The tiger death

The death of Dalu Mncube after mauling by a white tiger is sad and tragic, but I also wonder if it was preventable:

Mr Mncube, the righthand-man to Zion’s “Lion Man” Craig Busch, was killed by a male white tiger while cleaning an enclosure with another keeper at the sanctuary near Whangarei, made famous by a television show.

I am somewhat shocked they routinely clean enclosures with the animals in there. I thought they would secure them in one section as they clean.

The tiger is believed to have been 260kg Abu, one of four white tigers at the park, who also attacked keeper Demetri Price in February.

During that attack, Mr Mncube plunged his fingers into Abu’s mouth, then used a fire extinguisher to force the animal to release Mr Price.

So the tiger had previously attacked a keeper, and yet they still did not secure him during cleaning? That sounds almost reckless.

The tiger, one of only 120 white tigers in the world, has been put down and the park has been closed while investigations are under way.

I’m not sure why the tiger was put down? A tiger is not a domestic dog. Tigers attack and kill people – that is their nature. That is why we keep them away from humans. So why is the tiger killed for being a tiger?

Condolences go to family and friends of the deceased.

MPs Pecuniary Interests

The 2009 Register of MPs Pecuniary Interests has been published. Some of the entries I found interesting:

  • Anti-Australian bank campaigner Jim Anderton still has shares in the Commonwealth Bank of Australia.
  • Jacinda Ardern sounds like a young Che with her accommodation in Mexico for the International Union of Socialist Youth (which she chairs) paid for by the Partido de la Revolución Democrática of Mexico.
  • Agriculture Minister David Carter has an extra incentive to have a successful agricultural sector as he has shares in most rural companies.
  • Judith Collins was gifted a Blake Twigden painting.
  • Roger Douglas has shares in most of the NZX50!
  • Attorney-General Chris Finlayson gets royalties from a legal text he wrote (before he was AG).
  • Most of the Green MPs are involved with the Green Futures Superannuation Trust that buy properties in Wellington for them to live in, charging the taxpayer the rent.
  • David Garrett has an interest in a Tongan waste management company.
  • Nathan Guy has around six family trusts.
  • Kevin Hague is involved with Mountain Biking NZ so presumably a big fan of the cycleways.
  • John Key has set up a blind trust.
  • Melissa Lee has interests in three martial arts companies.
  • Paul Quinn has shares in Xero (like me).
  • Heather Roy pays her territorials salary to the RSA.
  • Nick Smith has had some contribution to his legal fees in Osmose v Wakeling & Smith from Parliamentary Service, as approved by the Speaker.

Dim Post on Housing Insulation

Danyl blogs:

I think that the government/Green Party initiative to insulate New Zealand’s housing stock is brilliant both in a general sense in that it will knock tens of billions of dollars off our public health bill over time and in a personal sense in that I’ve recently bought a 1920’s villa and the place is like a fucking deep freeze.

And that’s the mystery. Why have people have been living in this house for 80 to 90 years with no insulation and no proper heating? And why is almost every house in New Zealand like that? I guess it seems normal until you spend a few years living overseas and realise that the rest of the developed world spends winter in relative comfort inside insulated, centrally heated homes.

I agree that in Europe, you never come across a non insulated and centrally heated home – well not often anyway.

It will be interesting to see the exact details tomorrow.

One for the Crusher

The Press reports:

Tough new laws allowing boy racers’ cars to be seized and even crushed for “cruising” city streets are likely to be in force by the end of the year.

Police Minister Judith Collins warned that “every new offence (for street racing) will bring them closer to the crusher”.

Judith got her law!

Yesterday, police welcomed the Government’s move to target illegal street racing, saying two bills introduced to Parliament yesterday would make a “significant difference”.

Under the proposals, authorities will have more power to seize and, as a last resort, crush the cars of boy racers on their third street-racing offence within four years.

Doubt it will result in many cars being crushed but it may have a deterrent value – especially after a second offence.

About 100 crashes a year are attributed to illegal street racing, and the Government says the activity is responsible for an average 10 deaths per year.

Another 46 people are seriously injured by street racing, with a further 125 minor injuries. The social cost of the crashes is estimated at $30 million a year.

