The Dictatorship of the Proletaria
Okay which soon to be Labour MP once said his aim is to be implementing socialist policy and bringing about the dictatorship of the proletariat?
Trevor Loudon has the answer.
As usual clever billboards from National, leds to parody billboards. Last election there were some hilarious parody billboards and even some billboard generators.
But the current parodies being paraded by Jordan Carter and the Green Party are well lame is the nicest term I could use.
The Green Party are the ones who claim to not engage in dirty politics such as personal attacks, and instead just talk issues? Yeah Right!

The ‘witty’ Green billboard

And the one Jordan placed up.
If you want to see some really good parody (unlike that crap above) have a look at the parody memo on No Right Turn’s blog from Rodney Hide to Epsom voters apologising for any missed votes in Parliament but reassuring them that the Maori Party have been casting their proxy votes for them. Very funny.
Okay which soon to be Labour MP once said his aim is to be implementing socialist policy and bringing about the dictatorship of the proletariat?
Trevor Loudon has the answer.
Jeremy Greenbrook has photos on his blog from his civil union wedding on Saturday.
Cograts Jeremy.
A US (Democratic) Congressman is denying he was taking bribes, despite the FBI finding US$90,000 cash in his freezer.
They videotaped him also accepting a $100,000 bribe for a Nigerian official.
He has vowed his innocence. He’ll need some luck to prove it.
Steve Maharey is saying that just because the ERO said one in five kids were “not succeeding” at school, doesn’t mean that they are “failing”.
This sounds like the education bureaucrat in England who said that “failure” should in future be referred to as “deferred success”
The last remainder of Yugoslavia is about to end. Montenegro has voted by 55.4% (the EU requirement was at least 55%) for independence from Serbia.
This will mark the final stage of the six former Yugoslav provinces, becoming independent countries. The Serbian region of Kosovo may go independent at some stage also.
It looks like common sense may win out, despite the best efforts of some, on the Section 59 law.
An outright repeal would criminalise light smacking, and even moving your child against their will.
Sue Bradford has indicated that she is now likely to merely amend Section 59, rather than repeal it – the exact position I and many others have advocated for months.
The challenge will be to see if appropriate wording can be found that makes it clear violence towards children is illegal, but parents lightly smacking their child for misbehaviour is not. Former National MP Bob Simcock suggested the test could be if any bruises or marks were caused.
In 1999, Government spending on health was $5.88 billion. Expenditure next year is budgeted to be $10.73 billion – a staggering 82.7% increase.
Yet as most people know, health outcomes have only increased slightly, or in some areas not at all. Health funding seems to have become a black hole.
Tony Ryall points out one of the reasons. There are an extra 1,786 health bureaucrats now, than in 1999. And that is just at the DHBs who have 9,669 administrators. That excludes the 1,100 health ministry staff!
It looks like the Electoral Integrity Bill which allows party leaders to expel MPs from Parliament will not pass, unless it is restricted to List MPs only.
I’d rather the bill didn’t pass at all, but having it restricted to List MPs would be better than passing it unchanged.
Doctors, or specifically General Practitioners, are resisting a Government move to set their fees for them. This would be de facto nationalisation, effectively turning all GPs into state employees.
There is a huge variability in what GPs charge, reflecting location, demographics etc. Trying to have the Government set one national price is lowest common denominator thinking.
Incidentially GPs income is now very modest compared to a couple of decades ago. Commerce graduates within a few years are earning far more than GPs who spend twice as long studying.
UPDATE: The RNZCGP survey has incomes for GPs. The average income is $93,000 with average hours being 1.2 FTEs. Thsi works out to $77,500 for a FTE. The median income of $96,000 compares to public hospital specialists of $137,500 (and much much more for private specialists).
My series on Labour’s over-spending is now over. If you want to see all the posts together then click on this link to see all of them.
To follow them in order start from the bottom post. There are 26 posts all up. They are called:
* Background to the Series
* The players
* The timeline
* The issues
* First Contact
* Second Contact
* The fend-off
* The offer
* Over-Spending Series
* The Electoral Act
* Labour’s Response
* The withdrawal
* The CEO acts
* The Police Investigations
* The S221 Investigation
* The Section 221 Report
* The S214B Complaint
* The Section 214B investigation
* The Wairarapa Electoral Petition
* The Section 214B Report
* The Release and Aftermath
* What the Police should done
* Summary of the Case
* Recommendations
* The one that got away!
