The Road Safety Trust

Rural Women New Zealand have alerted me to the strange cast of the Road Safety Trust – an organisation funded by a crown monopoly that declined every grant application it received this year.

This quango is funded out of the sale of personalised plates. According to the 2007/08 annual report it made a $2.2 million  surplus that year. They budgeted $2.33 million of grants and paid out just $150,000. And this year they have approved none it seems.

Radio NZ reports:

The independent trust is funded by a portion of profits from the sale of personalised plates and one of its aims is to hand out money for community safety initiatives.

The trust has been spending money on its own national campaign to reduce driver distraction and has rejected 14 applications from community groups for the year to June because they did not meet its criteria.

Among those rejected were the organisations Rural Women and Safekids.

Rural Women asked for money to create signs to remind drivers of the speed limit when passing school buses.

So we have this quango deciding to fund its own campaigns (which seem to mirror existing NZTA campaigns) and declining every community group’s application as not being innovative enough.

The campaign to remind drivers to slow down passing school buses seems very laudable. According to Rural Women NZ a pilot on SH58 has seen an average speed drop from 90 – 100 km/hr to 20 – 40 km/hr.

The Minister has said he will look into the trust. I think that would be an excellent idea. They are privileged to receive money from a state monopoly – personalised plates. And the purpose of the funding is not to empire build with massive reserves, or running solely their own advertising campaigns. If your criteria are so restrictive that not a single group can manage to qualify, that suggests there is a problem.

UPDATE: A reader has located where some of the money goes. The Road Safety Trust is an “Official Partner of both the Air New Zealand Cup Referees and Heartland Championship Referees for the 2009 season”.

That’s much better than getting cars to slow down for school buses!

UPDATE2:

Vinnie-Munro-with-a-card_2380490

Now I understand what they mean by restricting funding to innovative campaigns. Because no one has ever thought that you can reduce the road toll by sticking a meaningless slogan on a rugby referee’s shirt, they decided to innovate and try that to see what happens.

While billboards telling people to slow down for school buses doesn’t meet that all important innovation criteria.

AP on Climategate e-mails

The Associated Press has had five staff go through all 1,073 stolen e-mails. Their conclusion is:

Emails stolen from climate scientists show they stonewalled sceptics and discussed hiding data – but the messages don’t support claims that the science of global warming was faked, according to an exhaustive review by Associated Press.

I don’t think there was a global conspiracy on climate change, any more than I think there was a conspiracy around the 9/11 attacks.

However enough was revealed in the e-mails, to ring some warning bells that some leading scientists have acted improperly. Some extracts from the lengthy article:

The scientists were so convinced by their own science and so driven by a cause “that unless you’re with them, you’re against them”, said Mark Frankel, director of scientific freedom, responsibility and law at the American Association for the Advancement of Science. He also reviewed the communications.

Frankel saw “no evidence of falsification or fabrication of data, although concerns could be raised about some instances of very ‘generous interpretations’.”

My worry is that there is now a mindset where only data that fits the thesis is considered.

One of the most disturbing elements suggests an effort to avoid sharing scientific data with critics sceptical of global warming. It is not clear if any data were destroyed; two United States researchers denied it. The emails show that several mainstream scientists repeatedly suggested keeping their research materials away from opponents who sought it under American and British public records law. It raises a science ethics question because free access to data is important so others can repeat experiments as part of the scientific method. The University of East Anglia is investigating the blocking of information requests.

The issue is not just whether data was destroyed, but also whether one can have any confidence in those scientists who proposed it.

When Climate Research published a sceptical study, Mann discussed retribution this way: “Perhaps we should encourage our colleagues in the climate research community to no longer submit to, or cite papers in, this journal.”

That brings in a new meaning of peer-reviewed.

