Blog Bits from the Left

  1. Judy Callaghan on the art of saying no
  2. Andrew Geddis on Justice Wilson
  3. No Right Turn on how Nathan Rees got rolled as NSW Labor leader as he stood up against corruption
  4. Jake Quinn covers the reported discontent over Goff’s u-turn on the foreshore and seabed, and notes that Andrew Little declared at the Labour conference that Maori should have their day in court
  5. Brian Edwards and Judy Callaghan debate Tiger Woods
  6. Chris Trotter labels Grant Robertson the MP for the Commissariat

An Adagio Christmas

Just got back from Downstage, where I watched An Adagio Christmas.

The performance was very silly, but very very very funny. It was a superb hour of entertainment, and I really can’t think of anyone who would not enjoy it – from kids to grandparents.

I won’t talk about the plot, because there isn’t really one. It is more a collection of acts, woven together with humour and skill. Instead I’ll rave about the company.

Mason West and Rowan Heydon White were the two circus artists. They do everything but fly through the air as they use poles, ropes and scarves to perform. They both have incredible muscle strength and do stuff that really should be impossible such as holding themselves almost at right angles to the pole with their arms. Any thought of women as the weaker sex would disappear after watching Rowan.

Angela Green was wonderful in her myriad roles from strugling author (her metaphors make you groan) to bolshie puppet.

Jenny MacArthur appeared to be a grumpy old woman, but transforms literally into a fairy. She was hugely entertaining.

Asalemo Tofete was the big guy who was the butt of several (politically incorrect) jokes.

And Rosemary Langabeer and William Henderson provided the zany music.

Part of why the show was so enjoyable, was that you could see the company were enjoying it also. It was funny, cheeky, a bit sensual, and very manic.

Downstage could offer a money back if you don’t like it guarantee on this show, and be confident they won’t have to pay out a cent.

Peter the Xmas Elf Caption Contest

A fine is not enough

The Herald reports:

Anti-violence campaigners have condemned the penalty handed to a Taranaki rugby player who strangled his pregnant partner but escaped with a $750 fine.

Paul Perez, 23, lifted his partner Dana Carlyle Brooks off the ground in May, choking her until she almost blacked out, before he punched her in the nose.

And he gets a fine only slightly more than speeding tickets.

Jane Drumm, executive director of Shine (Safer Homes in New Zealand Everyday), said the sentence was “just not acceptable” and she was extremely concerned for Ms Brooks’ safety.

“When someone puts their hands around a person’s throat and does that, that means they’re very close to being killed,” she said. “That is how women die.

Strangling is no minor assault. It is an attempt to kill, not to hurt.

Man needs life

Stuff reports:

A Taiwanese man has become the first person to finish nearly everything in the popular online game World of Warcraft, according to an online report.

The MMO Champion website reported the man’s character “Little Grey” is the first to complete every achivement in the game, reaching 986 out of a possible 986 points.

Along the way he’s virtually slain 390,895 creatures and died 8,543 times while completing 5906 quests, an average of 14.6 quests per day. That means he’s played for about 400 days.

I have luckily resisted every playing World of Warcraft.

Police probe of former MPs expenses

The Herald reports:

A former Government minister is being investigated by police for allegedly using his ex-MP perk of taxpayer-funded flights on business trips and then claiming driving mileage from the charity he headed.

Detectives have executed search warrants on the Auckland home of Roger McClay, a National Party MP for 15 years, and seized financial records from Keep New Zealand Beautiful, of which he was the chairman.

Former staff and fellow board members have also been interviewed by police.

Mr McClay, 64, is under investigation for allegedly invoicing the environmental organisation for the cost of driving mileage, but taking a taxpayer-funded flight instead.

As a former MP, Mr McClay is entitled to the 90 per cent subsidy for 12 domestic return flights each year. No charges have been laid and he has denied any wrongdoing.

He said he was disappointed at the length of the police inquiry but declined to comment further.

The inquiry has been on-going for a long time. It seems it was initiated between December 2008 and February 2009, and the search warrants referred to were executed in June 2009 – six months ago.

Not much comment one can make, without knowing if the allegations are true. The fact the case is unresolved after 12 months suggests it is not clear cut. No doubt at some stage the Police will either lay charges or close the file.

