Antonie Dixon is dead

Antonie Dixon, most known as the samurai sword attacker, is dead. He died in his cell in Paremoremo Prison from head and neck injuries, that have been reported as self-inflicted.

Not all killers are beyond redemption, but I think Dixon was one who would have always been a threat to society. Hence I can’t say I shed any tears at his suicide. It may allow his victims to not worry about his possible release one day.

A legal perspective on Fiji

Stephen Franks blogs on a column by Richard Fowler, the President of the Wellington District Law Society, regarding Fiji. Fowler has just returned from there and quotes Fowler:

Yet I am afraid that nothing about the present Fijian situation as outlined to me was that simple – particularly for Rule of Law type issues. I am no apologist for the 2006 coup but there are certainly some very odd aspects to the situation that do not sit easily with the abovementioned ’simple’ analysis. There is even a ‘back to front’ quality to much of it. The best I can do is pose for you the questions that started worrying me:

If Commodore Bainimarama was the counter-coup hero who removed George Speight in 2000, installed Quarase as interim Prime Minister, and then went back to his barracks rather like a latter day Garibaldi, what caused him to re-emerge and, for that matter so different from the previous coups, at glacial speed?

Why does the Labour party representing over 40% of the population and supported by most of the Fijian Indians, the people most obviously and adversely disenfranchised in the previous coups of 1987 and 2000, give some support to the interim government and even for a period participated in its cabinet?

I have to say that every Fijian Indian taxi driver I have had in the last couple of months has been 100% supportive of the coup, and saying how the NZ Government does not understand the situation.

Fowler goes on:

Contrary to what was suggested concerning a pervasive military presence in the New Zealand newspapers recently, in the whole of the week I was in Suva I never caught sight of one soldier and further the interim government during that week lost a very public Court challenge to the legitimacy of some of its actions and did not reach for extra-legal remedy.

Indeed, the Fijian Government has lost a considerable number of cases.

Who could blame the Fiji Law Society for cutting the interim government some slack in the light of the latter’s avowed intent to achieve a fairer electoral system that is not racially slanted in lieu of holding an election now which would just have the effect of perpetuating the old one? At what point does the Fiji Law Society cease to do so – because sooner or later the Commodore has to demonstrate meaningful progress? And where would that leave the participation of the Fiji Law Society up to that point?

I held my peace and boarded the plane thankful that no law society in New Zealand has ever had to face the issues the Fiji Law Society is facing.

I am one that supports Fiji not having a race based constitution, that marginalises one particular race. But that doesn’t mean the ends justify the means, and the Commodore should have stood for election on the grounds of changing it, not done a coup.

However the coup is now a reality, and the end game is going back to democracy. And as I said, I have no problems with holding a referendum on a new constitution first, and then elections.

But the problem is the Commodore is unable or unwilling to give any sort of timetable, to which he will be accountable. The longer it goes on, the more you suspect he will never give up power.

The challlenge for the Commodore is to turn rhetoric into reality and actually take steps towards elections. If he does so, then he will no doubt find sanctions start to get lifted. But if he doesn’t produce a timetable, then people will assume it is all about retaining power, not about changing the constitution.

Google’s Latitude

I’ve blogged many times over the last few years about how a future killer application will be one that combines GPS, mapping and friend finder on your phone.

As the Daily Telegraph reports, Google has launched such a service. It is called Google Latitude. It works for New Zealand, and you can download it onto your blackberry and other phones. Only problem is a download error code 500 at the moment.

There are huge privacy issues around such services. They key is to only let people see your location who you totally trust. But it can be an easy way of meeting up in town etc. I’ll blog more on this once I actually get it installed and working.

Labour MP to be sued for laziness

The Daily Telegraph reports that an 84 year old man  is suing UK Labour MP Ann Keen for laziness, saying she breached her “duty of care” to a constituent.

Imagine the precedent that would set if he won. I can imagine a few nervous MPs in New Zealand 🙂

January murders

Steve Pierson at The Standard is happy and celebrating because he was worried that either myself or Whale Oil would post how since the change of Government there were no murders in January, and contrast this with the last two Januarys.

