TVNZ inflghting continues

The TVNZ infighting continues with Ian Fraser threatening the Board with a personal grievance.

The possibility that an employee can be disciplined for what they say, effectively under oath, at a select committee is a worrying one. TVNZ may end up back in front of the select committee for this!

A little obsession

Someone seems to be talking about just one issue!

In the last week, Rodney has blogged or spoken about National’s leadership on five occassions!!!

On Sat the 28th, Monday 30th, a 2nd time on the 30th, an absolutely bizarre suggestion in a speech on Thursday the 2nd and again talking about it this morning.

Does anyone in ACT think this will help ACT?

Does anyone in ACT have any idea how much this annoys people who want to see the centre-right co-operate so they can form a Government.

My advice to Rodney is to quote his own words back on the 19th of January:

“It makes sense for National to be thinking about who they are going to work with.”

Indeed.

Tele-Marketing on Skype!

Kate’s date with Mike Hosking

Okay it hasn’t actually happened but Kate would like it to happen on 10 February.

This reminds me of that (surprisingly very good) movie about one man’s quest to have a date with Drew Barrymore.

Anyway if anyone knows Mr Hosking, feel free to let him know of Kate’s desire for a date. The downside for him is we will all read about it on Kate’s blog, the upside is that the gossip mags won’t be able to speculate on it as all will be revealed anyway.

Sharing a Bed

Been chatting to a few people about situations when you share a bed with someone but don’t want sex. It’s pretty common and probably most of us have done it.

However when asked (obviously referring to this case) about whether you would allow someone to share your bed when you don’t want to have sex with them, and you know they have made a bet that they can score you within six months – then everyone has pretty much said there is no way they would do that. I guess the jury came to the same conclusion.

US Democratic Party

A couple of months ago I was convinced that the Republican Party were headed towards a (mainly deserved) thrashing in the mid term elections in November.

However I hadn’t counted on the ability of the Democratic Party to do really stupid things, and wouldn’t want to make a prediction now.

In one seat a Democratic candidate put a doctored photo of her Republican Congressman opponent in a Nazi uniform on her website. These things have national consequences as we saw in 2002 when the boorish behaviour at Senator Wellstone’s funeral probably tipped several seats to the GOP.

The debate over warrantless NSA interceptions ended up with the Democrats looking like they were against intercepting calls between Al Qaeda and operatives in the US. And perception is everything.

The Justice Alito nomination has also been a disaster for them. Senator Kennedy’s behaviour seemed to be from Senator McCarthy and backfired massively as Alito’s wive broke down in tears. But even more of a disaster is that almost every Democrat voted against Alito. Why is this a disaster. Because Republicans previously had voted to confirm left-wing candidates (sometimes unanimously) who were well qualified. This precedent now means that a future Democrat President will be unable to get his or her picks confirmed unless they also have a majority in the Senate. Very very stupid. They concentrated on the battle (which they also lost) and forgot about the war.

You also have John Kerry swinging even more to the left to try and get another chance as their presidential candidate, and Republicans could not be happier.

I still think at this stage that the GOP will lose some seats in mid-term (especially because of corruption scandals) but the chance of them losing a majority in either House seems to be receding.

Russel Norman declares he is not a communist!

Frog Blog has a response from future Greens co-leader Russel Norman to Trevor Loudon’s posting about his Marxist-Leninist background.

The short version is that Russel is no longer a communist because of “the fundamental lack of democracy in Marxist-Leninist ideology” and their lack of commitment to environmental sustainability.

Personally I’m not that worried about people’s former views as even Stephen Franks was once a stinking commune communist hippy 🙂

Charity Marketing

Is it just me or are charities getting far more aggressive in their efforts to get people to donate to them?

I just got phoned up for the third time in three days asking me to donate to some worthy cause.

I’ve also noted that often in town you have (paid) young students stopping pedestrians and convincing them to join particular charities. I even ended up joining and donating $30 a month or something to the World Wildlife Fund after being stopped in Manners Mall (yes she was was very cute, yes I have a problem saying no to cute females, and yes I am sure that is why they hire them)

Am I just being targeted or have others noticed more calls and the like?

