GST – Doh!

A pretty big stuff-up from National in getting the broadcasting allocation mixed up so that $900,000+GST was spent instead of $900,000 incl GST.

I am really surprised it happened as the National Party HQ drills into every local campaign that campaign expenditures are GST inclusive. Now this was a broadcasting allocation, which is separate legislation but the same principle applies.

The remedy in this situation is unclear. Broadcasters are owed over $100,000. National is not allowed by law to make the money up. Very messy. The issue has been referred to the Police for a possible breach of the Broadcasting Act.

Generally most activists regarded this campaign as one of the best organised. It will be pretty gutting for all that to be blotted by this (fairly huge) mistake.

Reaction to David Benson-Pope report

Well first off DBP’s lawyer says the Police are wrong. Well he would say that, wouldn’t he.

The NZ Herald has a general round-up of reactions, and midly points out how selective DBP has been with his leaks.

John Armstrong is more severe, drawing comparisons to Richard Nixon in that the cover-up is far worse than the original ‘crime’. He highlights how badly DBP’s version of what the police report says is hugely at odds with its actual contents.

The Dom Post is also relatively severe on DBP saying “David Benson-Pope is under mounting pressure to resign after it was revealed his office leaked favourable extracts from a police file that contains significant evidence that he assaulted pupils while a teacher”.

Now that was great skiing

I’ve skiied in New Zealand for years and years but had never got around to skiing in an overseas country. And it was great – I just love skiing through (or around more correctly) trees.

Despite the fact I had none of my gear with me and had to hire or purchase everything, we got on the skifield by around 930 am. We were on Cypress Mountain which is a five lift field very near Vancouver. Some very nice runs with great scenery.

I used to ski for a week or two every year without fail but had been so busy in recent years it had been a while since I had skiied. However with powder so good, it was no problem getting in over 20 runs with my companions Colin (NZ) and Slobodan (Serbia).

Skiing

Finally the Benson-Pope Police Report

After several days of leaks and spinning we now have the complete report, and thanks to Scoop it is online. The link is to the key documents but they also have the full file.

Key aspects I have noted are:

Tennis Ball Incident

* 27 students interviewed. Nine recall the incident, 16 can not remember it and three rebut it. The three are described as very supportive of DBP.
* The Police say the nine witnesses are independent, appear to be genuine and do not have an axe to grind
* In a later paragraph they say the evidence is strong and none of the witnesses appear to have any hidden agendas
* The complainant did not even know DBP was an MP when he was informed that DBP had denied the allegation. The info came to light not from him but from friends who recalled it
* The issue of him having put the ball is his mouth first makes more sense in context. He basically says he stuck the ball in a bit as a joke (I imagine just biting on it almost). The DBP pushed it in further and he took it out. Then DBP pushed it right back in again and then taped his hands to the desk so he wouldn’t remove it again

Hit Face Incident

* Complainant and one witness agree it happened, one witness refutes it
* The witness says DBP did hit or slap a student in the left jaw. The witness says that DBP was a good teacher and the school needed more like him, and he thought about bullshitting that it never happened (but that it did). He goes on to say he thinks NZ needs more politicians like DBP, and is clearly a fan, which make his statement the assault happened far more credible.
The complainant has said he doesn’t like the assault being used as a political issue before an election but that he is concerned DBP has denied it happened as MPs should tell the truth.
* The pupil who does not recall the assault says he think he would have remembered someone being hit, but doesn’t recall much about that school camp
* evidence not as strong as for tennis ball and would need to be put to jury for credibility to be established

Overall

* The Police conclude the witnesses for both incidents are credible and reliable
* The Police say the appropriate charge would have been assault under S1196 of the Crimes Act as DBP had authority and control over the pupils and that this would be a major aggravating factor taking it outside common assault
* The Police also cite DBP’s complete denial of the allegations as an aggravating factor
* That the complainants just wanted acknowledgement that the incidents occurred and an apology
*Benson-Pope denies the incidents ever happened, agreeing they would both be assault. He claims all parties have been put up to this by Rodney Hide (impressive that Rodney can get 11 people to perjure themselves)

DPF’S views

Firstly I think there is really no doubt the tennis ball incident happened. Nine independent witnesses is well beyond what you can normally get for any sort of investigation. As the Police say this is very strong evidence.

I had always been puzzled about why this incident only happened once, if it happened, but it now makes sense reading all the affidavits. As usual DBP threw the ball at a student, but this time he clowned about and stuck it lightly into his mouth. DBP probably latched on thinking this was suitable and pushed it in further. And then when the student removed it, he thought no he had the right idea at the beginning and as a sort of joke pushed it back in and taped his hands to the desk to stop it being removed.

