Labour Decision Making Flowchart
Generation XY has a flowchart for Labour MPs to use in decision making. I hope to see it up on many a Beehive wall!
Oh now this is funny, and it’s not even bad taste – well only slightly. Safe for work.
Hat Tip: Iain Dale
Generation XY has a flowchart for Labour MPs to use in decision making. I hope to see it up on many a Beehive wall!
The Sunday Star-Times had some advice for the PM yesterday. Worth reading in full,.but especially this part at the end:
The sleaze label is now starting to stick to Labour, and it is clearly rattled as a result. Nothing else explains its cack-handed and panicky response to the problem. Clark used to understand that the only way to clean off mud is by using a political fire hose. That is what she should do here. First, she and her Labour colleagues should repay the money, apologise to the taxpayers and voters and promise never to do anything similar again. Then, if the police decide not to charge Field, she should ensure that Labour expels him from the party. Without Field’s vote, her job of managing her fragile coalition would be even harder than it is now. But that is the price of honesty and accountability.
Only in the education sector do you get such stupid unions, with the PPTA today oppossing extra pay for outstanding teachers.
The ultimate monument to union stupidity is the PPTA President’s claim “All teachers are good”. What arrogant and ridicolous stupidity. Of course they’re not. Teachers are not all cloned like imperial troopers in Star Wars. They are individuals and some are great teachers, some are good teachers and some are useless teachers. And no amount of training or support will change that some teachers are better than others.
The top teachers should be paid $100,000+ in my opinion. However so long as the PPTA insists that all teachers must be paid the same, they never will be.
My final post relating to the recent US trip. If anyone here is in Vegas, I recommend they see the show KA at MGM.
It is truly an amazing show – both with the design and stage but equally so the ability of the dancers to dance and fight while vertical and horizontal etc.
Just trust me – go see it. I can’t do it justice in trying to describe it
Very amusing is their pre-show guide on no cameras, no cellphones and no smoking. A “native” swings in and goes up to an audience member and plays with his camera before throwing it into the fire pit where it explodes in flames. He then does the same with his cellphone. Finally the audience member pulls out a cigarette and lights up. As he does so, he is also thrown into the fire pit to a large explosion. Very amusing.
For how long has it been customary for Thai Immigrants to practise koha or lafo?
With 81% of the public wanting Labour to pay back their pledge card costs, John Key has helpfully worked out a way for Labour MPs to do this.
On the basis that without the over-spending, Ministers may not have got to keep their higher salaries, Key calculates that $2,000 per banckbench MP and 17% of the difference between Ministerial and MP salaries will see it all repaid. His schedule is:
PM $22,813 x 1
DPM $15,150 x 1
Cabinet Ministers $17,066 x 17
Other Ministers $11,319 x 6
MPs $2,000 x 25
Total $446,000
Key generously doesn’t propose penalty interest for use of the money and even states allowing repayments over twelve months would be fine. And if the total Labour illegal spend turns out to be over $800,000 then repayment could pro-rata up and spread over two years. Very fair.
Inspire Net, my blog host, have a nifty stats package which makes it even easier to pull off links and referrals etc.
For August the most numerous visits came from:
Visits
vuw.ac.nz 3982
parliament.govt.nz 2549
massey.ac.nz 1723
ird.govt.nz 1712
catalyst.net.nz 1644
msd.govt.nz 1425
apn.co.nz 943
enterprise.co.nz 900
treasury.govt.nz 693
auckland.ac.nz 561
Also had a lot of visitors from:
maf.govt.nz
moc.govt.nz
moh.govt.nz
wellington-airport.co.nz
Top Stories
/2006/08/boobs_on_bikes.html 11038
/2006/08/labour_threatens_newspaper_wit.html 3592
/2006/08/a_pollice_ruling_i_dont_disagr.html 3243
/2006/08/a_competition.html 2491
Top Referring Sites
http://www.scoop.co.nz 1078
http://norightturn.blogspot.com 374
http://www.publicaddress.net/default,3414.sm 325
http://briefingroom.typepad.com 267
http://blog.greens.org.nz 267
http://newzeal.blogspot.com 188
http://asianinvasion2006.blogspot.com 174
http://www.publicaddress.net/default,hardnews.sm 146
http://thewhig.typepad.com 124
http://www.nzpundit.com 122
http://www.ellisnz.com 119
http://www.scoop.co.nz/link-out 110
http://kearney.blogspot.com 98
http://aucklanderatlarge.blogspot.com 95
http://www.iaindale.blogspot.com 91
http://tumeke.blogspot.com 90
http://pc.blogspot.com 87
http://www.nbr.co.nz/blog/ 79
Top Search Terms
boobs on bikes 6492 (ha that is hilarious)
david farrar 1228 (disturbed so many searching on my name)
kiwiblog 419
boobs 283
kiwi blog 255
nic miller 155
blog 134
farrar 120
wikipedia 117
boob on bikes 98
anita mcnaught lesbian 86 (Good God rumours still going strong)
david farrer 72
prison blog 55
dpf 50
angela bloomfield 47
jonbenet ramsay 39
paul clarkin 39
wallace chapman 38
aja rock 34 0.1 %
milf 33
Also featuring is the stats are:
angela bloomfield breasts
lisa lewis
la tomatina pictures
matthew hooton
nikki kaye
charlotte glennie
blowjob while driving
tony milne
jacqueline mackie paisley passey
kathryn ryan
emily braunstein
And finally we have the most unusual searches done on Kiwiblog’s internal search engine:
‘vacuum-sealed marijuana’
‘orgasms around the world’
It is unknown if Labour is going to advance with its plans to retrospectively legislate to wipe out the debts owed by Labour MPs to the taxpayer. If they do, I certainly look forward to the select committee hearings.
