How they voted

Grant Robertson blogs those who voted for letting communities decide, and those who voted against.

The breakdown by party was:

  • National 49-9
  • Labour 1-43 (incl Anderton)
  • Green 0-9
  • Maori 3-1 (1 not vote)
  • ACT 5-0
  • United Future 1-0
  • Total 59-62

The only good thing about the bill being defeated is it means the issue won’t go away.  If it has passed, allowing each community to decide their own policy for Easter Sunday (a day not even a public holiday), then the law would not be so broken, and people would stop agitating for change.

There is a reason there have been 11 bills seeking to change the law, and there will be more attempts. The religious conservatives and big unions were against late night shopping, Saturday shopping and Sunday shopping. They lost all those battles and will eventually lose this one. And it isn’t about the right to shop. I never shop on Sundays anyway – that is a day for drinking and the bars are all open. It is about who should decide what days and hours shops should open and close.

Transtasman Predictions

Transtasman puts its tongue in its cheek for its 2010 projections. Extracts:

Despite the recession, Phil Goff ’s poll ratings decline further. He has a long lunch with Ian Wishart and criticises the dominance of scheming, childless “front bums” in the Labour Party.

After two weeks of internal muttering Labour MPs say they are right behind Goff and anyone interpreting his criticisms of “front bums” as anti-women don’t know what they are talking about.

Ouch – so cutting.

Jim Anderton retires. It is nearly a month before anyone notices.

He’s a party leader you know.

Blog Bits

  1. Andrew Campbell (unionist who gives left viewpoint on Nine to Noon Politics) has done a guest post n The Standard decrying Labour for backing Goff’s speech.
  2. Whale Oil is not happy with the Dr of Laws degree from Otago University to Michael Cullen. I just hope this doesn’t mean Chris Finlayson will now make Cullen a QC!
  3. Eddie at The Standard joins the criticism of the Family Commission Chair for saying she can’t give a definition of Whanau Ora as she is a middle class white woman. He correctly labels this utter crap. Really isn’t it just time we get rid of the Families Commission as a nice idea but one that doesn’t deliver enough for the amount it costs.
  4. Chris Keall gives a good round-up of what is happening on copyright issues.
  5. Amy Adams is pleased with the unanimous vote to send to select committee her  Fair Trading (Soliciting on behalf of Charities) Amendment Bill which requires those soliciting on behalf of charities to be transparent about where the money goes.
  6. Stephen Franks is happy that the Wanganui District Council (Port and Harbour) Bill doesn’t appear to have the numbers and has been deferred. The bill, promoted by Wanganui District Council, basically confiscates the local port from the company that has a perpetually renewable lease for it.

Dim-Post MP Rankings

Danyl at Dim-Post does his own rankings. Superb. Extracts:

Nick Smith: 8/10. Environment Minister has done excellent work crafting an Emissions Trading Scheme that doesn’t handicap decent, struggling Kiwi businesses like The DimPost’s parent company Lanthanide, Nitrogen Tetrafloride & Heavy Metals Disposal.com (Inc  Chongjin, North Korea).

Paula Bennett: 8/10. Feisty westie MP has attracted controversy but is a vital weapon in National’s battle against Labour for the hearts of the strategic white trash demographic. …

Murray McCully: Shook my hand at a public meeting a few weeks ago and now it burns when I pee. 3.5/10.

The McCully one especially just cracks me up everytime I read it.

David Garret: Not his fault supermarkets are allowed to bulk sell discounted alcohol at 8 AM. 5/10.

Harsh but bloody funny.

I like the sound of the new US Ambassador

Colin Espiner reports on the new US Ambassador. I like what I hear:

America’s new ambassador loves New Zealand already because it has most of his favourite vices.

David Huebner held a press conference at his new home in Lower Hutt shortly after his arrival in Wellington yesterday, and immediately established his credentials as a Kiwiphile.

The Flight of the Conchords, wine, cheese, beer and rugby are just a few of his favourite things.

Previously a Shanghai-based lawyer, Mr Huebner followed the rugby sevens in Hong Kong, eschewing American football as too effete.

“I respect the fact that even at the highest levels you don’t wear all that armour plating.”

Superb. He basically says the Super Bowl is for wimps. And he is possibly being mischievous being a gay lawyer labeling American Football as “too effete”.  That’s just superb.

But his anecdotes and one-liners may give his staff the odd grey hair.

