Dunne on Greens

Hard to see United Future supporting a Government with the Greens in it. This is what Peter Dunne had today to say on them:

“I think they’re Luddite in terms of their transport and energy policies. I think their foreign policy verges on being in favour of terrorism and they have never yet found a drug they’re not in favour of.”

Maori MPs

Only increased 20 MPs to 21 MPs as NZ First lost so many MPs, many Maori.

21/122 MPs is 17.2% of Parliament, which compares to 12% of the adult population.

The breakdown by party is:

MAP 4/4 100%
NZF 3/7 43%
LAB 10/50 20%
GRE 1/6 17%
NAT 3/49 6%
ACT 0/2 0%
UNF 0/3 0%
JAP 0/1 0%

Georgina te Heuheu is joined in National by Tau Henare and Paula Bennett.

Female MPs

I just spent half an hour counting up the number of female MPs, and find that Parliamentary Service are right on the ball and have the stats already done here.

There are 40 female MPs out of 122, or 32.8%. The 2002 Parliament had 34/120 or 28% so that is a good increase.

Broken down by party, the percentages are:

GRE 4/6 67%
ACT 1/2 50%
LAB 19/50 38%
UNF 1/3 33%
NAT 13/49 27%
MAP 1/4 25%
NZF 1/7 14%
JAP 0/1 0%

National currently has only six out of 27 MPs female or 22% so it is a significant boost with eight new female MPs, and Lynda Scott retiring.

Electorates

Aoraki – Jo Goodhew has taken a 6,500 majority to Sutton and not only wiped it out, but turned it into an even bigger one for herself. This is a massacre. Well done the Goodhews.

Bay of Plenty – Ryall takes his 5,600 majority and more than doubles it to 12,600. Very nice work.

Clevedon – Judith Collins has gone from 3,100 to 11,700. Reflects the fact she is one of the most effective new MPs.

Clutha-Southland – Bill doubles his majority also. No surprise.

Coromandel – Sandra Goudie has taken the former Green seat and made a 10,000 majority for herself.

East Coast – a great result for Anne Tolley who has overcme a 5,300 majority for Janet Mackey to get a 1,300 one for Tolley over daughter Moana Mackey. Glad to see Moana has made it back on the list though – she is a thorougly nice person with a great future in politics.

East Coast Bays – the left were claiming they would knock McCully out. To be fair Murray always claims the seat is on a knife egde, but his 6,800 majority speaks for itself.

Epsom – A tough time for Richard Worth who lost his seat as people voted tactically. A 3,200 majority for Rodney must be beyond his best hopes, and he is understandably delighted. Once the voters have forgiven Rodney for the sight of a naked Keith Locke, his job is to lift the party vote for ACT now they are guaranteed not to be wasted votes in future. Also he needs to have a purge of a few people in the party!

Hamilton East – the thoroughly nice David Bennett has beaten the not at all nice Di Yates by 5,200 – huge.

Hamilton West – bad luck to Tim Macindoe who missed out by 688 votes.

Helensville – no surprise that John Key now has an 11,800 majority – reflecting his stature. Shit, if he lived in the electorate it might be 16,000 🙂

Invercargill – nice to have Eric Roy back with a 1,900 majority. Harpur proved a good candidate to keep it that cloase.

Kaikoura – Colin King held off the PM’s propoganda man Brendan Burns by 4,000 votes. Pretty safe.

Napier – Chris Tremain has run a terrific campaign to grab Napier by 3,500 votes. It is very very rare for National to hold Napier.

Nelson – Nick Smith is back to his normal 10,000 majority

New Plymouth – good effort from Moira Irving to take Harry D from 15,000 to a 5,000 majority. Perhaps people don’t like MPs who get their mates to pass a special law to re-elect him to Parliament without an election.

Northcote – now everything north of Auckland Harbour is blue. Jonathan Coleman gets a respectable 2,500 or so majority against a former Mayor.

Otago – a close result with a 1,900 majority to Jacqui Dean.

Otaki – an amazing result. Darren Hughes has had his 7,700 majority reduced to 226 and he could lose it on specials. Nathan Guy is widely regarded as having run a brilliant campaign and even if he does not win it this time, he is well set up to take it in 2008 (depending on boundary changes). If Darren wants to spend his life in Parliament as he told Salient, he needs to move to Palmerston North 🙂

Piako – Lindsay Tishc turns a small 1,600 majority into a large 7,800 one.

