows, and the population grows, the amount of government revenue and specifically tax grows. And from 1999 to 2008 the amount of tax revenue has grown by $24.5 billion or around $3 billion a year.

Now here is where the extremism comes in. The fundamentalist approach. Jordan is certainly right that a left wing Government will spend more than a right wing Government. But what one would normally expect to see is something like this.

A centre right Government might propose that it would spend 60% of the extra $3 billion in taxation on extra spending, targetted assistance etc and give 40% back in tax reductions.

A centre left Government might propose that it would spend 80% of the extra $3 billion a year in taxation on extra spending, and give say 20% back in tax reductions.

This is how it is meant to be. A choice between balanced priorities.

But Labour under Dr Cullen have taken the extra $3 billion a year. A total of $24.5 billion and has spent the lot basically. They will find money for savings incentives, for welfare, for foreign aid, for everything you can think of. But despite taking in an extra $24.5 billion a year, they can’t find even one dollar to return to those who pay the tax.

Look this budget is probably one of Labour’s better ones. I like some of what they are doing with Kiwi Saver. I think some of the increase for overseas aid is a good thing. But it is the total refusal to be balanced which grates. Instead of $70 million more for overseas aid, why not $60 million more and $10 million back to taxpayers. That’s a win win. Instead of $1.2 billion on Kiwisaver, why not $1.1 billion and $100 million back to taxpayers. Instead of $1 billion of WFF why not $800 million and $200 million back to taxpayers.

In eight years Dr Cullen has taken a Taliban approach to fiscal strategy. No one expects Labour to not spend more than National. No one expects Labour to give as big a tax cut as National would. That is why we have choice between parties. But to have $24.5 billion of extra tax revenue, and to refuse to give even 1% of it back let alone 10% or 20%. That is extreme.

It is the ideological equivalent of an ACT Government, not a National Government. An Act Government would probably have given back the entire $24.5 billion, and not increase spending by a single dollar. (Libertarianz members stop drooling). Labour doesn’t cut income taxes by a single dollar and spends it all. This is not mainstream economic management.

In countries like Australia, the debate is at the centre, where it should be. It is a choice between should the spending:tax cut ratio be 60:40 or 80:20.

NZ Labour in some areas is moderate and centrist. In its approach to taxation it is extreme left. And by refusing to even inflation adjust the tax brackets, every year almost every NZer ends up paying more and more tax.

Already 14% are in the top tax bracket, up from 5% in 2000. A further 6% are in the $50,000 – $60,000 range. Within a couple of years they will probably be over $60,000 and you’ll have 20% of taxpayers paying the 39% rate. Another few years and it will be 30%. This is what happens when you do not adjust the tax brackets for inflation.

Over the last eight years Peter Costello has delivered tax cuts of around 30% to 50% to every Australian earning under $100,000. Dr Cullen has delivered not even the packet of chewing gum.

The money go-around

Let’s look at an example of how the budget will affect a typical business. Let’s say it turns over $5,000,000 a year and makes a 10% profit before tax. That is $500,000. Now the 3% reduction in corporate tax means their tax bill will drop by $15,000.

Of the $4,500,000 in expenses, assume half is salaries. That is $2,250,000. And assume all the staff are intelligent and take up Kiwi Saver. That means the employer has to contribute 4% or $90,000. Start to see the problem?

Now the $90,000 will be helped with the tax offset. Let’s say you have 35 staff so the tax credits are $36,400. That still leaves you paying $53,600. Now the tax will reduce by 30% so your net cost is $37,520.

So Dr Cullen’s $15,000 tax reduction has been not just wiped out but with $37,520 of net kiwisaver contributions, you suddenly are $22,520 worse off.

The after tax profit was $335,000. Now it is $312,480. So your after tax profit has dropped 6.7% when it was meant to increase by 4.5%.

So Dr Cullen has in this example imposed extra costs on business equal to increasing the corporate tax rate by around 5%.

