Donald & Tanczos

Well how many people knew of viral myocarditis before yesterday. Sounds like that it would have been highly unlikely for anyone to have guessed this is what Rod Donald had. Nevertheless I still think there is a lesson for many in making sure you see a doctor if you are sick, and don’t know what is wrong.

The replacement of Donald with Nandor has generated considerable discussion. Even on Frog Blog, the comments have been mixed, and in the NZ Herald John Armstrong calls the decision “so obviously the wrong one”

I’m actually feeling rather sorry for Nandor in all this. There would have been celebrations if he had made it in on special votes, but coming in this way is hard. However having said that, he did himself no favours labelling Parliament a toxic hell-hole yesterday. That’s an awful attitude to take to the place – if you hate it that much you don’t have to be there. The world will survive without you.

Keating on Whitlam Crisis

Yesterday was the 30th anniversary of the sacking of Aussie PM Gough Whitlam by Governor-General Sir John Kerr.

Crikey‘s daily e-mail alerted me to the revelation by Paul Keating (a later Aussie Treasurer and PM) that his advice to Whitlam had been to put the Governor-General under house arrest!!

Me thinks Mark Latham is not the only former Leader to be a bit reckless.

Keating seems to have over-looked that you need to charge someone with a crime to arrest them, and also the furthe rpoint that it is highly debatable that the Police can arrest the head of state. Commentators talked to by Crikey said they though the Police would refuse such an order from the PM.

Please stop calling names

Regular readers of mccully.co will be aware of the inventive names in the newsletter, for targets of Murray’s displeasure.

For reasons unknown, the States Services Commissioner has written to McCully asking him to please stop making up names for top civil servants, specifically to stop referring to Labour Secretary Dr James Buwalda as Dr Bewildered. I am surprised Mark Prebble would think this would have any effect except to publicise the nickname more.

Dr Prebble does have a point, that generally one should not attack civil servants without cause – one should go for their Ministers. And I do have to say from my time in Government I was very impressed with the professionalism and dedication of the many public seravnts I had dealings with, not least of all Dr Prebble.

However when there are specific actions of a civil servant which are lacking, it is a different matter. And McCully does have genuine grievance against the Labour Department who did an whitewash of the lie in unison affair, which the Ombudsmen’s office blew apart.

I wonder what sort of criticism the State Services Commissioner finds more inappropriate. McCully attacking a department head on a specific issue, or the Leader of the Opposition attacking a depertment head for what was perceived as his general ideologicial bent, and all but stating that he should not have been appointed?

For those with short memories, the Leader of the Opposition was Helen Clark, and the department head she attacked was Mark Prebble when he was appointed as head of DPMC. Not for any particular reason but just because she thought he was part of the “new right”.

Another reasom why TVNZ should be sold

The outcry from TVNZ staff about both their shareholding Ministers dumping on them and saying TV3 is doing a far better job, is just yet another reason why politicians should not own media outlets.

And yet another reason is the potential for mischief with Michael Cullen’s comments that TVNZ News should be more upbeat. I think it is a concern when the person who can decide how much charter funding TVNZ gets, is basically hinting that things well go better for TVNZ if they have more good news stories in their news bulletins. Naturally the Deputy Prime Minister would want to the news to be all happy every day – hence another reason TVNZ should be sold.

Golden Handshakes

People will recall Helen Clark campaigning in 1999 on an end to golden handshakes. Well Heather Roy has published a useful list of ones since then. They include:

TVNZ Chief Executive (Ian Fraser) – $420,000
Families Commission Chief Executive (Claire Austen) – $50,000
NZQA Chief Executive (Karen van Rooyen) – $50,000
NZ Post General Manager (Robert Lake) – $208,858
NZ Police Commissioner (Peter Doone) – $137,500
Airways Corporation Legal Counsel (Ezequiel Trumper) – $160,000
Transend Managing Director (Drew Stein) – $80,000
Healthlink South Chief Executive (Jane Parfitt) – $265,000
Victoria University Vice-Chancellor (Michael Irving) – $420,000

Who left their phone on?

Maria is looking to sulk, unless I link to this blog piece about the MP who allegedly left their cellphone on during the funeral!