Matthew Hooton writing in the SST suggests a range of measures National MPs could try to stop such retrospective legislation – bearing in mind it would be the most corrupt law you could pass short of extending one’s electoral term without a mandate.
Hooton suggests several steps for National:
* Walking out of Parliament
* Boycotting Parliament
* Ask the Governor-General not to give Royal Assent
* Have National’s electorate MPs resign in protest, one by one with by-elections across the country until the government folds
The by-election idea is very interesting. One could start with National’s most marginal seat and justify it on the grounds of allowing the public to vote on the acceptability of such retrospective legislation.
Bill Ralston is facing formal disciplinary proceedings at TVNZ in relation to an “expletive-laden telephone call to the Herald on Sunday”
Considering Ralston is imfamous for his language, I wonder if this is being used as a pretext for pushing him out of TVNZ? And will we ever get to know his exact words? 🙂
To give credit where credit is due, the people appointed to be trustees of the NZ Superannuation Fund, or Cullen Fund, have done a magnificent job.
They have just achieved a 20% return on assets for the last financial year. God I wish I could transfer my private superannuation fund to be managed by the NZ Fund Guardians.
Of course they may just be having a lucky streak, but considering they have managed excellent returns for the last three years, that would be an ungenerous interpretation.
One bit I especially enjoyed from John Armstrong’s column today:
Her strategy was to somehow absolve herself of responsibility for Field by arguing that as Prime Minister she could discipline ministers but errant backbenchers were the territory of the party organisation, particularly when it came to candidate selection or – in Field’s case – de-selection.
The way Clark was talking it was if she was having an “out of body” experience and referring to someone else, rather than acknowledging she also happens to be leader of the Labour Party.
Having had some experience’s of political parties and their ruling bodies, I can safely say the chance of a ruling body taking action against an MP which is not sanctioned by the Leader is somewhere between zero and nil.
NZPA reports that for the second time the defamation case by Winston Peters against David Carter and TVNZ has been thrown out.
And in other news, the spider has just been released from the Betty Ford Clinic 🙂
Span blogs on a Star Wars like scene between Helen Clark and Mike Williams regarding *not* discussing Taito Philip Field’s party membership. Very good.
Bomber Bradbury reveals he has something in common with me. We both had crushes on Anita McNaught.
Cactus Kate has a lengthy post on the Business Roundtable and its perception problems.
Tim Selwyn blogs on things he is missing in prison. These are women, eggs, e-mail, views, and rugby. However not missing TV, traffic or money.
Didn’t do these last month as I was moving sites, so my count below is for a two month period:
Kiwiblog 280 posts, 7,875 comments
Any NZ blogs that want to be recorded, just post in the comments your blog name, no of posts and no of comments for August only.
No Right Turn 138, 963
Tumeke 77, 1275
Just Left 40, 540
IIQ illusions and allusions 31, 95
Andrew Falloon 23, 106
Aucklander At Large 23, 53
Daniel’s View 15, 2
On The Right 12, 31
The Kiwi Adventurer 11, 4
Laws Watch 8, 328
The the Kiwi Advanced Research and Education Network (Karen) was launched last night, and credit should be given the Government for supporting this so our universities and CRIs etc can keep up with the rest of the world.
The network speed is around 10 Gb/sec so will allow for terabytes of data to be able to be transferred quickly.
I am delighted the Police drivers have had their convictions overturned for their role in the PMs motorcde. While the motorcade was going too quickly, they were operating within the then procedures for VIP transport. A criminal prosecution was an over-reaction to what should have been a warning and new guidelines.
No real surprise that 81% of respondents in a Herald Digipoll support political parties paying back any taxpayer money illegally spent on their behalf. Of concern to Labour will be the fact 76% of Labour supporters also support paying it back.
National did well yesterday to pull out media monitoring research that shows Labour actually increased its election spending after being told by the Chief Electoral Officer they should include the cost of their pledge card. They had the ability and time to stay within the (electoral) law, and made a very deliberate decision to over-spend.
