How Government works

A Perinatal and Maternal Review Mortality Committee has been established but without an anaesthetist on board. Why? Because the expert recommended by the Society of Anaesthetists was turned down by the Government.

Why again? Because he is the person who complained to the Police about the PM’s art forgery. So never mind we may not know why infants die in hospitals, as long as those on the blacklist are kept away.

Now the Minister claims he had not been recommended by her ministry, as if it was a decision just made by neutral staff. But this is not how Government works. Departments always discuss proposed recommendations like these with the Minister or his/her political staff before making them. And you can be sure they were left under no doubt not to recommend Dr Sharpe.

St Molesworth: Top 10 things to do if you’re caught speeding

St Molesworth presents their Top 10 things to do if you’re caught speeding

1. Say you were totally engrossed in signing off Cabinet papers on a “Speed Kills” campaign.

2. Claim you didn’t notice how fast you were going because you were too busy painting.

3. Do what the average Kiwi would do and blame the nearest cop.

4. Explain that nothing interupts your monthly phone call to Dr Peter Davis.

5. Blame it on your genuine passion for rugby even though you’d rather be home reading a book.

6. Say you were rushing home to set the VCR to record Desperate Housewives.

7. Issue a statement saying, “by definition, I cannot speed”.

8. Don’t bother turning up in court – just send your press secretary.

9. Blame the entire thing on the last National government and the Bush administration.

10. Point out that it could have been worse: Ruth Dyson could have been driving.

Heh they are all very good this week. Favourites are 10, 9 and 2.

The Onion

ISP Survey

Now these are funny

$29b of surpluses

Yes that’s right. Today’s PREFU shows that Labour is planning to overtax New Zealanders by $29 billion over the next four years. To be fair around $8 billion for the superannuation fund should be set aside, but it puts the lie to the suggestion tax relief is unaffordable.

Also worth remembering Treasury usually under-estimate the surplus by around $2 billion a year, so over four years the cumulative surplus could well be over $35 billion which is over $20,000 per household. And also recall Cullen has a slush fund of $12 billion for additional expenditure hidden away in the forecasts also. At this stage the numbers get astronomical so I won’t even calculate them.

Incidentally the OBERAC surplus for 2004/05 has grown again to $8.3 billion. A year ago Treasury forecast an OBERAC surplus of $5.7 billion so in fact $2.6 billion over budget. But do we get any back – oh no!

This is almost a once in a generation opportunity to permanently lower tax rates in NZ. Labour can and will find increasingly bizarre ways to spend the tax take or redistribute it to hand picked people if re-elected. If an $8.3 billion surplus is not high enough to lower tax rates, then they will never ever ever ever lower them.

PREFU shows core crown revenue under Labour forecast to increase by $19.1 billion cumulative over the next four years. It is not too much to ask for a portion of that increase to be given back to those who pay the tax.

Hell we should not have to ask and beg for our money back. The Government should be taking the initiative here.

U-turn, u-turn, u-turn

I predicted that Labour would do a u-turn on the tax issue due to the polls, and sure enough they have. It isn’t a total u-turn as it is not actually reducing tax rates, but just handpicking 60,000 families to get tax credits which you have to apply to IRD for.

I prefer tax relief for all working New Zealanders, not just a few handpicked ones. It’s okay to target some relief, if you will also deliver across-the-board tax cuts, but Labour continues to take every dollar it can so it can redistribute it.

So much for the months of claims that there was no room for tax relief. I also note Labour have not provided a costing of the package.

PC Alert

It’s one thing to ban smoking in workplaces and bars as there is a genuine issue of protecting others from passive smoking.

But I’m sorry having a local body ban smoking in parks because it is unhealthy is PC madness. I detest smoking and never have smoked. But it is not the role of local authorities to ban things which they think are bad for people.

Why don’t they also ban walking in the parks. I mean it is better for people if you jog, so lets issue fines to anyone not jogging in the park. Oh and we don’t want residents getting skin cancer so lets make the wearing of hats compulsory. Aaarrgh!

This confirms all my prejudices about South Taranaki.

Petrol Prices

While I don’t like paying the extra cost of petrol, I am very relaxed with the recent increases in its price. That is because it is not some harbinger of doom but simply the market at work.

I am not a geologist so have no idea if oil will run out in ten years, 100 years or 200 years. But what I have confidence in is that if supplies do start to get scarce, then the price will rise and this will give the incentives for alternative fuel sources etc. Manufacturers will respond with different types of cars, consumers will buy them etc etc.

So the right response to petrol prices going up is in fact to do nothing and let prices create incentives. The NZ Herald editorial comes to much the same conclusion being that change will happen when it is economic to do so.

They are scathing of the Government’s list of proposals ranging from restricting car imports, petrol rationing or carless days, as one should be.

And idiot of the day award has to go to Dover Samuels who thinks the price increases are due to oil company profits and not due to currency fluctuations and rising global prices.