Personally I get paranoid about my phone going off during events like funerals. I worry that somehow I might knock it in such a way that it turns back on, so I actually remove the battery from the phone and stick it in another pocket (that way the phone can’t reassemble itself just to embarrass me).

Panic over inflation?

The Reserve Bank and the Government seem to be close to panic over inflation. They seem to have realised they have allowed inflation to get too high, and waited too long in taking action.

Hence their proposals yesterday to start interfering with banks operations. To say the proposals have had a luke warm reception would be gross under-statement.

John Key said the proposals risk “a complete implosion of the economy”.

ANZ National chief economist John McDermott said the moves looked “absolutely insane”.

David Tripe of Massey University’s banking studies centre said the options had the “face of Muldoon all over them”

Personally I agree with David Tripe that not even the Government is this stupid that they would try to return us to Muldoonism. But you can never say never.

Yay – protest at my place

The un-PC Dr Cullen

I’ve long suspected that Dr Cullen is not very politically correct. His razor-sharp sense of humour suggests a man not afraid to cause offence.

He has confirmed this with a wonderful quote as part of his tribute to David Lange:

“He could say some awful things sometimes about people. His love-hate relationship with the Labour Women’s Council was a wonder to behold and gave some of us with similar mixed non-PC feelings a great deal of pleasure and joy over a number of years.”

He said he couldn’t talk about it often, particularly in the Prime Minister’s presence, but she had left the House by the time he spoke.

Heh this is really very funny.

Another power list

The Claytons Foreign Minister

It is becoming obvious that Winston has got the baubles of power, but no actual power. He seems to be heading towards becoming a Claytons Foreign Minister.

When anything important happens internationally, Helen is over it. She has a PR out on the Jordanian bombings, and there is nothing from Winston. Helen even refers to MFAT advice so is clearly working with them bypassing Winston.

Meanwhile Phil Goff as Defence (not Foreign) Minister has pronounced ANZUS as dead and irrelevant. This is a massive intrusion into foreiegn policy, and makes Winston’s pledge of improving US relations much harder by using such blunt language.

So what have they left Winston to do as Foreign Minister? He gets to meet Ambassadors and appoints them. That’s it!

Boy would I be pissed off if I was a NZ First MP.

Unemployment

The fall in the unemployment rate to 3.4% is excellent, and as much as one can debate around the edges issues such as definition of unemployed (it has been contsant fro decades) and how much is due to the incumbent Government, one can’t argue against having the lowesr rate on the OECD and the lowest in NZ’s recent history.

The economy has been very strong – so strong in fact it is remarkable the recent election was so close. If I was in a Government with a 3.4% unemployment rate I’d be looking to win by 5% to 10%.

It is useful to look at the issue of free trade and employment in the NZ context. The Greens, unions and a few misguided supporters claim free trade destroys jobs and is bad for a country, hence we need to have tariffs etc to protect jobs.

Well NZ has almost the least amount of protectionism in the world. Only a very few number of industries have tariffs and they are now very small and insignificant. Yet we have the lowest unemployment in the world basically. Hmmn the lowest level of protection and the lowest unemployment. Sorts of destroys the arguments from the Greens and friends. And do we even need to look at the unemployment rate in countries like France with huge levels of protectionism?

Nandor’s back

As expected, Nandor Tanczos has announced he will accept the vacant seat in Parliament. I expect he will be sworn in on Tuesday.

This means that if the co-leader is to be within Parliament it will be either Keith Locke or Nandor. They won’t decide this for a few months though, and I still pick it will be someone not in Parliament.

Treaty Legitimacy

Keith Ng has a provocative piece on the legitamcy of the Treaty, saying he is not convinced it is the basis of our rights as citizens, as both parties who signed it were unelected monarchs and chiefs.

To quote Keith:

So why then should we take seriously the idea that our right to be in New Zealand comes from the Maori chiefs who signed the Treaty?

After all, to accept that such an arrangement is still valid is to accept that rights come from rulers, and that rulers *own* those rights, that it is theirs to dish out, and that they then pass it on to the next set of rulers to dish out to their subjects.

I personally see the Treaty as being akin to the US Declaration of Independence. It is a founding document of the country, and an important one. But it is not a constitutional document which gives legal rights. To go back to the US situation there is no constutitional right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness (imagine the court cases on that last one) as expressed in the Declaration, but it is revered as the document which allowed their country to form.