* Series is finished!
Now I can get back to sleeping again 🙂
There was one person who wasn’t investigated by the Police. And this is unusual because decisions on spending are vested in her name. In previous actions under the Electoral Act it has been the MP, not their secretary or their campaign chair, who has faced action.
So who is the on person who was never investigated, never asked any questions at all and arguably was responsible?
Well I’ll let the Labour Party General Secretary, Mike Smith, answer that question for me. This is his reply to the Chief Electoral Officer when asked about the pledge cards:
Clearly there has to be law changes, to stop a repeat of this at the 2008 election. My suggested changes include:
* Increase maximum penalties under the Act for corrupt practises from $4,000 to $1 million and from one year to three years in jail.
* Increase the penalties for illegal practies from $3,000 to $100,000
* Remove the Police from having a role in prosecutions. They have shown they are not interested and to be blunt not competent. This is a specialised area of law.
* There has long been a deisre to merge the three electoral agencies (Electoral Enrolment Centre is the third one). This should proceed and the new agency given the power to fully investigate and prosecute breaches. This will means Parties can not ignore the electoral authorities with impunity. A Judge will still of course decide on whether the law has been broken in any instance.
* Amend the Electoral Act to allow parties, not just individuals, to be held liable so different people in a party can’t just point the blame at each other.
* Amend the Electoral Act so prosecutions can be commenced within 12 months, not six. Six months does not allow enough time for a thorough investigation when you consider it takes four months or so for the election returns to be filed and published.
The overall case is damning. In summary:
* Labour were told 17 days before the election that the CEO considered the pledge cards electoral advertisements.
* Labour offered, prior to the election, to include the pledge cards in their election return.
* That offer, was withdrawn after the election. The large cost of the pledge cards makes it difficult to reach any conclusion other than the offer was made with bad faith to stop the CEO referring them pre-election to the Police. In other words they lied to the CEO.
* The overwhelming view of the top electoral and legal authorities, including the Secretary of Justice and the Chief Electoral Officer, was that the pledge cards were very clearly electoral activity and expenses.
* The Police investigation was superficial, and did not even investigate the over-spending charge.
* The Police brought into the view of Heather Simpson that the Parliamentary Service Commission rules over-ride the Electoral Act. This is despite the PSC rules themselves referring to the fact some parliamentary expenditure can be electoral expenses under the Electoral Act
* The Police kept confusing the two issues, right up until after the public release, when the CEO put them right.
* The Police failed to consider that Section 214B offences have strict liability, where intent is not required.
The unfortunate effect of all this, is that the authority of the Chief Electoral Officer and the Electoral Commission have been massively undermined, perhaps fatally. If a party can ignore warnings from the CEO 19 days before the election, lie to the CEO, make offers and retract them and all without any sanction at all – then you have the wild west.
I doubt any person could read these reports and paper and not conclude that if the Police had prosecuted for over-spending, a Judge would beyond any reasonable doubt have found the key people in Labour guilty of at least an illegal offence, if not a corrupt offence. This is what you call a slam-dunk.
The pity is we will never know. The time-line has expired, no private prosecutions are possible.
I am pleased to see that since I started this series of posts, there have been three stories in the media on this issue. Nick Venter did a very well researched story in the Dom Post on Saturday (not online) and both Ruth Berry and Fran O’Sullivan wrote about it in Saturday’s Herald. Fran has written on this previously.
I didn’t do this series of posts with the aim of generating stories in the media. I did it because I just wanted the story to be documented somewhere. Each day as I read more and more documents I got more and more outraged. My friends got sick of me no doubt ringing them every day exclaiming “You won’t believe what I’ve just read”.
Was this a stolen election? No-one can know. You can’t say if Labour had spent $350,000 less money (this is taking into account the $100,000 accidental extra broadcasting booked for National) they would have got less % of the vote. Certainly what you spend does affect the vote (otherwise one would not spend) but it is not a simple linear relationship.
What one can more easily determine is was it deliberate. Imagine you are in Labour and it is your worst nightmare – you are actually behind in some of the polls. National was meant to have no chance of winning in 2005 after the 2002 result yet Labour’s third term hands in the balance. The small centrist parties have said they will support the party with the most votes so even 1% or 2% makes a huge difference.