This would give the PSA nightmares

Guido Fawkes blogs on the Irish budget:

  • Welfare benefits reduced to 2006 levels, social welfare bill cut by equivalent to 1.5% of public expenditure
  • Dole allowance to be reduced to €150 a week
  • Social welfare to be cut 4.1%
  • Politicians’ pay will be reduced in line with public sector grades
  • Public sector pay cut of 5% on first €30,000 salary, 7.5% on the folllowing €40,000 of salary and 10% on next €55,000
  • Taoiseach (PM) to have pay cut by further 20% on top of previous 10%
  • Permanent pay reduction of 12% for those on over €200,000 in the public sector
  • Savings of over €1bn on public sector pay bill

SST on Lockie

The SST has done an extensive profile of Speaker Lockwood Smith. The beginning:

TWENTY-FIVE YEARS in the snake pit, and somehow Locky remains an innocent. The MP kept smiling his spooky smile through decades of derision and scorn. He began his public life as a fuddy-duddy – should school kids be reading the nasty sex scene on page 96 of The Color Purple? – and threatened to end it as a dork. Smith was appalled at the uproar which greeted his remarks during the election campaign about the small hands of Asian vine-pruners. Gosh, he didn’t mean to upset anyone.

National leader John Key made him say sorry, pencilled him out of cabinet, and in due course sent him to the Speaker’s chair. This is a place where parties put senior MPs they don’t know what to do with. The politician, says a parliamentary insider, was “dead and buried”. But Alexander Lockwood Smith, PhD, 61-year-old owner of a fine baritone voice and the best set of abs in parliament, refused to lie quiet in his grave.

Instead he launched a couple of revolutions and turned himself from laughing stock into an odd sort of political leader. He put an end to aeons of skullduggery and secrecy by publishing MPs’ expenses. He turned Question Time in parliament from a tableau of official evasion into a real test of the government’s mettle. He became that rarest of political animals, the celebrity Speaker. The pundits praised the new hero of accountability and openness.

The whole article is a good read.

Bring Back Bush

Public Policy Polling blogs:

Perhaps the greatest measure of Obama’s declining support is that just 50% of voters now say they prefer having him as President to George W. Bush, with 44% saying they’d rather have his predecessor.

That is a startling figure, considering how unpopular Bush was on both the left and the right.

No Wellington casino

The Dom Post reports:

A developer’s plan to build a casino in Wellington appears doomed after Internal Affairs Minister Nathan Guy ruled out a law change required for it to proceed.

Backers of the proposed billion-dollar project in Shelly Bay – which also includes a luxury apartment block and a gondola at the prime harbourside site – need the previous government’s moratorium on new casinos lifted if the centrepiece of the development is to go ahead.

But Mr Guy, who has responsibility for gambling, said changing the law was not in the pipeline and, even if it was, doing so would be a lengthy process.

“Any change to the law would be a decision for the Cabinet and caucus and would require extensive discussion with the wider community,” he said.

“At this stage, the Government has no plans to change the law.”

That’s a real shame. It is bizarre that the Government thinks Wellingtonians can not be trusted to have a casino.

I don’t think there should be any limit on the number of casinos. There should be rules around how they operate, but I don’t see it as the role of the state to determine which cities or towns are allowed one, and which are not.

A fun night

The end of last week turned out to be one that, as someone on my Facebook page commented, Sir Geoffrey Palmer would disapprove of.

Wednesday night started at 9 pm and ended at 3 am. The Nat’s caucus party on Thursday started at 5 pm and again the night ended around 3 am and on Friday a boozy lunch started at 1 pm and I finished drinking around 9 pm.

I guess this makes me an official heavy drinker – like Karl du Fresne. And soon we will hear what proposals are going to Government to try and “fix” us.

Anyway back to the Caucus Party – it was a very fun night. The location of Premier House made it a very well behaved night also, so not a lot of extra pages for the book. It was my first time inside Premier House in literally a decade. I did enjoy asking a staffer if they had a tapu lifting ceremony performed there earlier in the year 🙂

Everyone was in a pretty good mood, and the election seemed a long time ago. The food was superb, but there was a slight under-estimation of the number of people who would still be there at 11 pm, when the food stopped. So someone did a whip around for pizzas, and I got to make the call to Dominos to deliver a dozen pizzas to Premier House.

What I found disturbing was when I went down to the front gate to tell the Police about the order, and the officer there greets me with “Oh you’re the guy who ordered the pizzas”. As I had ordered them just a few minutes ago from my cellphone, this reinforced my paranoia that I am being monitored 🙂

At some stage after midnight, a few of us went down to Courtney Place. By coincidence ran into several Labour MPs at Hummingbird, and enjoyed some drinks and conversation with them. I tried hassling one progressive Labour MP about the Easter trading vote, asking him if he didn’t feel dirty that they only won, because God squaders voted with them. The response was when you win, you only feel bloody glad that you have won. Damn it- he is right.