Incidentally the portrayal of the complainant as being a bully is not supported by almost all his classmates. They all remember him as being cheeky, a talker and getting in trouble but not a bully. I can relate to this as I often got caned at school for being a talker but I was certainly not a bully (esp as I was tiny). It’s also clear that there was no political motivation behind the complainant, and he only came forward after it was denied in Parliament. He was totally unaware DBP was an MP up until then as he lived in Australia.

The hit to the face is less clear-cut. The other complainant again did not want to make an issue of that, was only annoyed it was denied. He didn’t like the fact it was being used politically. The witness who recalls it is a huge fan of DBP and seems very credible also. However the other witness does not recall it at all, and it is more likely to be something you would recall. Also the complainant says that everyone at camp was talking about it, yet no-one else (bar one) can recall being told about it at the time. I think something did happen, but it may not have been as severe as the complainant recollects in terms of causing bleeding etc.

As I have said previously, I believe the Police were correct in not prosecuting. The passage of time is relevant in this case, and the alleged offending was not at the high end of the scale. However I don’t believe anyone can read that entire Police file and not conclude that the tennis ball incident at a minimum did happen, contrary to what Benson-Pope said in Parliament and to the Police.

Now one could give DBP the benefit of the doubt and say perhaps he just doesn’t remember them, being actions of no consequence. However he doesn’t allow one to conclude this as he is adamant that the actions described are totally wrong and reprehensible and hence this is why he never would have done them.

DBP also constantly refers in his police interview to the fact that no complaint was laid at the time, hence it must not have happened. I think he places far too much reliance on this, from personal experience. When I was a Scout we had a Scout Leader whose behaviour towards us was sometimes, umm, inappropriate. Nothing too serious, and we all liked him, so we never thought to say anything at the time. It was only after a couple of years when the behaviour became shall we say more eccentric that we decided we should have a word to another adult. It is quite common for kids not to go running to authority figures when something wrong happens, if it is at the lower end of the scale.

Anyway so overall the Police have got it right. There is clearly a prima facie case, and the witnesses have significant credibility. Once again DBP could have made this all go away by simply not denying it outright in the House.

UPDATE: NZPA beat me to getting a summary out, with this story on Stuff. TVNZ has a story also.

Best and Worst Jobs

Scott Adams (yes that one, the Dilbert creator) blogs on how the worst job in the world seems to be being No 3 in al-Qaida as for around the tenth time they have announced they have killed the third highest ranking al-Qaida leader.

He says in contrast the best job would be to be the guy who sits there playing Doom on his PC until he gets an e-mail saying

Leaking and Spinning

I’m not personally against leaking and spinning of government reports – let’s be real – that is part of the job to try and get favourable coverage of policies etc.

Where the line should be drawn though is not reports on policies and programmes but judicial type reports. David Benson-Pope has today been exposed as having selectively leaked the Police report into his actions to the HoS. And his office denying they had done so.

If a Minister wants to arrange a good story of a report saying that xyz educational programme has been well received, then go for it. But when you are the accused in a criminal investigation then do not use your press secretary to undermine the Police process. Likewise Clark was also wrong to use the SST to leak (incorrect) information against Peter Doone who was facing a criminal investigation also.

The bottom line is no problem with Ministers leaking reports that they are the authors of, or directly concern their portfolio area. But semi-judicial reports by the Police, Police Complaints Authority, the Auditor-General etc should not be leaked and spun to the media until the final official version is released.

Oh talking of spinning, Trevor Loudon has a naughty comparison to DBP. And no he is not seriously making a comparison, but the holing up in a bunker part is funny!

Canada Tax Cuts

Tax Cuts have become a key campaign issue this week with the Conservatives offering a cut in GST from 7% to 5% in response to the Liberals earlier announcement of income tax cuts.

And yes for those who missed that, the centre-left Liberals are cutting income tax. Most centre-left parties do – in Australia, US and UK – the left parties all support tax cuts. Common sense except for Dr Cullen who says $8 billion is not a large enough surplus.

Anyway why are the Conseratives pledging to cut GST rather than income tax? After all most economists say income taxes are better for the economy as they encourage people to earn more, while GST cuts more encourage people to spend more.

The reason is that the GST is despised in Canada, and I mean despised. This may be hard to comprehend in NZ where we have had GST for almost 20 years and many consumers don’t even realise it is there. But when the COnseratives introduced it in the early 90s the backlash was so servere, this is the main reason they went from around 139 seats to just 2 seats in Parliament.

But it gets better than that. The Liberal Finance Spokesperson campaigned in 1993 on a platform of abolishing GST. And they got elected on that platform, and reneged. It’s still there. And what role does that Finance Spokesperson have today? He is Liberal Prime Minister Paul Martin.