That is more than a minor nuisance.

Is there anything the left do not label racist?

The Dom Post reports:

Housing New Zealand is trying to stop people being bailed or paroled to state houses without its permission.

But critics label the move racist and say it will increase poverty while swelling prison inmate numbers.

My theory is peopel call things racist as a way of avoiding intelligent debate on an issue. It is a way of saying only bad racist people can want to do that.

A clause added into new tenancy contracts this month demands that written permission be gained for anyone bailed, paroled or put on home detention at a state house with the exception of those listed on the tenancy agreement and their partners.

So it is not about tenants themselves, or even their partners, but about whether the landlord should have a say in whether someone charged or convicted of a crime should be able to live there.

Housing Minister Phil Heatley said the clause was not about targeting law-breakers but avoiding problems including someone being sent to a state house who might put themselves or the community at risk.

Might stop paedophiles being paroled to a friend’s house near a school. Mind you that should not be up to Housing NZ to stop.

Council for Civil Liberties chairman Michael Bott said the measure was racist, as Maori and Pacific Islanders were the most heavily represented in the court and prison system.

By Bott’s logic increasing prison sentences is racist. Hell even having prisons is racist.

It was an “offensive presumption of guilt” as many on bail were not convicted, and the move would boost prison populations if low-risk inmates were held back from parole.

How many is many? 40%? 35%? 30%? 5%? And as far as I can see this is not about people being refused parole – just Housing NZ having to agree to them living in a state house – I suspect Housing NZ will not be giving blanket nos, but exercising discretion over which property is appropriate.

Rankin Danger

NZPA report that Labour may try and prove Christine Rankin was having an affair with her latest husband, before his wife died:

The Government was challenged in Parliament today to say whether it would remove Christine Rankin from the Families Commission if it turned out she had been lying about rumours swirling around her private life.

Labour leader Phil Goff and two of his MPs, Annette King and Ruth Dyson, raised questions about Ms Rankin’s appointment to the commission.

The appointment was announced a fortnight ago by Social Development Minister Paula Bennett.

It was followed by reports in Sunday newspapers that Ms Rankin was involved in the break-up of the marriage between Wellington real estate agent Margo McAuley and Kim MacIntyre.

Ms McAuley was found dead in October last year. Ms Rankin and Mr MacIntyre were married in January.

Ms Rankin has publicly denied that she was having an affair with Mr MacIntyre at the time of Ms McAuley’s death.

So what exactly did Labour say:

Ms Bennett has said she heard about the rumours before the appointment, checked them out with Ms Rankin and was told they were baseless.

Mr Goff asked Prime Minister John Key what he would do if assurances Ms Rankin had given proved to be untrue.

Mr Key replied: “I can only accept people at their word and I accept the assurances that Christine Rankin gave to the New Zealand public at her word.”

Later, during a debate on the Families Commission, Ms Dyson put a question directly to Ms Bennett.

“I want to give her an opportunity to answer this – will she remove Christine Rankin if it turns out that she has been lying over the last few weeks about allegations that had been made of her?”

Now Labour has obviously had people approach them and say they think (or can prove) Rankin was having an affair with hew now husband.

This is a two-edged sword for Labour. As Rankin has denied any such affair (rather than simply say it was a difficult time for everyone and not go into detail) then it can be seen to be legitimate to raise the issue – as it is now one of honesty, not an affair. And if Rankin has not told the truth, and it can be proved, then her appointment would be threatened – by the lie, not by the alleged affair.

However Labour do risk a backlash that people will shoot the messenger, and resent them if they get up in the House and say “Miss X saw Rankin kiss Mr A at 10 am on this date”. It’s yucky stuff, and it may backfire. I think there has already been a minor backlash with a number of people telling me they hate Rankin, but are appalled at the attacks on her personal life.

Personally I think Labour will try and prove Rankin had an affair – otherwise they would not have had three senior MPs question the Government in teh House about it. My pick is that they will not front it themselves, but leave it for a Sunday newspaper to run with.

Ms King said Ms Bennett had not adequately investigated the rumours about Ms Rankin.

“I know what due diligence is,” Ms King said.

