Transtasman Campaign Winners and Losers

Transtasman rates the campaigns:

Campaign Winners And Losers

Winston Peters: Harder to kill than Rasputin, but his number looks up. Often truculently silly (eg the helicopter business). So no win, or No, Win.

The Maori Party: Looks like hanging onto its four seats but may not add any more. They’ve done OK, but not as well as they were expected to.

The Greens: The billboard campaign “vote for us” was outstanding. They will pick up a lot of disaffected Labour voters. Light bulbs, water pressurre and how to bring up your kids also featured. A couple of extra MPs at least look likely.

Peter Dunne? A good Minister of Revenue: his strength and his weakness. Such types seldom build lasting political forces. Will be able to hold Caucus meetings in front of his mirror as he does his spectacular hair.

ACT? Toned down the flakiness we’ve seen over recent years, but still ran an erratic campaign. May peel some votes off the right of National on the back of law and order issues. Three seats, max.

Labour/Helen Clark: Can’t see a belt without hitting below it. Too much rhetoric about what happened 15, 20, 25 years ago. A nasty, negative campaign unworthy of the party’s better side.

National/John Key: Did two winning things: after a shaky start he shed the smart-alecky 6th former demeanour he often adopts, and he refused to get into the gutter with Clark. Best line: Rich is when you can payyour credit cards and your power bill.

A nasty, negative campaign indeed.

What a coincidence

We read today about the secret taper, Kees Keiser. And his preposterous story about how he did it on the spur of the moment, and didn’t tell anyone about it.

Well according to the electoral roll/habitation index, Mr Keizer has a flatmate. A Mr Stephen Day. Now it is possible the roll is out of date, but this post is on the assumption it is accurate – and just before an election you expect it to be.

And what does Stephen do? He is employed by Ministerial Services and acts as a liaison between Labour and the Greens!! – officially on the issue of Buy NZ made. This means he is taxpayer funded through Ministerial Services yet works for Sue Bradford on behalf of the Labour-led Government.

Stephen appears to be a professional unionist, having worked for OUSA, NZEI, SFWU and Finsec before his latest job.

Now I am sure we will be told that Mr Day had no idea what his flatmate was up to. That he never even whispered a word to him, and that he spent all that time making audio recordings without being noticed.

I will let readers apply their own Tui test of credibility to this one.

UPDATE: I need to make a retraction. I got it wrong.

I described the relationship between the secret taper and the senior Labour/Greens Advisor as flatmates.

They are in fact brothers-in-law.

Doctors and Nurses may not get paid

The final legacy of Labour’s healthcare policy. The Capital and Coast District Health Board has a $70 million budget blowout (funny how the Minister has not sacked them even though he sacked the Hawke’s Bay one for a far far smaller sum).

The DHB has said if it does not get bailed out, it may be unable to pay staff wages. I can’t imagine staff will work without getting paid somehow.

Media Coverage of the NZ General Election

Tessa Houghton is a PhD student at the School of Political Science and Communication of the University of Canterbury and has been working on a study that has been conducted into the NZ media coverage of the 2008 election by Dr. Babak Bahador.

This study is based on a content analysis of the leading New Zealand newspapers (New Zealand Herald, Dominion Post and The Press) and television news programmes (TV1 and TV3 evening news).  The entire study is conducted over an eight-week timeline beginning from Helen Clark’s announcement of the election date on 12 September 2008 and ending on Election Day (8 November 2008).  The findings of this particular document only cover the first six of these weeks (12 September to 24 October).  Over the first six weeks, 574 stories were analysed.  It is expected that the entire study will incorporate over 900 stories.

The full preliminary results can be found here – new-zealands-media-coverage-of-the-2008-election-study-preliminary-results.

Some extracts:

Media coverage: Labour 37%, National 35%, Maori 9%, Greens 8%, NZF 5%, ACT 3%, UFNZ 2% and Progressive 1%

But then the breakdowns:

The tone of coverage is very interesting though. They divided coverage up into positive, neutral and negative. The net positive or negative coverage is:

  1. Maori +13%
  2. Greens +13%
  3. UFNZ +5%
  4. ACT -3%
  5. Labour – 7%
  6. Progressive – 10%
  7. NZ First – 10%
  8. National – 24%

They also compared total media coverage to the average support a party has in the polls. The difference between the two was:

  1. Maori +6.3%
  2. UFNZ +2.0%
  3. NZF +1.9%
  4. Greens +1.6%
  5. Labour +1.3%
  6. ACT +1.3%
  7. Progressive +0.9%
  8. National -13.6%

Then we have the tone of media coverage of the leaders. And the net positive over negative was:

  1. Anderton +19%
  2. Dunne +10%
  3. Turia/Sharples +6%
  4. Fitzsimons/Norman +2%
  5. Clark -1%
  6. Peters -11%
  7. Key -13%
  8. Hide – 15%

So Key and Hide had more net negative coverage that Winston!!!

