Smacking Poll

Interesting to note in the Dom Post that 82% of parents say it is okay to smack a child and 60% oppose repeal of Section 59 – the effect of which would be to ban smacking.

I note the UN has a committee which claims a country isn’t serious about human rights if it allows any sort pf physical discipline of children.

I wonder of the UN includes as physical discipline having a father chop his daughter’s head off as an honour killing because he didn’t approve of her boyfriend?

Leaders’ Ages

Craig R posted this as a comment and it is worth having a bit more sunlight on it. Below are the ages of the Deputy PM and some of the other party leaders at the time of the next election:

Michael Cullen – 64
Winston Peters (b. April 11, 1945) – 63
Jim Anderton (b. 21 January 1938) – 70
Tariana Turia (b. 8 April 1944) – 64
Pita Sharples (b. 20 July 1941) – 67
Jeanette Fitzsimons (b. 1945) – 63

So being in your sixties as a leader is far from unusual.

Who dated John Tamihere?

High Stakes

Bit by bit they get what they want

In 2000 the Government introduce the Employment Relations Bill. It was a draconian bill and the huge upraor from employers saw many of its worst provisions deleted before it was passed.

Then in their second term Labour brought in amendments that reintroduced many of the draconian aspects they had relucantly dropped in 2000. And then again after an uproar the select committee took out some of the worst aspects.

But now into the third term they are going for it again.

Hwo the law will work under this change is as follows. Say you have a small to medium sized business. And you employ a cleaning firm to clean your premises. Now let’s say after a year you have had crap service from the firm. The cleaners don’t do a proper job, they often forget to do stuff etc and you sack the cleaning firm after you find a new cleaning firm. However the new cleaning firm will be forced by law to hire the very same staff that were doing such a lousy job at the old cleaning firm!!

Pay the money back!

John Armstrong writes that a simple campaign focused on “Pay the money back” is a winner in today’s column. I agree, even though it will probably last for weeks not months as a headline issue.

The issue will be revitalised when the Police decide whether to prosecute. This may take a while as the Police can not charge a party, only people. Therefore they may need to interview all the members of Labour’s campaign committee to work out who was involved in taking the key decisions.

Key quotes from the column:

Labour’s response has made it look arrogant, cavalier with public money and cynical about the lengths it will go to stay in office.

Labour’s mistake has been to try to defend the indefensible. It has been more a case of spinning wheels than spin machine.

The party has grabbed at any passing defence. These have become increasingly bizarre as the previous ones fail to get traction.

Maurice the hitman

Yay. How great to see some “mongrel” in National with Maurice Williamson starting to give Winston back some of what he serves up.

Personally I think Peters looks ridiculous going on about Brash’s age all the time, considering both men are in their 60s. In 2002 Peters had a Caucus half the size of National’s. Now it is one seventh the size and he got thrashed in Tauranga also.

Halberg Awards

Halberg Awards have been good to watch. Best moment for me was when Tana Umaga came out to present an award. He got a standing ovation before he could say a word and a fairly extended chrous of “Uh Ah Umaga” which was classic.

Best of all Tana announced the Blues had just got beaten and cracked a joke about Auckland traffic 🙂

Winners are:

Sportswoman: Kate McIlroy (Mountain Running)
Sportsman: Michael Campbell (Golf)
Coach: Richard Tonks (Rowing)
Team: George Bridgewater & Nathan Twaddle (Rowing)

Supreme Award: Michael Campbell

Fast Internet!!!

One has to be very careful when seeing PRs about broadband packages that you look at not just price and speed but also data caps (and also minimum guaranteed speed which can be as low as 24 kb/s).

Take this PR from Telstra-Clear announcing you can get a 2 Mb/s speed for both download and upload for just $61.90 a month, including your phone line rental.

Sounds great. But then think about the 200 MB data limit.

Now if one is say using bit torrent at full speed and doing both download and upload at capacity that is 4Mb/sec which is 0.5MB/sec.

So at full speed you’ll be able to keep using the Internet for oh 400 seconds!!! Yes after 400 seconds of use your monthly package is all used up.

To be fair to Telstra-Clear some of their other packages have higher data caps such as 10 GB limit but that is over $100 a month.