I have to say I have better things to do than monitor the homicide rate on a daily basis, let alone claim it somehow magically changes with an election (I think overall offending rates can change with a change in policies, in society, in the economy etc, but not merely an election).

Incidentally the homicide rate only really got politicised after Annette King’s brain fart when she blamed it on the sun and the moon. That was worth mocking.

But what really amuses me is how worried Steve was by the thought that such a link would be made, because January homicides were so low. Was he listening to the TV news every night thinking “Oh no, zero murders so far in 2009. This is awful. DPF and Whale may do a post about the lack of murders since the election.”

Well just as Steve congratulated me for not doing a post on the lack of murders and trying to claim it was linked to the election, I’d like to congratulate Steve for resisting the urge to personally intervene to increase the homicide rate, just to prevent us from being able to post on how low it has been  🙂

Auction hits $20,000

The John Key cast and morning tea auction hit an amazing $20,000 at 1 am this morning.

There have been 202 bids and what has amazed me is how many different people are bidding, even after it hit $10,000.  This suggests to me it may get quite busy in the last few hours on Sunday.

The number of questions on the auction are in the hundreds and there have been almost 100,000 page views of it. I feel sorry for John’s staff who were up until midnight doing responses to questions.

Incidentally if you want want to support the good work done by the Fred Hollows Foundation but $20,000 is out of your price range, you can donate directly to them here.

DHB Chairs

The Herald reports the resignation of the Waitameta DHB Chair, Kay McKelvie and notes she is:

A sister of Helen Clark’s right-hand woman in Auckland, Joan Caulfield, Mrs McKelvie was close to the Labour-led Government and until now has kept silent on funding, even when her chief executives have spoken out.

People will make up their own minds about the timing of the resignation over “funding issues”.

But the links to Labour, may explain another DHB issue. I’ve been baffled by why Labour is campaigning so strongly for the Otago DHB Chair not to resign, despite being Chair for over 80% of the time the $17 million fraud occured.

Then someone told me that the Otago DHB Chair, Richard Thomson, is also very close to Labour. In fact it was suggested that he was once Pete Hodgson’s Campaign Chair. This would explain Mr Hodgson’s spirited advocacy on his behalf.

Poor Electoral Commission

You have to feel sorry for the Electoral Commission. Not only have they had to cope with the Electoral Finance Act, but today on One News we hear Energy Minister Gerry Brownlee was unhappy with them over the power outages in Auckland.

Did TVNZ possibly mean the Electricty Commision, not the Electoral Commision?

Kevin Rudd’s Big Bang package

Colin Espiner seems impressed with Kevin Rudd’s big bang package of NZ$53 billion.

Yesterday Rudd threw the kitchen sink at the Australian economy, spending a whopping NZ$53 billion on everything from schools to home insulation to road repairs to tax breaks for businesses. Hell, he even doled out $12.7 billion in one-off cash bonuses for struggling low-income families.

It should be noted that Kevin Rudd had a healthy surplus. Michael Cullen left Bill English a decade of huge deficits. But also the Rudd approach is not without critics. The Asian Wall Street Journal notes:

From Washington to Tokyo to London, politicians the world over are using the global financial crisis as cover to extend their powers. In Australia, Prime Minister Kevin Rudd is taking that tack a step further — he’s manufacturing a philosophy to justify his actions.

In an essay published in the February issue of the Monthly magazine, Mr. Rudd lays out his vision for “social capitalism”; a kind of halfway house between what he calls “extreme capitalism” and “an all-providing state.” “Whatever the nomenclature,” he writes, “the concept is clear: a system of open markets, unambiguously regulated by an activist state, and one in which the state intervenes to reduce the greater inequalities that competitive markets will inevitably generate.”

This is just the usual Rudd spin, or another name for Blair’s so called third way.

This is a vision for a greatly expanded state cloaked under the rubric of “free markets,” one in which Canberra would decide what inequalities were worth smoothing out and which ones weren’t. Australia had that model once; it was called the Gough Whitlam government. In the 1970s, Mr. Whitlam nationalized health and higher education, hiked public-sector wages, increased government spending and pandered to labor unions, a key Labor Party constituency. The result was one of the worst recessions in Australia’s modern history.

