2009 Temperature

The Herald reports:

This year is likely to be among the 10 hottest years on record, early figures from the World Meteorological Organisation indicate.

As delegates gathered in Copenhagen for the second day of world climate negotiations, the WMO said average global temperatures from January to October placed 2009 about 0.44C above the long-term average – making it the fifth warmest year since instrumental climate records began in 1850.

The 10 warmest years on record have occurred since 1997, the WMO said.

The decade of the 2000s (2000-2009) was warmer than the 1990s, which were warmer than the 1980s.

I’ve been studying a fair bit of the raw data around average temperatures, and it is far more complex than one might assume, mainly because there is no actual way to calculate it, as the temperature varies every few kms. The spread of temperature stations is not even. In an ideal world you might have a measuring point every 100 square kms, but that is impossible.

That is why most of the data we read talks about the deviation from a long-term average. Because that doesn’t have to be spread evenly. If you use the same measuring place, you can accurately say the temperature at this point was higher in year x than the average of these years. And if you choose lots and lots of locations, and they are not hand picked to give you selected data, then it is fairly safe to say average temperatures are rising.

And that is fairly uncontroversial. Even amongst “skeptics” few people are saying the average temperature is not warmer. There is some talk of whether it has warmed since 1998, but that is useful to view in context.

temps

The above graph I have created myself using the raw data on the web from three sources – the US National Climatic Data Centre (holds the world’s largest collection of climate data – they have 1.2 PB of digital data), NASA and the UK Met Office (the infamous Hadley).

Each centre compares to a different “average” period. The US NCDC compares to the century 1901 – 2000. NASA compares to the period 1951 – 1980 and the UK Met Office to 1961 to 1990.

They all show much the same direction, but not to the same magnitude. This is what one would expect. The graph does put post 1998 in context somewhat. 1998 was a very high year, and there is still an upwards trend – even if it has not yet exceeded 1998. The 2009 data is based on te monthly data for the first ten months of the year.

In yesterday’s thread there was a very good comment by Ben:

Global warming from GG emissions is the sum of two parts. First, a direct warming effect: a doubling of CO2 adds 1 to 1.5C to temperatures. No controversy there. But to get warming beyond that requires a second effect, positive net climate feedbacks, and the science on both the sign and magnitude of feedbacks is completely up in the air. About 80% of the IPCC’s 6.4C maximum warming depends on large positive feedbacks, which are completely unknown. It is not yet clear whether clouds and water vapor damp or add to underlying variation.

So there is consensus on direct effects, but on feedbacks, none at all.

I am not a scientist. But it is basic science that more greenhouse gases will increase temperature, if everything else remains constant. Ben says (I have not checked) that a doubling adds 1.5C. This is (as I understand it) uncontroversial and not disputed. This means that an option of do nothing is not particularly wise.

There is debate over whether there is “positive feedback” or not, and to what extent. Most scientists say there is, but this is not a case of something proven beyond dispute – it is based on models.

I have tended to take the formal IPCC reports as the most likely scenario. The stolen e-mails have damaged some of the credibility of IPCC processes – especially the boasting about making sure certain dissenting opinions are kept out. That really has rung some warning bells.

However even if one doubts this projections in terms of positive feedback, it is worth remembering there is really no doubt over the direct effects.

Where I think the debate should really be, is how much one spends on mitigation instead of adaptation. I do have real doubts that spending a trillion dollars or so globally on mitigation is sensible. Spending on adaptation may well be a better spend. However it is not quite a case of either/or but a mixture of both. Spending nothing at all on mitigation (ie never decreasing emissions) will result in inevitable temperature increases that will make life difficult in the future. Now this may not be in the next 100 years, but in the next thousand.

climchange

I have little time for those who claim that the world is doomed if by Xmas Eve there is not a decision to reduce emissions to a certain level by 2020.

But likewise I have little time for those who say it is all a giant conspiracy, and there is no need to do anything at all. I hasten to say that even prominent sceptics such as Ian Wishart do not hold that view. Almost every sceptic I know, says they are sceptical about how fast the planet is warming, and how much of it is due to mankind. Very few say that there is no warming at all, and that greenhouse gases are not contributing to that.

