Failure

Kay Skelton’s appeal

Another lovely person is appealing her conviction. The Dom Post reports:

A mother pleaded guilty to abducting her son because she thought she could not get a fair trial amid all the publicity about the case, her lawyer says.

Even judges had said Kay Skelton was a conniving woman prepared to deceive the court, but they had done so on the assumption that she knew where her son was and was refusing to say, lawyer Howard Lawry told the Court of Appeal at Wellington yesterday. …

She says her conviction should be overturned and the abduction charge should go no further. …

Both father and daughter were given sentences of home detention. Skelton also had to do community work.

Personally I think she got off very lightly with home detention and community work.

As the appeal is before Judges only, and not a jury, I don’t have to worry about influencing a trial, and can point readers to my January 2007 article on Kay Skelton. Her record of perjury and lies is appalling, with the lowlight being the fake DNA results.

Waitakere City Council in the gun

Stuff reports:

As the family of Aisling Symes prepare for her funeral, Waitakere City Council could face prosecution over her death. …

Neighbours of the home from which Aisling wandered away said yesterday that they had repeatedly warned the council about problems with the drain and a manhole cover that Aisling probably crawled through, saying it blew off under the increased water pressure when it rained.

Waitakere Mayor Bob Harvey began an inquiry yesterday into those allegations, while a spokesman confirmed that the council had received four complaints about the manhole cover since 2004, the latest on September 11 and September 25.

It is difficult to explain why nothing was done, despite four formal complaints. This is bread and butter stuff for Councils.

Tim Rainey, a lawyer who specialises in construction negligence, said it was “very much a live possibility” that the council could be prosecuted under the Health and Safety in Employment Act.

“If they were aware of a risk which could harm somebody then they would have been obliged to take all practicable steps to ensure that risk was either eliminated or minimised.”

The only problem with a prosecution is that innocent ratepayers will have to pay any fine, not those responsible.

Council staff visited the Longburn Rd property and inspected the drain on September 16 – five days after the first complaint.

They found it was blocked by tree roots, and were discussing with the property owner who would pay to clear the blockage.

“We were in the process of deciding how best to remove those when the tragedy occurred,” council spokesman Wally Thomas said.

“There was a matter of days between us receiving the last complaint and acting on it, and before we could clear the problem this tragedy occurred.”

However the complaints go back to before September the 11th it seems. What is the time gap between the first complaint, not the last complaint?

A deal on league tables

The Dom Post reports:

After months of disputes, Education Minister Anne Tolley has struck a deal with primary school unions that will see them work together on its controversial national standards policy.

Under the agreement, the Government has confirmed it will make it as difficult as possible for the media to produce league tables that rank schools.

It’s good that the unions will not try and boycott the national standards (as they are important), but I’d like some more details on how exactly the Government plans to make it difficult for the media to produce league tables. I sure hope they are not talking a law change.

It follows a threat from hundreds of primary school principals to boycott the policy unless changes were made to limit public access to performance data.

The peace deal with NZEI, the Principals Federation and the School Trustees Association follows months of disagreements between the groups over the introduction of the policy, which will see pupils from years 1 to 8 assessed in numeracy and literacy against national academic standards from next year.

Mrs Tolley told The Dominion Post the deal was a “a momentous occasion”.

“I can’t stress enough that it took my breath away that we have all for the first time sat round the table and said, ‘Yes, we are going to make this work together.’ That is fantastic.”

She said she told the groups she was prepared to work with them to stop the use of league tables. “We want to make it as difficult for you [media] as possible. It will be too hard and too much work and not worth it in the end. There are a few ideas we will discuss as to how we can do that.”

I’m fascinated as to what these ideas might be, because I can’t see what will stop media requesting achievement info for a school under the OIA, and then using that to compile a league table – should they so wish. Personally league tables have limited value and are overly simplistic, but I don’t believe you stop the media from publishing them, if they decide to.

PSA & SWFU not to merge

Got forwarded an internal union e-mail. Have not seen this issue in the media. The e-mail says:

A message from Paula Scholes, PSA president PSA and SFWU to cease merger talks

The PSA and the SFWU have decided to stop discussing the potential for a merger between our two unions. The primary reason for doing so was the inability of both unions to reach sufficient agreement on the issue of political relationships and affiliations. Both unions have long standing and proud traditions on the issue of political relationships.

