Somewhat farcical

Speaker Wilson has already rejected Rodney Hide’s request to refer Benson-Pope to the Privileges Committee in some circular reasoning.

On 7 June she rejected a referral saying there was no evidence of a question of privilege. She said however “I am, of course, prepared to look at any material which may be put before me in the future in regard to this matter.”

But now there is considerable new material with the Police report, she says “The matter of which you complain (an alleged misleading of the House on 12 May 2005) was raised at the time and was dealt with by me then”

So if you raise an issue at the earliest opportunity it gets ruled out for lack of evidence. If one decided not to raise the issue until say the Police report had been published, it would then be ruled out for not raising it at the earliest opportunity.

The equivalent is say that I walk down a street with a new Ipod and video-phone device. And Miss Ten mugs me and steals my Ipod off me. I go to the Police and they say she denies it, so they don’t charge her.

Then a few months later it emerges a CCTV camera captured the theft on film, and I take it along to the Police. They then say “Sorry we have already investigated this case, and we can’t re-investigate it”.

It’s somewhat of a farce, isn’t it?

Digital TV threat to survival of TVNZ

The Government has been told TVNZ faces possible extinction if it does not move to a digital platform.

Hmmn I am sure TVNZ in fact had plans to do just that. Almost certain they did. So why haven’t they?

Oh that’s right – because the Government refused to allow them!!

Governments often make very bad owners as they look at the short-term piolitics, not the long-term strategy.

Cullen maths is faulty

Dr Cullen claims that one is disadvanataged by getting a refund of your voluntary loan repayment as one still will pay interest on it until 1 April.

This is true but fails to note it is a trivial amount compared to what you can make. 4 months interest at 7% on $15,000 is $350.

However Mr Banfield may have that $15,000 for a long time to earn money off. We don’t know how much his total loan balance is, but let’s assume he had paid off his entire loan, and that he earns $51,000 a year.

His compulsory repaymenys would be around $300 a month. It would take 50 months to pay back the loan now. If he gets 6% gross interest which is 4% net interest then on average he will get $1,250 which is a gain of $900. Not bad cash for nothing.

This is the worst case scenario. If for example Banfield had another $15,000 owing on his loan and only earns $40,000 a year then he would have full benefit of the $15,000 for around seven years and partial benefit for a further seven years. Yep sure he would have pay rises in that time, but for simplicity sake if he did earn $40,000 he would gain around $6,000 in interest over time.

Bullshit

Benson-Pope doesn’t do himself any favours by telling such obvious porkies, as the one below. It doesn’t exactly add to his credibility over the wider abuse issue.

This particular issue is trivial, but the lie is blatant. Benson-Pope says the reason he chose to have lunch with John Cleese rather than turn up to Parliament is because he “did not realise a question from Mrs Collins about the effect poor childhood experiences had later in life would develop into questions about the allegations”

This frankly is a lie. No-one is that stupid or naive, and he shows his total contempt for others by such a bald-faced lie.

Let me explain a bit about how Ministerial office prepare for questions. When they get a copy of the questions, shortly after 10.30 am, staff and officials go to work preparing answers for any possible situation. Ministers know that innocuous questions are always designed to go somewhere to attack them or the Government, and the fun challenge is working out what the angle is. Normally not hard – you look at recent media stories and OIA or PQ releases and it is obvious.

Now even Martha the part-time tea lady could work out that the day after the Police report into Benson-Pope having hit a student in the face was the real issue behind the question by Judith Collins about poor childhood experiences. The possibility the Minister did not work it out is zero. Less than zero. Way less than zero.

Now it’s a small issue compared to the abuse allegations. But it shows a Minister who simply tells lies without compunction. And hence when you consider the wider allegations, then why the hell should one believe him there because sure as hell if someone will tell a lie about a small issue, you won’t get the truth on a big issue!

He could have even won sympathy if he had told the truth and said given a choice between lunch with John Cleese and seeing MPs wave tennis balls around the chamber, he thinks he made the call anyone else would make. But instead he lied.

15,000 leaky homes

Another reason to love Wikipedia

Tory Leadership Blog

For the hard core politicos like me who are following the UK Tory Leadership election, a great resource is this blog dedicated to covering the election.

They do reports from each of the 11 hustings meetings. One from Frimley is here, and also a new one from London. You even get the details of the Q&As.

Cameron still looks favourite to win. The contest has been relatively good natured, which is sensible as presumably the loser will want to be in the shadow cabinet of the winner.

Nicky Watson Dating Chain

Finally

Southpark on Scientology

The latest Southpark episode was on Stan joining the Church of Scientology, and being deemed to be the reincarnation of founder L Ron Hubbard.

The hilarious part though was involving Tom Cruise. Stan told Tim he didn’t think Tom was that great an actor so Tom cried and went into Stan’s closet to hide.

Most of the episode was then taken up with dozens of different people urging Tom Cruise to come out of the closet. It was just hilarious. The polar opposite of subtle.

