A flying start

This week’s Dispatch from St Johnnsyberg looks at John Key’s flying start to the job. The grades are:

  • Best Play of the Week: Tim Groser gets an A for the expansion of the P4 trade agreement
  • Worst Play of the Week: Gordon Brown gets a D for the protectionist departure tax, which has nothing to do with climate change – that is just the excuse.
  • EFA Breach of the Week: Looks at the Electoral Commission ruling on whether Trevor Mallard broke the EFA by releasing leaked copies of National’s policies.
  • Scandals of the Week: The citizenship scandal continues as an A- while the immigration job offer scandal rises from a C to a B-

Feedback and comments welcome at NBR.

Five Kiwis presumed dead or air crash

Very sad news emerging that there were five of the seven people on board the Air New Zealand A320 which crashed in the Mediterranean today were Kiwis. The plane was being operated by the German XL Airways who had leased it for the last two years.

By coincidence it is 29 years to the day since the Erebus crash.

The dead Kiwis (the authorities say no survivors are expected) are an Air NZ pilot, three engineers and a CAA Inspector.

It seems the air craft just fell out of the sky and dropped 300 metres out of the sjy into the sea, and sank to 45 metres.

My thoughts and condolences go out to Air NZ and CAA staff, plus friends and families of the five Kiwis. Also to the families of the German pilots who also perished.

MPs now official

The Chief Electoral Officer has announced that as there have been no applications for judical recounts, he has returned the writ declaring the sucessful electorate MPs and the list MPs.

The MPs will be sworn in on Monday 8 December.

When do you start attributing things to the new Government

NewZblog tries very lamely to blame National for the high migration in October 2008, arguing it should have reduced because National was ahead in the polls.

Now I think one doesn’t even have to try and respond to the lame attempt to blame National for migration figures that are for the month before the election. But it does raise the issue, when should you start holding a new Government accountable? Is it the Nov 2008 figures? Dec 2008?

A tend to to think 9 – 12 months is the usual lead in time you look for, to expect a Government to be “accountable” for various statistics. Accountable doesn’t mean they have a hell of a lot of control over them, but means that the country is now operating under the new policy settings.

Very few people or companies change behaviour just because a Government changes. Employers don’t go out the day after the election and start advertising new jobs they were holding off on. Expats don’t suddenly pack up their homes and get the next flight home.

What they do respond to, is policy changes. And generally it takes nine or more months to pass a law, and you have to wait until the budget in May next year for changes in government spending and taxation – and those changes may be spread over the next year or so also.

Another key thing to look for is what was the trend up until the change of Government, and did the trend then change? For example In 1990 unemployment was skyrocketing andat the end of the year National came into power. Unemployment kept increasing for nine months, and then it turned about and declined for the next five years. I blame the increase from Dec 1990 to Sep 1991 on the mess inherited from the former Government.

Some stats will not turn around for years and years, if at all. If you accept part of the solution to outwards migration is wage levels, and you also accept that the solution to wage levels is increased productivity growth, well it is a very long-term project to increase productivity growth. So at first what you might look out for is not a reversal in the trend, but even a slowing.

The other thing to look for is not just measuring actual vs actual, but actual vs projected. For example National will have a bigger deficit in next year’s budget than Cullen will have this year. The correct comparison to look at will be the size of the deficit compared to the projected deficit from the DEFU next month.

Wellington Water Meters

The Dom Post reports:

Two of Wellington’s leaders are backing debate on a user-pays water system to reduce Wellingtonians’ reckless consumption – now more than twice the national average.

Wellingtonians each use 400 litres of water a day compared with Aucklanders’ 300 litres and a national average of 160 litres.

Of course water should be user pays. Food is.

International research showed charging people for the water they used could slash consumption by 20 to 40 per cent. This would ease pressure on the region’s water supply and delay the need to build a proposed $142-million dam for 20 years.

An excellent reasons to do it. This part was interesting:

  • Cleaning teeth – five litres per brush.
  • Shower: eight minutes under ordinary shower head – 120 litres. Eight minutes under water-efficient shower head – 80 litres.
  • Bath (full) – 200 litres.
  • Toilet half-flush – six litres.
  • Garden hose (on full) – 250 litres every five minutes.
  • Dishwasher – up to 25 litres a wash.
  • Washing machine: top loading – 100-200 litres. Front loading – 70-85 litres.
  • Dripping tap – 60,000 litres a year.