The NZ model

Andrew Coyne, one of Canada’s leading bloggers, advocates that Canada should adopt the New Zealand public service model.

He’s right to hold the NZ model up. Putting aside the usual silliness from time to time it is still a world leader in terms of transparency and accountability.

Andrew also advocates purchaser-provider splits. I am a fan of these, but note that these have been somewhat reversed in the last six years – especially in health.

Visiting the Left

Some amusing things worth commenting on:

Jordan Carter repeats spin from Michael Cullen about incomes in NZ vs Australia. Dr Brash has said since 1999 the average after tax income in Australia has gone from 20% ahead of NZ to 33%. Jordan and Dr Cullen has responded with GDP growth per capita has gone up faster in NZ as some sort of rebuttal.

Now let’s think about this. In fact Dr Jordan Cullen has not rebutted Dr Brash at all. They have just produced a different statistic. They are saying the income of the country is going up faster than Australia while Dr Brash is saying the after-tax income of families is losing ground to Australia. Now do you see the key difference? Dr Jordan Cullen talks about pre-tax incomes and Dr Brash about after tax incomes, or how much you actually end up with.

So what do you conclude from this? That even when our economy grows faster than Australia’s, the average family ends up with even less money because the stinking greedy Government merely steals even more of it!!!

Now we turn to Tony Milne. Tony quotes his hero Winston Peters. So what does the Rt Hon Winston Milne have to say?

Oh he calls Dr Brash a lame duck leader. Oh the pain. Now let’s compare the records of the two leaders since Dr Brash became an MP.

The Rt Hon Winston Milne took his party from 10% of the vote to 5.7%, losing half his caucus. He also managed to lose a 10,000 majority in his seat and oh yeah also lost an electoral petition.

Dr Brash of course was far less successful than the Rt Hon Winston Milne. He merely became Leader after 18 months as an MP, increased National’s vote by 17% to a 15 year high and double the size of the National Caucus.

In 2002 National has only twice as many MPs as NZ First. Today it has seven times as many. Wow Tony Winston is definitely the person to quote about being a successful leader.

Chris Trotter

Chris Trotter has an excellent column in The Independent on the post-election negotiations. A must read for political junkies.

It will be interesting to see if his preidction that Nandor replacing Rod Donald will tilt the Greens to work closer with the Maori Party will hold true. He says that the Greens and Maori Party considered negotiating with Labour as a 10 vote centre-left bloc but the Greens led by Donald decided not doing so would get them a better result from Labour.

All too easy

I normally resist rebutting criticisms which are so easy to rebut it is an easy fight but hey so I don’t get out of practice I’ll quickly deal with Stephen Cooper saying I have been pushing racist filth.

Stephen starts talking about Arabs, but overlooks that I never mentioned Arabs. I only mentioned Muslims and I am well aware not all Arabs are Muslims and most certainly not all Muslims are Arabs.

He then claims I talked about white people in Europe. But again he is wrong. I have not referred to any race or colour. The last time I was in Europe there were many many non-white Europeans. Stephen seems to again confuse religion and skin colour or race.

Stephen also claims mixed marriages (in terms of Muslims and non Muslims) will become more common. I’d be fascinated to see any evidence he has to back up this assertion as the reports I have seen is that the lack of mixed marriages is a major problem. In fact one reason why NZ has comparatively less friction than many other countries is the high mixed marriage rate, but this has not been the case in Europe.

Stephen also repeats the claim that no two democracies have ever gone to war. Oh dear. Unless you adopt a definition of democracy which basically no country in the world qualified for until after WWII there have been several dozen wars between democracies. And closer to home umm didn’t Palestine just democratically elect a Government which vows to destroy through war its democratic neighbour?

He also claims “conservatives” have opposed immigration from Jews, Catholics, Irish, African, Russians, Mexicans, Turks, Islanders and Asians. Really?

Sigh. All to easy.

Muhammad Cartoons

Normally when a website or publication is under attack over some sort of controversial article or image, it is copied around the world. This is partly so people can see what the fuss is about, and also partly to support free speech and make people realise that trying to force one single publisher to back down will be ineffective.

I had been surprised by the fact the controversial Muhammed cartoons which had sparked death threats, fiery protests and threats of trade and diplomatic embargoes had not appeared in basically every newspaper and most of the blogs around the world.

