Grading the new laws

Very stupid

Stealing is stupid. Stealing from journalists is even more stupid. Stealing alcohol from journalists is terminally stupid.

NZPA report:

Wellington, Dec 18 NZPA – Up to four Labour Party staffers face the sack after they were allegedly caught stealing alcohol from a parliamentary Christmas function.

Police were called to Parliament in the early hours of today after the four people were seen loading surplus alcohol from the Press Gallery Christmas party into a car on the precinct.

One of the men was detained and arrested at the scene, allegedly with over $400 worth of wine in his car. He has been charged with theft.

The man’s accomplices escaped, but NZPA understands security footage shows four people were involved in the alleged theft — all of them junior Labour Party staffers.

$400 worth of wine is probably around three dozen bottles or so. Apart from the fact it is wrong, and also an abuse of the hospitality of the galley – it is also stupid considering the number of security cameras and guards around the place.

I left around 1 am and it was still going strong. I’m curious as to what time the alleged theft took occurred.

Goff will be ropeable. They will either be MPs secretaries or members of Goff’s personal office.

Labour leader Phil Goff said the staffers’ actions were “totally unacceptable”.

“I deeply regret that that action was taken. It is perhaps a message for young people at Christmas functions — watch how much you drink and remember you will be accountable for your actions afterwards.”

Mr Goff said he did not know the individuals personally.

In which case my assumption is they are secretaries/EAs – probably for new MPs. Their MPs will be very upset that their first staffing decision has blown up in their face.

UPDATE: Despite Goff saying he does not know any of them, they may actually be from his office, not MPs Secretaries. Not that I met everyone there last night, but there were not a lot of secretaries there.

How bad is Labour’s legacy

We found out today how bad is Labour’s economic legacy. In 1999 National left Labour with a strongly growing economy, falling unemployment, low interest rates, and low inflation.

Today’s DEFU tells us what Labour has left National. And my God it is bad:

  • Unemployment to hit 6.4% (and maybe 7.2%) within 15 months
  • Gross debt to increase from under 20% to a massive 33.1% (and maybe 38.6%) by 2013
  • OBEGAL deficits of $23 billion over next four years
  • Cash deficits of $48 billion over five years

This is appalling.  Even the “upside” scenario sees a massive increase id debt, deficits and unemployment.

Deficits of up to $6 billion are just unacceptable. If we do not improve from the lgeacy Labour left us, we will be leaving the next generation with a mountain of extra debt.

It gets even worse over the ten year horizon:

  • The costs of all the borrowing basically fuck the economy. We end up with a permament structural deficit with the books Labour have left us.
  • Even after 2019, the crown will be running an permanent OBEGAL deficit of 2% of GDP, or $4 billion a year. Even the “upside” scenario sees an ongoing deficit of 0.7% of GDP. So Labour have left us with an economy that is stuffed, even under the more optimistic scenario. We just can not run a decade of deficits.
  • Gross debt is now projected to hit 57% of GDP in 2023. Do you remember Helen and Michael telling us that hitting 22% of GDP would be reckless. Well they have left us with a debt on track to hit 57% of GDP!!!
  • Even net debt, which had reached zero, is projected to rocket up to 47% of GDP

This is a set of books, every bit as bad as those left behind by Labour in 1990. They are horrible. Bill English has the toughest job in NZ for the next few years.

The task for the National-led Government is to improve on this. DEFU is basically what would happen if you continue with Labour’s policy settings. The tax cuts were fiscally neutral so don’t affect things. Over the next few years we should always refer back to this DEFU as what we would achieve under Labour. National has to deliver smaller deficits and less debt than DEFU is projecting. That is their challenge.

The Gilchrist case gets murkier

The Greens are understandably upset that Rob Gilchrist also spied on them for the Police. Not to be fair to the Police, I very much doubt they asked him to do so. He probably just sends them any stuff he thinks is useful. But there are real issues of judgement for the Police involved. They should have made very clear that he should only report on activities where people planned to break the law, not all sorts of protest action. If they are paying him $600 a week, they do have some responsibility for his actions.

