School Students Forum

Just got back from a very enjoyable 90 minute forum at Vic Uni with over 200 sixth and seventh formers from Marsden and Scots. All parties were represented by MPs except Mark for National and Fiona for United. Winston represented NZF, Marian Labour, Sue Kedgley Greens and Heather Roy ACT.

Winston as usual was in jovial form, and connected well. Only downside was when Heather pointed out he forgot to mention to all the students he is promising to give retired people lots more dosh.

Funniest line of the afternoon belonged to Mark in response to a question on sterilising rapists. Fiona from UF supported this, and then tried to explain it was reversible (if they were later found innocent) as it involves pills. Mark’s quip “What you don’t sew it back on” brought the house down.

An Asian student got huge cheers when he asked Winston about his immigration policy.

And one MP didn’t go down to well when a student asked why shouldn’t murderers be kept in for life, and she firstly told the student one day he may be a criminal, and then compared it to speeding – saying you don’t lose your licence for life if you speed.

But all in all very good natured, and the students did well, even though some of the questions were very slanted (Cars are killing the planet, so why are we building more roads was one example).

They had a mock election afterwards. The results were:

Party Vote

National 43%
NZ First 22%
Labour 18%
Greens 17%

Personal Vote

Blumsky 49%
Peters 34%
Sue Kedgeley 10%
Hobbs 8%

Awatere-Huata found guilty

Making it simple

A massive u-turn

People should not under-estimate the size of Labour’s u-turn on childcare funding. You almost have to admire the audacity of them for claiming they are delighted to be able to do it – this decision is one they made most grudgingly.

In almost every portfolio Labour has tried to dick over the private sector. Hospitals, tertiary education, prison management, childcare – you name it and Labour has tipped the scales towards public sector provision only. Labour supporters just a few days on this blog were defending Labour’s decision not to extend funding to private childcare services.

But the backlash got too much. I had picked up that a huge number of parents were pissed off that Labour put ideology over common sense even when it comes to three year olds, so finally they relented.

The Debates

Because I have such strong feelings on the people involved I do not always trust my own instincts on debates. Sometimes I am much harder on my own ‘side’ than other people. Other times I think they are doing better because I know the other side is speaking crap, but the public doesn’t see it that way.

There was a clear consensus that Brash did not do well in the TV3 debate. Radio NZ was much closer. Those listening on the radio felt it was around 55% Clark to 45% Brash while those who were there scored it a bit stronger for Clark.

The TV One debate though was fascinating. Certainly the PM dominated in terms of speaking time and getting her lines away. But I am picking up a lot (and I mean a lot) of negative reaction to her behaviour. And after a slow start, Brash seemed to really hit his stride as he sucessfully got across the point that National will increase government spending by an average $1.5 billion a year and deliver tax cuts.

Vernon Small and Tracy Watkins declare Brash a narrow winner on the night. Also Colin Espiner gives it to Brash on points. Now unless one is addicted to ‘P’, no-one would label Vernon, Tracy and Colin as stooges of the new right, so their assessment is pretty credible.

Also well done to Mark Sainsbury for actually letting the Leaders debate each other. It was very welcome.

UPDATE: Adam Hamilton was in the audience and blogs his views. It seems that they were told not to interject, but alas about as much effect as King Canute.

PM finally speaks on motorcade

The PM has finally spoken up on the motorcade issue. To my amazement she turned down a wonderful opportunity to express sincere empathy for what were effectively her staff getting convicted for trying to get her to her plane on time.

Instead she has:
* sheeted home the blame for it on the police
* effectively called one of the police officers a liar, despite his evidence being given under oath
* disputed the judge’s conclusion that there had been a couple of points of danger during that journey.

NZ Herald comparison

The NZ Herald has a nice comparison of Labour and National’s packages.

The big lines of 0s for single people under Labour is telling.

In the story we also see the personal attacks from Cullen, suggesting this is two multi-millionaires doing it to get $92 a week extra. How pathetic.

Don Brash took a $400,000 pay cut to enter politics. To suggest he is motivated by personal gain is ridiculous. Likewise I would suggest that John Key (who grew up in a state home and made his own fortune) is not particularly focused on $92 a week for him.

I suspect the reason Cullen is so upset is because National in fact resisted giving him an easy target by lowering the 39% rate. If that had been lowered to 33%, then he would be out saying that someone earning $1 million a year will get a $60,000 tax cut. By only moving the threshold, National has in fact ensured that the super-rich are the ones who get the smallest tax cut, relative to what they earn.

Tax Thresholds

The more I think about the tax thresholds announced by National, the more I like them because they reflect what most NZers would regard as fair. In one sense they are playing catchup to a lack of movement in the last six years.

$50,000 is a pretty fair level at which to be regarded as “comfortable” and I love the idea that people will pay no more than 19% marginal rate for their first $50,000 of income. This will make a huge difference for new employees, those needing to save for a deposit etc.

