More on the budget

A couple of aspects of Deborah Coddington’s column today grabbed my attention.

The first is her statement:

It’s true we have one of the lowest top tax rates in the world but it kicks in at the lowest threshold.

Elsewhere in the OECD, you have to earn 5.4 times the average wage before you’re considered rich enough to make the high tax bracket.

Deborah is around the fourth or fifth journalist now to refere to this fact in the last few days. And prior to the CIS research paper no one was making such explicit comparisons. I think it shows how powerful and useful, such well timed research can prove to be.

I also found amusing the reciting of this exchange from the Budget debate:

And it led to some interesting exchanges in question time as Don Brash attacked Cullen over New Zealand’s trailing a sad 22nd on the international scale of competitiveness, while Australia is sitting pretty at six. Cullen said the main difference is that “Australia digs itself up and exports itself to China and Japan. Unfortunately, we do not have the gas and coal supplies to do that.”

That prompted Brash, not normally known for his wit, to ask if the Government’s bold strategy for “clawing back the gap between after-tax incomes in Australia and New Zealand” is to wait for Australia to run out of gas and coal.

Heh.

Kiwis doing well

The HOS reports on 31 year old Claudia Batten who has just sold her software company to Microsoft for up to US$400 million!

I’ve met Claudia a few times over the years, mainly through her aunt Annabel Young. The article says she may stand for Parliament one day. Heh, she’d even make John Key look poor 🙂

And just to prove how small New Zealand is, I was also at university and Carrington Hall in Dunedin with her husband – Andrew McIlroy. He was at Russell McVeagh along with Claudia.

Anyway congratulations Claudia and Andrew. A great success story.

The purge is coming …

Helen Clark deep down is a FPP politician and has little time for MPs who lose their seats. Once they become List MPs she sees them as serving at her pleasure alone.

Hence the SST reports that List MP Jim Sutton will be gone within a few weeks and Russell Fairbrother and Di Yates by the end of the year. Also on the to go list it seems are Jill Pettis and Ann Hartley.

If those three MPs go, the new MPs will be:

Charles Chauvel, Wellington lawyer
Lesley Soper, Invercargill Unionist and former Labour MP
Louisa Wall, former Silver Fern

Classic Cartman Quote

From the latest Southpark:

Cartman: I’m sorry I handcuffed Billy Turner’s ankle to the school flagpole

Principal: You know that’s not the point

Cartman: Okay I’m sorry I handcuffed Billy Turner’s ankle to a flagpole and gave him a hacksaw and then told him I had poisoned his lunch milk and that the only way he coudl get to the antidote in time is to saw through his leg

Mrs Cartman: That’s very naugthy Eric

Was the final episode for the half-series. I’m suffering withdrawal symptons now.

Save Nazanin

Nazanin Mahabad Fatehi has been sentenced to death by hanging. WHen she was 17 she defended herself and her niece when three men tried to rape her. One of them died from stab wounds.

Now Nazanin is Iranian. In a western country she would probably be acquitted or get a short prison sentence, as the death was obviously committed in self-defense. Also as a 17 years old, she could be treated as a minor. In Iran however, the minimum age for the death penalty is 15 years for males, and nine years for females.

Oh by the way if she had let the men rape her, then she may have got 100 lashes for being found guilty of having pre-maritial sex.

Overseas pressure can and often has saved people from the death penalty. If enough people pressure their Governments to register concern, it will have an impact.

Send an e-mail, or even better a snail mail letter, to our Minister of Foreign Affairs asking him to contact the Iranian Government to help save Nazanin from being executed.

Hat Tip: Juha

An interesting patent application

Have a look at this US patent application:

A pulsed gravitational wave wormhole generator system that teleports a human being through hyperspace from one location to another.

