Does NZ First now support free trade?

Winston Peters, along with Jim Anderton, has been one of the biggest advocates of trade barriers instead of free trade.

That is why trade issues were removed from his remit as Foreign Minister.

Yet today we read that has been lobbying US politicians for a free trade agreement with the US.

Now if this means Winston has seen the light, that is good news.

But does his party agree with him, or is Winston playing solo? Do all the NZ First MPs now support free trade, or at least free trade with the US? Does the Party organisation? What about all those anti free trade remits they have passed over the years?

Well said Winston

Labour’s plans to secretly get a majority in favour of direct taxpayer funding of political parties has hit a snag. Labour, Progressive, Greens and maybe Maori are all set to plunder the taxpayer. But without Taito Field they have only 60 votes.

Winston Peters was the most unequivocal in rejecting the idea. He said it perfectly:

“You get support the old fashioned way on the streets and the hamlets of this country”

Absolutely.

The key for me isn’t so much taxpayer funding per se, but that any change must not be rammed through without an electoral mandate. Those parties who support it should campaign on it for the 2008 election, and if they get a majority then they have a mandate to implement it after the election (not retrospectively).

Labour is playing with fire by trying to do a secret deal with the Greens and Maori parties. Let me quote the normally sedate weekly editorial by the NZPA Political Editor, Peter Wilson:

Has the Government lost its mind? It is playing with fire by even thinking about legislating for state funding for political parties without the National Party’s agreement.

State funding would be a fundamental change to electoral law, trying to do it without the main opposition party on board would mean an unacceptably flimsy basis for change and a politically dangerous move.

Pitch Invasion Law

My initial reaction to the proposed law where pitch invaders can be jailed for up to three months and fined $5,000 was pretty negative. Existing laws can cope I would have though.

But I can understand the commercial sensitivity. If Coke has paid $2 million to sponsor a world cup match, and someone runs onto the pitch in a pepsi logoed top, that is unfair, and something which is happening more and more.

So I have a solution.

Make it an offence to run onto a pitch or ground, unless the person doing so is naked 🙂

That way the potential for ambush marketing is halted, yet the fine tradition of streaking continues.

Homosexuality more dangerous than smoking!!

I actually laughed out loud when I saw on the Family First website a news story from overseas about how smoking reduces life expectancy by one to seven years, while homosexuality reduces it by 24 years.

First of all the research showing homosexuals die 24 years earlier is highly suspect, and not based on a random population sample. US research shows it is in fact around 1.2 years.

But even if it is greater than that. So what? Do they want the Government to run campaigns warning homosexuality may be dangerous to your health? Do they want to fund workshops to *cure* people of their addiction to homosexuality?

Do they think an 18 year old just decides one day they will be homosexual because that sounds like more fun, and that if they were aware of the shorter life expectancy they might just decide not to be homosexual?

Or maybe they think the Ministry of health should run a campaign that “fags are bad for your health” – both sorts!

Personally, while I think the research is rubbish, even if it was true, it would just show that homosexuality is not a choice, for who would choose to have a shorter life?

An angry Raybon Kan

Raybon Kan is well known as a very funny man. But today in the SST he is angry, and with good cause. He is angry at the spineless Mayors who didn’t attend a performance because the Consulate of China rang them and asked them not to. Some extracts which one can only endorse:

Let’s get some facts out of the way. The Divine Performing Arts troupe includes practitioners of falun gong, which as far as I can tell, is an earlier, slower form of pilates. It’s banned in China. Then again, so is freedom of speech. And freedom of the press. And the Dalai Lama. Well, if it’s as bad as any of those things, falun gong must be terrible. It might even be as bad as democracy. Democracy is so bad, it doesn’t even need to be banned. China’s 1.3 billion people simply reject it unanimously. (What do you mean, how do they know? They just know. Of course there’s hasn’t been a vote. Don’t be ridiculous. That would be democracy. They. Just. Know.)

Well then. Imagine you’re a mayor of Auckland. How lucky that the Chinese government rang to save you. Your delicate mind might have been brainwashed! What a near miss, with the Olympics next year!