Mr Huebner, “just the right side of 50” (he’s 49), said he had used up his State Department shipping allowance freighting his wine collection but had since discovered the quality of New Zealand viticulture.

“I’m looking forward to drinking from the top of the North Island to the bottom of the Mainland.”

Now that sounds my sort of Ambassador. His Excellency will be an early invite to The American Politics Appreciation Society in 2010, especially as we meet in a bar.

The first openly gay envoy appointed by President Barack Obama, he joked with one reporter who asked if he would dress up for the Wellington Sevens. “Would you ask a straight ambassador that question?“

And even better he has a sense of humour about himself.

A battle too important to concede

Stuff reports:

The Government has intensified a developing standoff with teacher unions.

After The Dominion Post revealed yesterday early plans by the primary teachers union to strike over the national standards policy, Education Minister Anne Tolley hit back, telling Parliament she was “disappointed” by the unions.

“I find it really disappointing that the unions want to stop parents getting information about how their kids are doing,” Mrs Tolley said.

“This Government is on the side of parents and we’re on the side of kids.”

Now that is not a typo. The unions are not going to strike over more pay, or smaller class sizes. They are going to strike to refuse to implement the policy of the Government, despite an explicit election mandate for it.

As far as I can tell, Anne has bent over backwards to work with the unions. She even said she’d work with them to try and stop the media publishing league tables. But they seem implacably opposed to giving parents nationally consistent and relevant information.

I say bring it on. Let this be Mrs Thatcher’s miners. The unions plans to pressure school boards to refuse to implement the standards. My response would be no standards, no funding.

All power to the union when they are trying to get payrises for their members. That is their legitimate role. But the unions seek to determine the education policy of New Zealand. They think the voters and the parents are unqualified. This is a battle over who is in charge of the education system and who does it exist for – is it the unions – or is it pupils and parents.

If you think the national standards is crap policy, then you’ll get a chance at the next election to get them thrown out. Elections should determine policy, not unions.

iPredict Column

BUY OF THE WEEK

OBAMA.DISAP.1MAR pays out $1 if at 1 March 2010, President Obama has a net negative approval rating, according to Real Clear Politics. His rating has fallen from +12% in September to +5% in November and now sits at just +4%. The price has gone up from 22c in early November to 34c over the weekend.

I was short on this stock, but have just purchased stock to cover myself, as I think this stock will increase in value.

SELL OF THE WEEK

UK2010.CON.ABS pays out $1 if the Conservatives win an absolute majority of seats in the 2010 general election. The stock is trading at 67c but pundits may not know that the Conservatives probably have to beat Labour by at least 10% to win an absolute majority and several polls in November had them dip under a 10% lead.

For now this stick is over-priced.

MMP

MMP.RETAIN is at 57c. Every poll out in the last month has shown retaining MMP to have a significant lead, and it is hard to see this changing greatly before the election – at least while we have a relatively stable MMP Government. So I think this stock is a but under priced.

AN EASY RETURN

SNAP.ELECTION.10 pays out $1 if there is a snap election next year. I think there is no realistic chance of this happening and the current price of 11c means a 12% return over a year.

NO WAY BACK

MP.TIZARD has fallen to 17c, presumably on the back of Lynne Pillay announcing she will retire but not until 2011. MP.POWELL remains high at 57c.

IS GOFF A GONER?

DEP.GOFF.2010 pays out $1 if Goff loses the Labour Party leadership in 2010. The price was 19c on 28 November and has risen to 32c on Monday.

MOST TRADED STOCK

AUS.TURNBULL topped the trades at $7,500. Next was the Reserve Bank of Australia stocks on $3,500.

Cheers,

David

Disclosure

David’s current iPredict positions are:

BROWN.RESIGN Short, DEP.GOFF.2010 Short, DEP.KING.2010 Short, DL.KING.09 Short, FASA04.REPEAL Short, GST.UP.JULY10 Short, LEAD.GOFF.09 Short, MAYOR.BROWN Long, MIN.DEPART2.09 Short, MP.ANDERTON Short, MP.PETERS.2011 Short, NAT.JAN10.VLOW Short, NAT.MAORI.09 Short, OCR.INCR.APR10 Short, OCR.INCR.JAN10 Short, OCR.INCR.JUL10 Short, PETERS.LEADER Long, PM.2011.NATIONAL Long, UK2010.CON.ABS Long, UK2010.CON.MAJ Short, ZIM.MUGABE Short

Links to stocks in this commentary: OBAMA.DISAP.1MAR, UK2010.CON.ABS, MMP.RETAIN, SNAP.ELECTION.10, MP.TIZARD, MP.POWELL, DEP.GOFF.2010 , AUS.TURNBULL

Wellington refuses to let communities decide

Todd McClay’s private members bill was as unthreatening as you can get. It didn’t repeal all those nonsense shop trading hour laws, as I would advocate.