So this is very cunning by the Conservatives. There are dozens of quotes by Paul Martin on how evil and bad GST is. And now the Conservatives have come out announcing they will reduce it, it is impossible for the Liberals to condemn the policy with any credibility.

So in the first week of the campaign, the media are saying the Conservatives have done relatively well, and set the agenda for this week. However they have started a fair way behind and there is seven weeks to go, so they are most definitely still the underdogs.

Hamish McKenzie has a useful summary of the state of play in Canada also.

Sigh

The parody blog has announced it is closing down – probably because I suspect they got bored.

They are however lying when they claim it is due to “veiled threats of legal action”. I have made no such threat, and wouldn’t. If I objected to the site I wouldn’t have linked to it (ironically probably delivering 99% of its traffic). My only comment was that the humour was lame.

ICANN Composition

ICANN wraps up today and it has been a fairly lively meeting (Karl Auerbach has a summary of the public forum) with various controversial issues (such as the .xxx proposal) being debated. The number of attendees was relatively high at 740, and they come from 113 different countries and territories.

Some of the smaller or less developed countries here have included Afghanistan, Burkina Faso, Cayman Islands, Christmas Island, Cuba, Ethiopa, Faroe Islands, Gambia, Iran (12 people), Iraq, Israel, Niue, Serbia, Virgin Islands and Yemen.

Also of interest is that on the InternetNZ Blog we have a link to the letter sent from US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice to the European Union to persuade them not to support putting the Internet under some sort of UN governance.

The letter is very strongly worded for a diplomatic letter. The opening paragraph refers to “paramount importance to the United States” and “essential infrastructure” – this is code for we will be seriously fucked off if you stuff this up.

Then Rice goes onto say “We regret the recent positions on Internet governance offered by the European Union”. Regret is also a very strong word for diplomats. Much stronger than that and you are talking Pearl Harbour 🙂

The level of officials at the WSIS PrepCom would have been reasonably junior, and I understand the earlier EU position had not been endorsed by the appropriate EU body. This letter sent at Foreign Minister level would have, I suspect, resulted in a degree of bollocking of said officials for their earlier position.

Military Democracy

Claire Harvey in the NZ Herald is appalled that David Morris has said “The Army is not an institution which allows democratic discussion”, comparing the statement to the Nazis at Nuremberg or the My Lai massacure.

Now it goes without saying that following orders does not extend to illegal acts, but as long as the action is not illegal, then such orders are not subject to consensus, voting or even discussion. Harvey is beating up a story out of nothing. It is obvious the former judge was not suggesting that the necessity for obedience extends to illegal acts.

The famous line “We are here to preserve democracy, not practise it” always appeals to me.

Go Gordon Brown

Not normally a huge Gordon Brown fan, but how can one not applaud him as he proposes:

“that future EU farm policy include no price support, export refunds or other production or consumption subsidies”

The French will be besides themselves with rage with this proposal that farm subsidies be not just reduced but abolished. The farm subsidies take up 40% of the entire EU budget!

Saving TVNZ

Russell Brown has a copy of a speech by the head of South Pacific Pictures, John Barnett on TVNZ.

Unlike Russell who can’t say if he agree with the prescription for public broadcasting in New Zealand, I am happy to say what Barnett proposes would seem to me to be a huge improvement over the status quo. It’s a long speech but worth reading in full.

There seems to be an emerging consensus that the charter has been a disaster, especially when you consider that it is a state secret what programmes are actually prodiced as part of the charter, so the proposal that charter money simply be given to NZ on Air is sensible.

Job Vacancy

Do you believe:

* That free trade is evil and that it is better for third world workers to be unemployed

* That NZ should be non-aligned and not part of any western defence alliances

* That global warming is going to start destroying small island countries in a few years

* That the Treaty of Waitangi is a living spiritual partnership, and that Taniwha do have rights

* That dihydrate monooxide is potentially dangerous and possibly should be banned

* That there should be a size limit for easter eggs

If you score four out of six or better, I’ve got the perfect job for you! 🙂

Benson-Pope report out

The Police report into Benson-Pope is out tomorrow, but the friendly HoS has been shown a copy by the 9th floor in exchange for using the 9th floor spin about more pupils say they can’t recall it, than say they can.

Frankly when it comes to something that happened 20 years ago, the number of students who can’t recall it is irrelevant. The issue is how many people say that it did happen, and is there any grounds to suspect they are lying or mistaken.

Seven students have confirmed the tennis ball incident happened. This is why the Police concluded it did happen.

According to the HoS (and lets wait for the actual report) there are no witnesses to the allegation he struck a student in the face on a school camp. This is certainly the more serious charge, yet of course now the real issue is whether or not he lied a few months ago.