I have to say I had no idea how wacky Scientology really is. Southpark showed secret beliefs of an alien called Xenu and aliens being frozen and dumped in volcanos so their souls could be brainwashed and confuse future generations of human beings, seventy million years later. They kept flashing on the screen “This is what Scientologists actually believe”.

A great episode.

More on Benson-Pope decision

Further to yesterday, my thoughts are:

1) The Police made the right decision not to prosecute

It is hard to disagree that given the combination of time lapsed and relatively low level of the alleged offending, that a prosecution would not serve the public interest. Worth noting however that a 20 year time lapse does not stop prosecutions for more serious crimes.

2) The Police are inconsistent

The Police prosecution of Shane Ardern over Myrtle the Tractor was a huge mistake. They persisted with this stupid prosecution until even the Judge basically said Piss off, and stop wasting my time with such a trivial matter. Kiwi Pundit highlights a trend in inconsistencies.

3) The Police do take inappropriate information into account

First of all, it simply is not the case that Ministers are treated no differently to anyone else. Senior Police are very very aware that charging a Minister (or MP) with a crime punishable by over two years jail will mean that Minister (or MP) will be automatically expelled from Parliament if found guilty, no matter what actual sentence is given.

In this particular case, the Police reference to the Minister’s high profile probably being why the matter surfaced the way it did is inappropriate, considering the Police were convinced the allegations were correct.

4) Benson-Pope refutes the Police findings

The Police have said they believe the allegations are correct and did happen. Benson-Pope in his press release says he still does not accept the allegations have substance, because the allegations were not made at the time.

While what Benson-Pope is nowhere near as serious as say sexual abuse, his general line of defence does not hold up in sexual abuse or rape cases, and nor should it here.

Benson-Pope also distorts the Police findings by saying the Police has found the allegations warrant no further action. He fails to acknowledge he did anything at all wrong, and that the Police did find they believe he broke the law.

Even the PM sort of apologised for Paintergate in that she acknowledge what happened and said she won’t do it again. Benson-Pope is showing a nasty side by continuing to deny this. Perhaps he should ask to be charged so he can test his denials in court?

5) The PM’s response is somewhat inappropriate

The PM is quoted in the NZ Herald as saying she welcomed the decision. She should not welcome the fact that the Police have said a Minister of the Crown did the things his former pupils accuse him of.

Having said that, I don’t regard Benson-Pope’s behaviour 22 years ago as grounds for dismissal from his Ministerial roles, now he no longer has education. As Rodney Hide said months ago though, Benson-Pope could never again be credible as Schools Minister. This has probably also killed off his chances of succeeding Clark.

6) Wilson should refer Benson-Pope to the Privileges Committee

If rumour is correct, no less than 19 former pupils have testified that the behaviour Benson-Pope denied (or refuted) in Parliament, did actually happen. If that does not qualify for a referral to the Privileges Committee, I don’t know what could. The release of the full Police report will aid any decision making by the Speaker.

The Privileges Committee has 13 members on it, with the composition being:

National 4
Labour 4
United 1
Maori 1 (Hone Harawira – they do have a sense of humour)
ACT 1
NZ First 1
Green 1

Labour has only 4 out of 13 MPs, so Wilson will be under massive pressure from Labour not to refer the issue, knowing if they find he lied to Parliament, he might have to resign as an MP and trigger a by-election.

But if Wilson does not refer it, her credibility with the Opposition, and the public, could be seriously dented.

Colin Espiner’s Blog

Greens vote for Government

Somewhat strange – NZPA reports the Government has won its first confidence vote 67 to 50 which has the Greens voting in favour and the Maori Party abstaining.

Yet the Greens had previously said they would abstain on confidence issues, after Labour shafted them in negotiations by making Winston and Peter Ministers, but not the Greens.

So why did the Greens vote in favour after indicating they would abstain?

Tamihere’s Utu

John Tamihere has managed to get elected back onto the board of the Waipareira Trust.

This seems to be motivated by revenge on some current trustees, and I suspect that the Trust is in for many years of infighting, which almost inevitably will undermine any good work it does.

Maybe JT should be looking forwards not backwards?

Quick students and graduates act now

Okay if you are a student or graduate with a student loan and you have made any voluntary repayments at all in the last six months, send off a request TODAY to the IRD to get the money back.

The kind people in National have highlighted the loophole that one can ask for a refund of any voluntary repayments receipted within the last six months. And with interest free loans, one can make money by getting IRD to hand the money back, and sticking it in an interest bearing bank account.

As the transcript of the House below shows Dr Cullen was totally unaware of this, but may act to close it down soon. So act quick. After all the Government campaigned on the interest free loans policy so they want you to benefit from it.

