Fiji set to clamp down on a free media

Most people are familiar with the saying two steps forward and one step back to describe a situation of slow progress.

That has been my hope for Fiji, that with a set date for elections in 2014, there would be some progress. But alas, the situation is looking more like one step forward and two steps back.

The Fijian Government has released a draft decree of proposed media censorship. It would make Fiji even more repressive in terms of media freedom.

NZPA report:

The regime of self-appointed Prime Minister Frank Bainimarama yesterday issued a new media decree which Newspaper Publishers’ Association chief executive and New Zealand Media Freedom Committee secretary Tim Pankhurst described as “highly oppressive”. …

“It not only targets editors and their journalists. Any members of the public brave enough to express dissenting views are also in line for crippling fines, ill treatment and jail.”

Media outlets could be fined up to F$500,000 (about NZ$344,000) and individual journalists up to F$100,000 (NZ$69,000) and be jailed for up to five years if they failed to comply with the decree’s dictates.

Offences included such “crimes” as criticising the government and even failing to run bylines, Mr Pankhurst said. Foreign media ownership was also restricted.

The foreign media restrictions are an attempt to close down the Fiji Times. The Commodore hates them especially as they refuse to describe him as the Prime Minister, unless he actually wins an election to that post.

Some aspects from the media decree:

  • The Minister of Information personally appoints, and can sack at any time, the Director of the Media Industry Development Authority
  • One of the tasks of the MIDA is to ban any material which creates “communal discord”
  • MIDA will require all media organisations to be registered with them
  • Breaches of MIDA rules will carry a potential penalty of $500,000 for an organisation and $100,000 plus five years in jail for individuals.
  • MIDA has police like powers to search and seize documents from media organisations
  • Bans foreign ownership of over 10% in a media organisation, which will close down the Fiji Times.
  • Sets up a Tribunal with the Chair appointed by the Attorney-General to hear complaints, and which must act within “guidelines’ given by the Minister
  • The Minister can by order prohibit any broadcast or publication that may give rise to disorder, and can demand copies in advance
  • The decree explicitly forbids any Court hearing a challenge to not just the legality of this decree, but any decisions made by the Authority, Tribunal or Minister under this decree
  • The media code bans “hypnotism” and “demonstrating exorcism”!

Cafe Pacific has a good analysis of the decree.

Coup 4,5 report:

This is very broad so it will be interesting to see what kind of stories come under this criteria. Censors are already stopping the publication of stories which make the interim government look bad; eg water and power cuts and bad road conditions leading to pot holes.

This clause really means any stories which the interim regime doesn’t like because it exposes them or shows that they’re not doing a good job, is not in their interest and offends them as it creates communal discord.

The communal disorder clause is what will allow the Government to ban anything which criticises the Government, or if it gets published to imprison the journalist for up to five years.

Johansson on Obama

Spending Cuts in the UK

My weekly column at NBR 24/7 takes a look at the UK elections. An extract and a proposal:

Both Labour and the Conservatives are promising to cut public spending faster than Margaret Thatcher did in her first term. Labour has pledged to cut the deficit in half within four years. The Conservatives are promising a further £8 billion of spending cuts beyond that.

And one good proposal:

One welcome manifesto pledge from the Conservatives is to publish online all items of government spending over £25,000. For the size of their economy, this is equivalent to publishing all items of spending in New Zealand over $1,000.

I suggest:

Think of how popular Bill English would become if he ordered every Government department, ministry and agency to list every payment that make, online in a searchable database?

Editorials 9 April 2010

The Herald has advice re Waihopai:

There seems no real point in the Crown’s mounting a $1.1 million damages claim against the Waihopai spy base attackers. It may be an open-and-shut case in which all that has to be proved is that damage was caused and that the three members of the Ploughshares peace movement were responsible for it. But it would be a pyrrhic victory. According to one of the trio, teacher Adrian Leason, the men have less than $1000 between them. The Crown would receive little, or nothing, after spending a considerable sum bringing a civil case. At the same time, it would provide the trio with a platform to further expound on the satellite station and their view of its role in the Echelon electronic eavesdropping network.