Kids Voting 2008

Local Government NZ, along with NZ Post, ran a simulated election amongst secondary school students alongside the general election. This is a great civics initiative and 13,000 voted.

And those who want a smaller Parliament will be delighted with the results – a Parliament of only 107 MPs!

How is this possible? It is an obscure feature called underhang – the opposite of overhang. Let us look at the results:

  1. National 28.4%, 36 seats, 29 elects, 7 list
  2. Labour 25.0%, 32 seats, 16 elects, 16 list
  3. Bill and Ben Party 11.7%, 15 seats, 0 elects, 15 list
  4. Greens 11.2%, 14 seats, 0 elects, 14 list
  5. Legalise Cannabis 10.5%, 13 seats, 0 elects, 13 list
  6. Maori Party 4.9%, 6 seats, 6 elects, 0 list
  7. ACT 1.9%, 2 seats, 1 elect, 1 list
  8. NZF 1.0%, 1 seat, 1 elect, 0 list
  9. United Future 0.7%, 1 seat, 1 elect, 0 list

Now the Bill and Ben Party only had two candidates (Bill and Ben!) on their party list, so there would be an underhang of 13 MPs for a Parliament of 107. This means to form a Government you need 54 votes. So what would the Government be?

You could do National 36 + ALCP 13 + Maori 6 = 55

More likely is Labour 32 + Greens 14 + ALCP 13 = 59

The electorate seat won by NZ First was actually in Tamaki, so their sole MP would be a Doug Nabbs.

They have given results for each electorate also. Below are the seats where a different party would have won the electorate vote if the kids were the real electors:

  1. Auckland Central – Labour
  2. Bay of Plenty – Labour
  3. Dunedin North – National
  4. Invercargill – Labour
  5. New Lynn – National
  6. Rimutaka – National
  7. Tamaki – NZ First
  8. West Coast-Tasman – Labour
  9. Whanganui – Labour
  10. Wigram – National
  11. Ikaroa-Rawhiti – Maori

It is great to see the kids encouraged to take part in mock elections and vote. The results do show though why the Greens are bonkers with their campaign to lower the voting age to include 16 and 17 year old schoold students.

Disagreeing with Garth George

Garth George says:

I have said it before and I say it again: The number one cause of abuse against women and children is abortion.

I disagree.

I think there would be less child abuse if there were more abortions.  The would would be a better place if those who are not suited to be parents did not become parents.

Tertiary Fees Cap

The Herald reports:

The New Zealand Vice-Chancellors’ Committee yesterday called on the National Government to view universities as national “infrastructure” that was in desperate need of investment.

The committee’s primary concern was that student financial support had been put ahead of university funding.

Victoria University vice-chancellor Pat Walsh said: “Put simply, the financial interests of students have been put ahead of the universities they attend.”

Th committee said the OECD average was for 82 per cent of government funding to be devoted to institutions and 18 per cent to student financial support. But in New Zealand 58 per cent went to institutions and 42 per cent to students.

The VCs are absolutely right. But you know they are a few years too late in complaining.

While in theory this would mean taking money from student’s allowances to give to the universities, University of Auckland chancellor Hugh Fletcher said “politically that’s not a reality, is it?”

Nope.

Professor Walsh said its preferred outcome was to get $230 million to $250 million a year from Government to avoid a “zero-sum game scenario of institutions versus students.

The VCs get 0/10 for timing. I presume they have read headlines about a decade of deficits, the recession getting worse etc.

The Vice-Chancellors’ Committee said if universities were not going to get increased funding, it would need more money from fees – which is prevented for domestic students by the “fees maxima” cap.

It said New Zealand’s fees were on average cheaper than in Canada, Australia and the United States.

Education Minister Anne Tolley said National’s policy was to retain the fees maxima “so no doubt we’ll disappoint them [vice-chancellors] with that”. She said there were no great plans to change the proportion of funding to students and to universities either.

The cap on fees tertiary institutes can charge is basically a crap policy. National I suspect knows it is a crap policy but pledged to retain it as Labour would have scaremongered about higher fees if you vote National. We have an inherited legacy of bad public policy, and sadly National has ruled out sensible reform.

