Don’s Campaign Launch Speech

Concluding part of speech

Highlights to date of Don’s speech

* The Clark Labour Government has run out of ideas. Run out of aspiration, ambition, vision or even hope. And now they have run out of time.

* Between 2000 and 2004, the income tax paid by the average household went up by 24%, almost twice as fast as pre-tax household incomes.

* One of the simplest changes I will formally announce tomorrow is in the field of tax on secondary employment. The New Zealand I hope to lead will be one where we reward, not punish, those who want to get ahead by taking on a second job. So we will change the way in which tax is collected on secondary employment. We will collect that tax at a rate below 20 cents in the dollar, unless the taxpayer asks, in anticipation of a higher tax obligation, for collection to be at a nominated higher rate.

*When a child falls behind in reading or arithmetic, we will give their parents a voucher to buy the extra tuition they need.

* I, Don Brash, will place the protection of New Zealand

Jim Hopkins

Heh Jim Hopkins is very funny. He has just been waving about DBP’s tennis ball and saying he doesn’t know where to stick it, but it won’t be in a mouth. The audience is pretty young for a National event and no-one seemed too offended – in facts lots of laughs.

Things kick off in ten minutes or so and Don on in around thirty minutes. Those who want to can watch the webcast.

UPDATE: “I’m here because Don was too frugal to afford Judy Bailey. If you had here here for what I’m getting she’d only be able to say “Welcome, Good Day and Good Night”

“We wanted to start with a haka but the Deputy Mayor of Auckland couldn’t come”

Slogan for Auckland – “Auckland needs a real dick” and “There is no doubt we have got one”.

“Winston Peters is in the room cunningly disguised as one of Saddam’s henchmen”. “Peter Dunne wasn’t allowed in because he wanted to bring his pet worm”. “The PM is on her way here and is expected in thirty minutes – her motorcade has just passed Rotorua” 🙂

Summary of all the Opening Addresses

The c word

The hall is filling up

United MP has no confidence in Labour

United Future MP and No 4 List Candidate Marc Alexander has said “after three years my supply of confidence has run out” with regards to Labour.

He also indirectly calls his leader “nuts” by saying MPs who will not answer the question “who would you prefer to work with are “nuts”.

Alexander also backs Tamihere’s account of Maharey as “smarmy” (in fact I don’t know anyone who has disagreed with that) saying he could not stand him and he did not trust him.

UPDATE: Talking of United Future, Aaron has spotted that today’s United Future adverts are funded by the taxpayer. It is very naughty to still be using your parliamentary budget for such direct advertising, after Parliament has been dissolved.

National’s Campaign Launch

Got up to Auckland safely. Was a wonderful drive with beautifully fine weather – will blog some photos later. A lovely ferry crossing to Waiheke Island where we are staying.

Heading back into Auckland CIty in an hour or so to prepare for the launch. The launch will be webcast live. I will try to blog some of it, but not sure about Internet access.

Taxpayer funded transgender surgery

The Taranaki Daily News has the story of a 73 year old who has had the Government (you and me) pay for her $30,000 gender reassignment surgery.

One can have a speerate debate about whether the taxpayer should fund such surgery at all, but even if you do accept in principle it may be okay for such funding, I really have to question the appropriateness of such funding for a 73 year old. With scarce health resources surely this is not a priority.

And just to annoy taxpayers even more, we read she can not pay for the surgery herself as she has a gambling habit!

But remember there’s no money available for tax cuts!

Redundent Headline

An NZPA story has the headline “Alleged rabbit abuser has mental problems”.

Who would have guessed it. You have sex with rabbits, and you may have mental problems!!

Incidentially the story itself is quite yucky – even I winced at parts of it, so don’t go there unless you have a strong stomach.

Big Government vs Small Government

Jonathan Milne in the HOS says that Labour is going to pledge a boost in contributions to its Kiwisaver scheme, with the election turning into the starkest choice between big and small government since 1984.

I think this is a point people should remember. Labour wants to not only control how much money you earn (by turning every family into beneficiaries where your income will change depending on government policy) but also want to control your savings by taking money off you and then using it to encourage you to save.

Labour’s vision of Government is one where there is no limits on how much money they take, and what they spend it on. They will, and have, merrily think up 100 ideas a year of new things to spend money on, on your behalf. They will never ever it seems say “Why don’t we give New Zealanders some of their own money back, so they can make those decisions for themselves”.