As with everyone else, I await the full report. Or should I say the almost-full report after the Police delete any portions the Cabinet Minister asks them to.

Kiwi Carnival is back

Trevor vs the Greens

Coddington on Hunt

Woodham on airline gender policy

Kerre Woodham has a good column on the issue. Apart from the usual stuff about how it is bad for children to be taught all men are dangerous, she also relates how some people have said that when they were kids travelling alone they preffered to be sated next to a man. The reason it seems is the guy will grunt once at you and leave you alone, while often the women will feel a need to be motherly and talk to you all flight.

It seems there is an obvious solution to this problem – let the parents decide. When booking or ticketing an unaccompanied child, just ask the parents if they have any preference for whom their child is seated next to, in terms of gender?

Woodham on airline gender policy

Kerre Woodham has a good column on the issue. Apart from the usual stuff about how it is bad for children to be taught all men are dangerous, she also relates how some people have said that when they were kids travelling alone they preffered to be sated next to a man. The reason it seems is the guy will grunt once at you and leave you alone, while often the women will feel a need to be motherly and talk to you all flight.

It seems there is an obvious solution to this problem – let the parents decide. When booking or ticketing an unaccompanied child, just ask the parents if they have any preference for whom their child is seated next to, in terms of gender?

Margaret Pope

The SST has a rare interview with Margaret Pope. Further extracts are here also.

Interesting aspects for me were:

* Her statement that Lange would probably have stayed married to Naomi, if he hadn’t met her

* The revelation that Lange became an alcoholic in his later years

Questions on hostages in Iraq

1) Isn’t it somewhat unwise to use the name “Christian Peacemakers” in a volatile dangerous Muslim dominated country?

2) Especially when you aren’t even a Christian!!

3) Isn’t it rather sad that the organisation they volunteer for hasn’t condemned the kidnappers?

4) And does insisting that no force can be used to rescue them, mean they will refuse to accompany any rescuers?

More PC

Wayne Mapp’s weekly newsletter has become much more fun to read since he was given PC eradication, as NZers around the country are helpfully sending him in examples.

This week we have listed:

* UNITECs requirement that campus bus drivers have to understand the importance of the Treaty of Waitangi. Yes that’s right the bus drivers!

* Health Boards refusing to give Plunket any details of new births, despite the fact they are required by law to be entered onto a public register

A 10 part quiz

I can never resist these things! Hat Tip: Jess

TEN FIRSTS

First Best Friend: Graeme McKenzie from Island Bay. Sadly lost contact after he moved north in 1978
First Screen Name: mouth of sauron (from when I worked for the dark lord)
First Pet: Minty who lived to 15 or so followed by Pickles who made her 20s. Both cats.
First Piercing: None thank God
First Crush: First proper one was Janette at university. First kid one was Jessica Taylor and Sandra Henkre at St Mark’s intermediate.
First CD Bought: God knows. Probably the Beatles.
First Car: Had a nifty fifty at university but first car was a Mazda 626.
First True Love: Anna (no not that one)
First Stuffed Animal: I was the proud possessor of nine koala bears, which my parents still hold in trust. Visitors were impressed a few weeks ago when we had them out for some kids, and I could still name most of the nine of them 🙂
First Words: Can’t recall, but as I didn’t start speaking until I was two I hope it was profound
First Game System: Can’t recall the name of the one which plugged into the TV but it was fun. Mainly played games on the BBC PC we had.

NINE LASTS

Last Alcoholic: A Coors Light last night
Last Movie Seen: Bewitched (on the plane)
Last CD Played: The Pogues
Last Bubble Bath: Bubbles are for girls.
Last Time You Cried: 25 November 2003
Last Time You Laughed: A few minutes ago when I read about atheists giving porn out for bibles
Last Time You Fell: On Sunday walking against a 40,000 crowd in Vancouver

EIGHT HAVE YOU EVERS

Have You Ever Dated One Of Your Best Friends: Yes. And still good friends.
Have You Ever Been Arrested: Yes.
Have You Ever Been Skinny Dipping: Only when I was skinny!
Have You Ever Been On TV: Several times
Have You Ever Regretted A Kiss: Oh shit yes.
Have You Ever Been Drunk: Not that often lately, but election night certainly qualified.
Have You Ever Slept For 24 Hours Straight: Yes
Have You Ever Worn the Same Pants for 3 Weeks Straight: No

(Remainder after the break)
Continue reading »

Porn for bibles scheme

Yes it’s true. A Texas university atheist group has set up an exchange scheme where “they gave free pornography to people who traded in religious scripture”.

That is very amusing. I wonder if a lot of bibles are going to go missing from hotel rooms.

Hat Tip: Boing Boing