If a group of protesters are planning to break the law by breaking into private property, and digging up GE potatoes (something that elements of the Greens have done in the past), then the Police are acting properly in monitoring this and trying to prevent this.

But if a group are just planning to hold a public protest against say the Police having tazers, then the Police have no legitimate role in collecting information about that protest.

This issue is posing some dilemmas for the Government, even though it all actually happened under the previous Government.

On the one hand the new Minister of Police doesn’t want to start the job, by undermining the Commissioner. They need to have a healthy working relationship. And also generally Police Ministers should stay as far away as possible from operational issues. Of course this rule is not absolute as we saw with the Commission of Inquiry into police conduct in the 80s.

But the element of possibly spying on a political party makes it a problem for the Government, especially as Rochelles Rees has scores of e-mails, documents and phone calls between Gilchrist and the Police. I imagine these documents will be revealed to the public a bit at a time over the next few months. And that means every few days the Government will be asked what is it doing about the issue. And the Greens will try and portray National as endorsing or being unconcerned about Police spying on protesters and even other political parties. The irony is of course it happened under Labour, and National has been victim of spying, leaked e-mails and secret taping more than any other political party. But perception is more important than reality, sometimes.

So is there a solution for the Government? Well, yes, a simple one occurs to me. Why not refer the issue to the Police Complaints Authority. This wipes the issue off the front page, and will ensure that some independent scrutiny is given to the issue. This is ideal for the PCA and is much better than having a formal external inquiry by a QC.

And here’s the clincher for me. I am 99% sure that after two months of released emails, documents and phone calls, Mr Hager or Ms Rees (or someone from the activist community) will themselves complain to the PCA. So why let it drag out in the media for weeks, and months. Just refer it to the PCA now.

Interestingly Garth George is also supportive of the Greens criticism.

The 2008 Press Gallery Party

Last night was one of their better ones. It was held mainly outside which is far more fun then in a sterile room such as the Grand Hall. And the journos spent many hours behind the bbq and the bar as cordial hosts.

Every year the gallery have a photo taken, and they all hang up proudly in their corridor. This year some wag added this photo to the corridor. You can’t see all the names, but they are of all the well known members of the gallery. Very, very amusing.

And as double proof Winston is gone but not forgotten!

Now the gallery party is of course off the record, so all the fascinating conversations remain private. But I did enjoy chatting to MPs and staff from all parties – it was a very relaxed do.

I can report on a couple of media movements though, as they are about to be made public:

  • A TVNZ reporter is moving to Phil Goff’s office, so it is not just the Government that has picked up the odd gallery member.
  • A high profile Maori Party candidate has been hired as Tariana’s press secretary

I hear whispers the House may rise today, so the party was well timed!

Merry Christmas from Labour

Labour’s legacy hits workers:

The average worker will have to pay a 21 per cent increase in their ACC bill next year, rising from $658 a year to $799, ACC Minister Nick Smith said today. …

A person on the average wage of $47,000 per year currently pays $658 a year or $12.61 a week to ACC for the levy funding the earners account.

The Labour Department, which monitors ACC, had recommended an increase to $940 a year or $18.02 a week due to increased costs, more claims and lower earnings.

Sadly the levy will inevitably have to rise to $940 a year, so that will be $250 more out of the average worker’s pay once it does.

Trevett on Question Time

Claire Trevett has a good article on question time yesterday:

Both sides went into the House primed for action – an Opposition ready to put the new National Government through the wringer and a Government eager to show what it was really made of.

Instead, those who had become so adept at answering questions over the previous nine years suddenly found they had little idea how to ask them. Those now responsible for answering them seemed to be under the misapprehension that the people in Opposition were still running the show.

It was very funny.

Three times Mr Carter stood up to ask the initial question and muffed it by adding extraneous words. He did no better on his follow-up questions, which fell foul of the rules because they did not begin with words such as how, why or when. Eventually Dr Cullen stood and used a point of order to give him a lesson on how to begin a question.

“Wassup?” yelled Mr Key – and by the time Mr Carter was done, the howls of laughter drowned Ms Tolley’s answers.

Poor Chris really had  shocker of a day.

Labour whip Darren Hughes showed the game of Gerry-baiting had lost none of its novelty – when Mr Key mentioned “stationary energy” Mr Hughes chipped in “we call that Gerry Brownlee”.

