No political comments

I can’t turn off all comments, so instead I just ask people to respect the electoral law and refrain from making any political comments at all between midnight and 7 pm Saturday. Reports on turnout etc are okay but nothing on who may win, who you want to win, or even policy debates. Just talk about rugby or something. Or girls. Or boys if you are a girl.

Ten reasons to vote to change the Government

1) Vision

Labour have shown themselves to be a Government with no vision other than to stop Don Brash. There are no plans for the future, no way ahead.

Brash has created almost all of the agenda, and Labour have been in catchup mode. On treaty issues, on taxation, on welfare reform, on student loans National has led and Labour have followed.

2) A once in a generation chance to lower tax

If a centre right Government is not elected in 2005, the opportunity to significantly lower taxes may never occur again. The reason is that a re-elected Labour Government would vow to never ever let the surplus get so big again. They would make sure that within minutes of a surplus appearing they had invented new ways to spend it. They’ll buy everyone a pet cow if necessary, just so long as they don’t have a surplus and can then claim no room for tax cuts.

And the reason tax cuts are good is not personal gain. Hell my annual saving I could probably make in a day or two if I got off my arse. It’s about having a faster growing economy.

3) Education

Labour have seriously screwed up the education system. Not in a minor way, but major league stuff here. Just read the reports on NCEA.

Trevor Mallard is not the person to fix the mess he created. And neither is David Benson-Pope. Bill English is. He will be an outstanding Minister of Education who has a passion for excellence for the school sector

4) Integrity

Helen Clark’s endorsement of the behaviour of Taito Phillip Field in paying an illegal over-stayer $1.20 an hour to work for him in Samoa, while getting a work permit for him off his colleague is appalling. At the very very minimum she should have got a QC to investigate, Or even reprimanded him. But no she has praised him.

5) Under 20% tax for 85% of taxpayers

The signal it will send to people entering the workforce, saving for their mortgage, paying off their loan is immense. Trust me that marginal rates do affect incentives, and it would be great to be in a country where no New Zealander will pay more than 19 cents in the dollar tax on their income up to $50,000.

6) Ideology

Labour really has bent over backwards to stick it to the private sector in any area where it may compete with state unions. They even discriminated against three year olds, until they backed down. In every sector from hospitals, to schools, to tertiary education to prisons they put ideology ahead of common sense. Patients have died because Labour refused to allow private hospitals with capacity to gain contracts for publicly funded operations.

A vibrant private sector improves the public sector. A lack of competition through monopoly provision has never ever produced quality outcomes.

7) Tertiary Education

The amount of money wasted on scam tertiary courses is somewhere between the hundreds of millions and billions if you count all non completed sub-degree courses. We used to get outraged over $20,000 coffee machines for Treasury. Ministers should have been sacked for the tertiary education fiascoes. Especially as the warnings had been there for years. Scandal after scandal was exposed and nothing was done until it all got too much.

How can a Minister see an institution go from $5 million a year to $246 million in just five years and not put a stop to it, and ensure quality. Maharey presided over the biggest waste of money any Government has ever seen in NZ’s history.

And I am a fan of investing more into tertiary education. One could have got close to universal allowances maybe, if Maharey was allowing money to be wasted away because it was politically incorrect to interfere and stop it.

8) John Key as Minister of Finance

Need more be said!

9) Their student loan bribe

If you want to invest $300 million a year more into tertiary education, then there are some great ways you could do that. Lower fees or better allowances. But interest free loans is the stupidest way to do it. As we now know, it will actually increase long-term student debt by $5 billion or so. It provides all the wrong incentives, and its only redeeming feature is that is sounds appealing on the surface.

Promising $300 million a year in lower fees may not have got the same headline, but it would be a much better way of helping students that this idiotic policy.

10) Don Brash as Prime Minister

I’m not just saying this, but I think Brash will make an outstanding Prime Minister. I’ve worked with and for him and he is genuinely nice guy with a good sense of humour. He is very seriously intelligent and generally knowledgeable in every policy area. Yes there have been bloopers on the campaign trail, but it has been obvious how much he has grown over the five week period.

He is a skilled CEO, and a good team leader. He has also shown at Orewa and beyond an ability to communicate directly to New Zealanders. This may be our only chance to experience Don Brash as Prime Minister, and it one which I think would be very good for New Zealand.

Play this song!

A very very bitter man

Mark Latham always struck me as somewhat unstable and volatile. He has now descended into a fit of vitriol and bitterness against his former Labour colleagues that makes Mike Moore look dignified in comparison.