Rangitikei – Simon Power keeps increasing the majority in the seat he initially won by 100 votes or so. Now at 9,000 and growing.

Rotorua – Steve Chadwick is down to a 532 majority. Should retain on specials, but a fright.

Tauranga – Clarkson wins by 568. Hard to see it losing on specials, but you will be closely watched. The key thing is will Winston go for an electoral petition on spending or cut his losses and concentrate on keeping his party over 5%.

Tukituki – Craig Foss has a hugely deserved victory over Rick Barker and wins by 2,300. A great guy who will do well in Parliament.

Wairarapa – Labour must be regretting not selecting Bob Francis. A grateful John Hayes beats Denise McKenzie by 2,500. Now the entire East Coast from Aucland to Wellington is blue.

Wellington Central – National got thrashed in both the party and electorate vote. It may be the worst result for a seat, compared to 2002, for National. And no it is not at all a nice feeling. We’ll have a look at what were the factors we could control, what were the factors we couldn’t control, and I am sure will be aiming for a much improved vote in 2008 (or earlier if Govt falls apart). The nice thing is Mark is there as a List MP and I am confident his natural personality and skills will shine as an MP.

West Coast-Tasman. O’Connor holds on by 1,900 but Labour loses the party vote there.

Whanganui – third time lucky for hard working Chester Borrows. You’d have to travel a long way to find a nicer more decent guy. He will love being the local MP.

Maori Seats – As predicted four for Maori Party with Sharples having a 1,700 majority over Tamihere who is out of Parliament. The others are back on the list.

Forming a Government

Okay, on the results to date we have an interesting situation, where the Greens may be the big losers if they don’t gain a 7th seat..

Helen does get first dibs to form a Government. Add on Jim Il Song and they have 51 seats – and need an extra 11 votes. Now the Greens have six and Maori Party four so with them you make 61/122. Can not pass a budget.

Also worth noting that the Greens will support Labour no matter what, but Maori Party is going to require some bargaining.

Now you have NZ First and United Future. Both have said they will initially offer support to the largest party (Peters may be backtracking on that though as I think he has said this is effectively a tie). However both have said that they can not support a Government which has the Greens in it. Therefore Helen has to crap on the Greens, to get a majority.

So the most likely Government is a minority Labour/Progressive one with 51/122 seats. Now comes the hard part for them. To pass any legislation they generally will need three out of the other four parties (Maori, Green, United Future and NZ First) to vote for it – now getting five parties in total to all agree on a bill will be damn difficult.

The other thing to look out for, if they do form a Government, is select committees. A Labour-led Government may get bills changed against their will at select committee level often.

Now can National form a Government? They have 49 seats and with ACT are a solid bloc of 51 – the same as Labour/Progressive. If NZ First and United Future come on board (and I suspect both are very nervous about propping up a third term Labour Government which has to pander to both the Greens and the Maori Party) you have 61 seats. One short of a majority.

However there is the Maori Party. Now I quipped last night that if they allow National to abolish the Maori seats, then National will allow them to keep powhiris :-), but more seriously it is hard to see that agreement could be reached on the key areas of Maori/Treaty policy. There is much commonality in other areas, but this one is a show-stopper. However in 1996 I never thought Winston would go with National, so nothing is impossible – and Tariana does not at all like Helen and will remember the last cab off the rank put-down, which is different to Don Brash who was always careful just to say that the policies seem incompatible.

Could National and Maori Party do an agree to disagree? National would not be able to abolish the Maori Seats because simply most of Parliament won’t vote for it. So could they say well status quo rules, because we don’t have a majority for these changes, but we will work with Maori Party to further common goals in other areas?

I don’t regard it as at all a likely option, but I suspect the prospect will be kept alive for a while, to maximise negotiating positions.

The final note is to stress again that specials may change things. If the Greens pick up a seat then they can join the Government in coalition. If the Maori Party pick up a seat off Labour (but due to overhang won’t gain a seat, Labour just loses one) then the CR could form a 61/121 narrow majority.

I doubt anyone will announce a Government before specials are counted.

How did each party go?

Labour – from 41.3% to 40.7%. Pretty good for a second term Government. However don’t think this means they held all their own vote. Many 2002 Labour voters voted National I am sure – the loss of electorate seats reflects this also. Labour replaced those voters with voters from the Greens and NZ First and to a degree United Future.