Likewise moving the top tax rate to only come in at $100,000 also works well. Psychologically that is the level many people aspire to as “well off” and while personally I would like to see the 39% rate disappear in time, if you have to have one that is a good place for it to come in.

Labour’s average student

Interesting to look at Labour’s average student with a starting salary of $38,000 and a loan of $40,000.

Not only would they pay their loan off two years quicker under National, but their nominal (non compounded or inflation adjusted) extra income after it is paid off is over $120,000 over their working life.

Labour’s student loan policy will only affect students for a few years – National’s will deliver lower taxes for life. And let’s be honest it is very obvious that Labour would never ever reduce taxes in future.

The other useful thing with National’s policy is students get the benefits of it the moment they are working. With Labour they don’t get any change to their disposable income until the loan is paid off.

1st week’s sleep

Okay 1st week of five for the campaign survived. My cunning plan to sleep during the day to make up for late nights and early mornings has only been partly sucessful. Sleep for week has been:

Monday 1 am – 4.30 am = 3.5 hrs
Tuesday 2 am – 6 am = 4 hrs
Wednesday 1 am – 4.30 am + 12.30 pm – 3.30 pm = 6.5 hrs
Thursday 2 am – 4.30 am + 5.30 pm – 9.30 pm = 6.5 hrs
Friday 1 am – 430 am = 3.5 hrs
Saturday 1 am – 6 am = 5 hrs
Sunday 10 pm – 5 am = 7 hrs
Monday – no sleep (yet)

So 36 hours over eight days. Only four weeks to go!

My own student loan calculator

National’s online calculator does the basic comparisons between National and Labour for students. However it doesn’t take into account the fact people do not stay on the same salary for life etc.

Therefore I have put together my own calculator in excel. Now do let me know if there is an error in it, but I have tested it and it looks okay. It takes account of both current interest writeoffs, National’s tax deduction policy for interest and also tax cuts which can be used as voluntary repayments.

Basically it allows you to plug in five variables (highlighted in bold):

* Your starting/present income
* Loan Principal
* Interest Rate (keep at 7% unless you want to play)
* Annual salary increase (Labour recommends on their calculator this be at least 3%)
* Inflation Rate (Currently 2.8%, long-term should be 1.5%)

Now using the standard Labour example of $40K loan, $38K salary, 3% salary growth and 2.8% inflation the calculator shows 15 years to pay it off under Labour and 13 years under National. Yep that’s right pay it off two years earlier and also once paid off you also get all the benefits of future tax savings.

On a $38,000 starting salary you would need a loan balance of over $100,000 to be better oiff with Labour.

The only thing not taken into account, I think, is Labour chewing gum promise to move tax thresholds every three years. It isn’t that major and besides I suspect in three years National would be looking at a further round of tax cuts anyway.

Anyway have a play – feedback welcome – and feel free to pass on.

Under $50,000 and maximum 18% tax

If you earn up to $50,000, then under National your effective tax rate will be between 15% and a maximum of 18%. That’s great for letting low to middle income workers keep more of their money – rather than forcing them to pay more tax so benefits can be paid to families with children earning over $100,000

And for those who claim the ‘rich’ will get the most benefit from the tax cuts. Well for those who earn over $100,000 they will go from paying 25.1% of all personal tax to 26.3%. Yes as the biggest taxpayers they get the biggest nominal amount back, but they do not get the biggest percentage – in fact they end up paying a greater share of the tax take.

The income which gets the largest percentage decrease is $50,000 – those on $50,000 will have their tax will reduce by a whopping 20.7%.

Also those on national super will benefit by $560 for a married couple, as the pension is calculated as a percentage of the average after tax wage.

Tax Calculator

Tax Calculator

Tax Savings

These are just my quick calculations.

If on $40,000 you’ll save $950
On $50,000 you save $2,350
On $70,000 you save $2,950
On $100,000 plus the saving is $4,750

The income bracket which gets the largest percentage decrease is $50,000 – their tax will reduce by a whopping 20.7%.

Also those on national super will benefit by $560 for a married couple, as the pension is calculated as a percentage of the average after tax wage.

National’s Tax Cuts

* The 15% tax rate, which now applies to income below $9,500 will extend to $12,500.
* For income between $12,500 and $50,000, the tax rate will be 19% (down from 21%)
* Income between $50,000 and $100,000 will be taxed at 33%. (threshold increased by $40,000)
* Income above $100,000 will continue to be taxed at 39%.

Also the threshold for abatement of WFF payments will be $30,000 from April 2006, and to keep the effective tax rate on extra income low, the abatement rate will be 20%.

The company tax rate will be reduced to 30% in April 2008.

Faux Pax II

Simon: Gidday David. You haven’t met my wife

DPF: Hi. Actually I think we have met – a couple of conferences ago

Wife: No this is my first conference. That would have been Simon’s previous blond girlfriend

People shouldn’t marry people of the same hair colour of exes!

