TUANZ Awards Dinner

I attended my first TUANZ Awards Dinners last night, thanks to lawyer Michael Wigley whose law firm sponsored the ISP of the Year award, and invited me to his table (Michael acts for InternetNZ and various ISPs on telco issues).

It was a very enjoyable night – black tie compulsory so the penguin suit was hired. Personally I can live without black tie dress codes, but the nice thing is the woman then all dress up accordingly and look magnificent, so no real complaints.

Started with pre-pre-dinner drinks in the bar, then official pre-dinner drinks downstairs at the Hyatt and finally after two hours of champagne with no food we make the dinner – 40 tables of ten spread throughout the ballrooms and six screens beaming people and presentations at us.

John Campbell was the host, and an excellent choice. Very smooth and witty, yet not dominating so much that he was the “story”.

ISP of the Year went to Orcon. I was picking it would be them or Ihug. A popular choice.

Telco of the Year went to Vodafone, which again was a popular choice. Vodafone are good with the innovation. Life without my Vodafone Blackberry and 3G data card would be like being in a gulag šŸ™‚

The media of the year was Telecommunications Review and journalist of the year was Peter Nowak formerly of the NZ Herald who accepted the award by phone from Canada. Peter was again a very good choice as he really gave important stories the prominance and detail they needed.

Finally the Chairman’s Award for leadership went to David Cunliffe, which was clearly the obvious choice with his telecommunications stocktake having invigorated the sector.

Dessert and dancing followed the awards and then after midnight the after-match parties took place in selected rooms. I think I did well to make my 10 am appointment this morning!!

Wednesday

Wednesday was that very rare day – a day off and in Auckland. I had meetings Tuesday and Thursday in Auckland, so the cheaper and more logicial option was to stay up. It was great to, for once, not be rushing from meeting to meeting and then to a plane.

Managed to catch up with an impressive number of people that day. Started with a random encounter with Craig Ranapia at Borders at 1 pm. Then had a coffee with an insolent chap a couple of hours later at 3 pm and then headed up to Sky City to meet the infamous Chuck Bird at 4.

An hour later at 5 off to a K Road pub for what I though was a small group – meeting Darren G plus two of the Sir H’s crowd – Adolf and Gooner. But also got joined by David W and a Rob and Michael from NZBC who were in the neighbourhood. Finally Phil U from Whoar also joined us so we had a very balanced group. Was good to put faces to names.

After a couple of hours at the pub then headed to Kingsland for dinner with Claire, Lin, Simon and a few others. Can highly recommend Canton for a good feed. We then headed next door for dessert and drinks. The only downside was getting there as my taxi driver (Singh3) not only did not know where Canton Restaurant was, he did not know where New North Road was and eventually admitted he did not know where Kinglsand even was. I will fire a letter off to LTSA iof I have the time. I mean not knowing a street is one thing, but not knowing an entire suburb!!

Then headed into town and ended up drinking with a couple of very sociable students in their apartment for many an hour, finally making it back to the Hyatt at 4 am.

A long, but very enjoyable day.

Turia must name names

Tariana Turia has to back up her allegations of being offered money in return for agreeing to back Labour, or withdraw the claim.

This is not a trivial issue. Is is an accusation of serious illegal behaviour, and blatant vote buying.

Clark’s billionaire friend, Owen Glenn, whom many thought fitted the description, has denied it was him. He says he has never even heard of Mrs Turia. How reassuring that the biggest donor in NZ politics is so well informed!!

A suggestion someone made yesterday was that an MP could write to the Speaker asking this matter go before the Privileges Committee. Turia was an MP last year and by her own words this was someone wanting to pay $250,000 so she and others would vote in favour of Labour on confidence and supply.

If Turia is unwilling to back up her allegation, then she can not expect to be taken credibly on other issues. You can’t make such allegations without proof.

