Death of a hero

Citing Wikipedia

Electoral Reform

Philip Temple, a highly respected commentator on electoral issues, has called for two changes to be made to MMP.

The first is to raise the threshold for qualifying for List MPs from one electorate seat to two electoraate seats. In Germany it is three.

The second is to remove the Maori seats, as recommended by the Royal Commission.

If both these changes applied to this election, the results would be:

Labour 53
National 52
NZ First 8
Green 7
United 1
Progressive 1

Total 122

Nat/NZF/Uni 61
Lab/Gre/Pro 61

This is assuming ACT won Epsom for tactical voting reasons, while Dunne and Anderton win even without the tactical advantage.

Who does Tauranga Mayor think he is?

The Tauranga Mayor, Stuart Crosby, has said he “will not tolerate behaviour by controversial new MP Bob Clarkson that harms the city’s image”.

Excuse me Mr Mayor, but when did a local body politician become the person an MP reports to? It hasn’t.

The fact that I agree that Clarkson needs to think before he speaks, is beside the point. The arrogance of the Mayor in thinking it is his role to lecture an MP is somewhat staggering.

Kiwibank Spin

the media are buying the spin that Kiwibank has made a $7.2 million profit.

As previously mentioned, a large proportion of the income and profit of Kiwibank comes from their agency services such as bill payments which were provided by NZ Post before Kiwibank was set up. So using pre-existing income streams to justify the $100 million or so taxpayers put into the bank is highly misleading.

National’s new Caucus

NATIONAL_CAUCUS.JPG

A nice photo of the new super-sized Caucus of 49. Now I think I can identify all of them, so here goes. Apologies if any are wrong.

Front Row (l to r): Pansy Wong, Bill English, Tony Ryall, Gerry Brownlee, Don Brash, Simon Power, Nick Smith, Katherine Rich, Lockwood Smith, John Carter

Second Row: Maurice Williamson, Lindsay Tisch, David Carter, Judith Collins, Chris Tremain, Mark Blumsky, Nicky Wagner

Third Row: Shane Ardern, Richard Worth, Paula Bennett, Chris Finlayson, Paul Hutchison, Tim Groser, David Bennett

Fourth Rpw: Colin King, Wayne Mapp, Allan Peachey, Tau Henare, Nathan Guy, Anne Tolley, Chester Borrows, Georgina te Heuheu

Fifth Row: Bob Clarkson, Jo Goodhew, Kate Wilkinson, Jonathan Coleman, Jackie Blue, Sandra Goudie, Craig Foss, Katrina Shanks, John Key, Brian Connell

Back Row: Eric Roy, Chris Auchinvole, Jacqui Dean, John Hayes, Clem Simich, Phil Heatley, Murray McCully

Votes

International Issues

Firstly Kiwi Pundit has a nice provocative blog on how Bush backers have won almost all recent elections.

Secondly you have what is the huge news (Hat Tip: PC) that the UK Government has basically admitted Kyoto is worthless and not a single country will actually adhere to it.

Also you have even Bill Clinton saying the BBC coverage of Hurricane Katrina aftermath has grossly unfair to Bush.

A nice thought

What I would do if I was ….

[Note these are what I would do if I was them, not what I actually want them to do]

Helen – have no-one but Anderton in coalition, and play off the four supporting parties against each other, with different groupings on different issues. Don’t let yourself be seen too closely linked with any one group as the others will sulk.

Don – Get re-elected Leader today (required by the rules) and make clear you intend to stay on for the next election as you led Natioanl to its biggest vote increase ever. Concede the election within an hour or so of the final count, if the left-wing parties do not lose any seats. Work out areas of maximum friction between the five parties propping up the Government, and be ruthless in applying pressure so that the Government falls apart.

Winston – take out an electoral petition in Tauranga. You will lose it, but the publicity will keep you in the media for months. Position yourself as the foes of the extremism of the Maori Party, being a mainstream voice for Maori. Support the Government while it is popular, but pull the plug once it drops significantly in the polls. Whatever you do, don’t go into the election propping up a third term Government as your party will be wiped out if you do, with no electorate seat.

Jeanette/Rod – in exchange for agreeing not to be in Cabinet, make sure you get much better policy and funding commitments than previously. Also a second select committee chair. Concentrate on green issues to maintain your brand, not socialism where you competer for votes.

Tariana/Pita – keep pretending to consider National so you can get a better deal from Labour. Don’t be pussies and accept platitudes but if they want your support demand something such as extending the deadline for filing treaty claims, or scrapping the deadline. Remember you can piss off 85% of the country as much as you like, as long as you gain votes from the 15% you are targetting.

Peter – ask for something actually useful and tangible, not just a quango which is the laughing stock of NZ. Rejoice in losing most of the religious nutters and seek to position yourself as the foes of the Greens (as Winston should do with Maori Party). This is your best chance to grow the vote – convince people that your party is the one which stops the Greens from making Government.

