Labour’s Response

Okay Labour has now had the CEO contact them three times over the pledge card. They have realised he is not going to be fobbed off. So this time they reply in detail to why they should not be referred to the Police for the lack of authorisation (the over-spending issue comes later). Their points are:

There is no way the statutory requirement of “wilfulness” can be proved on the facts as required by Section 221(4)

What does Section 221(4) say: “Subject to subsections (2) and (3) of this section, every person is guilty of an illegal practice who wilfully contravenes any provision of subsection (1) of this section.”

Now “willfulness” is a requirement for Section 221 prosecutions. However, and this is crucial, it is not a requirement for over-spending under Section 214B. In fact is is the opposite – 214B makes a breach a matter of strict liability, regardless of intent.

This makes sense. One can accidentally break the authorisation rule (as I have done in a very minor way once) but the over-spending rule is not one you can easily break accidentally. Hence it does not require proof of “willfulness”

To successfully use the willfulness defence, in my opinion, would need an exploration of who was in the room when the pledge cards were discussed and agreed to. But regardless of the willfulness defence the key thing is that it is *not* a defence for the over-spending.

Paragraphs Seven to Twelve from Mike Smith then deal with whether the pledge cards were within the guidelines of The Parliamentary Service. This is irrelevant to the Electoral Act. The internal rules of the PS do not trump the operation of the Electoral Act. The law is very settled on this point.

Then Mike Smith tries to argue under the Bill of Rights Act that interpretation must be done in a way to promote freedom of expression. Cute.

Finally Smith falls back on parliamentary privilege saying that the Electoral Act can not over-ride the privileges of MPs to communicate with their constituents in the manner permitted by the Speaker. Also very cute.

Now I am not a trained lawyer. However these arguments did not convince the Chief Electoral Officer or the Electoral Commission which is made up of the Secretary of Justice, a former Judge and a current Judge (plus their CEO). The ultimate test would have been to have a Judge hear the case and decide on the current circumstances. It’s worth noting too that even the Police said they thought a conviction was probable.

What is fascinating is the one thing Mike Smith did *not* argue. Nowhere did he argue that the pledge cards do not “encourage or persuade or appears to encourage or persuade voters to vote for” Labour. That is the key test laid down by the Act. Not only does Smith never challenge that the pledge cards on these grounds – neither do the Police as we shall see.

Instead Smith has argued that MPs are not bound by the Act, so long as the Speaker has approved their publications. Well this is contrary to the specific advice given to MPs by the Electoral agencies in their handbooks and is against the case law set down by the Wairarapa Electoral Petition.

Finally Mike Smith, possibly recognising the seriousness of the situation, makes his offer to include the pledge cards in their election return.

If I was a journalist I would be asking Mr Smith why he made that offer, who agreed to that offer being made, and why was it withdrawn later.

One should also remember that political parties and candidates are paranoid about over-spending and track expenditure carefully. In WC I had a spreadsheet which depending on what day the election was called tracked to the exact $ how much expenditure we had already incurred against the $20,000, how much is budgeted for next few weeks etc. Also National Party HQ tracked their expenditure plus the party vote expenditure of all 62 MPs on a very regular basis to check they were under the limit.

My point being that on the day Mike Smith offered to include the $448,000 in their election return, he *must* have known that would put them over the limit. You would be the most incompetent campaign manager in history if you did not know three days before the election whether you could afford to add $448,000 to your return and stay within the limits.

The only conclusion one can draw is that the Labour Party General Secretary deliberately lied to the Chief Electoral Officer, to kick for touch until after the election. And a decent police investigation would have asked who he consulted with before making that offer. Because unless you believe in Santa Claus you would think he would never ever make that call on his own authority.

The Electoral Act

So far we have established that the CEO warned Labour weeks before the election that its pledge cards constituted election advertisements and expenses. And that Labour had agreed to include the cost in its return. Before we turn to Labour’s arguments (which were rejected) for why they are not election advertisements, we need to be precise about the two offences under the Electoral Act.