And in the background:

The basis for this invention is an event, referring to FIG. 1, occurring on May 2, 2004, in which the inventor (“he”) personally experienced a full-body teleportation while walking to the bus stop (A) along a road (B) that runs perpendicular to the nearby commercial airport runways where planes are landing. There is a wide iron grating (D) for water drainage that crosses the road at the center of the bus stop. The grating width is such that one has to make a concerted effort to jump across it in order to get from one side to the other. Approximately 50 meters from the iron grating, he (E) felt a vertical wave (F), similar to a flag waving in the breeze, traveling down the street toward the bus stop. The wave velocity was about 1 meter per second, which was slightly faster than his walking speed. In the next instance, he (G) found himself down the street near the corner of the next block. Realizing that he had passed the bus stop, he turned around to see the iron grating approximately 50 meters up the street in back of him. Because there was no recollection of having jumped across the iron grating nor of having passed the bus stop’s yellow marker line, he realized that he had been teleported a distance of 100 meters while moving along with the traveling wave.

Read the whole thing.

Hat Tip: Tim Blair

Aussie rolls out the welcome mat

The Australian Treasurer has said Kiwis who want to earn more money and pay less tax are welcome to come to Australia – especially if they can also play rugby union.

This is somewhat undiplomatic of Treasurer Costello and Cullen will be furious at him for saying it.

Incidentially here is a comparison of the Australian and NZ budgets:

Australian Surplus
03/04 – $4.8b 0.6% of GDP
04/05 – $10.8b 1.2% of GDP
05/06 – $16.0b 1.7%
06/07 – 1.0% onwards

NZ Surplus (OBERAC)
03/04 – $6.6b 4.7% of GDP
04/05 – $8.8b 5.9% of GDP
05/06 – $6.9b 4.5% of GDP
06/07 – $5.7b 3.6% of GDP

Yes the NZ surpluses are three to four times as large as the Australian surpluses. And in Australia no-one is saying the tax cuts are unaffordable. In fact they are saying they don’t go far enough!

How about the rest of the world? Let’s go to the OECD. They have a series on Government net savings as a % of GDP. We are the third highest in the world at 5.6%

Australia has a far lower surplus than NZ, yet is delivering very significant tax reductions. Almost every country is the world has smaller surpluses than NZ yet many if not most of them reduce tax rates over time.

Cullen on tax cuts

Dr Cullen is saying he is “not ideologically opposed to tax cuts”.

This is like Annabel Chong saying she is not ideologically opposed to monogamy!

The NZ Herald says Dr Cullen is “sensitive about being portrayed as having a natural or ideological resistance to tax cuts”.

Well actions speak louder than words. Dr Cullen better get over his sensitivity.

I posted yesterday about how far outside the norm NZ Labour is with refusing tax cuts.

Monopoly Profits

Michael Ellis does a useful comparison. He mentions how one reason many support the recent regulatory changes with Telecom is its very high level of profitability with a 16% profit on its income. That is $916m profit off $5.6b turnover.

He then looks at the Government’s performance last year. Its $8.5b surplus off $44.4b revenue is a 19% profitability figure. So perhaps we need to break up the Government monopoly also 🙂

Spoof Telecom Ad

Oh this is very very funny. Go look at this spoof Telecom ad. Stay with it until the end and see what the kids tell you they think!

Very naughty but very funny.

UPDATE: The site owner has removed it. If another copy is out there let me know.

UPDATE2: Juha has put a copy online on his blog. Heh I have viewed it five tims now.

They’re back!

The Police Investigations

I have just made jpegs of around 20 extracts from the Police reports and will put them up later today or tonight.

I will also be making available all the full reports as pdfs.

A key thing to reember with the Police reports is they have dozens of pages investigating the authorisation offence which was the minor offence and the harder to prove offence.

You’ll find this hard to beleive, but there is basically no record at all of them investigating seperately the over-spending offence. And this is the offence which was the more serious and the one which was easier to prove because it was of strict liability. In fact all their investigating took place before they even received the complaint about over-spending from the Electoral Commission.

