RIP Terry Heffernan

Rex W notified me of Terry’s death a couple of weeks ago, and this post has been in my pending file, waiting for me to catch up.

Most people who followed politics in the 1980s and 90s will know Terry. He stood for Parliament eight times from 1979 to 2008. That is not as unusual as the fact he stood for five different parties. Terry would argue the parties left him, rather than the other way around. His electoral record was:

  1. 1979 – for Social Credit in Christchurch Central (against Geoffrey Palmer)
  2. 1981 – for Social Credit in Wanganui
  3. 1984 – for the Democrats in Wanganui
  4. 1987 – for Social Credit in Wanganui – missing out by only 87 votes to Russell Marshall on election night. I wish he had won!
  5. 1990 – for the Alliance in Wanganui
  6. 1993 – for NZ First in Wanganui
  7. 1996 – for NZ First in Albany
  8. 2008 – for National in Port Hills

I have to be honest and say that I was slightly appalled when Port Hills selected Terry as their candidate in 2008. I had not met him at that stage, and just had a natural prejudice against anyone who has stood for Social Credit, the Alliance and Winston. His fallout with Winston slightly redeeming him!

But as I met Terry, and saw him in action, I understood how he managed to convince a pack of Nat loyalists to pick him – he had a certain charisma about him, was a passionate public speaker, and a very hard worker.

Kudos to Ruth Dyson for noting her opponent’s passing on the order paper for Parliament.

I did not know Terry well, but my belated condolences go out to those who did. he spent much of his life fighting for what he believed in.

Nats get robbed

The Press reports:

A former National Party treasurer has been sentenced to 100 hours community service after taking more than $4600 in party funds.

Michael John Gibbs, 36, the treasurer of the party’s Wigram branch between September and December 2008, pleaded guilty in the Christchurch District Court on Thursday to the theft of $4636.

Judge Stephen Erber sentenced Gibbs to 100 hours community service.

I don’t know Gibbs, but it almost looks like he became Treasurer to steal money, as he only served for three months – his offending must have started at once.

The police summary of facts said Gibbs set up an internet banking account and was able to transfer money from the party’s bank account without following procedures that required withdrawal slips to be signed by two members of the Wigram branch.

This makes me wonder how this happened. If two signatures are needed, then the internet banking access should have been set up requiring two users to authorise.

By December 2008, he had completed 12 internet bank transactions totalling $4636.

In February last year, a new treasurer found there was only 10 cents left in the party’s Wigram account.

Pretty damn stupid, as obvious he would be found out.

Pure Golf

Late last year I met Michael Goldstein who had just done a great thing. He had just quit his job as a lawyer, to do a challenge to play a round of golf at a different course every day of the year, around the world.

Michael, and Jamie’s challenge, will help raise funds for The First Tee.

Yesterday they were playing at Coolamon, and have blogged about their challenge.

You can follow their exploits through their blog, or on Facebook or Twitter.

So far they have played 9,310 strokes between them (Michael is six shots ahead of Jamie) and they have managed 221 birdies.

If you’re a golf fan, you may want to follow their progress, and even consider helping with their fundraising for The First Tee.

Editorials 5 April 2010

The Herald focuses on the SFO:

Helen Clark’s Government threatened to abolish the SFO and merge its functions with a police unit.

Having survived that, the SFO is now facing a renewed barrage of criticism and an overhaul that seems likely to comprehensively change its mode of operation.

Judith Collins, the Minister Responsible for the SFO, has talked of rebuilding “its capabilities after years of political neglect”. …

The upshot appears to be that five senior staff with more than 70 years of fraud investigation experience among them, including Gib Beattie, the present assistant director, are unlikely to reapply for new roles.

All have been involved in high-profile cases, including, most recently, that of ASB Bank fraudster Stephen Versalko. If they depart, the SFO will lose a huge fund of institutional knowledge.

It will surely face a greater struggle to combine with other regulators to ensure the “speedier, united response to cases of suspected fraud” demanded by Ms Collins.

Too much of the criticism of the SFO has been over the top. It should not be the whipping boy for the finance-company debacle and nor should it be restructured in such a way that valuable experience is driven away.

If a wiser approach is not adopted, white-collar criminals will be the only winners.

In the end, the SFO will be judged on its results.

The Press calls for goodwill on the foreshore & seabed issue:

In recent New Zealand political and social history, few issues have been as divisive as the foreshore and seabed. This controversial debate was triggered by the Court of Appeal ruling in the 2003 Ngati Apa legal action, which suggested that in some narrow cases iwi might be able to convert customary title into freehold title.

For the then-Labour Government, this raised the spectre that Maori could end up controlling sections of the coastline and limiting public access. Labour over-reacted by passing legislation that placed the foreshore and seabed in Crown ownership, albeit with a process for recognising customary rights, and this triggered the formation of the Maori Party.

Now, National has offered an olive branch to iwi and the Maori Party. It is, inevitably, a compromise solution but, with goodwill on all sides, it does have the potential to heal the lingering sore that has been the foreshore and seabed issue.

People should not be surprised that most Iwi will say they want more, than what is in the proposed solution. To some degrees, this is like any other commercial negotiation. You never have one party say “Oh well actually I think we have enough money/resource, so we won’t try and get any more”. Of course you do.

