National and the Treaty

Both the NZ Herald and the Dom Post have articles today suggesting that National’s new MPs might lead to a change of policy on Maori and treaty issues.

They’re both right and wrong šŸ™‚

I don’t expect that core National policies such as one law for all, and removing treaty principles from most legislation will change. Likewise neither do I expect any change to opposition to the introduction of Maori only wards for local bodies.

However I think one will see more of a focus on the positives NZ has from Maori culture, the Treaty, land and fisheries settlements etc.

As well as getting two new Maori MPs in Tau Henare and Paula Bennett, National also has new MPs Chris Finlayson and Chris Tremain who have significant experience or background in Maori and Treaty issues. Chris Finlayson used to be Ngai Tahu’s lawyer.

You have been warned

Disloyal questions will not be tolerated of the Foreign Minister. A spokesperson said “the minister would not tolerate a repeat of the questioning he received at Apec”.

To save time I have compiled a list of acceptable questions, for journalists to ask the Foreign Minister not in Government:

(1) How did the meeting go, and are you happy with the outcomes
(2) There is no (2)

The Press has obviosuly not received the new Government guidelines on what sort os stories to write about the Foreign Minister, and in their editorial labels the Government set-up as a farce. Read the editorial in full, it touches on all the issues.

Government cunning plan to cope with prison space crisis

NZ Muslims

Terrific to see a decent jail term for the Dunedin man who abused a Muslim woman at a bus-stop, and then followed her to a book-store. Such behaviour is repulsive.

More difficult is the issue of Muslims complaining they are enduring longer inspections at airports. While it would be wrong to have a blanket policy to target everyone of a particular group, it is near inevitable that profiling would include a greater number of Muslims. Just as young single men have traditionally also usually attracted greater attention from border control agencies.

Less controversial, and praise-worthy, is the proposal for local Muslim associations to vet new members, to minimise the possibility of infiltration from radical or criminal factions.

Ministers first

The revelation that if there is a birdflu pandemic, Ministers would have priority access to the anti-viral Tamiflu should be no surprise, and indeed in my opinion it is justified.

As much as my libertarian streak likes the idea of no Government, the reality is that the last thing you need during a crisis is a non-functioning Government. Hence why they also have a civil defence shelter in the Beehive.

Green Bashing

Insolent Prick brands the Greens as “a socialist brand that tries to hide its real agenda behind the caring, sharing, friendly face of conservation and protection of resources” and decries Nicky Hager’s comments at Rod Donald’s memorial.

More scholarly, but no less damning, is Trevor Loudon who chronicles the career of Keith Locke in two parts. The summary is:

* Involved with League for Socialist action, a Trotskite Group
* In August 1970 he addressed Wellington Radical Activists Congress, arguing for Trotskyism at the session “Maoism or Trotskyism, which way for the revolution in New Zealand?”
* Labour unsuccessfully tried to expel Locke as a member in 1974
* April 1975 Locke wrote a lead article for Socialist Action under the banner heading: “Cambodia Liberated: Victory For Humanity” The “liberators”
* In 1976 said “Capitalism cannot be trusted with nuclear power. . . socialism . . . would step up nuclear power research in order to make it safe”
* February 21st 1980 Locke gave a talk in Wellington “Why Workers Should Support Soviet Action in Afghanistan.”
* October 1983 Locke signed a letter to US President Reagan protesting at the invasion (ie liberation) of Grenada
* National co-ordinator of the Philippines Solidarity Network whose role was to provide solidarity for the Maoist insurgency in the Philippines.

He has been a busy boy!

OIA Study

My bedtime reading is an excellent 51 page study of how the Official Information Act is working by Steven Price. Steven has included qualitative (interviews with journalists and officials) and quantitative research (last 10 OIA requests per agency).

The interviews with journalists show how badly sections of the Government treat the OIA.

The breakdown of requesters is interesting. It is:

Political (MPs and staff) 23%
Private Individuals 20%
Media 19%
Academic 10%
Lobby Groups 10%
Lawyers 9%
Companies 9%

Average processing time was 13 working days. Around 12% exceeded the 20 day deadline. Four agencies had an *average* response time of greater than the maximum 20 days. 40% of agencies had at least one overdue request.

In terms of refusals 41% of requests were declined or had information partially with-held. This is much higher than what one would expect in my opinion and Price documents many examples of what appears to be incorrect refusals.

In summary Price finds that overall the OIA is proving beneficial but that:

More than twenty years after the passage of the OIA, agencies have little excuse for these sorts of mistakes. Taken together, they seriously compromise the OIA’s ability to fulfil its constitutional role of promoting accountability, participation and good government.

Digital Cities Conference

May not be much blogging during the day tomorrow as I will be at the Digital Cities Conference. Of course as it is being held in an already digital city, I should be online thansk to Cafenet.

The programme looks very good. This is about getting serious broadband infrastructure into cities. They keynote speaker is Lars Hedberg the founderof the Swedish Urban Network Association. He was in the NZ Herald today.

Maiden Speech Quote

A slack treason trial

More maiden speeches

Six more maiden speeches today. The final Maori Party MP followed by Chester Borrows, Chris Tremain, Chris Auchinvole, Nicky Wagner and Craig Foss.

Ross Browne has an extract from Richard Prebble’s Letter where he rates some of the maiden speeches. Chris Finlayson is rated best speech to date and also Parliament’s best lawyer.

Happy 30th Cathy

Maggie threatened Mitterrand with nukes!!

Amazing story in The Sunday Times (thanks AF for the pointer) about revelation from the former President Mitterrand’s counsellor.