I agree.

“Claim of right” is enshrined in the 1961 Crimes Act for cases such as those involving people who have unwittingly bought stolen goods. It defies belief that the framers of that legislation envisaged it being used by men who freely admitted cutting through the fence surrounding a spy station, breaking into the base and slashing an inflatable plastic dome covering a satellite dish. The trial judge had his doubts, reserving a question of law relating to “claim of right”.

The Crown’s right of appeal is severely circumscribed. But the Solicitor-General has concluded, quite rightly, that the case raises major questions about the appropriateness of the Crown’s being required to prove that an accused acted without “claim of right” being used again in similar circumstances. He has, therefore, referred the matter to the Justice Minister. After a review, the Cabinet will decide if the Crimes Act should be amended to stop the defence being used in situations like this.

And I hope and expect Cabinet will do so. Otherwise it will be open season on government buildings.

The Dominion Post finally has its say on Easter trading:

In Wellington, regional chamber of commerce chief Charles Finny believes the law is nonsensical. “We see no reason why the state should be prohibiting people from opening. It should be up to the retailer or restaurant,” he says, arguing that the capital’s growing status as a tourist destination demands change.

Has the time come for a courageous government – that probably counts this one out – to sponsor legislation that permits shops to open throughout Easter, doing away with the quaint notion that the issue is for individual MPs’ consciences, and shop owners to decide for themselves whether or not they want to open?

The Dominion Post believes so.

I want to see the shop trading restrictions repealed. They are nonsensical, archaic and inconsistent.

However I don’t think one of the very few issues upon which MPs have a free vote, should become a party issue.

Migration to and from Australia

These migration states are interesting. The number of NZers leaving to Australia has been quite volatile, and is currently tracking down.

However the number of NZers returning to NZ has been pretty constant for most of the last five years, but has increased over the last year. It will be interesting to see how long the trend continues for.

The propoganda war continues

Is it just me, or has there been an article appear almost daily in the media for the last few weeks, advocating a drop in the legal blood alcohol level for driving?

If this is not an orchestrated campaign, it’s a bloody coincidence.

Today the Press reports:

Health experts have joined the call for a lower drink-driving limit after a horror week on New Zealand roads.

The pressure comes weeks before a Cabinet decision on whether it will lower the blood-alcohol limit from 80 milligrams per 100 millilitres to 50mg as part of its 10-year road-safety strategy, called Safer Journeys.

Twenty-one people have died in 14 road accidents over the past seven days, with an elderly woman pedestrian killed when she was struck by a vehicle in the Bay of Plenty town of Paengaroa the latest victim.

Police said alcohol was believed to have played a part in five of the crashes.

And in how many of them did the driver had a BAC between 0.05 and 0.08?

In the official stats for 2008, only one (yes one) driver aged over 25 killed in a car crash had a blood alcohol level between 0.05 and 0.08.

Here is the research I would want the Government to undertake, before making a law change:

  1. How many drivers currently drive with a BAC between 0.05 and 0.08. This will quantify how many people may be criminalised by a law change. This can be determined by collecting data at random checkpoints.
  2. How many accidents (fatal and non fatal) are caused by drivers with a BAC between 0.05 and 0.08. The existing data is incomplete. We need at least a year where an effort is made to get this data for every crash.
  3. What has happened in countries where the BAC is lowered from 0.08 to 0.05 (and no other road safety change occurred at the same time) in terms of number of prosecutions for having excess blood alcohol, and number of accidents. In other words did it change behaviour, or just lead to more people prosecuted?

Not unspeakably evil

The GCSB came out yesterday and said it does not contribute to “unspeakable evil” which of course almost forces you to quip that they only contribute to “speakable evil” 🙂

The main point the Director and former Director made was that NZ intelligence wasn’t used to help the US in the war in Iraq, as the then Government had made a decision not to support the war.

The main value from such spy stations tends to be intercepting communications between terrorists, helping authorities prevent attacks which see scores of civilians massacred. For every successful terrorist attack, there are often a hundred foiled plots. And not just in Europe, but even in Australia.