Eventually the Nats threatened violence against me if I remained with the Labour MPs, instead of the National ones so drifted across, and finished up around 3 am. It goes without saying I am firmly against the proposal to have bars close at 1 am!

Friday lunch was at the new Cafe Ortega on Majoribanks Street. The food was simply superb. Oysters as a starter, followed by a superb squid and chorizo sausage mixture. And my boneless chicken breast on pappardelle pasta was the envy of many. Highly recommended.

Busted Blonde blogs the lunch in more detail.

The battle for standards

The Herald reports:

Education Minister Anne Tolley says she will sack the boards of primary schools which allow teachers to boycott national standards, saying they would be refusing to obey the law.

Tensions over the new standards in literacy and numeracy are increasing.

Teachers’ and principals’ unions are lobbying school boards to support them in their call for a trial period before the standards are introduced nationwide.

The unions have also threatened boycotts and industrial action, and last week wrote to principals urging them to ask school boards to voice the same concerns.

Mrs Tolley has ruled out a trial, and said that in “extreme” cases of a boycott she would dissolve the board involved – because the trustees would be refusing to obey the law – and replace it with a commissioner.

“If despite having that pointed out to them, they absolutely refused, I do have the power to dissolve the board and put in a commissioner,” she said.

“In the end, I would have to do that. I don’t think it would come to that, but if it went to the nth degree I would do it.

You just cannot have schools disobeying the law.”

Absolutely. If people do not like the national standards, they should vote for a Labour Government that will scrap them. But National won the 2008 election with a explicit commitment to introduce the standards, and voters not unions should get to decide the law.

Mrs Tolley said the Ministry of Education would give as much support as possible to boards stuck in a standoff with teachers.

But she would not be backing down on her decision to introduce standards nationwide from next year.

The minister said she had already made many changes in response to concerns from the unions but each time, they had returned with more and she believed their arguments were now purely philosophical.

“That’s why I’m putting my foot down … If there are changes needed, we will make them.

“I’m not saying this is it from day one. But we have to get started because this is about kids failing in the system. I’ll do whatever it takes to make this work.”

As Anne has said, there has been masses of consultation and even compromise. But some no doubt seek delay just for the sake of delay.

The 3am mayor

Jonathan Marshall in the SST reports:

Revelations of after-dark communications with Key come as Wood releases on the internet the abusive rants Williams left on his answer phone in October.

Blogger Cameron Slater – who has feuded with Williams in the past – is from today hosting the recordings on behalf of Wood on his website whaleoil.co.nz.

Cameron has made a nice video including the phone recordings. They reveal a highly insecure Mayor who feels the need to leave abusive and threatening messages on the answerphone of his predecessor.

In investigating the messages to George Wood, the SST found even John Key receives the late night missives:


An exasperated John Key has confirmed that Williams, mayor of Auckland’s North Shore City, has on several occasions sent “aggressive” and “obnoxious” texts as late as 3.30am.

Williams has gained a reputation for firing off intemperate emails, text messages and voicemail to adversaries and colleagues until late into the evening.

In October, Williams emailed his mayoral predecessor George Wood at 11.34pm on a Saturday, describing Wood as a “buffoon” and a “disgruntled, failed has-been”. He also left abusive messages on Wood’s voicemail.

Key told the Sunday Star-Times that he had not replied to any of Williams’ messages. He said they had arrived at “anything up to half past three in the morning. It’s certainly nocturnal.

“I never reply to them , they’re never worthy of a reply. The messages were in an aggressive tone… I’m not going to respond to obnoxious messages at this time of the morning.”

Cameron has done well with this front page scoop for the Star-Times, with the recipients of the calls knowing where best to go to get them publicised. I expect he will end up becoming the most visited blog at some stage – even if he does it from D Block 🙂

Education unions criticised by parents and principals

The Dom Post reports:

The School Trustees Association, which supports the standards, is upset about a letter from NZEI and the Principals Federation trying to influence boards.

