Ouch

Labor drops support for compulsory student associations!

Not NZ Labour sadly, but Australian Labour.

This is a significant u-turn and must send a signal to NZ that VSM is inevitable. Labor’s u-turn is based on there being a facilities fee at teriary institutes. This is not a big issue here as most institutes already have a facilities fee.

Portraying Don Brash

Goodness it has been fascinating to see all the attempts to paint Don Brash as some sort of throwback to the 19th century. His latest crime is declaring he is not a feminist. I’m sorry people but get real – regardless of the technical definition, a guy labelling himself a feminist is just silly. It’s the sort of thing Steve Maharey would do.

The left are desperately trying to portray Brash as reactionary. This is an incredibly false portrait of a man who is a genuine market and social liberal. As seen yesterday in response to questions at Grey Power.

Despite an audience very much wanting to hear a conservative message, Brash made very clear he supports civil unions, and the prostitution law reform.

Don’s main crime has been to twice take National ahead in the polls, thus making it crucial he is ‘taken down’.

Not exactly hard labour

The Dominion Post reports on life at Arohata Prison, where Donna Awatere-Huata will probably reside. Inmates get:

* An unlocked chalet-style cell
* Personal TV
* La-Z-Boy Armchair
* Communal kitchen between four
* Weekly visits to the supermarket

The other interesting fact was that 60% of inmates come from the Hawke’s Bay. That is a staggeringly high figure for a prison which takes in the entire lower North Island.

Even her Ministers are embarrassed

Yay!

National has announced it is going to reintroduce discretion for police officers with regard to motorists exceeding the speed limit.

Now this is not some new experiment – this is returning the situation to what it was before George Hawkins got his hands on it. It means a police officer will be able to use his or her discretion whether to merely warn or ticket a motorist. That means they can take account of the conditions such as the road, the weather etc.

This will be very welcome by rank and file police. I know many have been unhappy with being forced into automatic revenue generation, rather than being able to use their experience and discretion to deal with situations.

Party Leaders

Rod Donald, Greens

No 1 priority is to stop free trade. Encourage people to buy NZ made. Raise minimum wage to $12/hr – will protect against competition from low wage economies.

Great question from audience on how can you expect anyone to allow us to export to them, if we block their imports. Donald said the balance of payments could be used as justification for an across the board tariff.

Peter Dunne, United Future

Family is core of society. Most businesses are small family businesses and they will deliver wealth so we can deliver social policy objectives. Crushed by too much regulation. Favour trade deals. Must grow cake, not restrict us to our boundaries. Green Govt would lead to lower dollar – overnight 🙂

United Future has contributed to stable government which has been good for growth.

In response to questions he said could consider keeping on party hopping law. Said biggest party gets first chance to negotiate but not guarantee they will go with them. Is becoming apparent policy not far off NZ First – will not give any indication of Labour over National.

Jim Anderton, Progressive

Only party which is promoting economic growth. Not supporting tariffs. Announced 1000 scholarships worth $12,000 a year.

In question to exchange rate volatility, said best politicians do not interfere (clap clap).

Rodney Hide, ACT

Vision is a free and prosperous NZ. You need to be free to prosper. Goal is to bake a bigger cake, not reslice it up. Business owners are retiring early due to hassle from Government. Govt should concentrate on core tasks. Support free market and free prices. Private property and contractual rights import. Could marry and divorce the guy next door in a civil union easier than I could hire and fire him [huge applause]. Supports civil unions but also supports rights for two parties to contract without government interference.

Heh someone got up and said I live in Epsom, so what should I do. Sean Plunkett said “Hope you don’t live next door to Rodney” in reference to marrying guy next door quip.

Don Brash, National

Was a DVD as he had a last minute clash. Sean Plunkett quipped at least easy to cut him off if he goes over time – just switch the DVD off 🙂

Gap with Australia has gone from $5K to $9K so 600 a week going to Australia. Productivity has improved, but not enough. Tax cuts are important but also need better infrastructure such as roads. Need more energy infrastructure and reduce business compliance costs such as OSH, ACC, HASNO, RMA.

Wananaga got eight times more funding than all apprentices combined. Of Labour’s seven pledges, only one is at all related to increasing economic growth.

Heh Rodney offered to answer questions on behalf of Don.

Party Finance Spokesperson Scores

They all did okay – no-one stunning and no-one flopped.

Michael Cullen, Labour – 8/10

No sign of the razor wit. Made his case well, but not sexy.

John Key, National – 8/10

John made the case for tax relief well.

Winston Peters, NZ First – 7/10

Actually showed some of his knowledge as a former Treasurer on what causes inflation.