Well done Goff

The Dom Post reports:

The Dalai Lama met with opposition leader Phil Goff after arriving in New Zealand with a flurry of diplomatic protocol hanging over him.

It is disappointing that John Key would not meet with the Dalai Llama, just to keep China happy. I think we should trade with China but not let them decide who we allow into New Zealand and meet with.

Mr Goff said that, if he was prime minister, he would still meet the Dalai Lama.

“I met with him when I was foreign minister, I don’t see any difference whether I’m a member of the executive or a leader of the Opposition. I’m meeting with him in his capacity as a spiritual and cultural leader and as a very nice person.”

Full credit to Goff for doing the right thing, and may it continue if he does ever achieve the top job.

Herald NZer of the Year

An excellent choice by the NZ Herald for New Zealander of the Year:

Lenny Holmwood knew he should just run.

He had seen the murderous rage in Jan Molenaar’s eyes. He had watched Molenaar shoot the policemen. He saw the gun was still in Molenaar’s hands, and realised the bodybuilder was far stronger than him. He sensed he could be next.

But Holmwood also knew the two wounded policemen on the street had no chance without him.

Molenaar was intent on finishing them off. Blood streaming from their wounds, the unarmed officers were completely out in the open as they tried to stagger up the steep road. Molenaar was just metres away as he turned the gun on them.

So, on May 7, Holmwood stepped up.

A true hero. He got shot saving the lives of the police officers.

The Business New Zealander of the Year is Mike Daniell, CEO of Fisher & Paykel Healthcare.

Other nominees are detailed here. They include:

  • Abby Wutzler & Maxwell Wilson for Tsunami warnings
  • Dame Anne Salmond for academic achievements
  • Paul Holmes for his anti-P campaign
  • Al Rowland for proving damage to veterans from nuclear testing
  • Deb Leask for her campaign against shoddy real estate practices
  • Mike & Conor O’Leary for savings boys from a burning car
  • Peter Yealands for wine making and conservation
  • Roger Levie – for his leaky homes campaign
  • Toesulu Maea Brown – for education in Manukau

Hooton on 2025

Matthew Hooton writes in NBR:

In the government’s defence, its two major strategic decisions have been absolutely right.

First was Bill English’s decision to resist calls to stimulate the domestic economy, beyond the effect of the automatic stabilisers and Michael Cullen’s election bribes, in response to the financial crisis.

Second was Mr Key’s absolute determination to maintain trust with the people. …

The problem is that the desire to maintain sound political strategy has overwhelmed its raison d’être. Some in the Beehive now see it as an end not a means.

Worse, one or two appear to believe that the government’s high poll ratings mean they are some kind of political miracle-workers.

Wiser Beehive heads understand that there is nothing surprising about a new government – especially one which has defeated a tired, hectoring and corrupt regime – achieving 50%+ in the polls, simply by keeping its promises, managing the daily news cycle and ruling anything out that doesn’t enjoy clear public support.

The difficult bit is turning this into a worthwhile legacy. Unfortunately, there appears to be no plan or even informal modus operandi to integrate political management with policy goals. …

Ludicrous policies will continue, like interest-free student loans, and free GP visits and daycare for the children of millionaires. Labour’s Working for Families, which traps people with massive effective marginal tax rates and which Mr Key described accurately as “communism by stealth”, is now defended.

It’s easy to accept the political logic of all these moves but their cumulative effect is that it’s difficult to see what levers Mr Key has left if he truly wants to achieve anything important with his prime ministership.

I agree that the numbers of levers remaining is relatively few. I think the 2010 budget is an important one. National needs to do more than merely announce how it has allocated the $1.1 billion spending contigency.

R v Internet Part II

Before I add my comments, you can also see some summaries at Tech Liberty NZ blog (worth subscribing to also).

Also the Twitter feed is extensive. Over 250 tweets. Is one of the best Twitter coverages I have seen as we had nine or ten people et the seminar twittering and several people not there also commenting and asking questions.

The morning session was mainly focused on contempt of court, and the afternoon on name suppression issues.

