Key mulls diplomatic posting for Clark

Stuff has an NZPA story on Key and Clark:

Asked today if he would offer her a diplomatic post, Mr Key said it was an option.

“Look I think if that was a step she wanted to take that would definitely be a live option,” he said on TVNZ’s Breakfast programme.

“But at this point I think she is just taking stock of what she wants to do – gathering her own thoughts – including about what she might want that to be.”

Well, ok I can understand wanting to get the predecessor out of the country, but do we really need an Ambassador to Rwanda?

Actually I do understand Foreign Minister Murray McCully has supplied a list of suitable countries for MFAT to vet as appropriate for Ambassador Clark.

NZPA on Labour

TV3 has an opinion piece from NZPA on Labour that is good reading:

Labour MPs aren’t saying it, but they must be thinking it: this year’s election wasn’t a bad one to lose.

If the results had been different, and if Labour had managed to stitch together a majority, it would have been a fourth term government facing the worst economic crisis in decades with the Greens, New Zealand First and possibly the Maori Party on its back.

Tax cuts would have been cancelled by now, but even with that Labour would have huge problems if it had won. The Greens and NZ First only care about spending more money – their idea of success is how much money they got for a project. I can only imagine how bad the deficit and debt would have got.

Also in for the chop is what English calls the previous government’s wish-list of unfunded projects, like pouring millions into KiwiRail. That caused cries of outrage from Labour, as have other cost-cutting announcements, but they must know that if they were still in office the calls they would have had to make would be just as hard.

How Labour handles the situation in the next year or two will be important in terms of public perception. With the country in crisis, it needs to do more than groan and grizzle every time the Government says something can’t be afforded.

If it demands a plan from the Government that adapts to a worsening situation, it must produce its own blueprint for economic survival.

If the Government says it has to cut funding and Labour doesn’t like that, it must say what it would do under the same circumstances.

This is the key. Everytime Labour complains about a spending cut, ask them where the money would come from. They have left the incoming Government with the worst set of fiscal projections ever. Are they really going to campaign on how they would make them worse?

A Green admires ban on bottled water

Stevedore at g.blog is full of admiration for Leeds University students’ association banning of bottled water sales.

He proudly proclaims:

Note: in this context ‘ban’ means make a democratic collective decision that for the good of the planet.  Compare and contrast this for instance to it’s opposite ‘freedom’, as in restore my freedom to live against my will on a globally warming planet by rolling back the ‘ban’ on old style inefficient lightbulbs.

Does this mean that banning the Green Party is a good thing so long as 50.1% of us make a democratic collective decision that it is for the good of the planet?

Nothing worse than a combination of the tyranny of the majority and zealotry.

Jon Johannsson’s 2008 Awards

Jon Johannsson at Pundit gives out his 2008 awards in his final column:

  • Politician of the Year – John Key
  • Politician of the Decade – Helen Clark
  • Comeback Politician of the Year – Roger Douglas and then Bill English
  • Political Loser of the Year – Gordon Copeland
  • Political Event of the Year – Privileges Committee hearings into Winston Peters’ conduct

Who to blame, and what to do with the economy

The set of economic forecasts inherited from Labour were bad enough reading last week. But then on Friday, I noticed that Finance Minister Bill English said that the economy is already nearly at Treasury’s worst-case scenario.

So how bad is the now likely worst case scenario:

  • Unemployment peaks at 7.5% in mid 2010
  • Economy contracts in year to March 2010 as well as March 2009
  • OBEGAL deficits of $32 billion from 2009 to 2013 – averaging greater than $8 billion a year
  • Gross debt to increase from $35 billion to $82 billion over four years – a $47 billion increase
  • Net debt to increase from $6 billion to $54 billion
  • Gross debt as % of GDP to go from under 20% to 39% in four years, and to 76% by 2023

This is a worse outlook than Labour left National in 1990. And you can’t even compare to the 1999 PREFU which was:

  • Operating Balances growing to almost $2.5 billion
  • net debt falling from 22% to 18%
  • Economic growth of over 3% a year
  • Unemployment to reduce from 7% to 5.7% over two years

Cullen was left with a wonderful set of projections.

So the next few years are going to be a disaster in fiscal terms. So who is at fault? Well of course the main responsibility is the global credit crisis – that goes without saying. But why are our fiscal fortunes so fragile, than a crisis such as this fucks our economy for the next decade or more? Let’s look at some of the possible culprits.

