Economic Confidence Plummets

One News had a poll a few minutes ago. They have National 4% ahead of Labour, but NBR on Friday had Labour just ahead. Personally I don’t think there has been much movement politically for any party since the election except sympathy support for the Greens.

The huge change though has been economic optimism vs pessimism. Before the election it was 51% to 28% or a net 23% positive. It is now 24% vs 42% or a net 18% negative.

A 41% movement in net economic optimism is gigantic. The good times may be about to end.

Also of interest is John Key registering 5% as preferred PM. For an unprompted question this is a very good result, and reflects no doubt his good performance over the campaign.

Update on Aaron’s ironman for cystic fibrosis

People may recall Aaron Fleming who has spent most of the last few months training for the 2006 Ironman as a way to raise funds for the Cystic Fibrosis Association of New Zealand.

You can read about why Aaron is doing it on his website, and can contribute – he is currently at almost $3,000. Aaron will also be on TV One Good Morning on Monday at around 10.35 am.

Mediawatch

Jeremy G asks why mediawatch is never critical of National Radio. Are they perfect?

I’m more wondering if it is time to declare their website dead, as it has not been updated since January!

I must say though that I do absolutely love the new Radio NZ website. Being able to listen to shows like Mediawatch if I miss them at the time is great. And also having as separate files each segment of larger shows like Linda Clark’s is great. I can look for interesting items and just play those.

Green Co-Leader Gender Debate

I’ve blogged a couple of times that the requirement in the Greens constitution for their two co-leaders to be opposite genders seems to be causing more problems than it solves, and why would you have such a requirement?

Frog Blog has entered the debate, and generated a lively thread. There’s a good mixture of comments there.

Frog says that “gender is the most fundamental *difference* between people and a key physical identifier that everybody shares.” I say this is bollocks and part of the left’s problem that they see people as part of a group, rather than individuals.

Richard from Philosophy etc makes the excellent point that “Gender is not the most fundamental difference between people. I share a lot more in common with a well-educated female philosophy student than I do a senile fundamentalist male.”

He concludes that what the Greens need is “With the loss of Rod, you need another pragmatist, not another penis”

Richard also goes on to say that asserting that gender is a fundamental difference between people, is the sort of prejudging of individuals which 120 years ago was used to justify not giving women the vote!

To use a bloggers example of this gender co-leadership requirement, let us imagine all the bloggers were a party, and we wanted two co-leaders who complemented each other, rather than were similar to each other.

Well under the gender requirement you might have Cathy Odgers and Insolent Prick as co-leaders. One would not be allowed to have Spanner and Cathy Odgers [previously said IP by mistake] despite the fact they would be more complementary.

Top 10 PC words for 2005

The Global Language Monitor has published their 2005 top politically correct words for 2005.

The winner is the BBC’s use of “misguided criminals” for “terrorists”. “Thought Shower” for “Brainstorm” is 3rd.

No 5 might come from NZ – the use of “out of the mainstream” to describe the ideology of political opponents!

“Deferred Success” for “Failure” is No 6.

And from our neighbours down under we have at No 10 the Australian Parliamentary Service banning use of the word “mate”

3-403

Both parties in the US have wings which they would be better off without. The Republicans have the fundamentalist religious right and the Democrats have the fundamentalist anti-war (or moveon.org) faction.

The decision to go to war in Iraq was and will remain a controversial one. The failure to find WMDs did weaken the case significantly, and very reasonable people can disagree on whether the decision to topple Saddam was the right one.

However the issue of whether the US should simply just pull out immediately is quite another matter. Almost any rational person knows that this would be a disaster and doom Iraq. They are not yet ready to police their own country, and a democratically elected Iraqi Parliament has said they don’t want the forces to leave yet.

However back in the US, the fundamentalist faction of the anti-war groups have been calling for immediate withdrawal. And more and more Democrats have been forced to humour them, as they need their support. And the big shock came last week when a US Democratic Congressman, previously seen as a hawk, called for immediate withdrawal (he now claims it was within six months).

The Republicans, who have been stuffing up so much recently they will deserve any electoral pounding they get, finally did something smart and played the bluff.

They tabled a resolution calling for immediate withdrawal. A brilliant strategy that forced those who wanted to play both sides, to actually make a call. And the resolution was defeated 3-403.

Now for the excitable out there, please remember this post is not about whether the war is right or wrong. Or about whether Bush lied, or about Karl Rove being the most evil man alive. It is about what is the best way forward from here for Iraq.

