Maori Over-Representation

In the debate on whether one still needs the Maori seats in Parliament, few people believe me at first that not only are Maori no longer under-represented in Parliament, but they are over-represented by around 40%.

Of the 120 MPs in Parliament, 20 are Maori. This excludes MPs such as Clem Simich who are of Maori descent but do not self identify. So that is 16.7% of Parliament.

Stats NZ estimate that in 2001 (Census Year) there were 335,440 Maori
aged 18 and over, out of a total population aged 18 and over of 2,836,
070. This is 11.8% of the adult population.

There is of course nothing at all wrong with there being more Maori in Parliament, than their proportion of the adult population. But it certainly dispels the claim that you need the Maori seats, otherwise there will be almost no Maori in Parliament.

Clark attacks Maori Land Court Judge

On TV One News tonight, PM Helen Clark launched what can only be called a personal attack on a Maori Land Court Judge, because the Judge is letting a foreshore claim proceed.

She first attacked the decision to schedule the case, on the grounds that the Judge should be aware the Government plans to change the law, and also that there is an appeal to the Privy Council.

On the first point, it is outraegous to suggest a Judge should not follow the law, on the basis of press releases from Ministers saying they will change it. Also add on the fact it is highly dubious if the Government even has the numbers for a change.

The appeal to the Privy Council does have some more substance, but the hypocrisy is that the Government has refused to appeal the decision of the Court of Appeal. If they has announced they would do so, it may have saved many problems, but they refused because it would make them look stupid as they are abolishing appeals to it. So the appeal is only from the Marlborough District Council.

Finally the PM suggested the Judge was conflicted due to her Iwi affiliation, and should not have even scheduled the case (the Judge will recuse herself from sitting to hear it). Regardless of the merits of ones view, I can not recall since Muldoon when you have had a PM attack a Judge’s ethics in public, rather than filing a private complaint.

You can really tell that the heat is on.

The big gamble

The reaction to the request from the Reserve Bank to gamble taxpayer money on the exchange rate has been almost universally negative except for Winston Peters which should wanr people off.

National’s Deputy Finance Spokesperson, John Key, knows a wee bit about this area, in his former (and very successful) role as global head of foreign exchange for investment bank Merrill Lynch. With NZ having foreign reserves of $3.5 billion, and a daily FX turnover of $1.5 trillion (of which around $1.5 billion is NZ currency) one can see why he calls the proposal “about as effective as a popgun in a bank robbery”.

But hey not enough Cullen gambles $10 billion on the Cullen Fund – lets also play with our foreign reserves also.

Is this consensus?

NZ Pundit censored!

This is very amusing. I am unable to access www.nzpundit.com from Sydney Airport as Net Nanny is blocking the site. Is this due to to the violence, the sex or the language I wonder?

Net Nanny also has turned the word “########” into “########” on my site.

Net Nanny really is a great example of why content filtering rarely works.

Hell on Earth

Am now at Sydney Airport after a hell on earth experience at Bangkok Airport.

Left Thai Airways Lounge 5 minutes before boarding call and discovered the gate (No 56) was at the very very far end of terminal. This was around a mile away (I kid you now) so I had to run most of the way (with overnight bag and laptop) to make flight on time.

When I got there, I discovered there was some error, and I was actually meant to be at Gate 11. This was at literally the furthest point from Gate 56 possible. I almost killed myself running another mile to make the gate before the scheduled departure time (was well past the boarding time). I really did not look at all well as I finally got there.

After having near killed myself running laden with baggage for around two miles, I get on board the plane to hear there is a delay as a passenger has fallen sick and they have to take their luggage off!

Just to make things even better I left my tickets at Gate 56 and the Airport staff were not as stupid as me, and knew they could not get them down to proper gate in time. So am just going to have to bluff my way on the Auckland to Wellington flight without the ticket. Shouldn’t be too hard I hope.

Anyway will hopefully be home in a few hours. God I hate flying and airports.

ICANN Rome Meeting

Yesterday saw the end of the ICANN meeting I had been attending. The meetings are held three times a year with the 2004 ones being in Rome, Kuala Lumpa and Capetown.

Most of the meetings are focused on domain name policies and operations. This is now a relatively sizeable industry with 60 million domain names generating around NZ$3 billion in primary retail revenue and a secondary market of several hundred million more.

Attending on behalf of InternetNZ, the .nz manager, the first three days were taken up with meetings of the country code managers covering a variety of topics from DNS security, to registration policies to internal ICANN structure. The biggest topic is the ongoing discussion with the Governmental Advisory Committee as to the roles and relationships between Governments and country code registries. In most countries the registry is not selected by the Government but historically was delegated the role before Governments took much interest in the matter. Nowadays the issue is on the UN, ITU and WSIS agendas.

The next two days were public forums on current issues. Most of these were to do with generic top level domains such as .com, .info, .net etc. The final day was the ICANN Board meeting where final decisions were taken on a number of issues.

I

Milford Gondola

The proposed Milford Sounds Gondola from Queenstown has got some debate going. No Right Turn is against it while NZ Pundit says the proposed area “is a wind swept tussocky shithole”.

