A headline one can’t improve on

The headline for today’s Dominion Post editorial is one that yoyu just can’t improve on:

Muzzle the dogs and pay it back

“Like a cornered animal afraid of capture, Labour’s parliamentary wing is lashing out at its tormentors in an attempt to take them down with it …”

A cornered animal indeed.

Go Nuclear

The head of Genesis Energy has said that the future for power is nuclear.

Nuclear is the cheap, safe, clean and almost limitless energy source of the future.

Even Frog is showing a degree of open minedness on the issue.

Of course as soon as one starts talking nuclear, a Greenie has already jumped in with a peak uranium theory!

Six years jail

Life on the Benefit

bFM

Shortly after midday I’m on bFM for 10 minutes or so to discuss current events or whatever Simon Pound wants to talk about.

UPDATE: Ha that was lots of fun. However I had forgotten the wonderfully unpredictable nature of student radio and was somewhat stunned when Simon asked me if I had ever got laid because of my blog!!

Luckily I have been around politicians enough that I have learnt how to avoid giving a yes or no answer 🙂

Just when you thought they couldn’t get lower

Well I doubt even the most rabid supporter will defend Labour on this one. Having failed to distract attention with dredging up the Brethren’s campaign and anoymous donations (which Labour has specifically kept legal, and receive themselves), yesterday they said they would start revealing “secrets about the private lives of National MPs” unless they back off about Labour’s illegal election over-spending.

It seems there really is no gutter low enough. I think even McCarthy would be repulsed.

There is a simple solution for Labour to stop people calling it corrupt. Take action against Taito Phillip Field (giving false eveidence to the Ingram Inquiry should be grounds alone) and pay back the illegal spending.

And as I am not an MP, I can use the hypocrisy word and point out that Labour has over the years called National corrupt on multiple occassions. They called Jenny Shipley corrupt for having dinner with Kevin Roberts. They alleged National had its policies written in Washington DC. So they are being fucking precious by complaining when the blowtorch is on them.

And the difference between the cases in that there was not a shred of evidence of wrong-doing in the two cases mentioned above. In the cases of the election over-spending there are formal reports and opinions from the Chief Electoral Officer, the Electoral Commission, the Auditor-General, and the Solictor-General.

The Press Editorial sums up Labour tactic’s well:

Labour’s cynical attacks on National over election spending smack of a desperate attempt at self-justification.

But amid these claims and the mutual taunts of corruption being thrown across an increasingly chaotic House, the real issue is straightforward: whether Labour in last year’s election broke the rules by spending parliamentary funding on soliciting votes. Given that it defies belief that the pledge card was not designed to gain votes, the conclusion has to be that Labour took a calculated gamble to bend the rules and has now been caught.

Its allegations against National are designed to divert attention from this basic point and from the issue of what role over-spending played in Labour’s return to power. But the attacks, to date at least, appear based on the theory that if enough mud is thrown, at least some of it will stick.

The over-riding priority must be establishing greater accountability for the public money spent on campaigning and restoring full public confidence in the electoral process itself. Rather than lashing out at National to divert attention from itself, Labour’s best hope of retrieving even some shreds of dignity from the current imbroglio would be to work positively towards these goals.

Magic Words

Have just checked into the CityLife Hotel in Auckland and at reception heard some magic words.

“Welcome Mr Farrar, Oh you have a complimentary double upgrade for your stay”

This takes me from a standard room through the deluxe room into an executive suite which could comfortably host 40 for a party 🙂

Just what I need at the end of a long day!

In Auckland

About to fly up to Auckland, and staying there until Friday pm.

Thursday and Friday morning got some interviews for a history project, and then InternetNZ meetings Thursday afternoon.

By coincidence one of my best mates from university will be in Auckland tomorrow also, so looking forward to a long overdue catchup. Has been almost a decade since we last caught up as he now lives in Australia. Might be a long night!

Russell Brown on Funding

Well done Air NZ

The Air NZ website now allows me to select seats for my domestic flights (yay) and also to have my boarding pass e-mailed to me so I can print it out on the day of travel.

This shows good vision. More choice and convenience for the traveller and less per passenger costs for the airlines.

The irony

Jordan Carter in this post claims National won’t be able to stand the scrutiny of the stolen e-mails.

Now here’s the irony – he has banned comments on the post. How’s that for an example of being able to withstand scrutiny!!!!

The comment I tried to make was merely that I’m not too bothered by Helen and Winston’s Nixonian tactics of using stolen e-mails (I seriously do not understand why National had not tried to get certain MPs arrested for possession of stolen goods) but could you imagine if someone managed to steal Helen or Heather’s e-mails. Good God. I’d especially like to read the ones about the pledge card!!!

UPDATE: Jordan has e-mailed to say the non allowing of comments on that post was done accidentially. I accept this entirely.

Ferrit Reviews

Hypocriticial Bastards

Student politicans spend a lot of time campaigning against fee increases – except of course their own ones.

VUWSA votes today on a proposal to increase the student association fee by 20%. Outraegous. They have an executive of muppets ( (c) Jeremy Greenbrook) who can’t manage a budget, so they just turn around and seek to whack students for more.