But this tension is not the only reason why the Maori Party has been circumspect in its reaction to National’s foreshore and seabed proposal. Maori leaders will want to be seen as pushing for the maximum concessions possible.

The party will be acutely conscious that within its ranks are those who would agree with its MP Hone Harawira’s view that Maori should have full ownership, rather than just customary title.

And that is a view some may have. But that is not what the Court of Appeal ruled. In fact, it is a million miles from what the Court of Appeal said.

But this would be totally unacceptable to National, and Prime Minister John Key has delivered a blunt warning that if he cannot forge a consensus around his party’s proposal, then the status quo will prevail.

Given that the Maori Party was originally formed to get rid of the hated foreshore and seabed legislation, the chance to achieve this and to get customary title through the courts is one which, while not ideal for all iwi, should still be firmly grasped.

And so far, there does seem to be goodwill.

The Dominion Post looks at Labour’s plans for Wellington City Council:

The Labour Party has announced it will relaunch itself into local body politics, and put up a slate of council candidates as well as, perhaps, someone for mayor.

So Labour want to take over the Council. I’m tempted to joke that at least it makes it easy to know who not to vote for, but in fact I don’t vote purely on ideological lines for local bodies. I regard (for example) that Ray Ahipene-Mercer does a good job as a Councillor, and he is left of centre. Celia Stephanie Cook also does a reasonable job, and she is Green.

Does Wellington want local body politics to return to tribal affiliations? Would that be good for the city?

The answer is “maybe”. Having a stance thrashed out at caucus meetings – which MPs hold regularly – before council meetings might mean that the fractious debate that so marks Wellington City Council disappears. Arguments would happen within the caucus instead.

That might improve the council’s public reputation.

On the other hand, councillors who represent a political party would be subject to the party whip – that is, be forced to toe the party line – or risk being dropped from the party ticket at the next election.

The same might be true, of course, of those who rely on Sir Robert’s patronage when or if they stand in October.

Party politics have their place. That might be around a council table. But cleaving to rigid ideologies is no substitute for considered thought, which is what ratepayers vote councillors into office to provide – especially when Wellington’s future is at stake in a post-Auckland super-city environment.

The over-riding concern of any councillor must surely be what is best for the city they have the honour to represent.

That is not possible for Labour Councillors. I agree a ticket can sometimes be of value, to get a coherent agenda through. But tickets are best as groupings of like minded people, but not as a party that bans Councillors from voting against the majority.

Labour has specific rules on local body elections.

  • Rule 87 bans party members from standing as Independents if Labour contests the election
  • Rule 91 requires candidates to sign a pledge that they will vote in line with the Caucus for that local body

So be aware, if you vote for a Labour candidate, you are voting for candidates who are forbidden freedom of opinion on any issue that comes before Council.

The ODT focuses on land in Africa and New Zealand:

During the past two or three years, as many as 20 million hectares of African land, an area equivalent to all the arable farming land in France and worth about $US20 billion-$US30 billion, have been acquired by countries such as Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and China.

These vast tracts have been either bought or leased to grow staple crops, or biofuels, which are then repatriated, says a 2009 Economist magazine article. …

It is partly against this background that attempts to buy up large parcels of New Zealand land should be considered.

The latest such move came to light on Wednesday when it was reported that a company, Southern Pastures, registered in Auckland, is seeking $500 million from local and offshore investors either to buy outright or controlling shares in farming concerns thoughout the southern hemisphere, but with a bias towards New Zealand. …

Leadership is required, and care needed, to devise policy on how New Zealand will play its part in the food supply chain over the next several decades.

On the one hand, the country requires inward investment to develop further aspects of food production infrastructure; on the other, once the land is gone, it is gone forever.

Measurable gains from such sales will need to be demonstrably substantial and long-lasting before they can be permitted.

If we ban Chinese firms from investing in NZ farms, then we can’t complain if China bans Fonterra from investing in Chinese dairy operations.

Housing NZ’s IT

The Dom Post reports:

A spokeswoman for newly reinstated Housing Minister Phil Heatley says he does not believe he will have a final say on plans by Housing New Zealand to spend $43 million replacing its software systems.

A pity, as there are some real questions about it.

The board of the Crown-owned corporation approved the business case for its Enterprise Transformation Programme last week. The spokeswoman says the project is an operational matter.

Two whistleblowers, two former managers and Roger Phare, operating officer at existing software supplier Technology One, have questioned aspects of the project, for which a bevy of consulting firms has been paid more than $6m for advice.

Yep that is $6 million just for advice on its IT.

Housing New Zealand has so far refused to detail projected annual savings of $70 million that have been called into question by opposition housing spokeswoman Moana Mackey, or comment on claims that it paid consultants up to $600 an hour and created a potential conflict of interest for strategic adviser Deloitte.

Now the very top lawyers in NZ do charge $600 an hour, but I’ve never heard of that level of charging on an IT project. You might pay it for top commercial lawyers in billion dollar deals, but rare for IT projects.

An earlier story in the Dom Post reported:

A whistleblower has claimed Housing New Zealand may have created a potential conflict of interest for a consulting firm that is providing advice for a $43.6 million information technology project. …

Housing New Zealand would not say whether Deloitte’s contract as strategic adviser precluded the consulting firm from securing any work implementing software that would be purchased as a result of the project.