“It’s not a matter of getting on the blower and giving Christine a call and saying ‘what have you been up to, are any of the rumours circulating about you true?’,” Ms King said.

“Due diligence is ensuring that when you’re going to appoint someone to the Families Commission, you do the work.

“And you, minister, didn’t do the work.”

This does cause problems for Bennett. Personally I don’t think Rankin’s personal life affects her suitability to be a part-time Commissioner advocating for policies good for Families. Half the Commisioners are divorced for instance.

But by Rankin denying the affair on TV, she has opened the door to make this an issue about her honesty.

Ms Dyson went on to raise Ms Rankin’s appearance on TV One’s Dancing with the Stars programme.

She said Ms Rankin’s chosen charity for donations from viewers was a trust called For the Sake of our Children.

“The people who texted `Christine’ to Dancing with the Stars were donating to an organisation that employed two people and did no research, no service delivery, but only did advocacy,” Ms Dyson said.

“And the two people employed by For the Sake of our Children were Christine Rankin and her son.

“That is a very unusual charitable organisation where you would go publicly on television and say `I am dancing for a good cause’ – dancing for your own salary.”

I am not sure if the description of the Trust by Ruth Dyson is accurate, but if it is, I would have to agree it is not a good look.

UPDATE: Karl du Fresne has a good column on the Rankin attacks.

Electoral Funding Issues Seminar

There is a seminar in Wellington on Friday for those interested in electoral funding issues. I encourage interested persons to attend. It is from 1 pm to 2 pm so can be done on your lunch break.

Transparency International (NZ), School of Government and the Institute of Policy Studies iInvites you to a seminar presented by Associate Professor Andrew Geddis, Faculty of Law, University of Otago on

The Regulation of Electoral Funding in New Zealand: What are the big issues?

Associate Professor Andrew Geddis teaches at the University of Otago, and has a particular research interest in the field of electoral law. He is the author of Electoral Law in New Zealand: Practice and Policy, as well as numerous articles on the regulation of election funding.

Friday 29 May 2009
1.00 – 2pm
Railway West Wing 501
RSVP to [email protected]

I’ll be there.

Justice Sotomayor

AP reports:

President Barack Obama named federal appeals judge Sonia Sotomayor as the nation’s first Hispanic Supreme Court justice on Tuesday, praising her as “an inspiring woman” with both the intellect and compassion to interpret the Constitution wisely.

Sotomayor is a politically smart choice. She is of course a liberal, but not out on the extreme enough to trigger a fight to the death with conserative opponents.

She has been a Judge for 17 years and was confirmed 68-28 in 1998 to the 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals.

Also demographics of course will play a role. As the first Latino to be nominated to the Supreme Court, Republicans will be wary about blocking her appointment. Plus Obama probably has the numbers to over-ride a filibuster.

If I had to make a guess now, I’d say she’ll go through around 65 – 35.

This is unlikely to be Obama’s only appointment. John Paul Stevens is 89 and Ruth Bader Ginsburg 76.

The Westpac $10 million

Something that has annoyed me about the coverage of the Westpac $10 million error is that Westpac did not accidentally give this couple $10 million. It gave them a $10 million credit facility.

In my mind there is considerable difference between someone finding $10 million in their account and spending it (while still illegal) and someone realizing their credit limit has been set too high, and withdrawing the maximum with no intention of paying it back. The latter is outright fraud.

Do others agree that there is a difference, and that it has not been made very clear?

My first dictionary

Inaugural TAPAS Meeting

We now have a confirmed speaker and date for the first meeting of The US Politics Appreciation Society.

Terry Michael, executive director of the Washington Center for Politics and Journalism, will be speaking upstairs at the Backbencher on the topic: “President Obama’s First 100 Days”. Terry is visiting New Zealand on a speaking tour sponsored by the U.S. Department of State and the U.S. Embassy in Welilngton, whom we thank for their co-operation.

It is from 6.30 pm to 8.00 pm on Wednesday 3 June. Full details are on Facebook and the TAPAS Blog. Note space is limited to 60 people, so first in first confirmed – make sure you RSVP to [email protected].