China’s website says falun gong is a cult. Let’s say it is. Let’s say falun gong is a cult, bent on bringing down the government of China (through tai chi). Hell, let’s say it’s a cult waiting to be picked up by a UFO. Maybe the giant gatherings for tai chi are really a human crop circle, to guide the spaceship in. Wouldn’t you still find it just a teensy bit suspicious, here in New Zealand, to be rung up by the government of China, and urged not to see a dance troupe? For a country that doesn’t allow protest, it seems China protest too much. Scientology might be a cult, but you don’t see the White House telling Dick Hubbard not to see Mission: Impossible.

I never imagined dance could be this powerful a political act. Then again, China’s always been into the arts: how well I remember the dance of the sugarplum panzers. Oh, that killed them in Tiananmen Square.

So here’s the thing. A New York performance troupe visits New Zealand. A third country, China, rings New Zealand leaders and tells them not to attend. And the Kiwis, without exception, do as they’re told. I’m starting to agree with Winston Peters: we have become part of China. Hmmm. I wonder what it costs to get a mortgage in Tibet?

This dance troupe comprises people of Chinese ethnicity, but obviously, no carriers of Chinese passports. Chinese nationals tend not to be seen dead professing falun gong. The last they get seen is while being arrested. Then they tend not to be seen, all becoming permanently, strangely reclusive. If falun gong is a religion, I can only imagine its main tenet must be life after death. Or life after life imprisonment. Or after torture. Or execution. You’d better hope there’s some reward for these people.

The very least that people in free countries can do is encourage freedom for those who don’t have it.

I just love the way his sarcasm drips with contempt. And he is absolutely right.

Matthew Hooton: One of the guilty

Matthew Hooton confesses to being one of the guilty. Yes he helped write and promote the forerunner to the NCEA, and concludes that in hindsight they were too ambitious, they tried to be too pure.

Everyone gave the new system a fair go. Unions, employers, teachers, principals, school trustees and both our main political parties supported it. Teachers devoted unbelievable amounts of time to its development, often without pay. Over 17 years, parliament has happily appropriated more than $600 million of taxpayers’ money to NZQA to try to make it work. Education ministers representing a Who’s Who of our top politicians – Lange, Phil Goff, Lockwood Smith, Wyatt Creech, Nick Smith, Trevor Mallard and Steve Maharey – all gave it their best shot.

In retrospect, the National ministers of the 1990s were right to keep delaying NCEA and Mallard was wrong to finally press go. After all the time, money and commitment, the PPTA has found that only a third of secondary teachers are happy with the new system. The Ministry of Education says students find the system demotivating, and believe it fails to adequately recognise achievement or provide them with enough information on their learning and performance. The Council for Educational Research has found barely a third of parents have confidence in NCEA.

It may well be true, as Maharey argues, that all these teachers, students and parents are wrong, but, with qualifications, perception truly is reality. What does it matter that some extreme left-wing theorist says NCEA is utopia, when teachers, students, parents and employers disagree?

This is a crisis in our school system and the government’s response so far is unconvincing. After $600m and 17 years, it’s not credible to say further tweaking of NCEA will satisfy the majority, and reverse the rush to alternatives.

The government could make it illegal for state-school students to sit international alternatives, and nothing can be ruled out from the regime that gave us the retrospective pledge-card legislation. But unless it is prepared to take that bold step, the government has to fast accept that the dreams of the ’80s and ’90s were unrealistic and the system has failed.

Maharey is under a lot of stress right now, personally and from the hospital passes he has received from Mallard. After a decent Easter break, he needs to commit to working with international partners – perhaps Australian state governments – to have a credible qualifications system ready for nationwide implementation before the start of the next school year.

It’s not impossible. It starts with a mea culpa, and that isn’t so hard.

Gerbich claims ad tampered with

I’m losing interest in this case, but I should report the latest twist – the Sunday News reports that Debnie Gerbich has claimed the alt.com ad she placed had been tampered with.

Seems a bit unlikely to me, especially as Gerbich in another interview claimed she did enjoy bondage.