One offence is that of not correctly authorising an election advertisement. These matters are enforced by the Chef Electoral Office as and when they occur. He also found an ACT billboard was an offence but as they agreed to take it down he did not refer to the Police.

The other offence is that of over-spending. And this is enforced by the Electoral Commission and can only be decided upon once the party files its return after the election.

Turning to the Act, we look at Section 221:

(1) Subject to subsections (2) and (3) of this section, no person shall publish or cause or permit to be published in any newspaper, periodical, poster, or handbill, or broadcast or cause or permit to be broadcast over any radio or television station, any advertisement which

ME

Last Friday was ME Awareness Day. ME being myalgic encephalomyelitis.

One of my former flatmates had ME, and it was a great learning experience for me about how it can affect your life. He had been Dux of his school, top scholar at law school, worked for a top law firm (Russell McVeagh) but as he got afflicted he had to keep reducing his hours. He always carried on working more than he should have, when led to the condition getting worse. Finally he had to leave law all together when he couldn’t work for more than a couple of hours a day. Within days he was volunteering at a local school to help kids with remedial reading etc. as he wouldn’t accept just sitting at home doing nothing.

Because the causes of ME is unknown, some people think oh it is all just in the mind – they’re just depressed. Trust me this is so not the case for most sufferers.

People may want to check out the Associated New Zealand ME Society website for more info.

Centre for Independent Studies

I think it is always a sign of the strength of your research, when those who don’t like it attack the messenger, not the message.

Dr Cullen was so alarmed by the CIS report into taxation, that he made an attack on it the first patsy question on the order paper where he could shock horror reveal that the author used to work for Bill English and they even had a business card to prove it.

All major parties in Australia take the CIS quite seriously. This article in The Australian.

Quite often they are also critical of the Coalition Government – especially their failure to do proper tax reform (which is different to just lowering tax rates).

Very interesting also to note in that article, that Australian Labor are now talking about giving vouchers and tax rebates to parents who send their children to private schools. Also worth noting the author of the article is a former Labor adviser for Kim Beazley and former speechwriter for Mark Latham.

More on Telecom Leaker

The NZ Herald reports that both the Cabinet Secretary and the DPMC Chief Executive offered their resignations over the leak.

As I said last night, this was not a systems failure so Clark is right not to accept. I am still amazed it was someone from DPMC and Cabinet Office. They ranked bottom on my list of likely leakers because the one thing they are known for is never leaking. And I mean never. You couldn’t get most Cabinet Office staff to tell you the time without them checking it wasn’t classified 🙂

DHBs forced to cull

Helen has tried to blame the great patient cull on bad management by a few DHBs. However this NZ Herald article makes it very clear that DHBs are instructed by the Health Ministry to make such culls.

The Waitemata and central Auckland boards have been told they need to reduce the list of over 8000 patients waiting more than six months by 6000 patients.

And what happens if they do not? They lose up to $3 million of funding.

This policy is being directed by central Government. The DHBs are the patsies who you are meant to blame.

Over-Spending Series

Salient joke defended

Keith Ng defends and explains the joke in Salient which has got the Chinese Embassy demanding action, apologies from the Vice-CHancellor etc. He says Salient has nothing to apologise for, and I agree.

The sad thing is that some people are so keen to take offence, at anything. Chill pills needed all around.

Final West Wing Episode

Sigh – I have just finished watching the last ever episode of The West Wing.

It has been a magnificent series. The script writing and acting has been superb.

Anyway I should end it with a list of favourites:

Favourite Male WW Staffer: Josh
Favourite Female WW Staffer: CJ
Favourite Consultant: Joey Lucas
Favourite Elected Official: Acting President Glen Allen Walken
Favourite Military Advisor: Nancy McNally
Favourite Episode: Two Cathedrals (2-22)
Favourite WW Blonde: Annabeth Schott

The leaker was a messenger!