Now we had this bizarre Police media release which said there was a prima facie case for a brech of the authorisation section but they did not find a prima facie case for the over-spending. This flies in the face of logic as they use the same legal definition and the over-spending has a much lower threshold of proof. Well the answer is the Police never investigated the over-spending. Seriously

The final Police report devotes just two paragraphs to it. And all it says is Mike Smith says he didn’t pay for them, so he is not liable. Absolutely incredible. Never mind he agreed to include them in his return and changed his mind. They didn’t even ask him about this. Never mind the law is 100% clear that it doesn’t matter who pays.

They spent all their time investigating Section 221 and neglected Section 214B which was far more serious and far easier to prove. I’ve gone through nearly 1,000 pages looking for the details of their Section 214B investigation and it simply isn’t there.

What do you do with a growing economy?

I think many NZers don’t realise how absolutely outside the mainstream (pardon the term!) Labour are with their refusal to cut tax rates despite tens of billions of dollars in surpluses over the years. This is not just a case of oh left wing parties never cut tax. You would struggle to find any party anywhere in the developed world who given our fiscal circumstances would not be reducing tax rates. Sure there would be a wide variation as to by how much, but NZ Labour is very isolated in its views.

To illustrate how ridicolous Labour’s stance is, let me point out what the equivalent opposite action would be to what they are doing.

Imagine a National Government that has presided over seven years of a growing economy. Over that seven years that have cut taxes every year. Also over that seven years they have chalked up tens of billions in surpluses. But over that seven years that have refused to increase Government spending by one cent. Yes no matter how good the case, no matter how long the waiting lists, no matter how many more students are attending universities the Government over seven years refused to increase spending by even a cent. That insisted that every single dollar of the growing economy must go into tax cuts and surpluses.

What would you call such a Government? You’d call it fucking crazy wouldn’t you. I mean sure if you had an operating deficit you might refuse to increase expenditure for say one year, but with massive surpluses what sort of Government would refuse to increase spending at all year after year?

Well this is what Labour are doing, in reverse.

Think about it. There are three approahces you can take when you have a growing economy. And with the odd minor blip, the NZ economy has been growing since around 1991. This is good. And as the economy grows, more people work, more companies make money and hence more tax is paid.

Now one extreme is to not increase spending at all. Stick it all into tax cuts.

Another extreme is to not reduce taxes at all and stick it all into extra spending.

But the middle way, the way practised by almost every-one, is to have a mixture of tax reduction and increased spending. Of course left wing parties will have a greather emphasis on spending, and centre-right parties a greater emhasis on tax reduction but normally you just argue about the mix. A CL party may put 80% of the increased tax take into spending, and give 20% back in tax cuts. A CR party might put 55% into increased spending and 45% into tax cuts.

But this Taliban-like ideological purity where NZ Labour will not consider any reduction in tax rates, no matter what, is just nuts.

Tax Facts

The latest key tax facts is worth a look at.

Those earning over $60,000 a year, the despised “rich” whom Dr Cullen increased the tax rate on because they weren’t contributing enough money, the bludgers who had an envy tax put on them when there was no fiscal need to do so. Yep we recall them.

Well they now pay 51% of all income tax. Yep the top 12% pay over half. The top 3% pay over one quarter of all income tax. Bet you Aussie has just started to look better for them.

We also see how a couple with three children will receive social welfare from the Government right up until their income is $93,760. Yes all you single people who did not get a tax cut – it is going to your Catholic lawyer as family assistance. Never mind he or she is earning twice as much as you.

Even couples with only one sole child get family assistance up until around $70,000. The Government giveth and the Government teketh away!

I would rather the Government just leaveth some more!

Budget Reaction

John Armstring compares Fran O’Sullivan says the Budget which again displays shallow thinking as far as spurring short-term economic growth goes.

David Skilling from the NZ Institute says if the Budget was intended to underline the Government’s commitment to economic transformation, we are in trouble.