It is far better to prevent a terrorist attack, than arrest the people who did it afterwards.

Love it

Sensible use of the private sector

The Dom Post reports:

About 250 Wellington patients will have their operations in private hospitals after district health boards decided they could not meet Health Ministry elective surgery targets without help.

Hutt District Health Board is negotiating with Boulcott Hospital to perform about 50 mostly ear, nose and throat operations, while Capital & Coast District Health Board has asked private hospitals to carry out 200 cataract operations.

Hutt chief executive Michael Hundleby said the board turned to Boulcott Hospital because it was concerned that Wellington Hospital – which does 40 per cent of Hutt DHB’s surgery – did not have the capacity to complete the operations.

Some on the left will cry out that this is privatisation. I suppose they would rather those patients simply remain on the waiting list rather than have the private sector provide the operation. Who cares about quality of life so long as we are ideologically pure eh.

Health Minister Tony Ryall said he was not concerned that DHBs were using the private sector to help them meet the health targets, which were introduced last year.

“Our priority is that patients are treated and in the Wellington region we’ve had a record total of 11,232 patients getting the elective surgery they need.”

Great.

Public ACTA this weekend

A reminder to those interested, that the Public ACTA conference is on all day Sturday in Wellington at the Town Hall. ACTA is the treaty being negotiated that may require countries to implement policies to terminate Internet access of copyright infringers.

As I have previously blogged, the position of the NZ Govt on ACTA has generally been a good one – but we only know this because the secret draft texts have been leaked in Europe.

This is an opportunity to learn more about ACTA and help critique the proposals around Internet access.

The programme is here. We have three top international experts speaking, plus a panel of local pundits. The three international speakers are:

  • Professor Michael Geist, law professor at the University of Ottawa where he holds the Canada Research Chair in Internet and E-commerce Law. Michael has a Doctorate in Law (J.S.D.) from Columbia Law School and is an internationally syndicated columnist on technology law issues.
  • Kim Weatherall is a Senior Lecturer in the School of Law and an Adjunct Research Fellow with the Australian Centre for Intellectual Property in Agriculture. Kim teaches and researches in intellectual property law, with a particular interest in digital copyright, the relationship between international trade and intellectual property, and the systems for administration and enforcement of intellectual property rights.
  • Jonathon Penney is the Internet NZ Senior Research Fellow in CyberLaw at Victoria University and has a MSt from Oxford and a LLM from Columbia. Hailing from Canada, he has previously worked as a lawyer with the Justice Department and as a policy advisor at the federal level

If you wish to attend, you can register here. Looks to be 100 or so people attending at this stage. There is no charge to attend thanks to InternetNZ,

Editorials 8 April 2010

The Herald calls for transparency over MPs legal expenses:

Taxpayers have a right to know how their dollars are being spent. That includes the allowances paid to the country’s parliamentarians for accommodation or travel, as some MPs have learned to their discomfort over the past year or so. It should also include the use of public money to cover legal costs when parliamentarians are sued. …

Clearly, there are occasions when it is legitimate for MPs’ legal bills to be paid with public money. Parliamentarians should act vigorously on behalf of their constituents. …

Yet but for the publication of documents by the New Zealand Herald and an admission by Dr Smith of the use of some public funding, taxpayers would have been none the wiser about either of the requests for reimbursement or their granting or denial.

The Prime Minister, John Key, said yesterday that taxpayers were entitled to know that money from the public kitty was being used for MPs’ legal costs, and that he would be open to such information being made public. That is a refreshing outlook, and one that indicates Mr Key is fully aware of the harsh spotlight on MPs’ expenses and allowances, both here and in Britain.

As I blogged, I’d include it in the six monthly expense reports.

The Dominion Post also wants more transparency, but around a health spending scandal:

Unacceptable. There is no other word for the situation that police claim has developed with Waikanae’s Te Runanga O Te Ati Awa Ki Whakarongotai, its health-provider arm Hora Te Pai and Capital & Coast District Health Board.

