Maori Roll Option

Tariana is not happy that National is against the Maori option and Maori seats. I think this is one of those areas where you have to agree to disagree. Both parties won’t be changing thie rpositions anytime soon.

What I found interesting was Justice Minister Mark Burton’s response to the suggestion that canvassers would encourage Maori to go on the Maori roll. He said that was “nonsense”.

But the Minister is talking nonsense. In 2001 at least one and possibly two or more organisations last time were repreimanded or suspended for advocating that electors should transfer to the Maori roll. These were organisations receiving taxpayer money to promote the option.

I have no doubt that such antics will occur again. The only question is whether they will be exposed again.

Productivity Growth

Spiders 1 Nudists 0

ICANN wrap-up

Kim Hill interviewed ICANN Chairman Vint Cerf (who also co-invented the TCP/IP protocol the Internet runs on) on Saturday morning. If you are interested in how the Internet works, it is a superb interview. Vint explains TCP/IP using postcards as an analogy. Even non-techs like me could understand it. It is 40 minutes long but touches on all sorts of issues.

Also Scoop has images and audio of a post-ICANN press conference by Chairman Vint Cerf and President Paul Twomey.

Most of the week of the conference is pretty routine with presentations and discussions on diverse topics. One of the more interesting ones was a panel discussion on what ICANN should do if a Government wants to take over the running of a country code top level domain, without the consent of the current operator. The views of Government reps and ccTLD managers was somewhat apart, but some common ground.

A few amusing incidents which I can recall:

The funniest for me was a dispute over a pub quiz question with an ICANN staffer. It was to do with how many applications for new generic top level domains were still under consideration. She disputed my answer and demanded a prize by the end of the week if I hadn’t worked out the correct answer. Now I am very competitive sometimes and this got me spending hours going through web archives, meeting minutes, transcripts etc of the ICANN site to work out which application had dropped out.

I couldn’t work it out so finally cheated a wee bit by asking on an IRC channel if anyone knew the status of the five applications. I had agreed not to ask anyone for help. Now on that channel were two ICANN board members. That night the staffer comes up to me and accuses me of cheating by asking board members. I look guilty but try to deny it (technically I asked an IRC channel) and ask her what makes her think that. She replies that the two board members asked the rest of the board and currently the entire board is discussing it on their discuss list and she now has to do an update for the board for tomorrow on the issue.

I guiltily admit okay maybe I did say something. Damn it – I hate losing! Am rather amused though that our dispute over a pub quiz question led to a board discussion on the issue 🙂 She ended up winning a prize.

Another amusing moment was at ten pin bowling with the Chairman of ICANN’s Government Advisory Committee. The GAC has been the main body opposed to or slowing down the .xxx TLD application. Hence when the GAC Chairman got three strikes in a row and the scoreboard showed an XXX next to his name, it made for a great photo opportunity. And the photographer was the .xxx TLD applicant!

Also got to poke fun at the Australians by asking out of Iran, China and Australia which country’s leader can most quickly get a parody website about him removed.

And another good moment was presenting the senior official from the US Government with an upside-down map showing NZ at the centre top, and the US at the side near the bottom declaring it to represent the new power balance in the world. It will look good on a US Government wall.

Finally on Friday night had a great night with some of the ICANN people at the NZSO with recitals of Cuban Overture, Concerto in F, American in Paris, and Rhapsody in Blue. Oh it was such a fun performance with the pianist and conductor so animated to match the music. The pianist did two encore tunes as he kept getting clapped back. I really must make sure I attend NZSO more often.

The amusing part was back at the Intercontinental Hotel afterwards where we had some nibbles and drinks. Vint Cerf had a 10 minute DVD showing closeups of Mars. However no-one in the room could get the DVD player to tune into the TV, despite being probably one of the most technologically capable groups around being present in the room. Finally we gave up and had to ask room service to do it for us 🙂

Telecom makes non data capped broadband available

Yes this is true. Telecom has made available a 256K broadband plan which has *no* data caps.

Only one problem. They are not doing it in New Zealand. It is only available in Australia. So Telecom can offer a broadband plan without data caps in Australia but not in NZ. Repeat after me that all is well with NZ broadband like a good lemming.

Hat Tip: Juha

Nice Shake

TV3 Poll

The problem with state control

The story of the British teacher whose formal qualifications means he can only be paid $25,000 instead of $54,000 illustrates everything that is wrong with having the Government centrally set all pay rates, and not bulk funding schools.

