And the winner is …

Well some good responses to the caption contest. Winners are:

David and Kerry demonstrate on how NZers can obtain real “broadband” internet –
Step 1: Paddle to Australia…

– from Mavxp

At the end of Labour’s fourth term, this was all what was left of the New Zealand Navy.
– from Darren

“Just as I was webcamming a session with Kerry for the wetsuit surfer fetish site, the press showed up.”
– from Edgar

The poor girl

I feel very sorry for St Marys Head Prefect Aysser Aljanabi who has made the news both nationally and internationally. It must be excruciatingly embarrassing to have to endure such stuff especially when you haven’t done anything at all except presumably be a popular and well behaved student who got made Head Prefect.

I think the Dom Post has some culpability here, even though their motives may have been good in terms of wanting to highlight a positive story about a Muslim immigrant. But quite simply the controversy seems to be manufactured. Not a single person has actually said they personally are unhappy about it – the media justify covering this as some sort of controversy when all they can point to is “it is believed one member of St Mary’s old girl’s association was so angry she emailed the school”. Oh my God is this the threshold we adopt here. Someone who will not be named sent an e-mail off!!!

Considering non Catholics have been eligible to attend and take up leadership positions at St Mary’s for many years, then whether the Head Girl is Muslim or Agnostic is not newsworthy. It would be different if the student and the school wanted to highlight this, but they have made it clear for over three months they did not want publicity.

The good thing from this ‘issue’ is that the school has been flooded with support for their stand. The sad thing is this has been at the expense of a young girl’s privacy who never wanted to be seen as an issue people take a stand on. She probably no more wants to be defined purely by her religion as MP Chris Finlayson wants to be defined purely by his sexuality.

The other sad thing is that some of the international reports talk of there being an “uproar” at the appointment. Oh what crap. There has been no uproar. Not a single person has complained publicly and I daresay 90%+ of the population support the school.

Cause of Bad Manners

Some sociology professor (need I go on) last week said rudeness and boorishness are increasing in New Zealand society and blamed it on the economic reforms of the 1980s. Yes seriously he did.

Phil Rennie replies in the NZ Herald that he had often looked for excuses for his rudeness and he had never thought of blaming Roger Douglas and David Lange.

Phil quotes British Labour MP Frank Field who is an anti-poverty campaigner and he blames the welfare state for a decline in the ethic of respect and the rise of Britain’s yob culture.

His rationale is that behaviour worsens when people know they won’t have to take responsibility for their actions, because they know that the state will support and reward them, no matter what.

This is a well documented phenomena. In economics studies of insurance especially for example one sees behavior change significantly due to insurance which insulates people from consequences of certain actions.

Collins is right

Judith Collins is absolutely correct, and the PM is wrong. Helen Clark said the removal of Section 59 has been “crudely and wrongly represented in the media as calls for a ban on smacking, which it is not” yet the Office of the Police Commissioner has said “If Section 59 was repealed in its entirety parents would not be authorised to use reasonable force by way of correction … smacking of a child by way of corrective action would be an assault.”

My preferred approach remains to have a more explicit definition of reasonable force. Now this is opposed by Professor Durrant from Canada as it was tried there. But let’s look at her reasoning. After the Canadian Supreme Court tried to define reasonable force someone on an Internet bulletin board posted “Thank God the little bastards will know who’s boss now”.

Jesus Christ. An obviously satirical comment on a bulletin board is used as justification. To be fair it sounds like the Supreme Court did a bad job of defining reasonable force. But I don’t think it should be left to Judges instead of Parliament. Former MP Bob Simcock a few years ago came up with a revised definition which looked fairly sound.

Drowning

Ok well that has put me off going to the beach. Dr Cullen has ordered that “anybody who thinks there are large fiscal surpluses to be spent now by means of large tax reductions should be taken out and quietly drowned”.

Does this mean that if I see any Labour MPs or staff on a beach I can shoot them and claim self defence? 🙂

2 million visitors

Now I’ve got Excel working again (yes blogosphere monthly stats due soon) I’ve updated Kiwiblog stats and on Friday had the two millionth visit to Kiwiblog. Someone out there has won a prize!

Also last week saw weekly vists for the first time exceed 50,000. A year ago it was 10,000.

Oh and for the geeks, the blog traffic downloads since the start has been around 500 GB. I’m glad I don’t pay per MB for hosting!

This is true, not made up

Cunliffe Caption Contest

Some photos are just calling out for a caption contest and I can’t resist.