Last night I made the decision to publish one of them here. So as it happens has a French newspaper [UPDATE – whose editor has sadly now been sacked], and hopefully many more people will do this.

I do this not to offend people who believe these images are blasphemy. I respect that you find them offensive, and hope you will respect my right to view and publish them. Just as I (and I suspect 99% of the world’s population) don’t want the Church of Scientology deciding for me what I can view, I don’t want any other religion deciding for me either.

In case you do wish to take action against me, can I ask that any lawsuits or threats are sent to my legal representative the Hon David Parker, Attorney-General, Parliament Buildings Wellington. Mr Parker I am sure will defend my rights in these matters.

And if you wish to visit me to register your disapproval, then you should go to 260 Tinakori Road, Thorndon, Wellington 🙂

Muhammed drawing newspaper.jpg

This is one of the images. I have to say that as insulting images go it is at the very low end of the scale. On a scale of 1 to 10 I would put this at around a 2/10 for offensiveness to a religion while the Southpark Bloody Mary episode would rank up at 8.5/10. Southpark has also had an episode where Catholic Cardinals debated how to cover up child abuse and declared they can’t stop abusing little boys because “If we can’t have sex with little boys and we are not allowed to have sex with women, then we’d have no sex at all”. That is a degree of offensiveness (and very good humour) far far beyond these cartoons.

The Whig’s cartoon is starting to get up to really offensive level in terms of such cartoons. I could understand the protests a bit more if that was what was published. But it wasn’t.

The rest of the 12 cartoons published in Jyllands-Posten can also be found online here or here. And as always Wikipedia has a good article on the controversy.

ACT Board Elections

The list of nominations for the ACT Board is online.

Garry Mallett and John Ormond are both standing for President. Ormond is the current VP and I suspect the favourite. Mallett stood for ACT for Hamilton East and was No 59 on their party list and was somewhat controversial.

Vice President is a three-way race between Barry Parkin, Frank (Muriel’s husband) Newman and Trevor Loudon.

Board member Auckland South region

David Seymour is unopposed as the board member for Auckland South – well done.

In Wellington Michael Collins squares off against Joe McTaggart

And Andrew Falloon is unopposed as a deputy board member for the upper south island.

Will be interesting to see the results of the presidential race especially.

US media

Contrary to what many may think I actually regard the NZ media as light-years ahead of much of the US media.

While journalists in NZ are certainly, on average, more left-wing than the average population (which gets reflected in subconscious bias rather than deliberate bias) we have a reasonably balanced press gallery. I get frustrated at the lack of serious research and content in some publications or broadcasters but that’s another issue. Yes Radio NZ seems to have a near total absence of conservative commentators but private radio is more diverse so overall not such a big issue.

However in the US (where around 90% of journalists are Democrats) the bias is incredible. Power Line gives a good example of an outrageous New York Times and ABC story on Justice Scalia suggesting he was on a junket instead of being at the swearing in on the Chief Justice.

Personally I don’t have an issue with partisan media, so long as they don’t pretend to be something else. In NZ for example everyone knows the NBR is right wing and hence its articles are read taking that into account. Likewise everyone knows the Listener is (or was!) left-wing. State owned media are a different matter as they *have* to be non-partisan. Of course in my ideal world we would have no state owned media!

Graham Capill drops appeal

Orewa III

Well the left pulled out the full range of hysterical reaction to Orewa III (or arguably IV), and this was before they even knew what was in the speech. Never has so many worked so hard to demonise.

Lindsay Mitchell blogs how Judith Tizard drops into the gutter by saying “The idea of a man who is married to a migrant attacking migrants really does worry me”.

Tony Milne predicted before the speech that “there will be a few dog whistles to red-neck talkback land”.

Russell Brown said he hoped Brash “will manage to get through one of these speeches without actually scapegoating any sector of New Zealand society”. Jeez Russell is it okay if I say I hope Minister xxx can get through a speech without urinating on anyone. I mean is there any more subtle but cunning way to disparage someone than starting it with “I hope they don’t”. Yeah I hope Simon Dallow doesn’t have sex with Wendy Petrie while reading the news also (a view probably shared by Alison Mau). So let’s just say it so people will think he may have done it otherwise.

