Don Brash responsible for Australian race riots!

Well not quite, but that is almost the lines the Greens are taking.

Don put out a PR slamming the group putting up posters in Wellington inciting racial hatred. He makes the point “The idea that some people cannot have the same depth of feeling for this country because of the colour of their skin or their ethnic background is bigoted nonsense”.

The Greens say that Brash though is responsible for making racism respectable in New Zealand (by arguing all NZers should have equal rights!).

They go onto compare his Orewa speech to the race riots saying “Cronulla is Australia

Peters loses

The Speaker has just announced to huge applause in the House that the Electoral Court Judges have determined that the election of Bob Clarkson as MP for Tauranga was not void.

Perhaps Peters will finally now concede he lost.

Huge congratulations to Bob and his team. Awful to have to go through this, but great to have Peters’ claims fall short.

UPDATE: The decision is online. Good work MOJ staff.

UPDATE 2: Just finished reading the 45 page judgement. It is going to be an incredibly valuable guide for candidates for future elections. They concluded that the maximum spent, in terms of what constitutes election activities under the Act, was $18,159.79.

UPDATE3: Peters is a very bad loser. He outraegously attacks the ruling as meaning there are no rule or limits on candidate expenditure, when even a first year law student who reads it could tell you it says no such thing.

He also says he plans to get his colleagues (ie Helen) to change the law for the next election.

What a pitiful loser he is. Not a hint of graciousness or concession.

EPMU and Air NZ

Some (not all) on the left are very upset with the Engineers Union (EPMU) for the proposal to save half the 600 jobs being made redundant at Air NZ. This is an interesting debate between (in my view) those who want to actually achieve something for their members and those who prefer protest over solutions.

Comrade Tweek has a copy of the Alliance press release. Let’s look at some of their complaints:

1) The unions have hired Michael Stiassny who “is not known as a workers’ champion” and specialises in company restructuring and insolvency

This is in fact a brilliant move by the EPMU. If they hired Jane Kelsey or Brian Easton to come up with a plan to convince Air NZ they don’t have to make all 600 jobs redundant, then Air NZ would spend around 2 minutes considering the proposal. By hiring someone with real credibility in terms of corporate restructuring, they have made it far far harder for Air NZ to not take the proposals seriously.

2) Only 300 of the 600 jobs are being proposed to be saved

Well given a choice between 0 and 300 jobs being saved, EPMU is working in the best interest of its members. They have obviously concluded that there is no chance of persuading Air NZ to keep all 600 jobs, so they have gone for a compromise.

Now Span says that as Air NZ is already profitable, then Air NZ doesn’t need to cuts jobs.

3) Span basically suggests that as long as the airline won’t go bankrupt it should not cut jobs, and the EPMU should not accept any reduction in terms or conditions

It’s hard in a few sentences point out the fatal flaws of an ideology which says as long as a company doesn’t go bankrupt, it shouldn’t cut costs. Let me just say that I don’t think you’ll find a lot of people wanting to invest in such a company in the first place.

4) In relation to an argument from me over cost of capital, Span says the Government has wider interests to consider

Firstly I can’t think of a more inefficient way to help people by having government owned companies forced to feather-bed. Muldoon tried it and it was a disaster. Since giving that up we now have 3% unemployment.

But as importantly people overlook that it is an opportunity cost for the Government. If the Government did not have say $1b tied up into Air NZ, it could then spend an extra $80 million or so a year (every year) on say free doctors visits for kids – unless the return from the investment in Air NZ is equal to or greater than it would get by paying off debt.

5) Len Richards says the unions should lead a nationwide campaign to force the Government to intervene and save the 600 jobs

The reason the EPMU has not decided to do this is because Andrew Little is not a moron. He know that such a gesture has a 0.001% chance of success, would allow the comrades to feel good about having tried, but in the end achieve absolutely nothing for his members.

The Government knows that if it interfered in this particular redundancy decision, then no Government Department, agency or company could ever make staff redundant again due to fear of pressure leading to Ministerial intervention.

Mr Little also knows that government intervention would also lead to the resignations of the entire Air NZ Board, some of its senior management and send the share price hurtling down-wards.

The EPMU may not succeed with their alternate plan, but good on them for pulling out all stops to try and achieve the best results for their members. I hope Air NZ carefully consider their proposal.

Competence Missing

Tuesday’s Colin James article touches on the David Benson-Pope saga, highlighting that what happened 23 years ago is not the issue as much as the Government’s handling of events this year.