But Claire passed over Simon Power’s slam to Hughes earlier on

9. JOHN BOSCAWEN (ACT) to the Minister of Justice: On what date is the Government planning to repeal the Electoral Finance Act and introduce new electoral law?

Hon SIMON POWER (Minister of Justice) : As part of its first 100 days’ commitment the Government intends to repeal—

Hon Darren Hughes: Fight them on the beaches.

Hon SIMON POWER: Well, that member should go back to his seat. Oh, that is right, he does not have one.

Ouch.

Sex or the Internet

A poll found 46% of women and 30% of men would rather go without sex for a fortnight, than the Internet.

I’m tempted to observe that for some, going without the Internet would be going without sex 🙂

Anyway Kiwiblog is running its own poll on the proposition, so have fun voting in the sidebar.

A small victory against nanny state

Gerry Brownlee has confirmed he is lifting the ban on traditional incandescent light bulbs.

I actually use eco-bulbs myself, but it is not the role of the state to tell people what sort of lightbulb to use, so long as they are safe. 2.5 million households all have different needs, and householders are quite competent at deciding for themselves what sort of lightbulbs to buy.

Personally I would advocate most people get ecobulbs – they save money and power. But I would also advocate most people vote National, and neither of my preferences should be made compulsory!

Rochelle hits back

Lyn Prentice at The Standard blogs on what Rochelle Rees (his niece) did after she discovered her boyfriend (Rob Gilchrist was spying on her and others for the Police):

I flew down to Christchurch and installed spyware on Rob Gilchrist’s phone to monitor his phone calls and text messages, and a script on his computer to continue sending his emails to me. I also downloaded the past 12 months of his phone bills from telecom, and managed to decrypt documents in his emails that had been encrypted.

I did say it was monumentally stupid of Gilchrist to ask his geek girlfriend to fix his computer when he has been using it to file spy reports on her. And I think morally she has every right to snoop through his stuff, considering the huge betrayal of trust Gilchrist did to her, and others.

Lyn notes:

In effect she had access to a large amount of the ongoing and past dialogue between Rob and his police handlers. This makes some of the statements made by Howard Broad in the last few days somewhat hilarious. He badly needs to get on top of what his officers are doing, if only because otherwise Rochelle can tell him.

It sounds like the Police should be somewhat concerned.

There is an arguable case that Rochelle may have broken the law as it relates to unauthorised computer access. But the Police would be foolish to even consider charging her, as the double standard would be immense. And personally I’d actually donate to her defence.

The big question I am still fascinated by, is why Gilchrist did it, and did he offer his services to the Police, or did they actively try to enlist him?

Dim-Post on spying on activists

A classic from the Dim-Post:

SIG Detective-Inspector Sean Gibson-Whyte is understood to be leading the investigation into Tino-rangatiratanga People’s Global Jihad for Social and Environmental Justice Now! and admits that the loss of Gilchrist as an informer has dealt a blow to the ongoing surveillance operation.

‘We have been reduced to reading Mr Fletcher’s blog, watching his web-cam, listening to his telephone calls with Mr Singh and installing listening devices in their homes and cars,’ Gibson-Whyte admitted ruefully.

Detective Gibson-Whyte is no stranger to set-backs: an experienced officer with a Masters Degree in criminal law, he spent nine years investigating gangs and organised crime in New Zealand and Asia Pacific and headed up a multi-country task-force to investigate the smuggling of amphetamine precursors from South East Asia before being pulled from the case to head up the inquiry into the Tino-rangatiratanga People’s Global Jihad for Social and Environmental Justice Now! task-force.

Other activists informed on by Gilchrist have expressed surprise and relief about the selective nature of his informing.

‘Rob sent the stasi pigs cell-phone pictures he took of my ‘PanArchy’ performance art installation but he hasn’t told them anything about the time I got wasted, broke into my ex-girlfriends flat and trashed the whole house,’ said Project for Total Human Genocide co-founder and environmental activist Jenny McCormak. The anonymous, Hawera based spokesperson for Sendero Luminoso Aotearoa has expressed gratitude that Gilchrist did not reveal details of her activities manufacturing and distributing the class A drug Ecstasy, although his information about the group has prompted the SIG to draft eleven more detectives into the task-force to adequately monitor the upcoming anti-patriarchy rave scheduled for new years eve.