National – from 20.9% to 39.6%. A remarkable result, despite the agony of not quite being enough. Once upon a time increasing your vote by 5% was seen as a landslide gain. And the ten extra electorate seats will make a huge difference.

NZ First – almost destroyed themselves with the smears against Clarkson, and ran an awful campaign. For a while looked to be getting 12% to 15% but in the end lost their only electorate seat and vote fell from 10.4% to 5.8%. Unless Peters wins Tauranga on specials or an electoral petition triggered by-election, they will have to be very careful about how they behave or it is outski in 2008.

Greens – vote dropped from 7.0% to 5.1%. Did nothing wrong, but nothing too great either. They will be gutted at loss of Nandor and hoping he makes it on specials.

Maori Party – got 2.0% which must be a disappointment for them as it represents less than 20% of Maori voters. Howevr they will feel pleased to have won a majority of the Maori seats, and may be in a position of considerable influence.

United Future – common sense says going from 6.7% to 2.7% is a bad result, however they will be relieved at least they got higher than the 1% some polls had them at. Worth noting Outdoor Recreation got 1.3% last time and thet merged with UFNZ.

ACT – no-one can claim going from 7.1% to 1.5% is anything other than an awful result, but full kudos to Rodney for keeping ACT in Parliament. And I am delighted Heather Roy stays on also. Commisserations to the other MPs who are out, especially Stephen Franks whose abilities will be missed by Parliament.

Jim Anderton’s Progressive – have to firstly note it was hilarious their abbreviation was JAP, and John Campbell and others had to ask who the Japs are :-), anyway they went from 1.7% to 1.2%, and will be disappointed to lose Matt Robson as it means the party has no purpose now other than to save Jim from attending Labour Caucus meetings. However they have a chance to get Matt back on specials and will have a big celebration if they do.

Destiny – 0.6%. Piss off Brian.

Legalise Cannabis – down from 0.6% to 0.2%. I think all the pot smokers now vote Green.

Christian Heritage – down from 1.35% to 0.12% which is great. Still concerned 2,495 people had God tell them to vote for CHP. Hopefully this means they will now give it up.

Alliance – down from 1.27% to 0.07%. Sorry Spanner but game over.

Libertarianz – 0.05% and 926 votes. Almost enough for a breakaway island 🙂

And finally need to note that you need 500 members to get registered, yet the OneNZ Party and Republic of NZ Party only got 465 votes and 449 votes respectively. Makes those memberships look rather dodgy!

What might specials do?

The ability for Labour to put together a Government could change considerably, depending on special votes. And while only a fool would predict what specials may do, we can look at how close each party is to gaining or losing a seat.

Our friend the Sainte-Lagu

Ouch

Well the result may not be impressive, but the hangover is. I have decided to rename my head Hurricane Katrina.

After the vodka and rum ran out, we headed into town. At some bar whose name I honestly can’t recall we decided shots were called for. To our great disappointment after eight or nine rounds they refused to serve us anymore. We were actually very well behaved, but I suppose the fact we were ordering new rounds every three minutes was a factor 🙂

Anyway my inclination is to amputate from the neck up, but alas the requests for analysis have already started so I will do my best in an impaired state. All errors can be blamed on Steven Heath 🙂

New National MPs

National now has 22 more MPs. On the results tonight there are now 14/49 MPs who are women, three Maori MPs, and one Asian MP. A lot more diverse.

New MPs are:

GROSER, Tim
FINLAYSON, Christopher
WAGNER, Nicky
HENARE, Tau
PEACHEY, Allan
GOODHEW, Jo
BENNETT, David
BORROWS, Chester
AUCHINVOLE, Chris
COLEMAN, Jonathan
BLUMSKY, Mark
ROY, Eric
WILKINSON, Kate
GUY, Nathan
DEAN, Jacqui
BLUE, Jackie
KING, Colin
TOLLEY, Anne
FOSS, Craig
BENNETT, Paula
SHANKS, Katrina May
CLARKSON, Bob
HAYES, John
TREMAIN, Chris

MPs who are out

This is based on election night results.

