A new version of an old song

Most Kiwis will know the classic Rolling Stones song “Paint it Black“. Well the Vast Right Wing Conspiracy has released a new version of it called Pay It Back.

Enjoy the song and share it with your friends and colleagues so you can sing along to:

I see a red card and they got to pay it back.
They stole from public funds now they must pay it back…

Order of New Zealand

I’m going to steal this idea from the NZ Herald. They asked for feedback on who would be suitable to join the Order of New Zealand – our highest honour and restricted to 20 NZers.

So lets have nominations in the comments section below. No negative nominations such as “Not Helen Clark” but positive ones. You can disagree though with nominations others make.

Trotter joins the pay it back chorus

Chris Trotter yesterday joined the chorus of people saying Labour must pay back any money the Auditor-General finds was unauthorised.

Now this is a huge change for Trotter who just a couple of weeks agao was definiatly praising Labour for stealing the election, saying that breaking the law was a good decision if it kept National out of power.

The Mallard scolding

Audrey Young in the NZ Herald has a brillant section on what the so called reprimand from Helen Clark to Trevor Mallard would be like:

“Trevor, it’s me. I’ve had to call you deplorable and say you’ll agree to lift standards in the House.

“Just tell them you’ll agree. I was a bit tough on the Auditor-General yesterday but I think it’s finally working. By the way: have you got any ideas on how I can put the boot into Brash tomorrow? What did you say? ‘Cancerous?’ Ha ha ha ha.”

Young notes that Mallard is not some errant backbencher but the 4th most powerful person in Labour after H1, H2 and Cullen.

If National spun like Labour

Helen Clark has tried to spin the issue of the $800,000 as an issue nothing to do with her or Labour but as a dispute between Parliamentary Service and the Auditor-General. She has declared we have done nothing wrong and they have said they refuse to pay it back, regardless of what the Auditor-General says.

Now think if National applied the same tactics to the GST broadcasting error. The Electoral Commission actually pays the bills for the broadcasting so if National spun like Labour, they would have claimed “This is nothing to do with National – its is a dispute between the broadcasters and the Electoral Commission”.

And instead of agreeing to pay it back, and proposing a bill which will legally allow them to pay it back, they would have said “No it isn’t our fault the advertising agency booked too much time. How we were to know. We have done nothing wrong so won’t pay a cent”.

And instead of immediately notifying the Electoral Commission of the error, accepting all responsibility for the error, and agreeing to face any penalthy that comes their way, National would have constantly attacked the Electoral Commission as “unfair” and “smearing” National.

The difference between the two approaches is huge.

One News Colmar Brunton Poll

Wow. That is what you call a decisive swing. National has gone from a 2% lead in the party vote to an 11% lead. Also of key interest is that the very important government approval rating has gone from +3% to -11% which is a 14% change.

Greens doubled to 6% which shows good things happen when you agree to pay the money back.

The PM doubts 49% support National. She is partly right that no party tends to get that vote in an election. But these polls are of decided voters only and what may have happened is a lot of Labour voters gone undecided which would make National go so high as a percentage of the decided vote.

The net disapproval ratng is the one which should worry Labour. That sends a very clear message that voters disapprove of their role in publicising Don Brash’s alleged affair and also the “non-personal” cancerous attack. Oh yeah, plus they also want Labout to pay the money back no doubt!!

Brethren costs Nats win?

The SST reports Katherine Rich as agreeing with Gerry Brownlee that the Brethren involvement cost National the election. I basically agree with this in that I have long thought they lost more votes off National than their pamphlets lost off Labour. Whether it was enough to change the result is speeculative but the notion that their $500,000+ helped National is not the case.

Their problem, as I have often said, is not being upfront with their activities. One press conference or press release announcing what they were doing and why would have changed the reaction entirely.