Normally only 50 students will turn up and vote on this fee which affects over 10,000 students. Hopefully more than that will turn up today at midday.

Hat Tip: Act on Campus

NZ Herald editorial spot on

Today’s editorial is so spot on, I’m going to quote almost all of it:

Fundamentally, Helen Clark and her cohorts believe any publicity they want to pump out is worthy of public funding. In fact, they believe party election campaigns should be financed entirely from public funds, and have tried to turn their difficulties with the Auditor-General into a case for complete public funding. They have succeeded only in revealing the depth of their error.

Only a party that believes all of its publicity should be state-financed could have made the decision to pay for something as blatant as its pledge card from the public information account of the Prime Minister’s Department. The pledge card was so clearly a campaign publication that even Parliament’s closest observers had assumed it was produced from party funds.

Yet the mindset of Labour leaders was such that they went ahead to produce the card from a public account even after the Auditor-General had raised issues over the rules before the election last year. When the misappropriation was revealed in the Auditor-General’s subsequent report, Labour decided it would legitimise the election spending retrospectively. Now that a Herald DigiPoll Survey has shown the extent of public disapproval of that cynical use of legislative power, the party appears to be dreaming up new ways to avoid paying its bill.

Labour has its back to the wall on this issue and is flailing about to find comparable spending by its opponents. It cites contributions to National by a religious group, as if that had anything to do with a misuse of public funds, and for which that party was rightly, separately, castigated for its economy with the truth. That argument is over. Voters had their say on National’s lack of judgment about its links to the Exclusive Brethren. Now Labour has dredged up National material from the election before the rules were clarified. It is all a bit desperate.

There is no way around Labour’s liability for its errors at the last election. It must pay the bill and call it a salutary lesson in the limits to which the public will pay for political puff.

Croc Humour

Cash for Policies

I think Helen and co have managed to insert the phrase “cash for policies” into question time around 35 times so far.

The fact that this is a charge without even a sherrick of evidence, seems to have escaped the Labour Brains Trust. Just repeating it 35 times will not make it true. I mean the media are not that stupid. And lets face it if there was any evidence of a party selling policies for cash, the media would be leading the charge with investigating it.

Labour has a history of just fabricating allegations and expecting them to be reported as fact. The allegations against Field came not from National but from dozens of different people in the community. The issue of the pledge cards is based on written letters and reports from the electoral authorities, the Police and the Auditor-General.

This nonsense about “cash for policies” is quite literally a fabrication. It goes back to Labour’s culture of entitlement. If you interfere with their “entitlements” they have a hissy fit and invent things to throw back at you.

Not that I’m really complaining. It just makes them look pathethic.

New Air NZ ad

Defending Bill

The other $400,000

Labour just might be the luckiest party in history. You see all the focus in on the pledge cards, yet the *other* $400,000 seemingly identified by the Auditor-General as illegal epxenditure could have wiped out most of their Caucus if it had been known in time.

Now in this I am assuming that any expenditure the Auditor-General has identified as electioneering, would also be found by the High Court to be election advertising in terms of the Electoral Act. The actual definitions are different, but as the Electoral Act definition is quite broad, it is highly highly likely any expenditure identified by the AG as electionering would be seen as election advertising under the Act, and hence an *election expense*. The reverse does not necessairly apply.

Now of this extra $400,000, some of it will be from inidividual Labour MPs and would be seen as promoting their constituency election. Now only Labour, PSC and teh AG know the breakdown and hopefully it will come out one day. But for now let’as assume $200,000 of the extra $400,000 is related to constituency MPs. On average that is $6,500 per constituency MPs.

Now if you add this to each Labour MPs election return, it would probably push all 31 Labour constituency MPs over their $20,000 limit. Now we can not know this without having details from the AG, but it is a very distinct possibility.

There is no way of testing this as electoral petitions have to be filed within 28 days of the return of the writs. But just think if National had known the extent of Labour’s activities and had filed electoral petitions. Every Labour constituency MP could be out of Parliament having broken the spending limit.

Now again as I say this is just a theory. But if we ever get the full details from the AG of the illegal spending, broken down by MP, then one could add the amounts to their election returns and work out who would have been caught.

Yes, Labour may have been very very lucky. And next time I am sure there is going to be intense scrutiny on Labour’s spending both nationally, and locally.

The culture of entitlement

In Canada the Liberal Party was widely seen and branded as having a “culture of entitlement”. This is something not unique to Canada, but we are also see it in NZ Labour, albeit not to the same extent as Canada.

In Canada a commission of inquiry (one with actual powers headed by a Judge, not a Clark Claytons Inquiry) found that the Liberal Party handed out government advertising contracts to agencies, in return for those agencies donating a portion back to the Liberal Party as money or services.

Now this has never happened in NZ, but it was reported some years ago that in the 1980s the Labour Party chief executive did raise the possibility of Labour’s debts to its advertising agencies being setlled by way of giving them government advertising contracts. Luckily Geoffrey Palmer was Leader and of too high integrity to take this suggestion up.