No great surprise

The Herald reports:

Auckland Museum director Vanda Vitali, and the museum trust board are embroiled in a performance dispute, and both sides have hired top lawyers.

Auckland mayors have also become involved to “save” the director from the board, although Auckland City Mayor John Banks said the dispute appeared to be the “beginning of the end for Vanda Vitali at the Auckland War Memorial Museum”.

Dr Vitali, who has been at the centre of several controversies since being appointed museum director in September 2007, refused to discuss the dispute. She has hired John Haigh, QC.

Board chairman Dr William Randall said the board was conducting a performance review with Dr Vitali that involved a fair amount of rigorous debate over matters of concern to the board.

“It’s the frequency of them that gets to us,” he said.

“We started with the restructure – that got a lot of negative publicity – we then went on to the Bomber Command issue, then there was Passchendaele, then we had the Hillary issue and subsequent to that was the PSA issue on unions.”

There have been so many issues, I am not surprised there is a dispute and potential loss of confidence. However hard to judge from the outside if this is mainly just resistance to a tough management style, or if Vitali is making errors of judgement.

Dom Post on Climate Change

The Dom Post editorial:

Last night, NZ time, representatives of 192 countries gathered in the Danish capital of Copenhagen for the start of a two-week conference devoted to global warming.

Depending on your point of view, the conference represents either a last chance for humanity to save the planet from a man-made apocalypse, or the culmination of a giant fraud.

If the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change is to be believed, the planet is warming, sea levels are rising and humans are to blame. The panel, a United Nations body, is forecasting temperature rises of between 1.1 degrees celsius and 6.4C this century and sea-level rises of between 18 centimetres and 59cm – sufficient to cause drought and coastal flooding and render some island countries uninhabitable.

If the sceptics are to be believed, fluctuations in the planet’s temperature are normal and there is no conclusive proof that human activity is to blame for the changes in the past 50 years.

What I find interesting is that the editorial even mentions the views of sceptics. A few months ago, and I suspect it may not have.

Notwithstanding the recent publication of emails suggesting that some climate-change scientists have sought to suppress data that does not conform to their theories, the weight of scientific evidence is on the side of the climate-change believers.

However, even if the sceptics are eventually proved correct, it makes sense to take a precautionary approach. If the sceptics are right, the cost of reducing carbon emissions will be measured in lower standards of living. Consumers will have to pay more for electricity and fuel, goods will be more expensive and inhabitants of developed countries such as New Zealand will have to compensate inhabitants of poorer countries for reducing their use of the polluting technologies with which developed countries built their wealth. If the sceptics are wrong, the cost will be drought, famine, the destruction of productive land and, as an editorial published by 56 newspapers today says, the drowning of whole countries.

A fair point. However the projected increase in sea levels by 2100 is from 19 cm to 69 cm – not metres and metres.

The challenge facing negotiators is to find a formula that rich and poor countries can agree to. An agreement to which the world’s biggest emitters, China and the United States, are not party to is an agreement not worth the paper it is written on. So too is an agreement from which other developing countries exclude themselves.

Absolutely. At present NZ has a more ambitious target than both China and the US. No way should NZ agree to a higher target unless the big emitters do.

Back on top

The Tiger List

The Herald reports:

News reports now push the total to 10 women linking themselves to Woods in the wake of his one-car crash, more details of which emerged today with an unidentified witness saying that Woods had been drinking alcohol earlier in the day.

And who are the ten:

  1. New York club hostess Rachel Uchitel
  2. Cori Rist, a 31-year-old divorced mother
  3. former porn star, Holly Sampson
  4. Cocktail waitress Jamiee Grubbs, 24
  5. Kalika Moquin, 27, a Las Vegas club manager
  6. model Jamie Jungers, 26
  7. Mindy Lawton, a 33-year-old waitress from Orlando
  8. three unidentified women, two from British reports and another waitress from Orlando

What is it with all that waitresses?

a041b6232c532ead8d0361661414a52f

This is Holly Sampson. Her latest flick is Descent into Bondage (2008).