In terms of issues, the major ones were:

  • Economy 25%
  • Tax 12%
  • Law & Order 10%
  • KiwiSaver/Super 8%
  • Immigration 8%
  • Maori Issues 6%
  • Health 6%
  • Education 6%

They also looked at overall coverage of policy issues compared to non-policy issues (polls, coalitions etc) and found the split 57% to 43% only. Should be 80:20 or more in my opinion. The only policy issue that got more coverage that either the polls or coalition options was the economy.

A fascinating study and thanks to Tessa for a copy. I look forward to seeing the full study after the election.

EPMU Donations

The shower ad

Final US election results

The final electoral college counts looks to be 364 for Obama and 174 for McCain. North Carolina and Missouri are not final but look to go to Obama and McCain respectively. That is around the scale of Clinton in 1996 who won by 379 to 159.

On the popular vote Obama has 63,687,862 to 56,283,891 for McCain – 53% to 46%. Obama got around 1,600,000 more votes that Bush did in 2004.

The states Obama picked up from Bush are Florida, North Carolina, Virginia, Ohio, Indiana, Iowa, Colorado, New Mexico and Nevada.

In the Senate the Democrats did quite well but well back on their target of. They started with 51 seats (including two Independents) and now have 56 – picking up North Carolina, Virginia, New Hampshire, New Mexico and Colorado. Sadly they did not defeat Ted Stevens in Alaska.

In the House they picked up 19 seats and the balance is now 254 to 174 with 7 undecided.

The exit poll results are quite interesting also:

  • Obama vs McCain was 49% to 48% amongst men and 56% to 43% amongst women
  • White men went McCain 57% to 41% and white women 53% to 46%
  • Blacks went 95% for Obama
  • Latinos around 67% for Obama
  • McCain won over 65s 53% to 45% while Obama won under 30s by 66% to 32%
  • Obama won amongst the 6%  earning over $200K by 52% to 46%
  • 14% of white Democrats voted for McCain while 8% of white Republicans voted for Obama
  • 20% of Conservatives voted Obama
  • 11% were first time voters and they went Obama 69% to 30%

And then there were state ballots:

  • Arizona voted to bay gay marriage and hiring illegal immigrants
  • Arkansas banned gay couples adopting children
  • California also voted to ban gay marriage but against for parental notification of teenage abortions
  • Colorado voted to end against ending affirmative action and not to ban abortion by defining human life as beginning at conception
  • Florida voted to ban gay marriage
  • Maryland voted to allow a video lottery
  • Massachusetts voted not to repeal state income tax
  • Michigan voted to allow medical marijuana and stem cell research
  • Nebraska voted to end affirmative action
  • South Dakota voted not to ban abortion except for mother’s health, incest or rape
  • Washington voted to allow doctor-assisted suicide

Many of the state polls will be found to be unconstitutional and never put into effect incidentally.

Ironic?

The Herald is running a caption contest.

The irony that strikes me is Jeanette is pro-choice (as am I) so personally that is one media stunt I would stay away from.

I’m not doing comments on this post as I don’t want it to turn into a debate on abortion. I just wanted to highlight the irony.

Armstrong calls it for National

John Armstrong writes:

It feels like it is all over, red rover.

The shouting won’t stop completely until campaigning has to come to a halt tomorrow evening. But rarely has the final week of an election campaign been so flat and devoid of any sense of a fight. Rarely has it seemed as if everyone is now merely going through the motions until Saturday finally rolls around. …

The feeling of fait accompli was apparent before today’s Herald-DigiPoll survey, which has a clear majority of voters rating a National-led Government as better equipped than Labour to handle the economy, with even more voters thinking National is going the win the election. …

However, the widespread feeling among those observing this election with no axe to grind is that over the last week the election has slipped away from Labour. The pervading question is no longer whether Labour has any chance of winning. It is now the margin by which National will win.