The SFWU has a long standing affiliation status with the Labour party, is this week signing a Memorandum of Understanding with the Green Party and has explored a formal relationship with the Maori Party. The PSA has an equally strong commitment to remaining non affiliated and independent of political parties.

Both unions have looked at various alternatives to affiliation or non affiliation of the new union, but a jointly acceptable position has not been achieved.

Governance representatives of both unions met four times over the past few months exploring the concept of a merger.

Both unions agree that we have significant areas of common interest and will benefit from working even closer together in the future, especially in the health and NGO sectors. Our important joint campaigns in the disability sector will continue and other joint campaigns are likely to follow.

While it is disappointing that the potential benefits of a merger will not be realised, both unions remain committed to continuing our close and constructive relationship.

The openness with which our potential merger discussions have occurred has done much to strengthen our already close relationship.

Basically they are saying the merger didn’t happen because the SWFU refused to give up affiliation to the Labour Party. They get too many MPs through Labour, to give that up. Their MPs have included Taito Phllip Field, Dave Hereora, Lianne Dalziel and Darien Fenton.

Not Evil Just Wrong

That is the name of a film being released in just under six days. It is about the costs of “global warming hysteria”.

The film compares the consequences of the ban on DDT, with the cost of trying to ban carbon emissions. They talk about how Al Gore would have you believe the sea level will rise by 20 feet in the near future, when in fact the IPCC say this would be over millennia.

You can host your own première of the film.

As I have said in the past, I tend to accept the IPCC consensus as to the effect of greenhouse gases on the climate, and what this may mean in the future. However what many people do not realise is that environmentalists and politicians often greatly exaggerate what the IPCC actually has said, and what the effect of warming might be.

And the BBC reported a few days ago:

To confuse the issue even further, last month Mojib Latif, a member of the IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change) says that we may indeed be in a period of cooling worldwide temperatures that could last another 10-20 years.

Professor Latif is based at the Leibniz Institute of Marine Sciences at Kiel University in Germany and is one of the world’s top climate modellers.

But he makes it clear that he has not become a sceptic; he believes that this cooling will be temporary, before the overwhelming force of man-made global warming reasserts itself.

And again I agree the long-term trend is for warming, but the hysteria over how it is urgent to have cut emissions by 40% by 2020 or the planet is doomed, is just that. In fact by 2020 the planet may still be in a cooling phase.

As we get better technology, and gradually transition to energy sources that produce fewer emissions, our carbon emissions will reduce. But 2020 is not some date of no return.

Weatherston appeals murder conviction

I’m almost speechless. With great restraint I said I hoped to never have to blog again on Clayton Weatherston until 2027, when he would become eligible for parole.

But the sick little fucker is appealing his sentence.

No competent lawyer could have advised him that he could possibly win such an appeal. He must just be doing it to further his narcissistic ego, so he stays in the headlines, or as another attempt to blacken Sophie’s name.

I’ll be appalled if he gets one cent of taxpayer money to fund his appeal.

UPDATE: I understand Judith Ablett-Kerr will not represent Weatherston at his appeal and he is seeking a North Island QC. I’m tempted to advocate that no QC touch him, but then he would seek to represent himself in court which would be even more of a spectacle. I just hope they can schedule the appeal quickly, so we can go back to forgetting about him

Speeding up the Parliamentary Process

The Australasian Study of Parliament Group has an interesting seminar in November:

Mechanisms used to speed up Parliamentary process

You and your guests are invited to hear Hon Dr Michael Cullen along with Hon Jim Anderton and Hon John Carter discuss the Parliamentary process and how it could be improved.

Dr Cullen is one of the foremost parliamentarians of recent times, a master of procedure, debate and repartee, and for nine years leader of the House. Mr Jim Anderton is another long-serving parliamentarian, who has served in governments and as leader of a minority party. Mr Carter was an effective chief whip for National in opposition.

The seminar will be chaired by Colin James.

Questions and discussion are encouraged.

The seminar will be preceded by the annual general meeting at 5.45pm, at which all are welcome. The seminar will start at 6pm.

Thursday, 19 November 2009

5.45pm – 7.00pm

Venue – West Foyer, ground floor of the Executive Wing (the Beehive)

Please join us for drinks (cash bar) and nibbles from 5.30pm

RSVP (acceptances only) Andrea O’Brien,
Chapter Secretary, ASPG
04 817 9597 Andrea.O’[email protected]

That sounds very interesting. I doubt I will able to attend on that date, but hope to get reports from anyone who does.