Computer Society chief executive Paul Matthews says organisations need not preclude consultants that provide them with strategic advice from also having a role in implementing any solution, but it would be unusual and “not particularly good practice”.

“It really depends on the circumstances. With most conflict-of- interest situations, if the terms in the conflict of interest are clear and they are open and transparent and all parties are aware of it, then in some circumstances they may not be precluded, but you would expect in a larger project they would be.”

Housing New Zealand last month acknowledged a steering group comprised of senior executives had over- ruled a recommendation by an evaluation panel in appointing Deloitte. It said the panel had over- stepped its brief in recommending a rival firm do the job.

So the evaluation panel recommended another firm, and this was over-ruled by executives? This is the point as which you get nervous also.

ALAC on Drink Driving levels

The CEO of ALAC writes in the Herald:

The Ministry of Transport’s Safer Journeys strategy includes a proposal to lower the legal adult blood-alcohol content for driving from 0.08 (80mg alcohol/100ml of blood) to 0.05mg.

In its response to the strategy, the Government approved a number of measures including a zero alcohol tolerance for drivers under 20. It has, however, deferred a decision on the adult level to later this month. It will also consider the option of undertaking more research into the risk posed by drivers with a blood-alcohol content between 0.05 and 0.08.

In my view, the time for more research is past. It is time for action. The evidence for a lower blood-alcohol content is overwhelming.

I disagree. I think the evidence is far from overwhelming. I think a sensible Government would indeed do more research.

The Safer Journeys document suggested:

As an alternative to lowering the adult drink-drive limit, we could do more research on the level of risk presented by drivers with a BAC of between 0.05 and 0.08.

To do this we could replicate, using New Zealand drivers, the overseas studies that look at the impairment effects of alcohol at different levels of BAC while driving.

We could also investigate whether we could better establish the level of crashes that are caused by drivers with a BAC between 0.05 and 0.08. This could involve requiring all drivers involved in crashes to be subject to a compulsory breath or blood test.

I think both those research ideas are laudable. ALAC continues:

Since the 0.08 for adult drivers was set in 1978, New Zealand and international research has consistently demonstrated that an alcohol limit of 0.05 or lower saves lives and prevents serious injuries. In Australia, New South Wales achieved an 8 per cent reduction in fatal crashes, and Queensland achieved an 18 per cent reduction.

The lower one sets the limit, it is likely the fewer crashes there will be. But one has to look at both sides of the equation. One could have a zero blood alcohol limit for all adults, but that will them criminalise most of the population. If you have one drink at work and drive home, you would be breaking the law.

Any advocacy that focuses just one one side of the equation, is unbalanced. One has to look at the benefits and the costs. If one only focuses on road injuries, then you would set a maximum speed limit of 30 km/hr on open roads. It is about a balance between safety and convenience.

Safer Journeys estimates that an adult drink-drive limit here of 0.05 would save between 15 and 33 lives and prevent 320 to 686 injuries every year. This corresponds to an estimated annual social cost saving of between $111 million and $238 million.

Well my reading of the document says:

However, based on the alcohol-related crashes that occurred over 2004–2008, we estimate that adult drivers with a BAC of between 0.05 and 0.08 are responsible for at least 7 deaths, 45 serious injuries and 102 minor injuries of the total 119 deaths, 582 serious injuries and 1,726 minor injuries that were caused by drunk and drugged drivers in 2008.

And if one goes to the actual 2008 crash statistics, we see there were 366 road fatalities. 211 drivers, 107 passengers, 31 pedestrians, 10 cyclists and 7 others.

Now of the 211 drivers killed, 171 were tested for blood alcohol levels.

Of the 171 tested, 58 had blood alcohol levels of over 0.03.

The chart shows that most drivers killed are not even close to the 80 limit. They are at least double it, sometimes triple it. This is where I think the focus should go.

But there were five dead drivers with a BAC between 0.5 and 0.8. So would changing the law save those five drivers, and an unknown number of passengers?

Well no. Two of the five are aged under 20, where their limit is already 0.03. And two more were aged 20 to 24. So only one driver aged over 24 had a BAC of 0.05 to 0.08.

This is why I am unconvinced that a lowering of the limit for adults will have much of an impact on the road toll.

A possible compromise may be to increase the age for the youth limit from 20 to 25. That road safety data shows that 20-29 year olds are still far more prone to fatal crashes, then over 30 year olds at differing levels of blood alcohol.

If an over 30 driver with a BAC of 0 is deemed to have a risk of 1 for a fatal crash, the risks at 0.03, 0.05 and 0.08 are:

0.03 – 2.9 (30+), 8.7 (20-29), 15 (15-19)

0.05 -5.8 (30+), 17.5 (20-29), 30.3 (15-19)

0.08 – 16.5 (30+), 50.2 (20-29), 86.6 (15-19)

If one had a limit of 0.03 for under 20s (status quo), 0.05 for under 30s (a reduction from 0.08) and 0.08 for over 30s (status quo) then you would have a similar level of risk over all age groups.

