Backbenches tonight

CTU submission on KiwiSaver

A birdie pointed this out to me. These are all quotes from the CTU’s submission on KiwiSaver

A key issue is the minimum worker contribution rate. We have previously submitted that there should be a 2% entry point in addition to 4% and 8%.

However, 2% is better than no contribution. Also a 2% deduction may be a better point of entry for new savers to establish a savings habit. The major concern is that thousands of workers will either opt out or not opt in to a KiwiSaver scheme because the minimum employee contribution rate is too high.

So what could possibly be the objection to a lower entry rate of 2%? If it is a concern that 2% from a worker (even with tax credits and employer contributions) will not deliver an adequate lump sum (or annuity) for retirement, then surely a lower than desirable balance is better than no balance.

Union officials are reporting that there is quite a lot of resistance among low income workers to join at a minimum of 4% of gross salary (which of course is more than 4% of take-home pay).

The fact is that there are now significant publicly funded benefits to belonging to a KiwiSaver scheme. In addition, the voluntary action of joining triggers employer contributions of up to 4%. It is therefore extremely unfair to set the bar too high at 4% minimum contribution and we urge the Committee to recommend a 2% option.

In this case, I am happy to agree with the CTU! Of course they do go on to say they would rather have a scheme where the employers pays 9% and employees 2% or something, but this will mean that low income workers who were funding KiwiSaver thorugh their taxes will now have a greater ability to go into it, and receive the generous 2:1 subsidies that apply to everyone earning up to $52,000 a year.

KiwiSaver and Superannuation

I really like the changes to KiwiSaver – it keeps the good parts of the scheme, makes it easier for low income employees to particpate, gets rid of much of the paperwork, reduces the overall cost to taxpayers (making it more sustainable in the long term) yet still has huge incentives to save.

I suggest people read the full policy paper.

  • Retain automatic enrolment of new employees, with the right to opt out.
  • Retain automatic deductions from a member’s wages or salary
  • Retain $1,000 ‘kick-start’ payment when people first join KiwiSaver
  • Retain the member tax credit, paid by the government into KiwiSaver accounts, which matches members’ contributions up to a maximum of $1,040
  • Retain compulsory matching employer contributions – but only for 2%, not 4%
  • Retain employer contributions exempted from employer superannuation contribution tax (ESCT)
  • Retain annual fee subsidy and the first home deposit subsidy
  • Still spend $800 million a year on KiwiSaver
  • Lower the minimum contribution rate from 4% to 2%, recognising how difficult it is for some people to put in 4%. Employees can still choose to put in 4% or 8%.
  • Lower the compulsory employer contribution to 2% also, to match. Employers can choose to put in more than that but 2% is the requirement.
  • Abolish the employer tax credit. Thank God for that – every employer in the land hates it – the paperwork creates more problems than the value of the credit. It makes it impossible to easily budget for staff costs also. The lower compulsory contribution matched with the abolishment of the tax credit means the overall impact on en employer with an employee on $52,000 is fiscally neutral – and no more paperwork!
  • Allow employers to pay staff who do not go into KiwiSaver more, but make it illegal to reduce someone’s pay if they choose to go in.
  • An employee on $50,000 will only have to contribute $1,000 a year to KiwiSaver and will get a total of $3,000 into their KiwiSaver account – a 200% subsidy. Previously they would put in $2,000 a year and get a total of $5,000 which is only a 150% subsidy. Either way it still represents a huge subsidy and you’re mad not to go into KiwiSaver.

There are also some bribes goodies on the wider superannuation issue:

  • Keep floor for National Super at 66% (under Labour is meant to revert to 65% again next year)
  • The tax cuts will see a couple on National Super getting $15 a week more in 2011 due to the link to the average after tax wage.
  • Lift the partner’s abatement threshold for Super from $80 a week to $100 a week

The full package

This compares the situation at the beginning of the year, to what it will be like in year three of a National Government.