It didn’t affect a single public holiday. It did not affect Good Friday. It only affected Easter Sunday (not a public holiday) and merely said that rather than accept the bizarre status quo of some “tourist” regions able to open and some can not, it would be a decision for each local authority – ie let the local community decide.

Todd, as MP for Rotorua, had huge local support for the bill as the bizarre status quo means Taupo shops can open, but Rotorua shops can not.

So this bill was as mild as you can get. It did not mean the whole country would change – it was about allowing local communities to decide – instead of Wellington.

You would have thought it deserved to at least get to select committee, so local communities could have their say on the bill.

An Easter bill last Parliament by Jacqui Dean passed the first reading 73-41. 15 Labour MPs voted for it – including Clark, Cullen and Goff.

And another previous Easter Bill by Labour MP Steve Chadwick had 27 Labour MPs vote for it at first reading and 14 Labour MPs vote for it at second reading. It was a true conscience vote.

This time Labour block voted against it, with the sole exception of Steve Chadwick. Why would Labour MPs who previously allowed more far reaching bills go to select committee, block vote against such a mild bill?

The answer is simple. Two major groups are against any change to the status quo. The first is the churches and religious right. Hence nine National MPs (almost all of religious conviction) voted not to allow NZers a chance to have their say on the law. Shame.

But the other major group that opposes any change, are the unions.

So why did this mean Labour MPs block voted? Simple. The national secretary of NZ’s largest union is the chair of Labour’s list ranking committee.

Again this was not a bill to change all of NZ. It was about allowing a process of letting local communities decide whether or not they should be an exempted area due to tourism etc. The status quo has Queenstown open and Wanaka shut. Taupo open and Rotorua shut etc etc.

Bad Taste Quote

The SMH reports:

“God bless Tiger,” Yahoo chief executive Carol Bartz told a conference this week, adding that all of the main Yahoo news sections got a “huge uplift” from the story.

“It is better than Michael Jackson dying; it is kind of hard to put an ad next to a funeral.”

Now that is an unfortunate quote.

Bye bye charter

The Herald reports:

Broadcasting Minister Jonathan Coleman introduced a bill yesterday to repeal the charter, which was created by Labour in 2002 to require TVNZ to broadcast a wide range of programmes for all groups in New Zealand.

Under the charter TVNZ was required to have a “significant Maori voice” and broadcast programmes for people and groups not generally catered for by other broadcasters.

Under Mr Coleman’s bill, it will be told simply to screen programmes relevant to and enjoyed by New Zealanders, include some local content and “reflect Maori perspectives”.

And the charter funding has gone to NZ on Air to be contestable.

This is a huge improvement, and was election policy. One of the things you learn about Government is agencies and institutions work well with a clear focus.

The Reserve Bank works well with one task – keep inflation down. TVNZ works better with one task – be a financially successful broadcaster. We had five years of TVNZ trying to be both commercial and public service and it was a failure. And that is not my opinion but that of a passionate advocate of public broadcasting – former CEO Ian Fraser.

The charter was criticised by some for giving TVNZ an impossible task in meeting dual obligations of a strong commercial performance as well as public broadcasting requirements. The broadcaster has previously been criticised for its use of charter money when it revealed it had used some of it for Dancing with the Stars – a high-rating programme.

Exactly.

Getting rid of the charter is a good thing. There is still the same amount of money for “public good” broadcasting” but it rests with NZ on Air, rather than TVNZ.

Personally I would go radical and sell off TV2, and merge TV One, TVNZ6, TVNZ7, Radio NZ, NZ on Air and maybe Maori TV into one BBC style public service broadcaster. Their combined budgets would get you pretty close to what you need.

Police and Traffic and Guns

The Herald reports:

New specialist traffic officers will be used to issue speeding tickets, freeing police to concentrate on fighting crime. …

he new-look “transport enforcement officers” proposal will effectively be a return to the separate traffic control force that patrolled the country’s roads in black-and-white cars until the early 1990s.

