Yet another contradiction!

We all recall that Winston and Helen justified his appointment as Foreign Minister, despite his opposition to NZ’s trade policy, by saying that the Foreign Minister isn’t involved in trade – we have a seperate Minister for that.

Yet yesterday Winston puts out a PR (from NZ First, not the Govt) talking about the wonderful things he did in the UK and says “good progress taking forward New Zealand

The Benson-Pope Report

The Beehive is already spinning the Benson-Pope report by the Police. They can get to spin it because Benson-Pope has delayed its publication by asking for changes, while at the same time giving copies to the 9th floor to spin.

They seem excited by the fact only nine out of 26 students can recall the incidents. Are they kidding – only nine??? It doesn’t matter if 1,000 students did not witness or can not recall them. Hell I can’t recall many incidents from 20 years ago. But if nine students have said they did happen, then no wonder the Police concluded they did. And again it is no surprise the accounts would differ somewhat – it would be a conspiracy if they all agreed exactly.

$30 million thanks Dad

There should be outrage over this. The daughter of the Te Wananga o Aotearoa CEO has made about $30 million through contracts with the wananga.

This is all ultimately taxpayer money – yours and mine.

Personally I don’t think anyone should be making $30 million out of taxpayer funded tertiary education contracts. You are paying way too much for the service if they are. But especially when your Daddy is the CEO, it is just outraegous.

Steve Maharey has a lot to answer for. This happened on his watch, and the unprecedented growth in funding to the wananaga should have rung warning bells. Instead of restricting its growth, they did the opposite and exempted it from the caps placed on other institutions.

One News presenters

The NZ Herald reports that Simon Dallow and Wendy Petrie will be the new 6.00 pm news presenters.

I hope that the move doesn’t mean we lose Dallow as an interviewer, as I have been a huge fan of Agenda. However I suspect for him one gets paid a bit more to present the main news every day than a weekly Saturday morning current affairs show!

Campaign Reviews

I was really pissed off when I realised I would be overseas on the day of Victoria University’s campiagn review conference. They hold one after every election and they are superb forums at which each party speaks surprisngly bluntly about what they did, what worked, what didn’t etc, plus contributions from some journalists and academics.

I should have asked Vic to web-cast it! They do publish a booklet of the day’s main speeches, so I will buy that at least.

In the best traditions of the conference, the NZ First contribution was very blunt and honest according to NZ Herald reports. Peters is seriously criticised for going dirty and negative on Bob Clarkson, as they beleive it hurt their nation-wide vote. MP Brian Donnelly also is quoted as saying “Winston has to find a way of sorting out a truce with the media, simply because we can’t go on with a Minister of Foreign Affairs in constant battle with the media.” Hope Brian doesn’t get charged with treason also!

Rodney Hide’s contribution is online, as is Colin James.

Kiwiblog Stats Nov 2005

Visits: 177,858
Pages: 894,451
MBs Traffic: 70,100

Interesting Search Terms:

1185 miss universe
470 la tomatina
464 david farrar
418 tomatina
235 condoms
227 antarctica
227 harry potter book seven
175 stag
120 stag party
117 luxembourg
111 police car
104 very funny pictures
89 reasons to stay in iraq
86 jenna-
77 hell on earth
62 political spectrum test
59 miss universe 2005
58 kiwiblog
56 police porn
52 political compass
31 lion sex
26 lipstick party
22 gracchi brothers
18 reasons to have sex
10 queef

UPDATE: Genius has done a blog post utilising all the above search terms!

Tauranga Electoral Petition

Well the petition is over, and we await the decision. The three Justices have indicated they had a statutory obligation to deliver their judgment quickly so hopefully we will find out the result before Parliament rises for the year.

The NZ Herald and Dom Post both have stories, and both seem to suggest that the Justices needed some convincing on some of the claims by Peters. However by alleging $100,000 of spending Peters only needs to win on one or two points and that may be enough to go over the $20,000 limit.

What I have found surprising is how so much of what Peters claimed they would do, they did not. Perhaps I missed it but didn’t they claim to have some secret witness from the Labour Party? And they talked about how they would cross-examine Clarkson but never even called him.

November 2005 NZ Blog Statistics

Not too many respones this month. But from those that did we have the number of posts and comments as:

Lite Bloggers

Left and Lefter 2 4

Medium Bloggers

Peter Metcalfe 10 2
Tumeke 14 35
Gonzo 19 5
Cattle Thief 23 7
Bloggreen Aotearoa 24 45
The Goodness 27

Heavy Bloggers

Philosphically Made 33 99
Liberty Scott 41 28
I hate socialism 42 79
Maria von Trapp 48 376
I see Red 51 167
The Whig 64 410
Clint Heine 68 137
Andrew Falloon 80 263

Stupid Bloggers

Silent Running 120 835
Not PC 138 360
No Right Turn 146 456
David Farrar 274 4253
Whoar 395

Australian Apples

As expected the Australian Government is still making it as difficult as possible for New Zealand to export apples to them – in breach of trade rules agreed upon.