The global price went over US$66/barrel this week. Blaming NZ oil companies for this is politics at its daftest.

The UK shooting

I have been somewhat stunned by the news reports yesterday that the Brazilian shot dead by the UK Police was not running, did not have a backpack or a heavy jacket. The official report is yet to come out but at this stage it appears that tragically he did nothing wrong but live near someone under surveillance.

On the original reports I felt the Police made a wrong but understandable decision. On the latest reports I think the term execution is not too far off the mark. This really is a tragedy.

Posts on NZ Reforms

View the Taxathon Ad

Regardless of the election result I think the creatives on National’s campaign team should win some awards for their work to date.

I’ve been flooded with calls and e-mails from people saying they love the Taxathon TV advertisement. It combines humour and opposition attack together very cleverly.

You can view the ad (plus a more serious one) online at National TV.

I just love the Southpark style characters. The more serious ad is a nice complement to it. The taxathon one serves as a sort of entree for the other ad which delivers the key message.

Promote the link to those who haven’t seen it on TV.

Labour are privatising!!!

We all recall the PM saying National is going to privatise because it will allow Landcorp to sell farms. How many people knew that in fact under Labour Landcorp has already been selling farms since 1999???

So the only difference in policies is that National will seek a minority investor in a coal company. Ohhh how scary.

Personally I would sell any state asset that moved or even looked like moving, unless it was a monopoly. The Government does a far better job of ensuring competition when it doesn’t own one or more of the players.

US relationship

Now Trevor and Helen told us that the nasty USA was writing policy for the Nats and also funding their campaign etc etc blah blah.

But then the US moves to allow a joint exercise with NZ despite the stand-off on ship visits.

So does this mean the US is now writing policy for Labour? Trevor please explain.

A new motive for spiking drinks

Normally when people are prosecuted for spiking drinks, it is a guy who wanted to have sex with a girl.

In a turn-about, a case in Auckland was about a girl who spiked her fiance’s drinks so he would want sex less often than the usual 35 times a week!

Considering the guy was 53, one has to be somewhat impressed 🙂

Greens refute McGillicuddy Serious comparisons

Oh dear it is a bit sad when the Greens feel they have to actually refute a statement from Gerry Brownlee that have policies that even the McGillicuddy Serious Party would be proud of.

And deep down I am sure they do agree with MGSP that NZ First supporters should be deported.

The interesting thing with their list of refutations is how many actually are true. Let’s look at them.

* Smacking Ban – even the Police now say it will criminalise smacking
* Drug Laws relaxed – correct (not that I have a problem with that personally)
* Road Funding frozen – correct – they boast of it
* New taxes – correct and their proposed making the first $5K tax free in exchange will be of most benefit to people who already pay no net tax
* More expensive energy and fuel taxes – correct
* Some imported goods banned – correct
* Support race-based funding such as spiritual healing – correct
* Allow mass strikes on any issue at all – correct
* Allow 16 year olds to go on the dole or sickness benefit – correct
* Too PC – well a smacking ban is a good example
* Brain Drain would accelerate – an assertion for the future so not provable
* Become a laughing stock – an assertion of opinion

The thing that struck me was that Frog basically didn’t refute the factual basis of any of the claims. Frog gave some context for why they want to do stuff, but in fact by their own words most of what Gerry asserted is absolutely correct.

Fisking Maharey

Wadestown MTC Meeting

G-Man has blogged on his impressions of the Wadestown Meet the Candidates meeting.

I missed it as I was on a plane back from Auckland after going up there for a meeting with the local Microsoft Executives plus their global head of “safety” from Redmond. Mainly talking about spam and phishing.

Looking forward to the Te Aro MTC especially. Its reputation precededs it.

Risawn and the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs

One of the great things about being a blogger is showing off photos of you with various people. Risawn managed to get a photo of her with General Myers, the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs.

She also has a photo of Leeann Tweeden and other celebrities. Nice to see they still supports troops working overseas with visits. Kosovo may not be as dangerous as Iraq but it’s never ‘safe’.

Further NZ reforms

Tyler Cowen at Marginal Revolution sets out six hypotheses on the future of reform in NZ. I’ll comment with my thoughts on each:

1. New Zealand reformed everything short of social welfare spending, education, and health care, which few voters wish or wished to reform. In fact the point of previous reforms was to preserve (and perhaps extend) previous levels of social welfare spending.

Social welfare reform is not in the too hard basket, and neither is education. There is public support for time limited benefits, work for the dole etc and centrist parties would also support change in this area.

Education reform is harder because of the teacher unions, but a change of Government will see a huge increase in the ability for parents and communities to run their schools, and for bad schools to not be propped up.

Health reform is near fatal until New Zealanders realise that if Labour can spend 50% more on health, get almost no increase in outcomes, and there is still a near bottomless demand for more, that one has to change the system. I don’t expect this to happen anytime soon.