The motivation behind a fees cap is to keep pressure on universities to keep costs (esp staff wages) down. But this turns universities into a competition for the lowest common denominator and makes universoty councils fall guys for the Government, just as DHBs are.

The Government sets the level of government subsidy and the level of student fees, yet leaves it to the institutions to take the blame for not being able to increase wages etc.

I prefer to keep costs down in universities by that dreaded word competition. I would let universities price their courses to meet demand. Why shouldn’t Vic Uni be able to make a commerce degree more expensive than an arts degree?

And competition is not just on price, but on quality. A law degree at Vic should cost heaps more than a law degree from Waikato, as it is far more highly regarded. Students should have the choice of a cheap B class degree or a more expensive A class degree.

Now don’t get me wrong – I don’t actually want fees on average to be increasing. I’d still want incentives to keep fees down. Some of those incentives will be competition. But the other is putting the right people on university councils. The Government should get rid of price caps, but put people on Councils who will support efficency measures, and strove to keep fees low. But at the end of the day the individual universities need to be able to control both their income and expenditure and be held accountable for it. Taking away any say over income, and making them responsible for expenditure only is not a sustainable model.

ANZ National moves to 20% deposits

It’s just got a lot harder to buy your own home. ANZ National are now requriring 20% deposits on home mortgages. Not that long ago 5% was all you needed.

This means that the median deposit needed will be $86,600 in Auckland, $73,800 in Wellington and $62,000 in Christchurch. And that has to be saved from after tax income.

The policy change is a logical consequence of the credit crisis, and of falling house prices. I suspect other banks may follow suit.

A fun evening

That was a long but fun evening. We had a pretty good crowd at the Wellington blogger drinks with around 30 people there. The drinks then morphed into Back Benches which had on Simon Bridges, Grant Robertson, Metira Turei and John Boscawen. All four were strong performers in my opinion. The new MPs have given Back Benchers a renewed lease of life.

There would be close to 100 people in the bar for Back Benches. Many of the new younger MPs in attendance, and you know its a really nice environment to socalise across the political boundaries. The inhouse parliamentary bar isn;t heavily patronised, so Back Benches may end up becoming the de facto weekly gathering for MPs, journalists and groupies 🙂

A few of us heading to Hummingbird after the Backbencher closed and I got home around 2 am, so that was a nice nine hours on the turps.

If National had not won

The Herald on Sunday wrote an article in advance for their 9th of November edition. It was the one they would run if John Key had not won on the night. Normally these would never see the light of day, but they accidentally filed it , it seems. So here is what you would have read the day after the election if National had not won:

SO SURE OF AN OUTRIGHT WIN WERE NATIONAL STALWARTS LIKE FORMER MP KATHERINE RICH THAT SHE REFUSED TO COMMENT LAST WEEK ON THE POSSIBILITY OF KEY NOT BECOMING PRIME MINISTER “BECAUSE IT’S JUST NOT GOING TO HAPPEN”
865 words
Nov 9th 2008 12:30pm Newspapers/Nz Herald

On page: 26

IT WASN’T meant to happen this way. So sure was John Key that he had this one in the box that he didn’t have an option two.

So sure of an outright win were National stalwarts like former MP Katherine Rich that she refused to comment last week on the possibility of Key not becoming prime minister “because it’s just not going to happen”.

Now Key has fluffed his big chance, not by losing outright but by allowing Helen Clark enough room to stick a Labour toe in a door that he was supposed to have slammed shut.

Now the voters can do nothing but wait while the negotiators do the deals that will ultimately decide who governs. While Key is a master dealer when it comes to investment banking, it is Clark who has an extraordinary ability to negotiate coalitions, partnerships and support agreements that most people wouldn’t have thought possible. If the Maori Party emerges as the kingmaker, punters are predicting Clark will have the upper hand.

Now the Dream Team, Key and his sidekick Bill English, face another three years in Opposition, another three years before the ambitious 47-year-old leader of the National Party gets another crack at what has been a lifelong dream.

And have another crack, he will.

Broadcaster and political commentator Bill Ralston predicts Key will be “pissed off to hell” with the loss but will treat it as a setback rather than a failure. He would use the next three years to hone his skills, Ralston said. “This is a guy who has never failed at anything.”