The Press calls it a timid budget “with the usual grand rhetoric about transforming the economy, raising productivity, strengthening families and enhancing national identity, but no sense that this administration really does have the ideas to achieve these goals”.

The Dominion Post concludes “there is money for tax cuts, and there would be even more if the Government took a closer look at some of the loopy schemes ministers have okayed over the past few years.

The decision not to cut taxes is a political one based on the belief that Dr Cullen and his colleagues know how to spend taxpayers’ money better than they do themselves”.

Not quite universally panned, but not far from it.

Road Funding

The Government’s delivery of extra funding for road construction has been welcomed by pretty much everyone except the Greens. Their idea of a transport solution is to have four hour delays on the roads so people will abandon their cars. Yes, seriously.

Over the next few years the Government will spend more on roading than it takes in petrol tax, and this is welcome. Of course this is also hypocritical as they attacked National for its pledge to do just that.

But there is still a difference between Labour and National’s policies. National has pledged as permanent policy to have all of the petrol tax spent on the roads. Labour are not committed to maintaining this, and are just doing one off ad hoc top-ups of roading from the consolidated fund.

As I have said before, the way for the future should be to set a policy to have all of the petrol tax go onto roading, and have the level of petrol tax adjust automatically to fund all projects over a specific benefit:cost ratio. This would deliver predictability and remove much of the politics around roading.

Another student mag under fire

Another student newspaper, Chaff, is under fire from Chinese students. This time for a satirical takeoff of a Cosmo cover.

0,1445,236551,00.jpg

My initial reaction is somewhat harsh – that people need to understand New Zealand culture thrives on satire, sarcasm and mocking – and it isn’t personal. Chaff doing a spoof of Chairman Mao has nothing to do with the idiots who spout racist abuse.

My second reaction is more harsh – that Chairman Mao killed more people (40 million) than Hitler or Stalin (20 million), so worshipping him as Jesus like figure is pretty fucked up. But anyway, even if he is a Jesus like figure – hell student mags mock Jesus and Christians hundreds of times over the years. It’s the double standards which infuriate me. Does anyone think mockery of a western leader or religious figure in a student newspaper would be an issue?

But there is one point on which I strongly do support the offended students. They pay a compulsory MUSA fee which funds Chaff. It it bad enough to be offended by an article (and I respect the offence is genuine), but when you are forced to fund the publication in question – well that really rankles.

There is no right not to be offended in NZ. The day we have that right is the day we have no humour, no satire and no free speech. However there should be a right not to have to fund student newspapers which offend you.

Oh I did have to laugh at one Chinese students’ defence of Mao by saying “He’s no more a killer than George Washington or George W Bush.” Heh in NZ comparing him to the same level as Bush is not a smart move – most Kiwis probably do regard Bush as a megalomaniac killer.

Hat Tip: Michael Ellis

A few Budget snippets

Tax revenue is forecast to increase from $46b to $57b in 2010. Over the five years the total extra tax paid will be around $31b.

Core crown expenditure to increase from $46B last year to $60b in 2010.

The underlying surplus, or OBERAC, for this year is $1 billion higher than six months ago. Treasury do many many things well, but boy do they constantly under-estimate the surplus.

Cullen spins a lot on what surplus one should use, and tries to convince peopel we should go back to the 1970s and do it all by cash accounting. I doubt any countries outside Mongolia rely on cash surplsues anymore.

Now the OBERAC (excluding gains from NZSF) over 2005 to 2007 is:

04/05 – $8.7b
05/06 – $6.5b
06/07 – $5.1b

Total – $20.3b

Now if $6.5b to cover NZSF contributions was retained, then tax refunds of $13.8, over three years could have been delivered. NZ families would have. based on around 1.5 million housholds, about $9,000 per household on average.

Sigh!

Oh John Key has a great press release, stealing the UNITE unions’ language. That Labour has a Supersize Me surplus but is refusing to give NZers even a McNugget of tax relief. Nice.