James concludes that the perception that Ministers are competent and on top of their jobs was only valid up until 2004.

Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha

ACC levies

When employers were given a choice of company for their workplace accident coverage, workplace accidents fell (it’s called incentives) and so did premiums.

Labour re-imposed a state monopoly, but promised it would not cost levy payers more.

Yet once again today the self-employed have received a 10% levy hike, on top of previous ones. And they can’t choose to go to a company which provides a better service, even though this is just for their own self-insurance!

A sensible stance on assessment

The NZ Herald editorial on school assessment and NCEA is very balanced, and for me is right on the money.

The Herald makes the point that standards-based assessment is as well suited to some subjects as it is ill suited to others. It works well for motor mechanics or maths, but far less well for arts and humanities.

One down, more to come?

Well despite the Government having said for ages there is nothing wrong at TVNZ, the charter is excellent, the board do not interfere, the truth is coming out.

Former Labour Minister Dame Ann Hercus resigned off the board last night, and the outgoing CEO incredibly has accussed another director of leaking against him.

Ian Fraser also accusses the PM’s Office of leaking the details of Judy Bailey’s salary. They deny it of course. Also alleged that H2 tried to get hold of a copy of Ian Fraser’s contract.

I think it is an excellent lesson in why governments are often very very bad shareholders. Unless the board is replaced and some guarantee of government non-interference is supplied I suspect many suitable candidates for CEO will not touch the job with a barge pole.

Tookie Williams

Tookie Williams was executed by the State of California a few hours ago. Now I am not a supporter of the death penalty (see one example here) but this guy wasn’t exactly a poster boy for clemency, despite the attempts by some to paint him as a hero, who should receive the nobel peace and literature prizes for his books.

A few useful facts from Wikipedia:

* Shot Albert Owens in the back as he was lying on the floor during a robbery which netted $120
* Said he killed Owens “because he was white and he was killing all white people.”
* Killed three Taiwanese immigrants during a $100 robbery. They were shot several times at close range
* When found guilty told the jury “I’m going to get each and every one of you motherfuckers.”
* In prison involved in over a dozen assaults on guards and other prisoners
* has constantly refused to co-operate with law enforcement agencies by revealing any information at all on gang operations

It’s one thing to be against the death penalty, it’s another to paint Tookie Williams as a hero.

Whoops another lie from DBP

This time he denied that he had spoken to the Prime Minister about his handling of the Police Report. Not even the most naive MP or journalist believed this was possible, so he then snuck into the House in the evening to admit he had spoken to the PM about it.

Also got an admission in the House yesterday that he authorised his press secretary to leak favourable parts of the police report, and also authorised the press secretary to say that the Minister was unavailable for an interview and had no comment to make; yet he does not think that is deceptive conduct!

He publicly states the report is for the police to release, he privately writes to them asking them to delay it, he then leaks favourable extracts while at the same time saying that the media should report he has no comment, and he thinks this is not deceptive??

It should be of course no surprise that it is being reported his press secretary will keep his job. Benson-Pope would be unable to survive an employment relations authority hearing into the case.

Type of Inquiries

The vast majority of voters I am sure don’t care about what sort of inquiry is set-up, when some scandal hits a Minister. But it is important.

You see the Government often goes for an inquiry where there are few powers for the inquiry head. They refuse to establish inquiries where witnesses can be summoned to give evidence.

And now as we see in the case of Phillip Field, the witnesses are simply refusing to talk to the inquiry. Which increases the chances the inquiry will be unable to conclude wrong-doing.

How convenient for the Government, if this does eventuate. Especially as the PM had already declared before the election he had done nothing wrong.

Appalling literacy in NZ

Literacy rates are so bad in NZ, that it appears most of the Cabinet are unable to read.

You see John Armstrong has usefully highlighted that the Government’s latest ploy to avoid having to actually answer questions in Parliament is to claim they have not read something.

So you have the PM claiming that she hasn’t even read a police report which concluded one of her Ministers had prima facie assaulted pupils. She must have been too busy reading a novel instead.

And just as incredibly you have Steve Maharey as Broadcasting Minister claiming he hasn’t read a memo from the CEO of TVNZ which states the charter is a failure – from the very man who was employed to try and make it work. Could there be a more important memo for that portfolio?

I suppose they subscribe to the philosophy that ignorance is bliss.

Even the Unions are now calling for quicker tax cuts

Fairly stunned by the news that the CTU has secretly advised Labour to bring forward its (chewing gum) tax cuts from 2008 to 2006.