Time will tell. But my feeling is since the H-Fee smear backfired Labour has had no forward momentum. And it is possible even the secret tapings are backfiring on them – there seems to be a revulsion about the tactics – not from partisans like me but everyday people.

A National-led Cabinet

Audrey Young looks at possible roles in a National Government:

United Future leader Peter Dunne would be the prime contender for Speaker if National formed the Government after Saturday’s election, the Herald understands.

I’ve heard of this possibility for some months. It depends I suspect on how well United Future goes. If only Peter is returned, then Speaker would make a lot of sense. If he gets one or more MPs coming back with him, a Ministerial role makes more sense. For my 2c I think Peter could be a very good Speaker, and very impartial. But he has also proven himself as a competent Minister.

Act leader Rodney Hide could be put in charge of prisons – as well as Inland Revenue.

Hell that is a good idea. Rodney could well sort out Corrections and I love the idea of him being in charge of IRD! It would also allow ACT input into tax policy which I fully support.

And new National MPs Steven Joyce and Hekia Parata could leap-frog incumbent members straight into the Cabinet.

The day they announced Steven’s list ranking, I concluded he would go straight into Cabinet. I’ve also regarded Hekia as the only other new entrant who could credibly go straight in. Not as certain as Steven but definitely a possibility.

If, however, National or Labour needed a support agreement with the Maori Party, co-leader Pita Sharples would be likely to get Maori Affairs and Associate Education.

The Maori Party co-leader, Tariana Turia, would be likely to get a portfolio within the Ministry of Social Development, and Associate Health.

Tariana in welfare would be great. And Sharples in Maori Affairs could lead a devolution of government spending in key areas to Maori providers rather than the state.

Guest Post

A guest post from Peter McKeefry:

This election we all have an important role to play. We need to elect a government that will guide us through troubled economic waters. However, we want more than that – we want a government who will promote New Zealand, grow New Zealand, and ensure New Zealand prospers. I also look for a government that promotes self-responsibility and self-determination. Normally I would not have bothered with including in my list a Government that would protect democracy – as I would have thought that would be a given – but after the lies and deceit of the Pledge card fiasco and then the democracy corrupting Electoral Finance Act, I now believe that protection of our democracy is more important than all my other key triggers.

So who will I support and why?

I live in Wellington Central – so I have a choice of voting for either Stephen Franks, or Grant Roberston. Both are good people and would do a great job as Wellington’s representative. However Grant supports Labour and does not see anything wrong with the electoral Finance Act. He told me that it is not an election issue. I will never support anyone who supports that insidious piece of legislation. Grant is probably waving the Labour flag on this issue – and I hope when National reform that piece of legislation, what is left of Labour will constructively contribute to wide cross party agreement. Labour will not get my vote for a whole variety of other reasons – including their hate of success (although they love to suck on the blood of the successful). I despise Labour because I believe there is nothing Clark will not do for power. On the other Hand I can and will vote Stephen Franks. His has major intellectual grunt. He is a hard worker and has been successful in his career as a lawyer and as a politician. Stephen has similar values to myself and I will be proud to have him represent me and my family in Wellington Central. The Labour Party have been spreading lies about him – such is the mentality of the negative campaigning. I have taken much joy in ripping down those lies that are posted on private property around the city.

My personal choice for the party vote comes down to National and Act. National are scoring around 50% and almost definitely going to form the government – John Key will be Prime Minister come Monday. I believe John Key will become a great Prime Minister – and New Zealand will prosper under a National government. Nevertheless, John Key needed to march left to gather up and grow the vote from the 40% that Don Brash delivered in 2005 to the 50% support now enjoyed.

National need friends and John Key will build friendships with Act and the Maori Party. National being friends with Maori will be one of Labour’s greatest fears. National will deliver to Maori.

Act more than any other party in parliament stand for self-responsibility does. In a nutshell that is my main driver. For too long Labour has made the bed and tried to tuck us in so we have become dependant upon Labour. Very comfortable – maybe too comfortable.

A bit more welfare here and there – often for those who do not need it – Labour have bought votes of students, of middle classes, of families, the gay community, the welfare beneficiaries – given them a bit more each time an election comes around. Labour have avoided making hard decisions because hard decisions will lose them votes. The bed is becoming so comfortable that people are reluctant to get out of bed and go and do some exercise.