I think Latham has just killed off Kim Beazley’s chances of ever being Prime Minister.

He has not just published a book, but is doing media interviews where he rips into all his former colleagues. I can’t wait to get a copy.

Election Drinking Game

A couple of people have sent me this election drinking game, which I’ve converted from the pdf.

drinkgameelect.JPG

I’ll be having my own guide for the night, as follows:

Each seat National wins off Labour – 1 nip

If Winston loses Tauranga – 4 nips

If NZ First gets wiped out – 5 nips

If NZ First gets wiped out, and Helen stays in power because of that – 2 nips

If Progressive get reduced to one MP (which will force Jim to retire next election) – 2 nips

If Jim Anderton loses Wigram to Labour – 3 nips

If the Greens don’t make 5% – 4 nips (nothing personal, just means Helen is goneburger then)

If Mark wins Wellington Central – 10 shots, one after another.

If Mark makes it as a List MP – 2 nips

If the Lower North Island Region (Napier and Whanganui down) gets nine National MPs – 3 nips

If LNI gets ten National MPs – 5 nips

If Helen has to try and negotiate a deal with both the Greens and the Maori Party – 2 nips

If National wins the most seats – 4 nips

If National ends up clearly able to form a Government – 15 shots in a row

If the Libertarianz win a seat or make 5% – stop drinking due to hallucinations

If Helen loses and blames it all on Michael Cullen – 4 nips

Suggestions for others welcome.

Thanks

Well it has been a fun election campaign. The only thing better than seeing democracy in progress, is participating in it. Has been a mad five weeks. I doubt I’ve ever been busier in my life, but adrenaline is a wonderful thing to keep you going.

A long list of thanks to various people, in no particular order.

To Don, thanks for taking National from the 20s to the 40s. You’ve made this election the most competitive in recent history and you currently are leading the odds at Centrebet to become Prime Minister in a couple of weeks.

To Mark, has been the best getting to know you and your family. Your unfailing loyalty has been appreciated, and I can’t wait for you to be an MP. And damn it, we are going to have a hell of a lot of fun the next three years. Hopefully even in the next three days 🙂

To Steven, Greg, Jo and the team at HQ, congratulations on the best run campaign I can recall. And John – you are a legend for the billboards.

To all the people who have helped out in Wellington Central, thank you for your work and efforts. I am amazed at the number of people who will give up every spare hour for months on end to help out.

To Jordan, it has been surreal working together at InternetNZ, while helping run opposing campaigns as evidenced by our discussions yesterday about how we need to meet on Monday to plan for the half dozen meetings we need to manage next week. I’m glad it’s stayed friendly for almost all of the campaign, and that we are still on speaking terms. Looking forward to having a drink with you on Saturday, regardless of location.

To all the Wellington Central candidates, well done on your contributions to the election. I think it’s been a top class field of candidates ranging from experienced MPs like Stephen Franks to Bernard from the Libertarianz. I’ve immensely enjoyed the meet the candidate meetings.

To all the staff at Curia, thanks for your work over the last few months. Huge thanks especially to Katrina and Anna who took over much of the day to day management to free me up for the politics.

To my flatmate/squatter, big thanks for keeping me sane and actually making sure I didn’t exist solely off microwave meals.

To family and friends, thanks for understanding that when I don’t return your phone calls four times in a row, it isn’t because I now hate you, just that I’m busy.

To all the National Candidates I’ve met and worked with – full of admiration for your willingness to put it all on the line. And can’t wait for Caucus to hopefully double in size or so.

To the National MPs, thanks for not fucking anything up too badly 🙂

[Heh, in case my sense of humour offends anyone, I will elaborate. During a campaign MPs only get significant publicity (unless they are on the front bench) if they stuff up so to some degree, so the challenge is to stick to the script, work your butt off and just work 80+ hours a week supporting the team, for little publicity. A thankless task often]

To all the people who have sent me material, tip-offs, jokes, files – thanks. Keep it up!

And oh yeah to the people who are stupid enough to read this blog, and the even more stupid ones who post comments, thanks for visiting so often.

To Frog Blog, thanks for being such a good sport as we bait each other. It is great that whenever I am bored I can take a swipe at the Greens, and be guaranteed a response within a short period of time.

Oh and big cheers to the Young Nats and Young ACT guys and gals for their willingness to spoil photo opportunities for the Prime Minister. Great stuff.

Anyway that’s enough from me. Only a couple more posts today as I am actually gaining a social life back and going to see a Gilbert and Sullivan musical tonight.