That’s why the Labor Party — the same Labor Party that Mr. Rudd belongs to — embraced truly free markets, trade liberalization and deregulation in the 1980s and 1990s. Those reforms underpinned 17 consecutive years of economic expansion.

Indeed the Australian Labor Party under Hawke and Keating did many good things. And Rudd’s record to date hasn’t been too bad – but he seems to be panicking.

Mr. Rudd makes only a passing reference to this record, acknowledging the Bob Hawke and Paul Keating Labor governments’ “ambitious and unapologetic program of economic modernization.” He goes further: “Neo-liberalism, and the free-market fundamentalism it has produced, has been revealed as little more than personal greed dressed up as an economic philosophy,” he writes. This is a far cry from the economic conservatism for which Mr. Rudd was elected in 2007.

Indeed, you never heard that on the campaign trail from him.

In his essay, Mr. Rudd uses the global financial crisis as a cover to attack his political opponents and talk up his own recent record. The opposition Liberal Party, Mr. Rudd writes, is “the political home of neo-liberalism in Australia” and bears blame for the current financial crisis, while Labor “has acted decisively through state action to maintain the stability of the Australian financial system.”

The irony is that Australia was better prepared to deal with the financial crisis because of its long record of liberalization and sound regulatory oversight. Australia wasn’t hit by a slew of subprime mortgage defaults or bank runs. Its problems came courtesy of muddled government interventions on foreign shores. Mr. Rudd’s Labor government reacted by guaranteeing bank deposits at taxpayer expense, banning short selling and proposing huge public spending programs.

The reason Kevin has so much money to spend now, is because unlike in NZ, he inherited a healthy economy. The bank deposit guarantee is not one I agree with the WSJ on, as almost all countries have been forced into that as a least worst option. As for increased spending – it depends on what the spending is for. Bringing forward infrastructure spending is desirable. Borrowing money to give cash handouts is not.

Milton Friedman once wrote: “What most people really object to when they object to a free market is that it is so hard for them to shape it to their own will.” It’s not necessary to read between the lines of Mr. Rudd’s essay to understand that that’s what’s going on here.

Very astute.

Spin

I’m not picking on Telecom, but their press release this morning is a good example of “spin” which was the oppsoite of Vodafone’s refeshingly clear “We stuffed up, you hate the change” release I highlighted.

I got a tip off last night that the staff in the broadband helpdesk were all notified of a meeting at 8.30 am this morning. They were even told that they would be paid if they were not rostered on, to attend the meeting. This suggested that it was to be a meeting to announce redundancies as their helpdesk would be trasnferred to the Philipines.

So when I saw the press release this morning headlined “Telecom to retain its largest contact centre in NZ following extensive trials”, I thought maybe I had guessed wrong. It sounds like good news.

But no, if you go all the way down to paragraph ten, you get the details that the broadband helpdesk is indeed moving to Manila.

Now, I am not criticising the decison per se. Its awful for the affected employees who have my sympathy. But it seems the offshore call centre was getting higher satisfaction ratings than the NZ one. If you are getting better quality, and for lower cost, then it is an almost inevitable decision.

My criticism is just not being upfront in the press release at the beginning. Trying to sugarcoat the 250 job losses in NZ, by proclaiming all the jobs you are not moving offshore is not helpful. Did you think the media would be fooled and not mention the job losses because they were not in the headline? Look at the Dom Post headline.

Audrey on National’s Women

Audrey Young blogs on National’s women making a mark. She even gives them names that they could use in the WWE:

  • Crusher Collins
  • Tolley the Terminator
  • Bruiser Bennett

Audrey talks about Judith:

Police Minister Judith Collins has been dubbed Crusher Collins since she touched a popular nerve with her desire to crush the cars of the criminal boy racers and make them watch.

You can tell she relishes even uttering the words.

She will also have wide support for her aim as Corrections Minister to spend a lot less on building prisons, perhaps prefabricated buildings on existing sites.

Huge support I would say.

But Collins has also showed she is not one-dimensional. She did the right thing in visiting early the grieving family of Halatau Naitoko who was accidently slain by a police bullet and publicly showed the sort of sensitivity the situation demanded of her.

But not a caricature.