Rodney Hide, ACT – 8/10

Very passionate and connected well.

Rod Donald, Greens – 7/10

Very solid, but opposition to free trade not go down well.

Gordon Copeland, United Future – 8/10

The surprise almost star. Proposed comprehensive tax changes, and made good point about business backgrounds of most of their MPs.

Dr Jon Johansson

For a couple of weeks now I have been intrigued by the commentary of Dr Jon Johansson on the election. He is being quoted almost everywhere on who is doing well, who isn’t etc. And I had been surprised by how unfailing he was in praise of Labour and Helen Clark and negative on Don Brash.

Now nothing wrong with people having their personal preferences, but when they get trotted out as a “neutral expert” every day then it is is not quite the required balance from media.

Of course it may just be that I am a partisan hack, and hence I had not acted on my instincts. But yesterday we had the candidates forum for school students at Vic Uni. The candidates were on after lunch and before lunch they had a ‘neutral briefing’ on each party and their policies by Dr Johansson. And when I turned up at lunchtime, not one but many students were complaining about how biased the ‘neutral briefing’ had been. So then I thought perhaps it isn’t just me, if even school students are picking this up.

So I went to my friend Google to see what Dr Johansson has to say on Helen Clark:

“With Helen Clark, in contrast, you sense that although she’s in no doubt about what she believes in, she has decided what she’s willing to compromise in order to achieve what in her mind is the greater good.

So positive spin for lack of principle.

“I’m incredibly admiring of her taking off for overseas holidays. That is such a healthy behaviour in a political leader.”

Wow even approves of her holidays.

Victoria University political scientist Dr Jon Johansson said he was sure Ms Clark would have been appalled by the [Holocaust] comment.

And can speak on her behalf as to how offended she would be by a comment.

But perhaps he is equally generous to Don Brash. Let’s see firstly this interview with Salient:

One person not sold on the policy or integrity of Don Brash is Victoria University New Zealand Politics lecturer Jon Johansson. Johansson says the Orewa speech is the result of the

Party Finance Spokespersons

The questions are:

1) Will you lower the company tax rate and/or personal tax rates? If so, when?

2) Will you set a cap on core Government spending as a percentage of GDP? If so, what would that cap be?

3) Will you commit to reducing the regulatory burden on businesses by ensuring new and existing legislation is subject to a Regulatory Responsibility Act?

4) Will you commit to work towards free trade agreements, and on what basis?

Answers below:
Continue reading »

Debt Projections

Keith Ng blogged last night that debt under National would increase by $12.8 billion. Many on the left have copied and linked to the post.

However Keith was wrong, and has done the very decent thing by correcting the record, which is a small increase of only $3.2 billion. Nice thing about blogs.

The lesson for future may be that just because staff are not on hand at 730 pm at night to talk to you, it is worth waiting to talk to them the next morning – especially when not on a daily deadline like a newspaper. Especially after you have been told that John Key has said you are wrong.

In Praise of Female Sexuality

The Sydney Morning Herald published a column titled “In Praise of Female Sexuality“.

It actually is a well argued case for better parental leave, but captures you attention with statements such as:

There is nothing wrong with pelvic display, push-up bras, Gosford miniskirts, spray-on jeans, low-cut tops, bare legs, bare arms, bare ankles, G-strings or even buttock cleavage, providing the displayer is young enough to get away with it. A woman’s body is at its fertility peak between the ages of 17 and 23. So when young women advertise or flaunt their sexuality they are being driven by a force far stronger than the Judeo-Christian ethic. They are driven by the power of peak fertility and a million years of evolutionary biology. Nature has programmed them for pregnancy, genetic diversity and keeping the species going. A big job.

Well I’m not going to disagree 🙂

Vote ACT if you are a Christian!

Transport Scores

Pete Hodgson, Labour – 8/10

Positioned himself well as having delivered funding.

Maurice Williamson, National – 9/10

Maurice was in great form. Got some laughs and left no-one in doubt of commitment.

Peter Brown, NZ First – 7/10

Much better on this issue. Clear positioning.

Roland Saspford, Greens – 4/10

Was hostile and confrontational to the audience, basically calling them idiots. A contrast to the previous Green speaker who articulated clear differences in a respectful way.

Ken Shirley, Act – 8/10

Managed to cover related issues such as Kyoto, Very good.

Larry Baldock, United Future – 7/10

Clear and concise but came across unrealistic with his suggestion of a four lane motorway from Kaitaia to Invercargill.

Transport

The questions to each MP are:

1) Will you ensure that all tax collected from road users is used for roading?