It’s a bit mean of me as David and Kerry were actually posing for an InternetNZ organised photo op to highlight the upcoming ICANN conference. But it is too good to resist.

So let’s have the best captions below. Keep them clean.

Oh and finally there has been much debate on whether wetsuits generally zip up at the back or the front, because if the former then the Minister may have his one on back to front 🙂

Labour on Tax Cuts

Tim Selwyn highlighted an amusing portion of the PM’s speech where it seems she said National is promising a “spend-up of tax cuts”.

I think reflects perfectly that to most of Labour they quite honestly do see no difference between them spending money on our behalf, and giving taxpayers their own money back to them. They see it just as a different form of spending.

And with Dr Cullen threatening to cancel the 67 cent a week tax cuts due in 2008, well who is surprised.

I mean in just five months Cullen has a six billion surplus, and he is now saying one can’t even afford a miserly $300 million a year reducition in tax.

Personally I’d be delighted if Labour do cancel even this miserly tax cut. Politically it would be suicidal.

Reactions to Extreme Islam Post

A couple of days ago I posted my calculations about how the radical or extreme faction of Islam is not microscopic or tiny but probably makes up 20% to 33% of the total religion. I had been frustrated that so often it is portrayed that only a tiny proportion back Osama bin Laden when in fact at least 175 million support what he does. Not 10,000, not 100,000, not 1,000,000, not 10,000,000, but over 100,000,000.

Personally I think the fact over 100 million people support flying airplanes into buildings is a bad thing and can’t work out why people think it will all be okay so long as one doesn’t talk about it. All sorts of wonderful rebuttals appeared such as the KKK claim to be Christian so that is just as bad. Yeah right.

Over at Public Address Che Tibby compares high levels of Islamic support support for suicide bombings, flying planes into buildings etc with the fact most people in the US support the death penalty.

Now let’s look at this wonderful case of moral equivalence. It is comparing terrorists deciding to kill innocent bystanders with the fact the 270 million living in a democracy have voted to have a system of laws, that where someone is charged with murdering other people, where twelve of their peers find them guilty, where generally 20 years of appeals all fail, then they are executed as punishment for their original crime.

Now don’t get me wrong I am against the death penalty. I would not vote for it. But really what planet do you have to be on to compare someone voting in favour of the death penalty for convicted murderers to someone who supports blowing up kindergartens and flying planes into buildings. I mean I’ve seen some moral equalising in my time but this may set a new record.

The same people who no doubt treat publishing an offensive cartoon as being the same as burning down an embassy to protest against it. I mean seriously how many more people are going to come out and think that somehow it is *balanced* to say well yes they shouldn’t burn the embassy down but those newspapers shouldn’t have published the cartoons either. How hard would it be to perhaps add on that the two acts are not equivalent in ‘badness’ (if one even accepts publishing was bad).

Oh yes people should also check out Christian Briggs who accuses me of Islamophobia (never mind In almost every sentence I keep making the point that I have no problem with moderate Islam, and that I have praised the local Muslim community several times for their responses to the cartoon controversy) and even has a photo of me up to scare the kids off.

Christian mainly takes issue with my stance that accidental civilian deaths in a war are not the same as deliberately targeting civilians or as he puts it “They murder and we accidentally kill”.

By this logic I imagine Churchill and Eisenhower were morally as culpable as Himmler and Goering. Which is why of course I disagree.

I will agree that not all civilian deaths in a war are accidental, perhaps I should add on or unavoidable. As in if someone places their gun battery beneath an apartment block then it is not an accident when you bomb the apartment block, but it is unavoidable unless you actually want to get mowed down by the gun battery yourself.

There are times when of course even “the good guys” do bad things in a war. The overall WWII policy of unconditional surrender etc was absolutely necessary but even I am unconvinced that Dresden for example was necessary or justified. But again even if one concludes that Dresden was not justified, this still doesn’t equate the Allies as being the same as the Nazis and Eisenhower or Harris being a Himmler or Goering.

I’m David and I have a problem!

The banning Greens

PC does us a public service by researching all the things the Greens want to ban, and reminds us thgat at their heart they are an authoritarian party.

In his list of 50 things they want banned, somehow lighting fires during a fire ban is not on their ban list.

But seriously. Wouldn’t it just be easier and a shorter list if the Greens gave us a list of things they don’t want to ban?

Stupidest hunger strike ever

Hunger strikes were designed as a way of attracting support for a cause as they work on the assumption most people don’t want the hunger striker to die from starvation. Not that all hunger strikers die from starvation – I recall teh Indian hunger strikers who survived for over 180 days. Of course they were hunger striking by roster 12 hours on and 12 hours off!