A voting guide based on who you vote

The Hooters Staff Manual

Attacking the messengers

Clark and Cullen really don’t like public servants who tell the truth.

Insolent Prick has highlighted this veiled threat to the Ombudsmen:

“Cullen said he held serious concerns about the precedent created, and would take the matter up with his office after the election. ”

Outrageous. He gets caught trying to suppress vital information, and his response is to blame the Ombudsmen. Read the fucking Official Information Act – all information should be made public unless there is a very sound reason not to. And helping Labour win the election is not a sound reason.

With Clark endorsing the ethics of Taito Field, and Cullen attacking the Ombudsmen, these (hopefully) last days in office are starting to stink badly.

And we also have Clark jumping in accusing Treasury of incompetence. This from the Government which had Michael Cullen write a letter instructing Treasury to assume that there will be *no* change to the rate of voluntary repayments if there is no interest on loans.

Not a single economist in NZ could or would try and defend that assumption. It is to be blunt a lie. One can argue all you want about changes to the rate of borrowing, but no-one at all can argue that abolishing interest would not affect the rate of voluntary repayments. This is like saying if there was no interest charged on credit cards, everyone would still pay them off on time. It almost qualifies for fraud, to instruct Treasury to make such an assumption, and then release costings based on that instruction while suppressing the original costings.

On behalf of Dr Cullen I apologise to all the staff at Treasury for making you produce such a bogus costing.

Helen does a jug scull

No not that Helen, but Helen Simpson standing for ACT in Auckland Central.

The ‘petite’ Simpson took up the AUSA challenge and whipped the arse off the Maori Party candidate.

Well done Helen!

And how does ACT get all the spunky candidates? There should be some quota to share them out equally. They are already over quota with Heather Roy.

NZ Herald gets it wrong

This is a common, but serious, mistake. The NZ Herald has written about the alleged over-spending in Tauranga and refers to the Creech-Boorman electoral petition where Creech replaced Boorman in Wairarapa in 1988.

The Herald states that Creech was declared elected because Boorman had broken the spending limits. This is incorrect. Creech was declared elected because the electoral court found he got more votes than Boorman. Yes Boorman was also found guilty of over spending which invalidated his own personal vote for himself, but that would merely have seen a by-election if it were not for the fact that the Court also found that Creech won more votes after it ruled on some disputed ones.

So (and I have checked this out) if Clarkson wins and is found to have over-spent (something strongly denied, and as far as I am aware verified by lawyers), then this does not elect Peters, but merely voids the election and a by-election would be held.

And if NZ First did not make 5% and had dropped out of Parliament, but Peters won the subsequent by-election, this would not qualify them for any List MPs.

Clark refuses to act on Field

Everyday as more information comes out on the actions of Taito Phliip Field, his actions appear more and more indefensible. However the PM has no problems at all with a Minister of the Crown acting in such an unethical way. It really is proof that her standards are non existant. I mean she hasn’t even called for any sort of inquiry.

The Minister’s wife has contradicted her husband on whether he was employed. And it is estimated that Field got $20,000 worth of work in exchange for paying $54 a week.

We also have comment that it is almost unheard of for a declined refugee application to then be given a work permit.

Tony Ryall sums it up by saying “You simply can’t have ministers arranging work permits for people who work for them”.

You can’t, except when Helen Clark says so it seems.

NZ Herald Poll

Somewhat bizarrely the NZ Herald Poll shows Labour 7% ahead and able to form a sole party majority Government. With all due respect, but if anyone believes that is a possible outcome, then I have a bridge for sale.

Both this poll and the TV3 poll cover a period of around a week, starting late last week. The only poll just done this week is TV One. This is not to say TV One is necessairly the likely outcome as the electorate is volatile, but that as so much has happened in the last week, it is dangerous to compare polls taken over different time periods.

Dr Dekel, owner of Digipoll, himself says “To get a correct picture when people are shifting their views so quickly, you need a high-speed camera”.

Anyway you have TV One and Fairfax putting National ahead both by 6%. TV3 says Labour by 2% and NZ Herald Labour by 7%. Unlike 2002 when most polling companies got the result pretty spot on, this election is going to be fulfilling or embarrassing for some of the polling companies.

Just like in the United States, results may come down to which set of voters are most motivated to vote!

VUWSA Election Results

Nick Kelly won the Presidency.

The Vice-Presidencies went to current General Executive members, Miri Duffield (education) and Maddy Drew (welfare).

The Treasurer is Hu Jia.

The Women’s Rights Officer is Caroline Prendergast.