National’s tax cuts

If anyone blames the deficits and debts on National’s tax cuts, then they are incompetent or lying. The tax cuts were 99% funded from changes to KiwiSaver, and other expenditure savings. They have no impact on the deficit or debt.

In fact National’s tax cuts are (in hindsight) an even better idea than when first mooted? Why? Because they contribute towards a total fiscal stimulus package of 5% of GDP – this is one of the largest in the OECD and may help soften the recession.

But even better, the tax cuts are not funded from cutting current spending (which would detract from the stimulus) but by reducing subsidies into KiwiSaver which would lock the money up for decades.

We’ll come back to the issue of KiwiSaver.

Labour’s tax cuts

So how about Labour’s tax cuts? Is all this fiscal doom and gloom because Labour finally gave in and delivered tax cuts? Well it is certainly true that Dr Cullen has indicated he would have not cut taxes to the extent he did, based on PREFU’s numbers. And many people suspect Labour, if re-elected, would have cancelled some or all of their tax cuts.

The cost of Labour’s tax cuts over four years is $10.8 billion. So yes, if Labour did not cut taxes at all in their nine years of office, then the fiscal situation would be slightly better. Of course taxpayers would be worse off, but who cares about them!

But compare that $10.8 billion to OBEGAL deficits of over $30 billion and an increase in debt of almost $50 billion.  If Labour had not delivered tax cuts (and had not spent the money saved – a big if), it would have somewhat improved the fiscal outlook, but left households worse off, and made the recession worse.

Labour’s tax cuts were equivalent to a one off $3.3 reduction in taxation – the only personal tax reduction in nine years, where taxation went from $32 billion to $57 billion.  It is probably the most modest tax reduction program in the western world.

Labour’s Spending

What has really left us with a massive problem, isn’t Labour finally doing a $3.3 billion annual tax cut, but the massive increases in annual expenditure.

Expenditure has increased from $34 billion per year to $57 billion. That is a $23 billion hike – or seven times as great as the belated tax cuts.

Now of course some of this is necessary increases – even Sir Roger advocates you should increase spending in line with inflation and population growth. But off memory that is still $18 billion a year in extra spending.

And this is the problem Labour has left us. They massively increased spending in non-essential areas, on the assumption that we would have record growth and surpluses forever. They didn’t just keep funding and improving existing programmes (schools, hospitals) but they invented new schemes. Now these schemes were arguably good things – but they were funded based on an assumption of growth and surpluses. And together they combine to remove flexibility from future Governments.

Let us look, at just three of them:

The Cullen Fund

The Cullen Fund was based on a premise that as we are going to have surpluses for the next 30 years, then we should save some of those surpluses to meet the future cost of superannuation, so we won’t have to borrow money in the future.

The fatal flaw was always the assumption about surpluses, but as the years went on and they continued unabated, the opposition to the Fund diminished, and even National signed up to it.

But we are now in a very different situation. We have a structural deficit, and face massive borrowing for at least a decade.

So the Cullen Fund is now based on borrowing heaps of money today, so we do not have to borrow heaps of money in 25 years? Anyone else see the fatal flaw? Borrowing money to save money is the sort of stuff that cuased the credit crisis.

The Government should seriously consider suspending contributions to the Cullen Fund. We can’t save money we do not have.

KiwiSaver

KiwiSaver has much the same problem as the Cullen Fund. It is all well and good to help subsidise people’s savings, but not if the taxpayer is having to borrow money to do so.

Because who is going to have to pay back and pay the interest on all that borrowing? Those same savers. So once again we have the stupidity of borrowing money today, to help people save. That is not sustainable.

I like KiwiSaver. If we were going to continue with record surpluses, it would be great to have a scheme which provides massive incentives for people to save. But we don’t. Does anyone think Labour would in 2009 have announced the KiwiSaver subsidies they did in 2007? Of course not.

National has wisely already cut the cost of taxpayer subsidies to KiwiSaver. Arguably they need to go further and also look at whether the employee subsidy is affordable. If we need to borrow to find it, then it isn’t.

You see the employer matching contribution is a 1:1 subsidy already, which is massive. Hell most people are happy to get a 10% return on investment and the employer contribution gets you an instant 100% return. Now the employee subsidy gets you a further 100% return, so those earning up to $52,000 get a 2:1 subsidy or a 200% return on investment.