But is anything funnier than Saddam Hussein on a hunger strike to protest that his trial Judge isn’t nice enough to him. I mean come on this could be the most supported hunger strike in history. Would do the world a great service if he did starve himself to death.

Call for TVNZ Changes

A group of 31 prominent New Zealanders has called on the Government to make TVNZ a fully publicly funded broadcaster, similar to the BBC, the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation and the Australian Broadcasting Corporation.

I have a number of thoughts on this issue:

1) The current model is beyond any doubt very very broken. Even the CEO of TVNZ whose job was to implement the charter has stated this. The only people in New Zealand who do not think the current model is broken meet every Monday morning on the 10th floor of the Beehive and even amongst them 19 of them are probably just pretending they think it is okay to placate Steve Maharey.

2) The costs of making both channels of TVNZ fully publicly funded is very very large. The costs of a TV channel do not rise greatly with the population they serve so the cost/capita would be massively higher in NZ than the UK and Canada.

3) However it would be worth looking at whether TV One could go non commercial and TV Two sold off as a fully commercial channel, with the proceeds earmarked to fund TV One as a public broadcaster.

4) Katherine Rich makes an excellent point that “People are getting their media fix from a wide range of sources, not just Television One. It is unfair to burden a state broadcaster with meeting the needs of everyone.” Indeed, and for the sake of argument one could argue it would be cheaper for the Government to buy every household a Sky decoder and subscription which might be cheaper than a BBC style broadcaster, and provide moire variety!

No easy options here but some change from the status quo is essential.

Opening Speeches

A shame I was overseas so couldn’t attend the opening speeches in Parliament yesterday as it seems Don Brash was in excellent form and delivered a very hard hitting speech.

Colin Espiner in The Press describes it as “arguably his strongest speech in Parliament since assuming the Opposition leadership” and even Jeanette Fitzsimons is quoted as saying Brash appeared to be on steroids and “looks like he is enjoying himself for the first time since he came here”.

The theme of asking Labout to “pay it back” is an excellent one which much of the public can be worked up about. Labour’s refusal to do so contrasts nicely with National which having discovered the GST error with its broadcasting allocation immediately reported it to the Electoral Commission and offered to pay the $100,000 without reservation.

The Press supports the theme with its editorial headed up “Pay the money back” and says “Prime Minister Helen Clark is quite correct to say that campaign funding rules need overhauling, her party must not be allowed to use this as a smoke screen to obscure what seems to be a cynical attempt to sidestep the spending regime”.

The NZ Herald also has a story on the speeches and John Armstrong also praises Brash’s speech, albeit with reservations.

Commitment to Broadband

While of course there is much of what Labour does I disagree with, I was delighted to see Helen Clark make a more competitive broadband environment a major aspect of her speech setting out priorities for the year.

There is a big difference between a portfolio Minister talking about reviews and the Prime Minister commiting the Government to action as a matter of “urgency”. This means that something significant will be done, and in months not years.

As someone who has been heavily involved in this area for some time, who has lobbied on the issue, attended and advocted at commerce commission hearings etc I’m especially pleased to see the commitment. Makes all the work worthwhile. Well not quite as it will depend on details which are a few monthstor off but a good step forward.

UPDATE: Further stories this morning in NZ Herald and Dominion Post. Also a Dom Post editorial welcoming the undertakings from the Govt.

Oh and also Fran O’Sullivan welcomes that “the Government has finally woken up to the fact that Telecom’s failure to deliver broadband and internet services at an internationally competitive rate is a major economic roadblock”.

Valentine’s Day

Now how’s this for a good mate.

I’m complaining to a lesbian friend that for Valentines Day I’m at a restaurant with two guys and every other table is simpering couples. So to cheer me up for Valentine’s she sends me a photo of her breasts.

Now’s that a true friend! 🙂

UPDATE: On the topic of lesbians just noticed this story about research which says the more highly sexed a woman is, the more likely she is to become a lesbian. Now that’s juat unfair!! 🙂

Peter Zohrab

When I saw the headline that “An outspoken men’s activist and critic of New Zealand’s legal system has been told he is not a fit and proper person to be a lawyer.” I thought I bet you that is Peter Zohrab.

And so it is. Former Usenet readers will remember Mr Zohrab well.

