InternetNZ Blog

InternetNZ has set up a blog which various councillors and staff will be regularly posting to, so those interested in Internet policy issues may find it useful.

I will still continue to post on some Internet issues on this blog, but more regular posts will be made on the InteretNZ blog, on a wider range of issues.

Rugby World Cup Bid

I wonder if the NZRFU wouldn’t be better off to withdraw its bid for the 2011 Rugby World Cup. It appears impossible to win, with the only speculation being whether it will be South Africa or Japan.

Certainly it is nothing like the London vs Paris Olympics bid where last minute lobbying by heads of government won it for London. Especially when your head of government has said she would rather read a book than watch a game of rugby.

The recent outreach tour by the NZRFU didn’t produce a single firm pledge to vote for us. We may only get one vote in favour!

A bad employer

Just getting more ridiculous

I thought I was being a bit harsh when I suggested Winston’s only job is to appoint and receive Ambassadors. But it appears not.

The PM has revealed that our Foreign Minister will not only not chair (as is traditional) the Cabinet external relations and defence committee, but he won’t even be a member of it!!!

So we now have a Foreign Minister who won’t even regularly participate in setting Government policy on foreign affairs.

UPDATE: No Right Turn agrees

Peters back to his old self

Winston Peters has a history over 20 years of allegations which range from wildy exagerrated to simply fabricated. Even as recent as this campaign he defamed an Iraqi who lives in NZ by falsely claiming he was formerly in Saddam’s presidential guard – no apology was ever made, or mistake even admitted to.

Now his latest nasty foray is his claim that if National keep picking on him and NZ First, he would reveal how “backers gave donations in exchange for a slice of state-owned companies if National won”.

Let’s be very clear about this. Peters is alleging corruption of the first order. Yet he says he will only reveal this corruption if National “potted” any of his MPs while he was away. A small step away from blackmail. If Peters really has even a shred of evidence on such an issue, he is obliged to refer it to the Police, not say I will keep it quiet unless you aren’t nice to me.

I should also point out that National’s policy this election had (sadly) almost no sale of SOEs at all. A minority float of Solid Energy and a few Landcorp farms.

Aaron’s Auckland Top Ten

Inside Fairfax Blog

Simon Power

Select Committees

The Clerk’s Office now has the list of select committee members online. Much better format than previously with all one the one page. Would be useful to show party affiliations thought for those who don’t know all 120 MPs.

Both ACT and National are asking for a select committee inquiry into TVNZ. ACT are asking the Finance & Expenditure Select Committee and National the Commerce Select Committee.

You need 6/11 in favour on F&E. As well as Hide, one presumes Foss, Key, Smith L and Tremain will vote in favour. They need one more vote – either Copeland or Doug Woolerton. Now both Dunne and Peters do not like TVNZ so will they allow their people to vote in favour?

On Commerce you need 5/9 in favour. Auchinvole, Rich, Tremain and Wong again in favour with Copeland being the sole swing vote.

If Labour can’t block an inquiry, I expect they will vote in favour also, so it doesn’t look like a defeat.

Possibly National has already talked to Copeland and got him on board with an agreement to do it theorugh Commerce, not F&E as ACT wants. Why would they do that? Presumably because Commerce has Katherine Rich as Chair so she can hold witnesses to account better.

Safe Birthing

I almost wept when I read this article in the SST about how some babies die because some midwives have an ideological objection to vaginal examinations during birthing.

I could do a rant about the wider politics of what has happened with maternity care – successive Governments have driven off thousands of GPs from maternity services so that only 30 GPs in NZ continue to provide maternity services. A tragedy – but a story for another day.

But let’s turn to the CEO of the College of Midwives who has said “Maori women found the checks particularly intrusive, as that part of their body was tapu”.

What politically correct horseshit. Before I rant on this further let me point out the correct attitude by a Hutt Valley mid-wife who treats all clients as individuals and has said “It’s so negotiable – We negotiate with each client and talk about the pros and cons.”

So anyway is the CEO of the College of Midwives saying that only Maori women find that part of their body as sacred? And non-Maori do not? Is she saying there is some objective research which has actually asked women, broken down by ethnicity, about what parts of their body they regard as tapu or sacred? Or is she just making it up?