Again any errors are mine. What it shows is a very significant package – earners in the $30,000 to $50,000 range get their tax bill reduced by 20% to 25%. Those on $100,000 get only a 12% reduction – and proportionally less as income grows (8.1% at $200,000).

Now Labour did deliver the first of the four stages of this tax cut package. They should get some credit for it. Sure it took nine years, lots of screaming, a previous package which they cancelled after the election, only did it because National and the public forced them to, and an admission now they in hindsight they wish they hadn’t done it, but for Labour that is as close as you will get 🙂

The rates used in this calculation are:

  1. 12.5% to $14,000
  2. 20% to $50,000
  3. 33% to $70,000
  4. 37% over $70,000
  5. A $520 rebate for incomes from $24,000 to $44,000 then abating at 13% until $50,000

2009 tax rates

I have done these myself. I think they are accurate but they were done quickly. If people spot an error, let me know.

This shows how much annual tax you pay at income levels as of today (taking into account Labour’s tax cuts) and how much your annual tax will be starting in April when National’s cuts would take effect.

The biggest percentage reduction in tax is those at the lower end of the income scale.

This is based on the following:

  1. 12.5% to $14,000
  2. 21% to $48,000
  3. 33% to $70,000
  4. 38% over $70,000
  5. A $520 rebate for incomes from $24,000 to $44,000 then abating at 13% until $48,000

Tables for 2011 to come.

$47 a week

The Herald reports:

A National government would introduce tax cuts for average wage earners of around $47 a week by 2011, party leader John Key said today.

Details yet to come. This includes the tax cuts we got last week.

UPDATE:

  1. A tax rate of 12.5% on income to $14,000
  2. 21% on income from $14,000 to $48,000 (moves to $50,000 in 2010 and rate drops to 20% in 2011)
  3. 33% for income from $48,000 to $70,000
  4. 38% for income from $70,000 (dropping to 37% in 2010)

Around 80% of taxpayers will pay a top marginal rate of no more than 20%. Hence secondary tax rates will shift to 20% for most.

Also a Independent Earner rebate of $10 to $15 a week for people not getting a benefit, Working for Families, or NZ Super, who earn between $24,000 and $40,000.

The long-term ambition is a top tax rate of 33%, but this will depend on economic conditions improving.

KiwiSaver

National is going to change Kiwi Saver from a 4% employer/4% employee scheme. It is going to make it 2% employer/2% employee and if conditions permit then lift that to 3% employer/3% employee. Note these are just the statutory minimums – employees can still put in more than 2% and employers can agree to higher contributions also.

The current KiwiSaver scheme (which I have often blogged support for) was set too high at 4%/4%. It was soaking up money needed today. As proof it was set too high, consider this. A 25 year old today on the average wage who went into KiwiSaver would have a higher income when they retire (including NZ Super) than they would have had during their working life (on the average wage). Now it is just nuts to have people earning more in retirement than they did while working. The 2%/2% scheme still has the incentive for the employee, but 4%/4% is part of what led to the projection decade of deficits.

Overall Package

The overall package announced by National isn’t just fiscally neutral – it is in fact fiscally positive by $283 million over three years. A small first step towards ending the projected decade of deficits.

But the bigger picture is growing the economy to pull out of deficit. $283 million won’t do it by itself. Putting more money into people’s pockets, rather than forcing it into super schemes that are currently losing money, will help. And moving to a flatter tax rate at the top end will also help economic growth in the long run.

National is also pulling back on its infrastructure package from $4.5 billion over six years to $3.7 billion over six years. That combined with stuff such as cancelling the MFAt expensaion plans will see debt tracking no higher than the status quo.

National have responded to the economic and financial crisis with a credible package that takes account of world events and a plan for economic growth. What is Labour’s response? Are they really saying that they don’t need to change anything from what they announced six months ago? Surely not. Labour need to reveals its policies and plans – if they have one.

Copyright and Select Committees

Colin Jackson from the Open Source Society has blogged a meeting between ICT reps and the Government over the new legal requirement for ISPS to terminate someone’s Internet account purely on the basis of allegations of copyright infringement.