Stripped to its essentials, the police allege that money that was meant to be spent improving health has been siphoned off into other areas.

Regardless of the final outcome of the police inquiries, that is no way to manage $590,000 of taxpayers’ money. It is public money, and the handling of it should be transparent, with the details of where it is or what it has been spent on readily available.

I agree. Phil Kitchin does an invaluable job in expsoing their spending scandals. But we should not have to rely on him.

As I have said previously, I’d do what some US states do and have the entire cheque register for the Government put online. People could then file OIAs about spending that looks dodgy.

The Press says the dam decision is a close call:

The benefits from building a hydro dam on the Mokihinui River, north of Westport, are obvious.

It would, by using a resource that on the West Coast is endlessly renewable, give the region enough electricity to power 45,000 homes.

The dam would not only supply most of the region’s electricity needs in an undeniably carbon-zero way, it would also end the reliance on a long and vulnerable transmission line that brings the area’s present power supply from the Waitaki. Supply would not only be more secure, it would be more efficient and West Coast electricity prices, at present some of the highest in the country, would be lower.

Which is why many locals support it.

The proposal would require a 85-metre high, 300m wide dam across the river that would create a narrow, 14 kilometre long lake covering 340 hectares. Meridian says that the impact would be minor and it has made a considerable effort to make sure they are kept to a minimum. No endangered species are threatened, it says. In addition, the resource consents Meridian has received have more than 200 conditions attached to them to further reduce the impact. Nonetheless, according to the objectors, a precious, irreplaceable part of the landscape will be irretrievably changed. …

But the country cannot afford to have decisions like this one made on emotion and sentiment. Electricity demand is growing by 2 per cent a year, equivalent to the needs of a city the size of Dunedin. The two-to-one vote on this scheme shows that the commissioners’ approval was not easily arrived at but it was made, as it must be under the Resource Management Act, after rigorously detached consideration of all the arguments. In this case the commissioners decided the development’s impact on the environment are not bad enough to block the project.

I’ve blogged on this separately also.

And the ODT looks at Easter trading:

Parliament, as it so often does, tried to design a horse with its legislative provisions controlling private enterprise during Easter, and instead produced a camel.

A particulary stupid camel, that has a limp.

There is nothing about the regulations that can in 2010 be considered just and necessary, let alone reflective of contemporary society.

The creation of geographic exemptions to trading on Good Friday and Easter Sunday, meaning some places can open their doors while others must close – backed by farcically small penalties – is simply unjustly partial. …

The Muldoon National government passed the legislation in 1980 which provided for shops to be open on Saturdays, and also broadened the range of heavily restricted goods able to be sold on Sundays.

The world did not come to a halt as a result; indeed, apart from the predictable complaints from the unions, the public in general welcomed the measure, which also signalled the decade’s major social change – the end of the five-day, 40-hour working week.

And one day when we have sensible laws around Easter, we will look back with bemusement over how long it took us to do it.

It is time for the matter to be settled and the only way that will happen is to abandon the so-called “personal vote” in Parliament and achieve suitable legislation by way of a Government Bill.

Whether John Key’s administration has the fortitude to do so, or is prepared to risk the undoubted wrath of church and union, is arguable: Mr Key agrees the present regulations are a shambles and would like them to be liberalised, and he has voted accordingly in the past.

It is time for a national solution: declaring Easter Sunday to be a public holiday would protect workers’ wage levels, and sending a Bill to a select committee would ensure public opinion – more accurately reflecting the times in which we live rather than electorate pressure on individual MPs – could be canvassed.

I’m a big supporter of change, and have myself mooted a trade off of making all of Easter public holidays in exchange for removign the trading restrictions.

But I am reluctant to have this become a party whipped issue. I think MPs should have freedom of choice on this.

Having said that, I note that Labour have almost adoped a party line on the issue, so maybe in time National will also.

New sentencing guidelines for rape

The Court of Appeal released last week their decision in R v AM. The individual decision about MA is not of as much interest as the fact the Court has used the case to quite radically change the way courts assess what term of imprisonment should apply.