My sympathies are in favour for a number of reasons.

1) From my experiences down there, very few people would actually see the gondola.
2) It would hugely reduce the amount of large bus traffic along the roads to Milford and subsequent environment damage from such.
3) It would be a magnificent ride with views of Milford.
4) It would allow far more people to see Milford without the normal increase in traffic congestion.

Interview with Helen

There is an interesting interview with Helen Clark and the Herald. Apart from one moment of stupidity when she implied voting National would lead to Redfern style race riots, the interview overall was actually quite a good one. Of course it was a wee bit of a patsy with questions like “Has the Brash speech made racism respectable?” which is equivalent to asking Dr Brash “Has the Prime Minister got out of touch?”.

I think in time people will look back and realise NZ owes Don Brash a huge vote of thanks for making it respectable to challenge the politiically correct nonsense that had become the status qup in NZ. Never before that speech would you have the Prime Minister:

* agree we should have asked in 1987 why we need the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi in legislation
* state the principle of partnership does not give Maori co-management rights
* saying it is fair to question why New Zealand pays for Maori elders to lift the tapu on Government buildings such as embassies when New Zealand is a secular state
* agreeing Marlborough Grils College is being ridiculous allowing girls to display greenstone pendants but not crucifixes

Not that I expect Labour will do much more than have Mallard blunder about trying to stamp out some of the worse stuff, but as I said it is a huge step forward that one can even talk about it now.

Bring it on!

As I mentioned earlier Helen Clark stole a (bad) line from John Kerry and said “bring it on” in relation to a debate about the future of New Zealand.

What is absolutely hilarious is that both Paul Holmes and Linda Clark have noted that Helen immediately after saying this, then refused to appear on their shows to debate Don Brash. Ha ha ha ha ha ha.

I mean how stupid can you be? Issue a public call to bring on the debate and then refuse all invitations to actually take part.

This is a must read!

If you read nothing else this week, you must read today’s edition of mccully.co from Albany MP Murray McCully.

Read about:
* The senior Dominion Post editor whose e-mail to Labour MPs saying “If I can ever help, sing out. Vice-versa, perhaps.” which went astray.
* How readers are cancelling Sunday Star-Times subscriptions in their droves over their partisan and offensive headline comparing Don Brash to Pauline Hanson.
* How Auckland College of Education splits it graduates into three groups for graduation – Maori, Pacific Island and Tauiwi. Yep thats right European or Asian NZers are Tauiwi or foreigners/strangers but Pacific Island New Zealanders are not.

Also a good read today is the very funny St Molesworth. Not on line yet so copied below.
Continue reading »

More hyperbole

The normally sedate and sensible NZPA is right into the hyperbole delcaring in the story carried by the Herald that “Helen Clark declared all-out war on National Party leader Don Brash” and “escalated tension over race relations into an assault on several fronts”.

It is amusing that Clark is reported as being upset that “her government’s positive initiatives were being questioned”. Oh boo hoo. How dare the Opposition question her positive initiatives. I predict she will start referring to herself in the third person soon, a sign normally linked to suggesting anyone disagreeing with her is unpatriotic.

The Orewa speech is now “gross and unpleasant” (to her poll ratings maybe). Then short of anything new to say she steals from John Kerry his normal concluding line “I say: bring it on.” How unoriginal.

Is Garth George mad?

I have never worked out why Garth George has a column in the NZ Herald. He seems to do nothing but whinge week in and week out.

Today’s column is a must read though, just so people realise how mad he is.

Firstly he seriously claims that “the increase in child killing and abuse and paedophilia which scars our land flows from that decriminalisation of abortion”. Hello blaming pedophilia on legalising abortion. This is not just drawing a long bow, but ripping it apart. Why not also blame AIDS, the Gulf War and NZ losing the World Cup on abortion also.

He also rails against the decriminalisation of homosexuality. Oh great, someone who wants to jail 5 to 10% of New Zealanders because of their sexuality which generally they have no choice over. Lets lock up the gypsies also.

Rich white men are binge drinkers

The Herald reports that binge drinkers are most likely to be white New Zealand men, who live in cities and have a household income of over $70,000.

ALAC states binge drinking is defined as seven standard drinks in a single session for adults.

Yes Chris, I would say that they are referring to you in this study!

Kiwis show how smart they are

Kiwis have reaffirmed how smart they are with the TV3 poll showing only 17% believe the PM is sincere with her u-turn on the Government’s race relations policy and 70% correctly think she is just trying to soothe public opinion in the short term.

Personally I think she just looks an idiot when she keeps repeating that Don Brash is basically a nasty vile racist for making his speech, yet all those who agree with him are

Where do they get it from?

Both the NZ Herald and the Dominion Post report on what Don Brash said on superannuation.

NZ Herald: Brash rules out super age rise
Dom Post: Brash on super: no guarantee for the under-50s

You would think they were reporting two different Don Brashes.