Party insiders doubt there is a chance Key will spit his dummy, quit politics and go back to the lucrative investment banking career that made him a very rich man.

That there will be no leadership challenge is in little doubt. “There is no question he will remain a strong uncontested leader of the Opposition,” MP Murray McCully said. “He will be unrivalled, unchallenged.”

He, like others, doubts Key had thought about a Plan B.

“He’s always been the sort of guy who from the time he thought he might take the job on has only ever had one scenario in mind.”

That innate confidence grew more evident as the campaign progressed, as Key’s media training paid off and as he took more risks _ like discounting a union with New Zealand First leader Winston Peters outright.

Ralston said the only way the National Party would lose Key now was if Caucus voted him out. “And I don’t think they have another alternative leader there. Bill English might think he is but the Caucus are aware that Key is the man.”

One National MP said he had never seen a more disciplined and unified caucus.

Whether English would even want the job is up for discussion. A source close to the inner circle doubted English would make a run for the leadership.

“He’s got the best of both worlds. He’s a family man, a committed Catholic with a busy working wife. He’s got plenty of power and influence without carrying the top dog title.”

And despite this loss, National’s polling leaves the party as a strong Opposition, a position Key is credited with achieving. In the next three years Key would have “more mana and authority than any leader of the National Party going back a long way,” one insider said.

Yesterday’s achievement in terms of the party vote would be recognised as being “substantially the result of his [Key’s] leadership”, he said.

“His stocks are very high. He’ll have a good deal of authority.”

He predicted he would be a “powerful and untouchable leader of the Opposition.”

Observers say Key will waste no time in reshaping the National Party, purging the old guard in the process. Ralston expects to see a new lineup which includes younger faces and a more diverse mix in terms of gender and ethnicity before long. Many of the old guard will “take the hint and the nudge”.

“I think he will very quickly take a knife to the party… that’s going to be a risky process because at the same time you destabilise your Caucus support.”

That he’s capable of the hard decisions is unquestioned. Back in the 90s, Key earned the nickname “smiling assassin” after implementing mass sackings for Merrill Lynch.

Ralston expects heavy scrutiny by Key of what went wrong in the campaign because there was “no shortage of money this time round”.

That would include looking at what tactics didn’t work, the party marketing and organisation, and the billboards and television ads.

The “Mr Nice Guy” strategy would be called into question, he said, and whether the party should have used “attack” advertising and Key should have come across as more assertive.

Blogger Russell Brown of Public Address described the Labour victory as a “bugger the pollsters” moment. “In the end people have responded to the trust message. Maybe in the end they didn’t trust John Key enough.”

Ralston predicted that Key would spend the next three years making sure he earned that trust.
Source: Herald On Sunday
Credit: Herald On Sunday

Katherine was very smart in refusing to comment in advance on the possibility of National not winning. I presume all the other people quoted in the article did comment hypothetically.

Incidentally congrats to Katherine for her appointment as CEO of the NZ Food and Grocery Council. The FGC represents $15 billion of sales and $3.5 billion of exports, and Katherine’s background in agri-business make it a great role for her.

Bill voted National

Bill Ralston blogs on how he is a regular Labour voter (cancelling out his wife he claims) but that this time he did break pattern to vote National. He states:

The sad truth is my wife insists on having her own political views. I blame those who gave women the vote in the first place. For many years we each cancelled out the other’s vote come polling day.

However, I must admit this year I drifted to the view that Labour was running out steam, out of ideas and out of office. I thought it was time it went and voted accordingly. That doesn’t mean if National performs badly over the next three years it will retain my vote. A Phil Goff-led Labour government is not a scary prospect and given a good excuse I will happily revert to form.

Now, it would be very nice if everybody else who writes about politics let their readers know which way they voted, otherwise I’m going to feel very exposed indeed.

Well I voted National with both ticks. I did give some quite serious consideration to voting ACT though – to reward Rodney for his work with Winston.

I have once voted Labour – the first time I could vote. But it was 1987 and they were the better alternative.

The challenge for John Key is indeed to keep voters like Ralston. They’re urban liberals who won’t be worried by a Phil Goff led Labour, so National needs to give them reasons to stay with National.

