Fran O’Sullivan on Telecom

Good God. If people think I am sometimes harsh on Telecom, read this column by Fran O’Sullivan.

Fran calls for Mark Prebble to expand his leak inquiry (which I can guarantee he will not do) to include the following:

1. Investigate just how the nation’s largest listed company was able to exert such a stranglehold over the Government at all levels that it took more than three years after the first recommendations emerged before the Cabinet dealt with its broadband monopoly.

a) Why did the Cabinet turn down a proposal put forward by previous communications minister Paul Swain that had been backed by the Ministry of Economic Development to crunch the broadband monopoly in 2004?

b) Was the billion-dollar leaker working for Telecom back then and was he or she part of a nexus of well-connected players paid from the telco’s alleged $30 million Government relations budget?

2. Investigate whether Telecom boss Theresa Gattung and her high-priced consultants “spread confusion” in Telecommunications Commissioner Douglas Webb’s mind that he could reverse his earlier decision to curtail Telecom’s monopolistic position in late 2003 in favour of a proposal put forward by the telco which it blatantly undershot.

3. Investigate how Telecom “duchessed” leading business organisations to the extent that Gattung could get away with claiming that the broadband issue was a manufactured grievance driven by competitors and the news media.

4. Investigate the extent of Telecom’s funding of political parties.

c) Why is United Future taking so long in giving approval for an inquiry by Parliament’s commerce committee?

5. Investigate how many former Beehive advisers are paid lobbyists or consultants to Telecom.

6. Investigate how Gattung got telecommunication regulations eliminated from a transtasman probe into competition issues affecting both countries.

7. Investigate what provisions the Government had made to ensure its market-sensitive decision to axe Telecom’s broadband monopoly was conveyed to the company in an orderly fashion to stop market disruption and insider trading.

8. Why did the Prime Minister need a visit to South Korea last year before she woke up to the fact that New Zealand’s telecommunications environment was “country cousin status” and do something about it?

Read the full column. Very powerful.

Johm Armstrong on e-mail handling

I probably link to John Armstrong’s columns more than any other person – not because he is always saying what I want him to say – but because he is so often right in his analysis of events.

While his language is overly colourful, I don’t think anyone would disagree with his analysis that the handling of the leaked e-mail was not up to standard.

The main story itself is a nonsense, as I pointed out yesterday. It should have been rebutted and dealt with, within one news cycle. But now the handling of the rebuttal has itself become the story and will keep it alive for a week or so.

Some days you do well, some days not so well. Main thing is to learn from the days that go not so well and make sure they are not repeated.

Helen vs Theresa

Heh. Someone puts audio clip online with Theresa saying telcos around the world had used confusion as their chief marketing tool. Then Russell and I blog about it. Then the NZ Herald picks the story up. Then the next day it is the major story on TV and press with the PM rebuking Theresa for her comments.

Blogs 1 Telecom 0 🙂

I am incidentially stunned that Theresa said she didn’t think local loop unbundling was a done deal. Because since the speech from the throne in February it has been absolutely obvious to me that LLU was going to happen, and Telecom themselves had shown signs that they were preparing for this.

LLU was not the surprise in the announcements – it was all the other aspects – something I will explain in more detail at some stage./

Helen vs Theresa

Heh. Someone puts audio clip online with Theresa saying telcos around the world had used confusion as their chief marketing tool. Then Russell and I blog about it. Then the NZ Herald picks the story up. Then the next day it is the major story on TV and press with the PM rebuking Theresa for her comments.

Blogs 1 Telecom 0 🙂

I am incidentally stunned that Theresa said she didn’t think local loop unbundling was a done deal. Because since the speech from the throne in February it has been absolutely obvious to me that LLU was going to happen, and Telecom themselves had shown signs that they were preparing for this.

LLU was not the surprise in the announcements – it was all the other aspects – something I will explain in more detail at some stage./

How weak!

I heard commentators on Newstalk ZB laughing about Winston’s latest e-mail revelation, basically saying that it was very very lame.

The e-mail purports to reveal that Don Brash said having an American strategist involved with the campaign would be a good idea. Wow wee. That’s almost as exciting as oh flying on a US airline.

It is sadly ironic that Peters resorts to playing on anti-americanism when he has vowed to improve the relationship with the US.

But let us turn to the substance of the issue – that somehow there is something bad or wrong to have overseas involvement in an election campaign. Bullshit.

Politics is global, and it is the most natural thing in the world that parties use expertise both domestically and internationally. Both National and Labour have had overseas advisors from time to time.

I’ve been active in the International Democratic Union for six years or so and 90% of the activities at their meetings is discussing campaigning, gaining contacts, ideas etc. That’s one of the reason I attend a lot of them (foreign women being the other of course 🙂

I’ve even lent a hand in the recent Canadian elections and have helped advise some UK lobby groups etc. I’ll probably help out on an Australian campaign at some stage if there is one at a convenient time, and have a number of invites to work on various US campaigns.