More of interest is that she has complained to the Press Council over the HoS assistant editor’s methods of trying to get them to co-operate. A lot of people will watch the case with interest.

Wayne Brown

The HoS has a profile of Auckland DHB Chair Wayne Brown with many comments from friends and foes.

I’m of a mixed mind in regard to the calls for Brown to resign or be sacked.

It’s a political reality that the Opposition needs to hold the Government to account, and when a $500 million contract is struck down by the court, the question of accountability does arise. To a degree the target is the Minister, not Brown and the other Govt appointees. By calling for Brown and co to be sacked, the Minister is the one who gets damaged if he doesn’t hold anyone accountable.

And in the case of Brown, his failure to call for conflict declarations at the beginning of each meeting was a departure from both previous practice and best practice.

But Brown has shown himself extremely proficient over many years at health board governance, and he has helped rescue failing health boards. This doesn’t just mean he has saved the taxpayer money, but by reducing costs in some areas, he actually allows more services to be provided.

It will be interesting to see what the Government does. They already have great problems finding experienced directors to serve on DHBs. If they sack Brown their job will be even harder.

HoS apologies to Sharon Shipton

The HoS has apologised to Sharon Shipton for their story last weekend about her leaving Brad Shipton.

The substance of the story may or may not be correct (I suspect it is) but the HoS story used the phrase “Mrs Shipton told the Herald on Sunday” when in fact they got their info from a family friend asserting she spoke on behalf of Sharon Shipton.

I would have thought it was a no brainer that you only claim to have spoken to someone when you have in fact spoken to them.

Audrey rates National’s front-bench

Last week Audrey Young rates the Cabinet. This week it is the National front-bench. Her ratings are:

John Key – Leader, 9

Bill English – Deputy / Finance, 9

Gerry Brownlee – Shadow Leader of the House / Energy / SOEs, 8

Simon Power – Corrections / Justice, 8

Tony Ryall – Health, 8

Nick Smith – Environment / Climate change, 7

Katherine Rich – Education, 5

Maurice Williamson – Transport, 5

Judith Collins – Welfare, 4

That’s an average of 7/10 overall.

Armstrong on National

John Armstrong reviews National since the leadership change:

Some blunt talk up and down the factionalised front bench after Don Brash’s resignation forced Bill English into rapprochement with Key. They not only discovered they could work together, but that they complemented each other. They realised they even might quite like each other.

The resulting benefits to National of this leader-deputy pairing cannot be exaggerated. The caucus started to focus outwards instead of inwards. Key picked up the baton Brash had dropped in the House. National began putting more pressure on Labour more often on more fronts.

Key has huge respect for Clark’s political skills. He repeatedly reminds his caucus that unity is paramount, and that his MPs must work even harder. Even then, he warns them that National faces a long, long haul to gain the Government benches.

Labour’s fallback option is to persuade voters that National’s leader and deputy harbour enmity towards each other, and that Key is the lightweight and English is the real leader.

Not surprisingly, the tactic is not working. It isn’t true.

I have been surprised that the best Labour can do is to call Bill English the co-leader and think that somehow this is politically damaging.

Debbie Gerbich

Patrick Gower at the NZ Herald has managed to convince his employers to pay for a subscription to a bondage and discipline website (not sure which one – I guess alt.com) to reveal that Debbie Gerbich has a profile there which says she would enjoy police and rape role-plays.

Gerbich supplied a video to the Sunday News of her having group sex with Brad Shipton and others in 2001, and claimed she was manipulated into taking part.

The evidence since then suggests otherwise with Gerbich having married one of the men in the video, and as we see today is advertising for similar activities.

Now there is nothing wrong with people who enjoy bondage – millions do. Likewise consensual police and even play rape role-plays are something many couples enjoy consensually. I would add a note of caution that personally I think you’re very stupid if you do such activities with anyone but a very trusted partner. To take part in such activities with relative strangers is damn risky both at the time and in terms of accusations afterwards,

Now in terms of Brad Shipton. He is a convicted rapist. He is also clearly a cheating sleazy bastard. But this doesn’t mean that in every encounter he has had, he has broken the law.