Dr Don Brash: Is the Minister aware that section 56 of the Student Loan Scheme Act 1992 permits student loan borrowers who have made voluntary repayments to request a refund of those repayments, up to 6 months after the Inland Revenue Department issues receipts for them; if so, does he think the Government

Benson-Pope gets the Paintergate treatment

As I predicted a few days ago, the Police have given David Benson-Pope the Paintergate treatment by declaring they think he did break the law and they can prove it, but that they do not think it is in the public interest to prosecute him.

However charging Shane Ardern for driving a tractor up some steps was!!

The Police press release is on Scoop.

However Benson-Pope is not out of the woods. He said in Parliament that the allegations were all false. The Police have basically said they believe the allegations were true including that Benson-Pope struck a student in the face. This should at the very least merit a referral to the Privileges Committee from the Speaker for lying to Parliament.

Gary Moore on Telecom

The afternoon Speakers were generally more technical, focused on how to make things happen, and how to apply for funds. The exception was an amusing speech from Christchurch Mayor Garry Moore.

Garry is quoted in the Dominion Post on Monday as saying existing capacity in Christchurch is “pathetic” and that Telecom has “a lot to answer for”.

That was the diplomatic version of Garry Moore. The blunt version was at the conference when he said “Oh yes and Telecom, may they rot in hell for-ever”.

I personally don’t have any issues with Telecom, in that they are acting as they are required to by law – to maximise returns for their shareholders. And they are very good at it.

My issues is with the setup of the infrastructure which has one company controlling so much of the infrastructure. The solutions are not bashing up Telecom, but making sure we have an environment where competition can flourish. Having said that I am not at all shy about forcefully disagreeing with Telecom on specific issues. In fact not shy about forcefully disagreeing with anyone on any issue 🙂

Message for Tony Randle

Bit Torrent and MPAA agreement

Boing Boing has the details of a joint press conference between formerly arch enemies Bit Torrent and the Motion Picture Association of America.

Sounds fairly sensible, and I like the direction for the future they talk about of having “movie files be protected against piracy and sold via online payment system to users of its P2P application”.

The presentation at today’s digital cities conference from Sweden talked about how those at high end broadband can now download a 4.7GB in 50 seconds. By comparison it would take 18 days on dialup! That’s what I want – the ability to pay for a movie or TV show and 50 seconds later have it ready to play at home.

Happy 25th Risawn

Mannequin Sex

Q: Why did the man have sex with a mannequin?

A: He just thought she was British 🙂

And that may be the defence in this US case where a man was arrested after being found “with his pants and underclothing down and lying next to the half-naked female mannequin”.

The gentleman, wonderfully named Plentyhorse, was described by the Police as having charmed the mannequin: “There was inappropriate activity between him and the mannequin. That

Peters following Thai lead?

Dean Knight has suggested that Winston warning the media he won’t tolerate anymore questions he doesn’t approve of, as being inspired by the Thai Prime Minister who has said “he will not answer reporters’ questions until next year because the alignment of the planets is not in his favor”.

Heh, one can’t rule Winston out from trying to blame it on the alignment of Mercury also!

Digital Cities Conference so far

The Digital Cities conference has been very good so far. There are well over 100 people here with almost every major local body represented plus many from industry.

Fran Wilde has been excellent as Chair, telling local bodies they need to treat this as core infrastructure and talking about the successful public/private partnership in Wellington which led to Citylink. Kerry Prendergast also spoke on the Wellington example.

David Cunliffe gave a very good speech highlighting the funds Government is making available for local bodies to use as part of the broadband challenge. He took questions for an extended session and demonstrated good commitment to making this happen, while realising that this is still a modest start.

Southland District Mayor Frana Cardno spoke on the work they are doing in NZ’s largest (by land area) territorial authority.

The highlight to date has been Richard Naylor, Citylink’s founder. He spoke about their corporate policy of:

These rules are for the guidance of Officers and the binding of fools

and also his views of roads:

The road is just a temporary cover for underground services!

Priceless.

Ernie Newman from TUANZ has just made the point that fibre is to a country today what roads and railways were 100 years ago.

Wasteful Spending

Good to see the Opposition not wasting time in exposing the ongoing waste of so much money by Government. Three examples just in today’s newspapers:

* $10,000 of health funding on rugby tickets, and how the Minister had known for six months about it.

* IRD paying almost three times its current rent in Christchurch because the landlord is politically embarrassing.

* And $750,000 of government and council funds on a conference which only 10 – 15 people paid the full fee to attend!

A $40 billion organisation is always going to be less diligent with its spending than households will be. That is why giving households some of their money back is a good thing.

Catholic Values

Glad to see that sex before marriage is now a more important value in Catholicism than forgiveness, acceptance or compassion. Michelle McCusker was fired from her job as a preschool teacher after she got pregnant without being married.

Can’t imagine that the preschool will have a hope in hell of winning the case saying that it was a justifiable dismissal. Firing someone for having sex before marriage just reeks of the dark ages.

The attorney for Ms McCusker makes a great point though – how do you tell if male employees are having sex before marriage?