If they do a film about Tiger Woods, I wonder if they’ll get Charlie Sheen to be the lead actor!

Thank God

The Herald reports:

The International Rugby Board (IRB) has agreed to a joint bid by New Zealand broadcasters to screen 2011 Rugby World Cup games.

Would have been a nightmare if they had not. I suspect there was some high level diplomacy. We’ve probably agreed to give the IRB Directors rights of first refusal on mining national parks 🙂

S59 Review

The Nigel Latta et al review of how Police and CYFS are implementing the new Section 59 has been reported back to the Government. It is online here. Some extracts:

It makes 13 recommendations to improve information to parents etc.

What is very interesting is the detailed responses to some of the cases that have been in the media.

The 2009 Transtasman Ratings

Transtasman has published its annual ratings for our 122 MPs. As usual, I do some analysis. The overall average rating is 4.5

Average Ratings per Party

  1. Maori 5.2
  2. National 5.1
  3. ACT 4.5
  4. United Future 4.0
  5. Labour 3.9
  6. Green 3.7
  7. Progressive 3.0

The influx of new MPs saw the overall average rating drop from 4.8 to 4.5. All parties except National had their average drop. National went up 0.3.

Top MPs

  1. Lockwood Smith 9.25
  2. John Key 9.0
  3. Simon Power 8.5

Bottom MPs

  1. Hone Harawira 0.0
  2. Ashrad Choudary 1.0

Top Labour MPs

  1. Annette King 6.5
  2. David Parker 6.0
  3. Darren Hughes 6.0

Top Third Party MPs

  1. Pita Sharples & Tariana Turia – 7.0
  2. Jeanette Fitzsimons – 6.0
  3. Roger Douglas & Heather Roy – 5.0
  4. Peter Dunne – 4.0
  5. Jim Anderton – 3.0

Top New MPs

  1. Steven Joyce 7.5
  2. Rahui Katene 6.0
  3. Amy Adams 5.0

Group Ratings

  1. Ministers 6.2
  2. Cabinet 6.7
  3. National frontbench 7.7
  4. Labour frontbench 4.5
  5. National 2008 intake 4.2
  6. Labour 2008 intake 3.7

It will be interesting to see in a year how the ratings have changed. Hopefully by then the Labour frontbench has had a reshuffle. That is a huge disparity between the frontbenches.

More on pillow attack case

I blogged Friday on the pillow attack case and quoted the Herald story which said:

The judge also blasted the police as “ridiculous” and “petty” for bringing action against Mr Taylor.

And I commented:

This is the aspect that will cause more legitimate concern amongst opponents of the anti-smacking law. The Government and PM puts great stock in the discretion available to Police. When you see the Police applying such discretion badly, it makes you nervous.

Now Police HQ have sent me a response to the Herald story, that is worth quoting:

A media report last night stated Police were petty and ridiculous in charging a man with throwing a cushion at a child.

Police were called to a family violence incident involving Mr Taylor on New Years Eve last year. Police were told Mr Taylor had assaulted a seven year old child, was intoxicated and refusing to leave the address. Occupants of the house were frightened of him and were found outside by Police on arrival.

Mr Taylor has a long history of alcohol, drug abuse and family violence which was a factor in laying the charge.

An assault had taken place on a child who was not involved in the original dispute which was between the Mother and Mr Taylor. Taylor refused to leave the address and left Police with no option but resolve the matter by arresting him.

An arrest does indeed seem justified in that case.

The charges initially laid by police were legally correct. An alleged assault had been committed on a child. On the information provided by the complainant and witnesses present, the assault was neither trifling nor trivial. The child had made a complaint that the assault had caused him pain, and redness to his forehead, that he has been whacked.

The defence counsel elected trial by jury and made no attempt to negotiate a lesser charge as indicated by the Judge.

The charge was later independently reviewed by the Crown Solicitor after Mr Taylor was committed for trial. The Crown laid an indictment for the same charge.