President Lorraine Kerr has written to the groups, branding the action as irresponsible and unprofessional.

“It is hard to escape the conclusion that the motives behind your letter are in the main political,” she wrote.

“We believe your letter is irresponsible and unprofessional in inciting boards to place themselves at risk by acting simply as the principal’s mouthpiece.

“We have made every attempt to respond to the matters regarding national standards in a thoughtful and pragmatic way. However, by taking the action you have in your letter, you have made it abundantly clear that you have no genuine interest in pursuing an informed and professional discussion of the issues.”

That is a damning letter for one professional group to write about another. Totally deserved though.

Stephen Blair, principal of Tokoroa North School, accuses the Principals Federation of turning the issue into an ideological debate.

“They have accused the Government of basing policy on ideology yet their opposition is based on ill-informed scaremongering,” he said.

And the national standards policy is so mild. It is not about one big standard test. It is just about minimum consistent standards and reporting.

I say bring in bulk funding, performance pay for teachers and vouchers and give the unions something to really complain about!

Herald on Sunday wins

NZPA report:

The Herald on Sunday (HOS) newspaper was justified in sacking assistant editor Stephen Cook, who was being investigated as part of a police inquiry into drug dealing, the Employment Relations Authority has ruled.

The HOS will be pleased to have won what was a messy battle with one of their former senior staff.

Armstrong on Labour

John Armstrong writes:

What is really going on inside the Labour Party caucus? The show of unity following Tuesday’s discussion on the negative fall-out from Phil Goff’s “nationhood” speech did not quite square with some rather odd happenings the next day.

For starters, there was Goff’s opting out of Wednesday’s question time in Parliament. The Labour leader delegated his usual role of questioning the Prime Minister to his deputy, Annette King. That may not seem a big deal. But the ritual nature of parliamentary warfare dictates that party leader take on party leader.

I presume it was because they knew Goff would get so many hassles about delivering a speech neither he nor his Caucus believes in.

Amid all this, Parliament’s finance and expenditure select committee was treated to some extraordinary theatrics from Labour finance spokesman David Cunliffe at its meeting on Wednesday. Cunliffe’s attempted interrogation of Finance Minister Bill English was Perry Mason mixed with Basil Fawlty – cringe-making and hugely embarrassing.

Hmmn had not heard about this. Will be great if the Office of the Clerk can arrange for Parliament TV to also cover select committees.

Trevor Mallard, Labour’s education spokesman, may find Education Minister Anne Tolley easy meat. But the end-game here should be the huge segment of middle-of-the-road voters worried about what kind of education their children are getting – not the teacher unions whose opposition to national testing is driven by self-interest.

The unions’ supposed concern that schools in poor areas will be stigmatised by failing to meet standards is a cynical cover for their real worry – that teachers’ inadequacies will be exposed by league tables which will show exactly which schools in richer areas are failing to deliver for their pupils.

The smart, though admittedly brave, move for Goff would have been to endorse national standards and even raise the benchmarks for satisfactory performance. In one swoop, that would have outflanked National and nullified Labour’s image of political correctness.

Mallard’s onslaught on Tolley means that opportunity has passed.

I think education could be a real battleground issues next election, and that parents will overwhelmingly be on the side of the party wanting them to know how their kids are doing.

Labour this year has only caused National any grief on three issues – emissions trading, ACC and cutbacks to night-class education.

I don’t quite agree here.

National has taken some hits on emissions trading I believe – but from its own supporters for doing anything at all, rather than from the left for not doing more.

There has been some grief around ACC relating to specific stuff like motorcyclists, but Labour has totally lost the argument over the unsustainable nature of the status quo. In 2011 I think ACC will be a negative for Labour as people will be reminded of the mess they left.

And on night-class education, those protesting have been the providers and a few others. I think the vast majority of NZers have been appalled to find out that they had been paying taxes to subsidise silk scarf painting courses and the like.

National’s Tony Ryall summed it up on Wednesday when he said Labour was suffering from RDS – “relevance deprivation syndrome”.

The term may have been coined by Australia’s former Foreign Minister Gareth Evans, but the Health Minister’s diagnosis was spot-on.

In short, Labour is desperately hunting for relevance and hurting badly in not finding it.