Clark on You Tube

The Government is catching up and in a first has put a video summary of the budget by Helen Clark on You Tube. Well done to them for starting to embrace the medium.

While it is a bit unfair to compare the PM promoting the budget to the Opposition Leader doing a tour of Parliament, I am struck by how relaxed and natural John managed that video, while Helen does come across somewhat stilted. But to be fair the video is about promoting the budget not Helen.

I hope the Nats do put up on You Tube John’s budget response speech. I love the few minutes of it I saw, and would like to see the whole thing.

The Budget lockup

Well I’m at my first budget lockup. All went smoothly getting in except my name was down as Farrah. Arrgh – memories of high school teasing about Farrah Fawcett Majors. A few media types joke with me about lowering the standards with bloggers being allowed in.

Have given up my cellphone and Blackberry but am allowed to keep my Vodafone data card on condition I do not use it until the embargo time has passed. I don’t think I have ever been separated from my Blackberry for so long. Well maybe when I sleep but it is of course at the bedside table!

Working out exactly what Kiwisaver means for employers and employees was my main challenge and the Treasury staff were superbly helpful in checking my calculations and correcting them. The one who helped me (she was referered to as a Kiwisaver expert) was a devastating combination of intelligence and beauty. Sigh – back to the budget.

Some of the Treasury staff remembered me from the days when I was part of the team putting together the budget communications package for the two months in advance. It was interesting being on the other side back then as not all your colleagues were cleared for budget secrets so you have to spend a couple of months being very careful who one could or could not discuss the budget with.

Dr Cullen took questions from the media and analysts present. I got to ask two question to him about Kiwi Saver – asking him whether there is a political risk for him that a future Government could convert the Cullen Fund into Kiwi Saver accounts (I suggested such a move would have his Foreign Minister’s support) if the take-up in the future reaches say 90% or so. He said he would fight that with all his strength. He did not disagree though with my assertion that employees would have to be very stupid not to take up Kiwi Saver, and it may be seen as de facto compulsory over time.

They put on a small lunch for us and had a nice chat to NZUSA people who were also in the lockup, plus various media people.

I thought I found a mistake in the Budget Economic and Fiscal Update to do with income from the Superannuation Fund but it turned out not be a mistake – the fund does technically make a tax loss one year. I managed to keep the excellent Treasury staff busy with a series of inquiries.

OBERAC has been renamed OBEGAL just to annoy us. Also the new international financial reporting standards mean that accounts from previous years will not be directly comparable to accounts from 2007 onwards which is a pain for people like me who like to study the trends.

Anyway Dr Cullen is just finishing his speech so time to go. Very much enjoyed being in the lockup. Having three hours to read all the info was really needed to usefully comprehend it, and being able to ask the staff for clarification was also very useful. Most of all getting to directly question the Minister of Finance on his budget, is very cool. I can’t see it happening in most countries! So thanks to Dr Cullen’s office for letting me in the lockup as media.

Budget 2007

I’m in the Budget lockup today, from 11 am to 2 pm. So I plan to start blogging details of the budget once we are released. However as people will have noticed, the front page can take hours or longer to rebuild, even though there are new posts, or changes to existing posts.

So what I am going to do is add on to this entry, any details of the budget. So after 2 pm clicking on the permalink for this entry and hitting refresh/reload should bring up the latest for you to comment on.

As predicted (thanks to Winston) Kiwisaver has significant changes to it. They are:

• Employer contributions become compulsory
• Both employer and employee contributions eligible for tax credit of up to $1,040 a year.
• This will make the scheme almost de facto compulsory as a employee on the average wage of $40,000 will for their $1,600 contribution effectively get $2,248 from the Government and $392 from their employer meaning total contributions of $4,240 for their $1,600.
• The more expensive an employee is, the more the employer has to pay, as the employer tax credit is capped.
• Overall it is a significant contribution by Government with $1.2 billion a year in 2010/11 going towards it
• The tax credits are not inflation indexed so over time as people earn more, the employers will end up with more and more of the bill.
• The table below shows how the scheme will work for three wage levels, once it is fully implemented in 2011:

kiwisaver.JPG

The Orwell Award goes to the press release which says– “The employer tax credit makes it much easier for employers to provide matching contributions” – the employer has no choice anymore as to whether it will provide them – they will now be compulsory!!!