The Judges decision to discharge the matter under Crimes Act 1961 s.347(2) was available in the circumstances. However, Police would point out it was the defence tactic to take a relatively minor case to trial where it could have been concluded in the summary jurisdiction. The case was laid in the summary jurisdiction and would have been disposed of as the Judge had suggested should have happened, had there not been an election of trial by the defence. In addition, the application under s347 could have been made by the defence at any point prior to the hearing. The application was brought by the Judge on the day of trial.

Also useful context to the story.

The TVNZ report stated police were petty and ridiculous. This comment was not made by the presiding Judge who did not criticise the police laying a charge in respect of this case. Rather, the Judge formed the view that the case could have been resolved with a lesser, included charge, which was unavailable to the Crown due to the election of the defence of a trial by jury.

This is quite a different impression to that of the original stories. Good to see the Police being proactive with their version of events.

I wonder if any of the media that ran the original story, have run the Police response? As far as I can tell, they have not.

Blunt on Obama and Afghanistan

November Public Polls

nov09polls

The November 2009 public polls newsletter from Curia went out this morning. You can subscribe to get it by e-mail here.

The most interesting results this month are from overseas. Obama continues to decline, the Conservatives lead in the UK has shrunk, and Abbott has dented Rudd’s lead in Australia.

Blog Bits from the right

  1. Alf Grumble MP wonders why the Greens are attacking John Carter for doing his job
  2. Whale Oil looks at the Christchurch Mayoralty
  3. Jenna Raeburn blogs a recent debate on the liquor laws
  4. Ian Wishart blogs a Rasmussen poll that finds only 25% of Americans think the science on global warming is settled and 59% say some scientists have falsified data to support their own theories and beliefs. However 46% still say global warming is a major problem, with only 36% disagreeing
  5. Iain Dale blogs a hilarious future obituary for Peter Mandelson
  6. Tim Blair finds that Google appears to have deliberately deleted Climategate as a suggested search term

Brash responds to George

Garth George’s column in the NZ Herald last Thursday was critical of the 2025 taskforce chaired by Don Brash.

The Herald (as is their right) declined [UPDATE: they now have published] to publish a response from Don, so he has offered it to various bloggers. His response is below and it is a first class fisking:

GARTH GEORGE HAS IT SERIOUSLY WRONG

Garth George was way off beam in his attack on the first report of the 2025 Taskforce.

Leaving aside the personal invective, he claims that the “biggest absurdity” in the report is the proposition that New Zealand can and should catch up with Australia. He says that “there is just no comparison between the two countries”, with Australia having five times our population, 32 times our land area, and huge resources of minerals. Well, those are factual statements about Australia, but they ignore some important facts which he would be aware of had he read the report.

First, there is no correlation between living standards and population – if there were, India would be super-rich and Singapore would be poor.

Second, there is no correlation between living standards and land area – if there were, Russia would be super-rich and Finland would be poor.

Third, there is no correlation between living standards and mineral wealth – if there were, the Congo would be super-rich and Japan would be poor.

In any event, a recent World Bank study showed that, in per capita terms, New Zealand has more natural resources than almost any other country in the world.

For most of New Zealand’s history, our standard of living has been very similar to that in Australia – sometimes a bit ahead, sometimes a bit behind. And the Taskforce didn’t off its own bat decide that catching Australia again by 2025 would be some good idea: the goal was set by the Government itself, and the Taskforce was set up both to advise on how best to achieve the (very challenging) goal and to monitor annually progress towards achieving it.

Too often in the past, governments have announced grandiose commitments to lift living standards – such as the last Government’s commitment to lift us into the top half of developed countries within 10 years – but then totally ignored those commitments, hoping that nobody would notice it. It is to the Government’s credit that they made a commitment and then established a mechanism to hold them to account.