That secretive behaviour, combined with the private detective hiring, do make them electoral poison. Of course National MPs should not refuse to meet with members of the Exclusive Brethren over constituency issues or at public meetings but any private meetings with church leaders to discuss political issues and strategy should be ruled out. Otherwise they remain Labour’s universal answer to any allegation:

Nat: Labour broke the electoral act spending limit
Lab: But you meet with the Exclusive Brethren

Nat: Labour won’t pay back the $800,000
Lab: But you meet with the Exclusive Brethren

Nat: Labour has the largest current account deficit in history
Lab: But you meet with the Exclusive Brethren

Nat: A Labour Minister has been savaged over his marina decision by a Judge
Lab: But you meet with the Exclusive Brethren

Nat: Prisoners are getting flat screens TVs which sost four times a normal one
Lab: But you met with the Exclusive Brethren

The SST also has a more in depth article on The Brethren.

Clark under pressure

In a somewhat sycophantic interview with the PM by the HoS, Clark declares she always keeps a sense of humour.

How-ever the NZ Herald editorial the day before poses the question “What is eating Helen Clark?”. Indeed the constant topic around the chattering classes, and including senior Labour Party figures, is how Clark’s normally excellent instincts could fail her so badly that she did not see the idiocy of labelling Brash cancerous in the same breath as deploring personal attacks. It was a error in judgement you might expect from a first time candidate, not someone who has been an MP for 25 years.

Incidentially I hear froma reliable source that the phone lines at the Cancer Society have been running hot with people complaining about her use of “cancerous” especially.

Anyway onto the editorial:

What is eating Helen Clark? What can have possessed her to term National leader Don Brash “corrosive and cancerous”? By any yardstick, there was little to gain, and much to lose. Could it be, then, that the weight of criticism levelled at Labour over the use of public funds to produce its election pledge card, allied to the smear campaign against her husband, has caused her to lose her bearings? Has a usually calm and astute figure fallen victim to the perils of personal politics?

There is one logical solution for Labour’s difficulties. It must pay back any taxpayer money found to have been unlawfully spent on electioneering. The Greens this week joined several other parties in opting for this. Labour should follow suit, abandoning its deeply unpopular proposal to introduce legislation to validate spending identified as unlawful in the Auditor-General’s final report.

The Greens’ move, decided even though they are puzzled by the Auditor-General’s interpretation of the rules, has been widely applauded. This, to some degree, would also happen if Labour took the same action. More importantly, it would, in one step, take the party to the political equivalent of clean air.

National, for its part, must rid itself of the hindrance that hovers, sword of Damocles-like, over it. Its links to the Exclusive Brethren, and the $1.2 million campaign orchestrated by the sect, may well have cost the party the last election. Now, National is caught in the wash whenever Helen Clark accuses the Exclusive Brethren of smear campaigns. Again, the solution is simple. Victoria’s National Party leader, Peter Ryan, who is contesting a state election in November, has said he will not accept donations from the sect. Don Brash should dissociate his party in the same way.

Will all this happen? The omens are not propitious. Even United Future leader Peter Dunne, Parliament’s self-proclaimed voice of reason, is becoming more irrational by the day.

Not content with breaching protocol in a particularly jarring way by claiming the former Solicitor-General had besmirched the reputation of MPs, he now claims the Auditor-General’s investigation into election spending is “a mess”. The intimidatory intent and luridness of his tone are as disgraceful as the extent of his disconnection from reality.

I think the Leaders of Labour, United Future and National would all do well to take the advice on the editorial.

An inquiry into PIs activities

Helen is musing about an inquiry into the activities of private investigators and politicians.

It will be very ironic if after having a toothless inquiry into Taito Philip Field, she then sets up an inquiry into what she sees as her enemies with the powers she should have given the Ingram Inquiry.

Personally I have no problem with such an inquiry, so long as the terms of reference include how Labour and NZ First MPs came to possess or have knowledge of personal e-mails to and from Don Brash.

VUWSA elections

It seems there are VUWSA elections next week. VUWSA spent lots of money justifying why their levy should go up, yet is doing a crap job letting students even know about the elections. Jordan Carter is very unhappy, justifiably.

Compulsory membership associations of course have little inecentive to communicate well with their members – after all you can’t leave if they do a crap job. And another great reason for voluntary membership comes in this quote from the VUWSA Campaigns Officer:

“Nick [Kelly], Joel [Cosgrove] and I agreed that the meeting to increase the VUWSA levy was more important than the University fee setting meeting on Monday”

They regard getting to put up their own fees as more important than restricting any fee increases from the university. Hell they will all be invited to the Vice-Chancellor’s Xmas drinks.