Rodney – first item is to have a purge of the party which would make Stalin proud, just with less blood. ACT officials have to accept that you are the Leader and without you ACT would no longer exist. The ACT infighting is what has driven so many activists to National, and it has to stop. Make Heather Deputy Leader and brand the two of yourself almost as a team – near co-leaders. Also give Heather some spinach or something so she develops a more vicious streak. Do not attack National, but differentiate on policies. Now people know ACT is safe, concentrate on rebuilding core support.

Jim – Join the Labour Party.

Your tax dollars at work

The Young Nats blog have a photo of a Young Labour table at Auckland University and you can see there the big red Labour banner with the parliamentary crest on it, which means it was paid for by taxpayers. This is the same one that Jordan jumped in front of at Victoria University to stop me taking a photo of it.

Parliamentary Staff

As we wait to find out the shape of a Government, spare a thought for all the parliamentary staff who work for MPs, because a couple of weeks ago they were all sacked!

All staff who work directly for an MP or Minister have their jobs end a month after the election, even if their MPs get re-elected.

Very tough in a party which has lost MPs, as the staff numbers get slashed almost in proportion to the number of MPs. A lot of good ACT, NZ First and United Future staff will be looking for jobs. I imagine quite a few will be picked up by National, but even existing National staff are not guaranteed to stay on.

I think I got sacked seven times while working at Parliament. Luckily I was rehired seven times also. My record for sackings has probably been beaten by OIA Girl though who holds the all-time survivor record!

It really can be a miserable time though. No-one takes on a job at Parliament expecting stability but when the decisions come on who is not staying on, it hits you really hard as you form some great friendships with colleagues. The survivors almost feel worse than those not kept on. I was actually in tears after the last staff reshuffle when Don took over as leader from Bill. It was truly a miserable day as so many mates were not kept on. The nice thing is that almost without exception all the ex-staff end up in better jobs with more pay and fewer hours before too long. Or pregnant eh Megs 🙂

The Herald has a useful story on the boost to the Leader’s Office National gets by having an extra 22 MPs – being a whopping $1.7 million. That is going to make a huge difference, as long as they don’t spend it all on bus shelter ads 🙂

Other resources come with new MPs. Each new MP gains a secretary and one or two electorate agents (one for list MPs, two for electorate MPs). So ten new electorate MPs and twelve new list MPs is 54 extra staff. And List MPs get around a $45,000 budget and electorate MPs around $65,000 so around $1.2 million extra funding for electorate based activities.

Is it all over?

If specials do not change the result, then I certainly think we have a Labour-led Government. It is just a matter of its form.

Prebble has claimed that even if the Greens fall below 5%, Labour would form the Government. Let’s look at that scenario. The Parliament would then be (if no other votes change in proportion to each other):

Labour 52
National 51
NZ First 7
Maori 4 (one overhang)
United 3
ACT 2
Progressive 2

Total 121

You need 61 seats to govern, and blocs are:

Lab/Prog/Maori 58
Nat/ACT 53
Uni/NZF 10

So if the centre parties failed to agree on terms with Labour you could get a centre right government with 63/121 seats. If the Greens do stay in then the best the CR can do is 61/122.

As I have said previously though (including on National Radio yesterday) I regard it as most unlikely the Greens would drop below 5%. But one should wait for the final acount, rather than make assumptions.

One degree of seperation

Found amusing reading this story about coalition negotiations, that I can claim some linkage to every chief of staff.

Labour’s Chief of Staff, Heather Simpson, taught me economics at Otago University.

The Green Chief of Staff, Deb Moran, was the women’s affairs private secretary in Jenny Shipley’s prime ministerial office, where I also worked.

The United Future Chief of Staff, Rob Eaddy, was Jim Bolger’s Chief of Staff when I worked for Ministerial Services.

The Maori Party ‘Adviser” Ken Mair I met at Moutua Gardens when we drove up there to invite him to attend a Young Nationals conference and speak on why he was occupying the gardens.

NZ really is a very small country with lots of party hopping amongst staff also! 🙂

Also in the story the Maori Party says it is looking at a range of options for support. Spanner takes a guess at what that might be.

About Time

Finally Helen Clark has backed away from her stance that Taito Field had done nothing wrong. She has now ordered a review of the Minister’s role.

However not exactly an independent review, but one from fellow Ministers. Ha – they probably just want to compares notes about how to get $1.20/hour labouring 🙂

Meanwhile the Minister himself still thinks there is nothing wrong with paying someone $1.20 an hour while asking their mate the Minister to get him a work visa. Taito Field has said:

“If anything [inaccurate] comes in the paper you can expect a defamation suit to be laid against the paper and you will probably be talking about millions,” he said.

“I don’t know why these people feel I’m their enemy. All I have done is try and help people.”

Cheer-up tonic for the right

If you’re feeling down about the NZ result, just go and read the latest from Mark Latham on Australian Labor. It is wonderful stuff with Latham now labelling himself a “whistle-blower“.

He has labelled current Labour Leader Kim Beazley as “indecent, duplicitous and unfit to clean toilets in Parliament House”. Now that’s a smear campaign.

He has also revealed how the trade unions almost blackmail Labor MPs to vote for things or risk deselection.