Those officers were part of the Ministry of Transport; the new traffic officers will remain under the control of the police force.

On the face of it, the proposal by Commissioner Broad seems sensible. I don’t think the proposal is a reversal of the 1992 merger, as control remains with the Police. Before the merger the Police were having to assist the MOT more and more with stuff like drink driving blitzes, and the level of training for MOT officers was seen as inadequate for the powers they were gaining.

Police Commissioner Howard Broad yesterday said he was “quite uncomfortable” with fully sworn police being used for road policing, as they were often just “sitting there with their radar gun”.

He told Parliament’s law and order select committee he wanted to use laws that allowed him to designate traffic enforcement officers, and also make greater use of technology such as speed cameras for road policing.

The move would free police officers for other duties, such as neighbourhood policing, he said.

Again, this seems a good move.

Civilians are now used to operate speed camera vans, but using a radar gun requires a police officer with power to stop a vehicle.

Mr Broad said he could give these limited powers under the Policing Act’s “authorised officers” section, and some motorway support officers in Auckland were already operating under this designation.

I say go for it.

Mr Broad also revealed a proposal to end firearms training for officers unlikely to require it, but increase it for those most likely to find themselves in dangerous situations.

Under the proposal, 40 per cent of Auckland police would not be able to use firearms. They would be trained only in use of the baton and pepper spray.

A critical response unit would be established to deal with call-outs.

Labour MP Clayton Cosgrove said the proposal could create problems, such as a community constable not being able to respond to an armed robbery because he could not use firearms.

Mr Broad said officers with low-level firearms training were often more likely to be killed, and he asked if Mr Cosgrove wanted officers trained in “gunfight protocol”.

“The idea you send a community constable into these situations as if they are Wyatt Earp is complete nonsense.”

Mr Broad became heated when the Napier siege – in which Jan Molenaar shot one officer dead and seriously wounded two others – was raised.

“Those police officers who did go in there [to rescue the wounded] without firearms, went in on humanitarian grounds, and they recovered people,” he said.

“They did an extremely good job in an extremely courageous way. They did not need to have firearms to do that.”

Mr O’Connor said the firearms policy was “a recipe for disaster” that would leave the police “out-gunned”.

I’d be interested in the views of the Police Assn on the firearms proposal, but on the surface it also seems reasonable, considering long standing police (despite Clayton’s grand standing) is that the Police are not routinely armed.

Groan

I was planning to get home around 8.30 pm last night, after a talk to a group of small business owners. I made the mistake of popping into Backbenches on the way home, which then led to Hummingbird in town.

End result is got to sleep around 3 am. I blame the MAF staff. Feeling decidedly slow today.

Dog Lovers

Stuff has a story:

Dogs have long been labelled man’s best friend, but it appears that pet pooches are also helping us hook up with other humans.

Romantic or otherwise, relationships are being fused between those who frequent dog parks for more than just the fresh air and exercise.

Melbourne-based town planner Virginia Jackson says dog parks have become social networking hotbeds, bringing together people from all walks of life in a kind of informal social club.

She spent more than two months interviewing 150 Melbourne dog owners, quizzing them on the social dynamics of their local dog park.

Almost 95 per cent of respondents said their dogs were a conversation starter, while 38 per cent said they had developed friendships that were stronger than an acquaintance.

Having gone out with friends who have dogs, I absolutely agree it canbe a great way to meet people – you end up conversing with all the other owners as your respective dogs lick each other all over.

However what amused me was the photo with this story:

3140633

The caption is “BEST FRIENDS: Take your pooch out to improve your social life.”

In her case, I don’t think it is the fact she has a dog with her that improves her social life!

White Middle-class Women can’t say? – Jadis

OK, so I’m not really meant to be posting.  I am meant to be a guest poster when David is on a holiday or some other excursion however we all know that he posts even more on holiday so what is the point in obeying his rules.

First of all, I had better declare that I am a white middle class woman.  Apparently Jan Pryor, as Head of the Families Commission, thinks being a middle class white woman is some impediment to answering a question with a straight answer at select committee.

Through questions from Labour and National MPs the Head of the Families Commission refused to define what she believed Whanau Ora to be because:

“…the simple fact that I am a middle class white woman. And so I don’t feel that I should be giving definitive answers.”

I’m sorry but “What the F***?”