Warren Young, the Deputy President of the Law Commission, gave an overview of the recommendations from their recent report on suppressing names and evidence. He said the threshold for getting name suppression shoudl be “extreme hardship” not just hardship as at present.

Most usefully he clarified that the recommendation relating to ISPs removing or blocking suppressed material is not meant to imply an obligation on ISPs to block overseas hosted material, just to remove material hosted on their own networks.

I asked a question about whom an ISP should be obliged to act on a complaint from – my preference is it should only be if the Crown Law Office or Police inform an ISP of suppressed material.

Judge Harvey spoke about the challenges of the Internet and supressed material, but did not think the horse had bolted. He made the case that one doesn’t have to achieve perfect suppression – it is often mainly aimed at making it hard for jurors to access material not relevant to the trial.

The final panel was myself, Sinead Boucher (Group Online Editor for Fairfax) and Ursula Cheer from Cant Uni Law School. Sinead and I talked about the issues we face from a practical point of view in trying to complay with the law, and Ursula touched on how different technologies come in and out of vogue with different challenges.

Now I can’t avoid mentioning a huge fuckup I did. It was one of the rare times I was speechless as I realised what I had done. I had a few slides to go with my talk, and I was talking about the recent high profile entertainer case, and was detailing the different sites you could find out on.

The point I was making was it was not just blogs, but the name was on Yahoo Answers, MSN NZ, was findable through Google search and even on the entertainer’s facebook page. I found it amusing that the entertainer himself could be liable for breaking his own name suppression.

rvi

I displayed the above page to show the comment someone had made on the page. I pointed out to the room packed full of lawyers from the Courts, Ministry of Justice, Crown Law, Law Commission etc (plus the Judge who originally dealt with the case) how careful I had been to draw green boxes over seven parts of the page to stop my showing the page, itself being a breach of the suppression order.

I went on to say how I then realised the URL gave the name away also, so had to go back and green that out also, and then also realised two of my open tabs displayed the name, and edited the graphic for a third time to green them out.

Just as I was about to move on, someone in the audience then pointed out that sadly I had overlooked the Google search box in the Google toolbar, and to my horror there indeed was the name of the entertainer (now behind a yellow-brown box). I was mortified as the audience started pissing themselves with laughter.

I mean how much worse can it be – you are boasting about how careful you have been to not break the name suppression order, and bang the name is up on the screen in front of everyone – and especially in front of that audience.

In the general discussion at the end, there was some discussion around the role of the media committee of the Courts. The TVNZ lawyer said the committee had one rep from print media and one from broadcast media, and many in the room thought an additional rep from Internet media could be a useful thing. Of course that is a decision for the judiciary, but it was agreed InternetNZ would write to the Chair to discuss the concept.

Feedback from participants was incredibly positive, especially from many of the lawyers. A common comment was how useful it was not just having lawyers there discussing things academically, but also having media and Internet practitioners with practical knowledge. There was a strong feeling that there should be more opportunities to get the various industries together on issues of mutual interest.

Kudos to InternetNZ President Frank March who MC’d the day well to finish ahead of time, and to the InternetNZ staff who primarily organised it. And most of all to the participants – had many great contributions not just from the speakers, but from the floor.

Has Greenpeace paid up?

Goff says axe 2025 taskforce

The Herald reports:

The 2025 Taskforce set up to find ways to catch up with Australia’s economic growth should be scrapped, Labour Leader Phil Goff says.

Mr Goff said today it had a budget of $447,000 over three years and had so far cost $150,000.

“The taskforce’s first report was a complete and utter waste of money,” he said.

“Why give your mates $447,000 to cook up something you say you’re not going to do … dump this soapbox for ACT and Dr Brash and save the taxpayer the unspent $330,000.”

This is a classic case of thinking tactically, not strategically. The last thing Labour should want is the taskforce wound up. Why?

It will exist for three years, issuing further reports and monitoring the Government’s progress.

If the Government does not act on any of the taskforce’s recommendations, then you are going to have this taskforce, headed up by National’s former leader, issuing damning reports about how the Government is failing to close the gap with Australia.

Goff shouldn’t be demanding the taskforce be closed down. If he was smart, he’d be offering to pay its bills himself.  He really needs to start thinking strategically.