National cannot afford to burn off those people so have had to swallow hard and say they will maintain the status quo. Only Act will kick them out of the bed and tell them to get a life. National need Act to have the excuse to get the lazy sods out of bed.

So here in Wellington I am pleased that I can vote for Stephen Franks (ex Act MP) on my electorate vote and Party Vote Act.

Peter McKeefry
Mt Victoria

Kees Keizer

The NZ Herald has an interview with the secret taper – Mr Kees Keizer. He claims it was all a sort of spur of the moment thing. As Tui says yeah right.

Speaking publicly for the first time, Mr Keizer said he came up with the idea to tape MPs at the cocktail party before National’s August conference on the spur of the moment

Yes of course. You’re sitting around a Friday planning what to do for the weekend, and you think hey I’ll go a cocktail party of a party I despise and try and tape them all. Of course that was spur of the moment, and wow I just happened to have a tape recorder in my pocket.

Mr Keizer said he took a digital recorder and had “legitimately” entered the conference by paying for a ticket – although he would not say what name he used.

Which is admitting he purchased it under false pretences.

Once Mr Keizer was in, he said he used his real full name and said he was interested in joining the Young Nats.

Actually he said he was a Young National, according at least one person who talked to him.

Mr Keizer has drip-fed the tapes to TV3 political editor Duncan Garner and refused to comment when asked if there would be more before the election. Mr Garner has indicated there could be more.

And of course something you do on the spur of a moment as a prank, you leak selectively to TV3 by anonymous e-mail timing each one for maximum political damage.

Mr Keizer said he had not edited the recordings to change the context but rather to keep his voice secret. He refused to release the full recordings so this could be tested.

And this tells us all we need to know. Now that his identity is known, there is no reason for him not to release a full recording. And the ethics of any media organisation that runs a selective extract will beyond doubt be tested with the Broadcating Standards Authority.

It was one thing to accept partial recordings when the sender was anonymous and wanted to keep his identity secret. But there is no ethical reason why TV3 could accept a partial recording now his identity is known. Doing so would indicate partisan motives rather than journalistic ones.

He said while he had friends and connections in the Labour, including those on the Labour-affiliated website The Standard, he also had friends in National too.

The Standard is the website where a blogger calling himself Batman posted about John Key’s supposed links H-Fee. That blogger is believed to be a senior official, most likely party president Mike Williams, although he has denied it was him.

The chances that his mates at The Standard don’t know all about it are nil, and as many of them are ministerial and parliamentary staffers, you can be sure Labour knows exactly what is in the tapes.

“I’d like to just absolutely confirm that I’m not a member of any political party and I’ve not been put into this by any political party or organisation.”

Of course he was not put up to it. The thought that Helen sits on the 9th floor ordering such tapings is ridicolous. But look at what he has not denied – that he has kept Labour informed of what is in the tapes, so they can plan their campaign around them.

Mr Keizer said his complaint about the EMA advert – made just days before the cocktail party – was not linked to Labour, but rather that he “wanted to learn more about the Electoral Finance Act and saw this as an opportunity.”

Now if anything confirms Keizer as an unmitigated liar, it is this statement. He complained about the EMA advert as an opportunity to learn more about the EFA!!!

“What you heard was genuine, there was no editing specifically to have it so it was in misleading quotes.” …

Mr Keizer said he would not be releasing the entire tape.

“Most of it is useless. It wouldn’t do any credit to anyone.”

So if he is telling the truth, why wouldn’t he release the full tape to show the full answers and what he said to elecit those answers? There is only one logical reason.

Final TV One debate

I’m struck by how civilised it is, and how often they both agreed with each other and backed each other’s answers up. Almost as if they were campaigning on the same ticket.

No big fuck ups and no home runs, so I don’t think any votes will swing on it. I will say I thought it was Helen’s best performance of the three debates – she talked like a real person and connected in a way she hadn’t with other debates. John did just that in the first debate, and of course again this time.

I actually say they are both joint winners – it was a good natured yet informative debate with minimal squabbling. Or so far anyway.

UPDATE 1: It’s only got more cordial. Someone must have spiked the fruit juice. I swear they’re going to hug each other at the end of the debate instead of the traditional handshake!