As expected the company tax rate drops to 30%, which will costs around $500 million a year. Also a 15% tax credit for research and development which means those activities (which are narrowly defined) will be taxed at only 15%.

Talking of tax, 14% of taxpayers will now be paying the 39% tax rate, up from 5% in 2000. And those 14% will pay 53% of all income tax.

TAX CUTS CANCELLED

The previous announcement to move the tax thresholds next year has been cancelled on the grounds they would be inflationary (yet somehow all the extra spending will not be). So people will continue to pay more and more tax as these thresholds are not indexed, with us not even getting the chewing gum tax cuts. Definitely a case of eating cake.

Dr Cullen has adopted wholesale National’s policy for all charitable donations to be tax deductible.

Provision is made for regional petrol taxes in every region up to 10 cents per litre. No more than 5c can go on roading so the rest must go on public transport.

The surplus for this year is projected to be $6.3 billion and over the next four years after that a total of $22.7 billion. And not one cent of it coming back to those who pay it. Tax revenue is projected to increase from $52.2 billion this year to $62.0 billion in 2010/11.

Also of key note is Dr Cullen has done his usual job of increasing the contingencies – they were $1.9 billion a year cumulative, but now are much higher. $1 billion of them is tagged for the business tax reform but what it means is when Dr Cullen say the 2010/11 forecast surplus is for $5.4 billion, that is including a contingency of $10.3 billion for new expenditure.

Overall the good are the business tax cuts and the tax credits for Kiwisaver.

The bad are the compulsion on employers to subsidise Kiwisaver, and most of all not only refusing to give personal tax cuts but cancelling the tax cuts already announced.
Continue reading »

Joke III

Anti Smacking Bill now passed

The anti-smacking bill has now passed and once it gets royal assent the Crimes Act will be amended to remove the defence of of reasonable force for parental correction. It replace it with reasaonble force for the purpose of stopping a crime, preventing harm, preventing offensive or disruptive behaviour and good parenting so long as it is not correctional. And with the Clark/Key compromise an explicit statement that Police can use discretion when the offence is inconsequential and a prosecution would not in the public interest.

It passed 113-8. Those against were two from ACT, Gordon Copeland, Judy Turner, Taito Phillip Field and in a hilarious attempt at populism, four NZ First MPs.

I still regard the bill as pretty flawed law, and suspect it will have to be revisited at some stage. The compromise did provide some welcome direction to the Police and should hopefully see the Police avoid Subway type trivial prosecutions in this area. But for me the concern was never prosecution but more how CYFS could use the law, and the possibility of couples going through a divorce using it as a tool in custody battles etc.

Harry not going

The head of the UK Army has decided that Prince Harry will be too big a risk as a high profile target, and will not be deployed to Iraq, due to specific threats against him.

He will be gutted and kudos to him for being so firm in his desire to go. It does highlight the consequences of having a hereditary monarchy where people by virtue of their birth alone are given a special place in society. If not for that he would just be a 22 year old solider of no interest to the insurgents.

Public Sector Blogging

The Dom Post reports on a discussion on public sector blogging at the GOVIS Conference.

I think the public sector would gain considerably by allowing people to blog about their work (within the normal limits of secrecy for some stuff).

The first reason is because it would be a very useful way to get information out to interested members of the public. If for example a social policy researcher at MSD had a blog at which they summarised and linked to interesting research in their area, that would get some following.

The second reason is that it is very easy to regard the public sector as faceless and soulless. Having individual staff able to talk about the areas of work they are involved in, helps dispel that perception and will lead to some better awareness of what different parts do.