You know how bad it is when John Howard has to come out and say that the Labour MPs are not as bad as their former Leader paints them.

Yesterday they had the Labor Party President on saying you can’t take what Latham says as credible, as he is obviously a demented, vengeful hate filled man. The interviewer then commented along the lines of “And this is the man your party tried to make Prime Minister, don’t you owe the public an apology?”

Bliss

The only thing better than not having to work until past midnight last night, was not having the alarm go off at 4.30 am this morning! 🙂

I have a life back. Now just have to find something useful to do with it!

Gay MPs

Someone asked if I would also cover the number of gay MPs, as I had done women, Maori and Muslims. Why not.

First of all this is just the list of openly gay or lesbian (or transgender) MPs. I do not want, and indeed will ban anyone who posts speculation about who they think is secretly gay. I know every rumour there is, and if they were all true 45% of Parliament would be gay it seems.

The numbers have increased from three to five. Joining Chris Carter, Georgina Beyer and Tim Barnett are Maryan Street (L) and Chris Finlayson (N).

Maryan Street is NZ’s first openly Lesbian MP. Marilyn Waring was outed as an MP, but was not widely known.

Votes per MP

I’ve done a quick analysis of how many votes each party needed to get an MP. In descending order they are:

Progressive 24,624
United 18,535
Green 17,270
NZ First 17,048
Labour 16,649
National 16,524
ACT 15,537
Maori 10,122

Could almost call it a Maori Party gerrymander as the overhang means their votes count almost twice as much as the other parties.

Now you could claim that is far enough won the electorate vote in four electorates. Well yes they did, but the number of votes cast in each Maori seat is only 16,000 – less than half the average in general seats.

Muslim MPs

What would you do if you were Helen?

Even if Greens pick up one more seat and Labour could form a 62-60 seat Government with the Greens, with Maori Party support, look at what the two options may be:

1) Labour/Progressive/Greens with 58 seats and four seats on confidence and supply from Maori Party.

2) Labour/Progressive with 51 seats and 17 seats on confidence and supply from Greens, NZ First and United Future (plus likely support on most issues from Maori Party)

The more I think about it, the worst it looks for the Greens. They face being merely one of four parties outside Government, yet supporting the Government.

Mike Williams’ predictions

Labour Party President made a number of predictions about marginal seats. Let’s see how they went:

Invercargill was a “reasonably safe” seat, Mr Williams said.

– National wins by 1,953

Mr Parker was in born Roxburgh which was in the middle of the Otago seat. “That whole area is absolutely booming under Labour.”

– National wins by 1,931

“It’s hard to see any good reason why Hamilton East would go back to National.”

– National wins by 5,223

Mr Williams said he would get back into Parliament as the MP for Aoraki.

“I think he’s got the numbers and so does he.”

– National wins by 6,616

Labour had conducted polling in Northcote and believed there was solid support for sitting MP Mrs Hartley.

– National wins by 2,359

Labour believes it could take two marginal seats off National.

One was Piako, which National MP Lindsay Tisch won over Sue Moroney in 2002 by 1621 votes.

– National wins by 7,788

The second was East Coast Bays which senior National MP and strategist Murray McCully defeated Labour candidate Hamish McCracken by 1534 votes to win.

“He now lives in Wellington. That’s well-known now (journalist) Jane Clifton admitted publicly that that’s the situation.

“Murray McCully is almost never seen in the electorate and he could be in with a very nasty surprise there.”

– National wins by 6,821

The only prediction Mr Williams seems to have got right was (sadly) Wellington Central.

Getting it so wrong in Epsom

Looking in NZ has a useful summary of all the incorrect predictions in Epsom.

This was not a minor issue as certainly it is logical that ACT would have got more list votes if the media had not universally claimed Hide could not win Epsom.

Considering how volatile the electorate is, I am very surprised that no public polls were done in Epsom in the last week.

The Naked MP

Keith Locke has confirmed he will run naked through Epsom, as he promised to do if Rodney won the seat.

Now the media will film and photograph it but they will pixellate or blur certain areas I am sure.

However bloggers have no such need to not offend people. So I think we should have a photo competion amongst the right wing blogs. All blogs who can send someone along to take photos and compete for best full frontal photo. We can then have people vote on which blog got the best photo!

And then send the left over photos to the Exclusive Brethren for their next pamphlet 🙂

The Green problem

I am surprised that so few media [I am told in fact the NZ Herald has focused on this quite a bit, and National Radio also] have focused on explicit statements from Unite Future and NZ First that they will not support a Government which has the Greens in them. Dunne repeated that yesterday, which got publicity but the NZ First statement has been so unreported that I wondered if I was dreaming it.

But no here on Scoop is the Greens’ response to it on the 7th of September. In words they may regret they said “We’re grateful with Winston Peters for laying down a bottom line that he would not support Labour if in coalition with the Greens”.

The four parties of the left have only 61 out of 122 seats. Unless one of those parties picks up a seat on specials, Labour will not be able to do a coalition with the Greens.