Okay well the leaker was not on my short list, or I suspects anyone. He is not a political appointee or policy analyst but a messenger with the Department of PM and Cabinet.

I am amazed. The DPMC messengers handle all sorts of highly confidential papers and until today I would have said are beyond reproach. I don’t think Michael Ryan was a messenger when I was in the Beehive, but I know many of the messengers from them still work there and will be hugely disappointed to have one of their own do this.

I think the SSC are right to refer this matter to the Police also. It is a shocking breach of trust. Also very honourable for the CE of DPMC to offer his resignation. And likewise appropriate not to accept it. This was not a systems failure.

Great Achievement

New Zealand Tax Levels

Phil Rennie from the Centre for Independent Studies has done a short research paper on tax levels in New Zealand. A very useful contribution which sorts out facts from myths.

Amongst the findings:

* Anyone earning under $180,000 pays less personal income tax in Australia
* The top tax rate, while low at 39%, comes in at 1.4 times the average wage – the OECD average being 5.6 times the average wage
* New Zealanders are paying 50% more nominal tax than they did in 2000
* personal income tax makes up only 43% of total tax revenue
* tax as a percentage of GDP is 34.9% in NZ and 31.6% in Australia
* tax revenue increased by $4 billion last year alone
* long-term tax revenue forecasts are very conservative, growing $5 billion from initial forecasts
* the current surplus is $9.4 billion in the nine months to 31 March 2006

Finally I give you this quote from Gareth Morgan, used in the paper:

Surpluses deny people their reward from work through over-taxing
– Gareth Morgan, Infometrics

UPDATE: An article by author Phil Rennie is also in today’s NZ Herald.

UPDATE2: The Dominion Post editorial endorses the report and calls for the tax brackets to be lifted in this week’s budget, not in 2008.

NZ has had Stalinist famine!

Far North Brothel

Just been listening to 60 minutes who have one of their items on the doctor up north who has turned his surgery into a brothel as he got sick of the Government regulations etc from the health bureaucracy.

Anyway they interviewed a local – Danny Sims, who is a lay pastor, who said

“They are buying sex because they want something different. They are buying sex because they want the bizarre … it’s not just the nice missionary-style type of sex”

Okay so sex which is not missionary-style is bizarre and “not nice”.

Quite an amusing item. Especially when the pastor tells children to stop listening so he can call clients of prostitutes “wankers”. Hilarious.

The offer

lab1.JPG

On 14 September Mike Smith replies, having consulted in his own words “senior counsel”. He argues in some depth as to why the pledge card and brochure is not advertising. But before we turn to his arguments, they key things is his final paragraph where he offers to include the cost of the cards and brochures in Labour’s election return.

For reasons I will touch on in later posts, the issue of spending limits is far more important that correct authorisation statements. So the concession on including it in the election return is a major one. One they later withdrew. Yes they agreed before the election to include the cost, and then weeks later so “Oh we have changed our mind”.

Why would they do this? On 14 September you would know for sure if you can afford to include the cost in your return and stay under the limit. I suspect that they were terrified the CEO would announce he was referring Labour to the Police prior to the election. So perhaps they conceded on the election funding as a diversionary measure. The best way to find out would be for a journalist to ask Mike Smith why did he make the offer, when he must have known it would put Labour over the limit as Labour had not reduced its spending in other areas to sat under the total limit.

The fend-off

Mike Smith replies to the CEO on 6 September 2005. He doesn’t answer any of the detailed questions put forward by the CEO, except to say:

* The material is produce by the Office of the Leader of the Parliamentary Labour Party

* A requirement of parliamentary guidelines for such ‘policy material’ is that it not be used to carry a vote message

* It doesn’t carry the words “Party Vote”

* All other questions should be addressed to the Office of the Leader

The CEO responds on 12 September noting the earlier questions were not answered in full, and noting a further complaint about the A2 flyer has been received. He repeats his questions, asking in essence:

1) Confirmation it is being distributed to every household, and how

2) Whether Smith authorised the advertising

3) Why is there no authorisation statement under Section 221

4) Any points Labour wishes to make as to why this should not be referred to the Police

Second Contact

The Chief Electoral Officer followed up his phone call of 30 August with a letter dated 2 September to Mike Smith, Labour’s General Secretary.