Broken Boughs

An interesting 68 page report from Maxim on the role of effective family interventions. They have actually done an evaluation of the dufferent family intervention programmes.

Their conclusion is:

We conclude that the preferred approach to family intervention is to develop and implement programmes that are family-focused, intervene early and are targeted to children and families that are at risk or experiencing actual problems.

They evaluate seven programmes:

  • Family Start
  • Parents as First Teachers
  • Early Start
  • Whanau Toko I Te Ora
  • The Parenting Programme;
  • Incredible Years
  • Triple P.

And their recommendations:

  1. Three programmes should be further implemented and funded: Early Start, the Incredible Years and Triple P.
  2. A comprehensive review of exemplary, evidence-based home visitation and parent management training programmes should
    be undertaken to identify other programmes that might be suitable for implementation and funding in New Zealand.
  3. Funding should be carefully allocated. Existing funding from unproven and/or ineffective programmes like Family Start and Parents as First Teachers should be reallocated to evidence-based programmes.
    Continued funding should be conditional on programmes continuing to demonstrate that they are effective and delivered with fidelity.

They’re back!

Diagnostic Medlab has effectively forced the Auckland DHBs into an embarrassing u-turn, and have been granted 10% of the medical testing market under a four year contract.

The big loser isn’t so much Labtests, but the DHBs themselves. The decision to move to Labtests was not necessarily wrong, but the transition plan in hindsight was woeful. The transition should have been done over six months or so, allowing a couple of suburbs to transition every fortnight, and make sure everything is working, before the next suburb moves over.

Diagnostic Medlab got much criticism for their campaign against Labtest, as the work of bad losers. But the campaign worked, and they just gained a $10.2 m/year contract.

Labtests loses $6.2 million a year for its reduced workload, and the DHBs (ie taxpayers) make up the extra $4.4m a year. This means the change overall does still save money, but a lot less than before.

NZMA say:

Today’s announcement has been welcomed by the New Zealand Medical Association.

“The decision by the Auckland District Health Boards goes some way towards reducing the inherent risk in the current arrangement of having a single provider and is therefore a step in the right direction,” said NZMA GP Council Chair Dr Mark Peterson.

And this raises the very valid issue of should they have gone with a single provider at all. Having both providers in the market will allow some comparisons of service, price and quality, and over time the one that performs better should end up with a greater market share.

The store music police

This article from Australia sums up the mentality of some people:

A MOTHER outraged by clothing shop music peppered with the F-word could not find a single agency to deal with her complaint.

Deb Sorensen was in a city Deborah K clothing store this month with her 14-year-old stepdaughter and her friend when “degrading and offensive” music was played.

“We were subjected to a loud barrage of foul and highly disturbing lyrics, including the ‘F’ word,” she said. …

Store manager Hussein Kaiser dumped the music, which he said was chosen by young sales staff. But Ms Sorensen said there was nothing to stop others playing it.

Victorian Consumer Affairs had referred her to ARIA (the Australian Recording Industry Association), which sent Ms Sorensen to AMRA (the Australian Music Retailers Association), which suggested the Australian Retail Association, which passed her on to the ACCC (Australian Competition and Consumer Commission), which suggested ASIC (Australian Securities and Investments Commission).

Ms Sorensen also contacted her local MP and Melbourne City Council. While most were sympathetic, no one could help. …

“There is obviously a gap in legislation, and authorities seem confused about who is responsible,” the mother of seven said. “Vulnerable children should not be exposed to sexually explicit, violent material, anywhere, at any time.”

No there is not a gap or a problem. No new agency is needed to deal with complaints about what music is played in a private store. If you do not like the music, then never shop there again.

If you really feel passionate, about it then blog about it, twitter about it. Even stand outside and picket then (God knows why though as they clearly said they dumped the music). But don’t go demanding some Government agency do something.

What she should have done, if she was smart, was ring ARPA (Australasian Performing Rights Association) and tell them the store was playing music without having paid royalty fees to ARPA. They would have probably had a SWAT team down there within 30 minutes 🙂

Crime Stoppers

Crime Stoppers was launched yesterday.

You can use it to report crime through their website or by calling 0800 555 111. They don’t record the call, want your name or details – just information on the crime and who is responsible.