The Dom Post seem to justify their headline on the basis that Don Brash said that after the year 2020 a future Government may have to look at the retirement age. Never mind that he specifically said

Public Warning

As a public service to anyone else who may ever be looking to stay in a hotel in Rome, I can advise that under no circumstances should you stay at the Hotel Aldobrandeschi. I cannot recall a worse hotel. In summary it has:

Lies, damn lies and statistics

Stuff reports that Maori have a 40% higher death rate than Europeans. This is rather amusing as I am prepared to wager than Europeans and Maori have the exact same death rate that is 100% unless someone can produce evidence to the contrary!

Many journalists are statistically illiterate and you often get nonsense like this reported, along with nonsense like party x is polling below the margin of error.

I suspect the study is referring to death rate in any one year for people of a certain age, but it is impossible to tell from the story.

You have 15,000 unread messages!

Logged into my e-mail this morning and was rather suprised to find that I had over 15,000 e-mails downloading. Even worse it was growing at over 100 per minute.

A quick check through webmail of some headers and found what was happeneing. I am one of the moderators of the nz.net.announce newsgroup and one of the other moderators had a bounce message going to the group moderation address which included himself so it was stuck in a never ending loop.

Not only was the number of messages expoentially increasing, but each message was attaching all the previous bounce messages, so the size of each one was also getting much bigger.

I didn’t fancy just e-mailing my ISP helpdesk with the problem as it can take 24 hours to respond and Jesus by then I might have been into the millions, so made Telecom some money by phoning from Italy and spending ten minutes on hold. Problem was solved within an hour thank God.

And Picture makes 11

And Best Picture to Peter Jackson, Barrie Osborne and Fran Walsh makes it 11 out of 11 for Lord of the Rings: Return of the King.

While most were saying LOTR was a clincher for Best Picture, no one was predicting a clean sweep. It is the only film to have won 11 Oscars in a clean sweep of the categories it was nominated for. Titanic and Ben Hur also won 11 but had been nominated for more categories (12 and 14 IIRC).

A huge day for not just Peter Jackson but all the mainly NZ based winners.

LOTR is cleaning up!

Wow Lord of the Rings is having a huge day at the Oscars having won seven out of seven so far. I can’t see how the big two (Picture, Director) won’t go to Jackson. A huge landslide so far.

LOTR Winners to date (in order presented) are:

Best Art Direction: Grant Major (Art Direction), Dan Hennah and Alan Lee (Set Decoration)
Best Costume Design: Ngila Dickson and Richard Taylor
Best Achievement in Visual Effects: Jim Rygiel, Joe Letteri, Randall William Cook and Alex Funke
Best Makeup: Richard Taylor and Peter King
Best Sound: Christopher Boyes, Michael Semanick, Michael Hedges and Hammond Peek
Best Music (Score): Howard Shore
Best Film Editing: Jamie Selkirk

UPDATE: and now:

Best Song: Fran Walsh, Annie Lennox and Howard Shore for ‘Into the West’

If LOTR wins Picture, Director and adapted Screenplay it will have set a record by tieing at 11 (with Titanic and Ben Hur) for Most Oscars for a single movie, but of those three, LOTR would be the only one to have won in every nominated category

UPDATE:

Best Adapted Screenplay: Peter Jackson, Fran Walsh, and Philippa Boyens
Best Director: Peter Jackson

I was hoping LOTR would get Best Picture and Director. I doubt anyone seriously thought it would win all 11 Oscars from 11 nominations. It is inconceivable Best Picture is not going to go to LOTR after the other 10 awards.

Only half?

Jesus died for the Treaty?

Okay not quite, but one might think so from the story in the NZ Herald on the statement by Bishops on the Treaty.

The Bishops claim that giving preferential treatment to Maori is effective in addressing huge socio-economic disparities, compared to the failure of policies that treat everyone the same.”

As they have called for claims to “be tested in the light of facts and figures” I would ask what facts they have to back up their assertions that the preferential treatment has worked?

More fundamentally the Bishops state the Treaty is a blueprint for modern New Zealand, creates a partnership, and defines a constitutional relationship.

Dr Brash responded “I don’t underestimate the importance of the treaty, but to imply that it creates some kind of eternal and permanent partnership between two separate bodies is to me not an accurate way of understanding the treaty.”

As more and more NZers will have some Maori descent, the Bishop’s view, in my opinion, can only lead to a Fiji type situation.

Revenue not safety

With despair I note the Police saying that every single Police District has been ordered to ticket without exceptions motorists exceeding the speed limit , quoting from the SST story:

“Fitzgerald said whereas police previously had discretion to consider circumstances such as weather and traffic conditions, they would now be encouraged to ticket anyone driving above the speed limit.”

This is beyond stupid. It is saying there is no difference between driving say in mid Otago at 110 km/hr on a straight road where you can see ahead for several kms in fine weather and driving over the Rimutaka Hill Road at 100 km/hr in wet weather. One is perfectly safe and the other is suicidal.

If the Government seriously thinks that one should never take into account condition factors, why don

Praise CNN

Europe is the worst place to fly directly to as its time zone is 12 hours apart from New Zealand that is hard to adapt to. Fell asleep yesterday at 5.00 p.m. and woke up at 1.00 a.m. On the good side though I discovered one of the channels does have CNN between midnight and 7.00 am so not quite so cut off from the English speaking world!