Student Debt Projections

I’ve gone to some official stats to try and estimate how much student debt will blow out by, due to Labour’s policy pledge. These come from the 2004 annual report on the student loan scheme.

In 2003 156,250 students borrowed $987 million, an average of $6,300 each. Only 60% of eligible students borrowed, and as more part-time students are now eligible the projected rate was 55%.

Now as one would have to be clinically insane not to borrow interest free money, the borrowing rate could go up to 100%. Allowing for 10% clinical insanity, I’ll assume 90% borrowing rate which means an extra 99,500 people will borrow. Let’s say 100,000 more.

So each year 100,000 more borrowers at the average of $6,300 is an extra $630 million a year borrowed.

Now in 2003 there were also 428,000 students enrolled at tertiary level, so this is still quite conservative predicting only 255,000 borrowers.

Of the $2.3b repaid since the scheme began, $1.2b has been compulsory repayments and $1.1b voluntary. Last year $200 million was voluntarily repaid.

Finally we also have that the average amount borrowed was $6,300, and now there will be no incentive to borrow less than the maximum which looks to be for an average student $9,000 to cover fees, materials and allowance. But again I will be conservative and say only an extra $1,000 will be borrowed per student, so this increase borrowing each year by $250 million.

Therefore we have a conservative scenario of an extra $880 million a year borrowed and $200 million a year of less payments. This is extra student debt of $1.1b a year. Against this you have $300 million a year of less interest so I think a conservative prediction is an extra $800 million a year of student debt.

So over a 15 year period, the total amount of student debt is likely to increase by $12 billion. And this excludes any upsurge in enrolments in wananga type courses due to the interest free money on offer to enrol.

Now this is just my unofficial calculations but the official ones when released after the election (would be a good idea for someone to try and PQ or OIA them beforehand) I am sure will also show a massive increase. When Labour did interest free loans while studying I predicted it would increase long-term debt projections, and indeed the official projections almost doubled. This will have at least as large an effect.

So people should be very aware of the huge distortions in incentives this policy will have. The incentive is to borrow the maximum and to never ever repay more than the minimum.

People should also read Kiwi Pundit on how Labour’s calculator is somewhat misleading.

Labour’s Student Loan Policy

Labour has announced it will scrap all interest payment on student loans. This will be popular in some areas, but I suggets people look very carefully about the motivations it now gives people:

1) You will be insane if as a student you do not take out a student loan. 100% of students will take loans out.

2) You will also be insane if you do not borrow the maximum amount. Even to stick it in the bank. Students are not stupid and like interest free money.

3) Likewise one would be insane to ever make a voluntary repayment. Given a choice of repaying a student loan or paying off a mortgage or even sticking money in a bank, there will be zero incentive to make voluntary repayments.

So what will be the overall effect of the policy? Total student debt is going to explode. It will be easier for some individual students, but overall student debt will have no limits on haw fast it will grow.

This is a prime example of something which looks attractive, but in fact is extremely bad public policy.

$11b surplus

Rodney Hide makes an excellent point on his blog. The official surplus projection for 2008/09 is $5.3b. But this includes an allowance for extra spending of $1.9b per year cumulative. This means on current expenditure one in fact is looking to have an $11b+ surplus in 2008/09.

Now it is sensible to have some allowance for additional spending initiatives but there is nothing magical about $1.9b/year cumulative. It used to be $600m a year.

TV Debates

TV3 have announced they will only have the six top polling leaders take part in their leader’s debate.

Frog suggests a less arbitary method of determining who is invited and excluded, and I tend to agree. Exlcuding a party which may only be 0.2% less than another party is silly, and TV3 should reconsider.

I love co-operation

Top 10 election slogans rejected by Labour

St Molesworth:Top 10 election slogans rejected by Labour:

1. Just tax it.

2. I liked the flight so much I nationalised the company.

3. Tax! Cackle! Pop!

4. You’ve never had it so Smarmy.

5. Do the crime, do a little time, get back into cabinet.

6. Tough on success and the causes of success.

7. Not everyday people.

8. Have a break, go on the dole.

9. Absolutely, positively, desperate to stay in Wellington.

10. Taxpayer funded advertising: millions;extra spending in the budget:
billions; state funded media: priceless.

UPDATE: Whale Oil has a version with comments from Mike Williams.