Unparliamentary Terms

Oh a wonderful resource – a (non-exhaustive) list of terms ruled unparliamentary over the years. They include:

* Idle vapourings of a mind diseased
* His brains could revolve inside a peanut shell for a thousand years without touching the sides
* Like a snail leaves a slime behind him
* Frustrated warlord
* Ayatollah
* The Arapawa Goat

This reminds me of that classi Havoc and Newsboy episode where they sat in the shamber with then Speaker Jonathan Hunt and rattlked through a list of obscene words asking him for each one if it could be used in the House. After a dozen or so he looked most relieveved when they finally found one which was legit!

Hat Tip: Tony Milne

Well done Zoe Chapman

Okay – important announcement for all women in Auckland. If you go to Soul Bar before 22 October (5 pm to midnight) and say “Whack it on the Platinumā€ you will get a free glass of champagne.

Why you ask?

Because some rich bastard fails to get into the pants of Miss Zoe Chapman, losing the bet she extorted from him that the price of failure would be to buy champgane for her and all other women in the bar for a month!

Zoe then e-mailed all her friends to encourage them o frequent Soul and try to bankrupt the property magnate. Good on him incidentially for honouring his bet.

Hat Tip to Ana at Spare Room has checked out the story with the bar and they confirm it is true in regards to the credit card, and not just an urban legend.

Who offered $250,000 to Maori Party to back Labour?

Tariana Turia is under pressure to reveal who made the offer of $250,000 in campaign funding if they agreed to back Labour, and who was the third party “wealthy individual” the offer was on behalf of.

The offer was made not once but twice according to Turia who says she understood the potential donor lived outside New Zealand, and had donated money to the Labour Party.

Seems to be one obvious candidate. I am sure the media will be asking him if it was him.

Labour claim to know nothing about this. Perhaps then they should set up a propoer commission of inquiry into the allegations so that the truth can come out and they can be cleared. I’d even be happy for the Commssision to also investigate Helen and Trevor’s claims of National accepting bribes for policy as it would be superb to have them actually have to produce proof of their claims.

Gary Moore to stand down as Chch Mayor

Christchurch Mayor Gary Moore has announced he will not seek a fourth term as Mayor. It seems the announcement was very emotional and it is not clear how much the decision is of his own free will and how much it is a fear of losing.

Moore from my viewpoint, seems to have been a pretty good Mayor. You want a Mayor with energy and presence which he has. And while he is Labour, he has worked with people from all parties pretty well.

I suspect this will see Tim Barnett stand as Mayor. It has been a real mystery to me why Barnett, whom I regard as one of the most politically astute Labour MPs, has never made Cabinet despite being in his 4th term. I presume it is Helen being overly sensitive to having too many openly gay MPs in Cabinet because how else do you justify Clayton Cosgrove, Judith Tizard, Dover Samuels and Harry Duynhoven as Ministers ahead of Barnett.

So if Tim becomes Mayor, wil this see Tony Milne seek the candidacy for Christchurch Central for any by-election?

The EB need a campaign manager

The things that strikes me with the EB’s foray into politics is how damn awful they are at it. Seriously any conspiracy theory that National is pulling their strings dies on the basis that they wouldn’t make such basic mistakes if they had decent competent advice.

The Press notes in its editorial that the EEB have become their own worst enemies. Not quite true as no-one knocks Helen off her perch, but basically correct.

Almost all of the activities – pamphlets, detectives, letters to the editor have caused them more harm than anyone else.

So my advice to the EB (if they were allowed to use the Internet and could read this) is to go and hire a good campaign manager. Hell think what some smart political nous could do with a few million dollars and 3,000+ volunteers. You could hand deliver targetted direct mail, swamp the letters to the editors sections of newspapers, phone canvass hundreds of thousands of households etc etc. I almost could be tempted to apply for the job šŸ™‚

Personally I’ll be quuite happy if they leave politics to God and us sinners again. But if they do insist on staying involved, please go get some help!!