Garth George accuses the Taskforce of recommending a whole range of things which we do not recommend. For example, he accuses us of recommending a flat personal income tax, and notes that if such a tax were established a whole range of low income people would have to pay more tax. But whatever the merits of a flat tax, the Taskforce did not recommend such a tax. What we did say was that, if core government spending were cut to the same fraction of GDP that it was in both 2004 and 2005 (29%), the top personal rate, the company tax rate, and the trust tax rate could comfortably be aligned at 20%. Under such a tax structure, all those earning above $14,000 a year would pay less income tax, while nobody would pay more income tax.

Nobody seriously argues that government was vastly too small in New Zealand in 2004 and 2005 (the end of the Labour Government’s second term in office), so why the ridiculous reaction when the Taskforce suggests reducing government spending to that level?

Mr George also suggests that we recommended abolishing subsidised doctor visits, and implies that we are advocating an American approach to healthcare. This is again utter nonsense. We suggested targeting subsidies for doctor’s visits at those who need them, either because they have low incomes or have chronic health problems.

He suggests that we favoured removing subsidies for early childhood education. Again, not true. What we said was that those subsidies – which have trebled in cost from $400 million a year to $1.2 billion a year over the last five years – should be focused on those who need them.

The recommendations of the 2025 Taskforce are actually totally in line with orthodox thinking in most developed countries, and are almost entirely consistent with the recommendations of the recent OECD report on New Zealand.

Don Brash
Chairman of the 2025 Taskforce

UPDATE: The Herald has also now run the response.

Dom Post on Tax

The Dom Post editorial:

The tax working group established by the Government doesn’t expect to report its findings before Christmas, but it is clear already that ministers will get more than they bargained for.

The group, set up to explore ways of aligning the top personal tax rate with company and trust rates, has carried out a root and branch review of the tax system. Its findings make for sobering reading.

The system is inefficient, counter-productive and unfair. The tax burden is being disproportionately borne by wage and salary earners who cannot restructure their affairs to take advantage of vagaries in the system.

The high proportion of the total tax take gathered from company and income tax increases the incentive for individuals and businesses to shift overseas. And the differing rates at which earnings on different types of investment are taxed is distorting investment decisions.

Yep, the current tax system is sub-optimal at best.

The group’s goal is not just to broaden the tax base but to make the system fairer and more efficient and to reduce the incentives for people and businesses to shift overseas by taxing things that are fixed, such as land and buildings, rather than things that are mobile, such as capital and labour.

This is pretty important. The more you tax capital and labour, the less there is to tax.

A property or land tax would have the added benefit of encouraging investment in productive enterprise by making investment in property less attractive.

Well it is not so much that there will be less investment in property, but a land tax will encourage land owners to get higher economic returns from their land, which is one way to lift economic growth.

The best tax brains in the country have given the Government a chance to make the system fairer and the economy more efficient. Doing so is in the long-term interests of everyone. The Government should grasp the opportunity.

I agree. It would be easier to do, if the crown accounts were in surplus. But even without that luxury, some change must happen.

Idiocy

NZPA report:

ACC’s higher than forcecast investment return has exposed the Government’s “scaremongering” about the corporation’s financial situation, Labour leader Phil Goff says.

Levies are going to be raised and some entitlements cut because the Government says ACC isn’t in a viable state to continue the way it is.

But Mr Goff, citing the latest Treasury figures, said today ACC’s investment funds had returned $500 million in the four months to October 31, which was higher than forecast.

I swear Labour oppose national standards for numeracy and literacy, because their election chances seem to be based on a hope residents can’t do basic maths.

I’m not sure what is scarier – taking (on paper) high returns for four months as some sort of guarantee of high returns over the long-term, or thinking that a $500 million return over four months will cover the $4.8 billion loss in the last year.

This is of course the same Labour that knew ACC lost $2.4 billion in 2007/08 and continued to increase benefits and entitlements. And then the Government broke the Public Finance Act, by not revealing the problem before the election.

Anyway let’s look again at Phil’s mathematics. Now the unfunded liabilities have increased from $9B to $24b in just four years. Part of the reasons is that the ACC Board and Minister assumed investment rates of returns that were grossly unrealistic – and Goff wants to do it all over again, on the basis on one four month period of good results.Does he really think that level of returns will persist for the next decade? If so, then I suggest he set up his own investment company.