How hard is  it to say “Wraparound” or ask Minister Turia during the meetings that Pryor has with her?  I’ve done my fair share of Women’s studies, sociology, etc papers (yes, I used them as filler subjects) but Pryor takes the cake.  The point is the Commission has done a paper on Whanau Ora so it is within the work of the Commission.  I suppose this is a new way of avoiding a question at select committee.

So here it is, from a middle-class white woman (who even lives in the suburbs)…. *Whanau Ora is a wraparound approach to helping families especially Maori.  Whanau Ora is a combo of using what is available within families, the state and community organisations so that there is a multi-faceted approach.

* Please note I have intentionally worded it so there is a bit of policy-speak so that the Head of the Commission might learn that she can still answer a question like a head of a wannabe policy (or is it lobbying) tax-payer funded entity, without using a cop-out, post-modernist, feminist line like she couldn’t possibly comment because she is middle class, white  and female.

Voting now open in Kiwiblog Awards

Voting is now open in the 2009 Kiwiblog Awards in the following categories:

  1. MP of the Year
  2. Labour MP of the Year
  3. National MP of the Year
  4. Minor Party MP of the Year
  5. Press Gallery Journalist of the Year
  6. Public Servant of the Year

You can vote in all six polls in the left sidebar. Multiple voting will be deleted and exposed.

ACTA

I’m getting nervous on the copyright front.

I was pleased the Government suspended the introduction of the “guilt upon accusation” S92A.

I was also pleased with their proposed policy replacement, that came out on 7 August. Didn’t agree with everything in it, but it was a lot better than the law passed by Judith Tizard. So far so good.

Submissions closed on that document on 7 August – that is four months ago. Most of the submissions were supportive.

So why I wonder has the Government not released its final proposed policy?

One reason I can think of is that they are getting furiously lobbied by United States lobby groups demanding changes to the proposed policy. We know the US MPAA had a Vice-President out here. I was pleased he only got to meet with officials, and not the Minister, but it would be naive to think such lobbying has no impact.

I hope I am wrong, and what emerges is at least as satisfactory as what was in the proposed policy. But why has it been four months with no news?

And then we have the ACTA (Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement) which could remove our ability to determine our own laws in this area. Let me quote Peter Dunne and Clare Curran on this:

Peter Dunne said:

UnitedFuture leader Peter Dunne has called on the Government to release details of the recent international negotiations on the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement.

“There is a lot of conjecture about the contents of ACTA and what it will mean for the protection and enforcement of intellectual property and copyright law here in New Zealand,” said Mr Dunne.

“The veil of secrecy surrounding the contents of the ACTA agreement is causing a lot of concern not only here but also among the other nations involved.”

Indeed. And there are conflicting reports on what ACTA covers. Some say it is large scale commercial piracy. Other say it seeks to mandate S92A type laws for everyone.

“It is in the public interest for the Government here to be as transparent as possible over ACTA.”

“While we have been told by Mr Power that the negotiations bear no relevance to the issues around the review of S.92A of the Copyright Act, many people are nervous that this is what has held the current review up.”

“A simple disclosure of the terms and text of ACTA negotiations would allay any misplaced anxiety while also giving New Zealanders the opportunity to voice concerns they may have.”

“Mr Power was quick to listen to New Zealanders over S.92A and scrap Labour’s unjust law; I encourage him to do the same over ACTA,” said Mr Dunne.

It would be great to both have the ACTA text made public, and also to be told what is causing the delay in the review of S92A?

Clare Curran has also said:

In the interests of transparency and public interest, the New Zealand Government should reveal the text of recent secret discussions in South Korea on the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement (ACTA).

Clare has also blogged a transcript of questions about ACTA at a select committee.

The official says:

On the section 92A question that you ask, the answer is difficult to give. I just do not know how the United States is going to approach this issue, either in TPP or in ACTA as yet, in that they have not come to a definitive negotiating position even in ACTA. It is also very early days, as you know, internationally in terms of putting place these kinds of provisions, and a lot of people are looking at New Zealand in terms of how we do it and whether we can provide something of a model for others to follow. The strong hope that we would have is that the kinds of provisions that we are going to recommend shortly—and that, hopefully, the Minister will propose shortly to Parliament—will be enough in terms of any further concessions sought from us from the United States, etc. I think that in terms of the kinds of bases that the US wants hit, we will hit them but we will still have enough safeguards to protect the interests of users as well as owners.

That to me suggests that what is acceptable to the US, is a factor in the review of 92A.