This has been going on for decades. It’s time to actually show some backbone and refer the issue to the WTO as a formal complaint. Yes I know it may upset Australia a bit, but tough. They shouldn’t sign agreements they won’t adhere to.

The Death Penalty

Personally I don’t like the death penalty (even though I will shout hang the bastard at the TV from time to time, and that’s just during question time!), for a number of reasons.

The main one is the justice system does make mistakes, and corpses find it hard to appeal. But also I don’t like the state executing citizens, even after due process. If you can’t create life, then you probably shouldn’t terminate it.

But having said that I find it somewhat tiresome about all the outrage shown when as Asian country executes a foreigner rather than one of their own citizens. Yes I agree I would rather they didn’t, but they are free to make their own laws and my sympathy for those stupid enough to ignore the fact that a country has a mandatory dealth penalty for drug trafficking, is limited. Not totally unsympathetihc but very limited.

However Keith Locke is holding a silent vigil. And the Press is also outraged, as is the Dom Post.

UPDATE: To balance things up former United MP Marc Alexander defends the Singaporean justice system.

UPDATE2: Murray from SR has IM’s me links showing the the NZ violent crime rate is 1146 per 100,000 population while in Singapore it is 46 violent crimes per 100,000 population.

We have 20 times more violent crimes per capita than Singapore. Ouch.

MP Ratings

Trans-Tasman (published by press gallery veteran Ian Templeton) has published his annual ratings for all 121 MPs. The NZ Herald and Stuff have already done stories on some of the top and bottom placed people.

As always I like statistics, so here are some interesting stats:

2004 Average: 4.40
2005 Average: 4.43

Averages by Party (2004 in brackets)

Labour 4.45 (4.48)
National 4.53 (4.46)
NZ First 4.00 (4.07)
Green 3.92 (3.50)

I’ve only included parties with six or more MPs, and the 2004 average is only for those MPs which were returned to Parliament.

If we exclude new MPs (those not there in 2004) the average for each major party is:

Labour 4.51
National 4.98

The top ranked MPs are:

1 Clark (Lab) – 9
2 English (Nat) – 8
3= Brash (Nat)

Axe the Carbon Tax campaign launched

National has launched a campaign to axe the carbon tax, including a dedicated website.

The site says that the tax will cost the following:
* Petrol up 6c/l
* Electricity up 6%
* Food up 1.3%
* Disel up 7c/l
* Gas up 7%
* Public Transport up 1.4%

3/10

Nov Blog Stats

Now’s that confusing. It’s still November in Vancouver but it is now December back in NZ. Anyway better stick to NZDT so any NZ blogs who want to be included in the monthly stats please send me your count for posts and comments to the [email protected] e-mail address.

A Xmas Canadian Election

The Canadian Parliament has thoughtfully sacked the Government the day after I arrived in Vancouver. This has been coming for a while, so it was nice they held off until I could watch it on 24 hour cable news.

Now Virginia may want to know why there is going to be an election in January 2006 when one wasn’t required until 2009.

The answer is simple. Corruption. And no not the minor stuff like baubles of office, but the real deal. The Liberal Party (centre-left) Government spent $250 million on a sponsorship programme in Quebec, meant to promote staying with Canada. However up to $100 million of this money which to advertising agencies, sometimes for work billed not performed, and then some of that money was allegedly donated back to the Liberal Party. This really happened it seems. It wasn’t just a suggestion such as a senior NZ Labour Party official made in the late 1980s, but it actually happened according to witnesses under oath.

Now the current Canadian Parliament has 133 Liberal MPs, 98 Conservative, 43 from Quebec Separatists and 18 from the (left wing) New Democrats. These are the four major parties. The Greens also stand in all seats, but not even Canadians are that stupid, and they have no seats. They do have a Sex Party though 🙂

Now the Government almost fell a few months ago, but in a stunning betrayal a woman called Belinda Stronach defected from Conservatives to Liberals on May 17. She had been a contender for the leadership of the Conservatives so this was not a junior MP. She quickly was appointed as a Minister and this move was seen as opportunistic to say the least.

So the Government held on for a few more months but finally the New Democrats voted with the Conservatives to bring the Government down saying they had lost their moral mandate to govern. A no confidence vote passed 171 to 133. It is the first Canadian Government to lose a confidence vote – a couple of others had lost confidence but called an election before being sacked.