The two page letter sets out that the Chief Electoral Officer believes the pledge card and pamhlets are election advertising, because:

* they have the same logo and the same slogan as Labour’s campaign advertising
* It makes commitments in respect of the future
* It is being distributed within three weeks of Elecion Day

Hence the CEO concludes “the statements made in the advertising encourage or persuade, or appear to encourage or persuade, voters to vote for the Labour Party” and hence “The advertising is therefore subject to the provisions of Section 221”.

lab2.JPG

The final part of the letter is shown here. In it you see the CEO specifically warns Labour that this may be referred to the Police as an illegal practice, and that he also regards the advertising as an election expense under Section 214B.

So at this stage Labour can have no doubt about the view of the top electoral official, and could have adjusted their campaign accordingly.

First Contact

lab3.JPG

This is a file note made by the Chief Electoral Officer first thing on 30 August 2005. There are four important things to note:

1) It is 18 days before the election

2) The CEO has quite clearly informed Labour that who pays for it doesn’t matter

3) To be deemed an “advertisement” it does not need to specifically call for the party vote.

4) Labour admitted that in 2002 their pledge cards and brochures did carry an authorisation statement – something they now call a mistake.

Now readers may wish to reflect on what probably happened internally within Labour after receiving this phone call. From my experience of parties and campaigns I would say that there would be an emergency conference call or meeting within hours of being notified that the Chief Electoral Officer was concerned about the lack of authorisation of a major part of a campaign.

The issues

There are three issues relating to Labour’s pledge cards, and here is where we start to get into what the Police got wrong. The three issues are:

1) Were the pledge cards an “election activity” and hence an “election expense” under Section 214B of the Electoral Act 1993.

2) Were the pledge cards an “advertisement” under Section 221 of the Electoral Act 1993.

3) Should the pledge cards have been funded out of The Parliamentary Serice, under the rules set in place by The Parliamentary Service Commission.

Now here is the crucial bit. Issues (1) and (2) have very little to do with (3). The first two issues are connected to each other, as they use similiar definitions in the same Act. But (3) is not connected.

To be specific, one can find the pledge cards are a legitimate use of Parlimentary funding, and also find they are an election expense and an advertisement under the Electoral Act.

Now this is not just my view, but the view of the High Court in the Wairarapa Electoral Petition, the view of the Chief Electoral Officer and the Electoral Commission. It is also made clear in the election guide to political parties:

Parties should also be aware that some facilities and services claimed against MPs’ budgets within Vote Parliamentary Service may have to be included in a party’s return of election expenses if they are used for an election activity on behalf of the party.

Now the fatal mistake the Police made is they spent all their time investigating Issue (3) which wasn’t even an issue for them. It has nothing to do with them. It is a matter for the Speaker and the Auditor-General.

The Police seemed to think that merely being okay under The Parliament Service Commission’s internal rules, means that it is okay under the Electoral Act. This is not true, as the Electoral Act stands on its own merits.

You will see in later documents how the Police were confused on this point right up until after they released their findings, and the Chief Electoral Officer had to put them right.

The timeline

This is a time-line of the major events relating to the investigation.