You know the CEO’s view on the pledge cards. You have a choice. You can reduce spending on your other advertising or you can risk being prosecuted after the election. You decide the election is too close to stop spending, so you take a gamble and risk prosecution. However to stop any adverse publicity pre-election from an investigation, you tell the CEO you will include the pledge cards as an expense (and implicitly restrict your other spending) so no news comes out during the final week. A few weeks later you then recant on your offer.
It may not be a stolen election, but it does make it a very dodgy “win”. If the Police had done their job then there would be the benefit of a Court Judgement to resolve the matter.
I will blog at a future date on the other non-prosecutions – the unions and the Brethren for their third party advertising and National over the GST error. But they are seperate to this case and I don’t want to muddy the waters as they have very little to do with each other.
There are many things the Police should have done in this investigation. A few of them are:
* Ask for minutes of campaign meetings where the pledge card was discussed (in electoral petitions, campaign minutes are included as part of the evidence).
* Ascertain the full list of people involved in the decision making.
* Seek early legal advice on the Electoral Act vs the PSC internal rules.
* Investigate why the 2002 pledge card was authorised under the Act, rather than just accepting the statement it was done mistakenly.
* Ask Labour to account for all their discussions and decision making after the CEO first contacted them on 30 August 2005.
* Specifically inquire as to who was consulted on and agreed to the letter offering to include the pledge cards in the party’s election return.
* Actually investigate the Section 214B breach, not just Section 221!
* Inquire as to the knowledge of Labour’s campaign spending to date, when Mike Smith made the offer to include the pledge cards in the party’s election return.
The above is a minimum of what I would expect. Instead we got one charge not investigated at all, and the other dealt with by a few e-mails, a written list of questions and a couple of short meetings.
The Police reports were finished on 1 March 2006. On 16 March 2006 the media suddenly realised that if charges are not laid by (arguably) the next day, Labour will be home free.
The next day the Police put out this press release.
Now I had been wondering over whether the Police hierarchy simply overlooked the deadline. It was mentioned many times by the Detective who did the S221 investigation, so surely it was not overlooked.
Well this e-mail from the Police Comms person makes it pretty clear with his reference to running out of time that they did overlook the time limit. The e-mail was done at 7.30 pm at night suggesting that after the publicity that day in the media, they scrambled to finalise their decisions and justifications in a public release.
Now amongst the media reports of the decision not to prosecute, the Police Acting Deputy Commissioner said that the Police had made recommendations to the Chief Electoral Office which would make things “tidier” next time.
The CEO had not received any such recommendation so wrote to the Police asking where they were on 20 March. The next day a meeting was held, described in the note below:

Nowhere is it better illustrated how badly the Police handled this case. All the way through they had been confusing the requirements of Section 221 and the Parliamentary rules. The CEO points out to them S221 is clear, the booklets put out to parties are clear and Crown Law also say the law is clear.
The Police then backtrack and say they meant the rules about parliamentary spending are unclear. This of course is not a matter for the CEO, the Electoral Act or the Police. That is a matter for the Parliamentary Service Commission and the Auditor-General.
On 27 February 2006, DI Peoples sent to DS Perry a
“>report covering the S214B complaint, and the various other complaints concerning other parties.
The same day DS Perry sends it to ADC Marshall. Two days later it is with the Acting Deputy Commissioner. How-ever remember they would already know what was basically in it, having collectively made the decision.
Now this conclusion is stunning in its simplicity. The Police simply say Mike Smith didn’t pay for the pledge cards, so he can’t be held liable. Also note that the Police did not investigate Heather Simpson under S214B – only under S221. In fact as I have said they didn’t investigate anyone under this section.
They don’t even refer to Mike Smith having agreed to include the cards in the party’s return. They also don’t consider that it was arguably not the pledge cards which had Labour exceed their maximum allowed, but all the other expenditure they did in the last 19 days of the campaign – despite knowing the CEO’s views on the pledge cards.
They also nowhere asked Smith whether he was part of campaign meetings where the pledge cards were discussed, where they were co-ordinated into Labour’s overall campaign etc. The wording refers to indirectly paying or abetting a person in paying.