The Pope’s reinstated Holocaust Denying Bishop

German Chancellor Angela Merkel joins the long iist of people criticising Pope Benedict’s decision to reinstate the Holocaust-denying bishop Richard Williamson to the fold.

It is an appalling decision. Bishop Williamson is a fully fledged anti-semite. Some examples:

  • believes the Protocols of the Elders of Zion are accurate
  • Jews are aiming for world domination
  • the Holocuast never happened says “There was not one Jew killed by the gas chambers. It was all lies, lies, lies!”
  • The Sept 11 attacks were an inside job
  • Has been a guest of David Irving’s
  • Says that Stalin, not Hitler, was to blame for WWII
  • Talks of Jews preparing the Anti-Christ’s throne in Jerusalem
  • Says Jews used the Holocaust lies to extort money from the German Government

The Bishop has expressed regret for the controversy, but has not retracted any of his statements. Oh, he also believes girls should not go to university saying “true universities are for ideas, ideas are not for true girls, so true universities are not for true girls”.

The Pope is from Germany himself. He saw the horrors of Hitler as a young boy, forced into the Hitler Youth against his will. It is incredibly disappointing that he can not see how offensive his acceptance of Bishop Williamson back into the Church is. The signal it sends is that the Roman Catholic Church condones anti-semitism, even if this is not the case.

Previewing Waitangi Day

AUT History Professor Paul Moon previews Waitangi Day:

Few people will miss the bad old days, when our national day was punctured by protests, revealing one of the less edifying sides of our country’s character.

Much of the new calmness that has descended on Waitangi Day can be attributed to John Key who, as Prime Minister-in-waiting, allayed fears about how a National Government would deal with Maori issues in general and who, on being elected, followed through with his commitment to inclusion by inviting the Maori Party to have a role in his administration.

It is due to this expected calm, that Taiuni’s Maori King is attending for the first time.

So now that the new age of co-operation has dawned, what is the future for the Treaty? The Government has made it clear that it is dedicated to a deadline for resolving historical claims, and so it is time to start looking to a post-Waitangi Tribunal era for the Treaty.

There will be some losers in this. A coterie of lawyers – fleshy-lipped from years of sucking healthy fees from the claims process – will be left looking elsewhere for sources of income. But it is unlikely that many people will evince much sympathy at their plight.

Personally I think 2014 to settle all outstanding claims may be overly ambitious, and won’t be surprised if it stretches out a bit beyond that. But I do expect that finally all claims will be settled between say 1990 and 2020.

The next challenge will be in considering whether the Treaty belongs in some formal constitution that will no doubt be devised in the next few decades (can I hear the sound of lawyers again rubbing their hands?).

This is a much more complex issue than it sounds, though. The Treaty of Waitangi was an agreement between two sovereign nations, and was not initially intended to serve as an internal constitutional document.

This is a critical point. It was, well a Treaty, not a constitution designed to be supreme law.  A constitution has to be voted on (well maybe not in Fiji but here) and accepted by either a super-majority of Parliament or by the people at large.

Someone once suggested that if you look at the United States, our Treaty of Waitangi is more akin to the Declaration of Independence (which has no legal standing) than the Constutition and Bill of Rights. The Declaration of Independence is an important founding document, but there is no constitutional right to the pursuit of happiness 🙂

Not that I am against any Constitution for NZ possibly having some recognition of the Treaty, but that is very different from just declaring the Treaty as part of the supreme law.

The SME package

National has announced a half billion package (0ver four years) of policies to help small and medium sized businesses, during the economic downturn.

There are five parts:

  1. a suite of 11 tax changes costing $480 million
  2. an expansion to the export credit scheme
  3. extended jurisdiction for the Disputes Tribunal
  4. expansion of business advice services
  5. a prompt-payment requirement for government agencies.

The tax changes are:

  1. removing the 5% increase in provisional tax over the previous year
  2. reducing the use of money interest rate for underpayments by 4.5%
  3. threshold for GST payments method (instead of accrual) to increase by over 50% from $1.3 to $2.0 million
  4. threshold for GST registration to increase by 50% from $40,000 to $60,000
  5. legal expenses of under $10,000 can now be fully expensed in the year incurred, not capitalised
  6. increase in threshold for montly PAYE filing increases from $100,ooo to $500,000
  7. FBT annual filing threshold raised to $500,000 from $100,000.
  8. value of minor fringe benefits to employees without attracting FBT will increase to $300 a quarter per employee from $200, and $22,500 a year per employer from $15,000
  9. FBT prescribed interest rate for low-interest, employment-related loans will fall from 10.90% to 8.05%.
  10. some other thresholds for accrual expenditure adjustments will also be increased.
  11. certain SME tax simplification measures that are part of a bill now before Parliament will be fast-tracked.