So what will happen? Well you would think the Liberals would be toast but despite all this, there is a good chance the Liberal Party will form the next Government. The Conservative Party is easily demonised by aligning them with Bush (fatal in Canada) and for many years they have been divided. The last election was the first one which had the right wing parties standing under one banner, and in 1993 they got reduced from 169 MPs to just two MPs!

The latest polls show the Libs around 5% ahead. However this is FPP, so it will come down to marginal seats and a poll did show 54% think the Government should change.

A smart young girl

Peters on Foreign Affairs in 1996

The Listener has done well, digging up this quote from Winston Peters in 1996:

When this magazine asked him, before the 1996 election, if he would take the Foreign Affairs post, he was frank: “You could only assume that if you thought I was stupid.” At the time, he indicated that the portfolio was not very demanding. “After all, if Warren Cooper can be Minister of Foreign Affairs, anyone in New Zealand can be.”

Indeed, anyone can and is.

Hat Tip: Amelia

How many Police was that?

Do you remember John Tamihere saying that he was in awe of Michael Cullen’s ability to change just a single word in an agreement with a coalition partner, and it could totally undermine what the partner thought they were getting.

Well looks like he has done it again. NZ First thought they were getting 1,000 frontline police staff, while it seems the agreement may just be for 1,000 more people employed by Police which could mean 1,000 more civilians sitting behind speed cameras.

From the sublime to the ridiculous

The latest twist in the men are not allowed next to children on planes issue is that a Motueka man has climbed up a ten metre high tree and is refusing to come down until the airlines review the policies.

Air NZ I am sure will announce a review shortly but if he is waiting for Qantas to change their policy, he may be up there for a long long time!

UPDATE: Dr Helen (also known as the Insta-Wife) has a lively thread going on the issue.

P-less

More DBP lies

David Benson-Pope seems to be subscribing to the school of thought which is “Why tell the truth, when a lie will suffice?”

Last week he cowered away from the House, and said it was because he did not think there would be any questions for him – a claim not even a moron would believe.

And now this week he is still cowering away, so timid and scared that he can’t even face a select committee. And his reason for not fronting up is because he claims it is the Chief Executive’s job.

As G-Man has pointed out, it is not just normal practice for the Minister and the Chief Executive to front up, it is almost unheard of for the Minister not to be there.

UPDATE: Some readers have made the point, which is not unreasonable, that when it is a financial review, not an estimate, it is less common for a Minister to attend. Standing Orders do not clarify that this is the case. Of course DBP could still choose to front and get the issue dealt with. Instead I am sure his Chief Exec will just have to fend off all the questions by themselves on his behalf.

UPDATE2: The Dominion Post reports that Benson-Pope’s predecessor, Steve Maharey, did attend the Select Committee with his Chief Executive for two of the last three times.

Just end it and stop the misery

How long will Helen and Winston cling to the pretence of what they have cobbled together as being a workable arrangement? Today we read that the European Parliament MEPs were asking Clark to explain the roles, saying they can’t understand it. Yeah well join the group.

And can someone give Helen a prize for Orwellian doublespeak as she keeps referring to the arrangement where we have a Foreign Minister claiming not to be part of the Government as an “innovation”. If that’s an innovation, then so is bird flu!

Let’s quote one European MEP:

“The position he stands for is diametrically against the position you’ve adopted for six years. Many people in Europe don’t understand that.”

Yep. Winston claims his biggest priority is repairing the relationship with the US. Helen says there is no problem to be repaired.

Uniting the political spectrum

Air NZ and Qantas have managed the near impossible – uniting the politicial spectrum to declare they are a bunch of idiots.

Not only do you have the Greens and National both declaring how stupid it is to ban men being seated next to children on flights, one has offended men and women almost equally. The number of women who have declared that just because they have ovaries doesn’t mean they should have to be landed with kids next to them is matched by the men who really are rather offended at the suggestion they are unsafe.

Keith Locke hs referred the issue to the Human Rights Commission, and it wil be interesting to hear their response. Hopefully more sensible than the Children’s Commissioner.

The NZ Herald has a round-up of reader reaction and it is 90% negative. NZPA also has reaction from others.

Tauranga Electoral Petition

The Tauranga electoral petition outcome will be very interesting. Not just for Bob Clarkson, but for all those involved in campaigns as the current law is notoriously hard to interpret and the court judgement will hopefully provide some clarity.

As the NZ Herald reports it may come down to whether materials include donated services.

Interestingly even if it is found Clarkson over-spent, the Judge has said that Peters has to prove that the over-spending was deliberate for Clarkson to be found guilty of corrupt practices and the election voided.

Common Sense

It’s good to see that Jim Sutton has got over his hissy fit over Tim Groser standing for National, and has included Tim in his delegation to world trade talks as an advisor.

Good to see National and Labour working together to advance our trade interests. Now all Labour has to do is to get their Foreign Minister to also support the Government on this issue 🙂