The organisation is an independent charity, based on the UK one set up by Lord Ashcroft, who has also donated to the NZ one.

In the last year, the UK crime stoppers achieved:

  • 91,649 arrests and charges from 1,060,047 actionable calls
  • 106 million pounds of goods recovered
  • 167 million pounds fo drugs seized
  • One person every four days charged with murder as a result of information provided
  • Contributes to solving of one in five murders in London

Now the UK has 15 times our population, but that still suggests it should prove a useful contributor to the fight against crime.

Putting country ahead of party

Readers will have seen the reports that the United States has lifted the ban on full intelligence sharing with New Zealand. The ban on joint exercises is almost all but gone. After almost 25 long years, the relationship is almost restored.

The praise for this should go not just to the current Government, but Opposition Leader Phil Goff and Trade Spokesperson Maryan Street who have been with McCully and Groser in Washington DC.

Despite the politics before the last election, I understand that the Opposition and Government have been posing a united front, and have made clear that no matter what happens in future elections, NZ will not be amending its anti-nuclear law. The Opposition did not suggest it will be gone by lunchtime, but that it has bi-partisan support and is a reality, so it should no longer be a barrier to the relationship.

This, combined with Obama’s own rhetoric about ridding the world of nuclear weapons, has led to a significant warming of relations on the military and intelligence fronts.

So praise, where praise is due. Congrats to Goff and Street for putting the country ahead of their party, and helping enable the Government and US Government to move closer together.

Satan in the Australian Parliament

AAP report:

A FORMER political running mate of Family First senator Steve Fielding says dark forces are casting spells on Federal Parliament.

Catch the Fire Ministries pastor Daniel Nalliah has organised a “prayer offensive” to combat evil forces including witchcraft, homosexuality and abortion.

Boy he really must dislike Albus Dumbledore then.

“These days people don’t think the Devil is real but we have seen the bad effects of the spiritual being known as Satan and we believe there is a spiritual fight over the nation of Australia being fought in the heavens.”

Asked what evidence of Satan there was in Parliament, Mr Nalliah said: “The number of politicians who have serious marriage problems.”

That is interesting in that he blames Satan for the marriage problems of MPs.

Personally I blame it on the fact many MPs like having sex with hot young staff members.

Bravo the Greens

I don’t agree with a huge amount of what the Greens do, but one thing they do that deserves praise is their constant willingness to invite and host in New Zealand dissidents from countries who try and pressure us to lower our own standards of freedom of speech, to meet their own.

The Herald reports:

Exiled Chinese Muslim leader Rebiya Kadeer says she wants to “meet with the enemy” during her New Zealand visit.

“Change can only happen when you change the hearts and minds of those who oppose you,” she said as she arrived in Auckland yesterday for a four-day visit. …

China tried to stop Maori TV from screening a Kadeer biopic last month, and despite talks among some Chinese students about staging a protest at the airport yesterday, no one turned up.

“If the Chinese here learn that it is okay to protest peacefully, then they would have learned a valuable lesson about living in a democracy,” Ms Kadeer said.

Meanwhile, following “internal messages of protest” by university staff on the administration’s stopping Ms Kadeer from holding a public meeting on campus, law professor David Williams has invited her to speak at the law faculty at midday instead.

“I hope that university security personnel will not be called upon to prevent the exercise of free speech,” Professor Williams said. “Rebiya Kadeer is the sort of person whose voice needs to be listened to. Her voice should not be silenced in a university.”

Ms Kadeer was once a successful businesswoman in the northwest Xinjiang region but spent six years in jail after speaking out against Beijing.

China regards her as a criminal who orchestrated the ethnic violence in Xinjiang in July that left nearly 200 dead.

It is opposed to countries providing her with a platform to engage in anti-China separatist activities, a charge she rejects.

Her visit, as a guest of the Green Party, will include meetings with human rights groups, a visit to Parliament and meetings with MPs.

I hope that over time, China will realise it should just accept dissidents will criticise them, and stop trying to pressure other countries to silence them. It just results in their message getting more attention – not less.

Air NZ slates IBM

Computerworld has an e-mail from Air NZ CEO Rob Fyfe to his staff:

Air New Zealand chief executive Rob Fyfe has lashed out at IBM in an internal email about yesterday’s mainframe crash that crippled services and disrupted thousands of passengers.