UPDATE 2: The debate makes me wonder if Labour polling tells them there has been a backlash over the H-Fee, secret tapings you can’t trust John agenda, because Helen talking about how John is a decent guy who just has different policies to her totally goes against their campaign to date of how you can’t trust him.

Anyway debates all over and two days to go. Yay.

Labour lets pack rapist Shipton out early

TV3 reported tonight that the parole board is letting pack rapist Brad Shipton out of jail in a couple of weeks despite the fact he hasn’t served even three years of his eight and a half year sentence.

How is it possible a pack rapist gets out of jail so quickly?

The answer is that Labour changed the law in 2001. Before they changed the law Shipton would have served around a minimum of six years of his sentence. But Labour changed the law to allow rapists to be eligible for parole after just one third of their sentence instead of two thirds.

This is the same Government that has also just made it easier for repeat offenders to get bail.

A goal for 2025

Lloyd Morrison has proposed a goal for New Zealand – to be in the top ten countries in the world by 2025 for GDP per capita. He writes:

New Zealand lacks a common purpose. No one knows exactly what we want. We hanker for a return to the times when we were one of the wealthiest countries in the world. We want everyone to be better off, knowing that individual wealth does not result in freedom from crime and the social fallout of excessive disparity. However, there is no clearly articulated goal we are pursuing and no solid plan of how we can get there.

As a result, there is no definition or accountability for policies or policy-makers. Policies are often clothed with loose positive objectives and ultimately ineffective aims. There is no co-ordinated accountability for these policies (or politicians) in terms of their ability to contribute towards a common measurable outcome. Consequently, we continue our steady decline. As the attached analysis shows, current forecasts have our GDP per capita slipping below Kazakhstan and Botswana by 2025.

I’ve been discussing this with colleagues and friends, and we believe that NZ needs to embrace a common objective that will provide the means to deliver what we are seeking as a nation.

Whatever the objective chosen, it needs to be simple, clear, measureable, understandable, aspirational and, most importantly, catalytic in terms of driving positive change that makes the outcome achievable.

We’d like to stimulate a broader discussion over what that goal should be for NZ. To kick-off the debate, here’s our starter for ten: NZ should aim to be back in the top 10 countries in the world based on GDP per capita by 2025. Not just the OECD, the world. Unachievable? No way. Ireland, Korea, Singapore and Taiwan all achieved the required level of growth over the last twenty years. It will take real collective commitment and more creative thinking about our economy – but that’s exactly what an ambitious goal will generate.

I’m hoping you’ll participate in a broader discussion about an aspirational, measurable goal for New Zealand. Please read the attached document. Pass it on to your friends. Participate in the debate by emailing [email protected] or contributing to the forum on www.blog.nzx.com. If you agree with what we’re proposing, show your support. If you don’t, please share your ideas for a national goal. Together, let’s take the first step in defining and delivering a better future for New Zealand.

Lloyd has out together this (a-measurable-goal-for-nz-short-2) presentation that is worth reading and also an FAQ – a-measurable-goal-for-new-zealand-_2_.

If you don’t like Lloyd’s goal, then suggest one of your own.

Obama is to be the 44th President

Dead on 5 pm, when the eastern polls close, the TV networks have called the race for Obama, with 287 electoral votes in the bag – 17 more than needed. He is the President-Elect of the United States and on the 20th of January 2009 will become the 44th President of the United States.

I predict he will get over 300 easily.

5.25 pm: McCain is doing his concession speech.

5.33 pm: Obama now has 333 votes to 155 for McCain. He has picked up Florida (27), North Carolina (15), Virginia (13), Ohio (20), Iowa (7), Colorado (9) and New Mexico (5). He also leads by 3% on the national vote or by 3,000,000 votes.

6.15 pm – and a great acceptance speech by Obama.

Kerr comments on big money in politics

Roger Kerr commented on yesterday’s blog post about big money on politics. I think this is Roger’s first comment on a blog post!

Roger made a few observations:

(i) Representative business organisations today typically take a national interest perspective, not a narrow, self-interested business perspective as in Fortress New Zealand days. The rationale is that what’s good for New Zealand is good for business in the long run, not the other way round. (Of course whether their advocacy conforms with that perspective should always be open to challenge.)

Thankfully it has been a long-time since business groups have demanded special favours for this sector, or that sector.

(ii) Consistent with (i), they routinely both support and criticise policy positions taken by all political parties.

Indeed, and groups like Business NZ have worked closely with the Labour Government on many issues – some might even say too closely!