David Boulton has taught for four years in Britain, has two university degrees, a post-graduate teaching certificate and “qualified teacher status”. But this doesn’t quite fit the NZQA system so he would be paid as an unqualified teacher.

Now the school still wants him – especially as there is a shortage of physics teachers. But the Government sets the pay scale and will only fund the school $25,000 for his position. Now if one had bulk funding then the school would be free to pay him as much as they think it is worth to hire him.

The smoking Russell Crowe

I feel sorry for Sky City who are facing prosecution as Russell Crowe smoked a cigarette during a performance.

I’m sure they didn’t ask him to stop because he is a celebrity. They probably didn’t ask him to stop out of concern he would punch out whoever asked him.

And Sky City is required by OSH regulations to not expose their employees to danger or risk. So they should use that as a defence!

Who will replace Cullen?

The PM has given a big hint that Dr Cullen may retire at the election, saying she only expects him to deliver the 2006 and 2007 budgets. If he is retiring in 2008, then it is probable they will want his replacement in office before the 2008 election.

What is interesting is who might replace Cullen. The leading contender is Trevor Mallard but I am not sure he has the gravitas for the role.

Clayton Cosgrove is another associate minister but that won’t happen under Clark. Cunliffe is a possibility as a former associate minister. Or one could give it to a senior minister such as Goff.

I think we can rule out it going to David Benson-Pope, even though he would be very good talking about the need for fiscal discipline 🙂

April Fools

Well a few people fell for my April’s Fools posting praising Labour for their 2c reduction in the middle tax rate.

Highlights were Miss Ten falling for it, and also the NZ Herald 🙂

People should know better than to think Labour would ever reduce tax rates!

Interviews that should have been

Lyndon Hood at Scoop has done a series of very funny (fictitious) interviews between various media personalities and Tony Blair and Harmeet Sooden.

They’re all quite funny, and capture the personalities well. But the funniest for me was this one:

Ian Wishart, Investigate
Were any of your captors Labour cabinet ministers?

Broadband Warriors

The NZ Herald on Saturday has a good series of articles grouped together as Broadband Warriors.

They have one general article on how local loop unbundling works, and also profiles of Telecom’s Bruce Parkes and Grant Forsyth who has just finished up with Telstra-Clear to go work for British Telecom.

Bruce has a good sense of humour and I had to laugh at how he dealt with Telecom being compared to Sauron in Lord of the Rings – the evil empire. He turns it around by claiming Telecom is Minas Tirith defending itself against the Orcs.

There is one part I sort of agree with Bruce on. He says “We’re not saying Telecom shouldn’t provide access to its network. What we are saying is the best way to achieve that is not necessarily through setting up an adversarial regulatory system.”

Indeed that may often not be the best way. But it may be the only way! Telecom has gone out of its way to provide very unhelpful and inadequate wholesale service to companies wanting network access. The debacle in rolling out UBS was probably a last straw for many.

A deleted Ebay auction

How one should respond to offensive cartoons

With an equally offensive cartoon!

An Indonesian newspaper published an offensive cartoon of John Howard and Alexander Downer. An Australian cartoonist has responded with this cartoon below:

The Indonesian Government is not that happy, even though the President himself is reportedly not worried.

A non-story

The SST has an article on how some high profile people are put into a special “VIP” category with ACC. All it means is that the thousands of staff who work there can not access their files – it is restricted to just three people.

This is entirely sensible, and I think the IRD does much the same thing.

But of course we have an “ACC advocate” who demands all records have the same high level of security. This is possibly one of the most stupid statements ever made. Think about it.

He has effectively called for every single file to be restricted so only three staff members can access it. Well this will mean a massive cost saving for ACC as it will be able to sack 1,000 or so other claims staff. Oh yes and it will also mean you will have to wait 14 years for a claim to be settled as only three staff will be able to access everyone’s files.

Naked revenue gathering

I’m stunned by this article which reveals Auckland City Council has parking wardens working from 11 pm to 7 am issuing tickets as fast as they can. This is naked revenue gathering which ignores the reason we have parking regulations.

The reason for parking regulations is to generally free up space so people can regularly use it. With no regulations the first people into town would keep their parks all day. They also ensure for example residents can park in their local neighbourhood.

Most people would agree that parking on a bus stop is a bad thing as buses need to be able to pull up on them. But if the bus service runs Monday to Saturday only, then parking on one on a Sunday doesn’t cause any problems for anyone. So ticketing someone for praking on a bus stop on a day in which there are no buses is simply petty revenue gathering.