Now it is worth looking specifically at the wording of S214B(3):
Every person who directly or indirectly pays or knowingly aids or abets any person in paying for or on account of any election expenses any sum in excess of the maximum amount prescribed by this section is,
Electoral Petitions are very rare, but provide the most valuable source of electoral law interpretation. Now the Police said
Yep of little application.
However looking at the petion:
You see down at the bottom that Reg Boorman’s expenses were found to include material paid for by Parliamentary Services. The Judge nowhere concerns himself with what the internal Parliamentary Service Commission rules are, he measures them solely against the Electoral Act.
This should have given Police a huge steer that the issue is not whether or not Parliament should have paid for them, but whether or not they were defined as adertisement and expenses under the Electoral Act.
As hard as it is to believe, there was none. Nowhere in the 1,500 pages of materials released under the OIA is anything at all relating to Section 214B being investigated.
No interviews, no legal advice, nothing.
The Electoral Commission wrote to the Police on 10 February 2006. Two weeks later on 27 February 2006 a recommendation not to prosecute is made, justified by just two paragraphs in a report.
I have no idea why the Police did not investigate the Electoral Commission complaint. I can only assume they did not realise the different legal standards in the Electoral Act and reasoned to themselves “Hey we are not prosecuting over S221 so we won’t prosecute over S214B”.
But this is a key thing to remember – there was no actual investigation into the S214B complaint. Or if there was there is no record of it.
On 10 February 2006, the Electoral Commission wrote to the Police on the issues of Labour over-spending under S214B.
The important thing to note from above is that the full Electoral Commission concluded there had been a breach, not just the CEO. The Commission include two Judges (one retired) and the Secretary of Justice.
It is useful to then review at this point, who has formed an opinion that Labour broke the law:
Chief Electoral Officer David Henry
Electioral Commission CEO Dr Helena Catt
Hon. Anthony (Tony) Ellis QC
Chief Judge Joe Williams
Secretary for Justice Belinda Clark
And from the way the agencies refer to their legal advice, it is implicit that similiar advice came from:
Crown Law
Ministry of Justice
And in terms of people with a legal background who think Labour did not break the law, we have:
Heather Simpson’s lawyers
And let us remember that the Police sought no legal advice before making their decisions. Anyway onto the S214B investigation …
On 27 December DSS Arnerich sent to DI Quinn his report on the Section 221 case. The full report is in this pdf file, starting at Page 36.
Before I get into the report itself, I should explain the nature of Police decision-making in cases like this. It is collective and taken at the highest levels. Quite simply a Senior Sergent doesn’t get to decide by himself whether or not to charge the Prime Minister’s Chief of Staff.
This e-mail extract shows the Police Executive were being kept aware of progress. What would have happened is that after a certain point, they would have decided what the report should recommend, and this would be reflected.
The Police Executive is formally the Commissioner and two Deputy Commissioners. It is likely other staff in the Office of the Commissioner would have been involved such as some Assistant Commissioners and Superintendents.
It is also worth noting that at the time of the investigation, the Government was deciding who would be appointed Police Commissioner and Deputy Commissioners. These decisions are made personally by the Prime Minister. This is not stated to suggest some sort of quid pro quo, but to point out that it is not in the interests of the Police hierarchy to prosecute members of the Government which appoints them, reviews their performance, provides their funding etc etc. If there is room for benefit of the doubt – you go for it.
Anyway to the report. Some key aspects:
The Police do not seem clear on why Section 221 exists.
This extract shows several mistakes. First of all the statement that Wairarapa Election Petition had little application is wrong. It set very clear precedent that expenses paid out of Parliament can be treated as election expenses. I will return to this.
You also see that reference is made to the purpose of the Members Handbook is integral. No it isn’t. The purpose of the Electoral Act is integral – the MHS does not over-ride it. Yet all the energy goes into this area.
It is quite possible to have advertising which falls within the PSC guidelines in the MHS and also is advertising within the definition of the Electoral Act, and hence needing authorisation.
Here we see several more errors. Firstly the Police discuss whether the breach was “wilful”. No mention is made of the fact that the CEO warned Labour 19 days before the election of his view, and they ignored it.
You also see that the Police (who have yet to receive the over-spending complaint) are worried that a prosecution of S221 may result in Labour being found guilty of over-spending and hence undermine the integrity of the election. Somehow they think not prosecuting for breaches helps the integrity!