Now I am a fan of an FTA with the USA. But I’d rather not give them everything they want before we even negotiate an FTA. Hell, we might be able to get rid of some lamb tariffs if we don’t bend over prematurely.

The official also said they hope for an update on S92A before Xmas. Not many days to go.

Also people interested in this issue might be interested in Kiwiright – a 12 minute documentary about the fight against S92A. It is embedded below.

© kiwiright from nu4mz on Vimeo.

Blog Bits

  1. Blaise Drinkwater looks at the battles on the left between those who see class warfare and identity politics as most important.
  2. As examples of what Blaise is looking at, read Chris Trotter on “The Kommissariat” and No Right Turn in response with “Dolchstossegende”.
  3. Bryce Edwards reviews a decade in Parliament for the Greens. They will be glad in hindsight they bailed out of the Alliance before Jim Anderton destroyed it.
  4. Colin Espiner critiques the Trans-Tasman ratings. I tend to agree with most of his comments and his conclusion “Overall Trans-Tasman has it about right, as usual, although I think it slightly favours the Government, particularly the ministers.”
  5. A Fiji blog has an interesting summary of what Phil Goff said on Fiji.
  6. Chris Keall blogs that NBR now has 7,500 paid subscribers to their online content. That is pretty impressive numbers. My view has always been that people will not pay for generic news, but will pay for excellent analysis or specialist content.

Bullshit Names

The Southland Times reports:

Staff at Remarkables Primary School are set to adopt some remarkable job titles when it opens next year.

Teachers will be known as “expedition leaders”, while the school receptionist will become the “director of first impressions”.

Oh God.

Best and Worst of Travel

NZPA report:

New Zealanders love to travel, but they don’t want to tip when they get there, according to a new top 10 travel “loves and loathes” list.

The list, released today by House of Travel, is the “best and worst of travel”, retail director Brent Thomas said.

So what are they:

Top 10 things New Zealanders love about travel:

* Your own entertainment system – and starting movies as soon as you board.

Yes this is superb. Makes a big difference. Also the fact the most airlines now have personal entertainment systems in economy class also now.

* Counting down the number of sleeps until you leave.

Not so much for me. It means I am frantic finishing work stuff.

* Standing in front of Big Ben, the Pyramids or Taj Mahal and realising that you’ve made it.

Yeah.

* Getting entrenched in the local customs and culture.

Not sure I get entrenched but I do like experiencing them.

* The blast of heat you feel on arrival for a tropical break.

Yep, so long as not too humid. Hawaii was perfect.

* Copenhagen Airport.

Never been there.

* The super cheap Thai foot massages at Bangkok Airport.

Hell at Akl International they were giving free back massages for a while.

* Not having to make your bed every morning.

Oh yeah.

* Curries, “real pizza”, pastries, ceviche – authentic fresh local cuisine.

After I visited Rome,  couldn’t eat pasta in NZ for some months.

* Getting home and planning your next trip.

Yep, always have one in the works I say.

Top 10 things New Zealanders loathe about travel:

* Passport photos.

Almost as bad as parliamentary ID photos

* Virtually every airport in the country “making some changes”.

I remember the days when it wasn’t a half marathon to go through Auckland International Airport.

* Early morning international flights.

Oh God I had so many on my last trip. Left Dubai at 2 am. Left Iran at 4 am and left Israel at 6 am.

* Having to take your laptop out going through security.

That and most things about the security checks.

* Having to “fight” for the arm rest.

If you have a window seat this is not so bad as you can lean on the window and rest there. But I prefer aisle seats as I like to be able to get in and out without disturbing others. It is a blessing when the centre seat is empty.

* The realisation that you only have one more sleep before you go home.

Nah by the end of a good trip, you are ready for home.

* Hotels and beaches that are nothing like their website pictures.

Beaches normally live up to billing, but some hotels are misleading. But this is why I look at user ratings – rarely wrong.

* The “bad hair days” caused by humid holiday spots.

Ha – not an issue shall we say.

* Unpacking and finding that your toothpaste, moisturiser or shampoo has leaked.

Or shaving cream!

* Tipping – why is that porter just hanging around?

I detest compulsory tipping. I love to tip for good service, but hate being forced to tip.

Herald on anti-smacking law

The NZ Herald editorial:

The Prime Minister’s appointment of child psychologist Nigel Latta to lead a review of the smacking law was an inspired one. Dr Latta, a noted defender of smacking, has undertaken the work with an open mind and has come to conclusions that should answer the concerns of 87 per cent of those who voted in the recent referendum.