(iii) It’s hard to fathom why some unions (eg EPMU) are so overtly partisan. Can this really be in the interests of their members? Governments change, as they should in a healthy democracy. How can they expect a sympathetic hearing for their members’ interests when they have publicly campaigned against a party that ends up in government?

Well the EPMU is a member of the Labour Party and hence can only be partisan. It does raise the question of how should a National-led Government deal with unions who have said their job is to get National kicked out of office regardless of what their policies are.

And as amusing as I find the CTU ads, I do wonder about the wisdom of being quite so partisan, that their influence with a new Government could be greatly reduced.

(iv) Unions in other countries seem less partisan and more willing to criticise the policies of ‘their’ parties, eg US unions in manufacturing industries on climate change issues.

Yes, some of the Australian unions also have been critical of ALP policies.

(v) Donations by corporates now seem to be very small, and are often split between parties.

So far the largest reported donation to National is $30,000. And I agree they are split between parties.

(vi) It would appear that the largest reported donation to a political party in recent years from a business source was that by Mr Owen Glenn to the Labour Party.

$500,000 to Labour plus $100,000 interest free loan plus $100,000 to Winston’s legal fees.

(vii) The most blatant case of business cash-for-favours in recent years would appear to be from racing industry sources to New Zealand First, whose leader Winston Peters has railed against ‘big business’ influence on politics.

I’m not sure ironic covers this situation adequately. I’m not even sure gross hypocrisy covers it.

Hooten on Garner

Matthew Hooton has a long post on why he thinks Duncan Garner was right to run the tape, but to put it in context. But he also gives an example of how the media may be relaying a lit, by not insisting on the full tape. His example is:

Labour Spy: Do you reckon Obama can win?

Key: Oh, I hope so, he’ll be a great president.  I’m actually looking forward to meeting him if I become Prime Minister.

Labour Spy: But you don’t think Americans will elect a black president?

Key: Sure they will.  There have been black mayors, black governors, black Secretaries of State, this is just the next step.  Sure there is still a lot of racism in the US – I saw it when I lived in New York, even way up in the North-East, and it is worse in the South – I still think Obama can win and it will be good for the world.

Labour Spy: Oh come on, New Zealand wouldn’t elect a bloody Maori boy PM ….

Key: Just wait a second.  I suppose you’re one of these racists who says ‘the American people aren’t going to elect some nigger boy their president, let alone have that black wife and those black kids in the White House.  He’s not even really an American’  … but if you think that you’re in the wrong party pal.

Labour Spy: Maybe, thanks for your time Mr Key.  I’ll go and talk to Bill English now.

And of course all that would be handed to TV3 is:

the American people aren’t going to elect some nigger boy their president, let alone have that black wife and those black kids in the White House.  He’s not even really an American’

Now that is a made up example by Matthew but a useful example of why it is important for media to treat extracts with caution. And remember this Keystone Kop who did the taping was deliberatly trying to entrap people by saying things he did not believe in.

US election thread

5.00 – the western states push Obama to over 270 and victory. A historic day.

4.34 – not looking likely that Democrats can get to 60 for the Senate. 58 is possible though. Electoral count now 207 to 135.

4.16 – Exit poll shows McCain getting 31% of Latino vote compared to Bush who got 40%. Electoral count now 207 to 95. Obama has won New Mexico, Iowa and Ohio

3.31 – It is Obama 200 and McCain 90. Ohio has gone to Obama and in Florida Obama leas 51% to 48% with 55% of precincts in. I think it is safe to now conclude Barack Obama will be the 44th President of the United States.

3.07 – in the Senate, Dems have picked up North Carolina, Virginia and New Hampshire. I think New Mexico also. That makes them 55. Will they make 60?

2.55 – the Democrats have picked up the Governorship of Missouri. For the US election no state has changed hands yet from 2004 – Florida and North Carolina plus Ohio should be the first to go if Obama is to win. With 43% of precincts reporting in Florida Obama ahead 52% to 48%,

2.52 – Obama 103 electoral votes to 69 for McCain. 270 needeed for a win. McCain ahead on popular vote just – by 13,000 votes. Dems now picked up three Senate seats so with their two Independents up to 54 seats.

1.40 – Obama leading in Florida by 13% but early days

1.12 – Democrats win one Senate seat – Virginia. Up to 52. They want 60.