Finally for those who are Victoria students and wish to vote, Jeremy Greenbrook-Held, has a list of whom he is voting for, and whom he thinks will win.

Dave Letterman’s Top Ten

The imfamous Dave Letterman “Top Ten Signs Your Husband Is Gay” is online at CBS.

My favourites:

9. On your wedding day, you wore the same dress

2. Yells, “Honey, I’m home after a long day of gay sex!”

1. Says he got rear-ended but the car looks fine

Superb Video

A huge hat tip to Spare Room (if you do not visit them daily you are missing out) for this youtube video of the TV3 item showing Mallard and Hodgson dancing. It is mixed in with grabs from Brash and Clakr interviews and is superb.

Great Quote

“Allegations of corruption are intolerable in a Western liberal democracy.” – Helen Clark.

No, Miss Clark. Corruption is intolerable. When allegations of corruption are intolerable, it’s no longer a Western liberal democracy.

A perfect summing up from Teenage Pundit.

Hat Tip: Not PC

A journalist blogs

Did Labour hire PIs

The Dunedin PI who has admitted wroking for the Exclusive Brethren has claimed that Labour had hired people to spy on National, the EB and specifically to go through the rubbish bins of Brash and Key. It is on the record that Key’s neighbours have twice seen men in suits going through the rubbish bins at or near his place.

Let me say that I do not for a second that believe these claims. Neither major political party is of the type that would engage in these activities. I do not believe the media should give any credence to the claims by Idour, unless there is at least a shred of proof.

Brethren must be isolated

Yesterday’s confirmation that the Exclusive Brethren did hire Wayne Idour as a private detective to investigate Labour MPs is deeply troubling. It is not quite as bad as having a PI “follow” MPs but it is still an activity which has no place in NZ politics. It also confirms Mr Idour and the some in the Exclusive Brethren are both liars, having both denied this activity previously.

I actually agree with the Prime Minister that National must now renounce any dealings with the Brethren. Their tactics condemn them. It was pleasing to see Don Brash condemn their behaviour (based on the reports) and that he would be very wary of ever agreeing to a meeting with them again. Personally I would like to see very wary become “not”.

In saying this I do not criticise previous meetings. Any party is going to be happy to meet with a group which says “Hey we don’t like the Government and want to help get rid of them”. Likewise dozens of electorates around the country were I am sure delighted that a few extra people came forward to volunteer to help deliver letters etc. You’d be mad not to.

However the situation has changed since then. What was fine back then, is different today. We now know the following:

1) The EB were not upfront with their authorship of the pamphlets. They made a huge tactical error in not announcing what they were doing and why, Their actions in the end caused damage to National. And the covert nature of their activities is not a once offer, but repeated around the world.

2) Their involvement does not appear to be a local decision, but part of a global trend, presumably upon orders. No Right Turn has done a good job highlighting these.

3) Most importantly they are now confirmed as having hired a private detective to investigate Labour MPs.

The combination of those three factors makes them a group one should stay well away with. They are free to campaign against whom they want, but National needs to be explicit that it will not be holding any exclusive meetings with them. One gets tainted by association, so the association must end.

I am sure there are many lovely members of the Exclusive Brethren. In fact I’ve met myself probably more than a dozen of them, and they all seem genuinely nice decent people. But they are being let down by the leadership of their “church” who presumably signed up to the decision to hire a private detective.

An apology

Best spin attempt ever

After calling Don Brash “corrosive and cancerous” Helen Clark then tried to claim this was not a personal attack because she did not mean Don personally, but the “Don Brash brand”.

She has obviously been spending too much time with Alistair Campbell.

This did not impress The Press, their editorial quoted below:

The personalised attack by the Prime Minister, Helen Clark, on the Leader of the Opposition, Don Brash, is something quite extraordinary in New Zealand politics.