One of the best.

The 1st question time

Very interesting to see people get used to their new roles.

Goff and Key well matched. Labour did quite well with questions on confidence in various Ministers over various issues, as it allowed the questions to cover everything.

Lockwood doing very well for his first day chairing question time. Handled well an issue over whether Chris Carter can ask Anne Tolley a question relating to a statement she made before she was a Minister. Even Cullen was nodding in agreement with him at the end.

Finlayson and Hide and having great fun tripping Labour MPs, especially Chris Carter, up on asking questions. Many people don’t realise there are very strict rules over how questions can be phrased, and while former Ministers may be experts at answering them, some have forgotten how to ask them.

Nick Smith is ripping into Maryan Street over the ACC blowout. Seems a lot of porkies have been told – more goodies to come I say.

Key just did a nice bounce back to Goff. Said that since the election we have learnt Key believes more in human induced climate change than Phil Goff believes in the Electoral Finance Act! Also reminded Labour emissions under them in NZ rose faster than in the US under Bush.

Freaky accident

The Dom Post reports:

The twin trailer articulated truck was transporting goods to New Plymouth when it drove over a mattress left lying on State Highway 3, north of Wanganui, about 2am today.

Sergeant Bruce Mackay said the driver was unable to safely swerve out of the way of the mattress and part of it was caught up under the truck’s cab, with friction from the drive shaft setting it alight.

“It was a freak accident. The driver kept going for a few kilometres and noticed sparks. When he got out there were already flames and within a few minutes the whole truck went up in smoke,” he said.

What are the chances?

DPMC BIM

John Key has released the DPMC BIM. The breakdown of the 120 staff is interesting:

  1. External Assessments Bureau 27
  2. Government House 27
  3. Cabinet Office 25
  4. Corporate Services 17
  5. Policy Advisory Group 16
  6. Domestic & External Security Group 6
  7. CEO Office 2

The last five sections look right to me in terms of staff numbers. Cabinet Office basically runs the cabinet system of government, and the Policy Advisory Group do a magnificent job in co-ordinating and leading policy across the entire Government. No-one sane would reduce their numbers.

But I am surprised 27 staff are needed for the Governor-General. That’s more staff than the PM has in his personal office.

Also somewhat surprised by 27 staff working in the EAB. I wouldn’t have thought there was that much assessing to be done – especially when you consider MFAT, SIS and GCSB also work somewhat in this area.

So maybe the Cabinet Committee on Expenditure Control can start in the centre 🙂

Labour’s problem with Mt Albert

Helen doesn’t want to spend the next three years as a backbench Opposition MP. And Phil Goff doesn’t want her to overshadow him. So normally we would expect to see a by-election in Mt Albert next year.

But it is proving rather difficult for Labour. You see Michael Cullen, being a List MP, will probably resign from Parliament in early 2009. This will bring in No 37 on the Labour List, Damien O’Connor. Now some in Labour probably think Damien should give way to new blood, but they’ll tolerate him returning.

Then we have Helen resigning, which will trigger a by-election. Labour will need to select a candidate for this seat, and let there be no mistake – Helen will pick the candidate. And who is favoured to get her blessing – List MP Phil Twyford. Twyford is highly regarded.

But here is the problem, Twyford is already an MP. So what happens if he wins the Mt Albert by-election? Well he would then resign his seat as a List MP, and that would bring in the next person on the Labour list. And who is No 38? It’s Judith Tizard!

Now Helen has won Mt Albert with some big majorities, but a lot of that has been personal. The party vote has been much closer. And if Mt Albert voters works out that voting for Twyford means Tizard returns to Parliament, then the seat could fall to a good National candidate. I can imagine a lot of money would be spent pointing out the nightmare scenario.

Now some might say, it’s easy. Just get Judith to agree to stand aside. After all, she probably doesn’t want to be back there by herself.