Rape has a maximum sentence of 20 years imprisonment and in 1994 the Court of Appeal in R v A ruled that the starting point was 8 years, and there was a large number of factors which could push that up or down.

The result of R v A is that almost all sentences tended to cluster around the starting point, and relatively few got near the maximum, or at the other end, got near the minimum. It also led to some lack of consistency.

In R v AM, the Court of Appeal has devised for bands of offending for rape, and three for unlawful sexual connection. They are:

  1. Rape 1 – 6 to 8 years
  2. Rape 2 – 7 – 13 years
  3. Rape 3- 12 – 18 years
  4. Rape 4 – 16 – 20 years

And

  1. USC 1 – 2 to 5 years
  2. USC 2 – 4 to 10 years
  3. USC 3 – 9 to 18 years

Before I detail what qualifies for each band, I have to say I think the decision is a significant improvement for sentencing. It has bee frustrating that no matter how vile the crime, very few people ever get close to the maximum sentence. This should result in the very worst rapes getting sentences close to the 20 year maximum.

The decision gives a lot of examples of how existing cases would fit into each band, and whether they would be at the lower or upper ends. It is a very detailed sentencing guide. To some degree it shows why there is no need to have a Sentencing Council, as legislated by the last Government. The Court of Appeal looks to be filling that niche quite nicely.

The description of the activity which falls in each band is summarised here:

  1. Rape Band 1 (6 to 8 yrs) – offending at the lower end of the spectrum where there are no aggravating factors, no serious violence, no abduction, the victim is not very young or very old.
  2. Rape Band 2 (7 to 13 yrs) – involves moderate violence, pre-meditation, a rape involving more than one offender, or an especially vulnerable victim
  3. Rape Band 3 (12 to 18 yrs) – offending with serious additional violence, wit multiple (three or more) aggravating factors. For particularly cruel, callous or violent rapes.
  4. Rape Band 4 (16 to 20 yrs) – for multiple offending over considerable periods of time, gang or pack rape.

These guidelines are binding on all lower courts from the 31st of March. It will be interesting to see how it impacts sentencing. The Court has said it does not expect the average term of imprisonment to increase (it has already increased from 7 yrs 3 mths in 1996 to 8 yrs 3 mths) but that there will be a greater variety of sentences – more at the top end, and more at the lower end.

It is worth noting that the above focuses on the initial sentence for the offending. Courts also then take into account the circumstances of the offender. Also if an offender pleads guilty their setence is normally reduced by 10% to 33% depending on how early in the process they plead guilty.

The case judgement, from a legal point of view, is a very interesting one. On an emotional front, it was pretty gruesome reading the summarised details of around 52 rape and unlawfu sexual connection cases. I can only imagine what the trauma must have been like for the victims.

Sad they still don’t get it

It is sad to see so many senior members of the Catholic Church are not understanding what the issue is with the child abuse scandal.

The Herald reports:

The Vatican heatedly defended Pope Benedict XVI, claiming accusations that he helped cover up the actions of paedophile priests are part of an anti-Catholic “hate” campaign targeting the Pope for his opposition to abortion and same-sex marriage.

Or it might be about the lack of opposition to, or more specifically action against,child abuse.

The Vatican newspaper quoted Sodano yesterday as saying the church is “certainly” suffering because of paedophile priests but he asserted that “Benedict XVI has apologised several times”.

“But it’s not Christ’s fault if Judas betrayed” him, Sodano said. “It’s not a bishop’s fault if one of his priests is stained by grave wrongdoing. And certainly the Pontiff is not responsible.”

Here is what they don’t seem to get.

I, and I am sure most people, do not blame anyone in the Catholic Church for the fact a priest molested children, unknown to them. The responsibility absolutely lies with the priest, not the Bishop, the Pope or the Church.

But, and this is the big but, it is different when the Bishop has been told about the child abuse and molestation. And when the Bishop doesn’t report it to the Police, when the Bishop does not sack the priest, when the Bishop merely moves the priest to anoter area, which leads to more molestation of more kids – then the Bishop does have some responsibility.