Dr Latta, assisted by Police Commissioner Howard Broad and the head of the Ministry of Social Development, Peter Hughes, has found that smacking as most people know it – light, admonitory, open-handed and instantaneous – remains permissible. Social workers are not alarmed by it and police are not prosecuting it, despite all the claims to the contrary of initiators of the referendum.

The review has found none of their cited cases stood up to closer scrutiny. Police investigations that seemed trivial or frivolous at first glance all turned out to contain more serious elements than the parents had admitted to campaigners such as Family First. Dr Latta said: “In all cases there wasn’t one where I thought the only reason [the police] investigated was because of the law change. In every case, when I looked at the police file, it was blindingly obvious why they had.”

I still think the law is a bad law, and that the Borrows/Boscawen amendment would be a far better law. I even think the original Bradford bill (merely to delete S59) would be a better law than the current one which is says it is fine to smack for some reasons, but not for others – and doesn’t define what level of force is reasonable.

So I would still like a law change. However Latta’s review of the disputed cases is reassuring that the Police and CYFS are not pursuing parents just for a light correctional smack. I was already pretty confident the Police were not over-reaching, but was worried about some of the zealousness you can get with CYFS.

Dr Latta’s findings ought to put to rest the fears of many parents who have been under the misapprehension that the Bradford bill outlawed smacking entirely. It never did, though it often seemed Sue Bradford was content to leave that impression. A complete ban would have been fine with her.

Well it does outlaw correctional smacking entirely. But it is unlikely you will be sanctioned for breaking it. John Key once compared it to speeding – if you do 51 km/hr in a 50 km/hr zone that is breaking the law, but you won’t get pinged.

Bradford did indeed want to ban smacking entirely. Even worse she lied about her intentions and said it was not about banning smacking. If she had been honest from the beginning, the law may not have met such anger.

The law expressly allows parents to use reasonable force to stop or prevent a child doing something dangerous, disruptive, offensive or persisting in such behaviour. Confusion was created because the law also says smacking is not permitted as a means of “correction” alone.

And that is why I think the Borrows law is superior. It defines reasonable force (and sets it at a very low level) but doesn’t leave you trying to work out if a smack is for preventing disruption (ok), good parenting (ok) or correction (not ok).

Comment Ratings

Have installed (thanks to Inspire) a new plugin. You can vote a rating up or down, as before. But there are now some consequences to it.

Comments with lots of positive ratings get highlighted. I have set the threshold for now to 5. I may need to raise it. I don’t want too many highlighted – just those which get lots of people saying this is great.

Comments with lots of negative ratings gets hidden – you can still read them if you want by clicking on them, but it allows you to skip over them. Now I have set the threshold at 10 negative comments, as I don’t want lots of comments hidden. I will increase this if people are voting comments down just because they may not agree with a comment, as opposed to it being a comment of poor quality. There is a huge difference.

Ideally I want a plugin where each reader could choose their own thresholds, but the one time I tried that it crashed the system as 500,000 comments and 5,000 users is too much for it. We’ll see how this goes. Remember nothing is blocked – it is just requires a click to view.

Also comments with lost of both positive and negative ratings also get highlighted as a hot debate comment. The threshold is a total of 12 votes (both positive and negative). Again I’ll revise this an necessary.

Also the sidebar now displays not just the most recent comments, but the more highly ranked ones.

Feedback, as always, welcome.

Powershop

I’ve blogged several times how much I enjoy having Powershop as my electricity supplier. Not just because they don’t turn the lights off if I accidentally pay late, but the fact my usage and costs have become so transparent to me.

The Herald reports:

Disgruntled consumers are increasingly likely to dump their power company.

A Consumer survey of 13,000 members in September showed they were less tolerant of poor service, with 14.3 per cent stating they had switched suppliers during the past 12 months, compared to 6.8 per cent in 2005.

Two small companies, Powershop and Energy Direct NZ, were most popular.

Powershop, which allows consumers to buy blocks of electricity from different suppliers online, was rated good or very good by 92 per cent of customers.

Energy Direct NZ was second with an 82 per cent rating.

Good to see it is not just me who is a fan.

My average bill for the year has just dipped below $50 a month. I used to pay almost that much in fixed charges I reckon.