So there is nothing more routine and normal than having some international experience on your campaign team. Peters and Mallard’s attempts to paint this as something sinister is laughable and pathetic.

Incidentally I did enjoy in Canada, when people asked me where I was from and why I was there, replying “I’m from DC – Cheney sent me up” to observe the look of fear on their faces 🙂

Field Inquiry Draft Report done

At long last, the inquiry which was meant to last nine days has a draft report after eight months.

Now a few things to watch out for:

* When the PM says she has not seen the draft, this is is literally true but she almost certainly has been briefed on what it says.

* The fact she has mentioned there is a draft report suggests that the level of misbehaviour has not been enough to warrant charges or losing one’s seat. If it was really bad news, then there would be no mention of the report until they had worked out an exit strategy for Field.

* Be very very cautious about leaks from the draft report – especially in the Sunday papers. Remember how Benson-Pope leaked a couple of sentences totally out of context

* The sooner the final report is released the better it is for Field. If there is no final report for several weeks, then he is fighting against the draft. If they release it at 4.30 pm this Friday then he feels it is harmless

* The inquiry had no powers at all to force people to testify.

Smears from Helen

Rather than just say the obvious, which is that a Government Department behaved badly to visiting MPs, Helen has decided to go for the smear treatment and is insisting that the National MPs who walked out were not being rebuked for sitting in the front row, but for boorish behaviour during the ceremony.

This shows wonderful powers of telepathy as the PM wasn’t at the event in question.

MP Paula Bennett, who was there, dismissed Clark’s allegations as fiction, saying that the kaumatua made it very clear that he found it offensive and that it ‘brought shame’ for two women to sit in the front.

This is very simple. The Department broke Government policy by complaining about the seating arrangements, and they have apologised. Also if Georgina Beyer had not unilaterlly over-ridden the wishes of her committee none of this would have happened.

MPs under the influence

NZPA has reported on the story told by former Labour Invercargill MP Mark Peck about his battle with alcoholism.

The most startling revelation for me was that he was drunk when he announced he would not be standing again for Parliament, and that he might not have stood down otherwise. Mind you not as bad as Muldoon calling an election under the influence!

I suspect that the best thing for Mr Peck was standing down though. Parliament is not a good environment for fighting alcoholism. It’s not that the place is incredibly boozy, but the long and late hours lend themselves to situations where some drinks in the evening can be common.

Peck’s personal problems were not in fact much of a secret around Parliament. Not many secrets are well kept in and around the Beehive. There was a fair degree of sympathy for when he crashed his car and confronted his alcoholism – something which would normally be fair game for attack. And the good thing is that he has now been sober for around 18 months – as he himself said on this blog.

On a lighter note, dancing on the tables at the average National Party would not be that remarkable – the Nat parties have a good history of vigourous singing and dancing 🙂

Hayley Westenra stalked

Leaky Homes

I recall well the day when an angry Helen Clark denounced on radio the leaky homes issues as a beat-up, saying it was just the Herald “banging on” about it.

There are now 15,000 homes with a collective repair bill of over $1 billion.

As the Government arbitration system may take over 20 years to hear all the cases, the Government is looking at interest free loans for houses needing repairs.

The mad monarchist

Oh this is hilarious. Mr Bill Wilmot has a monarchist blog (which frankly probably scares more people off the monarchy than Camilla does) and many people will know Lewis Holden who has his Republican blog.

Well Mr Wilmot has decided to play super sleuth and expose Lewis. So after some detective workj worthy of Sherlock Holmes, or maybe the Pink Panther, he reveals that Lewis is a Deputy Secretary of the Ministry of Economic Development and hence a Labour Party hack (as all civil servants are according to Wilmot).

The only problem with this fine detective work is that Lewis is not the Deputy Secretary of MED. That is just someone with the same name. Our Lewis is a law student at VUW.

So how stupid does this make Mr Wilmot?

The part I can’t wait for is his promise to “write more on other members of the ‘Republican movement’ front orgainization, and to expose their links to the Labour party”. Please, please pick me next.

Benefit Numbers

The number of people on a benefit has fallen by 2.9% in the last year. This is pleasing, and reflects what has been a growing economy.

However as Lindsay Mitchell points out, the numbers on sickness and invalids benefits continues to increase – by 4,400 people in the last year. We saw in the late 90s that you could get those numbers to reduce, and in a context of overall falling benefit numbers they certainly should be.

Is Venezuela funding UNITE?

Matt McCarten admitted a few weeks ago that UNITE was seeking overseas funding for its work.

Trevor Loudon connects some dots with a UNITE organiser being in Venezuela, and asks whether the Venezuelan Government or unions are funding UNITE?

It would be useful for someone to ask UNITE to reveal the sources of their overseas funding.