At last!

Auckland Koru Club, after years of requests, now had broadband access for laptops. Oh the joy. Not only do you get normal speed Internet, I don’t have to pay for additional charges of dialing in to my ISP on a broadband account.

Even better they say they will have wireless in a few months. Hopefully this will happen at Wellington Airport also.

I am currently at Auckland Airport incidentially. So far the only budget news I have heard is from text messages being:

1) Obscene level of surplus
2) Lots more spending on the roads, and the Greens are wailing
3) Don Brash gave a great speech

Polling Newsletter

Curia Research, my polling company, has just published the first of what will be regular monthly newsletters on public opinion polls.

Every month the newsletter will present a summary of political polls in New Zealand, Australia, the United States, the United Kingdom and Canada, and provide an analysis of them. It will also cover current NZ polls on policy and business issues.

The newsletter is free, but in future will be distributed by e-mail only. I am putting the initial edition up on my blog to let people know it exists. If you would like to receive future editions, please e-mail [email protected] with your name, e-mail address and if applicable your organisation.

The full newsletter (six pages) is available here as a pdf. And below is an extract summarising the public polls since the election.

allpolls.JPG

National and Labour have remained within a few points of each other since the election which is represented as September 2005.

allminors.JPG

The Green Party has polled consistently over the 5% threshold. NZ First had a steady progressive decline in 2005 to just over 3%, but in 2006 have stabilized. United Future also declined in 2005.

Gay scarf offended

Messenger may sue for unfair dismissal

The messenger sacked for leaking the cabinet paper to Telecom may sue over his dismissal.

This would be deeply ironic if he does. Because while no-one would disagree his dismissal was justified on substantive terms, the current employment law requires near perfect process. So if SSC and DPMC have erred in any way he may get a payout.

Budget Coverage

Dr Cullen’s office kindly agreed to treat blogers as media and accredited me to the budget lockup today. This would have meant I get to start reading the budget papers at midday, so as his speech starts at 2 pm I can then start reporting and analysing material as he announces it.

However in a fit of stupidity I overlooked that I have a meeting in Auckland today starting at, you guess it 2 pm. Even worse I am chairing the meeting and set the date and time! So budget coverage from DPF will have to wait until later on Thursday. Doesn’t sound like too many surprises left in the bag anyway.

The CEO acts

On 20 October 2005 the Chief Electoral Officer refers the breach of Section 221 to the NZ Police. He had warned Labour no less than three times before the election the pledge cards were an electoral advertisement. He has had legal advice from the Ministry of Justice and Crown Law Office. He even had Labour agreeing to include them as an electoral expense and then reneging on that commitment.

lab6.JPG

Now note the language in the letter from the CEO. He labels the actions a “clear breach”. This is unusual as many referrals from the CEO to the Police do not conclude a clear breach but just ask for an investigation.

lab7.JPG

The CEO on 20 October also writes back to Labour. He states the arguments put forward by Labour have been considered but he remains of the view that “the advertising clearly encourages or persuades or appears to encourage or persaude voters to vote for the Labour Party”.

The withdrawal

So it is still pre-election. Labour have said that they don’t think the pledge cards are electoral activity, yet have offered to include them in their election return.

In the meantime the Chief Electoral Office has been getting legal opinions. One from the Office of Lgeal Counsel on 14 Sep 2005 and one from Crown Law Office on 16 Sep 2005. These are blacked out so we do not know their exact advice. However in light of the fact that the CEO later referred Labour to the Police, it seems a safe bet they both backed the CEO’s view of the law. In fact months later the CEO tells the Police that Crown Law had stated the law with regards to Section 221 is very clear.

lab5.JPG

Then comes the bombshell. Out of the blue, three weeks later on 5 October 2005 Labour withdraws its offer to include the costs in their election return. Now this is a serious matter of electoral administration when a major party gives a pledge to the top electoral officer, and then reneges on it.