Tue 30-Aug-05 CEO asks Labour why pledge card and brochure not authorised

Fri 02-Sep-05 CEO writes to Mike Smith

Tue 06-Sep-05 Mike Smith replies to CEO saying it is all the Leader’s Office

Mon 12-Sep-05 CEO repeats questions to Mike Smith

Wed 14-Sep-05 Mike Smith writes to CEO offering to include pledge cards in election advertising

Wed 05-Oct-05 Mike Smith writes to CEO withdrawing offer to include pledges cards

Thu 20-Oct-05 CEO refers lack of authorisation to Police

Mon 12-Dec-05 Heather Simpson spoken to by phone

Tue 27-Dec-05 DSS Arnerich recomends to DI Quinn not to prosecute Labour for lack of authorisation

Wed 18-Jan-06 DI Quinn recommends to OOTC not to prosecute Labour for lack of authorisation

Thu 09-Feb-06 Electoral Commission refers Labour to Police for over-spending by $418,603

Mon 27-Feb-06 DI Peoples recommends to DS Perry no prosecutions

Mon 27-Feb-06 DS Perry recommends to AC Marshall no prosecutions

Wed 01-Mar-06 AC Marshall recommends to ADC Carson not to prosecute but to have Dr Andrew Jack review the rport

Thu 02-Mar-06 Acting Dep Cmsr Carson asks Crown Law and OOTC Chief Legal Adviser to review

Fri 17-Mar-06 Police announce, on arguably last possible day, no prosecutions

Mon 20-Mar-06 CEO writes to Police asking for recommendations referred to by ADC Carson

Tue 21-Mar-06 Meeting between Police and CEO re Police release

Wed 22-Mar-06 Police write to CEO to advise Police will contact OAG re Parl Expend Rules

Some key things to note at this stage:

1) Labour were first alerted to the CEO’s concerns 18 days before the election. The standard campaign is in the last four weeks mainly, so this was quite early in the peice

2) Labour agreed, prior to the election, to include the pledge cards in their expenditure

3) Only three weeks later did Labour withdraw its agreement – after the election

The players

To help keep track of who does what, these are the major players:

Electoral Authorities

David Henry, Chief Electoral Officer

Robert Peden, Manager Electoral Events, Chief Electoral Office

Electoral Commission consiting of:
President: Hon. Anthony (Tony) Ellis QC
Chief Judge of the Maori Land Court: Joe Williams
Secretary for Justice: Belinda Clark
Chief Executive: Dr Helena Catt

Police

Asst Commissioner Roger Carson, Acting Deputy Police Commissioner (Operations)

Asst Commissioner Peter Marshall, Assistant Police Commissioner (Crime Reduction & Public Safety)

DS Nick Perry, Detective Superintendant, National Crime Manager

Andrew Jack, Chief Legal Adviser, Office of the Police Commissioner

DI Harry Quinn, Detective Inspector, Wellington District Crime Services Manager

DI Bill Peoples, Detective Inspector, Acting National Manager of National Bureau of Investigation SUpport

DSS Mike Arnerich, Crime Strategy Manager, Wellington District CIB

Labour

Mike Smith, Labour Party General Secretary

Heather Simpson, Chief of Staff to PM Helen Clark

Background to the Series

Over today, and possibly tomorrow, I am going to make a series of posts drawing on the hundreds of pages released by the Police under the OIA in relation to their decision not to charge Labour with over-spending at the last election. These will include extracts and scans of various letters and reports.

They will all be in the new category of Electoral Act, so that you can click on the series link to see them all together.

I believe that any fair person reading the documents will conclude, as I have, that the Police decision not to prosecute was based on either incompetence or cowardice – not a charge I make lightly. But the documents speak for themselves.

I also point out that this case is not a borderline case, or a marginal call. It was over-whelming.

There have been other cases involving Labour Ministers – specifically Helen Clark, David Benson-Pope, Pete Hodgson, and David Parker. In those cases the decisions made not to prosecute, while debatable, were reasonable decisions to make. I have actually said they were on balance the right decisions. They were certainly decisions on which reasonable people could disagree.

My contention here is that the Police reasoning and decisions in this case are not ones you could reasonably agree with. They have in fact made very basic mistakes throughout. They appear to have done almost no actual investigating or interviewing, and misled the public with their public release.

Anyway don’t take my word for it. Read on, and at the end of the series, come to your own conclusions.

Iworldpeople

Online Air NZ

The SFO