Bearing in mind this is not an area that directly affects me (and no doubt some will decry that I dare to comment on the issue) I would suggest that pretty much all women, regardless of ethnicity, don’t care for examinations there, unless it is medically necessary.

So no-one misunderstands, I have no view at all on whether a mother should consent to such examinations as part of birth. I have a very strong view on the inappropriateness of a midwife not allowing a mother to make that decision because they have an ideological disagreement with it. And I have a strong view on the stupidity of making sweeping statements that (not some, or many, but presumably all) Maori women consider something tapu. I’d love to see the research backing up that statement.

UPDATE: This story is also worth reading.

A stupid doctor

I wonder how stupid you have to be to think that under any circumstances it is a good idea to take a photo of your genitals and upload it to your work (hospital) computer so you can e-mail it around.

Less serious in my view is the old joke e-mail where your friends think it is a calendar of hot babes, and after the first page they turn out to be 90 year olds. I’ve even seen the male version where it looks like pin-up hunky guys dressed as half naked firefigthers etc and then the rest are very old, very wrinkeled and very maked guys. Heh and the person who sent that one to me is a female over 60!

Looking up for tertiary

To date the comments from Dr Cullen on the tertiary funding model have seemed sensible. And the new TEC CEO, Janice Shiner, also seems to be saying the right things.

I hope they can follow through and repair the sector from the disaster Maharey left it as. I’ll praise them if they do.

Now that’s a bad date!

71 MPs for tax cuts

Immigration Consistency

I swear that trying to understand the internal thought processes of the Immigration bureaucracy is challenging to say the least. I especially have problems trying to understand the consistency of these two cases:

Person A was charged with conspiring to committ a kidnapping. He was found guilty. This is a very very serious crime. He was sentenced to prison. The Deportation Review Tribunal has said he is okay to stay in New Zealand, despite not being a citizen.

Person B has never been found guility of any crime. In face he has never been charged with any crime. He has not even been arrested. His ‘crime’ is involvement 15 years or so ago with a US publication that has been ruled objectionable. The level of involvement is hotly disputed as ranging from having been interviewed for it, to being its publisher. I do not want a repeat of the debate on that issue.

What I fail to understand, is how a convicted kidnapper can possibly be deemed suitable to stay in NZ, if the criteria are so strict in other cases?

Treaty tests for immigrants

Selling out already

I’m dismayed that Peter Dunne has said his party will vote in favour of the obnoxious keep Winstons’ caucus together (party hopping revivial) bill.

He voted against it in 2000. It is the exact same law. No doubt he has been pressured from Labour to vote for it to keep Winston happy. So sad to sell out so cheaply.

Agenda

Went to the Agenda website this morning to get the transcripts from yesterday with Don Brash. They’re not there yet, but will be worth a read once they appear.

However the transcript of 5 November, which I missed, is interesting – specifically the interview with John Barnett – one of NZ’s most prolific producers, and follow-up comments. AMongst the gems are:

“The board is not appointed from its knowledge it’s appointed by gender, geography, friends of the minister, political favours”

“Well I personally think the thing should be sold, I don

Whoops

Free Speech thanks to DPF

Outgoing VUWSA President Jeremy Greenbrook blogged today that incoming President Nick Kelly asked him to withdraw a comment Jeremy made regarding the 2006 executive. Jeremy goes on to say some platitudes about the various members of the 2006 Executive.

His original post is on his presidential blog and we see a “cencered (sic) by incoming president” on it.

Unfortunately both Nick and Jeremy seem to have forgotten about Google’s cache. Now this will disappear in a few days, but for the sake of free speech, I report the unedited words below:

Nick Kelly has been elected VUWSA President for 2006. He will be fine – he’s been on exec as long as I have – but I am worried about his executive. With only the odd exception they seem like a bunch of Muppetts.

Now I think muppetts (sic) are cute. Hell some days I’d love to be called a muppet. Talking of muppets I’ve just read that there will be a parody of America’s Next Top Model called America’s Next Muppet. Heh.