“In my 30-year working career, I am struggling to recall a time where I have seen a supplier so slow to react to a catastrophic system failure such as this and so unwilling to accept responsibility and apologise to its client and its client’s customers,” he says.

“We were left high and dry and this is simply unacceptable. My expectations of IBM were far higher than the amateur results that were delivered yesterday, and I have been left with no option but to ask the IT team to review the full range of options available to us to ensure we have an IT supplier whom we have confidence in and one who understands and is fully committed to our business and the needs of our customers”. …

Air New Zealand outsourced its mainframe to IBM in 1997. Four years later, it also outsourced its mid-range systems to IBM.

The outage was caused by a back-up generator suffering a power failure during a scheduled maintenance check at IBM’s Newton datacentre in Auckland on Sunday morning.

The systems were out for between four and six hours and that is a very long period for an outage.

An IT company I am on the board of has a contractual target of keeping total monthly outages to under 0.1%, or less than 43 minutes per month.

It will be interesting to see what emerges from the meeting between Air NZ and IBM.

Lee’s company may owe $100,000

The NZ Herald reports:

Evidence emerged last night of potentially serious breaches of contract between the television production company of National Party list MP Melissa Lee and funder NZ on Air which could cost the company at least $100,000 in repayments.

The funding organisation’s chief financial officer, Wayne Verhoeven, sent the MP a letter on June 12 outlining what it considered to be breaches of its funding contract through inflating company profits from the contingency fund.

The contract between Asia Vision Ltd and NZ on Air explicitly prohibits the producer making any changes to the agreed contingency budget or the agreed company markup (production company overhead) without the consent of NZ on Air.

Mr Verhoeven’s letter accuses Ms Lee of using money from the contingency budget to increase the markup from 8 per cent to 10 per cent over five series of Asia Downunder.

The five years of contingencies total $100,126.

Last night, Ms Lee described it as “an innocent error”.

She said she had replied to NZ on Air in June but had not yet had a response.

“I have been waiting for them to let me know the outcome.”

Ms Lee told the Herald she had not been aware that the errors had been happening as the finances were handled by the production manager and accountant.

“At a time when there was no increase in funding, the company reduced its profit margins so it could continue making quality television and prudently maintain a contingency fund,” she said.

“This has come as a total surprise. The company wasn’t aware that the money set aside in the contingency was technically expected to be refunded.

“I’m not deeply involved in the day-to-day accounting, but the company’s moved quickly to rectify the problem and will pay back any money deemed to be outstanding.”

The company had amended processes to ensure such an error could not happen again, she said.

“I’d also urge other production companies to seek advice and make sure they comply.”

This issue is quite separate from the false allegations made against Lee before the by-election, but they are cause for concern in their own right.

Normally I would hold a case like this up as an example of the dangers MPs can have in continuing with business activities as an MP, but this actually predates Melissa’s election to Parliament.

Labour released the NZ on Air letter last night.

It had previously complained about Ms Lee’s company while she was National’s candidate in the Mt Albert byelection. NZ on Air cleared her in May of misleading the agency.

The Labour Party says Broadcasting Minister Jonathan Coleman must have known about the letter.

“Unless he fronts up and tells the public what he knows, he could be accused of a cover-up,” Labour deputy leader Annette King told TV3.

Dr Coleman said he had known about it since August 18.

It is unclear whether or not the company does have to pay back $100,000 or not, as at this stage we do not know their response to the response from Lee.

From a political management point of view, this should have been sorted out within weeks, not months, of the issue being raised.

If I was advising Melissa, I would have counselled her to get a final decision from NZ on Air as soon as possible, to repay immediately any money owing (if that was the final decision), and then to do a media release announcing what has happened. You front-foot the issue, rather than wait for the Opposition to discover it.

Now it is still a bit murky, as we are yet to hear from NZ on Air what their final position is, but it certainly is not a good look even on facts known to date.

Aisling Symes found in drain

September 2009 Polls

sep09polls

Curia’s September 2009 public polls newsletter is out. This newsletter is normally only available by e-mail so if you would like to receive future issues, please go to http://listserver.actrix.co.nz/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/polling-newsletter to subscribe yourself.

You can also get more details of individual polls at Curiablog.

As one can see the gap closed considerably in September between National and Labour.

sep09seats

However not a big change in terms of projected seats for each bloc as the Greens have lost support, and ACT has gained support.