He reveals that during the Falklands War Mrs Thatcher told Mitterrand that she might nuke Argentina unless Mitterrand handed over the codes to render useless the missiles the French had sold to Argentina.

No wonder Mitterrand said that Thatcher had “the eyes of Caligula and the mouth of Marilyn Monroe”. He goes on to say “You can

Anna’s final post

Dom Post lets loose

The Dominion Post shows its displeasure at Winston Peters accusing media who criticise him as treasonous by labelling him the “Sun King of Tauranga” and suggesting that if Zimbabwe had not been made unwelcome at CHOGM, Peters and Mugabe could swap notes on what constitutes treason and how to deal with disloyal media.

While most people back home are laughing at Peters, and treating the issue as a joke (or the Minister as one anyway), it is worth reflecting on how this looks overseas. I mean if I read in a newspaper that a senior Minister is threatening the media with treason charges, I tend to think banana republic. And the story has already made Australian media.

Dive students

It is good that the number of taxpayer funded places on diving courses has dropped to around 400. It did get as high as 1,200.

But why is it not zero? What rationale is there at all for a diving course to be treated as education instead of leisure? Who not also have the taxpayer fund gym memberships?

Medians not Means

The Police have said that the reason the average 111 response time has increased from 11 minutes to 15 minutes is because of one call which was never closed off, and wasn’t actually urgent.

This problem could be solved by using the median, instead of the mean as the average. In fact the median is arguably more useful a measure. Medians don’t get distorted by extremes at either end.

Even feathered birds can’t refer to birds

Sandra Coney is upset about a public transport ad which has a cartoon Pokeno, Maxx, saying “there were some nice birds” in town.

Yes really.

The interesting thing is that the ad had been vetted as acceptable by the ARTA’s comms and marketing team – all of whom are women, and the ad was designed by a woman.

So all those nasty women are letting the sisterhood down. Shame! šŸ™‚

Clark misses the point

It is becoming apparent that the Government has at all thought carefully about how having a “independent” Foreign Minister will work.

Clark today is reported as saying that Peters is bound by collective responsibility on issues such as defence and trade policy in his role as Foreign Minister. But he isn’t – he has quite clearly said he does not support the trade policy of the Government.

The reason Downer and others are asking about the role of Peters, is because they will be trying to figure out what point there is in meeting a Foreign Minister who basically does not represent the NZ Government except in a very limited sphere of issues.

When you deal with Condi Rice, you have no doubt she is speaking on behalf of the United States of America. None at all. Likewise no doubt that Jack Straw speaks for the UK Government.

But a Foreign Minister who is not even a member of the Cabinet External Affairs Committee? What would you talk about – the weather?

The Dominion Post also points out that Clark and Cullen have both contradicted Peters on his request to Australia to help with the US relationship. So who does Downer listen to – the PM or the Foreign Minister?

UPDATE: And in another example this story which has Peters indicating New Zealand troops could extend their tour of duty in Afghanistan and the government might increase troop numbers but Clark contradicting him and saying this was not under consideration. Right hand and left hand do not seem to be talking to each other.

Third of men 70-plus ‘still have sex’

Marriage Bill

United Future’s Marriage (Gender Clarification) Amendment Bill will come up for a vote shortly.

It is a strange bill as it seeks to define the law as “a marriage must be one
man and one woman” which is already the law as ruled by the Courts.

Are United Future worried that there is a loophole which allows a man to marry his pet rabbits? Or that a woman might have three husbands?

Of course what United Future is worried about is gay marriage. Now it is quite legitimate to have a view that marriage should retain its traditional definition, but even if one does, this bill is unnecessary. It will not stop a future Parliament changing the law.

Tony Milne predicts that the bill will be defeated, unless National doesn’t allow MPs a conscience vote on the issue (which would be highly surprising).

Frankly Parliament has enough important legislation to take ups it time, that throwing this out at the first reading would in my opinion be a good move. It might be different if there was a lack of clarity over the current law, but the Courts have very explicitly already said that the current law does not allow gay marriage.

Baublewatch

As previously mentioned, the NZ Herald has started a baublewatch column, with the initial entries being:

1. Base salary up from $120,000 as a minor party leader to $171,600 for minister outside Cabinet.

2. Access to ministerial cars.

3. Qualifies for a VIP diplomatic passport.

4. Overseas trips to Korea (last week) and Malta and the UK (this week).

5. A trophy photograph for his wall of him in the background of an international line-up with US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice.

Another one they can add on is:

6. Around $1 million in funding (total is $23 million for all offices) for his ministerial office, including around 10 extra staff.

2006 Netguide Awards

The 2006 Netguide Awards are now open for voting. This year they will be decided purely on votes received, rather than a judge’s panel.

To quote Mayor Daley, vote early and vote often šŸ™‚

UPDATE: Nick E points out “…the winning Web site in each category will be decided by public votes OR by NetGuide choosing the winner in the category from the five sites that recorded the highest number of votes”

Winston goes mad

Ve vill listen to the ReichMinister. He has majestically proclaimed it is now TREASON to criticise our beloved leader, who represents the Reich but is not part of the Reich.

Virst up for re-education camps are the NZ Herald who are flouting the vegulations for the purity of political veporting with their new baublewatch column. THEY ARE TRAITORS ALL OF THEM.

Road Pricing

Good to see the Ministry of Transport raising the issue of road charges to help fund the building and maintenance of roads.

Users of roads should pay for them. In the absence of the technology, petrol tax is an adequate but not entirely satisfactory alternative.

Rates are, in my opinion, an entirely inappropriate method to fund roads.