The third reason is that it could lead to better policy, with blogs as a two way information tool. If a health policy analyst has a blog, not only could they talk about some of their research, but members of the public could comment on it, and perhaps refer the staffer to other relevant research etc.

Public sector blogs would not just work well for policy roles though. I’d love to read a blog by Treasury staff about the challenges in putting together high quality monthly consolidated accounts for the Govt. Also to have Treasury and IRD staff talk about revenue projections and the reasons for different models etc.

National’s Climate Change Target

No Right Turn originally blogged that he thought National’s target of a 50% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2050 was rather underwhelming. To his credit he has reevaluated the target on the basis of emissions per capita, and has now concluded it would be “doing out bit”.

What I would still like to see is some ballpark costings of what the costs will be of such a reduction by 2050, and what the benefits to NZ will be. It will obviously not affect global temperatures at all significantly (I suspect it’s impact is around 0.001 of a degree) but the benefit to maintaining trade access can and should be estimated.

NRT has a fair point that at some stage one would want some intermediate targets also. Yes this should be done but we should be aware that change does take considerable time. Unless one wants to plunge NZ back to pre-industrial era, one can’t just close down the coal powered energy plants etc. I mean even if one decided tomorrow they were all to close, it would take 10 – 15 years to get consents for all the replacement plants.

What is good news is the approval by the Environment Court of the Makara wind farm.66 of the 70 proposed turbines were approved and it will end up generating enough power for most of Wellington.

Xero going public

Xero, the company selling an online accounting solution of the same name, has announced an initial public offering for people wanting to invest in the company.

I blogged back in March that I was impressed with Xero – both the concept and the actual product.

In the Dom Post Tom Pullar-Strecker writes that Xero has a chance but is no sure thing, saying the best asset Xero has is “the admittedly impressive credentials of Xero’s management team and their ability to market the company to success” rather than any technology trend.

Fronde CEO Jim Donovan is more bullish, blogging that “the chartered accountants love the features designed for them, and will no doubt be pushing it to their small business clients” and sees 10,000 customers as a modest milestone. Donovan concludes “So I’m buying in. I’m not betting the house – it’s very pricey for an early stage deal. If the share price drops after the initial euphoria wanes (and it probably will), I’ll probably pick up some more. If it works, and I expect it will, I’ll do very nicely, thank you.”

For my part, having read through the 100 page offer document, I’ve decided to apply for some shares. Now people should not regard this as financial advice of any sort. I am not a financial analyst. What I will say is to point out the obvious. Investing in Xero is a relatively high risk investment as they are a new company with no guarantee that their product will prove popular enough to cover their costs. But the counter to that is the potential rewards are significant – much more than interest from your bank account. So my advice is not to invest any money you can’t afford to lose, if you do invest. But I have enough faith in not just the product, but also the board and management of Xero to take a risk, in the expectation of worthwhile returns.

Disclosure: I have absolutely no financial ties to Xero, its directors or staff. I am socially acquainted with their CEO and their Market Communications Manager. Neither have asked me to invest or to blog about investing. I am doing both at my initiative.

Government loses another MP

Ten days ago I commented:

United Future, I hear, is having the Christians depart unhappy with Dunne on smacking.

I didn’t expect it to go so far as to include on of their three own MPs. But as everyone will know by the time this post actually appears, Gordon Copeland has quit United Future and is reforming the Future NZ party with former MP Larry Baldock.

This will be a big blow to United Future. Such messy infighting will not appeal to the public. It does give Dunne some opportunity to use it to show that UFNZ is not anymore a “Christian party” but a secular centrist party. But I suspect many of the members and funding will follow Copeland.

I see little opportunity of the new Future NZ party making the 5% threshold or winning a seat.
This move by itself does not threaten the Government in terms of supply and confidence, but does make passing laws that much harder.

If the Greens abstain, then confidence and supply votes will be 59 in favour and 56 against (if Maori Party vote against which is by no means certain).

Labour will be very unhappy this is announced they day before the budget. Headlines this week will be not just about the budget but about will the Government go full term etc.