The Press endorses tax cuts

The Press has endorsed tax cuts in today’s editorial. Key points are:

* One thing, at least, has been cleared up early in the current election campaign: the myth that tax cuts were impossible has been shown to be false

* Its [Labour’s] latest promise would create beneficiaries out of those who only a few years ago the Labour Party decreed were “rich” and should be taxed at a higher rate

* As fast as the revenue has grown, spending has grown even faster. Much of it has been hugely wasteful.

* The waste in junk polytechnic courses and suchlike have become notorious, the failure to improve health outcomes despite all the extra money that has been spent is well known.

* Above all, tax cuts that would deliver the right signals to hard-working, productive, enterprising workers and businesses are necessary. Incentives for growth should be spread as widely as possible to produce the maximum benefit. Taxing one group of New Zealanders to provide privileges and advantages for others is no way to achieve social justice or the economic advancement we need.

I can’t recall a recent editorial that has made the case for something so well.

Faux Pax

Driving up to Auckland, I was expounding on my theory that we should only have four universities (Otago, Canterbury, Victoria and Auckland) and the rest should be polytechnics etc. Conversation goes like this:

DPF: Waikato is not a proper university – a law degree from there makes you almost unemployable
Neill: How about Massey
DPF: Also doesn’t make the grade. Most students are extra-mural so it is really just a glorified correspondence school
Neill: And Bernadette, what are you studying at the moment
Bernadette: I’m doing a degree extra-murally through Massey

An extended silence followed.

Keith Ng on Steven Ching

Heh yes it rhymes. Anyway Keith has blogged (on Tze Ming Mok’s blog just to confuse people) about Steven Ching, and he doesn’t hold back.

Ng holds Labour responsible for “selecting someone who doesn’t really speak English, doesn’t understand New Zealand politics, doesn’t seem to care about either, and who was clearly never going to make any genuine contribution beyond raking in donations.”

He winds up further saying “Labour, by selecting someone who was obviously never going to be able to contribute anything as a representative, they have demonstrated a genuine commitment to the idea that Chinese New Zealanders are nothing more than passive participants who should have a token role in the democratic process because, really, they’re just a bunch of rich, greedy foreigners who don’t even speak English anyway.”

Wow this make’s Aaron’s coverage look balanced 🙂

Secondary tax rates

I know a lot of the students who work for me will love National’s policy to reduce the deduction rate for secondary tax to under 20% from the current 33%.

Many students have a couple of part-time jobs. Their combined income puts them in the lowest tax bracket but instead of having tax deducted at 15% on their second job, they have more than twice as much deducted and have to wait a year or more to claim it back – if they even remember to. This can make a significant difference to weekly income.

I’d say over half the students who work for me are using a secondary tax code, and will benefit from this. A very sensible change.

Labour-Greens ‘lunacy’

Peter Dunne, who currently supports Labour, has said United Future would refuse to join a coalition which includes the Greens, and it was highly unlikely they could even support it on confidence and supply. This kills off Clark’s preferred strategy of being able to have both Green and UF support, and pick and choose between on depending on the issue.

So if Labour and Greens do not get a majority of seats, then they would need the Maori Party also to form a Labour/Progressive/Green/Maori coalition. Wow that would be interesting, to say the least! 🙂

Spam Law

The Dominion Post has an article on Microsoft wanting the proposed anti-spam law to be opt-out not opt-in. David CUnliffe is absolutely right that this approach would be too weak and open up huge loppholes.

Also good to see that the issue of enforcement models is open for revisiting at select committee. It is a very good bill generally, and will be an excellent one if the enforcement model is changed.

Is it safe to speed when overtaking?

The Transport Safety Minister has said people should not get too prissy over the GG’s car hitting 130 km/hr while overtaking. I actually agree.

The Police national road policing manager has said “overtaking was never an excuse for speeding” and “If a person had to travel at an excess speed to overtake, the decision to overtake in the first place was flawed. ”

Now this is to be blunt just nuts. The useful fastandsafe website calculates that to overtake a truck driving at 90 km/hr, a motorist would need 2075 metres of clear distance, if they were not to exceed the speed limit.

It would be great of those in charge of road safety abandoned the zealotry and used common sense to say that in order to pass a vehicle going slower than the speed limit, it is sensible to temporarily modestly exceed the limit.

Aristotle’s Books

Sadly Aristotle’s Books closed on Saturday. It was great having a dedicated bookshop for classical liberal publications.

On the plus side, by chance, I got to Auckland around an hour before they closed and picked up 14 books (non-fiction) and 19 videos (just popular movies or TV series) for around $140. That is a seriously good bargain – thanks James.

I am now the proud owner of:

* The Holy Qur’an
* A City Possessed by Lynley Hood
* The future of freedom by Fareed Zakaria
* A biography of Hitler by John Toland
* The 1788 publication “The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire” by Edward Gibbon

Now I just need time to read them all!