The language of tax relief

John Armstrong’s column focuses on how Labour is trying to label its social welfare package as tax relief – implicitly agreeing with National and ACT etc that the tax burden is too high and needs releiving.

Frog also doesn’t like that Labour has abandoned its socialist vocabulary and makes the cases for taxes not being a burden, but an investment into society. Well if that is the case then let’s double taxes and imagine how much better off we’ll all be.

Wait for the autobiography

Well arrogance has a new level. Not only will Helen refuse to comment on the convictions of her drivers until after any appeal deadline but she said in the RNZ debate that she will not say anything at all until she publishes her autobiography.

How open and accountable.

DPF in Auckland

There won’t be much blogging this weekend as I’ll be spending most of it on the road. I’m driving a van of staff and Young Nats up to Auckland today for Sunday’s campaign launch, and back again on Sunday afternoon.

Opening Address

$9 billion of tax reduction

National looks set to deliver significant tax relief on Monday, confirming today that the tax cuts over three years will total over $9 billion. The annual reduction from 2008/09 on will be about $3.9 billion.

The forecasts the package was done on, do not include the extra $2.2 billion of revenue revealed in PREFU yesterday.

The reduction in tax will still lead to a healthy OBERAC surplus of 2% of GDP (around $3 billion). And that is after allowing for an extra $1.5 billion a year of new spending.

A small portion of capital expenditure will be funded by debt (as is absolutely normal commercial practice) but the increase in gross debt is less than the $1.7 decrease in net worth if Labour’s student loan bribe was implemented.

The ‘alternative budget’ looks like a very mainstream approach to fiscal management – a 2% of GDP surplus, $1.5 billion a year of new spending and then a reduction in surplus revenue above that level.

Of course people will be keen to see the details of how much particular rates are adjusted by, and how much certain thresholds move. Only three days to go.

David Lange Quotes

Drivers guilty of some charges

The PM’s drivers and escorts have been found guilty of some charges. I feel very sorry for them – ending up with a conviction for trying to get Helen Clark to her plane on time. Yes they used bad judgement with regard to the speeds they went, but considering the lack of clarity in police procedures, it should have been a warning, not prosecution. Without exception every VIP Driver and DPS officer I’ve known has been a first class person focused on doing whatever is necessary to make life easy for the PM.

I am staggered that Helen Clark, even now, is refusing to comment on the case. She claims she won’t be commenting based on legal advice – now the trial is over, so how can there be a legal impediment to commenting??

A second strategic blunder?

I labelled the budget “tax cut” a strategic blunder within 24 hours as the initial reaction was so negative – not that people were not getting something, but at the tactics of Labour trying to have it both ways.

I wonder whether yesterday’s extension to working for families may also be a strategic blunder. The talkback is incredibly hostile, almost everyone without kids is complaining that the Government is using them as cash cows, and the well off families being targeted are saying that they would rather not be dependent on state support.

This may just blow up big time.

Damian Christie at Public Address gives an excellent viewpoint on why he doesn’t like the package. He also works out that even families earning $150,000 will receive a benefit if this is implemented.

I think that New Zealanders have an innate sense of fairness. I hope they will see the massive inequality in taking tax off some New Zealanders to give it to people earning even more than they do, just in the hope of getting their votes.

Even as a semi-libertarian I am happy to pay taxes to support the family on $28,000 income with a couple of kids. I want those kids to grow up well looked after. But I am furious at the thought that a Catholic lawyer on $140,000 will be getting a subsidy from me, because he or she has chosen to have a big family.

The official Clark Brash Drinking Game

Tonight we have the first ever debate between the two contenders for Prime Minister – Helen Clark and Don Brash – on National Radio from 7 pm to 8 pm. We also have the party opening addresses on Tv One at 7.30 p.m.

To allow for more pleasurable viewing and listening, my flatmate and I present the official drinking game rules for the debate and/or the opening addresses.