Noelle McCarthy

The Sunday Star-Times did a large and prominent story on Noelle McCarthy and raised issues about whether some of her verbal on air essays were too similiar to articles from various European newspapers.

I’m possibly somewhat biased on this issue as the GPS system in my car is called Noelle, but I think David Cohen’s blog on this issue is very apt:

we feel like offering a bit of solidarity towards Noelle McCarthy over the media treatment she received this past weekend, when a small number of her articles and columns were deemed of sufficiently compelling interest by the Sunday Star-Times to warrant a manifestly overlong story on their purported similarities with a number of previously published British pieces.

Despite having spent the better part of a week poring over McCarthy’s efforts, reporter Kim Knight came up with nothing more earth-shattering than the fact that McCarthy reads fairly widely when it comes to British papers, and yes, she had probably been a bit naughty in riffing a little too hard on a few of their recent reports. But did that pretty inconsequential discovery justify anything more than a small aside in a media column?

Cohen has written a lot on plagiarism:

As it happens, we’ve spent some effort in the past looking at real plagiarism scandals — you know, the ones involving entire chapters of books, existing scholarly essays and questions of wholesale academic integrity — and we’ve also ribbed McCarthy from time to time over other matters.

And David has shown, at the link he provides, that he has and will ping McCarthy when she deserves it. He also pings me often when I deserve it 🙂

Bus his conclusion here:

Involving as it does just a few words and the odd phrase here and there, this latest one simply doesn’t make the serious cut. Especially not in a country where slapping new intros on to a press release and running the lot as a news piece is standard fare among many overworked reporters.

There is a fine line between when you do and do not need to attribute, and Noelle was probably on the wrong side of that line with a couple of her on air pieces, but as Cohen says I don’t think it warranted such a big story, and you do wonder if the fact she also writes a column for the SST’s rival newspaper was a factor.

Seven useless facts

A meme is going around where you have to list seven useless facts about yourself. M and M tagged me. And Busted Blonde has the best facts to date:

3 – I have killed approx 40,000 muttonbirds by crushing their brains with my teeth severing the brain from the brain stem causing instantaneous death. Consequently one of my back bicuspids is buggered.
4 – I co-negotiated a $11.2m Maori land settlement package on land that wasn’t our family’s – and got paid $210 for it.
5 – I once wrote a press release about extracting semen from bees

So my seven:

  1. As a child I hated seafood and wouldn’t eat it, but now can’t live without it.
  2. As a student, I once was found under a hedge impersonating a hedgehog.
  3. The first time I entered the University of Otago Library was to attend a meeting of the Library Committee, to which I had been appointed.
  4. American Pie (the Don McLean version not the devil spawn version) is my all time favourite song
  5. I am an excellent skier, and have worked on a ski field.
  6. I wanted to be a doctor, when I was growing up and worked during holidays for several years in a medical laboratory.
  7. My first job after university was as a secretary to a group of psychologists

I won’t tag anyone as many alreayd have done this, but people are welcome to tag themselves.

Taxpayers pay for PI to watch TV

It’s bad enough we have a stupid law that bans adverts on television on Sunday mornings. God knows why.

But even worse, the taxpayer through the Ministry of CUlture and Heritage paid a private investigator to watch the quarters, semis and final of the Rugby World Cup, so they could prosecute TV3 for showing advertisements.

TV3’s defence is they were also broadcasting to an overseas audience, which is an exemption.

But why on Earth did the taxpayer need to fund a private detective to watch and record a TV show? Was this beyond the dozens of staff at MCH? Does MCH not have any video recorders? Do none of the staff have any video recorders?

Hat Tip: Whale Oil

Minto blames Goff et al for Nia Glassie’s murder

John Minto has worked out who is to blame for the murder of Nia Glassie:

There is never any excuse for abuse of children and it’s natural for us to want long prison sentences for her killers. However, unless we clearly see the context in which she was killed then we will condemn other children to similar abuses.

Yes the context of what makes people stick a toddler in a drying machine to torture her.

As Nia Glassie lay dying in hospital last August the New Zealand Herald published figures related to child abuse among Maori. Social issues reporter Simon Collins reported that Maori children were more than twice as likely to die from child abuse as other children but that this was a relatively recent development.