For my 2c I am hoping troop withdrawals can begin in 2006 and be completed in a couple of years. But there are a hell of a lot of variables that make it impossible to give firm dates this far out.

Osama bin Laden’s demands

As previously mentioned, many have the misguided belief that if Israel moved their fence a few metres, or the Iraq war had never happened, then Osama bin Laden would not be attacking civilians.

Well someone has gone through his published statements and found that the summary of what he wants is:

“The United States to convert to Islam, ditch its constitution, abolish banks, jail homosexuals, bar women from appearing in the press and sign the Kyoto climate change treaty.”

Tim Blair notes it’s that last one which is the deal breaker 🙂

Dating website lawsuits

Two interesting lawsuits at the moment against dating websites.

Match.com is being sued for allegedly hiring people to send bogus romantic e-mails and even sending their staff out on sham dates as a marketing ploy. I wonder how much the staff get paid for that!

Yahoo Dating is more boring. They are simply accused of inventing profiles!

Deborah on Winston

Deborah Coddington has done some nice research on previous statements by Winston Peters on immigrants and Asian students. This is in light of Winston now saying he wants more Chinese students in NZ. Deborah catalogues how Winston has said previously:

* Immigrants are necrophiliacs, triple murderers, rapists, fraudsters or HIV carriers

* New Zealanders were witnessing – nay encouraging – the Balkanisation of their own country

* Chinese students were responsible for “theft, fraud, fighting, assault, intimidation, vehicle crashes, disorder, domestic stabbings and a sideline of extortion and weapon-carrying

Tauranga

A fascinating reference in Audrey Young’s column that even if Winston wins his electoral petition against Bob Clarkson, he might not stand in any by-election.

I had been discussing that possibility with various people recently. You see I think there is a very significant possibility that Peters would not win if there was a by-election. And the humiliation of losing his seat twice would be too much to bear.

Hopefully of course the electoral petition will not succeed.

Goff need to talk to Clark

Having helped stuff up APEC for Peters, Goff has come home to plead that people are nicer to Winston (otherwise Winston will sulk).

Goff blames journalists for daring to report his stuff-ups, and the NZ Herald wonderfully allows Fran O’Sullivan to fisk him in reply.

If Phil Goff wants to stop people undermining Winston, he needs to talk to Helen Clark who today said “There had been no need to discuss improving relations between the two countries [NZ and US] as they were in a healthy state” which directly undermines Peters who says improving the relationship is his number one foreign policy goal.

I’m sorry but this is like amateur hour. The PM and the Foreign Minister can’t even agree on the most basic questions of foreign policy. And as Audrey Young shows in her column, Phil Goff has also created many of the problems.

Finally also read Fran’s column which gives a good over-view of it all.

10 km/hr tolerance gone

The disaster that was APEC

Even being generous, it is hard to regard APEC, Winston’s first outing as foreign minister, as anything but an unmitigated disaster. And not because Winston himself is incapable of doing a reasonable job, but because Clark and Peters have come up with a new system of executive government which is so bizarre it was inevitable it would cause problems.

Let’s look at today’s stories alone:

* Goff has had to apologise to Peters and reassure him he isn’t trying to undermine him.
* Goff has had to reassure Australia that “policy from Winston will be not policies spun off the top of anybody’s head but the policy of the Labour-led Government”. Not even I would blame Winston for being insulted by that.
* Goff told Winston the remarks were untrue, and he denied making them. When told by the NZ Herald the remarks were on the record, Peters said “You’d better have it on tape”. The Herald with incredible (and deserved) smugness responds “The Herald does”. Heh.
* Revelation that Peters’s staff are making fools of themselves desperately trying to see if anyone has a photo of Peters shaking hands with Condoleezza Rice. That’s all they want – the photo op.
* Dr Cullen pours scorn on Winston asking Australia to help us with our relationship with the US, saying “he would rather Australia supported New Zealand’s bid to host the Rugby World Cup”.
* References to Peters being like a mother-in-law. Despite Cullen trying to claim he likes his mother-in-law, no-one in NZ believes this was a compliment.
* Cullen saying that Goff would be keeping a close eye on the portfolio, implying Peters is not trusted

I have long studied Winston’s behaviour and psychology. He will be seething with rage at all this bad publicity and insults. It could be a very rough ride if he goes feral.

Benson-Pope case

When I linked to Whale Oil’s list of inquiries and reports we are still awaiting, some lefties claimed it was wrong, as David Benson-Pope had been cleared by the Police over assault allegations.