Also of concern is that Copeland holds a key swing vote on certain committees, so legislation progress could be much more difficult also.

Fiji now illegally detaining suspected bloggers

I’m waiting for the bloggers who have cheerleaded for the Fijian Dictator to admit they were wrong. His latest move is to detain a businessman on suspicion of being a, yes blogger.

The businessman may have been mistreated during his interrogation.

The Dictator is also trying to get the local telco to block access to blog hosts such as Blogspot. Freedom of speech takes another nail to the coffin in Fiji.

Chief Intelligentsiya makes the point:

The attempts to block access to blogs and continuing detentions are blatant dishonouring of the commitments the junta gave to the EU in Brussels last month when they promised not to intimidate or infringe on the rights of Fiji’s people, in return for continuing aid.

We know the EU is watching. Just don’t wait until it’s too late.

It would be very nice also if the NZ Government lent its voice to such protests.

Walking and Bus Stops

Lindsay Mitchell blogs on the advice Scottish Police have given out to men, to help women feel more secure when alone in the evenings:

“Resist chatting to a woman who is waiting, for example, at an isolated bus stop. She won’t know that you mean her no harm. Remember that a woman may also feel threatened by what you think are admiring looks.”

The leaflet reiterates previous advice that men who find themselves walking in the same direction as a woman should cross the street to reassure her that she is not being followed.

Now it goes without saying that casting “admiring looks” at a woman alone at night is not a good thing to do, beyond the normal smile or visual recognition of each other.

It also goes without saying that crossing the street just because there is a woman on your side is somewhat of an overkill. Not to say that one shouldn’t be sensitive about the nervousness of being followed. I sometimes get nervous when I can hear or see the shadow of someone behind me. Likewise I often go out of my way not to stay behind someone when walking along, by walking at a different pace to them.

What is interesting is the issue of chatting at bus stops etc. I’d be interested to hear from women especially on whether they find it worrisome or a relief if someone strikes up a conversation at a bus stop. Part of me thinks that one might prefer someone who is friendly (not sleazy) and comments on the book they are reading or other such banial stuff. It sort of humanises them as less likely to then drag you around the corner. Personally I’m not a bus stop chatter, and believe the best stranger is a silent one. But others might disagree?

Joke II

Russell Brown on Investigate allegations

Russell Brown has provided some background on some of the more serious allegations in Investigate, and that some may have already been covered in a book by a former police sergeant, Tom Lewis.

Ian Wishart responds to Russell here.

More importantly the allegations have been referred to the Police Complaints Authority. I think this is the sensible course of action. I hope the PCA realise that they need to investigate the allegations using their own resources.

Best Business Book Title Award

Fronde CEO Jim Donovan (with some help from me) has selected the highly commended and the winner in the contest for the best title for a NZ Business Book. Highly commended were:

* Accounting Secrets of the Quipu, by Rod Drury (Bwooce)
* Discipline in the Workplace, by Sue Bradford(Glenn)
* Rich Dad, Rich Dad, by D Myers (also Glenn)
* Successful Team Building, by Bill Ralston (David Schnellenberg)
* Guaranteed returns: A Guide to Property & Foreign Exchange Investment, by Doc Bollard (Jason)
* Brand Aid: Seven Secrets to Boosting Your Media Profile, by the Exclusive Brethren (also Jason)
* Doing Your Business in Public, by Jerry Collins (Andrew Bannister)
* Australian Expansion Secrets, by Stephen Tindall & Theresa Gattung (John, who deserves a special round of applause for the most entries).

All very witty, and very good. The overall winner though can’t be beaten for timing and relevance:

* Corporate Uniformity: Brand Enforcement, by the Mongrel Mob (submitted by Bwooce).

There were around 100 entries in total I would say. Well done to all the winners.

Another great UN move

Guess which country has just been elected Chair of the United Nations Commission on Sustainable Development?

It is the country which has had negative GDP growth since 2000, inflation at 1600% and much of the population are starving?