Pundits on Goff

John Armstrong writes:

Phil Goff emerged from Labour’s caucus meeting yesterday claiming his MPs were unanimous in their backing of both the tone and content of his now-infamous “nationhood” speech. There is no reason to doubt him. Short of doing what is currently the unthinkable – toppling him – the caucus had little option but to weigh in behind their leader – in public at least.

I’m reminded of the old adage that anytime a Caucus feels the need to pledge unanimous support for a leader, the coup is not far off. Not as Armstrong says, this is not the case at the moment – but unanimous pledges of support are things best avoided.

There could be no halfway house. The priority was to present a united front to the world outside. That was evident in Goff and party president Andrew Little, who has acknowledged party members’ worries with aspects of the speech, entering the meeting shoulder-to-shoulder.

Given Labour is rating around 30 per cent support in the polls – 20 percentage points behind National – the party could not afford go into the summer recess amidst internal dissent and with questions over the leader’s actions unresolved.

Goff insists he was not playing the race card when he gave the speech. If he was not overtly playing the race card, however, he knew perfectly well that he was producing enough evidence – be it the use of loaded language like “porkbone politics” or the choice of a provincial city audience for the speech – to lay himself open to that charge.

Yeah I’d love him to make that speech at Ratana, on even in Wellington Central, rather than Palmerston North Greypower. Instead Goff says he is not going to talk about the topic again. Dr Brash had the sincerity of his convictions and was happy to defend his views from one end of the country to another.

The PM put it this way yesterday: the tragedy of Phil Goff was that he had made a speech he did not believe in and as a result the Labour Party no longer believed in him. Not quite. The party has to believe in Goff because for the time being it has no one else it can believe in.

What Goff’s advisors do not realise is that the speech did not have credibility coming from someone who has been an MP for around 30 years and a Cabinet Minister in the last Government.

Colin Espiner blogs:

What I found interesting was that neither Goff nor Little tried to deny that there had been discontent within the party over the speech – they simply used the usual political euphemisms such as “robust debate” and the intriguing comment that “the Labour Party is not a Stalinist organisation”.

Heh the missing words are “no longer” 🙂

Ironically while Goff claims Labour is not “Stalinist” and has always vigorously debated issues, that actually isn’t true. It didn’t debate very much at all when Helen Clark was in charge, and that’s why Labour was so successful.

I’ve no doubt the party is probably a more relaxed and even pleasant place to be now that Clark and her iron-fisted rule have gone, but the free flow of debate and opinion can always be interpreted the wrong way if one isn’t careful.

That’s all I think has happened with Goff’s speech – at least, so far. No one is going to use this to challenge the leader, partly because no one else wants the job right now and partly because there are so many people in that caucus who think they are next in line that they’d never get any agreement on a candidate to replace him.

I’ve always said it is likely Goff will survive until the election, but it will be fascinating to see who stands after the election. At a minimum you could expect Jones, Cunliffe and Little.

Cubicle Dairy Farming

The Herald has details of what is actually proposed:

However, a director of one of the companies behind the proposals says critics who call it “factory farming” have got it all wrong.

Richard Peacocke was reluctant to be interviewed while involved in environmental hearings related to the applications. However in statements, he said: “Factory farming implies that stock are unduly restricted.

“Each cow will have its own cubicle to stand, sit and sleep. The floor of the cubicle is a thick rubber pad and the cows are free to enter and leave the cubicles at will and wander around the balance of the shed and feed as they require.

“There will be clear roof panels to allow sun and light to enter. Additionally the cows will be free to wander out onto a large open air holding yard during fine weather and stand or sit in the sun.”

Mr Peacocke said the effluent would be collected and stored, with liquid waste watered down and spread on pasture at “very low rates”.

The proposal is for 18,000 cows that will live within the stables (including yard) for eight months a year.

I suspect this is an issue similar to battery hen farming. Around 80% of people will say they don’t like it and would be happy to pay more for free-range egss. But in reality free-range only has 10% of the market.

The bigger concern is if it could undermine the overall NZ dairy brand. This is why Fonterra is against.

Federated Farmers are supportive though, and say this model of farming s more environmentally friendly. I’d be interested in the details of that claim.

UPDATE: Press editorial has some details:

From an environmental point of view, the proposal has a lot to recommend it. Rather than having herds roaming free and leaving effluent to flow where it will, with the risk of pollution to waterways and aquifers, it would, while the cows were under cover at least, be collected for more orderly disposal. While the details of that disposal would have to be scrutinised closely, that is almost certain to be less damaging to the environment.