But who is next on the list. Well the next four candidates are Mark Burton, Mahara Okeroa, Martin Gallagher and Dave Hereora. The four stooges without the humour. Persuading Mt Albert residents to vote for any of those to return to Parliament could be a challenge.

So who is next in place 43? Louisa Wall. Now I think Louisa was a talented MP and would be a boon to Labour’s ranks. But she is seriously unpopular with many of her colleagues who don’t want her back. So who is next at 44? Lesley Soper – she would attract more shoe throwing in a Labour Caucus meeting than George W Bush attracts in Iraq.

Spots 45 to 49 are all vacant as they won their electorate seats. Finally in spot 50 you have Hamish McCracken. Well at least he is an Aucklander. However having been given three unwinnable seats and rankings in a row, he is hardly in high favour.

So you see the problem for Labour. Either Helen has to stay on for the full term, or someone other than Twyford is the candidate, or they risk the public working out voting for Labour will bring a plonker back in on the list and losing your predecessor’s seat in a byelection would see Goff rolled.

So I am picking Helen won’t be going anywhere until they work out a way around their dilemna.

City Vision Cr votes to ban smoking in Auckland CBD

Meltdown with Fiji

Commodore Bainimarama seems to be very misguided if he thinks he is in a position to demand NZ issue visas to various family members of Fijian officials.

Such a demand would guarantee the Government won’t issue a waiver. If he wants waivers, then you have to make concessions, not threats. Such as a firm timetable for elections.

The threat is very lame – expelling our Acting High Commissioner. So what? It hurts Fiji far more not having NZ diplomatic presence, than it does NZ.

And this morning, they have expelled TVNZ’s Barbara Dreaver. Again, the Commodore is getting bad advice if he thinks this upset the Government at all.

I’m open to persuasion that the Commodore has good motives – his planned reforms to get rid of race based voting are laduable. But the longer he remains the self-appointed ruler, without taking concrete steps towards elections, the longer sanctions will remain. The way ahead lies with him.

The transitional relief package

National announced yesterday the relief package for those who lose their jobs during this period of global recession. It is up to $160 a week for 16 weeks for those with high accommodation costs.

Strangely one of the criticisms from Labour has been people who get a redundancy payout of over $25,000 will not be eligible.

Labour really don’t get this concept of limited funds, so you target to the most needy. But hey it is good to see Labour concerned about those who get redundancy payouts equal to one year on the minimum wage or seven months on the average wage.

A visit to Mangarara

On Wednesday last week, I had a very enjoyable day in Hawke’s Bay as a guest of the Air New Zealand Environmental Trust.

The Trust was set up by Air NZ, who gave it an initial donation. Passengers can also donate to the trust here, to offset the environmental impact of their flights. And yes our flights to Napier were offset!

The Trust invited several bloggers along, being very open about the fact they wanted to increase awareness of what they do.

There were three other bloggers there. Matthew and Waveney who are trying to live wastefree for an entire year. They talk about the day on their blog.

Carlin Archer from Ecobob was the other blogger, and he talks about the day here. He has the best collection of photos.

The highlight for me was Ruud Kleinpaste – the Bugman. His enthusiasm for biodiversity was infectious. He had fun showing off his katipo and his wetas.

So why was I there, amongst all these dedicated environmentalists? I certainly don’t walk the walk like they do. But I guess in someway I may be like the average Kiwi in that I do a bit – I do recycle most of the the rubbish, I use eco-friendly lightbulbs, I absolutely adore the outdoors, support the World Wildlife Fund through a monthly donation etc., and use public transport almost daily.

We spent the day at Greg and Rachel’s Mangarara Family Farm. This is the view from the House – their own private lake! Horseshoe Lake is a 30ha wildlife sanctuary on the farm.

The overall farm is 300 hectares and their aim is to restore as much of the original ecosystem as possible, so they are planing native forests and converting it to a sustainable beef and sheep station. The forests will also act as carbon sinks to help with offsetting greenhouse gas emissions. That’s a triple win with more native forest, a more sustainable farm and lower net carbon emissions for NZ.

The Air NZ Trust’s first project is a conservation programme involving more than 100 acres on Mangarara Station. It will financially contribute to the purchase and planting of 85,000 trees over the next three years.