Other significant changes are a doubling from $7,500 to $15,000 the value of any disputes before the Disputes Tribunal, which saves having to go to District Court. Also the Government has instructed all Departments to pay their bills no later than the 20th of the month following receipt of invoice.

Also good is the New Zealand Export Credit Office (NZECO) will provide short-term trade credit insurance for exporters, as the lack of such credit insurance could have seem some exporters having to turn down orders.

There is no silver bullet amongst the changes announced, but that is because there is no magical cure. One just has to keep working away at making things better. This is why reform is not a one off thing you do, but is continual.

Quiz of the Day

Top ten debates

The Herald lists the top ten debates of the last decade. They call them as:

  1. Seabed and foreshore
  2. GE food
  3. Rugby Word Cup post-mortems
  4. Civil Union Bill
  5. Anti-smacking law
  6. Smoking ban in bars etc
  7. NCEA introduction
  8. Auckland Waterfront Stadium proposal
  9. Ahmed Zaoui detention
  10. Urerewa Terror Raids

I’m pretty staggered they did not list the debate triggered off by Don Brash’s Orewa speech. I would say that got talked about more in homes and workplaces than any other issue on that list, except the anti-smacking law possibly.

Predictions on media over next decade

As part of their series on ten years of Herald online, a number of media industry people look at the next ten years:

Bill Ralston – Media commentator, radio host
Everyone goes on about the death of traditional media, but the market’s a really interesting thing, it expands and contracts. Very seldom do you see one form kill off another. Everyone’s concentrating on digital – it’s slowly making more inroads into advertising. But it’s not going to kill papers, it won’t cut the throat of radio. TV didn’t kill radio or movies. They all changed and adapted. Everyone jostles around a bit, squeezes up together and continues to make a living.

I am a bit more pessimistic over print media. As Bill later says there are opportunities from this digital age, but I think advertising is going to move more and more online. In the US classified ads have almost died, and Trade Me has sluaghtered a lot of print advertising in NZ. Also online advertising can give advertisers so much more precise information – such as how many people saw an ad, clicked on it, what their demographic profile is etc etc.

Dr Martin Hirst – AUT associate professor, journalism curriculum leader
People talk about the death of newspapers all the time. I would think we have another ten years of newspapers. Journalism will continue in one form or another. I’m not sure if online media are a replacement for newspapers and TV and radio. Online media tends to be a replication of other media, a mirror or extension of their newspaper outlets, not a replacement. Whether this will continue in the future is debatable.

I certainly agree newspapers are still here in ten years. But in thirty? Not so sure.

John Campbell – Television presenter
The problem with television is that it’s expensive to make. We will see a preponderance of niche communications, something for everyone, whether you’re a macrobiotic vegan or Canterbury supporter. And where you’ll find it is online.

How can a construct of broadcasting, born of one channel, reinvent itself in an utterly fragmented market where people have so much choice? How do we survive within that market? That comes down to everyone’s ability to connect with an audience, an audience which has so much choice.

Very astute words from Mr Campbell. The market is fragmented and with PVRs, the emphasis is going on programmes not channels.

Copyright is another thing to consider – I could do a story at 7pm and it could be on YouTube five minutes later. How do we enforce that, do we want to worry about it, what do we do about it? As a rule of thumb I can’t take other people’s work and take it to air. YouTube rides roughshod over all those notions.

But it will also normally be on the TV3 site that evening also, so what is the problem? If it is lack of advertising revenue because it is on You Tube not TV3 site, I think one solution might be for TV channels to embed ads in their online content and stick it on You Tube themselves.

Eric Kearley – General manager, digital services, TVNZ
In the next ten years storage space on home devices is going to increase drastically, and bandwidth prices will decrease. These two in combination will see much more content available on demand.