UNITE, VUWSA and the Workers Party

I blogged on the 15th about how the Workers Party had expelled VUWSA Jasmine Freemantle from their ranks. I quoted:

The WP has tried to argue that I needed to consult with the Party and the Wellington branch before putting forward claims in collective negotiations. While it would be completely inappropriate for any VUWSA President to do such a thing in conjunction with their political party, such actions would be absolutely unprofessional in light of Unite’s relationship with the WP.

Now this sets up a real conflict of interest. Half the executive of the Workers Party are on the UNITE payroll or involved with UNITE. So what you have is UNITE through the Workers Party trying to control both the employee and the employer. The Workers Party basically says that if you are a member and the VUWSA President, you must give in to all the demands from UNITE.

Now since I blogged about this around two weeks ago, I’ve had a number of interesting documents fall my way, including details of the changes that Freemantle is trying to negotiate to the UNITE contract – these changes that are so anti-worker that she has been expelled for.

First of all is requiring consent for annual leave to be sought in writing in advance. My God – how draconian. I mean what is wrong with the employer just working out when you don’t turn up, that you are on annual leave?

Then we have the unlimited sick leave provision. Now this is not just sick leave for yourself. Or for your family members. But also for your pet. Yes unlimited sick leave for you if your pet is sick. So restricting sick leave to seven days a year is obviously just complete fascism.

Then we have the oppressive salaries. The VUWSA contract has automatic salary increases every year. Anyone can rise to the top of the scale – from the accounts clerk to the Salient Distributor.

The proposed top of the scale is $37.04 an hour – a fulltime salary of $72,500. This is not deemed high enough by the Workers Party who called it “Anti-worker and reactionary”. Even someone in their job for just a year, such as the Salient Editor gets $43,800. This may explain the lack of coverage of this issue in Salient 🙂

So the proposed change is that moving up the pay scale be considered as part of a performance review. And this is unacceptable to the Workers Party.

Somewhere in all this we should think of the poor Vic students. They are forced to join VUWSA and hand over $2 million a year to keep it going. They would like to think that they have an Association Executive that actually tries to get value for money out of the staff they fund. But when you have UNITE controlling the Workers Party, and the Workers Party trying to dictate to Executive members what they must agree to (or face expulsion), it is no wonder it is the student who gets done over.

As far as I know, the contract negotiations are stalled. So will UNITE call a strike over the right of staff to have unlimited sick leave for their pets?

The myth of rich white men from Remuera

We hear a lot from Labour about how rich white men from Remuera will dominate the new Auckland Council.

With that in mind, it is interesting to look at the actual representatives from Hobson Ward (so called home to these awful people), thanks to Whale:

In the Hobson ward of Auckland City (that’s where the blue blood barons, dead white males and rich pricks come from) the Community Board is all women and has one Maori (Hinu Te Hau) and two pakeha woman (Desley Simpson) and (Diane Gribben) and one chinese Frieda Yu.

And of course Councillor Aaron Bhatnagar is Indian.

OECD Broadband Stats

The 2008 OECD Broadband stats have mounds of data. To save you opening several dozen spreadsheets, I’ve done it for you. Some interesting aspects:

  1. NZ is one of only four countries that only has data capped broadband. In 16 countries there are no data capped plans at all. And in 10 countries there is a choice of plans with and without data caps.
  2. NZ’s average data cap is 20.3 GB and average cost over that is US$7/GB
  3. The time it takes to reach a data cap at advertised speeds is almost the worst in the world – ranged from 6.8 minutes to reach the monthly cap on Telecom Basic to 25 hours on Woosh.
  4. Our average advertised download speed is 13 Mb/s (actual is a different matter)
  5. 14 countries now have over 1% fibre penetration – we are still on zero.  OECD average is 10% penetration.
  6. NZ had the third highest growth in broadband connections in 2008 – up 3.77 connections per 100 homes.
  7. NZ now in 18th place out of 30 – continuing the gradual improvement from No 23.

2008broadband

This graph shows nicely how far behind we were compared to the OECD average in the early 2000s. And the telecommunication reforms of 2006 have, I believe, been partly responsible for the very significant closing of the gap. However as Australia shows, we still have a fair way to go.

Thorndon

I live in Thorndon. Wonderful place to live. I recall a few months ago a glossy brochure from the Council on how they wanted to help protect Thorndon heritage and protect some homes. It all sounded wonderful.