It’s am ambitious challenge, especially as there has been no rain since mid August! So they took advantage of our presence to have us help water some of the saplings, using lake water.

We rode on the back of some sturdy farm vehicles to an existing area of native forest. For several kms there are plain fields only, and suddenly this little patch of wonderful greenery. It even has a small little bach out there, making it an ideal hideaway. We nailed some bamboo tubes (known as weta motels) to some of the trees, as they help attract wetas, which form an important part of the ecosystem. I got bitten by a weta when I was seven, so I had to overcome my natural genocidal instncts towards them 🙂

I really enjoyed the day learning more about the work of the trust at Mangarara, and meeting a lovely group of people. We have one of the greenest countries on Earth, but it will only stay that way people making a commitment to it.

Fibre to the Home Report

InternetNZ released today the first ever comprehensive costing of options for achieiving ultra high speed broadband to at least 75% of New Zealanders. This was defined as a minimum 100 Mb/s for residences and 1 Gb/s for businesses.

The report is 150 pages of detailed models and costings. It was done by Network Strategies, who are an independent leading firm of telecommunication economists.

There are lots of technical details on whether one should build just layer zero or layer one infrastructure, whether it should be GPON or Ethernet or even peer to peer. The techos will find that part interesting.

But the real “big news” in the report is that it may be billions of dollars cheaper to build a fibre network through existing utility (electricity lines) companies, than through expanding current telco networks.

The major cost of fibre deployment is the cost of placing it. And lines companies already have networks of ducts plus overhead cables, and very importantly resource consents. If 50% of fibre deployment can be done using existing utility infrastructure (and some estimate as much as 70% could be done this way), then the total cost is projected to reduce from $5 billion to $3 billion and the cost to the Government from almost $4 billion to under $2 billion.

Now this is only one report, but hopefully a useful contributor to the debate over how to best achieve the Government’s goal of ultra high-speed broadband to 75% of NZ. But one reason I am quite enthusiatic about the path it suggests, is because it makes vertically integrated monopolies far less likely. You see none of the electricity lines companies offer telco services (such as Internet access, TV, phone). They would operate any fibre network on open access principles to all telco providers at a standard wholesale cost (estimated to be around $40/month). In one sense very similar to how Citylink have operated – they just provide the fibre, and let ISPs offer the services over it.

This actually has the potential to reverse much of the regulation in the telco sector. If there is infrastructure competition or separation, then you probably don’t need Telecom (for example) to be giving competitors access to its networks. Regulation is what I call a necessary evil. If one can get the infrastructure setup in a way so there is less regulation, that is a good thing.

There are literally dozens of big questions facing the industry and the Government, in working out a way foward. This report does not seek to answer them – it is a first step. Issues such as national vs regional, ownership, existing investment plans, the role of Chorus, RMA issues, funding, are all very significant ones.

It is going to be a very exciting time over the next few months, as the Government’s plans get finalised. Some people are sceptics, but I think there will be significant economic and environmental benefits to NZ if we get a fibre network in place ahead of most other countries.

Sir Roger at his best

A journalist mentioned to me that Sir Roger Douglas has been very effective in countering Labour’s claims over the tax cuts. The Hansard is now out, so I figured I would take a look.

This bill restores the tax threshold position of 10 years ago for those who are on 21c in the dollar or those who are on low to middle incomes. It does not restore the relative position of those on the 33c or 39c index. In other words, those on the higher income are still in a relatively poorer, or worse, position than they were 10 years ago. The arguments that have been put forward by the Labour speakers in relation to the bottom tax rate of 12.5c simply do not hold water. If we analyse the people who pay only 12.5c we find that around 90 percent of that group actually come from high-income families. They are the wives or the husbands of high-income earners. They are the children of high-income earners. What the Labour Government did in its tax legislation of last year was to encourage income splitting so high-income earners who had the capacity to do that said “Thank you very much Labour” and the poor suffered, and the low-income and disadvantaged paid for that.

This sent Labour into full frenzy mode.