Please Miss

Stuff reports:

Tradition has gone out the classroom window as an increasing number of primary schools allow children to address teachers by their first names.

The move away from honorifics – reflected across other aspects of society too – has sparked debate among education experts. Teachers say it removes an unnecessary level of authority and encourages more curious and questioning students. Critics say it gives children more freedom than they are prepared for.

Wellington’s Mt Cook School principal Sandra McCallum said using Christian names changed the learning dynamic. Instead of passively accepting what they are told, children are not overawed by authority and are more questioning.

“The old adage that children are there to be seen and not heard – that has changed,” she said.

But Victoria University anthropologist James Urry argues that removing the age-based hierarchy is empowering kids before they are ready.

“The consequences of this usage in schools is a collapse of authority and a lack of respect which also extends beyond school. Children are empowered often without the social skills to handle their empowerment,” he said.

“There has to be discipline, there has to be authority or it’s Lord of the Flies.”

I have mixed views on this. When I was at school, teachers were always addressed with as Mr Jackson or Miss Petris etc. In the 7th form, a few teachers said call them Wayne when alone. It is interesting how hard habits die. If I meet a former teacher years later, I still automatically call them Mr Wilson, rather than Ken.

Having said that I personally don’t like being addressed with an honorific. If someone calls me Mr Farrar, I will usually retort that is my father, not me (actually he is Dr Farrar but you get the point). I spent around 13 years as a Cub/Scout/Venturer leader and always encouraged use of my christian name – this would sometimes cause problems at regional activities when they would be told off by other leaders for being disrespectful by calling me David.

This preferred use of my christian name policy was especially the case when I was a cub leader, as cub leaders often get names from the Jungle Book. I recall being with some mates in Courtenay Place McDonalds as a 22 year old, and running into a couple of the Cubs (aged 8 – 10) from Island Bay. Imagine my horror when they greeted me in front of all my mates as “Baloo”.

Anyway back to what to call teachers, I think it is a decision for what fits the culture best of each school. If I was a teacher (as I once considered) I would much prefer being called David than Mr Farrar. But if the other teachers at a school prefer honorifics, I would go with the flow.

For whom the ETS tolls

This week’s Dispatch from St Johnnysburg looks at the toll the ETS has taken in New Zealand and Australia. I note:

So it has been quite a torrid time for National, who had days and days of negative headlines. Finally they got the changes passed into law, with some medium to heavy political bruising as the cost.

However painful those bruises might be, they pale into insignificance with the crippling wounds the ETS legislation has inflicted on the Australian Liberal Party. Despite only being the Opposition, not the Government, the ETS legislation resulted in a move to their fourth party leader in just two years.

I also look at what may become an ETS referendum election in Australia:

While it is difficult to imagine that Tony Abbott could win such an election, it would pose a fascinating dilemma for NZ National if Abbott did. There would be great pressure on New Zealand to delay or further amend its ETS, if Australia abandoned having one. After working so hard to get the genie into the box, it would be a political nightmare to have the issue flair up all over again.

So it poses the question. If Australia does go to the polls early next year to an ETS triggered election, will John Key be quietly hoping for Labor’s Kevin Rudd to win?

Comments and feedback can be made at NBR.

Excellent

Stuff reports:

The Labour Party would scrap national primary and intermediate education standards if elected, says education spokesman Trevor Mallard.

Wonderful news.

Now we just need Labour to confirm how much it will increase income tax rates by to cover all its spending pledges.

Tensions within Labour

This has the potential to get interesting. Firstly Goff does a further u-turn on the foreshore and seabed:

Opposition leader Phil Goff has indicated Labour is backing away from its stance of allowing customary title of the foreshore and seabed to be awarded to iwi that meet the criteria involved.

Labour’s submission to the review of the Foreshore and Seabed Act earlier this year recommended the legislation be amended to allow customary title, rather than simple redress and protection of customary rights. …

Asked to clarify whether that meant its position on customary title had changed, Mr Goff told the Herald he remained open to considering it but would first have to be convinced it was necessary.