The nice glossy brochure forgot to mention that:

The council’s preferred heritage proposal would prevent Thorndon residents changing the exteriors of their homes without resource consent, including adding items such as skylights, decks or extra windows, which did not previously need consent.

It may even stop you changing your letterbox I am told!

Public law specialist Chen Palmer criticised the council saying:

It gave “insufficient information” about how current rules were working and did not justify why the proposed changes were necessary.

Its heritage planner had been “unwilling or unable” to discuss other options when asked to.

Oral and written consultation misled people about the impact of the changes.

Too bloody right. I don’t still have the glossy pamphlet but did not gain that impression at all.

Thorndon Residents Association spokeswoman Jo Freeman said many residents favoured a compromise. “As long as it doesn’t affect the streetscape you should be allowed to do whatever you want at the back or the side of your house.”

More red tape could lead to residents, already frustrated by stalled resource consents, abandoning the suburb, she said.

“I’ve had a number of people say, `If it comes in, we will move. We can’t live in our houses with our families the way they are now.’ It could result in a sort of a ghetto in Thorndon.”

Architect and Thorndon resident Roger Walker said he expected any heritage area decision to be challenged in court. In Auckland, blanket rules against demolishing pre-1940 houses in suburbs such as Remuera and Ponsonby were relaxed after a challenge by residents.

The Council is proposing actual zones, rather than identifying individual houses of significant heritage. And we see below what a nightmare they can be:

A Thorndon mother, fighting for two years to restore an 1883 home, says it highlights the pitfalls of protection.

She and her husband bought the house five years ago and plan to revamp it. “It won’t be that modern. We want people to walk into the house … to believe it’s always been like that. We’re just trying to drag it into the 21st century.”

The roof leaks, walls are not insulated, water drips from the bathroom to the kitchen, and light switches “sizzle”. Wellington City Council put a heritage listing on the house two years ago, preventing alterations to the outside till heritage planners approved them.

“It’s emotionally draining. We’ve had to compromise … to the point where the pleasure in doing up the house is gone.”

Delays have been frustrating but the council has charged only the initial resource consent fee. There is also a council heritage fund that can pay for some work.

However, the couple say council planners were inconsistent and delays had cost up to $100,000.

“When we tried to revert the windows to their original 1883 look, one heritage adviser said that would be no problem, but then another came along and … insisted that we keep the 1930s windows.”

They wanted to add windows, and were told they must be different from existing ones.

You can only feel sorry for them.

No 13s in Palmie

Palmerston North is till stuck in the 19th century it seems. The Dom Post reveals that Council policy when numbering sections is to skip No 13 – it goes from 11 to 15.

Decades ago some hotels did not have a 13th floor. But this is the first time I have heard of a ban on 13 still being current policy.

Not that one needed any additional reason not to live in Palmie, but now you have it.

Herald on Catt

The Herald talks to retiring Electoral Commission CEO Helena Catt:

Tomorrow Dr Catt will head off for a more nomadic life of what she describes good-humouredly as “democracy-enhancing activities in the Pacific”.

First stop will be Vanuatu to help run a new civic education programme with the Australian Electoral Commission, largely funded by Australia’s aid agency, AusAid. She will also be working on the professional development of electoral administrators, trying to ensure the electoral processes in Pacific countries are robust enough to reduce reliance on overseas aid – Micronesia is on the list and Timor, probably in August.

A nice time to be in the Pacific 🙂

Her five years at the Electoral Commission spanned two of the more volatile elections in recent history.

The first, in 2005, involved the Exclusive Brethren and the Auditor-General later ruling some party spending of public money unlawful. That, combined with ongoing disquiet about anonymous donations and donations being squirrelled away in trusts led to the Electoral Finance Act in 2007.

It was at this point that Dr Catt became more widely known than electoral agency heads usually are after going public with concerns about the new law – rare for a public servant.

Dr Catt spoke out while the EFB was before Parliament still, and made the point that they would not know how to interpret parts of the proposed law, especially around the exemption for spending for parliamentary purposes as that had never been defined.