2) Will you change the Land Transport Management Act to give higher priority to building and maintaining roads?

3) Will you change the Land Transport Management Act to make it easier for private sector investment in roads, including tolling by private companies?

Answers over the break:
Continue reading »

Pat Robertson is insane

Pat Robertson has always been rather loopy, but he goes off the deep end with his call for the United States to assassinate Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez. Mad!

I suppose it is no surprise coming from a man who one said feminism “encourages women to leave their husbands, kill their children, practice witchcraft, destroy capitalism and become lesbians.”

Workplace Law Scores

Damn it, I will score the MPs – keeps it interesting for readers:

Paul Swain, Labour – 7/10

Spoke well, and delivered unpopular message without being confrontational

Wayne Mapp, National – 8/10

Concise and covered key issues well

Peter Brown, NZ First – 2/10

To be blunt was almost a joke with no specifics at all, just oh we want everyone to be nice to each other.

Lucy Highfield, Greens – 8/10

While no-one would have agreed with her views, she put the case for her position very well.

Stephen Franks, ACT – 9/10

Stephen gets an extra mark for the quip about what did Tonga do to deserve Judge Goddard and Ross Wilson.

Gordon Copeland, United Future – 7/10

Solid performance with specifics, despite attempt to be centrist.

Workplace Law

The questions to each MP were:

1) Will you remove from the ERA the union monopoly on collective bargaining?

2) Will you remove from the ERA the presumption that employees are always at a bargaining disadvantage?

3) Will you change the ERA to allow for effective grievance-free probationary periods?

4) Will you change the Holidays Act to restore the ability of the parties to negotiate holiday payments

5) Will you restore choice to ACC legislation, so businesses are free to choose private accident cover if they wish?

6) Do you support the target of having 250,000 people in industry and trade training by 2007, and what changes, if any, would you make to funding arrangements to achieve this?

Answers are over the break:
Continue reading »

BusinessNZ Conference

I’m live-blogging the BusinessNZ Election Conference as they were kind enough to ask me if I would cover it. I’m on the media bench along with a collection of actual journalists!

There are 25 MPs speaking, and the agenda is:

* The workplace
* Transport
* Environment & Energy
* The Economy
* Election Survey Results
* Party Leaders

I’ll do a blog on each section, plus anything else which grabs my interest. I’m thinking of giving each MP a grade out of ten, but I’ve found that can also be a good way to offend a lot of MPs!

Disclosure: BusinessNZ has paid the $49.95 cost of a 24 hour wireless connection (an outrageous price the hotel charges) at the Hotel Intercontinental for me, plus supplying the normal free lunch 🙂

A clear choice

The Press conclude’s today’s editorial by saying:

Voters can choose between the statist, redistributionist recipe of the Centre-Left and a Centre-Right alternative which encourages enterprise by letting taxpayers retain more of the money they have earned through their hard work.

Indeed!

Student Loan Calculator

The Dominion Post reports over a million ‘hits’ within 12 hours for National’s tax cuts calculator.

The student loan calculator on National’s site under-estimates significantly the benefits for students, as it assumes you will stay on the same income level. My own calculator in excel allows students to set a number of variables to see how much better off they will be with National’s package. Your loan has to get to be over $150,000 almost to do better with Labour.

NZ Herald on Labour U-turn

The NZ Herald concludes that Labour’s u-turn on early childhood funding was released on the day of National’s tax cuts because they were embarrassed.

The Herald states that 63% of childcare centres were privately owned and ineligible for funding by Labour. You have to wonder about the decision making of a Government which didn’t even check out facts like this before making an decision. But hey who needs facts when you have ideolology.

The Herald also reminds us that “too many people were perhaps willing to believe Mr Mallard’s insinuation that private centres provided an inferior standard of early education.”

The Herald concludes “If the u-turn on early education is the sign of an ideological relaxation, education at all levels could be the better for it.”

Sadly it is not. The u-turn was forced on them due to the election campaign. If re-elected there is little doubt Labour will continue to tilt the balance against the private sector whenever and where ever they can. Rather ironic as it is the private sector which pays the tax which allows them to spend so much money.

Cellphones in Cars

Now as a general rule, I’m against banning cellphone use in cars. The vast majority of drivers can sensible decide when it is or is not safe to use a cellphone. Certainly there are times I’ll let the phone ring unanswered because I need all my concentration.

But going around a corner, having hit 170 kms/hr and having both a cigarette and a cellphone in your hand is insanity – and sadly fatal for three people.

Blogs by Party Affiliation

Grant is annoyed