Gerbich herself never said the sex was unconsensual. She argued she was manipulated into it, but her marriage afterwards to one of the men somewhat undermines that. The sad truth in this case seems to be she thought she could make some money out of the video, and dramatising it up a bit, and she thought she could remain anonymous.

Really Sunday News should have checked out the background to Gerbich more before running with her story. Would have saved her a world of pain if they had.

A good idea from Mr Bolger

Former PM Jim Bolger has suggested NZ trial a scheme launched by New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg.

The Bloomberg scheme provides financial incentives for poor families with regards to their children. Such as:

* US$25 ($35) if their children have perfect school attendance
* US$50 ($69) if they keep a doctor’s appointment
* $300 ($415) if their children score highly in state tests

Families can earn up to US$5000 ($6900) a year.

In some ways it is a pretty crude scheme, and can even be seen as insulting. But on the other hand there is a cycle of poverty, of failed education, of poor health that needs to be cracked or we have more Kahui families.

What Bloomberg has done is a trial of 2,500 families and a control group of another 2,500. That seems a very good way to proceed. Judge it off its results.

The Titanic Consiracy Theory

Most people will be aware of the moonbat conspiracy theory that 9/11 was actually orchestrated by the US Government, and there is some lunatic video promoting that theory.

Well in the same vein, have a look at this video which casts doubt on the sinking of the Titanic. Hilarious.

Hat Tip: Grouchy Old Cripple

French Presidential Election

The first round of voting in the 2007 French Presidential election is on Sunday fortnight. There are three main candidates and the two highest polling will go through to a run off a fortnight later. The three main candidates (I am not including Le Pen as he is polling at least 10% behind the two two) are:

Nicolas Sarkozy, Union for a Popular Movement (right)
Ségolène Royal, Socialist Party (left)
François Bayrou, Union for French Democracy (centre)

The UDF normally are supportive of the UMP but have moved away in recent years. They are the most pro EU of the parties, actually advocating the EU become a federal United States of Europe.

Now the polls are quite fascinating. Generally they show Sarkozy ahead of Royal by 5% or so, and Royal ahead of Bayrou also by 5% or so. Their placings of 1, 2 and 3 have occurred in the last 45 or so polls.

And again the last 45 or so polls (there have been a couple of draws) have shown in a run-off Sarkozy would beat Royal.by 4% to 8%.

So if nothing changes will Sarkozy be the 8th President of the Fifth Republic?

Not at all necessarily. It depends on how strategic the left are. They have two options:

1) Hold fast behind Royal and hope that before the final vote in a month, she can beat Sarkozy in a one on one election.

2) Transfer support to the centrist Bayrou, so he makes the run-off election. If Royal drops out, far more of her support would go to Bayrou than Sarkozy. The polls show that Bayrou would beat Sarkozy narrowly.

So what is more appealing to the left? A high probability of stopping Sarkozy or a lower probability of having Royal elected?

Royal has never been the preferred candidate of many of the establishment figures (including her husband) in the Socialist Party. I suspect if she still trails in the polls a week before the first election, her support could well drop away to Bayrou so he faces Sarkozy in the run-off.

Having a President with no parliamentary majority, and in fact with almost no MPs would possibly be a good thing, as they would have to work with all. But it could also make them somewhat of a lame duck. They won only 29 out of 577 seats in 2002. If they win the Presidency, then the June legislative elections would see them improve, but not enough to have a majority.

A man full of love

I think I may have discovered NZ’s most disturbed person. Or at least the one most full of hate. I discovered him today on Good Friday when he commented on this two month old thread in favour of the monarchy and against us nasty republicans.

His comment has to be read to be believed, but some extracts:

The republicunts don’t have to keep on proving how braindead they really are.

Hates republicans

Jim Bolger was proving how dumb he really is when he sold out the people of Wanganui over Moutoa Gardens back in 1995.I will never forgive that Hell-bound Pope of Rome-worshipping wanker.

So he also hates Catholics (he is Anglican)

Bulging Bolger told lies to the people over the M.M.P. system by claiming it would bring greater democracy & curb corruption,when it hasn’t.