And when not one Bishop, but dozens of Bishops fail to take action against priests who molest children, and this is a policy laid down by the Vatican, then the Church hierarchy does have some responsibility.

Not for the initial abuse. That is absolutely just the fault of the individual priest. But for not having them sacked and arrested, that is the fault of Bishops and of the Vatican which condoned their lack of action.

Electoral Reform in Canada

The Conservative Government in Canada is proposing electoral reform for the House of Commons and the Senate.

At the moment, the House of Commons has vastly different sized seats. This is because the Canadian Constitution guarantees provinces a minimum number of seats, being the greater of their number of Senators or the number of seats they had in 1985.

What this means is the electoral quota in each province varies greatly. Currently:

  1. British Columbia 108.548
  2. Ontario 107.642
  3. Alberta 106,243
  4. Quebec 96,500
  5. Nova Scotia 82,546
  6. Manitoba 79,970
  7. Newfoundland and Labrador 73,276
  8. New Brunswick 72,950
  9. Saskatchewan 69,924
  10. Prince Edward Island 33,824

The Government can;t amend the constitution, so what they are doing is passing a law to effectively increase the size of Parliament,  This will see the House increase from 308 seats to 338 seats.

The three provinces that gain extra seats are 14 for Ontario, 4 for Alberta and 5 for British Columbia. Ontario.

Alberta is heavily Conservative, while British Columbia is a stronghold for the hard left NDP and Ontario tends to vote Liberal, so the changes do not favour the Conservatives at all. It is a good example of principled electoral reform.

The other major change is to the Canadian Senate. At present Senators are appointed by the Prime Minister, effectively for life (they retire at 75). The Conservatives are proposing a term limit of eight years, so a Senator retires after eight years in the Senate.

Another step in the right direction.

TV3 axes Sunrise and ASB Business

Dan News reports:

TV3’s morning shows Sunrise and ASB Business have been axed.

Sources tell Dan News that staff were informed of the decision this morning and the decision is effective immediately, the last shows went to air this morning.

Condolences to the staff who lose their jobs as a result. Not a surprise decision though – they just couldn’t compete with the pulling power of Paul Henry and co on TVNZ’s Breakfast.

More Labour rankings

I blogged yesterday some rankings for Labour MPs, based on their number of PQs, releases and news stories.

Rob Salmond helpfully suggested that rather than just averaging out their ranking in each category, I should measure how from the mean each MP is in each category and average those out. I’ve done so for the table above, and I think it does give a better feel.

The MPs are ranked on their simple average. I’ve also calculated a weighted average where the number of news stories is given 1/2 weight, number of releases 1/3 weight and number of PQs 1/6th.

Some observations:

  • Goff and King now ranked 1st and 2nd, which is appropriate.
  • Mallard and Hipkins are ranked third and fourth mainly due to their high number of PQs. On the weighted average though Hipkins is ranked lower
  • On the weighted average Charles Chauvel and Phil Twyford are 4th and 5th
  • Ashraf Choudhary, Rajen Prasad and Raymond Huo are still ranked as the bottom three

The Mokihinui Gorge dam

The Herald reports:

Commissioners who gave the green light to an 80m-high hydro dam in the Mokihinui Gorge north of Westport were overwhelmed by the gorge’s natural beauty, but said there were other equally beautiful gorges in the area.

John Lumsden, a civil engineer, and West Coast councillor Terry Archer outvoted fellow hearings commissioner Greg Ryder to say yes to the dam – the largest flooding of conservation land for hydro power ever proposed in New Zealand.

Explaining why they gave consent, the pair said: “If the Mokihinui River were to be considered in isolation, it would be difficult not to form the view that to build a dam and flood to gorge would be a travesty.

“When we walked through several sections … we could not help but be overwhelmed by its natural beauty.”

But they said that beauty was not unique on the West Coast, or even in the Buller District.

The renewable electricity the dam generated would give locals a more reliable power supply and take a load off fossil-fuelled power stations during dry years, they said.