Now the Auckland City wardens are also targetting surburban parking. Again a very good idea to be patrolling at 5 pm when people return home from work. But if your girlfriend drives over to your place at midnight and manages to find a spare park, normally leaving at 7 am, how is ticketing her for not being a resident at 3.00 am helping anyone. I doubt there are any residents driving home at that time who need the park.

My suggestion to aspiring Auckland City politicians is to campaign on a platform of abolishing routine parking patrols after midnight. You should win in a landslide!

The Louise Nicholas case

The Press editorial gets it pretty right for me in saying:

As a senior police officer representing power and privilege, he was involved in a deplorable private association with a young woman who plainly was out of her depth. He used her in a callous and careless way.

I don’t tend to judge anyone’s consensual sexual behaviour, but three police officers all having casual and group sex with a teenager is not a relationship of equals. Don’t get me wrong I am not saying one can not have a strong loving relationship with someone significantly younger than yourself. Of course you can (as many people, including me, have). Neither am I saying casual or group sex by itself is exploitative. What I am saying is that in this case it was exploitative with the combination of factors involved.

However like the jury I have never been convinced, certainly beyond reasonable doubt, that it was not consensual. The flatmate’s testimony alone was compelling reason to doubt the veracity of what Nicholas said (even though I suspect Nicholas very much believes what she says). The flatmate had no reason at all to lie.

So while the actions of Rickards and co were, perhaps extremely unwise, sending Rickards to prison for up to seven years for a sexual encounter which he had no reason to think was not consensual and welcome would have been very very wrong.

Even though the behaviour was “morally reprehensible” (as admitted by the defendants) it was not illegal unless Nicholas made it clear at the time the encounters were unwelcome.

The SST also has an interview with one of the other four former offices whom Nicholas has accused of sexual assault in the past. SST also has an article by Steve Braunias who attended the trial.

Another obstacle gone

Blog round-up

Epsom warming up

I think Epsom is going to keep political watchers amused for the next three years as the fight a permament campaign there.

Whale Oil has the latest chapter where ACT challenged Richard Worth to debate drinking age limits on campus. Worth responded that he would be delighted to do so, but only if drug liberalisation was also added as a topic.

This was declined by the ACT team!

Trevor’s blog in the news

NZPA have done a story on ACT VP’s Trevor Loudon’s blog. I had to laugh at how a spokesperson for David Benson-Pope described it as being in “poor taste”. I’d take that as a compliment with pride 🙂

They also make reference to the article on The Whig’s website about the new ACT President.

At long last!

I am always ready to praise Labour when they do something right, so I can only offer my congratulations to Dr Cullen for his announcement in this morning’s pre-budget update of a reduction in the middle tax rate.

It isn’t as much as I would like, being only a 2c reduction in the 21c rate but it’s a good start. To quote Dr Cullen “While our priority remains investing in services and infrastructure, the level of our structural under-lying surplus is high enough to allow the Government to lower tax rates on low and middle income New Zealanders”

The cost of the tax cuts is $580 million a year. Not anywhere near enough with a surplus of over $5 billion but it is useful progress.

March 2006 NZ Blog Stats

Okay, for those who want to be listed, don’t e-mail your stats to me, but just attach them as a comment to this thread and I’ll update the post during the day. Remember to include blog name, no of posts and no of comments Stats so far are:

Anarchia 4, 25
Peter Metcalfe 7, 14
Joe Hendren 10, 4
Kete Were 10, 60
Gareth Robinson 14, 37
Sagenz 16, 28
Tumeke 21, 61
NZBC 26, 83
Just Left 31, 586
NZ Be Free 48, 50
Oswald Bastable 69, 80
Clouds of Heaven 81, 33
Client Heine 81, 264
Silent Running 120, 986
Whale Oil 128, 79
Lindsay Mitchell 134, 176
No Right Turn 142, 630
David Farrar 219, 4175

Contempt of Court

Contempt of Court:
1 The willful and intentional failure to comply with a Court Order or Judgment by a party to the action. Contempt of Court is punishable by fine or imprisonment, or both.
2 A finding by a judge that a person has violated a court order or is guilty of conduct before the court calculated to disrupt the proceedings of the court.

I’ve just deleted a dozen comments from the previous thread. Also as a public service warning to other blogs who have posted or linked to statements which breach supression orders, you may wish to note in the Dom Post that Justice Randerson has ordered that his supression orders will remain and specifically the monitoring of Internet sites.

And yes I know you may be talking about another set of supression orders, but the principle still applies.