Four techie things

  1. Now have a USB powered 320 GB external HD. Cost only $100 or so and it is light enough to keep with the laptop. Means I can be backing up easily daily. The old external HD was a big clunker and unreliable.
  2. Finally got my laptop bluetoothing with my Blackberry. Can now sychronise it without needing the cord. Yay.
  3. As it was on sale for $25, finally got a webcam. Will be good for skypeing with friends overseas. My curiousity got the better of me and tried chatroulette briefly. I got to see more male genitalia than even Annabel Chong could handle. Don’t think I will return!
  4. Am getting moderately excited about the iPad. While I generally prefer to read books the old fashioned way, I can see how great it will be for students who can dump all their textbooks into it. Also would be great for lengthy trips – no more having to lug a dozen books in my suitcase.

Liberals to govern in Tasmania

The recent elections in Tasmania saw a hung Parliament. Labor went from 14 to 10 seats, Libs from 7 to 10 and Greens from 4 to 5.

They have five multi-member electorates, so in every electorate there are two Libs, two Labor and one Green.

What is interesting is that Labor have surrendered power voluntarily, rather than trying to hold onto power by doing a deal with the Greens.

The outgoing Labor Premier said before the election that he believes the party that won the most seats, or the most votes if seats are equal, should be given first chance to govern. The libs had 2.1% greater share of the vote.

The Greens are miffed that the decision by Labor, means the Libs do not need to negotiate with them. Both the Greens and Labor have said they will vote supply to allow the Government to govern, but the Greens are under some pressure to renege.

Labor in fact have gone further and said they will not move a motion of no confidence, unless there is maladministration.

Six of the Liberal MPs are newly elected, so some first time MPs may end up Ministers.

Some may ask why did the Labor Premier not try and do a deal wit the Greens. This article gives some background:

That is the long-sustained Labor narrative, upheld ever since the Michael Field-led Labor-Green accord of 1989-92 disintegrated, that says the Tasmanian Greens should never be trusted again.

This is the view that minority governments never work. That trying to rule in minority equates to too many compromises and death by a thousand cuts, resulting in a loss of economic confidence in Tasmania, political chaos and a morass of indecision.

And that whichever political party is placed in minority government will be ripped to shreds and punished severely at the ensuing state poll after their parliamentary term invariably ends up truncated in about two years time.

Labor’s view is supported by the evidence of Tasmania’s past two most recent attempts at minority government that relied on the Greens’ support on the floor of parliament.

The Labor-Green Field government disintegrated in February 1992 after 32 months, with Labor then out of power for the next six years.

The next minority Liberal-Green accord Rundle government of 1996-1998 only lasted 30 months. After that experience, the Liberals have not had a sniff of regaining government until this year.

With that background, Bartlett believes — and former premier Michael Field is one of Mr Bartlett’s closest mentors while his brother Terry Field has been his personal chief of staff for the past four years — Labor is much better off in opposition for reasons of short-term expediency.

They’ve chosen Opposition, rather than trust the Greens again.

Bring on the Super City

Brian Rudman reminds us why the Royal Commission unanimously recommended creation of the Auckland Super City:

The death rattles that echoed around the recent meeting of the Territorial Local Authority Electoral College are proof of that.

This weirdly named entity consists of councillors from the seven territorial councils and acts as the statutory link between the councils and assorted regional amenities.

Ten days ago it met to rubber-stamp the size of ratepayer contributions for the 2010/11 year for the Auckland Museum, Museum of Transport and Technology and the 10 amenities lumped together under the 2008 Auckland Regional Amenities Funding Act.

Funding for the two museums was nodded through without a blink, but when it came to the 10 amenities, three of the councils that fought so hard against the act in 2008 reignited the battle and voted against the levy. …

As a result, an arbitrator – thought to be retired High Court Judge Peter Salmon, QC – has had to be brought in at ratepayers’ expense to decide between the expert funding board and the six parochial councillors who fluked the victory.

There’s hope of a decision within three weeks so the 10 amenities, which include the Auckland Philharmonia Orchestra, Auckland Regional Rescue Helicopter, Auckland Theatre Company and WaterSafe Auckland, will know what level of regional funding from July 1 they can expect.

They can’t even on basic funding decisions for regional amenities.

In the electoral college, the opposition came from Manukau, Franklin, Papakura and, to no one’s surprise, the perennially deep-pocketed misers of the North Shore. Tony Millar, the one Auckland City representative to show up, got the backing of the two Waitakere City representatives and, hallelujah, Rodney deputy mayor John Kirikiri.

A week after the defeat, Mr Kirikiri was still steaming. He had defied instructions from his own council to vote against the levy, saying he and his fellow college members were duty bound to follow the wishes of the government legislation.

He also respected the views of the funding board, which, he pointed out, he and his college colleagues had helped to appoint.

“We chose them because they had the knowledge, skill and ability to come up with decisions that the electoral college plainly can’t.”

He adds: “For the electoral college to vote against it is abhorrent. These amenities are relying on this funding. The Super City’s got to be better than what we’ve got now. Good riddance to this committee, it’s plainly not doing what it was set up to do.”

And that is the Deputy Mayor of Rodney.

There will be some teething issues with the new Auckland Council, but I am sure in 2020, most Aucklanders will look back and wonder why they left it so long to get rid of their divided and bickering local Councils.