Turia not happy

Tariana Turia doesn’t want to meet with Don Brash any further, saying their views are so far apart.

I’m surprised she has taken so long to realise it.

However it does pose challenges to National. While I don’t believe a National/Maori coalition or agreement could or would be viabale or stable, it is useful to have a good working relationship on the issues there is agreement on. And as many have noted National doesn’t have many potential partners scoring over 1% at the moment.

Further falling

All bad news in the media today for Brian Connell. First we have the publicity over his vow not to cut his hair until Don Brash is no longer Leader. Good God – are you 12???? I mean seriously, one is a Member of Parliament.

Then we have David Carter saying that the Independent had confirmed to him prior to the Caucus meeting that they knew someone was going to confront Brash. I had certainly heard the day after it happened that the Independent had the story written in advance and were just waiting for the Caucus meeting to then confirm and file the story..

On top of that one of Connell’s staff, now on either annual or sick leave depending on who you believe, confirming Connell had spoken top the Independent earlier that day. There’s also scuttlebutt around that there has been a refusal to hand over cellphone records showing or disproving if a cellphone had been left switched on and transmitting during the caucus meeting.

And finally in the Herald story, he threatens to take a few people with him if he does retire from politics. Later when he realises it was on the record he says he was “musing” not “threatening”.

The Press has a story about Connell no longer living in his electorate. The Press also notes that he has put out no press releases in two years and asked only 14 written parliamentary questions this term (something I and Andrew Falloon highlighted a week or so ago).

NZPA also reports on the threat to bring others down and how the suspension came as a complete surprise. I’m amazed it was such a surprise as I actually raised the issue on TV twelve days ago and it seemed obvious to me by the response that MPs wanted to take some action.

A guide to the taxpayer funding debate

Audrey Young in the NZ Herald has done a great service by providing some clear questions and answers in relation to the debate over the pledge card etc. It cuts through the spin from all sides, and sets out what is known and what is important etc.

I’m especially pleased to see it debunks the myth that the Auditor-General “approved” the 2002 pledge card.

We need more articles like this one. It doesn’t back any side, it provides factual background, with a bit of opinion.

The fall and fall of Brian Connell

Brian’s suspension from Caucus is indeed not just because of what happend in Caucus two weeks ago (as serious as that was), but really does relate to a series of events over the years, which have all been damaging to National.

All MPs make mistakes from time to time which may damage them or the party. But these are measured up against all the good stuff they do. To take a comparison, Simon Power over-reached in a defence speech a couple of years ago and seemed to commit National to following our allies without question. That was untidy and Simon got pinged for it publicly and privately.

Simon didn’t sulk though as he was moved into the Chief Whip’s role and by all accounts worked incredibly diligently and sucessfully at that (and it is a crucial role) and then since the election as law & order spokesperson has been highly effective at exposing the problems in Corrections and other areas. Hence the defence speech is now history and Simon is again seen as a top contributor to National as he is scoring blows against Labour on almost a daily basis.

This is the contrast to Brian. Most MPs would struggle to name any runs he has scored for the team. And when you not only are not scoring any runs, but getting your team mates run out all the time, it is inevitable they move to drop you from the team.

The run-outs, so to speak include:

* Controversy over candidate selection CV
* Declaring he was Prime Ministerial material before he even was an MP
* Joking he hated cats so much he threw one into a fireplace
* Criticising publicly then Deputy Leader Nick Smith
* Use of extravagent language in opposing Civil Unions Bill, which caused even fellow opponents to cringe
* Publicly calling the Leader stupid over the Katherince Rich sacking
* Contradicting the Leader over the forestry policy during the election campaign
* Publicly attacking Murray McCully
* Calling Dr Brash unfit to lead if he had had an affair
* Suggesting his party membership was of little value to him

It’s the combination of the above which made yesterday almost inevitable. It’s quite sad because on a personal level I’ve always found Brian Connell to be very pleasant, and I have a great fondness for the Rakaia electorate having worked for its former MP. But at the end of the day when you are causing more harm to your own team than the opposite team, a halt has to be called to it – and it has been.