2009 Kiwiblog Awards

Yes it is time for the annual Kiwiblog Awards. The categories are:

  1. MP of the Year
  2. Labour MP of the Year
  3. National MP of the Year
  4. Minor Party MP of the Year
  5. Press Gallery Journalist of the Year
  6. Public Servant of the Year

Make your nominations below, and then I’ll announce the finalists and run a poll in each category. These are all positive awards – for the best person in each category.

2008 winners are not eligible to be nominees for 2009. Here are the 2008 and 2007 winners for each category.

  1. MP of the Year – Rodney Hide (2008), John Key (2007)
  2. Labour MP of the Year – Winston Peters, Phil Goff
  3. National MP of the Year – John Key, Bill English
  4. Minor Party MP of the Year – Rodney Hide, Heather Roy
  5. Press Gallery Journalist of the Year – Audrey Young, Fran O’Sullivan
  6. Public Servant of the Year – Owen Glenn, Kevin Brady

Quick Google

Google must have its bots hovering constantly. Last night I blogged something, then thought I’d seek more info on the topic so googled it. My own blog post came up as a hit, less than 60 seconds after I had made it.

Little has personal concerns over Goff speech

Goff”s desperate speech and u-turn may turn out to be a nail in his coffin. The Herald reports:

Labour’s president, Andrew Little, revealed yesterday that he has “personal concerns” about the speech.

It is no small thing for a party president to criticise the leader in public.

Mr Little said the speech had been discussed with Mr Goff at length at Labour’s national council meeting.

The president relayed his concerns, which he said were both his personally and those of people in the party.

“The extent to which I’ve got concerns is an issue for me and Phil, and no doubt the party and Phil and I wouldn’t air those publicly.”

But what is the game plan, that you will publicly air that you have concerns, just not what they are? There is no way this does not weaken Goff’s leadership.

A spokesman for Mr Goff said last night that he “absolutely stands by everything he said in the speech”.

It had raised important issues such as National’s “shabby” deal with the Maori Party to get the Emissions Trading Scheme through. Mr Goff also had grave concerns about National “playing politics” with the foreshore and seabed legislation.

So now the leader responds through the media to his own president.

Mr Little told the party conference in September that Labour had been wrong to deprive Maori of the right to test their claims in court when passing the Foreshore and Seabed Act.

The legislation will now be repealed as part of the governing agreement between National and the Maori Party, and Labour offered earlier in the year to work with National to achieve an “enduring consensus”.

But Mr Goff’s speech effectively changed Labour’s position on the law, saying it was working well the way it was now and repeal would make “wounds fester”.

Yep a u-turn in just two months.

I don’t think anyone thinks there is anything wrong with Labour opposing National’s ETS changes and associated deal with the Maori Party.

Likewise there is nothing wrong with Labour saying it supports the retention of the Foreshore & Seabed legislation. Of course they look a bit mickey mouse when they say they back change, that they are sorry for it, and then do a u-turn.

But where Goff went wrong is bringing together those two separate issues, along with Hone Harawira’s comments, into one overall theme of those Maori are getting away with too much.

Submission on Electoral (Administration) Amendment Bill

Submission on the Electoral (Administration) Amendment Bill close on Thursday 10 December 2009.

My submission is below:

SUBMISSION OF DAVID FARRAR
TO THE JUSTICE AND ELECTORAL SELECT COMMITTEE
ON THE ELECTORAL (ADMINISTRATION) AMENDMENT BILL

About the Submitte

  1. This submission is made by David Farrar in a personal capacity. I would like to appear before the Committee to speak to my submission.
  2. I have over 15 years experience with the Electoral Act.  As a former parliamentary staffer I advised National Prime Ministers and Opposition Leaders on the Act.  I have been an electorate campaign manager and a national campaign staffer, requiring intimate knowledge of the Act. I also have blogged extensively on electoral issues.

Executive Summary

  1. I support the Electoral (Administration) Amendment Bill, congratulate the Government on introducing it, and urge the Select Committee to pass it.
  2. I do propose one small, but significant change, relating to the appointment of the members of the Electoral Commission so that the Minister of Justice must gain the consent of the majority of parliamentary leaders, not just consult with them.