Reason #53 to change the Government

I’ve decided to do a daily reason as to why people should vote to change the Government. With 53 days to go, we start with Reason #53.

Violent Crime

Under Labour the level of recorded violent crime has increased by 13.96% – an extra 5,541 violent crimes a year.

When Labour took office, violent crime had been falling. And during the previous five years (to compare identicial time periods) it had increased by only 0.01%.

Dom Post on Mallard

The Dominion Post Editorial on Trevor Mallard is fairly damning. It reminds people that he has a history of making allegations he cannot substantiate.

They point out that Mallard’s lies over the United States will most definitely damage the relationship with them, and “yet again Labour is unable to distinguish between the national interest and the Labour Party’s political interests”.

What they need to do

RMA Changes

It is very timely that National announces its RMA Policy on the day Genesis Energy is in court appealing a court ruling that restricted their water rights from the Whanganui Rover on the basis it would interfere with the “life force” of the river.

This is pretty close to state sponsored voodooism when beliefs in mystical life forces of rivers are given weight in law.

As Owen McShane has pointed out the court case has huge implications for future energy supplies. If the precedent stands that one’s use of a river is limited due to its life-force, then investment in hydopower will dry up pretty quickly.

Especially when you consider nuclear power is not an option, coal is a bad thing with Kyoto, and wind power suffers from NIMBY everywhere.

Oh and also useful to remember that the 75 year old Western Springs Speedway was halted because Marian Hobbs funded the objectors with legal aid.

Grand Standing

I’m starting to get a bit sick of the grandstanding over the Zimbabwe tour. The ICC has made it very clear that the Government has to pass legislation to stop the tour. The PM’s motion in Parliament will do nothing except get publicity for her.

I also wonder if the Herald is quoting directly from the ninth floor when they assert “Helen Clark’s decision for the motion to be in the Prime Minister’s name lends it strength.” It’s a very subjective statement to make, and one that sounds like it did not come from the reporter. However it is not credited to anyone.

National odd on favourite to win

Harry Potter Questions

Bid now

More on S59 case

Dave at Big News has even more revelations about the case which is being used as a rationale for abolishing S59.

I’ve heard storiesover the years about a certain over zealousness by some social workers. If the allegations here are correct, we have some serious problems to sort out.

What is in the water?

At lunchtime today someone at a public meeting in Cannons Creek tried to charge National candidate Chris Finlayson. Luckily other candidates (well done) intervened to stop him.

One should be able to advocate in favour of the abolishing the Maori Seats, even in Cannons Creek, without worrying about this crap.

There have been recent death threats against Phil Goff and Helen Clark. I hope this is not all a sign of a growing intolerance in NZ politics.

It’s the 17th

A blog study

I saw a link in the latest Hard News that a Victoria University media studies student, Amie Mills, is conducting some work on blogging – and specifically, the people who respond to them.

After going to Amie’s blog, I find out that the study is speficially of readers of Hard News and Kiwiblog. Somewhat surprised that this is the first I find out about it (unless there is an e-mail amongst the hundreds backlgged during my time away, in which case my apologies) but the study looks very interesting and the questions should get some useful results, so I encourage people to take five minutes to fill in the survey and e-mail results to Amie.

More sewer dwelling

To keep Trevor company down in the sewer (where he has elected to stay, endorsed by Helen) we also have Steve Maharey. Steve (and we wonder how he got his nickname) has been handing out some sort of dossier on Don, full of quotes from his biography.

As Craig Ranapia has said, I find the book extracts refresing in that they reveal how depressed one can get after a marriage breakup. I actually think such candour from politicians is a good thing. Labour have enjoyed telling stories about canned beef for months on end.

Now it is all public domain, but isn’t it rather creepy to have the No 3 Labour Minister handout out attack sheets with extracts from the book in it. Paul Henry ripped into Clark about this on Breakfast TV and that is when she came up with her lame response about doctored photos of her.

The comparison would be to have a senior National MP handing out to the gallery extracts from Helen’s biographby quoting how she was so upset on her wedding day (as Jim Anderton had forced her into marrying for political reasons) that she was in tears.

I’m just pleased that National is not responding to the gutter tactics and instead almost every day announcing new policies, as part of a comprehensive package.

Conversation Transcript

At the cocktail party on Tuesday in DC, the following conversation took place between myself and a staffer from one of the family values thinktanks. There were around half a dozen people in the circle. I think it speaks for itself:

Staffer: I’ve actually been to NZ.