Anyway after Judith, Tony and Russell getting all excited about Dr Brash’s jihad against immigrants let’s look at what he actually said:

The first of these is immigration, not least because it is intimately connected to economic policy. Indeed, immigration has been thought of by many people as being relevant only to the economy. How do we fill gaps in the workforce? What level of gross immigration is needed to offset the steady outflow of New Zealanders? How do we ensure there are enough people of working age to ensure that older New Zealanders are cared for in their old age?

But just as importantly, how do we do this while retaining the common values that bind us together as a nation? New Zealand is a liberal, tolerant and secular society, a society that embraces the Western Enlightenment ideals of personal liberty, private property and rationality as the basis of decision-making. These are values so central to our society that we hardly even think about them. Immigration can add greatly to our society, but it also has the potential to undermine the glue that holds our society together.

Our current immigration policies have evolved without serious public discussion or debate, and we will be giving careful consideration to this issue through the coming year.

Now read the above again. This is what Judith Tizard claims is “attacking migrants”. How on hell can we have a serious debate about immigration if people like Judith Tizard claim that the above is “attacking migrants”. This is of course Labour arrogance at its very worst – disagree with us and you are a bigot and a racist.

And as for sanely debating immigration (something NZ First has sadly made even more difficult to do) well anyone who thinks we don’t need to talk about the role of values in immigration is living on a different planet to Europe.

Now moving onto the media coverage of Orewa III let me start with the appalling TV coverage last night. The guest on Breakfast TV this morning basically ripped it to shreds as it spent almost more time on the fact John Key arrived late than you know the actual content of the speech. Almost a total triumph of banality.

Almost as laughable has been the 9th floor inspired spin that this speech is somehow a last gasp chance for Brash to cling onto the leadership with vultures circling. Let’s take a reality check:

* Brash achieved the best result for National since 1990
* Brash came within 2% of winning the unwinnable election
* National is actually ahead of Labour in most polls
* A Government traditionally post-election has a honeymoon in the polls where they put on a significant lead. This time there hasn’t even been a one month honeymoon (thanks to our Foreign Minister mainly)
* The economy looks to be seriously slowing down and this normally damages a Government

Don’t get me wrong – I am not at all complacent about the work needed to be done by National to take a commanding lead and keep it. There is a hell of a lot to be done. But these ridiculous attempts to manufacture crisis are well ridiculous. As I said above when TV spends more time almost on the significance of an MP being late to a speech (hmmn must be a cunning plot) than on the actual content of a speech – well no wonder ratings keep dropping.

Religious Satire saved by 1 vote in UK

Yay. The House of Commons by 1 vote has voted against a law change which would make incitement to religious hatred punishable by up to seven years in jail.

Rowan Atkinson had led a campaign against this clause as the law was worded in such a way that satiricial parodies of religions could also be prosecuted. A victory for the Black Adder! Only the second lost vote in nine years for Blair.

The Blair Government defended the measure on the basis it was just extending the current laws on race to religion. But there is a key difference. No-one can choose their race, but people can and do choose their religion.

Hat Tip: Sir Humphries

More stories on this here.

Critic banned

A 2005 issue of Critic, which only editor Holly and two other people would still have a copy of, has been banned by the Office of Film and Literature Classification.

This is the infamous drug rape article. Somewhat ironic that a newspaper edited by a woman has been found to be demeaning to women, by a man!

The online version of the article has been deleted so someone at OUSA is awake!

Hat Tip: Lyndon Hood

UPDATE: An alert reader has suggested I should ask if the Greens will be commenting on this issue. We await to see!

Around the Blogs

Some good posts around.

I loved Michael Ellis’ Top Ten Cricketing Sledges and Comebacks. No 5 and No 2 are classics.

Tim Selwyn rebuts Russell Brown on immigration. I don’t agree with everything Tim said but I do think that the issue of religious belief and immigration policy is one that is very real.

Kiwi Pundit has a truly excellent post on his beliefs. More people should do posts like this. I’ll try to do so one day when I have the time.