Specific Comments

  1. This bill is long overdue. A combined electoral agency was first recommended by the 1986 Royal Commission into the Electoral System. It was also agreed in principle by the Government in 1994 (in 1997 they changed their mind). In 2000 it was proposed by the Ministry of Justice and again in 2001 by the Election Framework Taskforce
  2. I agree with the decision to only merge the Electoral Commission and Chief Electoral Officer at this stage, and after the 2011 election to also merge the Chief Registrar of Electors.
  3. Of the three models for the (new) Electoral Commission, my preferences in order are 1) Independent Officer of Parliament, 2) Crown entity, 3) Within the Ministry of Justice
  4. I note the Ministry of Justice has advised that establishing the Commission an Independent Officer of Parliament could not be done in time for 2011. If this is the case, I would not advocate that one delay the merger to go with this model, however I would urge the Committee to ascertain exact details of why the Ministry says this model could not be completed in time.
  5. I also note the assertion that the functions of the agency do not match the criteria for an Officer of Parliament as set by the Finance and Expenditure Select Committee. Notwithstanding that, I believe the independence that an Officer of Parliament would give the Commission is highly desirable, and that the criteria should be reviewed.
  6. It may be useful to solicit advice from the current and former Clerks of the House, as to whether or not they believe the Electoral Commission would be a suitable Officer of Parliament.
  7. My main reason for preferring the Commission to be an Officer of Parliament is that it ensures any Commissioners have the support of a majority of Parliament, not just the Minister of Justice.   If this model is not feasible, then I would advocate that the Crown entity model require the Minister of Justice to gain approval, not just consult with, other parliamentary parties.
  8. I note from the departmental papers, that the original recommendation was for the Electoral Commission to have a sole commissioner. I believe it is safer to have a Board and a CEO model (as proposed), and support this remaining.
  9. Clause 4D(2)(b) provides for one of the Commissioners to be appointed as Deputy Chair of the Commission, and that this person can not (obviously) be the Chair. I would propose that the Deputy Chair should not be the Chair or the Chief Electoral Officer. In a Board/CEO model it is undesirable for the CEO to be even the Acting Chair. It would be simpler and cleaner to simply have each of the three Commissioners to have a distinct role – Chair, Deputy Chair, and CEO (Chief Electoral Officer).
  10. 14. Clause 4D(4) states “Before recommending the appointment of an Electoral Commissioner, the Minister must consult with the parliamentary leaders of all political parties represented in Parliament.”
  11. The early papers from the Ministry do not even provide for the Minister to consult parliamentary leaders. This requirement was added on, presumably at the request of the Minister or Cabinet Domestic Policy Committee. It is commendable the need for consultation was accepted by the Government.
  12. However I believe it is desirable for the Minister to not just consult, but to gain approval of a super-majority of parliamentary leaders. While the current Minister has shown considerable integrity in his dealing with electoral issues, this does not mean a future Minister would do the same, and they might appoint a Commissioner over the objections of other parliamentary parties.
  13. The expanded powers of the Electoral Commission make the need for wide parliamentary acceptance of Commissioners even more vital. The current Electoral Commission has little role in the actual running of the elections compared to the Chief Electoral Officer. And the current Chief Electoral Officer is appointed by the Secretary of Justice who is appointed by the State Services Commissioner. This is well removed from political appointment. Under this bill, the Minister of Justice will directly appoint the person who primarily runs the NZ electoral system.
  14. My proposed amendment is for the Minister to gain a double super-majority, so that Clause 4D(4) would state “Before recommending the appointment of an Electoral Commissioner, the Minister must gain the written approval of parliamentary leaders representing at least 75% of all political parties represented in Parliament and at least 75% of all Members of Parliament, and attach such approvals to the recommendation to the Governor-General.”
  15. Electoral Commissioners should be of such unquestionable integrity, independence and competence that even having one parliamentary party oppose their appointment should give pause. However requiring unanimous assent to an appointment is undesirable as it may encourage unreasonable demands in return for support.
  16. Requiring a double super-majority provides safeguards for both large and small parties. The requirement to have agreement from leaders of at least 75% of the parties in Parliament means that the two major parties can not decide on an appointment opposed by more than one small party. As the Commission decides issues such a broadcasting allocations, this is desirable. Likewise though the Government can not “gang up” with several small parties to make a appointment opposed by the major opposition party, as it is likely the major opposition party will always have at least 25% of the MPs. Hence this will encourage the Minister to put forward nominees that are widely supported and uncontroversial. This will protect both the Minister and more importantly the reputation of the Commission.
  17. Some may assert that no Minister would appoint someone, if opposition parties had objected to the appointment when consulted. I have been told by former Opposition Leaders that this has occurred on a number of occasions. Hence this extra safeguard is not theoretical.
  18. A current or former Judge has normally chaired the Electoral Commission. I am not convinced this is absolutely essential, but the Committee may wish to consider whether this is a practice they wish to depart from.
  19. Finally, while outside the ambit of this bill, I would note that once the Electoral Commissioner has been fully integrated with the Chief Registrar of Electors, Parliament may wish to consider if it should play a significant role in local body elections. I think there would be considerable merit in handing it authority for local body elections, in conjunction with local returning officers in each authority.