More sense from the EPMU

I’ve previously blogged my approval of the EPMU efforts to save 300 Air NZ jobs by proposing realistic alternatives to Air NZ, not just protesting.

Now Andrew Little, EPMU National Secretary, delivers some excellent common sense on the cartoon controversy:

Freedom of speech and rationality are cornerstone values of western countries and it is essential we, and our public institutions (institutions with a public face), are seen to cherish them and not compromise them.

It might be a western perspective, given our culture generally of tolerance, but to take such offence at the published cartoons to the point of being driven to violence not to mention international trade threats is something we should be denouncing. I am extremely uncomfortable when I hear editors of substantial newspapers apologising for causing offence after exercising a perfectly justifiable editorial judgement. I expect editors to be bold in reporting news; their news judgements shouldn’t be based on causing possible offence to the community or the authorities. I’m sure the left can do a lot better at standing
by values of free speech and expression, and trusting most people to know bullshit when they see it.

Quote stolen from Molesworth and Featherston.

From a purely partisan sense I should be glad that so many (not all) on the left rushed to promote self-censorship (as it loses them support) but this issue is so vital to our future that I would much rather have widespread support for the right to satirise, criticise and even offend religions.

Working with Industry – not

Jihad on NBR

NBR’s In Tray flicks at their favourite victim again as part of a Saving TVNZ feature:

David P Farrar, veteran blogger: There comes a point beyond which a quality television watcher cannot be pushed, and for me that came recently when I switched on the TV hoping to see the blasphemous and outrageous Bloody Mary episode of South Park, only to find that I had obviously tuned in at the wrong time, thus ending up instead looking at what appeared to be an entirely innocuous semi-pornographic webpage presented by somebody who spent Valentine’s Day looking at a photograph of his lesbian friend’s breasts. And then I realised I was looking at my own blog!!!!

Let it be known that the Church of Farrar takes great offence at this satire of its main prophet and will be burning down NBR’s Wellington Embassy as a peaceful protest.

The entire In-tray article is over the break:
Continue reading »

Another school story

Goodness the major concern to Wellingtonians must be obscure school appointments and policies as today’s lead story in the Dom Post is that Wellington High School paid 13 out of 1,000 students a $50 prize for having a 100% attendance record.

Back when I was at school we had to work much harder to make the front page. Rongotai College managed it though when there was a national controversy over the principal video recording pupil’s getting caned so he could examine the best aeronautical way to cane (he was a former aeronautical engineer).

Most amusing was how when the debate went public over this issue the Evening Post trumpeted a banner headline “Civil War breaks out at school” and I grabbed a copy to see which school this had happened at, to find I was at the so called civil war wracked school!

Civil War meaning two students shoved each other in a disagreement on the issue.

Can’t even keep their word

I suppose I shouldn’t be surprised but now Labour have shown they can’t even keep their word on parliamentary deals.

With all respect to Tim Barnett but it is a load of baloney that it was up to the Speaker not the Whips to keep MPs from his party quiet during the Leader’s speeches. This is in fact against standing orders and flatly wrong.

People may not be aware of this but Parliament runs on the basis of private agreements all the time. Whips agree at the Business Committee we’ll only debate the committee stage of that bill for 90 minutes even though we could fillbuster it for six hours. And it is the Whips who enforce the agreements by telling their own sides what the agreement is. The Speaker generally can not enforce any agreement that is more restrictive than standing orders.

So if Labour had agreed to hear both speeches in silence (and Clark’s was) and then Labour screamed non stop during Brash’s speech the fault can only lie with the Whips. Wither they broke their word and didn’t tell their MPs not to heckle or they were ignored by their own Caucus.

This seems like a small issue, but Parliament runs on a Whip’s word being his or her bond. That is why you tend to appoint Whips who are good at working with MPs from other parties. You don’t appoint a Muldoon or a Meurant as a Whip for example.

Now I have a lot of time for Tim Barnett. But on this occassion he has let Parliament down badly.

Rodney declares war

Heh heh. Rodney Hide’s suggestions in Parliament that Margaret Wilson should force Labout to pay the money back seem to have annoyed her to the degree she has written to Rodney asking him to “withdraw any reflection on my integrity conveyed in your remarks”.

Rodeny’s response is to place on his blog a copy of the Speaker’s letter, ripped into four pieces. Oh dear oh dear – I don’t think she will be amused.