Doh!

Heh. Arrived early for a meeting so sitting in guest lounge enjoying the view and checking out some websites on the Blackberry. Think to myself “Wow, never had the speed so fast” and then realise I am of course in Vodafone’s Head Office which probably explains the good connectivity and speed!

Connell suspended

The National Party caucus has decided to suspend Brian Connell.

Leader Don Brash says the suspension is the result of Mr Connell’s behaviour stretching back over the past few years.

The party board decided last week that Mr Connell had again failed to show the restraint and discipline expected of a caucus member and decided it no longer had any confidence in the Rakaia MP.

Auckland all week

I’m flying to Auckland early this pm and up there until Friday. For once I’ve actually got some spare time while up there so hope to catch up with a few people on Wednesday especially.

For someone who has vowed to never live in Auckland, I’d hate to add up how many days a year I actually spend up there!

Presley out?

I’ve just heard that a massive split is happening at Callplus/Slingshot with Malcolm Dick (Annette Presley’s former partner) announcing Presley is departing her executive role at Slingshot, but Presley is reported to be denying that, claiming no knowledge of her own departure.

Sounds very badly handled, no matter who wins.

Culture & Immigration

Thomas Lifson states:

It is quite insulting and patronizing to immigrate to a country and expect it to adapt to the very things one left behind. This is the behavior of a conqueror, not an immigrant.

By definition, an immigrant asks for the privilege of being allowed to live in a country not his or her own. Immigrants have no right to demand change. No more than I have a right to barge into your house and demand you rearrange the furniture, knock out the wall between the kitchen and family room, and paint the parlor walls a different color.

An immigrant stipulates that the country to which he or she goes has a superior system. Without such an attraction, why else leave behind family, friends, and the attachments of sentiment?

Do you agree or disagree and why?

Hat Tip: Tim Blair

A critical analysis

On the 7th of September Rodney called the submission by Bronwyn Howell on the Telecommunications Amendment Bill as the finest submission he has ever seen presented to a select committee, and said those arguing for the confiscation of property rights need to respond to Howell’s work if they are to have any intellectual credibility.

Well the challenge has been taken up, and TUANZ and InternetNZ commissioned reviews of the submission by two expert economists. Dr John Small, of Covec is the former head of economics at Auckland University and is an expert in competition and regulatory economics. Dr Tommaso Valletti, is a professor of economics at Rome University and Imperial College, London, and until recently teaching at the London School of Economics. He is an expert in the economics of telecommunications and an advisor to Ofcom, the UK telecomms regulator, the OECD, the EU and the World Bank.

One can read the reports of Dr Small and Dr Valletti online. Here are some extracts starting with Dr Small:

Howell is clearly energetic and passionate about the subject. It may be that these admirable qualities are the root cause of the serious weaknesses in the paper. It is otherwise difficult to understand how she came to blatantly misrepresent the work of others, make statements that would not pass muster in a first year economics course, suggest that her own exceptionally weak empirical work is evidence of anything meaningful, and appear ignorant of her logical errors.

Dr Small concludes: “If I was reviewing it for an academic journal, I would recommend it be rejected.”

Dr Valletti summarises his report with:

It is shown that the literature reviewed in the Submission is very selective and far from being accepted within academia. Some of the results quoted are very controversial.

He also makes the point that many of the studies Howell relies on have not been published
in leading academic journals. This means they have not been vetted by the academic community and by referees.