This is the challenge facing NZ. If we want to have more renewable energy supply, then we need more dams. Yet, a dam has an environmental impact also.

What would people rather have – another coal powered power station, that only impacts a small area (yet releases huge amounts of greenhouse gases), or a renewable power hydro dam which impacts a larger area?

Some in the environmental movement are against all new energy projects. But that is a recipie for blackouts in a few years.

I’ve don’t know enough about Mokihinui to say whether the Commissioners made the right decision or not. But my challange to those who say it should not go ahead, is to specify an alternate location on the West Coast for a new power station.

Are legal expenses a work expense?

It is good that the public now know that some legal expenses for some MPs have been met by the Parliamentary Service.

However the reporting on this issue hasn’t made very clear a quite important point – that the paying of such expenses has not been an additional cost to the taxpayer – it has meant less gets spent by a parliamentary party in other areas such as pamphlets, Axe the Tax buses, press secretaries etc.

Each parliamentary party gets a set amount of money allocated to it, based on their number and type of MPs. The leadership decides how to spend that money – around half normally goes on paying for staff in the leader’s office, and the rest on expenses such as postage, printing, research, advertising etc.

Parliamentary parties go to great trouble to spend their full budget each year. A party leader would generally much prefer to spend more of their budget on some extra billboards for their latest campaign (such as axe the tax) or to hire an extra staff member, than pay the legal expenses of an MP.

So why do they sometimes pay the legal expenses of an MP? When they consider the legal expenses were incurred by the MP as part of their job. Much the same as any boss would have to decide whether to pay the legal fees of one of their employees.

Note that this can only be used to defend a lawsuit, not initiate a lawsuit.

Over time, three National MPs had their party leaders consider whether to meet some of their legal expenses out of the leader’s fund. I think they got it right in all three cases.

The Peters lawsuit against David Carter was for comments made by Carter explicitly in his role as Chair of a Select Committee which has been sent a letter making a number of allegations (off memory all Carter said was that they were so serious they needed investigating). I regard that as a work related expense.

The same goes for the Osmose lawsuit vs Nick Smith. Nick’s comments were in his role as parliamentary spokesperson for National on building issues.

Those two cases were both approved. The legal expenses for the private lawsuit against Gerry Brownlees relating to his evicting a protester from the 1999 National Party campaign launch were not approved. While there is an argument that Gerry was acting in his capacity as a whip, I think the correct decision was made that this was a private party function, and Gerry was acting in a private capacity, not a parliamentary capacity. Hence his legal expenses were not met.

So I don’t have an issue with the eligibility of legal expenses of MPs to be considered work expenses, met out of the bulk funded leader’s fund. Nor do I have an issue with the decisions made to date.

However on the issue of transparency, I would agree that it would be sensible for there to be a requirement for any use of parliamentary money on legal expenses to be disclosed, perhaps as part of the six monthly disclosures.

A civil suit vs the Waihopai Three?

The Herald reports:

One of the three Waihopai spy base attackers has welcomed the prospect of a $1.1 million Crown damages claim, saying the trio have less than $1000 between them.

Otaki school teacher Adrian Leason said even if the Crown won a lawsuit, it would have trouble getting the money.

“If they are going after Father Peter, Sam and myself, our combined personal wealth is probably under $1000.

Which is why a civil suit is the last thing the Crown should do. Sure, they may win the case and find the three liable for damages, but they’ll never get any money out of them.

Worse, another court case is exactly what they want. Their motives in their actions was to gain publicity for their cause, and they’d love another week or so of taxpayer funded publicity.

To some degree, their actions are much the same as Bethune’s in Japan – they want trials and all the publicity that go with them.

The Greens should support this

National and the Greens have an MOU where they co-operate in a few areas. Well I’ve found another area where they can work together.

ABC reports:

Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio is implementing a new inmate program at Tent City Jail called “Pedal Vision.”

The program uses inmate-powered cycles to generate electricity for televisions.