So Phil Goff is advocating a position different to Labour’s own submission on the law. As expected, this is causing some tensions within Labour, according to Vernon Small:

Labour leader Phil Goff will be asked to explain his controversial “nationhood” speech at next week’s party caucus meeting.

Discontent, especially on the Left of the party, has centred around Mr Goff’s comments on the foreshore and seabed policy.

A Leader who has to “explain” a speech to Caucus has some problems.

Labour sources said Wellington Central MP Grant Robertson questioned the speech at last week’s caucus meeting. He was again expected to be prominent among those expressing concerns at next Tuesday’s caucus meeting.

It is significant that Grant is leading the charge, for several reasons.

The first is that Grant will just be doing his job as a local MP. Wellington Central is a very liberal seat, and Labour activists there are very liberal. I have no doubt Grant will have been bombarded by supporters asking what the fuck is going on.

The second is that Grant is often (correctly) described as a future Labour Party Leader. Despite being first term, he is a heavyweight in caucus. Having Grant criticise a speech by the Leader, is not the same as having George Hawkins criticise it.

The third is that Grant is clearly from the leftish faction in Caucus. Now under Helen Clark factional warfare almost ended, and the factions were informal and flexible. But Goff’s speech and the reaction to it, may be the start of the factions becoming a bit more significant.

Sources said the party’s ruling council had already asked Mr Goff to explain the speech on Saturday .

“There will be questions at caucus on Tuesday,” one senior MP said.

The party’s council is almost exclusively from the liberal left side, so this is no surprise.

But another discounted a move against Mr Goff’s leadership, saying the concern should not be read as a sign of “deep divisions” in the party.

Oh absolutely it is premature to start talking of moves against the leadership. Such a possibility would not be considered until late 2010 at the earliest, and even then only if the polls remain dire after the 2010 budget.

Border SmartGate

The Herald reports:

Transtasman travel has become a lot easier with the introduction of the SmartGate system at Auckland Airport.

Prime Minister John Key became the first person to sign in with the new technology yesterday.

Customs NZ deputy controller John Secker said the opening of Auckland’s SmartGate was the single biggest development in border processing in 20 years.

Passengers with Australian or New Zealand electronic passports can now fast-track into the country by using a new automated system.

Travellers scan their passports at a kiosk, answer a few questions using a touch screen and are issued with a ticket.

At the gate, a camera scans the passenger’s face using biometric facial recognition technology.

If there is a match with the image stored in the passport, the gate opens.

They have a similar system in Dubai, and I was very impressed with it. You can do pretty much everything yourself – even putting your bags through the x-ray, scanning the passport.

Great to see this move to make trans-tasman travel more hassle-free. Now if only someone could fix Wellington Airport so the security scans are done before the Koru Club, not afterwards. Auckland Airport is vastly more efficient with one security point for the airport.

The pillow attack case

The pillow attack case is interesting because t both can and can not be linked to the S59 debate. The Herald reports:

A judge has thrown out an assault case against a man who threw a cushion at his nephew’s head following an argument with the boy’s mother.

George Taylor was accused of assault last New Year’s Eve following an argument about whether the mother of the 6-year-old was being overprotective of her children.

He threw a small decorative cushion at his nephew’s head, and although the mother did not see the incident, she called the police. …

At the hearing, the boy, who was speaking from behind a protective screen shielding him from the accused, told the court that the pillow strike had not really hurt and that he felt no ill-will towards his uncle.

The boy said he had been hit on the top of the head, had not been injured and had not been sore.

Now in a literal sense, this case has nothing to do with S59 as the defendent was an uncle, not a parent. In fact it is due to the complaint from a parent, that it proceeded at all. So some would argue it is protecting parents rights.

However others may argue that as the law now places parents on much the same platform as all other adults, a parent may now have to fear a pillow fight leading to charges. Personally I think that is over-reaching, as the key thing here is it is the parent, not the child, who insisted on charges.

Yesterday in court, the judge said a trial would potentially damage the boy and dismissal of the case was in the overall interests of justice.

The judge also blasted the police as “ridiculous” and “petty” for bringing action against Mr Taylor.

This is the aspect that will cause more legitimate concern amongst opponents of the anti-smacking law. The Government and PM puts great stock in the discretion available to Police. When you see the Police applying such discretion badly, it makes you nervous.