Three Strikes Debate

The Herald reports:

The Government’s revised “three strikes” bill is estimated to cover more than five times as many criminals as the original legislation, significantly widening it from the original target of the “worst of the worst” offenders.

The issue was highlighted in a Maxim Institute-sponsored lecture at Victoria University in Wellington by Auckland University professor Warren Brookbanks and law lecturer Richard Ekins.

It’s good to have debate on this, as people should be aware of what the law will do.

For my part it would be nice to have a focus on how many victims would have not been killed, raped, assaulted or robbed if this law had been in force for the last decade, not just a focus on how many offenders will have been affected.

The Sentencing and Parole Reform Bill, now before Parliament, would set up a warning and sentencing system for anyone convicted for one of 40 qualifying offences deemed to be serious violent or sexual crimes.

Strike one would be a normal sentence and a warning; strike two would be a sentence without parole; strike three would be the maximum sentence for that offence, without parole.

The original bill held that a conviction counted as a strike for a violent offence where the sentence was five years or more.

The initial proposal called for an extra 132 prison beds in the next 50 years; the new one is estimated to require 725 beds.

Personally I’m comfortable with that. The original proposal would have affected well less than a dozen criminals a year.

I don’t think we have a high number of criminals in this country. We just have a number of criminals, who commit a high number of crimes each. And having a rotating door policy where they are in and out of prison after not just their third serious offence, but sometimes their 100th offence needs to come to an end.

Professor Brookbanks said that “qualifying offences” was a much lower test, as it applied to convictions for certain offences regardless of how serious or trivial they were.

“The shift from qualifying sentence to qualifying conviction radically widens the scope, bringing far more offenders into the scheme,” he said.

Yes it does, deliberately. The old scheme would have had little deterrence value in my opinion. The good feature of this new scheme is certainty (and remember certainty of being caught is one of the biggest deterrences to crime) of sentence.

If you have had two previous strikes, you have had a Judge in court tell you to your face that if you commit another serious offence, you will get the maximum sentence for that crime with no parole. There is basically no chance of getting 12 months jail, and out in six. You will get a sentence of (generally) at least seven years with no parole for your next serious offence.

He said that with no incentive to plead guilty to a strike-three charge, there would be more trials and appeals, which would be more stressful for victims and see court costs rise – a point raised by Labour critics.

A fair point, but how many defendants facing a third serious criminal charge, do plead guilty? Give us some hard numbers.

But as I said, the numbers I really want to see is how many fewer victims of crime there would have been, if this had been the law up until now. How many crimes have been committee by criminals after they have had a third serious offence conviction, during the period they would have served if given the maximum sentence?

Fallow on Tax

Brian Fallow writes:

“We need to stop the tax system creating the wrong incentives,” said Treasury Secretary John Whitehead in a speech last week.

Citing Inland Revenue data, Whitehead said 1996 was the last year that more people made profits than losses from rental properties, yet the number of such properties had increased significantly since then.

I wonder what the total amount of tax losses claimed in those 15 years has been.

“Now why would increasing numbers of people – rational New Zealanders – invest billions of dollars collectively in an area that is unprofitable?” he said.

“It’s hard to believe it’s not because of the tax advantages. People can claim depreciation against their investment properties – even when most real estate was significantly increasing in value. They can deduct tax losses on property against their other income.

“And if they sell a rental property the capital gain they make is usually untaxed.”

The depreciation is reversed at sale, but you may have had interest free use of that money for a decade or more.

A widely quoted passage of the Tax Working Group’s report in January said that in 2008 the $200 billion invested in rental housing yielded net rental losses totalling $500 million.

That meant that collectively landlords not only paid no tax on their rental income, they were able to escape paying around $150 millon of tax on other sources of income they had.

However, Michael Littlewood, of Auckland University’s Retirement Policy and Research Centre, has cast a lot of doubt on the robustness of the $200 billion figure. …

But if he is right to conclude that the true combined value of residential investment properties could well be less than half the $200 billion stated, how much ice is that likely to cut with policymakers?

I doubt it will change decisions, but it will change estimates of how much revenue the Crown may gain from any changes.

It depends what they are most worried about. If their concern is that New Zealanders are over-invested in property and that that is for tax reasons rather than, say, a shortage of other investment opportunities, then Littlewood’s results are highly relevant.

But if the concern is purely fiscal – how to fund the gap between the $2 billion and change that a GST increase would yield and the cost of comprehensive income tax cuts and compensating adjustments to superannuation, benefits and family tax credits – then the focus would be not on how much is invested in rental properties but on the aggregate $500 million of net tax losses.

A bit of both I’d say, with priority on the latter.

The IRD data charted by the tax working group shows a clear downward trend in net rental income for the past decade, and it was 10 years ago that the Labour Government raised the top marginal tax rate from 33 to 39 per cent, increasing the incentive to shelter income through highly geared property investment.

I sometimes wonder if anyone actually pays the (now) 38% tax rate? Much better to reverse Cullen’s envy tax, and clamp down on loopholes.