This now means the following groups are in favour of greater or quicker tax cuts:

National
ACT
United Future
NZ First
Maori Party
Greens
Progressive
CTU
Business NZ

And against greater or further tax cuts are:

Labour

Australian Editorial on VSU

The Australian has come out strongly in favour of the VSU legislation just passed in Australia. It says:

VSU involves a profound point of principle: no Australian should be forced to join a union

They also make the point, student union leaders often refuse to accept:

And while the student unions and newspapers will of course be free to run any political line they like, lacking a captive audience they will be forced to work harder to connect with students’ needs and preferences. They will be the better for it.

A question

Xmas Presents for DPF

snow.JPG

For all those who want to take sympathy on DPF spending Xmas away from home, and in freezing winter (forecast is for -21c tonight) instead of summer, you can send me presents from my wishlist I have set-up on Amazon Canada.

I used to buy off Amazon a lot but the postage to NZ got so expensive that the books etc started to be more expensive than buying locally. However by being in Canada it means it is only local freight charges, and I get them in a few days!

The wishlists are a cool idea, as people buying for you just click on what they want to purchase, and it is automatically sent to the recepient and charged to the donor. I’ve used them in the past to send stuff to Risawn in Kosovo but never had one for myself before. I’ve also taken part this year in the secret santa programme where everyone who agrees to take part buys a present (max US$15) for someone else randomly assigned to them, using that person’s Amazon gift list.

For those who are expecting presents from me, they will get them when I return. Now everyone did want maple syrup didn’t they? 🙂

Game over for the charter

In the last few months we have had commentator after commentator and industry expert after expert say that Labour’s strategy with the TVNZ Charter was not working – that one can’t have TVNZ with conflicting imperatives of being a commercial broadcaster, but also have the fluffy charter about national identity.

Well thanks to the Greens, we now know that no less a person than the outgoing CEO of TVNZ agrees. This is a damning indictment on the policies which brought in the charter, and Maharey’s reputation in broadcasting must now be heading towards his one for tertiary education.

Fraser’s memo states that TVNZ local content will shrink markedly next year to pre-charter levels, that priority will be given to commercially valuable programmes and other programmes will be scheduled in “inhospitable” places.

Just in time for dinner

Flew Air Canada from Winnipeg to Toronto and got met at the airport by one of the locals. By pure coincidence there was a dinner that evening with the local party and the chairman of the national campaign for the Canadian Conservative Party, and we got to Barrie (around an hours drive from Toronto) dead on 6 pm when it was due to start.

Almost 100 at the dinner, so got to meet pretty much all the locals. Was seated at the top table as compensation for being introduced to everyone at Patrick’s friend from Australia 🙂

The national chair is actually a former party leader – John Reynolds. He was fairly up to date on NZ politics.

I’d been told he would have his assistant with him, and assumed it was the woman pictured below who sat one his right, rather than the reasonably elderly gentleman on the other side.

Helenaguergis.jpg

As it happened the gentleman was his assistant, and in fact had been his politics lecturer when Reynolds was a student! The young lady (who is one of the most stunningly attractive people I have met – photos don’t do her justice) is in fact the MP for Simcoe-Grey, Miss Helena Guergis. Luckily I managed to hide the fact that I thought she was a parliamentary staffer until she was introduced.

Guergis also spoke briefly at the meeting, and is a very good public speaker. A number of people told me that she is a rising star and could well be deputy leader or higher one day. She is already in the shadow cabinet despite only being elected 18 months ago.

Which country is this?

71% say their lives are going well
69% are optimistic about their country’s future
60% say they feel safe in their neighbourhoods, up from 40% in June 2004
Average household income is up 60% in 20 months
70% rate their economic situation positively
Cellphone ownership has gone from 6% of households 18 months ago to 62%
75% express confidence in the upcoming election
74% say the schools are good
66% say crime prevention is good, up 13%
62% say medical care is good, up 11%

Click here to find out what country this is.

I love the irony

Rockies Train Trip Photos

Peters leaving Tauranga?

Accused of Plagiarism

Race Riots on Sydney Beaches

A spectacular photo

The NZ Herald has a spectacular photo of a car smashing through the barrier at Meremere and sneding a cameraman flying into the air.

You can see the poor cameraman, Robert Miller, around 12 feet up in the air and upside down. Somehow he came out of it with only minor injuries.

Mal Bain, who took the photo of the other cameraman in the air, did incredibly well to get such a spectacular photo.