On the other hand, the system worked. The court correctly threw it out and reamed the Police. But a pity Mr Taylor had to go through a year of stress over something that should never have been a criminal matter.

Pillay retiring in 2011

Labour List MP Lynne Pillay has announced she is retiring in 2011. She was MP for Waitakere from 2002 to 2008.

Lynne used to chair the Justice and Electoral Select Committee, and I found her very professional when I made submissions on various issues.

It is interesting that she is announcing her retirement now, yet not retiring until 2011. In the past List MPs have retired mid-term. What we are seeing is the Tizard effect – Phil Goff’s compulsive fear of having Judith (who is next on the list) back in his caucus.

Incidentally I approve of not retiring mid-term (unless a former leader). I think MPs should stay for an entire term, if elected.

This raises the issue of which other Labour MPs may retire in 2011. My thoughts are:

  • Parekura Horomia – probable
  • Ruth Dyson – possible
  • Chris Carter – probable
  • Lianne Dalziel – possible
  • Pete Hodgson – probable
  • Sue Moroney – possible
  • Rick Barker – probable
  • Ross Robertson – possible
  • George Hawkins – probable – but only if he wants to
  • Darien Fenton – possible
  • Rajen Prasad – possible
  • Ashraf Choudary – probable

On current polls, Labour may get fewer MPs in 2011 than in 2008. They will want to protect their new intake, and get some fresh faces in. Their list ranking process will be interesting.

Blunt on Hone

Naughty Tiger

News.com.au reports:

GOLF superstar Tiger Woods has admitted “transgressions” saying he had let his family down, in a statement posted on his website that appeared to confirm rumours of an extramarital affair.

A famous person having an affair is hardly unusual, but this case has generated considerable discussion, as his wife, Elin Nordegren, is a beautiful model in her 20s.

Greer McDonald asks the question of whether monogamy is natural:

Do you think that the majority have just been taught that monogamy is the right and only way, and that it’s actually “natural” to want – and be with – more than one person?

Or is it in the human nature to be coupled up and be okay with that?

For my 2c I think that the vast majority of guys are attracted to other women, even if in a happy relationship. However that does not mean you act on the attraction.

R v the Internet

The seminar on the Internet and the Courts has been really good so far. You can follow it on Twitter here. It is also being filmed and will be viewable on the Internet.

Chris Finlayson gave a very amusing and interesting opening address. Referred to how someone once threw a cat at a Judge and the Judge said if you do it again, it will be contempt. It is indexed in law journals as “cat throwing-contempt-one cat allowed-two cats is contempt”.

He also said how relieved he was to find the room full of relatively normal people (ie lawyers) rather than Farrar-like hobbits 🙂

Professor Tony Smith had what I considered a good suggestion that the Courts have a staffer who proactively looks for material before a trial starts that may be pose a risk to a fair trial, and asks voluntarily for temporary removal.

Solictor-General David Collins talked about how Internet issues take up a large amount of his time, and the inability of getting Yahoo to remove material. Is seeking an agreement between governments to seek to enforce each other’s court orders to ISPs. There are some risks with this approach, as if publishers are deemed to be subject to the laws of every country they have readers, the lowest common denominator can apply.

Steven Price said that compulsory filtering only happens in repressive countries like China and Australia. Heh. Said genie was out of the bottle but not sure if it is a problem. Thinks there should be less use of contempt.

Robert Lithgow QC said he was probably only person in room who has prosecuted for contempt, defended people for contempt, has been charged with contempt himself and in fact appears shortly in the Supreme Court for Vince Seimer over his contempt issues.

He agreed with Steven Price largely and said the law of contempt is fundamentally buggered and only getting at the nutters now. He also said that there is no constitutional significance to modern commercial media as we don’t need them now, as bloggers are the public! Said the press are watchdogs and mongrels. They bark indiscriminately and only interested in food and biting!

Radio NZ Political Editor (and Chair of EPMU Media Committee) Brent Edwards said Internet got around censorship in even most sinister regime, so will do so in countries like NZ.

Robert Lithgow suggested all court cases should have a static camera so people can view over Internet, and not rely on the media so much. I agree entirely.