Dim-Post on Daylight Saving

Danyl ponders on what would happen if a Government tried today to introduce daylight savingL

Setting my clocks back this morning had me thinking about what a great little trick daylight savings is for maximizing use of sunlight hours, but also how impossible it would be to bring in such a scheme today: Labour would launch a protest bus tour (‘Stop the Clock!’), the Business Round Table and CIS would insist that we had to set our clocks forward a thousand hours to catch up with Australia, Herald columnists would thunder about Wellington bureaucrats kidnapping the sun for an extra hour every night, the unions would strike for the right to set their clocks back two hours. The government would compromise and set clocks back five minutes for a week in mid-June.

I know its satire, but deep down you also know that some of it is true!

The blueing of Auckland

Matt Nippert in the Herald on Sunday looks at the blueing of Auckland.

I can certainly recall the days when National held just half a dozen seats or so in Auckland, and now it is Labour that is reduce to single figures in Auckland.

Almost one in 10 Aucklanders voted National for the first time in the 2008 general election. Head-to-head, there was a 15 per cent swing to the right, and four middle-Auckland electorates changed their political colours.

National’s average vote in Auckland was 48.3%, compared to 38.0% in Wellington and 42.1% in Christchurch.

The National over Labour gap in Auckland was 15.4%, compared to 10.9% nationally. Only rural NZ had a bigger gap

Auckland also had the largest swing in the country. National went up 6.9% and Labour went down 8.9%.

This movement was particularly pronounced in the city south of the bridge and north of Manukau: young Nikki Kaye unseated Judith Tizard in Auckland Central; Pansy Wong crucified the opposition in the newly created Botany; leopard-skin-clad Paula Bennett stormed home in Waitakere; and burly Samoan rugby player Sam Lotu-Iiga claimed Maungakiekie from old-school unionist Mark Gosche.

The print copy has an amusing sketch of Paula, Sam and Nikki respectively as Wonder Woman, Super Man and well I am not sure but I think Sheena.

Repeatedly, Labour MPs interviewed for this story refer to their electoral defeat as a movement of tides.

That of course is part of it, but not all of it. For may part, here are some of the factors which led to National winning seats off Labour in Auckland.

  1. Right candidates for the seats
  2. They ran campaigns to win the seats, not just party vote campaigns. A good local campaign will life electorate vote and party vote.
  3. The boundary changes were generally favourable to National, especially in areas like Maungakiekie.
  4. Incumbent MPs were retiring or weak
  5. The Government had lost touch – ie time for a change

Now if Labour are placing all their faith in (5) no longer being an issue, then they may get a shock.

The implication is that if the tide of support went out in 2008, it’ll come back in eventually. But, a year and a half later, there is little sign of a sea change that will wash the left back to power.

One has to make it happen, not just wait for the tide.

Chris Carter, whose electorate seat Te Atatu swung almost 20 percentage points to National from Labour, is almost blase about Patel’s change of allegiance: “By and large the Indian community is still with us – and the South African one is for the other guys. That’s the way it’s always been.”

But not necessarily the way it always will stay.

While Trotter has been bitterly attacked by Labour backbenchers for his diagnosis, their leader concedes he may have a point. “I think that’s probably right,” says Goff of the loss of ‘Waitakere Man’: “There’s a group of people out there who thought that Labour had become too nanny-statist, telling people what to do and not to do.”

Not just nanny state. Too reluctant to give tax cuts, and too keen to grow government spending.

SST on Andrew Williams

The SST editorial is one I agree with:

Some say the revelation of the mayor’s exploits is part of an Act Party plot against him. Certainly Act’s leader, Rodney Hide, doesn’t like Williams and wants him to go. Some of the mayor’s local opponents are also Act people. But Act didn’t force the mayor to spend a lengthy period in two bars in one day and then to urinate in public. Nor did Act tip off this newspaper about what the mayor was doing, despite vague accusations to that effect. Our reporter happened to notice Williams in a bar. There was no stalking, despite what the mayor’s wife, Jane Williams, has claimed. The reporter observed the politician. He saw him urinate in a public place and then drive the mayoral car home. He put the facts to the man himself. In other words, he did his job. The newspaper duly published the story, and the arguments began.

And a point often overlooked, is this was not a case of being caught short. This was a deliberate decision to take a piss outside the Council building, rather than go inside.

The Sunday Star-Times did not join Rodney Hide in calling for Williams to resign and it is not doing so now.

And neither have I, for what it is worth. Pissing in public is not a sackable offence.Hell, one former Minister even got away with pissing on a waiter in a hotel corridor.

They will also remember that this is not the first time that Williams has behaved in a peculiar fashion. The prime minister says Williams sent him obnoxious texts in the middle of the night. Williams is of course free to disagree with the PM. He is free to text him. But doing so in the small hours is dopey, unpleasant and even a mild form of harassment.

And doing so to the PM is especially stupid. Most people can turn their phones off at night. The PM is one of the few people who does have to be contactable at all hours. Having is cellphone number is a privilege that should not be abused.

The mayor’s supporters will say all this is just colourful and eccentric and nothing to really worry about. And it’s true that there have been plenty of eccentric mayors in New Zealand, although not so many from the rather staid and respectable North Shore.

Williams reminds me of Tim Shadbolt, but with a key difference being Tim can laugh at himself.

A readers’ poll on the Stuff website last week showed an overwhelming majority thought he should go. Williams, who is becoming adept at managing the crises he inflicts upon himself, called a special press conference last week to announce that he would stand for some unspecified post in the elections this year. So – Andrew Williams for the Auckland super city council? Heaven forbid.