For updates and discussion of the US election results.

Ideology kills

MacDoctor blogs on how Labour is placing ideology above patient care. He explains:

There is excess capacity in the private health system. There is also an ability in the private health system to provide even more excess capacity at relatively short notice. Most surgical clinics have been constructed to allow rapid expansion of wards and theatres, particularly if resource consents are streamlined.

There are thousands of people on elective surgical waiting lists who are waiting many months to years for operations. Most of them could have already had their operations if the private sector was allowed to properly partner with DHBs. Currently, most private sector “public” operations are done under limited contract – often 1 or 2 surgical sessions at a time. There is absolutely no incentive for the private hospital system to “flex up” as the huge demand is being dealt with in a piecemeal fashion.

This is bad enough for Mrs. Smith who has waited three years for her hip operation and can barely walk. It is life-threatening to those who need cardiac surgery or radiotherapy. I am certain that, if Saturday sees the return of a Labour government, the brand new radiotherapy clinic in Auckland will have a few patients sent to it by the DHBs – the ones who have waited well beyond a safe waiting time. There will, however, be no concerted plan negotiated between the DHBs and the new clinic to maximise this new resource, because Mr. Cunliffe is apparently nearly out of his comfort zone.

This means, to put it baldly, people will die because of his ideology.

He also dispels the myths around using the private sector more:

I hear objections to using private health care occasionally from my colleagues. Their objection is that, if you move these patients out of the public system, hospital doctors will eventually have insufficient variety of work to maintain their skill sets (”I’m in charge” Cunliffe puts it as “sucking capacity out of the public system – a nonsense phrase, if I have ever heard one). Apart from the dubious ethics of essentially denying people timely care in order to maintain a doctor’s skills (or non-existent theoretical hospital capacity), this objection does not hold water. Most of the surgery dealt with by the private clinics is low complexity. Private clinics usually lack ICU beds and so cannot deal with the very complex. What maintains your skills better – 10 routine hip replacements or three complex revisions? Removing a dozen easy appendixes or a couple of complex appendix masses?

He concludes:

So let’s stop this whining about privatising medicine and use all of our resources, both private and public, to get the medical care that people need. National’s thoughts on this are very promising, particularly the multiyear funding guarantee which will enable both public and private resources to expand capacity with confidence. Yet another reason to vote for the three-headed hydra. :-)

I note that the Herald uses the word “Elite” meaning “private”. I realise this is probably due to space constraints in their headline, but it is hugely insulting to those people who are having to mortgage or sell their homes in order to get the surgery they desperately need. I think we need to get past the place where we see private medicine as the domain of the wealthy and see it as a normal and valuable part of the entire health system.

This should be an op ed in a newspaper.

Disgraceful

The Herald reports:

Some Chinese voters are crying foul over Labour’s tactics to get the elderly to the ballot box early.

Botany resident Harry Lu plans to lodge a complaint with the Electoral Commission today after his mother-in-law was asked to cast her vote, and told who to vote for.

On October 24 she was taken by Labour officials to an early voting station at Panmure Library following a talk by Labour’s Chinese candidate Raymond Huo.

Lu alleges elderly Chinese voters are being taken to early-voting stations by officials, coerced into casting their votes early – and being told where to put their two ticks.

Mr Lu said in Mandarin: “I feel that the Labour Party is taking advantage of the vulnerability of elderly Chinese voters.”

His mother-in-law, who wanted to be known as Mrs Chen, 72, said she felt “cheated” after casting her vote because she didn’t get the chance to listen to the policies of other parties.

“I don’t even know who I voted for. I just followed the instructions of the Labour Party man on how to fill in my form because my English is not very good. He was standing right beside me and telling me what to write and where to put my ticks,” she said in Mandarin.

So is this a one off event?

Yesterday, the Blockhouse Bay Chinese Association held a meeting after some members said they had been pressured to cast their votes.

A 73-year-old New Lynn resident said she was told by Labour activists that there wouldn’t be any translators on election day, so she needed to vote early.

“I didn’t vote last time, and I was told that it was against the law, and I could be arrested,” she said.

Looks to be quite wide-spread.

How disgusting to prey on the fears of elderly voters like this, and exploit their lack of English skills.

All three years were false returns

The Electoral Commission has published further documents on New Zealand First, and they confirm that every single erturn they filed in the last three years was false. The 2005 and 2006 returns can not be prosecuuted simply because the time has expired.