Peter Metcalfe beats me in pointing out that the accidential release of the GCSB annual report shows Lange lied about being kept in the dark, a fact confirmed by the recent statement by the GCSB.

Lindsay Mitchell depresses me by reporting that the interfering busy bodies in Western Australia are going to ban all kids in the state from wearing denim to school. God they should get a life and leave it up to each school to set their dress policy.

Blog Drinks Update

Well around five people RSVPed and over the night around two dozen turned up. A very good night and general agreement these need to happen more than once a year.

Oh yes the two people who forgot to pay for their meals. Yes you who had sausages and mash and you who had the steak sandwich – I have retained the Mongrel Mob as my debt collection agency.

I will no doubt have forgotten a few, so add onto comments if overlooked, but off memory the following were there:

* Amelia from Redebate
* Richard from BZP
* Dave from Big News
* Chaucey from Chaucey
* Michael from Elllis in Wellywood
* Will from Gonzo Freakpower
* Nigel from Kiwi Pundit
* Andrea and Stu from The Penthouse
* Graeme from Sparrows are Cool
* Jeremy from Aucklander at Large
* Lyndon from Fighting Talk
* Jordan from Just Left
* Keith from Public Address
* Geoff from Thorndon Bubble
* The Denizen from Jonathan Liverstone
* Maria from Maria von Trapp
* Jordan W, Phil L, Chris B, Dennis R
* Conor and Joey from NZUSA

Most amusing debate was when one started on VSM. After a few minutes we realised that with one side being the co-presidents of NZUSA and the other being myself and Chris Bishop, the chance of either side persuading the other was zero so changed topics to avoid driving everyone else off. Other topics discussed with greater agreement was parental means testing and bilingual census forms!

Geoff amused himself by speculating on whether any of the other patrons in the bar was Idiot from No Right Turn who could have been covertly observing us as he was down in Wellington.

A very good night which carried on until close to 11 pm when we had to leave after the waitress reminded us for the third time they were closed and she wanted to go home!

Jan Blog Stats

Drinks tonight

Reminder that the blog drinks are tonight, starting 5.30 pm at the Backbencher on Molesworth Street.

These are not exclusive. Both bloggers and blog readers are welcome. And in true bi-partisan spirit they are co-hosted by Jordan Carter. Co-host does not mean we pay for your drinks though. In fact I have no idea what it means.

Due to my new found control over time and space, this post should stay at the top of the blog all day.

Religions and Free Speech

It is interesting to contrast how different religions handle publications that they consider are derogatory or offensive of their beliefs.

With the Catholic Church we have the fine example of the South Park Episode which features a statue of the Virgin Mary bleeding out her behind and the Pope eventually investigating and declaring it is no miracle as in fact the bleeding is from elsewhere and quite ordinary. Now I have viewed this episode. It is truly offensive. It is especially offensive to Catholics who revere the Virgin Mary.

Luckily for me I enjoy offensive comedies so found the episode hilarious.

Now various Catholic groups have lobbied for that episode to not be aired. They have signed a letter to C4 asking it not to be shown. An appropriate action. C4 hopefully will of course show it anyway. And that result will be accepted.

Now over in Denmark a newspaper ran some cartoons that satirically ridiculed the prophet Mohammed. The reaction to this newspaper from many representatives of Islam has been amazing. This is a private newspaper not owned by the state.

However Libya has closed its embassy, Saudi Arabia has recalled its ambassador, religious leaders have called for boycotts of all Danish products, Danish aid workers in the middle east have been threatened, protests have burnt the Danish flag etc etc.

All this over one private newspaper running some cartoons. Islamic Governments around the world declaring the Denmark must kill off a free press and stop a repeat.

I hate to think what would happen if South Park ever satirised Islam in the way it does the Catholic Church.

And meanwhile in the UK Rowan Atkinson is continuing his fight against a bill which basically will make it illegal to insult religions.

Personally I think that just as it is important for people to choose a religion freely, people should be able to criticise and satirise religions freely.

A pledge Clinton would never make

Silvio Berlusconi, the prime minister of Italy has promised not to have sex until after the general election on April 9.

Having seen the wives of the new Canadian Prime Minister and UK Tory Leader, I am fairly confident in predicting there won’t be a lot of leaders making similiar pledges.