Tze Ming Mok replies to Keith with some good points such as the fact the Magna Carta was signed between unelected monarch and lords, yet is part of our law today.

It’s a good debate, which deserves a wider audience.

St Molesworth: Top 10 signs things are going wrong at TVNZ

St Molesworth are getting back to their old weekly schedule. This week is Top 10 signs things are going wrong at TVNZ. My picks:

1. Kate Hawkesby’s wardrobe allowance now only includes Glassons vouchers.

3. Chen & Palmer makes more money out of TVNZ than its presenters.

4. TVNZ chosen as the location for the next season of reality TV show ‘Survivor’.

8. Hospitality budget for the entire company now equivalent to one good Ross Armstrong lunch.

Hiring women

Why I won

Despite a lack of campaigning on my part, I have won the most eligible Bachelorette poll at About Town.

Why did I win? Simple process of elimination.

People didn’t want to vote Kate as she blogs there and a Kate victory would look like it had been won using diebold voting machines.

People didn’t vote for Cathy because she intimidates too many of them. Those who liked the idea of being whipped and beaten voted for her though (God there are a lot of you). I should clarify that I am not suggesting that Cathy beats or whips people – just that any lefty men who vote for her would be seeking that sort of dominant figure.

People didn’t vote for Spanner as she is married.

And people didn’t vote for Maria because as charming and chirpy as she is, the words “high maintenance” float around her like a halo.

So hence I won by default!

Congratulations Conor

Select Committees

The full list of select committee memberships is out now. Interesting to look at on how many Labour and the Government has a majority.

Commerce – 9 members, Labour 4, Government 5 – safe

Education & Science – 10 members, Labour 4, Government 5 – could have some fun

Finance & Expenditure – 11 members, Labour 4, Government 6 – you never want this one without a majority

Foreign Affairs – 9 members, Labour 4, Government 4 – potential for somew fun but only if one can get Keith Locke to vote with National!

Govt Admin – 6 members, Labour 3, Govt 3 – the Govt won’t send anything too controversial here

Health – 12 members, Labour 4, Government 5 – this one may be very rocky for the Government, esp with Sue K chairing

Justice & Electoral – 8 members, Labour 3, Government 3 – also some potential to upset the Govt. Interesting that Russell Fairbrother is passed over for Chair to Lynne Pillay. Sounds like Helen wants him gone for losing Napier.

Law & Order – 7 members, Labour 3, Govt 4 – but as Ron Mark is swing vote, may be ugly for Govt.

Local Govt & Env – 9 members, Labour 4, Govt 4 – Jeanette F will generally vote with Govt though.

Maori Affairs – 8 members, Labour 3, Govt 4 – potentially very messy if Winston allows Pita Paraone to go with his conscience.

Primary Production – 8 members, Labour 4, Govt 4 – not usually controversial

Regs Review – 6 member, Labour 3, Govt 3 – usually bipartisan

Social Services – 12 members, Labour 4, Govt 5 – Nats & Act have six members so if they get Judy Turner with them, the Government can face some real issues

Transport & IR – 10 members, Labour 5, Govt 6 – should be safe for them

I would link to the full list of members, but I can’t see it online yet.

Rod Donald Funeral

Kudos to TVNZ for webcasting the funeral for Rod Donald. Also nice tributes yesterday from Gerry Brownlee.

I have been surprised by how affected I was by Rod Donald’s death. Some of it is just due to his age – 48 is far too young. Partly that it was such a surprise – Norman Kirk in 1974 had been unwell for some time, but this was so unexpected.

I did know Rod reasonably well. Nothing close to how well you get to know MPs from your own party, but I had a strong interest in electoral law and campaigns, and often would see Rod at events discussing these things as he had a similar interest. He also chaired the session on Blogs and Parliament which I was a guest speaker for, back in July. As many have commented he had a good sense of humour and was a nice guy. It will take some time to think of Parliament without him.