For a serving Prime Minister to attack her chief political adversary as a “corrosive and cancerous” person and as “not fit to be a leader in New Zealand” is probably unprecedented. Not even in the rancid days of Robert Muldoon was such bitter, venomous language used by a politician in public discourse. That it should be possible to make a comparison with Muldoon – a model in personalised politics no-one should wish to follow – shows how lamentable the Prime Minister’s attack is. Despite Clark’s promises to raise the tone after the descent into the gutter in the last couple of weeks, she has regrettably only succeeded in lowering it.

caucus, and ultimately, voters to decide. By wading in with her two-cents worth, Clark clearly hopes to divert attention from herself and her own party’s misdeeds.

In the end, it all comes back to Labour’s profound discomfiture over its election mis-spending. In addition to assailing Brash, Clark this week again launched into the Auditor-General, Kevin Brady. It is very hard to see how this can be anything but an attempt to put public pressure on the Auditor-General at a time when he is considering his final report on the matter, with the aim of discrediting it in advance. It is a disquieting manoeuvre and further evidence of how far Clark has become unnerved.

More allegations against the Exclusive Brethren

Prime Minister Helen Clark has revealed two more outrages done by the Exclusive Brethren.

In an exclusive interview she has accused them of being behind this week’s coup in Thailand. “Look at the parallels” the PM stated. “Both countries have a PM accused of corruption, and claims of an illegitimate election. It is obvious the Exclusive Brethren were behind the Thai coup are are seeking to do the same here”

When asked if her allegations were based on briefings from the SIS and GCSB, she replied “No I heard it from a member of the press gallery whom I can not name”:

The PM also went in to bat to defend her fellow “left” leader – President Chavez of Venezuela over his comparing Bush to the Devil. “Look some people think it was wrong of dear Hugo to compare Bush to Satan, but what they don’t realise is I have proof that Bush is also a member of the Exclusive Brethren”

“It is a well established fact that if one is a member of the Exclusive Brethren, then they are not only equal to Satan, but also corrosive and cancerous. I mean that in a non personal way of course” the PM concluded.

Broadband Prices

The spin unravels

A copy of the actual invoices for the pledge card, released under the lawsuit Darnton v Clark, seriously undermines Labour’s spin, as reported in the NZ Herald.

The invoices were stamped “approved for payment” and signed by Heather Simpson. The Parliamentary Service has specifically said the MPs authorise the expenditure, not them.

But the real potential smoking gun is the strong hint that The Parliamentary Service has been reluctant to pay for them, and only did so under direct order from the PM’s Chief of Staff.

You see they were not paid until 17 November – three months after they were produced. And they were only paid for after a letter from the PM’s Chief of Staff saying:

The publications were created and issued in compliance with established procedures.

“To my knowledge, they comply with all applicable laws and procedures for such publications. That is an entirely sufficient certification for your requirements.

Kindly ensure that the payments are made without further delay.

If Labour wishes to persist with its spin that they acted within the rules and Parliamentary Service approved the pledge cards, they need to reveal all correspondence between them, and PS on the issue.

I have *never* known the need for such a letter to accompany invoices to be paid. The only possible situation where it would be needed is where the PS has expressed serious misgivings over the expenditure. And again I can think of no reasons for a three month delay in payment, except PS resisting. Note the reference to “further” dleay clearing indicating PS had been delaying.

On the face of it, this evidence fatally undermines Labour’s claims, and shows the defence to be a tissue of lies.

The private detective

Let there be no mistake. If the EBs (or anyone) have hired a private detective to follow the PM or her husband, then that is repulsive. If the EBs have done such a thing, then their God will be very upset with them.

However the situation is unclear. The person named as having followed Davis denies he ever has. Now maybe this is a case of “He would say that, wouldn’t he” but some proof is needed.

At the moment most of the case seenms to be once again the PM claiming she has been told something by her secret unnamed friends who never come forward to verify her claims. A higher standard of proof is needed than “Mavis told me that Bill told her that Sally told him that someone hired a private detective to follow Peter”.

Again though, if it is true it is disgusting.

More lies

Another day, another lie.

Today’s one is the claim from Helen that the Auditor-General has been privately saying hat he backs Labour’s plan to pass a backdated law validating unlawful spending in last year’s election campaign.