Go here for the answer if you still can’t work it out. This just shows what a contempt for human rights most members of the UN have.

This is the same body that has elected Iran as a vice chairman of the U.N. Disarmament Commission and Libya as chair of the United Nations Human Rights Commission.

A Classics prize to Mr Griffin

Peter Griffin was in the HoS writing about the terribly exciting Encyclopaedia of Life, which I blogged about earlier this week.

It is interesting to note it was inspired by Wikipedia, but contributors will be vetted for this project, as one can do when you have tens of million in funding.

But what really impressed me was Griffin’s reference to Pliny the elder. Pliny who died two days after the eruption of Mount Vesuvius, which destroyed Pompeii, was a superb example of how advanced the ancient Roman society was. He wrote a encyclopaedia series of 37 books on natural history.

His encyclopaedia was treated as authoritative for centuries after he died right through to the middle ages.

Pot blames kettle for consent delays

The Dom Post reports:

The Government’s call for more renewable energy is being hobbled by slow consent processes for wind farms, prompting Environment Minister David Benson-Pope to call in chief environment judge John Bollard to discuss the delays.

Blaming the Judges for the delays when the Government has not only refused to amend the RMA to allow for quicker decision making on consents, but in fact has made changes which make delays even more likely – well classic pot calling the kettle black.

The RMA changes do not have to reduce the ability of the community to have their say on consents. It is about reducing the time and complexity of the multiple stages, and the ability to take a case directly to the Environment Court if you know it will inevitably end up there anyway.

Mike Moore on Gangs

Ouch. Former Labour Leader Mike Moore is not being subtle writing in the NZ Herald:

You know a government is running out of puff when politicians say, “If a problem was easy, it would have been fixed years ago”.

Who could he be referring to?

For many politicians, a problem only exists if it is on the front page and appears in opinion polls. Take the time spent on the anti-smacking legislation. Action to appease public opinion was cleverly taken when votes were being lost. As though violent parents will check with the law library before they hurt their babies.

Much, maybe most, of drug sales, prostitution, and probably counterfeiting, is done by gangs. Their management pyramid is based on a perverse reversal of normal community standards and sanctions. To get promoted, you must commit offences, rape, beat, steal and sell illegal substances.

We need an anti-gang czar to head the authority that brings together the Police, Customs, Immigration, Corrections, Labour, all welfare agencies, even the Security Intelligence Service, to keep track of these villains.

We need someone who, every morning, thinks, “What are those bastards up to and how do we hammer them?” Every time a gang member travels overseas, starts a business, registers a car, applies for a benefit, we need to know.

This is in fact something I advocated on Saturday. I don’t think you can ban gangs. I am not even sure about the wisdom of banning their patches. But you can use the current laws to put them out of business with a zero tolerance policy. Just as they got Al Capone on his taxes, use every weapon at one’s disposal to break up the gangs. Do random WOF checks of their cars. Check for arms every fortnight. Have the IRD and WINZ scrutinise for tax and benefit fraud. Set up a police station next door to their gang headquarters.

A lot cab be done within the existing laws. It requires the right attitude from the Government, from the Police and from other law enforcement bodies.

Watch them hide

It is amusing to watch in Auckland as the Council has tried to pull a swifty to fool the ratepayers. After the backlash against their huge rates increases of 11.4% and 13.4% for the last two years.

Now instead of cutting back their spending, they are just trying to make it look like they are spending less by hiking up water charges instead – up 19% in two years.

But what I find funniest in the story is the reluctance to comment:

Mr Hubbard, who promised more “openness, transparency, honesty and accountability” at the start of his mayoralty, yesterday was reluctant to discuss the financial problems at Metrowater and price rises of 19 per cent in two years for the 142,000 customers in Auckland City.

The mayor said he was not at the committee where the latest price increase was discussed and had not had a chance to go through the background papers. “It is on my list of things to go through tomorrow.”

Finance committee chairman Vern Walsh, whose City Vision ticket promised at the 2004 elections to keep water bills “fairly priced”, could not be reached for comment.