However the Police say a decision is due next week. And if Rodney Hide is correct, 19 students have backed up the allegations.

It will be very interesting what happens. The Police may do a paintergate and say they believe crimes were committed, but that it is not in the public interest to prosecute.

No more student happy hours

Some killjoys have killed off a very old and welcome tradition – cheap happy hour drinks at student bars. Yes it is now illegal to offer cheap drinks in case, shock horror, it encourages students to drink too much!

Next it will be illegal for fast food operators to offer to upsize meals, as it may encourage over-eating.

And then Sue Kedgely will suceed in banning chocolate easter bunnies over a certain size.

Interfering pricks, all of them.

Maiden Speeches Day III

Tax Increases

Treasury recommends a reduction in some taxes, and the Government rules it out immediately.

Social Development Ministry recommends an increase in some taxes, and the Minister says “I’m open-minded on these issues”.

Tax is a one way highway for this Government.

UPDATE: The Dom Post Editorial flays Cullen for shooting messengers and labelling the Treasury advice as a “three-yearly ideological burp”, pointing out he hailed Treasury’s 2002 briefing papers as “high-quality and pragmatic analysis”. It is disgraceful he shits on his own Department if they dare to give advice he doesn’t agree with.

The Press also wades in calling Cullen’s response deja vu Muldoon.

Also Insolent Prick wonders what all the pro-tax spin doctors in MSD do. To be fair to MSD they have shown some common sense by recommending part-time work-testing of DPB recipients once their children are at school. That has of course been ruled out immediately. Only tax increase are worth considering further.

And the final insult comes from Dr Cullen. You remember those miserly derisory tax cuts he promised for 2008. The chewing gum ones. Well he has threatened to cancel them, if they don’t get to implement their new carbon tax. United Future is furious, as they have been humiliated having won a review as part of their agreement.

So Dr Cullen is saying a $8 billion surplus is not enough to even afford a 67c a week tax cut in three years, unless they can whack us with the carbon tax.

Congratulations NZRFU

Well I am amazed but delighted that NZRFU has won the rights to host the 2011 rugby world cup. That is a huge coup.

Having believed the conventional wisdom that NZ had no chance at all, I had even said that NZRFU should withdraw. Damn pleased to be so wrong, along with all the sports betting agencies.

And yes well done to all the bid team, including Helen Clark. They really have done well to win it against almost all expectations.

Maiden Speech Transcripts

I am in meetings later this afternoon so will sadly miss today’s maiden speeches. However National has put online the maiden speeches of Paula Bennett, Chris Finlayson, Bob Clarkson and Tim Groser. All good reads. As I have said previously the chance to make thoughtful contributions can be all too rare in Parliament, which is why I like maiden speeches so much.

Media calls

Came out of a 90 minute meeting yesterday to find three messages on my phone – all from media. One from TVNZ, one from Radio NZ and one from Herald on Sunday.

My immediate thought is “What’s happened?”

My next thought is “It wasn’t me, whatever it is”

My third thought is “Can I deny or delete it”

However calling them all back, each call was on a totally different issue or subject. Weird coincidence.

Kiwiblog by E_mail!

One can now get a daily dose of Kiwiblog, delivered by e-mail. Why? Well like PC who I stole this from, I don’t know if there is anyone out there who can’t use the web, but hey a daily e-mail works well for Public Address, so worth a try.

I am using Feed Blitz. To subscribe to this blog just scroll down the left-hand side to just below the recent comments. Enter in your e-mail address, and after you click on a link in a confirmation e-mail you’re subscribed.

Now does this mean if I blog 12 times a day, you’ll get swamped with 12 e-mails? No you get just one e-mail with an extract and link to each item I have posted since the last e-mail. So it may be useful for those who just want to check our particular items.

Fun in Parliament

Various stupidities

First of all we have Nick Eynon at Three Point Turn who says:

This renewed call from Treasury to cut taxes is a little out of date don’t ya think?
Didn’t we just have an election a couple of months ago centred on this very issue?
Team Tax Cut lost. Get over it.

Okay Nick, now you may have missed this but Government Departments are obliged to offer their honest advice to an incoming Government. As much as you might want them to lie, that is not desirable.

Let me use an analogy. If National won the election, would you really demand that Te Puni Kokiri in its briefing says “We think the Government should abolish the Maori seats, scrap our department, and get rid of treaty principles in legislation?