In 1987 child abuse deaths for Maori were on a par with the rest of New Zealand. From 1978 to 1987 the number of children aged 0 to 14 per 100,000 killed was 0.92 for non-Maori and 1.05 for Maori.

However from 1987 it rose rapidly. For the period 1991 to 2000 the figures were 0.67 for non-Maori but 2.40 for Maori.

This dramatic increase has obvious roots. The number of Maori in paid work dropped by 15 per cent between 1986 and 1991 while total employment fell just 6 per cent. Maori unemployment peaked at a staggering 26 per cent in 1991 while the non-Maori rate was just 9 per cent.

Maori were disproportionately degraded by the policies of Rogernomics under Labour’s 1984 to 1990 government.

Yet those who killed her did so in a time of near full employment. But hey let us ignore that and blame it all on Rogernomics.

Those who demand vengeance for Nia Glassie’s death would be better to first set up a gallows outside Parliament and the Business Roundtable offices before they focus on the miserable men guilty of her murder.

Yeah, nothing to do with those who tortured a three year old. Or the neighbours who did not report it. The guilty parties are those who saved a country from bankruptcy.

The most important solution to ending child abuse is to make full employment the number one economic priority. Forty hours work on decent pay by which a breadwinner can support a family in dignity and respect must be at the heart of social and economic policy. Not surprisingly it was dropped as Labour Party policy back in the 1980s by the likes of Roger Douglas, Helen Clark and Phil Goff while it’s never been National Party policy.

So Douglas, Clark and Goff plus National are all to blame. Again never mind that at the time this happened unemployment was the lowest in the world.  I think it is reprehensible of Minto to try and blame this sociopathic torture and abuse on the economic policies of 20 years ago.

Anything less than this is to cry crocodile tears for Nia Glassie and condemn more children to her fate.

You don’t get full employment by turning a country into Cuba, as Mr Minto advocates. You get it by having a strong economy.

Agenda dead – for now

Very sad to see Agenda killed off by TVNZ. It has been a very influential show, with comments made by MPs on the show often causing headlines for some days.

Ironically thanks to the change of Government, Agenda may be able to continue on another channel. It depends how quickly the policy changes can be implemented.

A&E Waiting Times

Idiot/Savant is sceptical of the planned policy to have maximum waiting times for A&E. He claims that in the UK, the response to such targets was:

The policy is based on UK Labour’s attempts to improve quality in the NHS by introducing these sorts of absurd targets, and Ryall claims that policy was a success, having led to a reduction in the number of patients waiting for than four hours from 23% to 3%. But that success was an illusion. As noted in Adam Curtis’ documentary, The Trap, faced with pressure to improve their statistics, NHS managers created a new and unofficial post, the “Hello Nurse”, whose sole purpose was to greet new arrivals to A&E so they could claim for statistical purposes that the patient had been “seen”. Faced with a similar target aimed at reducing the number of patients waiting on trolleys in corridors, they simply removed the wheels from the trolleys and reclassified them as beds.

I’m not sure whether to be appalled or impressed by the ingenuity – reclassifying trolleys as beds!

The targets were met, but the underlying performance didn’t change one iota. Mangers being managers the world over, the same is likely to happen here. It’s a general problem with this sort of empty managerialism and obsession with statistical targets: the statistical goal – measured patient “waiting time” – ends up taking the place of the real goal – patient care. And doctors and nurses end up spending all their time filling in performance spreadsheets rather than doing what they’re supposed to be doing: seeing patients.

Idiot/Savant arguments would be stronger, if the status quo had not failed so badly. Under Labour we have had $3.5 billion of exra funding for health, no targets for A&E, and the result has been 20% of people waiting for more than eight hours.

Why does he think throwing more money at it, without targets will work? Can he cite an example in the world where it does?

As I said yesterday, the benefits of targets are it creates transparency. DHBs can cost what the cost will be to meet the six hour target. Dedicated funding can be applied for. If the Government refuses, then people can hold the Government accountable.

Rather than clinging to the dead 80’s cult of managerialism, National should target the real problem: lack of resources. The reason people have to wait so long in A&E is because hospitals cannot afford to employ enough medical professionals to deal with demand.

And without a target to aim for, how on earth can one calculate what it would costs to have the extra staff?