The drink driving limit

The national road policing manager has called for the legal blood alcohol limit to be reduced from 80mg per 100ml of blood to 50mg per 100ml of blood.

As with all things, one needs to look at the benefits and costs.

The benefits are fairly obvious. There would be some reduction in accidents and deaths caused by drivers affected by alcohol. However it would be pretty minor as the vast majority of fatal accidents involving alcohol are not in the 50 – 80 mg range but well over 80 mg.

Looking at MOT research there were 100 fatal crashes, killing 155 people, involving alcohol in 2005. They estimate a social cost of $660 million from

Quite fascinating is the licence status of alcohol affected drivers in fatal crashes. Only 43% have a full licence, with 27% on learner and restricted and 15% not legally licensed at all. So lowering the blood alcohol for drivers on a full licence will only affect a minority of fatal crash cases.

bloodalc.JPG

Now this graph stolen from the MOT shows very clearly where the problem is. The vast majority of crashes are when people are double or more the legal limit. The numbers in the 51 – 80 range are in single figures, and this is for over three years. I’m somewhat stunned by the numbers who are triple the limit!

So the benefits of a reduction to 50 mg are not particularly large, compared to the overall problem.

Now let us look at the costs:

A 50 mg limit would mean a couple could no longer safely share a bottle of wine over dinner. It would mean you couldn’t even have two or three drinks legally after work unless you get picked up or like me can walk home.

Overall it would seriously reduce normal everyday socialising, without significantly affecting the drink driving problem which consists of young drivers or repeat and disqualified drink drivers who are generally twice the existing limit anyway.

It’s not just about a chicken

Ian Wishart makes a worthwhile point on his blog, that while everyone is laughing about the policeman and the chicken, it is about far more than that.

According to the same sources (former officers) who were correct about the bestiality video, they are alleging a police cover up of a paedophilia ring, of police gang rapes, of Class A drug use, of killing a cat and chopping it up onto a BBQ, and corrupt dealing with brothels.

Now I have no idea if these allegations are correct or not. The video one has turned out to be. I can understand the media not wanting to publish the other allegations until they have investigated them, but please don’t anyone say they are not serious enough to be investigated.

The article has named half a dozen police and political figures. The media has the duty to put the allegations to them and not accept “no comment” for a response. I, like many, do not know if what is alleged has happened. I would like the truth to come out.

But turning back just to the video, I do wonder if the Police Commissioner still gets it, even today. Look at this story in the Dominion Post:

Mr Broad said the incident reflected another time in police culture. If it happened today, he said he would expect it to be discussed with the officer’s supervisor and “some internal action taken”.

Umm this reeks of the double standards of the 1980s. Have a discussion, and internal action. Let us be clear about this. Bestiality videos are illegal. The penalties [under current NZ law] depending on what you do with them range up to ten years jail. The correct response from the Commission should be “If it happened today the police officer who possessed and/or showed the video would be charged”.

Greg O’Connor also fails to make the distinction when he says:

“The reality is, if watching a pornographic video in the 1970s and 80s were a bar to holding higher office, there would be very few people eligible.”

Again let us be clear. Watching most porn is perfectly legal, and yes many many people have done it. But pornography which involves rape of children, rape of animals or rape or torture of other adults is illegal and a serious criminal offence. And most NZers have not watched such stuff.

But again at the end of the day, the video is not the important issue. It is the other allegations that need to be rebutted on the record by those accused (and if they have been defamed they should sue for defamation), or an official inquiry of some sort needs to occur.

April Public Polls

Curia’s monthly newsletter summarising the polls in NZ and several other countries, is out later today. You can subscribe to it at this link to receive the full report direct to your inbox.

apr07polls.JPG

As one can see, the trend in 2007 continues of a widening gap between the two major parties. And for the first time ever, the average of the public polls show National able to form a Government with ACT and United Future, without being reliant on the Maori Party.

The graph above does not include the latest TV3 poll as that was conducted in May.