Then we have Frog Blog excited because naughty Nandor not just got to mention the Treaty when taking the oath, but wow we he didn’t really take it back and he also made reference to “the people of Aotearoa” which not even the Maori Party did.

I’m sorry but grow up. Who gives a f***. Oh dear we are more Maori than the Maori Party because our non Maori MP used the word Aotearoa!

Incidentially as a Republican I support changing the oath, but there is a process for changing it.

Then we have the About Town crew who think they are really really smart because they did a double dupe. Umm no. You simply lied. Any moron can tell a lie, and because most people will believe someone until given cause not to, of course some people will believe a lie. April 1 is the honourable exception to the rule.

A clever dupe has elements of truth to it. A good example is Random Contributionz who used a real life event (the protests at the Aussie HC) to classify it as a terror test. That was very well done.

Perspectives on terrorism

Crikey yesterday said that the likelihood of a Westerner dying from jihadist violence is around 0.0001%, while the annual probability of an Australian dying of smoking-related causes is 0.1% and Americans are almost nine times more likely to die falling off a ladder than in a terrorist attack.

Hence they lambast the media for having headlines such as “Stockpile of chemicals found in shopping mall”.

I think Crikey fundamentally misses the point. Terrorism has never ever just been about death tolls. It is inane to use that as a focus. Terrorism is about how it affects society and human behaviour. Two bombings in Bali, and that place is now a pariah for many tourists for years to come.

To somehow suggest that the media should not give more prominence to an alleged plot to kill as many people as possible, perhaps by blowing up a local nuclear power plant, than they do to the road toll is ridiculous.

The Press has a good editorial on the issue today. They remind us that the police role in terrorism is dramatically different to traditional crime. Traditionally police apprehend perpetrators after the crime. When it comes to terrorism the challenge is prevent the crime in the first place. Especially when it is 95% likely the perpetrators will be dead themselves. And yes that is why we do need to give the Police and intelligence agencies more powers (but not unlimited – the 90 days detention without trial Blair wanted was too much). Because if we don’t, their role will simply be to tell us afterwards how it happened.

Maiden Speeches Day II

Got the final seat in the gallery for Pita Sharples’ maiden speech. Some good common sense there. At the end his supporters in the Gallery rose and did a thundering waiata and haka. It was very cool to see such passion about having got him into Parliament.

Then we had Maryan Street. I thought she was the best of the four new Labour MPs, even though she got annoying with it being an inaugural, not a maiden speech. Good God – let’s also lobby the ICC to ban the term from cricket, why not.

Paula Bennett’s speech I loved. It was so personal and about her and her life. She spoke about her pride in being Maori, her pride in also being European but most of all her pride in being a New Zealander. Also how she became a solo mother at 18, and how proud she is of her daughter (who was in the gallery) who is also now 18.

Labour’s Darien Fenton spoke. I have to admit I didn’t listen that closely to the Labour ones. She mentioned unions a lot, as another Labour MP did yesterday.

Chris Finlayson’s speech was a great pleasure. Chris was a very successful lawyer and orator before becoming an MP, and showed it in the House. He wonderfully managed to praise and insult Margaret Wilson at the same time (by saying he hoped we would not be losing her as Speaker to become a Supreme Court judge) and bitch-slapped Michael Cullen not once, but three times. Each time by praising one of Dr Cullen’s colleagues such as congratulating David Parker on being appointed Attorney-General and say he looks forward to some good law reform now that we have a lawyer as Attorney-General, not a former history teacher 🙂

Chris also spoke on an issue dear to my heart – about how National has inherited both a liberal and a conservative heritage from the parties which formed us in 1936, and that liberalism and conservatism can work together to produce great outcomes, rejecting that liberalism somehow belongs to the left. Like Chris I am proud to be a liberal conservative!

Then we had Bob Clarkson. Bob was Bob. He detailed his life from his first business deal aged 8, to deciding to stand for Parliament. His line of “When I was 30 I got married,” Mr Clarkson told Parliament. “After 11 years I asked my wife what she wanted for Christmas and she said a divorce. I wasn’t thinking of something quite so expensive.” absolutely brought the house down. I could see Don Brash almost falling out of his chair with laughter. Bob also got in a nice line or two about how Peters threw everything at him, yet he still won and Winston lost.

Again as the speeches are placed on Hansard, I’ll link to them. Interestingly I noted that the Hansard staff were not actually writing anything down during the maidens. I suppose because you don’t have interjections, they can rely on the MP’s supplied speech notes as being a full transcript.