Liberal media bias

Rotorua lakes

I love the Rotorua lakes, having spent five days canoeing across most of them, and camping by the lakesides. They will always have very fond memories for me, as it is on that trip I met a very special person, Anna, who was visiting from Germany.

I think it is entirely fair the Government pay $10 million compensation to Te Arawa to compensate for the 1922 settlement not being inflation adjusted.

But giving them compensation, plus the title to the lakes, is a bit like picking both the money and the bag when asked to choose by Selwyn Toogood.

I am very sympathethic to treaty settlements based on breaches of property rights. That is why I have some unease over legislating on the foreshore issue – that should have been Labour’s final resort, not its first resort.

But awarding title on the basis of ghosts of Maori warriors on a phantom canoe spiritual beings, taniwha, kaitiaki [guardians] which appear as lizards, eels or floating logs is mumbo jumbo nonsense.

I also regard it as offensive to have Anaru Rangiheuea state “It’s a matter that is not up for debate unless you are a descendant of Te Arawa or in Government.”

It is up for debate, and I think Lake Taupo serves as a lesson about the pitfalls of giving away title to lakebeds, even if one tries to protect public access. Over time it inevitably leads to more friction, with claims for airspace rights also.

Lets pay the compensation, but lets stop handing out title to lakebeds and seabeds. They must remain for all NZers.

Mayor Bruce Hucker

Am I the only one somewhat amused that Bruce Hucker, by pulling out of the race for the Auckland mayoralty, has actually become the de facto Mayor, as leader of the left bloc on the Auckland City Council.

I hope Dick Hubbard enjoys being the Governor-General of Auckland while Hucker is the PM.

The $2 million waka

This is sad

Fuller Tamaki Report

I wasn’t quite live blogging before. I was doing a Major Ingham and texting the proceedings out to a friend who blogged for me. For some reason my final text with the result didn’t get through. There was wireless connection there, but it was secured so I couldn’t use it.

The room was full with 200 people in attendance – like the good old selections of old. In fact several delegates were also at Rob Muldoon’s selection meeting in 1960!

A lot of VIPs there including former leader Jim McLay, and former MPs Sir Douglas Graham and Belinda Vernon. Banksie turned up also and was greeted with a standing ovation. I half expected him to declare himself a late nomination 🙂

All five nominees spoke really well. I wasn’t expecting it to be settled on the first ballot, which meant Allan Peachey got at least 31 of the 60 votes.

Party rules means I can’t report on the content of the speeches, which is a pity.

Allan is almost certain to be the next MP for Tamaki. He is currently the principal of Rangitoto which has almost 3,000 students (and 6,000 parents). It is the largest school in NZ. He leads a team of seven Deputy Principals and over 150 staff.

Next selection I will be attending is the three way race in Wairarapa – a nice winnable seat.

Tamaki Selection

Scott Simpson is speaking first….elimination results to follow

Selwood’s up next….

Margaret Voice is speaking

…Coleman’s up…

….now Peachey

And Allan Peachey has won on the first ballot which is a decisive victory. Well done Allan and commiserations to Scott, Margaret, Stephen and Jonathan.

Voter turnout and systems

The Dominion Post has the inevitable story into the low voter turnout and delays.

It is quite unacceptable that some results took over 48 hours. There is something wrong when we have the results of the Australian election before the Wellington City Council, despite WCC closing at least 9 hours earlier. I suppose we should be grateful that we got the results at least before the Afghanistan results.

In hindsight the use of STV was a mistake. Now don’t get me wrong I think STV would be a good system for national politics, but is seems totally unsuitable for local body elections.

In national politics, most of the voters will have followed enough news to be able to have a fairly well formed view on which party and candidate they like, and those they do not.

But in local body politics, most candidates are invisible, and voting is almost all based on name recognition. I would estimate less than 5% actually vote based on detailed knowledge of the merits of various candidates.

Now FPP works well for local body, as all voters have to do is tick (for example) up to five people that they have vaguely warm feelings about. But if you then ask them to rank those five people in order, most have no idea, and hence it puts them voting. I have had several people tell me they got put off by the need to rank candidates.

STV seems to be a good example of great in theory but awful in practice.

I actually would vote for STV over FPP for national elections. But for local body elections, it should be dumped.

Good God Harry makes sense

I was staggered yet pleased to find myself in near total agreement with transport safety minister Harry Dynhoven.

Harry has said in the SST that speed limits should vary according to conditions, that some motorway sections could have a higher than 100 km/hr limit, and a focus on speed cameras and blind enforcement had alienated many motorists.

I could swear Harry is plagiarising me (but I don’t mind) when he says: “Is it rational for us to have a 100km/h limit on highways that are long, clear, straight roads?” asked Duynhoven. “In the central part of the South Island we have a lot of long roads where you can see forever and there are no traffic entrances or exits. But we also have the same 100km/h limit on all rural roads, no matter how windy or twisty.”

Exactly!

Howard is back

It’s all over, with the Coalition having made it 76 seats. In fact so far Libs look to have won five off Labor, and only lost three in return. Latham is about to concede and Howard has won a 4th term.

This makes Howard Australia’s second most sucessful Prime Minister (after Menzies who was PM from 1949 to 1966) and the most sucessful current centre-right politican in the world (appropriate for the Chairman of the International Democrat Union).

The Republicans in the US will be much relieved by this. Having Latham withdraw tropps from Iraq in the middle of the US election campaign would not have been good for them.

UPDATE: Looks to be a 2% swing to the Coaltiion overall. This is amazing considering they also got a swing to them last election, despite being in Government. Latest ABC prediction is Coalition 86, Labor 61 and Others 3. Last election it was Coalition 82, Labor 65 and Others 3.