DPF: Oh how come?

Staffer: I was an adviser to the Christian Heritage Party for one of their campaigns. They didn’t listen to my advice though, and hence didn’t make it.

DPF: Hmm, Christian Heritage.

DPF: Was Graham Capill the Leader for that campaign?

Staffer: Yeah he was.

DPF: Oh well he’s just been in the news in the last few weeks back in NZ.

Staffer: Oh what for?

DPF: He got sentenced to nine years jail for rape and abuse of young girls

Staffer: Oh my God, you are kidding

DPF: Nope, been the major story.

Staffer: So is it possible the accusations were just made because of the role he has? I mean it must be an occupational hazard.

DPF: Well he pleaded guilty to all charges, so I think we can assume they are true.

Staffer: Oh

DPF: But he did claim in mitigation that one of the girls had consented and she looked older than she was.

Staffer: How old was she?

DPF: Around eight years old

Staffer: Jesus Christ. You use that as a defence if you are 20 and she is 15, not if you are 50 and she is 8.

DPF: Yeah you would think so.

Staffer: God, I am so glad they didn’t listen to my advice and make it to Parliament. How horrible.

DPF: Yeah we’re pretty glad also.

DPF walks off.

DC Day IV

Last September I reported on how I got to attend the weekly meeting of the vast right-wing conspiracy. I did a repeat visit this week, but ended up being one of the major speakers!

Every Wednesday around 100 representatives of leading lobby and industry groups, plus Republican representatives of the House, Senate and White House meet at the offices of Americans for Tax Reform.

Someone had said they sometimes have had brief updates on overseas elections, so I had e-mailed them to say I was happy to give a 90 second update if they were interested and there was time (highly unlikely as the 90 minute meeting is normally very busy and run very tightly). I didn

Distorted Photos

Helen Clark on Breakfast TV has just said that National’s billboards are designed to degrade her and are using a distorted photo of her.

I’m somewhat staggered that Helen would want to start a debate on which photos of her have been distorted or doctored. I’m pretty sure it isn’t the ones used by National!

Unless Labour now regards not using the official state supplied photo of the PM to be illegal and a distortion? I mean really how precious can you get.

UPDATE: A reader suggests people look at this NZ Herald story and decide for themselves which photos are distorted. And Whale Oil has a montage for people to choose from.

National’s Tertiary Policy

National has now released its teriary policy. The first part, also part of the tax policy, was to make interest on student loans tax deductible.

I like the fact that one can intelligently justify the policy in terms of treating getting a tertiary education along the same lines as borrowing to go into trade or business. The cost is relatively modest, but this is not a bad thing as if one makes student loans too attractive, you encourage students who don’t need them, to take them out. The total amount of long-term predicted student debt has skyrocketed under Labour because of this.

Labour has wasted billions of dollars, as seen by:

* Tertiary education expenditure has grown by almost $1 billion since 1999, but degree courses have grown by only 6% in six years, while community education courses have grown by 545% and certificate and diploma courses by 116%.

* Labour is spending $65 million on community education courses which have no assessment, no qualification, and no requirement for evidence that students are doing the courses.

* From 2000 to 2004 Labour spent at least $3.3 billion on sub-degree courses, of which only one third of students completed, so $2.2 billion was spent on unfinished courses.

In the full tertiary policy (not yet online), the key points are National will:

* Abolish Community Education courses run by tertiary institutions as informal courses with no assessment, no qualification and no teaching time are not tertiary education.

* Remove funding restrictions on trades and apprenticeship funding and encourage more trade training and apprenticeships by paying more for high-quality, high skills qualifications.

* Freeze government spending on student enrolment in sub-degree certificate and diploma courses

* Institutions who do not have adequate quality control systems or who have approved dubious courses will lose the ability to approve their own new courses.

* Pay institutions for students when there is evidence that students are genuinely engaged and learning, not just enrolled.

* Cut funding for any course where the drop-out rate exceeds 50% two years running.

Ouch

Mallard stands by his claims

Despite not a shred of evidence, Terevor Mallard is refusing to back down from his claims.

On Saturday I ran into a press gallery journalist at Auckland Airport. His view, which I had already formed, was that if Labour lose the election, political analysts will point to two major events as to why. The first being the budget, and the second being Mallard’s wild accusation.