He says that is rubbish
or to quote him “I would never say that”.

Helen specialises in claiming people say things privately and not naming them, because it makes it impossible to contradict.

As an example she has claimed three press gallery members have all confirmed privately that National MPs promoted the Peter Davis rumours to them. Now no gallery member has said this publicly and a large number have said quite the opposite. In fact I understand an informal survey has been done within the gallery and not a single member says they have said any such thing to Helen.

So either she is lying again, or for some unknown reasons three members of the gallery are not willing to publicly confirm what she says they privately say.

Talking of Corruption

Let me quote the Electoral Act 1993:

[214B.Maximum amount of parties’ election expenses—

(2)In the case of a general election, the total election expenses of a party that is registered under Part 4 of this Act shall not,—

(a)If the party is listed in the part of the ballot paper that relates to the party vote, exceed $1,000,000 plus $20,000 for each constituency contested by a candidate for that party (which sum shall be inclusive of goods and services tax); and

(3)Every person who directly or indirectly pays or knowingly aids or abets any person in paying for or on account of any election expenses any sum in excess of the maximum amount prescribed by this section is,—

(a)If the act is done with knowledge that the payment is in excess of the maximum amount prescribed by this section, guilty of a corrupt practice; and

Now there is not a single independent authority who does not think Labour spent more than the limit set down in the Electoral Act. And they were warned three times before the election that the pledge card had to be included.

So what is so outraegous about calling a spade a spade?

Labour calling people corrupt

Helen Clark claims that calling her Government corrupt is somehow the lowest of the low, something no decent Opposition should ever do. This is of course self serving pap as people will recall her MPs accusing Jenny Shipley of taking bribes to give the tourism board contract to Saatchis and Mallard’s constant allegations that National sells policies.

She justifies her attack on Don Brash by saying the use of the word “corruption” against Labour was “intolerable and had no place in a Western democracy”.

But anyway I thought I would take a very quick look through Hansard in the late 90s. And in a few minutes alone I find these. Perhaps a journalist might want to quote some of these back at Helen the next time she pretends to be outraged.:

CLARK: There is, I believe, jolly close to corruption in the Fire Service Commission over the role played by the chair of the commission

MALLARD: Today we had the stench that is surrounding this rotten Government. We had Mr McCully and the revelations about the behaviour of one of the senior officers of this Parliament. That approach will taint the Prime Minister, and while she may have had a sweet summer, what we will see in the end is a collapse because of her own inability to run a Government that is seen to be clear of the greed, the graft, and the corruption that New Zealanders think surround this place.

Mr Mallard was yelling across the House: “Pack of crooks.”

TREVOR MALLARD: It is absolutely outrageous. It is the sort of corruption that we would expect in countries like Indonesia. We would not expect that level of corruption in any OECD country.

Trevor Mallard: Why does she stand by her Minister after he issued a threat in an attempt to obtain funding for an application, outside guidelines and precedents, for a group that involved two very close relatives, and does she accept that in most democracies such action would be regarded as corrupt?

TREVOR MALLARD: I am making an allegation of corruption

MALLARD: There is only one way the Minister could have studied those balance sheets and that is through his role as Minister of Tourism. If a public official anywhere else in the world took advantage of his public position to obtain documentation that was not made available publicly, then attempted to take advantage of that for his personal and private benefit, it would be insider trading or corruption.

And finally we have two hypocrisy awards for Labour:

Hon. TREVOR MALLARD (Minister of Education): I raise a point of order, Mr Speaker. I want to make it quite clear that it has often been ruled in this House that linking actions of members to corporate donations to a party, and suggesting quite directly that people are acting as a result of those donations, is out of order.

Yes that is Trevor in 2000 saying it is wrong to link actions of MPs to corproate donations. What hypocrisy considering he has explicitly made such allegations on multiple occassions recently.

I put it to the House that the Prime Minister has been central to the development of a strategy that sees the National Party freeloading off public money devoted not to the promotion of New Zealand but to the attempt to resurrect a failed, dying Government.

And the supreme award goes to this statement accusing Shipley’s Government of freeloading off public money!!!