Bolger actually campaigned against MMP. Never mind. We can agree he hates MMP.

Another reason why I am so fiercely against the republicunts is because they have allowed the subhuman faggot,lesbian,& ‘transsexual’ filth to get ‘married’ & adopt children.

Hmmn subhumans. We can add gays, lesbians and transsexuals to his hate list.

The Maori Nationalist subhumans are allowed to get away with promoting their deeply offensive agendas.

Doesn’t seem too keen on Maori nationalists either.

The imposition of a 2 term limit for M.P.s & local councillors.

That would be interesting. The PM and all the Ministers would be either brand new or second term MPs. Hence the parliamentary staffers would get to run the country as the Ministers come up to speed 🙂

The restoration of the death penalty for serious crimes such as murder,rape,child abuse,& political corruption.

Well that would deal with the pledge card issue, but a bit dramatic even for me.

The repeal of the deeply offensive ‘Civil Union’ & the Homosexual Law Reform Acts.

Yes let’s make sodomy a crime again. Bring back the sodomy police!!

The amendment & strengthening of the Race Relations Act,1971 that would proscribe any organisation that has the promotion of a racist agenda as one of its aims,& provide for the death penalty to be imposed on the leaders of such organisations or political groups.

That’s a growing list of people he wants to execute.

I believe very strongly that the black,white,& red rag that masquerades as a ‘Maori flag’ should be proscribed on the grounds that its colouring is the same as that of the Nazi German flag,& that it is used as a way of expressing an extremely racist message.

Goodness I never noticed the similarity.

Fiji.Sanctions should be put on China,which still illegally occupies Tibet,& on Turkey,which still illegally occupies northern Cyprus (part of Cyprus,a fellow British Commonwealth member state).

I wonder if he also thinks sanctions should be placed on the UK for their illegal occupation of parts of Ireland 🙂

… told him that the only good Maori Nationalist is a dead one.

Am I the only one concerned that Mr Aidan John Work actually gets to vote?

Now he has a myspace page, and we get further depth to his views there:

I am openly opposed to any form of homosexual rights,as homosexuality is explictly condemned in the Bible,especially in the Books of Leviticus & Romans.Naturally,I am an advocate of giving homosexuals,’transsexuals’,& those who willingly perform ‘sex change’ operations the death penalty.

My goodness. Not only does he want to jail homosexuals, he actually wants summary executions of them. I can’t see why he objects to a flag resembling the Nazi flag, because for once it seems no exaggeration to say he would have fitted right in with them – after all they also executed homosexuals.

He cites as rationale for executing homosexuals the godhatsfags website and the fact Iran does it. Well shit, has me convinced.

I am an advocate of imposing the death penalty on those who engage in violent crime,smuggle narcotic drugs,promote racial agendas,or engage in corruption.

How about jay walking?

Why we do not need a sedition law

Some people may argue that we need to retain a law banning sedition, to cover cases where people pose a major risk to NZ, advocating the overthrow of the state etc.

A quick peruse through the Crimes Act 1961 find many other sections which can deal with actions more significant than a petrol soaked couch competition. They are:

* Treason s73
* Attempted Treason s74
* Inciting Mutiny s77
* Sabotage s79
* Unlawful Assembly s86
* Riot s87
* Criminal Nuisance s145
* Threatening to destroy property s307
* Threats of harm to people or property s307a
* Threatening act s308
* Conspiring to prevent collection of rates or taxes s309

It is great to see Peter Dunne state he will introduce a private members’ bill, if the Government won’t act. It would be superb if all the MPs would give it leave to be introduced, if he does so.

A great day

Went up to Pararparaumu with friends for a outdoor lunch at mutual friends. Almost no traffic which was great. Despite being April the weather was like mid summer. We spent hours outside enjoying sun and wine and chat. A great way to spend a public holiday.

Was very funny as I am chatting to one of their kids about university, as she is choosing between Vic and Otago for her first year. I, of course, am encouraging Otago and was telling her the good hostels. Her parents less impressed as I tell her about that Otago has courses such as surveying where there are about 20 guys for every girl. She seemed very enthused about that course, especially as she says most girls are annoying (and whom an I to disagree). Alas I think she will stay with her law intentions.