Part of the reaction has been a reminder of our own mortality. Part of me wants to throw away all plans for the future and live hedonistically for today, as tomorrow may never come. Stuff getting married, settling down and having kids – I may be gone in a decade – non-stop parties is what I want. But then I get more sensible and realise apart from trying to live healthier, one can’t do much about how long we have. One vow I have made is that if I feel sick for a couple of days, I’m not just going to wait for it to pass, but see a doctor. Luckily for me that isn’t hard!

Mad Mary Mapes

I was staggered to read that sacked CBS producer Mary Mapes still can’t see that she did anything wrong. My God, and she was a senior producer for them – so lacking in judgement.

She claims that no-one has “proven” the documents she used were not authentic. Again one can only be staggered that she believes the standard of ethics required from her is that they must be proved to be fake, rather than proven to be authentic.

And as it so happens, they have come as close to being proven fake as you can get. Without a confession or a resurrection one can not prove anything to 100%, but considering the story rests of a man man claiming to have been given them in a field by someone whose name he faked, and is a proven liar. Well need more be said.

The killer paragraph in the story is:

Mapes says she is continuing to investigate the source of the controversial documents whose authenticity was seriously questioned by the CBS panel. She tells Ross that she had no journalistic obligation to prove the authenticity of the documents before including them in the “60 Minutes II” report. “I don’t think that’s the standard,” she said.

Terrorism Motives

I know some people have such a bad grasp of history that they think terrorism didn’t exist until the 2003 Iraq War, and think it can all be blamed on that.

Whale Oil has some useful quotes from those arrested in Australia, including:

“My religion doesn’t tolerate other religion … The only law to spread – here or anywhere – has to be Islam.”

and a book identified three jihad targets: Infidels who did not accept the Koran as the book of heaven; those who took up arms against the Prophet; and those in Islamic states who refuse to pay tribute to Muslims.

“It is a Muslim’s basic duty to wipe out the above classes,”

Maiden Speeches

Maiden speeches are one of the three best types of speeches you hear in Parliament. The others are ironically valedictory speeches, and also speehes on major conscience issues when you get real debate and persuasion.

I have the draft time-table for the address in reply debate when most of the maidens will occur, so people can listen in or attend. It is likely the times may change a bit befiore Tuesday so I will do an update if they do. I’ll also list the party leader contributions.

Tuesday 15 November

3.20 pm Shane Jones, Labour
3.35 pm Sue Moroney, Labour
3.50 pm Don Brash, National
4.20 pm Helen Clark, Labour
4.50 pm Winston Peters, Foreign Minister not in Government Party
5.20 pm Jeanette Fitzsimons, Green
5.50 pm Maori Party Leader (not sure which one)
7.30 pm Peter Dunne, United Future
7.40 pm Rodney Hide, ACT
7.50 pm Jim Anderton, Progressive
8.10 pm Tim Groser, National
8.35 pm new Labour MP (not yet allocated)
9.00 pm new Labour MP (not yet allocated)
9.25 pm Mark Blumsky, National

Wednesday 16 November

3.30 pm new Maori Party MP
3.55 pm Paula Bennett, National
4.20 pm Chris Finlayson, National
4.45 pm Bob Clarkson, National

Thursday 17 November

3.20 pm David Bennett, National
3.55 pm Colin King, National
4.20 pm John Hayes, National
4.45 pm Nathan Guy, National
5.10 pm Allan Peachey, National
5.35 pm Kate Wilkinson, National

Tuesday 22 November

3.40 pm new Maori Party MP
4.25 pm Chester Borrows, National
4.50 pm Chris Tremain, National
5.25 pm Chris Auchinvole, National
7.30 pm Nicky Wagner, National
8.15 pm Craig Foss, National

Wednesday 23 November

3.25 pm Jacqui Dean, National
4.00 pm jo Goodhew, National
4.25 pm Jonathan Coleman, National
4.40 pm Jackie Blue, National

Party Vote Map

Oldies hoodwinked

I thought Winston had actually driven a tough bargain by getting Labour to agree to increase the rate of superannuation form 65% to 66%. But alas the increase is only for three years!

Superannuitants would actually have got more from National’s tax reduction package, and it would have been permanent.

When Tamihere talks about how smart Cullen was in being able to con his coalition partners, this is what he means. Cullen knows a permanent increase in the rate is unsustainable, so he appears to agree to it, but in the fine print it is only for one term.

Grey Power should feel very betrayed.