UPDATE: Have blogged at Curiablog the Roy Morgan poll out today. Has National at all time high of 57.5% and cocountry heading in right direction also at all time high of 72%.

UK Labour to do asset sales

Reuters reports:

UK Prime Minister Gordon Brown plans to sell off 3 billion pounds (NZ$6.47bn) worth of government assets.

The asset sales will be carried out over the next two years, and include betting company the Tote, the cross-channel rail link between Britain and France, a portfolio of student loans and the government’s stake in uranium-processing firm Urenco.

The bridge and tunnel crossing over the River Thames at Dartford is also up for sale, and local authorities are expected to raise a further 13 billion pounds (NZ$28bn) through asset sales on top of 30 billion pounds (NZ$65bn) already identified in a 2007 report …

What a shame that the British Labour Party will sensibly sell some assets that are better in private hands, and the NZ National Party will not do the same.

The Labour and National consensus to rule out all assets sales, no matter how logical, is the most extreme in the western world.

I do not advocate National breaking its promise not to have asset sales during this term, but they’d better have a more rational policy going into the 2011 election. If Gordon Brown can do it, so can we.

Unemployment

A nice headline in the Herald about how the dole queue has dropped for the first time in around a year. However I would not read too much into it:

  • Firstly the HLFS is the better (and internationally) comparable figure of unemployment as it measures everyone available and looking for work regardless of if they are on the dole.
  • Some of the drop is because of the Government’s subsidies for young people. Now it is great this has got them into work, and off the dole, the effect may not be permanent.
  • There are seasonal issues, and over summer you gets tens of thousands of tertiary students seeking work

So I still expect unemployment to increase in the HLFS in Sep 2009 and Dec 2009 quarters. But maybe things will get better before late 2010.

But Business NZ chief executive Phil O’Reilly said the figure tallied with other evidence that employment might be picking up much sooner than the September quarter of next year, when current economic forecasts predict unemployment will peak at 7.5 to 8 per cent.

“There’s a good possibility of a permanent trend downwards from early next year,” he said.

That would be good.

Council of Trade Unions secretary Peter Conway agreed that the signs were that unemployment would peak sooner than next September and at less than 8 per cent.

He and Mr O’Reilly noted there had been no large-scale closures in the last few months, although there was a risk that some businesses might be forced under by the strength of the dollar.

Let’s just hope the US economy doesn’t implode, causing a W shaped recession.

Liberty Scott on Nobel Peace Prize

Liberty Scott summarises things well:

The best sentiments I’ve noticed on this, is that Morgan Tsvangirai, who had been mooted for the prize, has been imprisoned, tortured, beaten up repeatedly, lost his wife in an accident, and STILL decided for peace in Zimbabwe, to form a joint government with the murdering gangsters of Zanu-PF.

Apparently that wasn’t good enough. Not good enough for an African man in Africa at the front line of essentially civil war and insurrection, in a truly bankrupt economy, to risk himself so much to bring peace and justice to Zimbabwe. He may have been able to do much for Zimbabwe with the US$1 million prize.

But instead it went to Obama for some nice speeches.

I don’t think you can criticise Obama for this. From all accounts he is as mortified as everyone else, and this actually makes his job much harder.

Sensible advice from Dim-Post

Danyl blogs:

Labour’s determination never to form a government with the Greens put the party in a terrible situation. If you want to have an effect on environmental issues you really have to have a place in the government and Clark made it pretty clear that the Green Party would never occupy such a position. This wasn’t a problem for Bradford who doesn’t seem to have any interest in environmental issues and was able to advance her social justice causes through private members bills that she could negotiate on a case by case basis, but a policy of permanent opposition wasn’t viable for the party as a whole.

And this is partly why Fitzsimons and Bradford are retiring. They don’t see a change of Government in 2011 as likely and even if Labour wins in 2014, they might spurn the Greens again. This is somewhat less likely now, considering their preferred partner of NZ First has disappeared from Parliament.

The Greens are always more likely to form a government with Labour but they need to be in a position to realistically threaten to form a government with National before Labour will take them seriously in post-election negotiations.

This is what Bradford doesn’t understand. I have said 100 times over that given a choice between a National-led Government and a Labour-led Government, they will go for a Labour-led Government pretty much everytime.

But they need to keep open the possibility of supporting National, so they can get a better deal from Labour. This is not advice designed to help National – it is advice about how the Greens can stop getting screwed over by Labour.