Left at 11.30 and got back at 4.30 – four cops on the way up but none on the way back. The headlights got plenty of use!

A quiet evening in tonight. Tomorrow sees me up in the Wairarapa during the day, hopefully trialling some assault siege constructions for use against the Beehive. Then in the evening planning a “big night out” bar hopping with some tourists.

Might see Black Sheep at some stage over the weekend.

Crazy Easter Laws

Sigh – time for my annual Easter rant about our crazy Easter trading laws.

First of all, we have the inconsistencies highlighted by Cameron Brewer – Parnell shops can trade, but Newmarket ones can not. Idiocy.

But then we have the whole notion of the state stopping employees from earning extra money, stopping customers from being able to shop, and stopping retail business owners from earning a living.

I’m all in favour of no retail employee being forced to work on Good Friday or Easter Sunday. But many of them would love to work as they will earn double and a half time effectively.

We have 11 public holidays, and they should all be treated equally.

Family First claim surveys show most families say they want more time to spend together. So, what? Those who choose to, can choose to do just that. But why force your wishes on those who would rather earn money, so perhaps they can then afford to go a better holiday the following weekend?

If one uses the logic of more time with families to justify restrictions, then why not turn the clock back three decades and ban weekend and weeknight trading. And hey let’s bring back six o’clock closing also for bars.

It’s a very simple principle for me. The state has no role in banning people from shopping. We have 4 million NZers. Some of them may want to go to church, some of them may want to be with their family, some of them may want to blog, some of them may want to watch movies, some of them may want to start work on their annual accounts, some of them may want to buy some plants. It is not for nanny state to say we will allow you to do your annual accounts but not allow you to buy a plant.

And please if you are going to debate this thread, come up with a better argument than “You can shop 362.5 days a year, surely you can live without shopping for 2.5 days”. That’s not the issue. If you accept that as a maxim, them I’ll propose laws that you can not have sex on Mondays because hey you can have sex the other 300 days a year. Oh yeah also let’s ban speaking for just 2.5 days a year – you can speak the other 362.5. Hey how about this – we could ban churches from opening on certain days, because you have all those other days you can go to a church.

REPEAL ALL SHOP TRADING HOURS RESTRICTIONS – NOW!

Parliament online

Czech Easter

Clint, who is due to marry a nice Czech girl, blogs on how Easter is celebrated in the Czech Republic.

Men and boys get a bit of birch or pussywillow to make an Easter pomlázka (stick) and go from door to door to spank women. For every woman they spank they get given a ribbon by the women and also shots of alcohol or sometimes food.

I’m sure Sue Bradford’s bill will outlaw this barbaric practice!

Death of Usenet

Another step towards the (sad) death of Usenet. Aardvark reports TelstraClear is looking to drop Usenet access, as Telecom have already done.

I was a regular in Usenet for seven years before I began blogging. Made many friends from there, and had some great debates. I haven’t connected to an NNTP server for years but do use Google Groups to check stuff out from time to time.

NZ First to pay it back – maybe

It looks like NZ First will be paying back their $158,000. Well in so far as we can tell.

Winston has said an announcement would be made shortly and it would include a cheque.

So it is probably good news. But on the other hand it might be a cheque for a legal challenge. Or a cheque for less than the full amount.

But it probably does mean repayment. I think they know they would face electoral oblivion if they were the only party to refuse to pay it back.

John Key, Drummer

Maharey vs Plunket

Russell B pointed out that I had ignored the issue which got Maharey so angry at Radio NZ. That is true – I focused on his idiocy in threatening to go to the RNZ Board instead of the BSA.

In terms of the substance of the issue, I can’t see any rational defence for Sean Plunket in asking whether the comparison to Botswana suggested racism. I’d be very annoyed if I was Maharey and would want an apology also. However I wouldn’t threaten to illegally involve the Board and I wouldn’t lose my rag in Parliament over the issue of the Minster threatening illegally to go to the Board.