I recall when I worked in the PM’s Office seeing missives from Mr Zohrab that would refer to the dykeocracy which ruled the country etc. Burton Shipley would have found them amusing.

I also recall with amusement when he testified to a select committee that women lost intelligence during pregnancy and so they can’t be relied on or something. I made sure I shared his wisdom with all my female friends but just ended up with a lot of bruises!

Cheney shoots lawyer jokes

Most would have heard the US Vice-President accidentially shot a lawyer who was his hunting companion.

Naturally the jokes have started such as “I’d still rather go hunting with Dick Cheney than driving with Ted Kennedy”

Over at NRO’s The Corner I had to laugh as I read one editor say “I earnestly hope that the man Cheney shot was not the prophet Mohammed” 🙂

Other jokes at The Corner are:

Three of the Top Ten Things He Said Afterwards:

Armstrong on Labour Spending

John Armstrong has a nice succinct way of describing issues and he has done it again with Labour’s taxpayer funded election spending:

Rules covering such spending specifically allow parties to publicise their policies – but not to solicit votes.

Labour made a complete nonsense of those rules.

Getting the taxpayer to bear the cost of producing and distributing its signature pledge card was breathtaking in its audacity.

Labour’s mistake was to go a step further and try to exclude that spending from its expenses covering the three months prior to the election. In the commission’s view, that took Labour over the limit.

Regardless of what the police determine, pre-election arrogance has boomeranged badly on Labour.

The pledge card – a device designed to increase trust in Labour – has been devalued.

Labour now looks shamefaced. To defuse things, it is deliberately fudging and confusing the separate issues of election overspending and spending of parliamentary funds.

Indeed. What will be interesting is how Labour deals with the investigation. It is unthinkable that the Police will not prosecute at least one Labour official for the offence. Now the issue will be do they get him or her to plead guilty?

National is also I think likely to be prosecuted for the GST broadcasting error, but they have been totally candid about the fact they booked too much broadcasting, reported it themselves to the Electoral Commission and will plead guilty if charged and pay any fine.

But for Labour it will be a terrible dilemna. If the people charged plead guilty then the pressure to repay the $445,000 will be immense. If they plead not guilty then the issue stays in the media for much longer and all sorts of incriminating evidence could come out in a trial.

Prison Approaches

There seem to be two distinct ways to run the criminal justice system in New Zealand.

One is to say we will let the number of prisoners dictate the number of prisonss.

The other is to say we will let the number of prisons dictate the number of prisoners.

The Government appears to be leaning towards the latter approach where the threshold for going to prisons gets raised not because it is desirable, but to save the cost of building new prisons.

Any debate on open prisons should be focused on whether it better serves the community, not on saving Dr Cullen some money by not having to build new prisons.

Melbourne

No more blogging until late today or tomorrow as I grab a plane to Melbourne in a few hours.

Nothing too exciting – just a quick visit to meet with some Government officials from the anti-spam enforcement unit of the Australian Government. Basically finding out as much as possible about how their unit operates so we can help shape how the NZ Government unit might operate. Main focus being on user-friendly and efficent.

Idiotic Christians

The Christian (and other) leaders who are continuing to advocate for the Bloody Mary episode of South Park to be banned are really pretty stupid.

They have guaranteed that ratings for that episode will be massively higher than normal. And it shows on a TV channel that 95% of the population probably don’t even check out on a regular basis.

One would have thought they would have learnt from the last ten times they have complained about something, that all they inevitably do is boost ticket sales or viewers.

If they find the episode so offensive, then they should simply just not watch it rather than try to stop me from watching it.

Daud Azimulla says “Something like this isn’t funny”. Bzzt wrong. I’ve seen it and it is very very funny. Of course that is only my opinion but I am *choosing* to watch it. The focus of the episode isn’t even on Mary, but taking the mickey out of alcoholics. Mary only comes in as a way for Stan’s dad to be cured of alcoholism as he needs a miracle.

The winner of the hyperbole contest is Anglican Bishop Muru Walters who has said the television cartoon is demonic and satanic as the purpose is to humiliate somebody.

Hmmn so enjoying humiliation is satanic and demonic now. Hmmn does that make me a demon. Hmmn let’s ignore that photo at the top right!

Estimating Extreme Islam Numbers

One of the more stupid statements around is that extreme Islam is no different from extreme Christianity – that the religions are basically the same and both suffer from a small number of extreme adherents who give the rest a bad name.

Now this is true at a superficial level. An insane Christian who blows up an abortion clinic is just as bad as a mad Muslim who blows up a kindergarten.