UPDATE 2: It looks like the Liberals won eight seats off Labor – well beyond anyone predictions, as most focus was on what the net loss to Labor would be. This makes 2007 a lot harder for Labor as they will need to pick up at least 15 seats.

WCC Results

The results are finally in (I blame STV) for Wellington.

The results are not final, but at this stage we have:

Mayor: Kerry Prendergast
Northern: Robert Armstring, Helene Ritchie, Hayley Wain
Onslow-Western:Andy Foster, John Morrison, Jack Ruben
Lambton: Stephanie Cook, Ian McKinnon, Alick Shaw
Eastern: Ray Ahipene-Mercer, Leonie Gill, Rob Goulden
Southern: Bryan Pepperell, Celia Wade-Brown

Looks to be a fairly dysfunctional Council I have to say. Some very good incumbent Councillors have missed out.

An early concession

Christchurch moore to the right

The Christchurch City results are in.

Garry More has won easily as expected with 60,000 votes to the next candidate on 11,000. The interesting Paul Telfer got only 1,552 votes.

In the wards I note Labour and Christchurch 2021 lost in Shirley-Papanui, Fendalton-Waimairi, Burwood-Pegasus, Riccarton-Wigram and Spreydon-Heathcote (yay where Mrs Jim Anderton got sacked). Their only victory seems to be one of two seats in Hagley-Ferrymead. The reduction in council size has wiped out most of the left.

Michael Laws wins

Tasmania Results

Tasmania closes before all other states, so we get their results first. In no way is it an indicator for the country, but it is interesting that ABC News are predicting the seat of Braddon will go from Labor to Liberal.

UPDATE: The coalition is now also leading in Bass accordingb to ABC.

If Labor loses two seats in Tasmania, it will make it difficult to win enough seats to form Government, as they will then need to pick up 15 on the mainland.

Wellington Regional Council

The Regional Council results are here.

Three of my five picks made it – Judith Aitken, Fran Wilde and Sally Baber (I am obviously good at selecting women). Terry McDavitt also made it which I am happy about. Chris Laidlaw topped the poll, showing name recognition is often all important.

Three other Mayors down

John Terris has lost to David Odgen in Lower Hutt. Ogden won by around 1800 votes. Ogden should be quite good, and looks to have a good Council.

In Palmerston North Heather Tanguay has won. I know Heather from when she was a local executive director for Red Cross, and I worked in the national office.

In Hamilton the incumbent Mayor, David Braitwaite, has been crushed coming 4th with only 2,302 votes. Michael Redman has won with 19,126. Martin Eilliott who accussed Redman of having a small penis (how does he know?) got 6,706 and thank God convicted fraudster Ewwan Wilson only got 4,761.

Curtis holds on

Full Auckland City Details

Mayor

Banks loses to Hubbard

Avondale-Roskill Ward (4)

No change except Linda Leighton replacing David Hay, both from CRN ticket

Eden-Albert Ward (3)

Neil Abel and Cathy Casey of City Vision defeat Mark Donnelly and Greg McKeown of CRN, giving City Vision all three seats.

Eastern Bays Ward (2)

CRN holds both seats with Toni Millar replacing Juliet Yates.

Hauraki Gulf Ward (1)

Faye Storer retains her seat

Hobson Ward (3)

Action Hobson wins for Christine Caughey and Richard Simpson. Scott Milne of CNR is the sole survivor.

Tamaki-Maungakiekie Ward (4)

Goes from two Labour and two Indpendents to three Labour and one Independent.

Western Bays Ward (2)

No change with Hucker and Sefuiva re-elected for City Vision.

Auckland Regional Council

Shadbolt storms home

Banks out

I’ve just heard that john Banks has lost by around 17,000 votes. Also a number of Council seats have gone away from Citizens and Ratepayers now, so it looks to be a very different Council.

I suspect things were much much closer until the fiasco over the copies of the NBR article. The public hate underhand stuff like that (even though I don’t think it was illegal) and it taints the entire team.

UPDATE: You can see results here.

The Council makeup is

Citizens & Ratepayers Now 6
City Vision 6
Labour 3
Action Hobson 2
Others 2 (Faye Storer and Bill Christian)

So CR have 7 and CL have 12 (13 with Hubbard) on ACC.

Condolences to Aaron Bhatnagar who lost his seat on Hobson Community Board. It was great having an incumbent blogging on local body issues.

Looks like City Vision have won most of the community boards also – a decisive victory.

An enslaved New Zealand

I knew the Aussies were getting pissed off with us for spending so little on defence and bludging off them for security, but now they have set up a political party whose policy is to enslave us in retaliation.

EnslaveNZ has a top ten list of reasons to invade and enslave New Zealand.

I actually think the idea isn’t all bad, because it would be like Planet of the Apes (Aussies as apes of course) and after a few years the cunning Kiwis would overthrow their masters and rule both countries.

Civil Unions Ad

I’ve just donated $20 to the Civil Union Bill campaign through their easy online support page. Funds go towards a newspaper ad in support.

It was pleasing to see the One Network News poll which showed 46% in favour of the bill, and 34% against.

I predict that if it is passed, in 15 years people will wonder what all the fuss was about. Just as people today can’t believe homosexual sexual acts were actually outlawed prior to 1986.

This looks to be a good movie

I got hooked on Southpark after I saw the movie. Ironically I only went to see the movie after Christian Heritage called for it to be banned, citing specific grounds being that they objected to “a sex scene between Saddam Hussein and Satan”.

The moment I read that I knew I had to see it.

The same team have now produced “Team America“. There have also been calls to ban this film because it has an explicit oral sex scene between puppets 🙂

It also sees several liberal hollywood stars killed in grusome fashion. I can not wait.