National – none

Labour – John Tamihere, Lesley Soper

ACT – Muriel Newman, Stephen Franks, Ken Shirley, Kenneth Wang, Gerry Eckhoff

Greens – Nandor Tancoiz, Mike Ward

Maori – none

NZ First – Jim Peters, Dail Jones, Craig McNair, Edwin Perry, Bill Gudgeon, Brent Catchpole

United Future – Marc Alexander, Larry Baldock, Murray Smith, Dr Bernie Ogilvy

Progressive – Matt Robson

Plane Crash

Plane Crash

Wellington Central

Electorate Results

At 9.33 pm the following are the projections:

Aoraki (6,000 margin so far overturning 6.500)
East Coast
Epsom to ACT
Hamilton East
Hamilton West
Invercargill
Napier (great one Chris)
Northcote
Otago
Rotorua (amazing)
Tauranga (yay)
Tuktituki (well done Craig)
Wairarapa
Whanganui
plus four Maori seats to Maori Party

I’m only going to cover those which have or may swap hands.

At 7.42 pm the following look possible:

Aoraki, Banks Peninsula, East Coast, Ham East, Ham West, Invercargill, Napier, Northcote, Otago, Tukituki, Wairarapa, Whanganui.

Plus Epsom, Tauranga and four Maori seats.

Epsom

Heh heh. Keith Locke has to run naked down Queen Street.

Rodney is 2,000 votes ahead. ACT will be in the next Parliament.

Okay I think Rodney is going to win Epsom as the electorate is quite homogenous.

Rodney now ahead by 147 on 4,333 votes.

Rodney is ahead by 96 votes with 3,745 counted. Looks like it will be very tight.

Tauranga

Clarkson has won – a 1,110 majority with 87% of booths in.

10% counted and Clarkson ahead by 541. Looking good.

Only 5% counted but Clarkson ahead 1,254 to 831. I think Clarkson will win by over 2,000 votes based on gut instinct over what Peters did this week.

Party Vote Results

And Labour is in the lead. Unless specials change things, it’s another three years of Helengrad. But Labour need five parties supporting it to govern which may not be that stable.

And the gap keeps shrinking. It is possible Labour may get more votes than National which means they will hold onto office. But it may need to wait for specials.

I’ve looked at St Lague formula and National is in danger of losing a seat to Labour which would tie it. However Progressive may lose a seat also. Other factor is Greens normally pick up a lot on specials.

And still shrinking. CR has 62 seats and CL 60 seats. This could be hung. If Labour get more votes they have won. If they do not, then they may still win, but may be hung.

As I said the lead will shrink, and is down to 5.5%. What will it stop at?

Okay things are looking better, even with only 200,000 votes counted as National is now 9.7% ahead. This definitely will shirnk but it is a useful lead to have at this stage.

145,000 votes counted and National ahead 47.3% to 37.3%. This doesn’t give me a lot of confidence as based on past elections that may shrink to only a 1% or so lead which isn’t enough. But still too early to speculate, even though I am!!

Okay with 6,000 votes in so far the results are:

National 50.5%
Labour 33.5%

Only 2,994,000 votes to go

I do warn people not to take much from party vote results until after 8.00 pm as the early booths are small rural ones and are not representative. Sometimes not even until 8.30 pm does it start to give a good impression.

Results

I will be providing some commentary from 7 pm onwards. It won’t be non stop as I have several official duties to do tonight also, but will cover major highlights. Most of you know where to get official results from.

I’ll probably set up a number of threads and keep updating them, rather than make 100 posts. I’m thinking of the following threads/posts:

* Party Vote Results
* Electorate Results
* Tauranga
* Epsom
* Possible Governments

Any suggestions for others or should that cover it?

Elections are good for blogs

Well elections are good for blogs. These graphs show number of unique daily visits up until midnight.

monthly.JPG

This shows the number of daily visits, over the last 31 days on a rolling sum. So in the month up to the election we had over 160,000 visits. A year ago it was a bit over 20,000.

weekly.JPG

The weekly (last seven days) graph has gone up around 60% in the last two months. The temporary blip a couple of months ago was a ton of searches for the identities of the celebrity drug case names.

daily.JPG

The daily stats can be harder to follow because they vary so much. Generally weekend days are 30% lower than weekdays. We had over 7,500 visits on Thursday which was a record.

Thanks to Scoop who remain our number one source of referrals, followed by NBR. A true bipartisan effort 🙂

Billboard still up

I’ve voted

I voted at Thorndon School ay 9.37 am. Not busy yet. Under electoral law I can not reveal who I voted for with either vote, so people will have to guess 🙂

Good to see one particular unnamed party was the only one there with a scrutineer for each booth.