Yes, yes, yes. You want to see episodes 1 to 6 of MASH, you just push the button and a minute later episode one at least is ready to go.

Herald on RMA reform

The Herald Editorial proclaims:

John Key said the recession added fresh urgency to the need for changes. In reality, however, these were overdue whatever the economic climate. In the 18 years since its well-intentioned introduction, the act has struggled to be a credible vehicle for genuinely sustainable resource use. Most fundamentally, the mechanisms for issuing consents have been too easily abused. Commercial rivals have used them to handicap competitors by lodging objections, neighbours have settled scores by refusing to consent to housing extensions and suchlike, and too many developers have been at the mercy of rival claimants to tangata whenua status and been charged excessive consultation fees. The upshot in all instances has been unacceptable costs and delays.

We have effectively flushed hundreds of millions of dollars down the drain due to consenting delays.

But, in one respect, Mr Key’s hands have been tied. Notably absent is a proposal to remove references to the Treaty of Waitangi and Maori cultural and spiritual values. It was part of National’s election manifesto but has fallen foul of the new relationship with the Maori Party. Now, somewhat lamely, the Government says the dropping of the Treaty clause has been rendered unnecessary by case law and improved practices.

Welcome to MMP. The jury will be out on this issue, until we see some cases under the revised law. If projects still face significant delays because of arguments over the “life-force” of a river, I won’t be too impressed.

Already, however, the Government has ventured into areas that its green-tinged predecessor would have avoided. In the main, it has trod carefully. In quick time, it has arrived at a better balanced and more consistent Resource Management Act.

It is all about balance, and I think the changes will have a significant impact on our economic growth – especially with the looming infrastructure spending.

Iran’s space programme

A challenge

  1. Go read Phil Goff’s press release on National’s RMA changes
  2. Then decide whether or not Labour is for or against the said RMA changes.
  3. You may repeat step 1 as many times as you like, but you may find it doesn’t help you.
  4. Then state in the comments whether or not you think they are for or against.

Maybe Phil is intending to do a John Kerry – and be both against and for it!

Maori Seats debate at Te Papa

Florence from Te Papa has commented on the constitutional issues thread:

Since the Maori seats are part of the listed constitutional issues, I thought you might be interested by this event we’re organising at Te Papa: on Thursday 5 February, 6.30-8pm, we’re having a debate between Professor Philip Joseph and Derek Fox about the future of Maori seats in Parliament.

This will be webcast live from Te Papa’s website, so anybody can watch it. We’ll also allow people to ask their questions through our blog, by email or via a live chat.

So join us on Thursday, we really want to hear from anybody who’s interested in this subject.
http://www.tepapa.govt.nz/treatydebates

That’s great it is online, and allows online questions and feedback. Plus you can attend in person for free. I plan to listen online.

Police not to prosecute Anderton

NBR reports that the Police are not prosecuting Jim Anderton for breaches of the Electoral Finance Act, despite a referral from the Electoral Commision. Naturally Jim has concluded that this means the Electoral Commission were wrong:

Progressive leader Jim Anderton has criticised the Electoral Commission for referring a complaint that he breached the Electoral Finance Act (EFA) to the police.

Mr Anderton said today that the police had written to him advising that there had been no breach of the EFA. …

Mr Anderton said the complaint was frivolous and a waste of police time.

He accused the commission of taking a cavalier attitude.

“The decision to refer these complaints just before the election, when even the most cursory examination should have shown no offence had been committed, showed poor judgement,” Mr Anderton said.

Actually the Electoral Commission set out a very detailed case as to why they beleived Anderton had breached the Act – he was using taxpayer resources to send out unauthorised material with the Progressives campaign slogan on it.

The fact the Police are not prosecuting is of no surprise. The history of the Police with electoral law enforcement is rather woeful.

Trades on Trade Me

Some puerile sorts have got all excited I understand with my trade history on Trade Me, and a contact tells me have started e-mailing it about.

How pathethic.

I know one’s Trade Me history is public, if people know your username and my one is no surprise – I’ve even linked to my feedback page for those who can’t guess it. If people get excited that *six* years ago I purchased some FHM magazines, then it says a lot about them.