Anyway Fozzie Bear was a cool muppet. If I was a muppet I would want to be Fozzie.

Donald & Tanczos

Well how many people knew of viral myocarditis before yesterday. Sounds like that it would have been highly unlikely for anyone to have guessed this is what Rod Donald had. Nevertheless I still think there is a lesson for many in making sure you see a doctor if you are sick, and don’t know what is wrong.

The replacement of Donald with Nandor has generated considerable discussion. Even on Frog Blog, the comments have been mixed, and in the NZ Herald John Armstrong calls the decision “so obviously the wrong one”

I’m actually feeling rather sorry for Nandor in all this. There would have been celebrations if he had made it in on special votes, but coming in this way is hard. However having said that, he did himself no favours labelling Parliament a toxic hell-hole yesterday. That’s an awful attitude to take to the place – if you hate it that much you don’t have to be there. The world will survive without you.

Keating on Whitlam Crisis

Yesterday was the 30th anniversary of the sacking of Aussie PM Gough Whitlam by Governor-General Sir John Kerr.

Crikey‘s daily e-mail alerted me to the revelation by Paul Keating (a later Aussie Treasurer and PM) that his advice to Whitlam had been to put the Governor-General under house arrest!!

Me thinks Mark Latham is not the only former Leader to be a bit reckless.

Keating seems to have over-looked that you need to charge someone with a crime to arrest them, and also the furthe rpoint that it is highly debatable that the Police can arrest the head of state. Commentators talked to by Crikey said they though the Police would refuse such an order from the PM.

Please stop calling names

Regular readers of mccully.co will be aware of the inventive names in the newsletter, for targets of Murray’s displeasure.

For reasons unknown, the States Services Commissioner has written to McCully asking him to please stop making up names for top civil servants, specifically to stop referring to Labour Secretary Dr James Buwalda as Dr Bewildered. I am surprised Mark Prebble would think this would have any effect except to publicise the nickname more.

Dr Prebble does have a point, that generally one should not attack civil servants without cause – one should go for their Ministers. And I do have to say from my time in Government I was very impressed with the professionalism and dedication of the many public seravnts I had dealings with, not least of all Dr Prebble.

However when there are specific actions of a civil servant which are lacking, it is a different matter. And McCully does have genuine grievance against the Labour Department who did an whitewash of the lie in unison affair, which the Ombudsmen’s office blew apart.

I wonder what sort of criticism the State Services Commissioner finds more inappropriate. McCully attacking a department head on a specific issue, or the Leader of the Opposition attacking a depertment head for what was perceived as his general ideologicial bent, and all but stating that he should not have been appointed?

For those with short memories, the Leader of the Opposition was Helen Clark, and the department head she attacked was Mark Prebble when he was appointed as head of DPMC. Not for any particular reason but just because she thought he was part of the “new right”.

Another reasom why TVNZ should be sold

The outcry from TVNZ staff about both their shareholding Ministers dumping on them and saying TV3 is doing a far better job, is just yet another reason why politicians should not own media outlets.

And yet another reason is the potential for mischief with Michael Cullen’s comments that TVNZ News should be more upbeat. I think it is a concern when the person who can decide how much charter funding TVNZ gets, is basically hinting that things well go better for TVNZ if they have more good news stories in their news bulletins. Naturally the Deputy Prime Minister would want to the news to be all happy every day – hence another reason TVNZ should be sold.

Golden Handshakes

People will recall Helen Clark campaigning in 1999 on an end to golden handshakes. Well Heather Roy has published a useful list of ones since then. They include:

TVNZ Chief Executive (Ian Fraser) – $420,000
Families Commission Chief Executive (Claire Austen) – $50,000
NZQA Chief Executive (Karen van Rooyen) – $50,000
NZ Post General Manager (Robert Lake) – $208,858
NZ Police Commissioner (Peter Doone) – $137,500
Airways Corporation Legal Counsel (Ezequiel Trumper) – $160,000
Transend Managing Director (Drew Stein) – $80,000
Healthlink South Chief Executive (Jane Parfitt) – $265,000
Victoria University Vice-Chancellor (Michael Irving) – $420,000