Unless the fiscal fortune improves, maybe the employee subisdy has to go also. Sure that means only a 100% return instead of a 200% return, but that is a lot better than the standard 10% return and I doubt it would discourage people going into KiwiSaver. Maybe raise the employer contribution rate to a maximum 3% so the total saved isn’t decreased.

Working for Families

This is another major spending commitment that falls into the category of unaffordable with hindsight. Basically whenever Labour had spare cash they hoovered it up into this targeted welfare assistance programme. And now taxpayers are going to have to borrow billions of dollars to fund this programme.

Unlike the other two programmes though, this one can’t be easily reformed. Families have grown used to having the extra cash, and in the midst of a recession, it would be quite wrong to take the money off them.

But what does need to be done, is some medium-term work on a better tax and welfare system that has less tax churn.

RIP Bevan Burgess

The exodus continues

In the year to Nov 2008, there were:

  • 83,802 PLT departures (76,000 previous 12 months) or 1,600 a week
  • 48,474 PLT departures to Australia (40,786) or 930 a week
  • 60,871 PLT departures of NZ citizens (54,722) or 1,170 a week
  • 37,502 Net PLT departures of NZ citizens (31,614) or 720 a week

It will be interesting to see if the credit crisis makes the exodus worse, or if Kiwis return to home in troubled times.

Who killed Ethan?

Yes, it is one of those horrible mind numbing Shortland Street threads. Block your eyes, those who get offended I watch a TV soap.

Over at Throng, I have suggested that Brooke is the likely killer of Ethan. My reasons are:

  1. She loves him and we all know love can turn to hate
  2. His final humiliation of rejecting her, could push her over the edge
  3. Few characters would have a gun, so it was probably Ethan’s gun and Brooke is likely to know he had one
  4. Her character won’t be missed when convicted and sent to jail
  5. Ethan did not look worried when he saw the killer, which would make sense if it was her

Of course there are other suspects, namely:

  1. Alice
  2. Maia
  3. Chris
  4. Callum
  5. Libby
  6. Keiran

A nice little who-dun-it for season end. Of course not as good as the classic Dallas Who shot JR plot which had half the world guessing!

The Gilchrist saga gets yucky

Rochelle Rees has put out a release:

Further in the emails sent by Rob Gilchrist to the police counter-terrorism units, was an email sent on 30/07/2005, containing naked photographs of a female and then teenage activist, sent with the subject line “needs a shave….”.

Now Gilchrist was not a police officer, and I suspect he sent a lot of unsolicited e-mails to his police handlers, but nevertheless you would at a minimum expect the Police to have told him not to send such material ando/or reconsider his value to them, if his judgement is this flawed. Any person who circulates naked photos of someone they have been intimate with is a scumbag.

There is no evidence that the police objected to the “needs a shave….” email, and clearly Rob Gilchrist had reason to believe that police would want to receive such an email. On the contrary, the fact that the police continued paying Rob Gilchrist $600 per week for over another 3 years, shows they did not view his conduct as grossly inappropriate.

Maybe they did, maybe they did not. But this is just another reason why the Police Complaints Authority (or another suitable body) should be asked to investigate the activities of the Police with regards to Gilchrist.

Also discovered on Rob Gilchrist’s computer were naked photos of a then 16 year old activist, which look to have been taken while she was sleeping. Naturally, I am left wondering if those were forwarded to the police, and whether any photographs of a similar nature were taken of me and sent to the police.

An understandable concern.

Best cartoon ever

2008 Awards

Roarprawn has her best and worst of 2008. A few are below:

BEST POLITICAL PLAY – John Key for his decision to say “f” off to Winston .
WORST POLITICAL PLAY – Winston for lying about helicopters
BEST STORY STILL TO HAVE AN IMPACT – Investigate piece on immigration. passports , Shane Jones and Bill Liu
BEST NEW MP – Amy Adams solid, lives in the south, knows rural affairs and knows shit from clay.
BEST MINISTER – Tim Groser – he will do good things for our country
BEST POLITICAL APPOINTMENT – John Key for elevating Paula Bennett.
BEST POLITICAL INTERVIEW – Sean Plunkett and his interview of Winston

Catcus Kate also has a Best of 2008, with some extracts below:

1. Best Overseas Business Jaunt – Monaco
4. Best Airline – Air New Zealand Business Premier – but you need first class
6. Best DVD set – Boston Legal series 4.
12. Best Sex Scandal – Paul Henry and all those women??? WTF.
15. Best Con – The possibility Judith Tizard may return on Labour’s list
21. Best (looking) Sportsman – Daniel Carter

WINZ emergency grants

Armstrong’s Politician of the Year

Few will be surprised that Armstrong gives it to new Prime Minister John Key. The commentary is interesting:

Had the election been fought under the pre-1996 first-past-the post system, the outcome would have been of the landslide proportions of Sir Robert Muldoon’s stunning victory in 1975 and Jim Bolger’s similar rout of Labour in 1990.

We see this in the electorates where Labour now only holds 21 out of 70 seats.

His opponents and critics had predicted he would falter as Leader of the Opposition, wilt under the pressures of an election campaign, and fail as Prime Minister simply through lack of experience. Wrong, wrong and almost certainly wrong again.

The really stupid thing is these critics lowered expectations for Key. So then when he casually strolls into the first Leader’s Debate and wins it, the impact is even greater.

Far more courageous was Key’s refusal to work with Winston Peters. It could have backfired. However, Key felt he was left no option after Peters’ appalling performance over Owen Glenn and donations to NZ First.

It was a calculated risk, but to some degree he had no choice. Up until the point where his lies were exposed by Owen Glenn, National had been keen to keep Peters in as an option. But they realised that he was so unstable, that any future Government that involved him would not be stable.

Key wanted his administration to be a clean break from the past. Having Peters on board would have tainted it from the beginning – as well as possibly harbouring the seed of its destruction.

Absolutely.

Stupidity

CTU President Helen Kelly has said:

Council of Trade Unions president Helen Kelly said all workers should be able to get similar increases.

She said some vulnerable workers struggled to get any increase at all.

“It would be great if all workers had the same bargaining power and influence as judges and were able to get pay increases like that,” she said.

Judges have no bargaining power at all. An independent tribunal sets their pay unilaterally.

So is Helen Kelly saying she would like all workers to lose their bargaining rights, and have a tribunal set pay for all workers?

Fiji to expel High Commissioner today

Cabinet Committees

John Key has announced the Cabinet Committees. Very pleased to see the Ministers from support parties are full members of appropriate Cabinet Committees. That’s a far more professional arrangement than the nonsense under Labour when the Foreign Minister wasn’t even a member of the Cabinet Foreign and Defence Committee.

So what are the committees:

Cabinet Strategy Committee – chaired by the PM, this determines the key strategic direction. The members are the nine front bench Ministers plus McCully and Joyce. The inclusion of Joyce is a good indicator of the influence he has, despite being a first term MP.

Cabinet Economic Growth and Infrastructure Committee – chaired by Finance Minister Bill English. 16 Ministers on it, so I suspect the real decisions will be made within a tighter circle. A bit surprised Rodney Hide is not a member as Regulatory Reform Minister.

Cabinet Social Policy Committee – chaired by Health Minister Tony Ryall and covers health, welfare and education.

Cabinet Domestic Policy Committee – chaired by Justice Minister Simon Power and covers law & order and state services.

Cabinet Committee on Treaty of Waitangi Negotiations – chaired by PM John Key as a mark of his commitment to progressing these.

Cabinet External Relations and Defence Committee – chaired by Foreign Minister Murray McCully

Cabinet Committee on Domestic and External Security Co-ordination – chaired by the PM and meets as required. It is rarely good news if it meets!

Cabinet Expenditure Control Committee – chaired by Finance Minister Bill English. A very small committee with just seven Ministers including Rodney Hide and Steven Joyce. They have a lot of work ahead!

Cabinet Legislation Committee – chaired by Leader of the House Gerry Brownlee. Works out the Government’s legislative agenda. Lots of lawyers on it.

Cabinet Appointments and Honours Committee – chaired by PM John Key. Heather Roy and Tariana Turia on the committee as well as 11 National Ministers.

Cabinet Business Committee – chaired by PM John Key. Seems to be an Executive Committee of Cabinet that can make decisions in between regular meetings. The nine frontbench Ministers only.

Mark Felt has died

Goff on alcohol theft

I’m reluctant to politicise the alcohol theft issue, because while it is Labour this time which has the stupid staff members, there have been plenty of stupidities done over the years by staff from all parties – including myself! Of course theft is at the more serious end of the scale.