Labour’s problem was they were trying to legalise their pledge card and exempt it as an expense, but they did not wish to clearly state that in the law for fear of the backlash. So they left it undefined and had then Justice Minister Annette King give contradictory speeches as to what she thought it means. It was a farce.

Dr Catt said she spoke out because “it had to be said”.

It left her slightly battle scarred and was one of the reasons she decided not to remain.

Heh. Whle the 2011 election should be less trouble than 2008, the mere fact there will be a new set of rules will make it somewhat challenging.

State funding of political parties

The Herald reports:

Prime Minister John Key says he is “not completely closed” to the prospect of using more public funding to run political parties and their campaigns – an apparent softening of National’s vehement opposition to such suggestions in the past.

The question of public funding of parties is one of the central issues of a review of electoral finance law to find a replacement to the now repealed Electoral Finance Act.

First of all, I would not read too much into this. As state funding is within the terms of consultation on electoral financing, he is not ruling it out in advance. This is a good thing as it means the consultation is not a sham.

But it should ring some small warning bells. If you are oppossed to further state funding of parties, then don’t rely on MPs to be against it. Have you say. I will blog next week some further encouragement on this.

Currently, the only state funding for party campaigns is about $3 million in broadcasting allocation to registered parties for election advertising on television and radio.

That is the only direct funding. But parties also gain considerable indirect benefits from being in Parliament – they gain budgets, staff, travel for MPs etc etc. Now this is for parliamentary purposes and I do not advocate it should be reduced. But I think one should recognise there is a political benefit also from this funding. Bryce Edwards will comment no doubt in more detail on this.

If there is a case for taxpayer funding, my inclinations are that it should go to the small parties not in Parliament, to give them an opportunity to have their voices heard at election time. I don’t see a case for giving more money to parliamentary parties that already have a huge advantage over parties not in Parliament.

Green Party co-leader Russel Norman said his party supported at least partial public funding and limits on how much one donor could donate to ensure parties were not dependent on a few wealthy donors.

This excuse holds little sway with me. So long as one has transparency, you can see if a party is dependent on a few wealthy donors and voters can judge that party accordingly. What Noram advocates will actually led to a US style dirty money system where donation limits leads to less transparency as donations go into third parties, or major donors become recruiters of other donors instead. Transparency and simplicity are far preferable that the US system of dirty money that Norman advocates (even if he doesn’t realise that is what he advocates).

It said supporters believed it would limit “actual or perceived corruption or inappropriate influence” because parties would not be as dependent on private donors. It would also help ensure an even playing field for parties whose supporters were not wealthy.

Why stop at an even playing field on wealth. How about time? It is unfair that some parties have supporters who are too busy to volunteer at much time. We shoud have the state force everyone to volunteer the same amount of time to a party to keep it equal.

Also it is unfair some parties have more members than other parties. Who should Labour with 8,000 members get less money than National with close to 40,000?

Many countries where parties do get money from the taxpayer have tighter restrictions on donations, including limiting the amount one person can give and prohibiting donations from corporations and trade unions.

The problem with this, is that most union support is in staff time – not money. During an election campaign hundreds of union staff are unofficially given time off to campaign for Labour and sometimes the Greens. They put up hoardings, supply union vehicles, deliver, door knock etc.

Shameful behaviour

We are seeing the nasty side of certain people come out in the by-election at student hosted meetings. The Herald reports on the Unitec meeting:

Act candidate John Boscawen was accosted with a chocolate and cream lamington as a Mt Albert byelection debate yesterday descended into farce.

Malcolm France, a candidate for People Before Profit, attacked Mr Boscawen with the cake as a protest against the Super City.

That’s just pathethic – and even more so that it was done by another candidate. France should be banned from all future MTC meetings.

The blunder-prone National candidate Melissa Lee also came under fire. She faced questions over an email in which she was alleged to have said she wanted “a big diamond ring … to knock some sense into the media (although a gun is tempting)”.

The email was a response to a question posed by a magazine, which asked: “Which accessory would you choose: a gun, a fur coat, a big diamond ring or a grill?” Ms Lee said the email was written by a volunteer staff member who wanted to add some humour.

How that made the TV news last night, I don’t know.