In summary I urge the Justice and Electoral Committee to recommend the Electoral (Administration) Amendment Bill be passed, with an amendment requiring the Minister of Justice to gain the agreement of a double super-majority of parliamentary leaders for the appointment of Electoral Commissioners.

David Farrar

The Standard on Lee

The Standard has obtained documents under the OIA from NZ on Air, relating to Melissa Lee and NZ on Air. They show that Melissa was aware of the issue back in May 2009.

If the issue was known about that far back, it is bad political management to have it unresolved for so long. If I was an MP, and found out that there may be some money to be repaid to a government agency, I would ensure the matter was dealt with in days or weeks, not months. And then do a media release announcing the repayment, and what caused it. That is far superior to having the information come out through the media.

Despicable scum

The SST reports:

An HIV-positive man injected his wife with his own blood while she slept, infecting her with the virus that causes Aids.

It is believed the man wanted to give her the disease so she would start having sex with him again. She told police he also hoped it would prevent her from finding another man and leaving him.

That is probably the most selfish act I have come across for years. Sickening.

The man has been remanded in prison awaiting sentence for wilfully infecting another with a disease, an offence that carries a maximum 14 years’ imprisonment.

I know one can live for years with HIV, but I still think his actions come close to homicide, and a life sentence should be an available penalty.

In court documents, the woman, 33, described how her husband twice pricked her with a sewing needle laced with his infected blood as she slept and how she once caught him handling a syringe full of his blood.

It is bad enough to have unprotected sex with someone, if you are HIV+. But at least that is a lottery. To actually prick or inject someone with your infected blood, is just unforgivable and incomprehensible.

Tamihere on Goff

John Tamihere writes:

LABOUR Party leader Phil Goff did an absolute somersault on his party’s position in regard to Foreshore and Seabed matters and Maori matters generally. …

Goff and his attack this week reflects not just a desperate man leading a desperate Party but shows the lack of integrity, credibility and leadership.

It is easy to divide a country, it is tough to unite it. Goff has embarked on a cheap, nasty direction for the Labour Party and I’m glad I’m not a member of it anymore.

You have to wonder why Parekura Horomia, Mita Ririnui and Nanaia Mahuta still remain in a Party that they know took the stick to us whenever a poll came out showing there was a difficulty to matters Maori.

The Foreshore and Seabed Legislation that we voted for is unworkable and unfair. It needs to be repealed and Goff knows that.

Pita Sharples and Tariana Turia are pro-Maori but not anti-Pakeha. Goff and his mates have taken the Maori vote for granted and whilst they can be pro-Pakeha, they are definitely now anti-Maori.

That is harsh criticism, considering it is from no Maori radical, but John Tamihere.