The University Council Representative is current General Exec member Cordelia Black.

The General Executive compromises of Melissa Barnard, Kate McEachen, Joeleo Cosgrove, Christopher (CJ) Hunt, and Delia Timms.

Publications Committee was won by Nicholas O’Kane

The bio on the new President includes:

Nick Kelly’s background includes being kicked out of the Labour Party in 2002 for opposing sending troops to Afghanistan and interjecting Helen Clark’s conference speech. He is a current member of the Anti-Capitalist Alliance. He is a 23 year old BA graduate. He has been arrested, but not charged, three times for burning the flag, occupying Star Mart and for the incident at the Labour conference.

Should be a fun year in 2006.

Epsom Poll

Roy Morgan, who publish the well known Australian Morgan Polls, have published a poll of Epsom and on their website state the poll of 475 electors had Hide on 39%, Worth on 32% and Nash on 11%. The 11% undecided are leaning towards Worth by 10:1 though which suggest Worth narrowly ahead after probing.

Roy Morgan is a reputable firm, and I wouldn’t dismiss their poll results as they are willing to put them on their site. However they have not published the actual question they asked, and what questions if any preceded it, so I am not quite sure how to analyse it, except that there may be a backlash to Clark telling Labour to vote Worth.

Final TV Polls

TV3 poll shows Labour 2% ahead while TV One shows National 6% ahead. Important to note that TV3 was done from Thursday to Wednesday while TV One was more recent being from Monday to Wednesday.

Both have a significant trend to National. TV3 has had the gap move 7% in National’s favour (9% to 2%) and TV One move 4% (6% lead from 2% lead). Both polls only include one day of the student loan cost expose.

Anyway TV3 would have a seat allocation as follows:

National 48
United Future 4
NZ First 8

CR 60 seats

Labour 50
Green 8
Maori 2
Progressive 1

CL 61 seats

TV One seat allocation would be:

National 55
United Future 3
NZ First 7

CR 65 seats

Labour 47
Green 6
Maori 2
Progressive 1

CL 56 seats

I understand the Herald poll tomorrow has Labour marginally ahead. This will add to the confusion, but again useful to note the different time periods. TV3 is over a seven day period, while TV One is the last three days. Not sure yet what period Herald poll covers.

Electorate Tactical Voting

I have already blogged my view on tactical voting around the party vote, and pointed out why no party can ever put out a message other than give your party vote to us.

Now in discussing electorate voting, I want to stress that this is not advice directed at any particular seat. In fact it is not advice at all, merely my views on what factors are important in making tactical decisions.

The electorate vote is somewhat different. It is certainly less important than the party vote. It is not unimportant, however, just less important. But certainly the party vote is king.

Given a choice between National winning Government and not winning a seat, I

Please Miss can I go to the toilet?

Auckland Roads

Just got phone spammed

Heh Rodney Hide just phone spammed me with a automated voice call asking me to vote ACT 🙂

Technically not spam, in that I reserve that term for those mechanisms where the recepient effectively pays for the delivery such as e-mail.

And just to go totally off topic Brash has just become the favourite at Centrebet with $1.80 to $1.90 for Clark.

Saturday

If anyone local has a laser printer which I could borrow for the day on Saturday, it would be very useful. My office one has died and I won’t be able to get it fixed in time. Doesn’t need to be a huge grunty one, just something that can print off some name and number lists faster than an inkjet at draft speed.

Also if any “friendlies” have some spare time that day, would be happy to have some help with data entry etc. We’ll provide you with some food and also get you an invite to our party that night. Note you should be known to me personally or be able to be vouched by someone whom I know.

Bomb Threat in Tauranga

Biggest Party does not equal Government

Just a reminder to people that there is a difference between being the biggest party and forming the Government. Certainly Labour have had a bad week with a corruption scandal and the cover blown on the student loans bribe. And I would be surprised if this does not translate into National being the biggest party.

However the left have a four way bloc of the Maori Party, the Greens, Progressive and Labour. And the target is for National plus potential allies to outpoll them in terms of the effective (non wsted) vote.

I think it will be a very close, and thrilling, election night with multiple variables such as:

* Maori Party overhang
* Progressive overhang
* Do ACT, Greens and NZ First make it

all affecting the outcome of who forms a Government.

Student Newspaper Editors

Most of the student newspaper editors are being interviewed on Breakfast TV now.

Emily from Salient wins the oscar for best dressed.

Holly from Critic seemed the most articulate.

Nick from AUT best debater.

Gareth from Canta most left wing (in a tight competition)