In response to a question about what she would do if she wasn’t in politics, the mainly Polynesian group shouted that she would be “on a plane back to Korea” and she could “become the racist relations commissioner”.

I think this shows very clearly who the true racists are.

Bye bye to Obesity Action Coalition

The Herald reports:

The Government has lopped another limb off Labour’s “bureaucratic” public health tree, ending state funding for the Obesity Action Coalition.

This is excellent news. Labour often funded groups which then in turn lobbied Parliament and the Government on social issues – despite this being something the Auditor-General had warned against.

When we talk about state funding of political parties, we should also look at state funding of lobby groups.

The Herald does a summary:

Gone or going:

* Funding of Obesity Action Coalition.
* District health board staff who help schools with nutrition policy.
* Rule that only healthy food and drink be sold at schools.
* Labour’s plans to control food industry recipes.

Staying or coming:

* Promotion of healthy food at schools.
* New physical activity scheme for schools.

Excellent. Far too much time is spent trying to ban food or food advertising, and not enough promoting exercise.

Anyway let us look at what the Obesity Action Coalition has been doing.

On its website it is promoting and linking to the Greens petition to being ban the tuckshop food police. So the Government has been funding a lobby group to argue against Government policy. I repeat lobby groups should not be state funded.

And they have many reports. Take this report on Pacific Island obesity.  One of their recommendations is:

Banning access to and advertising of foods high in fat, salt and sugar

Banning advertising is bad enough, but banning access to certain foods!!!

And look at this press release on how public policy should be set:

OAC Executive Director Leigh Sturgiss told the committee the public health workforce uses a tool called the “scream test”. “The likely success of a proposed measure is gauged by the degree to which the affected industries protest. If there is no “scream”, chances are the proposed measure will be ineffective. The tobacco industry and its allies used to scream a lot, and now the fast food industry and its allies are screaming as well,” Ms Sturgiss said.

So their aim is to make affected industries scream loudly. So much for weighing up costs and benefits.

If the public health workforce really do use a “scream test” then I think the Government should use a “scream test” on the public health workforce. This is a good start.

Pseudoephedrine

The Herald reports:

Prime Minister John Key is proposing to combat the drug P by banning its main ingredient, pseudoephedrine, from use in over-the-counter cold and flu tablets.

Mr Key’s first task for his chief science adviser, Professor Peter Gluckman, is to investigate “whether it is possible for New Zealand to eliminate pseudoephedrine in the making of cold and flu tablets”.

Mr Key said he was surprised by the amount of methamphetamine – known as P – being made from locally obtained pseudoephedrine.

I’d have no idea about how important pseudoephedrine is in cold and flu tablets, but sounds like an ideal first issue for the Chief Science Adviser.

The pseudoephedrine ban Mr Key is considering would supersede the much-discussed option of a national computer register that would alert police to suspicious cold and flu tablet purchases.

Police support such a register, but no progress has been made despite almost 10 years of discussions.

But many committee meetings no doubt!

Pharmacy Guild chief executive Annabel Young said the alternatives to pseudoephedrine were not nearly as effective in dealing with cold symptoms.

She said much of the locally produced methamphetamine was made from Contac NT smuggled in from China and restricting access to over-the-counter pseudoephedrine products would not stop this.

But Gisborne pharmacist David Moore, who refuses to stock pseudoephedrine, gave the Herald a list of 11 tablets using alternative ingredients such as phenyleprine that he said were just as effective.

No surprise there is a difference in views – otherwise no need to have the CSA investigate and report on it.

Scum

There is something about cruelty to animals and children that just makes my skin crawl when I read about it. The Herald reports:

An 18-year-old has been jailed for two years after dragging a goat tied to the back of his car along the road until it died.

Kurt Sharp, 18, pleaded guilty to a charge of wilful ill-treatment of an animal causing death, as well as a raft of burglary charges.

Judge Roy Wade, in the Pukekohe District Court yesterday, sentenced Sharp to two years’ imprisonment. He said that a lighter sentence of home detention would send the wrong message.

Sharp tethered the goat to the towbar of a car in Waiuku, forcing it to run behind it. When the goat could no longer run, the animal was dragged behind the vehicle for about 2km.

What scum. I’m glad he got a jail sentence,not home detention.