Reports say Arpaio’s recent visit to Tent City inspired the idea, when he saw that many of the inmates were overweight.

The stationary bikes are customized so that as an inmate pedals, a connected television is powered once the cycle generates 12 volts of electricity.

One hour of pedaling equals one hour of television viewing for the inmates, according to Arpaio.

Arpaio said the inmates will only be able to watch television in the television room if they choose to pedal.

I’m surprised Judith Collins hasn’t already got Corrections Department onto this. The Greens should love this for two reasons – it creates renewable energy and it is also an anti-obesity measure.

Wikileaks doing good

This is the video posted by Wikileaks, and I am glad they have exposed this to the public.

Newsweek sum it up well:

The footage is horrific; the attack killed 12 people and injured two children, none of whom appear to have been engaged in combat. Two of the men killed were Iraqi civilians employed by Reuters. All the while, the voices of the U.S. military personnel can be heard radioing back and forth about the shooting, demonstrating a cavalier disdain for the lives they are ending. At one point, they chuckle about a tank rolling over a dead body.

And regardless of the legality of their actions, that is a horrific culture. Of course you get desensitised to death in combat – you have to, to survive. But there is a difference between being desensitised and gloating.

It’s stomach-churning, but is it a crime, as WikiLeaks contends? As I pointed out, the pilot was very clearly following a military protocol, which explains, for example, why he was looking for a weapon before firing upon a wounded man (he never found one, but got permission to fire after a van showed up to take the man away). Still, that doesn’t necessarily mean he was following the protocol correctly, nor that the protocol lives up to international laws of war.

Questions the US military has to answer.

Andrew Sullivan has a summary of reaction, as to whether it was legal or not.

More on the NAB

I blogged on 23 March the change of name and focus for the External Assessments Bureau, who have now become the National Assessments Bureau.

Mainly I rebutted the hysteria that this meant the PM is getting a private spy agency, but I did comment at the end:

Having said all that, I am interested in the rationale for change, and think there should be a fuller understanding of what “gaps” in analysis there were, that this change will plug.

To that end I have just filed an OIA request with the DPMC for any information about the change of name and mandate for the EAB to the NAB. I have no doubt parts of any papers I receive will be redacted, but I hope to gain some better understanding of the change, and will blog it when I get the response.

DPMC have responded, and their reply is here – OIA Reply – Farrar, David – change of name and mandate of EAB [DPMC] – Scanned

Most of my request has been transferred to the SSC, as the lead agency that did the review. They’ve also withheld any info from within the NAB itself (no surprise), but did provide a news item from the DPMC Intranet, which has some quite interesting aspects to it:

  1. NAB is now tasked with establishing quality standards for intelligence analysis across the entire NZ intelligence community.
  2. NAB now responsible for developing a national assessment programme which will draw on resources outside DPMC
  3. The NAB and the DESG (Domestic & External Security Group) are moving out of their current location (Reserve Bank Building) into the new GCSB bulding in Pipitea Street, when it is completed later this year. So most of the intelligence community will be housed together.

Giving the NAB a role in quality control over the intelligence community seems quite sensible.

Sky vs Reven

I was a big champion of how TVNZ should make their free to air channels viewable on Sky boxes. It took a while, but you can now get TVNZ6 and 7 on Sky, which is great.

Sadly Sky do not seem to be reciprocating in the spirit of open access to the episode programme guide for their own channels.

Over at Geekzone Reven explains:

i just receieved a take down order from sky.

was wondering if anyone has any legal expertise?

not sure how much of a case they have, since
– i dont host any epg data
– sky isnt even used as a source for xmltvnz

What this is about is the application designed by Reven reads programme guide data from TV websites, so that users of home theatre PC’s can have an electronic tv guides built in to their systems.

If people want to use their own PCs as an electronic TV guide they should be able to.

In the US and Australia, courts have ruled EPG data is in the public domain. But the small guy probably can’t afford a lawsuit from Sky.

Sky produce a great product in My Sky, and great channels. But if someone wishes to subscribe to their channels, but use their own electronic EPG, they should be able to.