The clause in question was in the original bill, and removed by the Select Committee (unanimously) as unnecessary as ISPs already terminate for illegal activity. The Select Committee also added on a clause to penalise people (up to $100,000 fines) who made false allegations of copyright infringement. This was also unanimously agreed to.

The Government then introduced at the Committee of the House stage an Supplementary Order Paper that reveresed both these changes made unanimously by the Select Committee. They put back in the provision for an ISP to be forced to terminate a customer merely on allegations of infringement, and even worse removed the penalty for false complaints.

What I found interesting from Colin’s blog was this explanation for why it was put back in:

When it opened, Judith Tizard spent 30 minutes telling us why the change had to be made. She began by strongly expressing her anger that we had complained to her at this stage in the proceedings. None of us, she said, had been to see her before this on this topic. When we protested that we had worked with the Select Committee, which had removed this provision – and balanced it with one which made licence holders liable for false accusations – this was completely inappropriate of the Select Committee, because Cabinet had already decided this was going ahead. We should not have been surprised, we were told, that this provision was reinserted by the government at the last minute before the bill was passed.

That is an interesting view on the roles of Select Committee. That it is completely inappropriate of them to mack changes that go against Cabinet policy.

So why do we bother with select committees?

The latest victim of the Electoral Finance Act

One of the nasty clauses of the Electoral Finance Act is it requires home or residential addresses to be used in all authorisatiion statements. There may be some merit in this for material put out by individuals, but for parties and organisations their registered office is all that should be needed – as was the case in the past.

Over the weekend four women stuck 1,000 (plastic( knives into the Bob McCoskrie’s lawn. They also placed an (ironically) anonymous note on his front door.

This is thuggish intimidatory behaviour. I have condemned mens rights groups for their antics outside the homes of Judges and lawyers, and this is even worse. It is clearly designed to intimidate.

It is possible the people responsible could have found Bob’s address even if he was not forced to have it on election material for Family First. But that is not the point – there is a difference between being in the White Pages and having to have your home address plastered on pamphlets, websites and billboards. I know of several women who have refused to be financial agents because they don’t want their home address published so widely.

Just another reason to vote for parties that will repeal the Electoral Finance Act.

Herald on Greens

And today the Herald looks at the Greens:

Performance rating this term: 6/10

Recovered and refocused after the death of Rod Donald soon after the 2005 election. Has spent the past three years forging itself as a party that can stand out of the shadow of Labour. Has had some policy gains, largely in one-off projects. However, has not been able to make any gains in the polls, despite growing public concern on environmental issues and Labour’s own low polling.

However the latest Colmar Brunton had them at 7%, so they may be starting to pick up support now – time will tell.

Assets and liabilities:

Sue Bradford is one of the party’s better-known faces, as a staunch advocate for social policies, and should be used more. All MPs are strong voices for their causes, the party has a diverse party list and does its research thoroughly for its policies. But it is still viewed as airy-fairy by some voters and as too “nanny state” by others, after the anti-smacking law and the push for the ban on the sale of incandescent light bulbs.

Not just light bulbs they want to ban either!

Achievements and failures:

A stellar run getting private members’ bills passed into law – including allowing mothers to keep babies in prison for longer, and getting rid of the “youth wage”. Sue Kedgley’s flexible working hours bill and Nandor Tanczos’ waste minimisation bill also became law. Played significant role getting the Government to agree to electrify Auckland’s rail network. …

But from outside government its successes have largely been restricted to one-off projects. Was forced to cave in after threatening to pull its support for the Emissions Trading Scheme despite getting no concessions on its main concerns, and settled for a $1 billion fund to make homes more energy-efficient.

As the ETS pushes up power and fuel prices, and at a time of weak economic growth, it may become a political liability.