I think it will be hilarious if Williams stands, as that will probably encourage Whale Oil to stand in the same ward as him. The meet the candidate meetings should become pay per view events!

McCarten on ACC

Matt McCarten writes in the HoS:

One hundred thousand workers on the legal minimum wage of $12.50 an hour get 25 cents added to their hourly wage this week. Thousands of others between the minimum and $12.75 an hour will get a top-up.

Given that we have a recession, many people may think those workers should be grateful to John Key for giving them anything. As Key said, at least the 25 cents would cover inflation, making them no worse off, and a group of low-paid workers told me this week that “it’s better than nothing”.

But as with many stories about workers and their relationship with the employment system, all is not as it seems. The fact is that, from today, low-paid workers will be worse off than they were this time last year even after the supposed largesse from our Prime Minister, because their Accident Compensation levies go up this week, too.

The Government hopes workers won’t notice, but those on the minimum wage will have an extra 3.75 cents an hour automatically deducted from this week’s pay packet.

It’s a tax increase, although National pretends it’s not. What is galling is that the levy increase is being imposed to ensure ACC can show a big profit and then be flicked off as a cash cow to some multinational after the next election.

Matt is right that ACC premiums are going up, from 1.7% to 2.0%.

However what he overlooks is that National’s pruning of ACC has prevented the premiums from going up even further. The massive unfunded liabilities left by Labour would have pushed the employee ACC levies up to over 3.0% of income.

Matt was one of those protesting the pruning of ACC’s costs, so for him to them protest about the levy increase is rather hypocritical.

This is not Disneyland, where you can have the costs of ACC increase, but not have levies increase.

And frankly the idea that anyone would buy ACC is as nonsensical as the notion that anyone would buy Kiwirail.

Stupidity from two Denominations

I’d rather not be taking a whack at two different Christian religions (one of them nominally my own) at Easter, but they set the timing.

First we have Anglican Archbishop of Sydney Peter Jensen saying:

RELIGIOUS leaders have used their Easter sermons and messages to condemn the rise of atheism, with Sydney Anglican Archbishop Peter Jensen describing the philosophy as an “assault on God”.

“As we can see by the sheer passion and virulence of the atheist – they seem to hate the Christian God – we are not dealing here with cool philosophy up against faith without a brain,” Dr Jensen told worshippers.

“Atheism is every bit of a religious commitment as Christianity itself.

“It represents the latest version of the human assault on God, born out of resentment that we do not in fact rule the world and that God calls on us to submit our lives to him.

“It is a form of idolatry in which we worship ourselves.”

No, it isn’t and the Archbishop’s generalisations are as offensive as generalising about Christians.

But then to trump that, we have The Rev. Raniero Cantalamessa, the Pope’s personal preacher:

Pope Benedict XVI’s personal preacher has likened accusations against the pope and the Catholic church in the sex abuse scandal to “collective violence” suffered by the Jews.

Yes blaming the Catholic Church for covering up child abuse, is just the same as the pogroms.

“They know from experience what it means to be victims of collective violence and also because of this they are quick to recognize the recurring symptoms,” the preacher said.

Quoting from the letter from the friend, who wasn’t identified by Cantalamessa, the preacher said that he was following ”’with indignation the violent and concentric attacks against the church, the pope and all the faithful of the whole world.”‘

“The use of stereotypes, the passing from personal responsibility and guilt to a collective guilt remind me of the more shameful aspects of anti-Semitism,”‘ Cantalamessa said his friend wrote him.

Catholics as a whole of course have no responsibility or collective guilt over what a minority of priests did.

But that is different from the hierarchy of the church. In many countries, the hierarchy covered up the child abuse.  Priests were left free to abuse, and their crimes were not reported to authorities. Fot that there is a collective responsibility – not by all Catholics, but by the Church hierarchy which in almost every country reacted in the same way.

More silly name supression

The Dominion Post has a big story today on the inquest into the suicide of Margo McAuley. As with any suicide, it is all very sad.

What caught my attention was this:

Wellington coroner Ian Smith held a two-day hearing into Ms McAuley’s apparent suicide in October 2008. He suppressed the identity of the high-profile New Zealander Mr MacIntyre married within three months of his wife’s death. Mr MacIntyre’s new wife publicly denied the pair were having an affair before Ms McAuley’s death. That was repeated by Mr MacIntyre during the inquest.

I had not realised that the coroner had imposed name suppression. With all respects to the coroner, that is a silly and futile action.

I am sure the vast majority of New Zealanders know who MacIntyre’s new wife is, or at the least can find it with a 10 second go on Google. Does the coroner think we all have amnesia?

It also seems to be stretching the sort of info which gets suppressed. I am a bit staggered that for the duration of the suppression order, it is an offence to state who Kim MacIntyre’s wife is.

If the name suppression is permanent, does that mean his wife can never be named?

Again, how very futile. But don’t drop hints as to the name in comments unless you like demerits. I am sure anyone who wants to know can find the name on the Herald or Stuff websites in a few seconds via Google.