To be fair to Labour, most parties in opposition can struggle with that for some time.

Who dun it?

All the talk around the city is speculation on who is the real author of the Sean Plunket blog. After much detective work Kiwiblog can reveal the shortlist of suspects.

Noelle McCarthy
Peter Cavangh, Radio NZ CEO
The new Mrs Plunket
Matthew Hooton
Mark Unsworth
Peter Cavangh’s lawyer
Geoff Robinson
Lynne Snowden
Beven Rapson, Metro Editor

UPDATE; We now have a prime suspect and unlike the others this one has strong circumstantial evidence pointing to Mikey Havoc.

Rating the Emissions Targets

Most readers will know that NZ’s emissions target for 2020 is between 10% and 20% below 1990 levels. Greenpeace and others have run a campaign demanding it be at least 40%, despite the fact it would mean shooting (or killing off by some means) at least 20% of our dairy herd.

Most analysis of targets for a country are facile, and do not take account of the conditions in each country such as the profile of the emissions, how possible is it to reduce them, what has happened since 1990, population growth etc etc.

A great example of the superficial approach is the Climate Action Network zealots who have today declared that NZ given NZ a third place for “fossil of the day” because the Government refuses to unilaterally agree to a higher reduction target. The media will report this was huge column cms and broadcast time.

What they will not report to the same degree is the work of the Climate Action Tracker that has done detailed assessments of each developed country, based on multiple factors. The Greenhouse Policy Coalition drew attention to their work earlier this week.

They rate 49 countries (27 EU countries are rated as a group), and NZ is actually rated 10th highest in terms of the commitment made. I’ve put in brackets what their share of global CO2 emissions is. The top ten are

  1. Costa Rica (0.3%)
  2. Maldives (<0.1%)
  3. Brazil (1.2%)
  4. Japan (4.6%)
  5. Norway (0.2%)
  6. Iceland (<0.1%)
  7. India (5.3%)
  8. Indonesia (1.2%)
  9. Mexico (1.6%)
  10. New Zealand (0.1%)

The bottom ten are:

  1. United States (20.2%)
  2. Ukraine (1.1%)
  3. South Africa (1.5%)
  4. Russia (5.5%)
  5. EU27 (13.8%)
  6. Croatia (0.1%)
  7. China (21.5%)
  8. Canada (1.9%)
  9. Belarus (0.2%)
  10. Australia (1.3%)

Now I believe New Zealand (being one of the smallest countries) does have to make a reasonable commitment. It would be economic suicide to tell the rest of the world to fuck off, and declare we will do nothing.

But the current target of 10% to 20% is at the upper limit of what is achievable by 2020, and those calling for it to be higher are ignoring the evidence that it compares pretty favourably to most of the rest of the world.

Super City Wards

Alex Swney and Greg McKeown write in the Herald:

The commissioners have suggested that communities are better represented by two councillors rather than one, so they have gone for huge wards, more than twice the size of general electorates, with two councillors each.

If that is such a good idea, why don’t we double the size of general electorates and have two MPs per electorate? At the centre of this is a debate about parochialism – somehow two councillors will be less parochial than one. Strong local representation at all levels of local government, including the new Auckland Council, is healthy and required.

I tend to favour smaller wards with just one Councillor each. I think you get better informed decision making when voters have to select just one representative than multiple.

There’s a lot of talk about representation for communities of interest. But under the commissioners’ draft plan, the people of Paritai Drive, Orakei, and Princes St, Otahuhu, have been lumped together in a ward with 161,400 voters and two councillors.

How awful for the good people of Otahuhu.

Blog Bits

  1. Enjoy the Sean Plunket blog. Sadly it is not actually Sean’s blog, but a parody. Still it should be enjoyable.
  2. Jeanette Fitzsimons blogs “The Government’s moves to make the power retail market more competitive are good” which makes me start to doubt them!SHe goes on to say that energy conservation is more important. I do not regard them as being mutually exclusive.
  3. Judy Callingham blogs that the TVNZ charter was a toothless tiger and is best put out of its misery.
  4. Chris Keall solves the mystery of Air NZ cracker-gate, as raised by Roar Prawn.
  5. 12,230 people have joined the Facebook group “I’ve slept with Tiger Woods”
  6. Roar Prawn wonders why Trevor Mallard has taken to yelling out Cactus Kate’s name in Parliament, leading Cactus to declare “I have not had sexual relations with Trevor Mallard“. My view is that is only because Trevor is not married 🙂
  7. Whale Oil blogs on the sad case of Labour’s leper.