Drink one sip if

Helen Clark mentions
* Working for Families
* Iraq
* Nuclear
* Better off with Labour
* Free interest on student loans
* More operations

or Don Brash mentions
* Tax Cuts for all working NZers
* Treaty of Waitangi
* Welfare Reform
* RMA means a road takes longer to get consent for than plan
* NCEA
* 600 people a week going to Australia

Drink two sips if

Helen Clark mentions
* RMA
* David Lange
* Pledge card

Don Brash mentions
* Singapore
* One standard of citizenship
* how he used to be a peace protester

Drink three sips if

Helen Clark mentions
* George Hawkins
* Marian Hobbs
* NCEA
* Winston Peters

Don Brash mentions
* Winston Peters
* Iraq
* Nuclear
* Just a few farms

Drink the entire bottle if

Don Brash again says “The Prime Minister is absolutely correct”

Helen Clark says “You wouldn’t be wrong”

Drink everything you have if:

Helen Clark says “Of course I knew how fast we were going, I’m not stupid”

Don Brash says “Gone by lunchtime”

Suggestions for other rules can be made in the comments, and the better amongst them will be added to the official rules!

Labour’s bribe is good news

I welcome yesterday’s announcement that Labour will, if re-elected, spend hundreds of millions more on family support handouts. Never has the electorate been given a clearer contrast between two approaches.

It has also made several things very clear. They are:

1) The debate is over about whether National’s tax policy is affordable. Labour have conceded this one lock stock and barrel after months of scare mongering.

2) Labour will never ever in 100 years even agree to reducing tax rates. Given the choice, yesterday they chose to spend it on handouts.

3) Working for Families is not tax relief. For administrative reasons it is done through the IRD but it is effectively social welfare benefits. You even have to apply to get it (and only 60% have), unlike tax cuts which apply at all taxpayers automatically.

4) This package effectively makes almost every family in NZ a welfare recipient.

5) Students entering the workforce will face higher tax rates so that families earning over $100,000 get subsidised by them. Seriously.

6) Elderly NZers who have income on top of national super will be over-taxed so that families earning over $100,000 get subsidised by them.

7) This is wealth redistribution on a massive scale. Not from rich to poor, but from anyone without children to almost anyone with children. A lawyer on $90,000 will get a welfare handout for having more kids.

8) The difference between Labour and National is stark. National will let NZers keep more of their own money. Labour will never ever give people money back, but instead spend it on your behalf by giving it to target groups as it sees fit.

9) This demolishes the concept of the welfare state as a safety net for those in need. It entrenches what is somewhere between socialistic and communistic principles that have the state take more money than it needs, so it can equalise incomes.

What a cheap bastard

The Manawatu Standard has the story of the first year student who saw an advert for a film experiment and found out they wanted to appear in a porn film.

Now absolutely agree with her on false advertising is bad etc. But what intrigued me is that the cheap bastard making the film was only offering $200. I have no idea what the going rate if for appearing in a porn film, but that sounds miserly if you are going to ask someone to risk years of future recognition etc.

Hmmn just done a Google on “pay rates for porn stars” and got a sponsored link for the NZ Government’s worksite 🙂

However checking other links out I find that maybe he is not that stingy. This article says guys get only US$250 – US$500 a day and girls $500 – $700 a day. You’d have to make a lot of movies to live off that.

I predict guilty

Just to annoy Grant I’ll bypass the legal system and make a prediction for the Donna Awatere-Huata trial. Now I have not heard all the evidence, but the Dominion Post has provided first class coverage through reporter David McLoughlin.

I will be amazed if Donna is not found guilty. Wi Huata might get off, but the prosecution’s case seems over-whelming and the only defence appesr to have been someone saying the SFO didn’t exclude the possibility someone else broke into the Huata’s place to generate fake invoices on their computer, plus a number of character witnesses saying Donna is a lovely person (she isn’t).

Cathy Odgers has her own perspective on Donna on her blog.

He only wanted sex twice a day

The man who was poisoned by his partner because she claimed he wanted sex five times a day, has said he only wanted sex twice a day which he “did not think … was unreasonable in a new relationship”.

One could have a fascinating discussion about what is reasonable in a new relationship and then later on. Does the decline in frequency have a mathemathical formula it follows?

I have to say I think the woman was very lucky to get off. If you don’t want sex as much as your partner, just tell him – don’t poison him. And if you can’t work out a compromise, then split up.

Incidentially the stereotype that women always want it less than men is not something that is universally true based on the number of female friends who have told me how annoyed they are they don’t get to shag their partners more often.