2. Further reforms were thwarted by a move to proportional representation in the early 1990s, which gave minority parties undue influence and weakened threads of accountability.

This is a significant issue. However the small centrist parties do support education and welfare reform to various degrees. However further economic reform would be more difficult if reliant on them.

3. Asset privatizations in particular were oversold — remember the Auckland blackout? — and New Zealanders lost their appetite for further changes.

Aaarrgh that was not in any way related to privatisation. The issues with that company go back years and it was in fact in community ownership IIRC.

The major sale which turned NZers off asset sales was probably Telecom, as it retained the monopoly local loop and numbering plan etc and has used them to stymie most competition.

Asset sales can and have been popular. Even though one gets a bit less for the sale price, making sure a significant proportion of shares can be purchased by “mums and dads” sure Contact Energy sold off almost without significant opposition.

But due mainly to the Telecom experience NZers are react badly to the word privatisation. If you ask them whether the Government should really be owning hotel chains and the like again they will agree they shouldn’t, but they still react instinctively against more private ownership.

4. New Zealand policymakers were well ahead of public attitudes, and managed so many reforms only because the country’s (previous) Parliamentary system had few checks and balances. It is taking public opinion an entire generation to catch up to where policy stands. Only then might current reforms continue.

Certain aspects were ahead of public attitudes, but others were not. Free Trade is supported by all parties bar the Greens. In some areas like welfare reform the public have been ahead of the policy makers and wanted it tougher for much longer.

5. New Zealanders can once again sit content, since they are no longer in danger of being blown out of the water by Australia. If they start falling behind again, reforms will resume.

NZ is starting to fall again behind, and this will be a catalyst in years to come I predict.

6. Donald Brash will be elected Prime Minister in September, and reforms will resume then.

Certainly one will have welfare and educational reforms of some significance. Some further economic reforms, but not asset sales (bar a few farms being sold to you know farmers).

There are some good comments on Marginal Revolution blog itself which are worth a read. Anyone else got predictions (preferably not a hysterical reforms are evil and the public hate them rant)?

Green Bill will outlaw smacking

The Greens keep claiming their bill to repeal S59 will not outlaw smacking. However the Police have said “smacking of a child by way of corrective action would be an assault” is S59 is repealed.

I regard this as a major blow to the credibility of the backers of this bill. They have repeated the line that it is a smear to claim the bill will criminalise or ban smacking.

So is the Office of the Police Commissioner part of this smear? Who do you trust as to whether the bill will ban smacking? A frog or the head of the Police?

Just to repeat my position – I do support amending S59 to more tightly defining reasonable force. I even support Bradford’s bill going to select committee so it can be amended to do just that. But a simple repeal will criminalise and ban smacking – the Police have made that clear. Sure they may not prosecute in every case, but that won’t change the fact it will legally be an assault.

More on false rape allegations

The high profile rape allegation against an unnamed taxi driver has been found to be invented, as the complainant it seems did not even take a taxi. She has been charged with making a false complaint.

The sotyr mentions there are 450 people charged annually with making false complaints (of all sorts). The actual number of false complaints is probably a magnitude higher – it is disappointing the Police do not keep detailed statistics.

While far from official, a taxi company said nine out of ten complaints against taxi drivers are false. A lively thread last week debated a police claim that 60% to 80% are false.

It really is frustrating that there are no statistics kept along the lines of:

* No of total complaints made
* No of complaints where a person is charged and found guility
* No of complaints made where a person is charged and found not guilty
* No of complaints made where no charges laid
* No of complaints where Police are satisifed no crime occurred

Everyone is a loser when all we have is guesswork.

Hypocrisy Alert

On the same day the Unions are claiming that tax cuts will kill workers (don’t ask me how, my mind isn’t that lateral) they are also saying that they are against a law to prevent stoned employees from operating boats, vehicles, aircraft or machinery.

The call came from the Far North Coroner who found that the sinking of a boat was basically because the skipper was stoned and decided to carry on in unsuitable weather.

Nice to see the unions are focused on the big issues – tax cuts kill workers, but no law needed on flying planes or operating ships while stoned.

No accountability again

The Ministry of Education has paid for someone to tell teachers at a professional development seminar to vote Labour. Now this is so far beyond the line of acceptability it is not funny.

So what is the response of the Ministry? Is it that we have told the contractor we will not use him again? No they have “spoken to the contractor involved”. Well I bet you that has done the job.

I’m sorry but this is an instant termination offence.

What do you do when you have no new policy?

Labour’s sixth pledge of more cataract and joint operations has been reported as something new – remember Labour said they had lots of new policies for the campaign.

However as the NZ Herald points out they not only announced this pledge in May, they have been repeating it every week since then. The only genuinely new policy announced is the daft student loans one which they probably dreamed up in a few hours when they were panicking. It is notable they are still refusing to have that policy costed.