I was discussing last night whether Labour would have the numbers to retrospectively legislate, even if they decided to try.
Presumably they could get both poodles (Jim and Winston) to vote in favour so that is 58 votes.
National and Maori would be against at 52 votes. Now even though Rodney Hide has spoken against the AG;s report, I can not believe he and Heather would vote for retrospective legislation such as this. It would quite simply be the death of ACT. Likewise with all the emphasis the Greens put on principles, I can’t imagine they could hold their heads up high and vote for it. So that is 60 votes against and 58 in favour.
So who might decide? United Future with three votes.
Having said that I think Labour would be suicidal to even try. And they may find not many MPs can easily vote on any legislation because the money owed to Parliamentary Service is not legally owed by political parties but by the MPs themselves. Therefore any MP who has not paid money back will have to make a declaration to Parliament under Standing Order 166 that they stand to directly financially benefit from the legislation. Now how will it look to have half the Labour Caucus declaring they will personally gain from a law and then vote for it.
I had a brief appearance before the Justice & Electoral Select Committee today, advocating that Parliament not reduce from 120 to 100 MPs. The Committee was very polite and receptive with a few targetted questions and a bit of humour. I can’t speak for them, but I would be surprised if the bill is recommended to proceed.
Prior to that the Committee was hearing submission on Sue Bradford’s Section 59 bill and there were some very emotional submitters, talking about personal backgrounds with abuse. It was really good to see the Committee dealing with such a horrible issue in a very sensitive non-partisan way. Sure the MPs on there may disagree on what the law should say, but one could tell they were operating in a genuine way.
My third select committee experience for today is to note (thanks No Right Turn) that the Commerce Committee has reported back the anti-spam legislation and I (and InternetNZ) are delighted that the Committee has taken on board all the submissions and make some really really good improvements to the bill. It’s again excellent to see Select Committees doing such a good job. Too many people think Parliament is only about Question Time.
Ran into Sophia from Red Confectionary and local Act on Campuser Jordan K at the select committee, so we had a quick beer at the Backbencher afterwards. Always good to meet new people.
Taito Phillip Field has claimed he has done nothing illegal, and with the Police now inquiring into this, he has been stood down.
But the issue has never been one of legality as much as ethics. The criminal code is the bare minimum standards for society. For MPs we expect behaviour well beyond that. Let me illustrate with some examples:
* A (for example) National MP could refuse to help any constituents who are not members of the National Party. This would be 100% legal, yet also deplorable and one would expect the party leadership to come down like a tonne of bricks on any MP who acted in such a way.
* Closer to home, there is nothing at all illegal about immigrants who gained residency through an MP, to choose to paint homes for him as a show of gratitude. It is grossly unethical for an MP to allow them to do that, but it is not illegal.
* An MP could refuse to speak to any rotary clubs unless they pay him or her $1,000 speakers fee. Quite legal but unethical.
* An MP can quite legally accept $100 donations for her political party, from constituents whom he is helping. Again grotesque but not illegal.
* An MP can seduce the 19 year old daughter of a constituent who comes to him to help, and then also sleep with the 17 year old teenage daughter and not break the law in any way, yet be regarded as acting unethically.
* An MP can lie to a QC, and not have broken the law, as the QC was not given the power to require testimony under oath.
* An MP can ring up constituents and pressure them to shut up, and this is not against the law.
* An MP can lie to his Ministerial colleagues in order to get immigration visas approved, yet this is not illegal – only grossly unethical.
The vast majority of what Field has been accused of is not illegal behaviour. While any potentially criminal behaviour such as forged birth certificates should be investigated by the Police, this in no way negates the necessity to have a proper investigation into the ethical behaviour.
And Labour can do this at any time by either giving leave for the Privileges Committee to investigate, or setting up a proper Commission of Inquiry.
NB: Note that some of the examples above are just that – examples – and it is not suggested one MP has done all the above.
Congratulations to Lewis Holden who has won NZ Debating’s Bledisloe Cup for public speaking and was also a member of the team which won the Joynt Scroll competition.
Lewis spoke, of course, on constitutional issues!
Keith Ng has what I consider the best contribution around to the Tazer debate.
Keith has provided links to videos showing inappropriate Police use of tazers (including one simply horrible clip showing multiple taserings which kill the victim) but also clips of Police using them to protect the community etc.
Keith comes down on the side of the tazers being available for use, as do I. But this is not carte blanche for the Police to use them at any provocation. I was shocked by the TV3 footage of a police officer using pepper spray on a handcuffed man on the ground, and if incidents like that are allowed to continue, then support for weapons like tazers will dry up.
So the ball is in the Police court. They have them to use them, but how they use them will be the crucial factor in public acceptability.
Somewhat shocked to read that Lord Cooke died last night. I wasn’t aware he (presumably) had cancer.
He was one of NZ’s most dominant legal personalities. A worthy member of the Order of New Zealand. His Wikipedia profile has some details on him.