No political comments

I can’t turn off all comments, so instead I just ask people to respect the electoral law and refrain from making any political comments at all between midnight and 7 pm Saturday. Reports on turnout etc are okay but nothing on who may win, who you want to win, or even policy debates. Just talk about rugby or something. Or girls. Or boys if you are a girl.

Ten reasons to vote to change the Government

1) Vision

Labour have shown themselves to be a Government with no vision other than to stop Don Brash. There are no plans for the future, no way ahead.

Brash has created almost all of the agenda, and Labour have been in catchup mode. On treaty issues, on taxation, on welfare reform, on student loans National has led and Labour have followed.

2) A once in a generation chance to lower tax

If a centre right Government is not elected in 2005, the opportunity to significantly lower taxes may never occur again. The reason is that a re-elected Labour Government would vow to never ever let the surplus get so big again. They would make sure that within minutes of a surplus appearing they had invented new ways to spend it. They’ll buy everyone a pet cow if necessary, just so long as they don’t have a surplus and can then claim no room for tax cuts.

And the reason tax cuts are good is not personal gain. Hell my annual saving I could probably make in a day or two if I got off my arse. It’s about having a faster growing economy.

3) Education

Labour have seriously screwed up the education system. Not in a minor way, but major league stuff here. Just read the reports on NCEA.

Trevor Mallard is not the person to fix the mess he created. And neither is David Benson-Pope. Bill English is. He will be an outstanding Minister of Education who has a passion for excellence for the school sector

4) Integrity

Helen Clark’s endorsement of the behaviour of Taito Phillip Field in paying an illegal over-stayer $1.20 an hour to work for him in Samoa, while getting a work permit for him off his colleague is appalling. At the very very minimum she should have got a QC to investigate, Or even reprimanded him. But no she has praised him.

5) Under 20% tax for 85% of taxpayers

The signal it will send to people entering the workforce, saving for their mortgage, paying off their loan is immense. Trust me that marginal rates do affect incentives, and it would be great to be in a country where no New Zealander will pay more than 19 cents in the dollar tax on their income up to $50,000.

6) Ideology

Labour really has bent over backwards to stick it to the private sector in any area where it may compete with state unions. They even discriminated against three year olds, until they backed down. In every sector from hospitals, to schools, to tertiary education to prisons they put ideology ahead of common sense. Patients have died because Labour refused to allow private hospitals with capacity to gain contracts for publicly funded operations.

A vibrant private sector improves the public sector. A lack of competition through monopoly provision has never ever produced quality outcomes.

7) Tertiary Education

The amount of money wasted on scam tertiary courses is somewhere between the hundreds of millions and billions if you count all non completed sub-degree courses. We used to get outraged over $20,000 coffee machines for Treasury. Ministers should have been sacked for the tertiary education fiascoes. Especially as the warnings had been there for years. Scandal after scandal was exposed and nothing was done until it all got too much.

How can a Minister see an institution go from $5 million a year to $246 million in just five years and not put a stop to it, and ensure quality. Maharey presided over the biggest waste of money any Government has ever seen in NZ’s history.

And I am a fan of investing more into tertiary education. One could have got close to universal allowances maybe, if Maharey was allowing money to be wasted away because it was politically incorrect to interfere and stop it.

8) John Key as Minister of Finance

Need more be said!

9) Their student loan bribe

If you want to invest $300 million a year more into tertiary education, then there are some great ways you could do that. Lower fees or better allowances. But interest free loans is the stupidest way to do it. As we now know, it will actually increase long-term student debt by $5 billion or so. It provides all the wrong incentives, and its only redeeming feature is that is sounds appealing on the surface.

Promising $300 million a year in lower fees may not have got the same headline, but it would be a much better way of helping students that this idiotic policy.

10) Don Brash as Prime Minister

I’m not just saying this, but I think Brash will make an outstanding Prime Minister. I’ve worked with and for him and he is genuinely nice guy with a good sense of humour. He is very seriously intelligent and generally knowledgeable in every policy area. Yes there have been bloopers on the campaign trail, but it has been obvious how much he has grown over the five week period.

He is a skilled CEO, and a good team leader. He has also shown at Orewa and beyond an ability to communicate directly to New Zealanders. This may be our only chance to experience Don Brash as Prime Minister, and it one which I think would be very good for New Zealand.

Play this song!