It is important to note that both reviewers are only commenting on the quality of the Howell submission. They are not saying that there are not grounds on which you could criticise or critique the Government’s stocktake research, and are not necessarily advocating in favour of the Govt’s package – that was outside their remit. What they are saying is that the Howell paper is not something great reliance can be placed on,

VDSL2

Bye Bye Brethren

Corrupt vs Cancerous

The NZ Herald Digipoll is fascinating. Not for the party vote figures (which have National well ahead) but for the question of whether people agree with Labour being called corrupt, and Helen Clark calling Don Brash cancerous.

52% say Dr Brash was right to call Labour corrupt, with only 38% disagreeing. This should ring massive warning bells to all Labour MPs (esp as even 30% of those voting Labour agree with the corrupt tag). Not that I am in the habit of giving friendly advice to Labour but for the love of God just follow what the Greens have done and say “As much as we disagree with the Auditor-General, we will pay back any money he declares was not appropriate to pay from The Parliamentary Service”. This will get rid of the corruption stench overmight – well that plus finding a new candidate for Mangere.

Most NZers are fair minded. They will not judge Labour corrupt off the original decision to fund the pledge card from their parliamentary budget. It’s the refusal to pay it back which brings the corrupt tag with it. The electoral over-spend was also corrupt but that can now never be determined in court.

As for Helen calling Don Brash “corrosive and cancerous”, my insitinct when I heard it was a blunder of massive proportions. And in the poll 74% of voters say the comment was “not okay”. The PM has forgotten the difference between language hard-core partisan activists will agree with, and language which resonates with most NZers.

Domain Name Disputes

There have now been four decisions made by expert panelists under the new dispute resolution process for .nz names.

The decisions are a fascinating read for the 0.1% of the population who, like me, are interested in domain name issues.

One of the four cases had the respondent contest the claim, and this was resolved in favour of the complainant – Intercity.

The other three were uncontested, but despite that one case was unsucessful as the complainant did not establish they had legitimate rights in the name.

Don Brash, Agony Aunt

Oh this is a superb hidden gem. Scoop has dug up some old audio archives of Don Brash before the last election being interviewed by student radio, and the hosts turned it into an agony aunt session with Don giving advice to students ranging from cyberspace love to hairy partners to blondy bimbo beauty queens.

I can only imagine the press secretary slitting his wrists while listening to this, but I actually think Don comes out really well in them – gives good advice mixed in with his own experiences. It’s a testament to his good nature that he went along with it. I can imagine many politicians would have refused to take questions of that line.

I find it somewhat bizarre when people try to paint Don as some sort of far right extreme “cancerous” figure propped up by the religious right. I suppose they have to try and paint him that way, but those lucky enough to actually get to know him see the sense of humour and disamring nature where he’ll go along with something like this.

Hat Tip: David Slack

The Empire Strikes Back

I’m glad to see I was not the only one who felt uneasy reading the Dominion Post headline “Labour strikes back at sect“, detailing how the Government is looking to strip the Exclusive Brethren of labour law exemptions in response to their foray into politics.

It has all the overtones of a vengeful Government seeking to punish a group simply because they campaigned against them in an election. It’s a style of politics we don’t see overtly in New Zealand, or not until now.

idiot at No Right Turn and Greenie Phil U share the sense of discomfort.

I actually disagree with the law having a faith based exemption. Just as I don’t want power stations not built because of the spiritual life-flow of rivers, I don’t want some people to have a different employment law because of their religious belief.

But the way the Government plays it as an issue of revenge is what makes a lot of people nervous. As we already see a Government which believes it is above the law and will attack anyone who threatens it (including the Auditor-General), this is just another symptom of a sick culture.

NZ First to pay it back – probably!

Congratulations to NZ First who have said “We have the capacity to pay, we will pay, but when we know what we’re paying and why we are paying it”.

While there is some wriggle room, it is a very welcome statement, reinforcing MPs are not above the law.

This now leaves only two out of eight parties off-side. The common sense of United Future doesn’t yet extend to a statement they will pay it back. And we have Labour whose strategist Pete Hodgson has declared that under no circumstances whatsoever will they pay back even a cent.