But I find myself slightly annoyed by Phil Goff’s response. Now generally I think Goff is making good judgement and calls, but Stuff quote him:

Labour leader Phil Goff said the staffers’ actions were “totally unacceptable”.

“I deeply regret that that action was taken. It is perhaps a message for young people at Christmas functions – watch how much you drink and remember you will be accountable for your actions afterwards.”

Umm, I hope Phil is not suggesting all young people steal things when they have had a few drinks.

And I am not even sure blaming what happened on alcohol is a good idea. They were loading the wine into a car. So either one of them were sober enough to drive, or they were also going to be drink driving.

Phil also said:

Mr Goff said he did not know the individuals personally.

But the Herald reports:

Aidan Smith was arrested after allegedly being caught taking the wine to a car outside Wednesday night’s party, which was attended by Prime Minister John Key and a collection of other ministers and senior MPs.

Smith was still working as Labour MP Pete Hodgson’s assistant yesterday. He is due to leave that role soon to work for the party’s finance spokesman, David Cunliffe. He has previously worked in the party’s research unit.

He is listed as working in the Research Unit, which is part of Phil Goff’s leader’s office. Now one must take Mr Goff at his word that he has never met Smith, but all I can say is that in my experience it would be very very rare for an Opposition Leader not to know all of his office staff. In fact often they will know most of the MPs secretaries also. Its unclear whether he was Hodgson’s secretary, or a researcher working for Hodgson (which makes him part of the Leader’s Office).

As to the four involved, I had a degree of sympathy initally based on an assumption it was an opportunistic fit if stupidity. You’re the last people at a party and there is a box of wine, and you think hey it is paid for anyway, we could have drink it anyway, and hate it to go to waste. Now don’t get me wrong – that is still wrong, but I can understand with some empathy how that may happen. But according to the Herald it was very calculated:

A group of up to four people, also believed to be Labour staffers, were seen acting suspiciously as they came in and out of the party, which was held in Parliament’s Doidge room and spilled into the area outside.

Press Gallery chair Vernon Small of the Dominion-Post and deputy chair Jane Patterson say they tracked Smith to the carpark.

It is believed that the group of four were taking full bottles of wine from the bar then smuggling them individually out the gate and up to the car.

A partygoer claims to have seen one making fake phone calls as an excuse to go in and out of the party.

If this is correct, that is pretty inexcusable. Now it is possible the accussed denies the events, so I won’t comment further than this for reasons of natural justice. But if the above account is accurate, that makes it very serious.

Facing Off from 11 to 12

I’m on Faceoff on Newstalk ZB Wellington from 11 to 12 with Ken Laban and Kathryn Asarae.

Topics are:

  1. Are fines for truancy the solution?
  2. Is ACC out of control?
  3. What part of Xmas most annoys you

I’m not sure any part of Xmas annoys me. Will have to think about that one.

Farewell Paul Holmes

I wasn’t always a fan of Paul Holmes on TV. Don’t get me wrong – he made the Holmes show into a huge success, but I didn’t think he was the best political interviewer on TV and would get frustrated with some of TV work.

But with his radio show, I have no mixed feelings at all. I absolutely love Holmes on ZB and listen to him most mornings. His sense of humour and ability to poke at sacred cows was wonderful. He really had few peers, and it showed in the ratings. I am not sure if we will see such a talented radio person again.

The NZ Herald (despite often being a target of Holmes) delivers a nice farewell editorial.

I don’t know who I will listen to now. Not sure how Hosking will go. I could defect to National Radio but again with Sean Plunket leaving, that loses some of its appeal.

A smart appointment

Pleased to read in Computerworld that The Chief Executive of the Ministry of Economic Development has appointed Bruce Parkes as Deputy Secretary for telecommunications and energy.

While individually there are many fine civil servants, collectively there is a legitimate criticism that there can be a lack of private sector experience. Bruce has held senior positions in both the telecommunications and energy sectors, and it is great to see someone with that background appointed to a senior role.

I’ve actually taken part in Commerce Commission hearings, on the opposite side to Bruce – when he was at Telecom, and I was part of the InternetNZ team. He was always very professional and didn’t let the areas in which you disagreed (which were a few) interfere with the relationship in the areas where you did agree.