Great Ad

50 years for abortion doctor killing

AFP reports:

A BORN-AGAIN Christian who said he killed a prominent US abortion doctor to save the lives of unborn babies has sentenced to life in prison with no chance of parole for 50 years.

Scott Roeder, 52, was pulled out of the courtroom screaming “you have the blood of babies on your hands”‘ after the sentence was handed down.

Mr Roeder should be more concerned about his own blood. He is obviously totally unrepentant and would kill again if released, so it is good he will effectively never be freed.

In a move that critics feared could provide cover for acts of political violence, Roeder had sought to convince jurors he was only guilty of voluntary manslaughter.  Under Kansas law, voluntary manslaughter can apply when actions are taken based on an unreasonable but honest defence that he or she is preventing a greater harm.

Now does that sound familiar? Few things are more dangerous than someone who thinks their religious beliefs place them above the law.

Gaynor on GPG

Brian Gaynor writes:

However GPG’s New Zealand shareholders still have some influence and the May 7 annual meeting is an important one for the company.

It is 20 years since GPG was reconstituted by Sir Ron Brierley and this is the year he has vowed to return value to shareholders.

This promise seems to be waning and shareholders need to give a strong message to the directors that procrastination is unacceptable.

The best way to do this is to vote against Resolution 2 (the directors’ remuneration report), Resolution 3 (the re-appointment of Tony Gibbs as a director) and Resolution 4 (the re-appointment of Ron Langley to the board).

Why does Gaynor say this?

GPG’s annual report shows the company had a loss of £36 million for December 2009 compared with a loss of £50 million for the previous year.

These figures are not overly important as the key issue as far as investment companies are concerned is their sharemarket performance and that has been fairly dreadful in the case of GPG.

The company has underperformed the benchmark NZX50 Gross Index in four of the past five years and had a negative 2009 return of 4.9 per cent, including dividends and 1 for 10 bonus issue, compared with an 18.9 per cent appreciation in the benchmark NZX50 Gross Index.

GPG has had a negative return of 28.6 per cent since the end of 2004 compared with a positive 6.6 per cent return by the NZX benchmark index.

Pretty bad results, to say the least.

The directors have been extremely well paid even though the company has underperformed the NZX by a wide margin. Since the end of 2004, Tony Gibbs has had total remuneration of $23.1 million.

Blake Nixon, who is based in London, has earned $17.7 million and Gary Weiss $21.7 million.

The company’s performance does not justify these huge remuneration packages.

Many company directors are underpaid, but I don’t think that is a description one can apply to GPG.

These three Directors have been paid around $63 million for a result of wiping out 29% of the company’s worth.

It is time for shareholders to say enough.

Garner interviewed

A very amusing interview of Duncan Garner by Michele Hewitson. An extract:

So, I’ll tell you what he had to drink: the best part of a bottle of wine and five beers, plus two more after I left. Northing would give me greater pleasure than to be able to tell you he was rolling, and indiscreet.

Alas, the only discernable effect was that his cheeks turned a fetching shade of pink (which exactly matched his shirt) and he swore more, but no great surprise there, now, is there?

Duncan can hold his piss.

He’d sent an email suggesting we book the table under Mark Sainsbury’s name, so as to get star treatment.

Now that is a good idea.

He is relentlessly competitive. He talks about going head-to-head with his great mate and competitor, Guyon Espiner, at TVNZ, like the sports journo he used to be: “We’re here to knock each other out.” I asked about a rumour that he and Espiner collude on story angles which earned me one of his eruptions: “Complete crap. It’s bullshit. I’ve heard this rumour. It comes from print hacks.”

Both TV and print bosses hate it when one of their competitors runs an exclusive, which they didn’t have.

ECan vs its own Commissioners

I blogged two days ago on how ECan management were even interfering with their own independent Hearing Commissioners. A 2007 final judgement makes these points:

Wayne Russell is a hydrogeologist from Auckland, Dr Greg Ryder is an aquatic ecologist from Dunedin. Philip Milne who chaired the hearing is a environmental law partner with Simpson Grierson in Wellington. We were appointed by Canterbury Regional Council (“the Council”) to hear and decide 69 applications by 59 applicants.

These were the three independent Commissioners. It is fair to say they are experts – which is why they were appointed. Their job is to decide on applications according to the law, and best science. The Greens claim to be pro-science, but are very selective in their use of it I note.

They note:

The hearing was somewhat unusual. In essence it largely became a two way debate between the Council officers and the applicants’ experts and counsel. Notwithstanding that there were no submissions in opposition to many of the applications and little evidence from submitters, the officers remained adamant, that with some very minor exceptions we should not grant any of the applications.

This says a lot. Often hearings are between applicants and objectors. Here, the Council management argued against, despite there being no objections from any person or group.

Some of the officers have at times adopted more of an advocacy role than a neutral advisory role. …

We appreciate that there is a need for precaution in relation to this resource, however we were left with the impression at times, that the case presented by officers was overly focussed on persuading us to decline consent. This was reflected in the officers’ strong opposition to us granting any but a few exceptional applications. There was also considerable resistance to the proposed adaptive management approach. We felt that the officers had rather more confidence in their view of how the resource operates that the science warrants.

That last sentence I suspects says a lot about why there were so many problems, and why they were seen as dysfunctional by all the territorial local authorities.