Thirdly they refer to parliamentary rules being unclear and confusing (which they are to a fair degree). But again this misses the point that this has nothing to do with the Electoral Act requirements.
Finally note that the decisions have been made without *any* legal opinion sought. If they had done so, they may have realised their mistake in confusing parliamentary rules with the Section 221 requirements.
The report concludes as we see above that no prosecution be taken. Now bearing in mind that S221 does require “willfulness” as a test, it is not totally unreasonable to not prosecute for the S221 breach.
But the far more serious over-spending offence in S214B has a very different legal test. Not only if there no “willfulness” requirement, it goes in the other direction and specifies strict liability.
The Police job sheet for the Section 221 investigation shows who the Police talked to. Remember this is all prior to receiving the over-spending complaint. At this stage only the lack of authorisation is the issue.
A summary of the Police activities is:
27 Oct – DSS Arnerich assigned case
02 Nov – talked to MOJ lawyers and sought copy of Wairarapa Electoral Petition
08 Nov – seeks copy of adverts
16 Nov – speak to Mike Smith
21 Nov – Mike Smith states that Heather Simpson was responsible for pledge cards
22 Nov – Meet Mike Smith
12 Dec – Meet Heather Simpson, questions e-mailed in advance. If only all suspects were treated so!
This section is rather amusing. I would call it more than a “concept” that an internal document authorised by the Parliamentary Service Commission is over-ridden by the Electoral Act. However the Police seemed to have taken Heather Simpson’s unsupported contention and given it priority over the very clear advice from the Chief Electoral Office.
Also of some importance is what the Members’ Handbook itself says. Let’s look:
So the Members’ Handbook itself actually defers to the Electoral Act and points out that certain expenses charged to Parliament can and should be deemed election expenses.
Now again I am not a lawyer and can not say for 100.00% that the Members’ Handbook doesn’t have some special status which allows the Electoral Act to be ignored – but such a decision is one for a Judge, not the Police. It would in fact be a major re-interpretation of constitutional law.
I should also point out that at no stage did the Police seek legal advice on this point before making their conclusions.
20 Dec – answers received from Heather Simpson.
Now this is the end of the Police job sheet. The extent of the Police investigation was one meeting with Mike Smith who basically said nothing to do with us, plus all the parties do it. And then one meeting with Heather Simpson where she was given a set of questions and had eight days to answer them.
In a later blog I will touch on what the Police did not do. This is a very long list!
NRT reports that a majority of the Justice and Electoral Select Committee have reported back that the Electoral (Integrity) Amendment Bill not proceed any further.
It might still pass into law though. In favour of the bill are:
Labour 50
NZ First 7
Progressive 1
Total 58
Against:
National 48
Green 6
Maori 4
ACT 2
Total 60
United Future with three MPs is undecided. They voted against the original bill in 2000, and only pledged support this time up until select committee.
I hope they do vote to kill it off. The electorate has proven more than capable at kicking out MPs that need kicking out. Yes it was nice to get rid of Donna Awatere-Huata early but she would have gone anyway once she was convicted. This bill just gives too much power to party leaders.
Nuclear Power is more and more being seen as part of the answer to global warming and limits to other resources.
Australia:
Soaring oil prices would push Australia more quickly towards the
Phil U blogs about the Green Leadership contest, from an insider perspective.
He is obviously no fan of Russel Norman, and states that Norman was one of the Green activists who did not want them to leave the Alliance.
The battle between Tanczos and Norman (most commentators don;t regard the other candidates as having a significant chance) is often portrayed as a battle between two wings – the hard left wing and the environmental first wing.
Phil makes the point that if Sue Bradford replaces Jeanette in the next couple of years, then it will be a clean sweep for the hard left faction.
There is an inaccuracy in the post – about me having attended the post election debrief run by Vic. I was overseas when it was on, so didn’t make it. I did blog reports from others who attended which is what I think Phil is referring to.
I’ve never met or seen Norman to the best of my recollection. I’ve had some interaction with Nandor over the years and in the Comms/IT area I’ve found him pretty knowledgable and passionate about the issues. Of course we probably disagree in around 85% of other areas but there’s a reason I won’t be getting a vote 🙂
Hat Tip: Sir H