Telecom’s Marketing Strategy

This audio clip of Telecom CEO Theresa Gattung is startling. You hear her talk about how telcos use confusion as their chief marketing tool when it comes to pricing, that confusion helps all of them to keep prices up for longer than would have been the case otherwise, but how at some level customers know telcos are not being straight up.

Well yes we do know now for sure.

Now I don’t know when it was said, or the context in which it was said, but I look forward to hearing from Telecom such things.

Hat Tip: Russell Brown

Ngai Tahu

The NZ Herald has an article on the contest for the chairmanship of Ngai Tahu.

In the article, it notes that Ngai Tahu’s assets now come to $534 million, which is triple the $170 million they got in 1998. This is a superb result which speaks well of the goivernance and management to date. It shows what can be done with the right attitude.

Police use of pepper spray

I have not seen the TV3 footage, but this Herald article on how it shows a police officer pepper spraying a man who was already restrained and handcuffed is shocking by itself.

One wonders how wide-spread this practice may be – I mean it is unlikely that the one and only time it happened, it just happened to be caught by a passing TV cameraman.

You only use pepper spray in self defence or to protect others – not because the guy is just getting lippy.

Does Prohibition Work?

UK Media

Cross-Party Relationships

Pamziewmzie blogs about the perils of hooking up with someone from another party. She is Labour-aligned and her companion was from ACT.

The funniest part for me was that Mr ACT didn’t just try and sleep with her, but also tried to convince her to join or support ACT – now that’s promoting the party at every opportunity!

There are two sorts of cross-party relationships I have seen. One is those on the same side of the spectrum such as National/ACT or Labour/Alliance. I know of several National/ACT marriages and a couple more which will probably end up married. And the blogosphere used to have a Labour/Alliance husband and wife.

The other sort is across the political divide such as National/Labour or ACT/Greens etc etc. These ones, in my experience, are heaps of fun. You see there is so much to talk about – you are always probing each other’s arguments, finding out areas you do agree on, and they on average tend to be more passionate than dating people within your own party. There is also the fun of either keeping it secret from your friends, or shocking them that you are together.

I know a few people (including one now Labour MP who told me she would never ever sleep with a right winger on principle) who only date people who share the same views as them. I’m the opposite – I love the friction, the debates, the shared passion for politics etc. The relationships don’t always last until death do you part, but they are fun.

National Radio Politics

I’m pleased to exclusively announce here that the very enjoyable politics segment is returning to National Radio’s Nine to Noon show today.

Matthew Hooton returns from the right, and Laila Harre replaces Peter Harris on the left. Kathryn Ryan will earn her pay mediating.

The programme is not yet listed on the RNZ website but I understand they will be on at 11 am on Mondays.

Israel prevents assassination of Palestinian President

Israel foiled a plot to assassinate Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, by tipping him off to it.

So who was trying to assassinate him? Was it Israeli settlers? Was it a Jewish fundamentalist? Was it the CIA?

No it was Hamas. Yes, that’s right the group just elected to a majority in the Palestinian Parliament. The same group Winston and Helen just gave $500,000 to.

Hat Tip: Tim Blair

Kathryn Ryan

Kathryn Ryan starts work tomorrow as the new host of the Nine to Noon on National Radio.

Lenghy profiles and interviews of her are in both the Sunday Star-Times and Herald on Sunday.

Leah Haines in the HoS repeats advice Kathryn gave her years ago on the downside of provincial media postings:

“You need to understand that your sex life is over unless you are prepared to lower your standards,”

Heh. I knew a few journalists who have done provincial jobs and would agree with that 🙂

Anyway good luck to Kathryn for her first day tomorrow. I doubt she will need it though.

Hair Loss caused Rent Boy encounter!

The UK Liberal Democrat Leadership Contender, Mark Oaten, who had his use of rent boys (he is married) exposed during the campaign, has blamed his actions on, wait for it, anxiety with his dramatic hair loss in his 30s!!

Wow if hair loss really causes you to sleep with rent boys, then I’m in real real trouble!!

Hat Tip: Iain Dale

Rich Rulers

Forbes has compiled their annual list of the richest rulers. In order they are:

1. King Abdullah Bin Abdulaziz, Saudi Arabia, $21 billion
2. Sultan Haji Hassanal Bolkiah, Brunei, $20 billion
3. Sheikh Khalifa bin Zayed Al Nahyan, United Arab Emirates, $19 billion
4. Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum, Dubai, $14 billion
5. Hans Adam II von und zu Liechtenstein, Liechtenstein, $4 billion
6. Prince Albert II, Monaco, $1 billion
7. Fidel Castro, Cuba, $900 million
8. Teodoro Obiang Nguema Mbasogo, Equatorial Guinea, $600 million
9. Queen Elizabeth II, Queen/U.K., $500 million
10. Queen Beatrix Wilhelmina Armgard, Netherlands, $270 million

So the only two non royals who make the list are Fidel Castro and the President of Equatorial Guinea. Has there even been a poor communist leader?