I have listened to the speakers from Labour cry wolf about how they want to help the poor and the disadvantaged, but over the last 9 years they took $18.2 billion in extra taxation from average New Zealanders or $1,000 a month. The fact is that had we left that extra $1,000 a month with low-income families in particular, they would be a whole lot better off than they are at the moment. The fact is that Labour spent that extra tax, that extra $1,000 per family, on dubious programmes and failed social experiments that have not benefited New Zealand households by anywhere near the $1,000 a month it took from them. Labour would have been far better to leave the money with them. For families, that $1,000 per month represented books for children, meals in restaurants, carpets, clothes, and extra savings. For the economy it represented lost jobs in shops, factories, and service industries right across the country.

I think we are gong to hear a lot about that $1,000 a month!

Final Results of the 2008 Election Media Study

I blogged on the 6th of November some fascinating findings from the preliminary results of an academic study of media coverage of the 2008 election.

The study is based on an analysis of the leading New Zealand newspapers and television news programmes (TV1 and TV3 evening news) over an eight-week time period. The final results are uploaded here as a pdf – new-zealands-media-coverage-of-the-2008-election-study-final-results

The results:

Overall Media coverage:

Labour 38%, National 34%, Maori 8%, Greens 7%, NZF 6%, ACT 4%, UFNZ 2% and Progressive 1%

Negative Media Coverage

  1. National 38%
  2. NZ First 37%
  3. Labour 36%
  4. Progressive 31%
  5. ACT 26%
  6. United Future 21%
  7. Greens 18%
  8. Maori 17%

So National had a higher proportion of negative stories than NZ First!

Net Positive less Negative Coverage

  1. Greens +14%
  2. Maori +13%
  3. United Future +1%
  4. ACT -2%
  5. Labour – 10%
  6. Progressive – 12%
  7. National – 16%
  8. NZ First – 16%

This suggests to me the Greens and Maori Party were not held to the same level of scrutiny as other parties.

What I found interesting was the further breakdown that found news stories were more negative on National, but analysis stories more negative on Labour.

They also compared total media coverage to the result a party got at the election. The difference between the two was:

  1. Maori +6%
  2. Labour +4%
  3. NZ First +3%
  4. United Future +2%
  5. Greens +1%
  6. Progressive 0%
  7. ACT -0%
  8. National – 11%

Then we have the tone of media coverage of the leaders. And the net positive over negative was:

  1. Anderton +14%
  2. Turia/Sharples +9%
  3. Dunne +5%
  4. Clark +3%
  5. Fitzsimons/Norman -4%
  6. Key – 7%
  7. Hide – 15%
  8. Peters -19%

In the preliminary report, Key and Hide had more net negative coverage than Winston. The re-emergence of the Owen Glenn affair obviously resulted in a change for the last two weeks.

A breakdown by media, finds that Key got much more negative coverage on TV than Helen Clark.

In terms of issues, the major ones were:

  • Economy 28%
  • Law & Order 10%
  • Tax 9%
  • Maori Issues 7%
  • Education 7%
  • Immigration 6%
  • Health 6%
  • KiwiSaver/Super 6%

A very interesting, easy to read report.

Support the Auckland City Mision

A great initiative from the Mashup Mafia:

The Mashup Mafia are proud to announce that Low Rollers will host it’s second annual Christmas charity appeal for the Auckland City Mission on Thursday 18th of December at Auckland’s leading night life venue The Carpark Bar. So after the remarkable contribution put forward by the Auckland drum & bass community last year, we’re back to do it again – except this time, on a much much much larger scale!!

This year we are working hard alongside key sponsors to bring one of the biggest names in drum and bass – FUTUREBOUND – direct from the United Kingdom here to Auckland for one night only! We’re also planning a mind blowing audio-visual experience like never before, and we’ve even drawn support acts from around the country for what we believe is going to be the biggest feel-good drum and bass event of 2008!

Orcon are also giving away some free bar tabs to their customers, to encourage people along.

Maiden Speeches

Keeping up with all the maiden speeches has been too much, but you can view them here.

Auckland Central MP Nikki Kaye

List MP Hekia Parata. Hekia sings as part of her speech!

List MP and Minister Steven Joyce

List MP Kanwal Singh Bakshi

New Plymouth MP Jonathan Young