ACC $1,300 to $2,000 a year

As expected, the increase in ACC levies is less than proposed, but are enough to stop the unfunded liabilities increasing.

What I find interesting is that the average worker now pays $1,300 a year in ACC levies. That is a huge amount of money. If workers paid it directly, I suspect there would be far far more support for reducing the costs of ACC. But workers pay it in three ways – through the employee PAYE levy, petrol tax and vehicle registration levels.

On top of that is the employer levy. Ultimately workers pay for this also, through lower wage levels. Employers factor the total cost of employment into decisions on staffing and wage levels. This is another $700 a year

So the average worker has $2,000 paid to ACC. The average after tax income is around $40,000 so ACC consumes around 5% of take home pay.

Over a worker’s life, they pay a huge amount of money into ACC. Are they getting value for money? I have my doubts. Of course it is the nature of accidents that some will be injured more than others, and need more support. But I suspect for 95% of levy payers, the benefits they get from ACC are miniscule compared to their lifetime contributions.

The Government has started off in the right direction by trimming some of Labour’s expansions to the scheme. I hope they continue to trim.I’m all in favour of families not being left starving when an income earner is unable to work due to an accident. I am more sceptical about ACC funding the myriad of providers of different medical services from counselling to physio. I’d rather we fund them through Vote Health for low income families rather than have someone on $100,000 get free phsyiotherapy for their skiing injury.

The rise and rise of Andrew Little

My Dispatch from St Johnnysburg is titled The rise and rise of Andrew Little. An extract:

Now under the leadership of Helen Clark, the parliamentary leader was the supreme leader. There was no question of the party president questioning her in public, or some decision being made she did not agree with. Clark’s great legacy to Labour was the unity it had under her rule.

But Phil Goff is no Helen Clark, and the power of Andrew Little is on the rise.

Comments and feedback can be made at NBR.

Parliament TV blog

This is a great move. The Clerk of the House has commissioned a website where Parliament TV segments are viewable. So rather than have to watch entire debates, you can see individual speeches and questions.

The site in In the House. It uses blog technology such as tags, so rather than have to do keyword searches, you can just click on tags etc.

The creators think this is a world first, and it could well be. I’m very impressed.

One request I would have is that they consider adding on the ability to embed videos. They will be far more successful in having people view segments if blogs can embed the videos.

Climate Change blamed for cannibal polar bears

cannibal-polar-bear

Marty G at The Standard shows off his expert knowledge of Arctic polar bears, and declares this photo shows how climate change has turned polar bears into cannibals. He says:

This is climate change. This is just the beginning.

I have a terrible feeling that this picture is an omen of things to come.

Oh yes, next there will be cannibal geckos, cannibal crabs and worse.

Or one could talk to someone who actually lives in the area, as the Daily Mail did:

But this theory is disputed by Inuit leaders in Rankin Inlet, Nunavut, who claim it is wrong to connect the bears’ behaviour with starvation.

Kivalliqu Inuit Association president Jose Kusugak said: ‘It makes the south – southern people – look so ignorant.

Ignorant indeed. Unless you prefer Marty’s knowledge of polar bears to the local Unuit leader.

‘A male polar bear eating a cub becomes a big story and they try to marry it with climate change and so on, it becomes absurd when it’s a normal, normal occurrence.’

What a shame – it could have made a great film – revenage of the cannibal polar bears.

Some humour for the next wee while

The Nats Caucus Party is tonight. It would be optimistic to expect any blogging from me until Friday afternoon!

The parties used to be every six months, but this is the first one since June 2008. They didn’t even have a post-election bash last year because of the recession. So this is well overdue.

As with all social functions, what happens on tour stays on tour. So don’t expect any good stories tomorrow – I save all those for my book 🙂

Anyway in the meantime, read this e-mail conversation, and you will not be able to stop smiling. It involves the author of the spider drawing e-mails. Check his whole site out if you have the time.