But we still see the culture at work with the demands for “democracy funding” and also the outrageous proposed $15 million advertising campaign for Working For Families. This campaign is in fact what first led the Auditor-General to start trying to clean up the system.

Now a culture of entitlement does not mean by itself, a party has acted illegally. It does help understand why the party keeps pushing the boundaries and is then outraged when told they have gone too far.

For the sake of clarity, let us look at what Labour has done, and which are illegal, and which are not.

1) The $15 Working for Families campaign

Now I regarded this as outrageous, but have never labelled it illegal or corrupt. That is because the Auditor-General reviewed the programme, and pared it back. I might not like the fact they still spent $12 million on a campaign which could have been done via targetted idrect mail for $500,000, but that was within the rules. Greedy, but not corrupt.

2) The over-spending by $418,000

Lasbour clearly broke the law here. The incompetence or timidty of the Police is the only thing which saved them from an inevitable court ruling against them. My series into the Police investigation demonstrated to any reasonable person that the Police fucked this up majorly. And the fact that Labour were warned three weeks before the election they had to include their pledge cards, and they ignored that advice gives them no defence. An aggravating factor is that they lied to the Chief Electoral Officer.

A good comparison has been made to Bob Clarkson. Clarkson was warned his spending was being challenged. So he stopped some spending, and this allowed him to remain under the limit. Labour were warnned with three weeks to go, and not only did they not decrease their spending to stay under the limit, they increased it (while telling the Chief Eleectoral Office the opposite)

3) The $800,000 of expenditure provisionally ruled illegal by the Auditor-General

Now I don’t actually label the Government corrupt for the illegal expenditure. A number of parties were found to have used taxpayer money illegally.

4) Refusing to pay the money back

*If* the Auditor-General affirms his draft opinion that the expenditure was illegal, then a refusal to pay it back is corrupt. It is not the expenditure which was corrupt – it is the refusal to obey the law.

5) Retrospective legislation to personally MPs

If MPs vote for a law which will personally relieve them of their debts to Parliamentary Service, then that is corrupt.

Legal vs Illegal

The PM is having an impressive temper tantrum and having failed to defend her party’s behaviour, she is now resorting to classic FUD tactics of claiming everyone is as bad. Specifically she is labelling National corrupt for accepting anonymous donations.

Now I am almost embarassed that I have to spell this out in small words, but just in case anyone is confused, here it is.

Anonymous donations are deliberately allowed for under the Electoral Act. This is not some rorting of the Act, but something long-standing and known. Labour have been in power since 1999 and has amended the Electoral Act half a dozen times since then. They have deliberately decided to keep anoymous donations legal.

Why? Well Labour themselves receive hundreds of thousands of dollars in anonymous donations.

So when the PM claims National receiving anonymous donations is somehow wrong or corrupt, the question that should be asked back to the PM is:

“Well Prime Minister, is it your contention that anonymous donations are corrupt only when made to National, but are fine when made to Labour”

or

“Well Prime Minister, is it your contention that anonymous donations are corrupt only when another party gets more of them than Labour does”

Yes this is how weak her position is.

The issue of whether or not they should be allowed is something reasonable people can disagree about. Personally I favour them on balance because it means that MPs don’t get to know who major donors are, and hence can’t be suspected of “favours”. But if the law is changed to not allow them, then it’s not that major a deal.

Of course the PM is desperate for everyone to start debating legal anonymous donations rather than her latest outraagous proposal to avoid paying back the $800,000 (if the AG confirms it in his final report).

Rather than have the MPs pay back the money which is deemed illegally spent on their behalf, they are now proposing to merely under-spend their budget the following year. Now if spending was illegal, it is illegal. Underspending you legal budget does not change the fact that taxpayer money was spent on an illegal activity and should be refunded by those who benefited illegally from it.

This is of course all subject to the final Auditor-General report. And again the PM is not being subtle. I heard her yesterday saying that she expects the Auditor-General to recommend validating legislation, claiming this is what he normally does in these instances. If the AG does not follow the PM’s “advice” I suspect he will be very out of favour.

You’re all wrong

Jordan Cater helpfully explains on his blog why everyone except Helen is wrong. Go read.

The media it seems are maliciously working with National to make Labour look bad. I especially like the part where Jordan insists the pledge cards did not solicit votes. A pity Mike Williams has said it formed the centre-piece of Labour’s re-election campaign.

But forget that. As Jordan says the fact 81% of people want Labour to pay back the pledge card is due to “lazy hacks and malicious bloggers”.

These lazy hacks must of course include the Editors of the Sunday Star-Times, Dom Post, Press and Herald who have all called for it to be paid back.

Jordan also tells the media that they must stop referring to ‘unlawful’ spending. Yes, of course. After all who are the Solictor-General and Auditor-General anyway and what would they know.

Court Decisions online

The Government has announced over 2,000 decisions of the High, Appeal and Supreme Courts are now available online. This is good. They are available here.

It has taken a while though. I recall in 1998 or 1999 having a very minor role in getting the then Government to announce it would make court decisions available over the Internet. Only taken eight years 🙂

Steve Irwin dead