Blogging now an Olympic Sport!

Health Outcomes

This really is rather scandalous. Labour has increased health spending by over $3 billion or around 50%. A massive massive increase.

Now one would have expected health care to have become far more available and waiting lists to have dropped. After all this is spending an extra $2,000 a year per household.

But in Auckland, Wellington, Otago (and other areas) you now need to be even sicker than was the case five years ago to qualify for key operations.

But listen to Pete Hodgson defend this. He says:

Prioritisation of treatment was better than several years ago, meaning that those getting an operation might be on average sicker but those left on the waiting list were less sick.

Huh. Can someone translate that into English.

100 complaints against Harder

The Law Society has revealed that since Harder became a lawyer in 1983 they have had more than 100 complaints against him. You really can’y say they have been hasty in striking him off.

It also transpires that Harder agreed to be struck off in return for some of the latest charges being dropped. The more serious charges included coercing a female client into havign sex with him by saying he would get her off if he did.

I wonder what his actual court record was in terms fo wins and losses? I could never work out why people kept using him.

Lotto

I basically do not gamble. I will accept all sorts of silly challenges due to my competitive nature [makes board games very nasty sometimes] but I have never been into throwing away money which statistically I will not get back.

Until last week I had never ever purchased a lotto ticket. At university I did buy quite a few scratch and win tickets but they were only $1 each.

Anyway last week I decided that as life had been pretty good lately perhaps this meant I was lucky so I decided to buy my first lotto ticket. $11 handed over for a power dip.

Well finally got around to checking the results today and not a single line had more than two numbers match. Ha – not even close. I’m going to try it for one more week but if I donm’t win something decent this week I’m going to go back to my Lotto boycott!

Another student association under Police investigation

I used to keep newspaper clippings of all the student associations that had been investigated for fraud etc but I had to stop when the UN pointed out my files had got so big I was responsioble for 1.8% of greenhouse gases due to tree felling the paper necessary.

This one is the Otago Maori Students’ Association. I imagine like on the other campuses it is funded by OUSA compulosry fees.

More Abu Ghraib Photos

18 months ago when what happened at Abu Ghraib became known, I blogged that the actions of the US soldiers involved was totally indefensible.

The damage from their actions lives on, and yesterday Australia’s SBS broadcast further photos which are even more appalling. As Donald Rumsfield said they are sadistic cruel and inhuman.

Even if the number of people involved was relatively small, their actions will be a blot on the US military for years if not decades to come.

Yay the NZ Empire remains

TVNZ Board referred to Privileges Committee

The Speaker has ruled that TVNZ’s Board should be referred to the Privileges Committee. I don’t expect they will get fined (or imprisoned 🙂 but it will be highly embarrasing for them.

Let me predict now that TV3 will make that the lead item for the 6pm news the day they appear, unless a very large asteroid is found to be heading towards Earth!

2006 Freedom Forum

Yay just got notice that the 2006 Freedom Forum will be held at the Reagan Ranch in August. Guest Speakers not confirmed yet but if they are as good as last year I’ll be happy. Will be great to look around the ranch, the library and a decommissioned Airforce One!

Photos from the 2005 Freedom Forum are here.

Shane Jones

You know it normally takes three terms in Government for MPs to develop the arrogance that annoys so many voters. But Shane Jones seems to have picked it up in just a few months.

Prior to Jones entering Parliament I was a reasonably big fan of him, based on his impressive record of achievements. But someone in the Whips Office really needs to give him a smack around the head before Section 59 is repealed.

On the three strikes and you’re out theory Jones is on strike two. Strike One was when he thought his role as Select Committee Chair was to beat up and sneer at witnesses just because they said unwelcome things.

Strike Two was his response to a letter of complaint about the earlier rudeness with a “I ripped it up”.

The job of a select committee chair is not to unilaterally decide what will and will not be considered by the committee. Any formal correspondence should be placed before the committee even if complaining about your chairmanship. In fact especially if complaining. Select Committees are not Government committees they are committess of Parliament.

If Jones is this arrogant already I shudder what he will be like as a Minister. As I said I think he has the potential to be a very good Cabinet Minister one day. But someone really needs to talk to him about concepts such as respect and democracy.