The amended returns state the following amount of big donations:

  • 2005 – $87,684.83
  • 2006 – $67,083.33
  • 2007 – $80,000.00

So that is 234,768.16 that never was declared.

So why was 2007 not prosecuted:

The Secretary explained that the omission of the $80,000 donation was as a result of a misinterpretation of the Act. Legal advice received indicated that the Spencer Trust was “a body of persons involved in the administration of the affairs of the party” and as such when donations were made to the Spencer Trust those equated to donations to New Zealand First and the payment of the money from the Trust to the Party did not amount to another donation.

So the defence is she followed legal advice. The legal advice was wrong. I bet you we can all guess where that advice came from. This was the same legal advice that Winston did not have to declare the Owen Glenn donation. Possibly the same legal advice who gave false evidence to the Privileges Committee?

Also interesting that their argument was that the Spencer Trust was an integral part of the Party. This contradicts Winston who claimed it was independent.

The Electoral Commission accepts that the Secretary had no intention to mis-state the facts in respect of the return of party donations. The Commission also considers that under the circumstances it was reasonable for the Secretary to rely on what she had been told by the Party and by the Auditor, who is a professional and also relied on legal advice, in respect of the classification of the donations in question.

This is quite clever. There is no liability for the professional advisors if they give wrong advice, but the party secretary is protected because she got their advice.

I wonder if the law should be changed to have the Electoral Commission appoint the auditors for a political party, rather than the party?

Finally they note:

The matters the Electoral Commission was required to consider are governed by sections 214F to 214L of the Electoral Act. Those provisions apply in respect of the obligations and actions of the Party Secretary only. As a result the Commission has considered, and this decision pertains to, the actions of the Party Secretary only.

I advocated in my submission on the Electoral Finance Act that parties themselves should be able to be prosecuted for incorrect returns etc. The law currently only allows individuals to be charged, and you get situations like this when people can escape liability by not holding the correct role.

At the end of the day the important thing is that the public now know NZ First received $235,000 of donations over three years though the Spencer Trust, and that Winston has personally benefited by a further $140,000+ of large donations. This is the info that they went to such great lengths to keep from us.

The final CTU ad

The best ads this election have been the ones not from the parties. The CTU have alerted me to their final anti-National ad. Not as funny as their first couple but still a lot better than most out there. They try a bit too hard on this one, but the Borat part was good.

Labour loses Press Council complaint

The Press Council has rejected a complaint from a former Labour MP about its coverage of Labour’s transitional assistance package. What makes this issue especially interesting is that the former MP berated the Herald for publishign information that was different to what the Labour Party pamphlet said – even though the pamphlet was wrong.

So in fact she was complaing that the Herald told the truth, instead of running the incorrect information put out by Labour!

The Press Council has rejected a complaint against the Herald brought under fast-track procedures during the election campaign.

Rejecting a complaint about the Herald’s coverage last week of Labour’s just-announced Job Search Allowance, the council went further and praised the newspaper for not taking a party press release at face value.

How dare the naughty Herald not beleive what Helen tells them.

In an email of complaint to the editor of the Herald Tim Murphy, Ms Kirk said a fact sheet that would have been available to reporters showed that single and married people, solo parents and couples with children were all included.

But Mr Murphy said Ms Kirk had compared a discrepancy between the Herald article and the policy releases and assumed the newspaper was wrong.

Well by definition, the Prime Minister can not be wrong.

Mr Murphy said the Herald’s Press Gallery staff had complained loudly to the Prime Minister’s office about the “misleading nature of the material that was handed out”.

“Far from being worthy of a complaint to the Press Council, the Herald coverage of the Job Search Allowance was an excellent example of reporters doing their job properly – not accepting material presented by politicians at face value, and digging further for the facts for our readers,” Mr Murphy said.

In its ruling today, The council said: “Newspapers have a duty not to accept political statements or releases at face value, and the Herald acted correctly in subjecting the Job Search Allowance to scrutiny.

“It was entitled to reach the conclusions it did when reporting the initiative, even though it may not have been what the Labour Party would have wished. Without a doubt, the policy is aimed at families on two incomes. Why the press releases showed figures for single workers or solo parents who would not be eligible is something of a mystery.”

Not much of a mystery. They were hoping the media would help them con the public that Labour was promising something they were not.