The reason they are parked on trolleys in hospital corridors is because there is not enough space. But solving these problems would cost money, which National would rather give to the rich in tax cuts. It’s just a question of priorities – and National clearly rates redistributing wealth to those who need it least well ahead of ensuring that every kiwi has decent access to healthcare.

And now we just get the blind slogans, instead of intelligent analysis. Idiot/Savant is not stupid. He has read National’s fiscal package. He knews that the tax cuts are being funded almost entirely out of changes to KiwiSaver. Not from less spending on Health.

In fact National has pledged significant funding to train up more doctors, to set up 20 new surgicial wards etc etc.

The Herald editorial is supportive of the policy:

It is also all the more reason to welcome Health Minister Tony Ryall’s plan to impose maximum patient waiting times on emergency departments, and to hold district health boards and their management accountable for meeting them. His initiative is sure to attract criticism. Such targets are always something of a crude measure, if only because they fail to give sufficient recognition to quality of care, which should, ideally, be hospitals’ paramount concern.

The target are no silver bullet, but frankly we should be debating why we have never had them before, not be surprised that these minimum measures of accountability are being introduced.

But Mr Ryall can be excused for starting at this point. There is a sense that, while the Labour Government increased the health budget by more than $3.5 billion, too much of this was swallowed with little discernible increase in efficiency. There were neither quantitative nor qualitative improvements. At the very least, targets incorporated into performance agreements will lay the foundation for better results by increasing accountability in emergency department operations.

Indeed. The status quo has seen massive funding and little way to judge how well utilised that funding was. Now that is great if you are Minister of Health, but not good for patients and taxpayers. This si why I said Ryall’s policy was brave – it actually creates an accountability for him as as Minister that was previously lacking.

Seatbelts for Tractors

Chinese Bloggers

An interesting article on the positive impact Chinese bloggers are having:

Tens of millions of mice over-ran China’s internet trap this year, swamping it with chatter, nibbling towards freedom of speech.

Riots in Tibet, the Sichuan earthquake, an under-age Olympic hero, poisoned milk, official corruption, and even a fake tiger sighting – China’s top news stories this year took on new life in the blogosphere.

The twisted reports and deliberate silence of the Communist Party’s traditional propaganda machine – state-owned newspapers and television – were held to ridicule by swift-moving mice that scrutinised, uncovered and spread little pieces of competing truth

Yay.

The number of bloggers in China doubled to 107 million in the six months to last June, according to the China Internet Network Information Centre. Total users rose 56 per cent from the previous year, to 253 million, giving China the largest online population in the world.

Mr Mao says he can see a tipping point coming. He believes that as a result of blogging, young Chinese brainwashed by their education system are now trying to think for themselves, work together and find smarter solutions.

Sounds hopeful.

Does Wellington want technology or not?

Very disturbed to read in the Dom Post:

Public anger over a proliferation of cellphone towers and broadband cabinets has prompted Wellington City Council to look at tightening controls on communication companies.

Council planners have received applications covering more than 170 sites from telecommunication companies this year.

They include more than 100 roadside cabinets, each the size of a large fridge, to be installed in Wellington as part of Telecom’s “cabinetisation” programme for faster broadband.

Also included are 70 applications from NZ Communications, which is establishing a national mobile network.

Complaints from residents and business owners over the proliferation of towers and cabinets prompted Mayor Kerry Prendergast to seek a review of the council’s district plan rules.

The rules allow almost all telecommunication installations on council-owned reserve land, and on land next to roads, to proceed unhindered.

Did any of those people complaining have a cellphone or use the Internet? If so, their complaints should be ignored as hypocritical.

Any Councillor that votes to change the rules should also surrender their cellphone and Internet connection.

We have national guidelines on safety for such installations. It would be madness to have every single cabinet and tower go through its own resource consent process, even if they comply with existing rules.

Blog Bits

  1. Busted Blonde has a post on domestic violence and how she spent several years in an abusive relationship. Go read it, and make sure you show it to any friends who need to read it.
  2. Adam Smith blogs on the Giles cartoons. As a child I loved Giles cartoons, and every year could not wait for the annual. Grandma was my favourite character. For those who never saw them, you missed out on classics.
  3. Matthew Hooton makes the case for an Upper House.
  4. Steven Price reviews two decisions by the Advertising Standards Authority.
  5. Matt Nolan wants some better statistics from the Government.