But it misses the key point that the numbers of “extreme” adherents is several magnitudes higher in Islam. In Christianity the number of extreme followers who believe it is religiously justified to execute civilians is oh say a few dozen or a few hundred at the very most. And there is no doubt Christian leaders condemn any killing of innocents.

Now while the number of Muslims who are actively part of terror groups is thought to be around 10,000 the problem is that literally millions and tens of millions support them. It’s not just a few thousand.

A Pew survey in May 2005 of almost 18,000 people found the following levels of support for violence against civilian targets:

Jordan 88%
Lebanon 58%
Pakistan 44%
Indonesia 33%
Turkey 20%
Morocco 18%

Now taking into account the population in each country, this gets estimates for Extreme Islam followers of:

Jordan 5.0 million
Lebanon 2 million
Pakistan 70 million
Indonesia 80 million
Turkey 14 million
Morocco 6 million

So in just those six countries you have around 177 million people who believe suicide bombing is acceptable. They represent one third of the total Muslim population so if the percentages are the same globally (I doubt they are, so should be lower) then one could be talking up to half a billion who support suicide bombings and killing people in God’s name so to speak.

Now this is still a minority of all Muslims, but it is a pretty damn big minority and the next time some moron says oh they are more worried about extreme Christian fundamentalists than they are extreme Islamic fundamentalists then think about that massive difference in numbers.

Now again I stress the majority of Muslims do not support suicide bombings and the like. And this would be especially true in New Zealand. This article is not about whipping up hysteria against individuals who happen to be Muslim. It is about recognising that the problem is huge. It is hard to credibly claim that Islam is a religion of peace and it is only a few extremists who ruin it for the rest.

Islam is a religion which has a massive split in it. Around two-thirds or more do not support violence targeted against civilians, yet somewhere between say 20% and 33% do. That’s not a small faction but a big fraction 🙂

And in case people think that it might just be say in Israel or Iraq that many Muslims support suicide bombings (not that I personally think that makes it in anyway more acceptable) then consider that support for the man who masterminded the plan to fly planes into the Twin Towers, Osama bin Laden, is also very high:

Jordan 60% = 3 million
Pakistan 51% = 80 million
Indonesia 35% = 80 million
Morocco 26% = 8 million
Turkey 7% = 5 million
Lebanon 2% = 70,000

So that’s 176 million or so who support the guy who dreamed up flying planes into towers, bombing tubes and nightclubs etc.

The challenge for moderate Islam, and the entire world, is how to reduce the proportion of Muslims who regard violence targeted towards civilians as sometimes acceptable from as much as a third down to 1% or so. And this won’t happen in a year or even ten years, but as the Pew survey shows there has been improvements in most countries from a couple of years ago, so progress can be made.

Previous pledge card funding

Labour have said that their previous pledge cards were not declared as election expenses (I had been previously informed they had been but clarified on Friday I had been told they were not), which might make people think the electoral authorities are being inconsistent in including it this time. However there are a number of easy explanations.

The first being that if Labour had not previously included the pledge cards in their declarations, then the Electoral Commission would have no way of knowing that the cards were not included. They were known about this time because of National’s complaint to the CEO. So this is possibly the first time that the Electoral Commission has been asked to make a decision on if they count.

Another less likely possibility is in previous elections they were distributed outside the 90 day period – which would not count. Also it is worth noting that in previous elections the total expenditure was not near the maximum allowed so all around there was probably less scrutiny.

What is also apparent from this article is that Labour is quite ignorant about the difference between rules for taxpayer funding and the rules for whether it counts as an election expense.

Labour keep saying that as the pledge cards “does not urge people to vote, join or give money to a party, it does not qualify as an election expense.”

However that rule they are quoting is the rule for whether The Parliamentary Service can pay for it. The three things prohibited are indeed asking for money members or votes.

But the rule for whether it counts as an election expense is different. It says “”encourages or persuades or appears to encourage or persuade voters to vote for the party”. And hence the two electoral agencies have decided their pledge cards did count. Labour keep quoting thee wrong rule.

Now people might think hang on there is no precedent for counting taxpayer funded material as election expenses but indeed there is. In 1988 Reg Boorman in Wairarapa was found guilty of corrupt practices as the court found his parliamentary produced material had to be included in his expense return which out him over the limit.

Finally as Labour’s Mike Williams claims it is all unclear, let us remember his quote from 7 December 2005 when National made the GST error with its broadcasting allocation. He said “there was no way it could have misinterpreted the law”.