Latest dog toys poll

Upton on Peters

I am trying not to blog on Peters much. With the help of my psychiatrist and some happy pills, I even refrained myself from firing off an angry post last night on his incredibly rude treatment of TVNZ’s Jessica Mutch. But the Vast Right Wing Conspiracy Ruling Council has ordered me to try and give Winston less airtime, so I complied.

But Simon Upton’s analysis yesterday of Winston is too insightful to pass up. Some extracts:

I was present 30 years ago when Winston Peters won the National Party’s nomination for the Hunua seat. There was never any doubt about the outcome. His youthfulness, flawlessly fluent delivery, charm and above all self-assurance swept all before him.

And Simon goes on with more examples of the charisma.

Few politicians can hope to hold either the finance or foreign affairs portfolios. Winston has held both. I have, obviously, no firsthand experience of his execution of the latter role (carried out in bizarre isolation from the Cabinet). But I witnessed his reign as treasurer. It was an uneasy, faltering performance carried by the professionalism of his officials and the self- effacing industry of Bill Birch. There was something genuinely sad about watching him arrive at Cabinet meetings with his papers unread, still tightly secured by their green Cabinet Office ribbon.

Winston’s two departments have both loved Winston. Treasury found him a good Minister because he only read the one page summary papers, never the full papers. Birch handled all the details. A Minister who never second guesses officials, makes officials purr.

MFAT love Winston even more. He has been totally tamed and captured to their viewpoint in a manner not even Sir Humphrey could aspire to. Take this story from ZB:

New Zealand First Leader Winston Peters is belittling suggestions a budget boost for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade should be cut.

Both National Leader John Key and Finance Minister Michael Cullen have signaled the extra $600 million set aside for MFAT in this year’s budget could be cut, in light of the poor state of the Government’s finances.

Winston Peters, who lobbied for the spending as Foreign Minister, says it is the wrong move to cut an area that could help grow the country’s exports and wealth, at the first sign of trouble. He says it would be disastrous for the country.

You can;’t get better than that. a Minister who will argue that the way to get out of the economic crisis is to hire more staff for MFAT. And I suspect he actually believes it, so successful has MFAT been at taming their Minister. This can only happen when the Minister doesn’t take independent advice or delve into details.

Winston wasn’t cut out to be a policy wonk, or a detail man. He was cut out to be a leader. That he failed to become prime minister is possibly the singular political tragedy of our time. Perhaps too many people told him that he would be. He believed his trajectory to be unstoppable – and he took the sort of risks (leaving his party, calling by-elections) that only the most self-assured politician would consider.

Winston probably would have ended up National Party Leader in the mid 90s, if he had played a smarter game, and not tried to white-ant Bolger from within Cabinet.

But at the end of the day, he could not win the respect of those of his political colleagues who ultimately mattered – the ones who did the hard work, who read their papers and knew how to temper ambition with responsibility.

As time went on, Winston covered his inadequacies with belligerent counter-punching. He also began to believe his own rhetoric that he was unlike other politicians.

Recent events have revealed a politician every bit as human and flawed as the rest.

Ironically, the flaws he has denied would easily have been forgiven him if he had delivered substance to match his charisma. His failure to do so means his political legacy will be correspondingly meagre. We are all the poorer for that.

This has been WInston’s problem – he never ever admits fault, and thinks he has none. Most MPs know what their weak areas are and will work hard to improve them. But Winston has always though charisma alone will get him through.

The PM’s air force travel

I’m going to defend the PM (at least partially) on her use of the Air Force to campaign in Invercargill, after commercial flights were closed.

For the sake of the organisations that were hosting her, it is right that she did everything she could to turn up on time. A lot of work will have gone on behind the scenes by those groups hosting her. Previous PMs have always had the Air Force available as backup transport.

So I don’t think the PM did anything wrong in using the Air Force. She is still the Prime Minister.

But what I will criticise her for, is not offering the service to other party leaders who were stranded. That would have been a magnamious and principled decision. Because while she is PM, Parliament has been dissolved and she is out campaigning like they are. It would have been a widely applauded measure if she had offered John Key or other leaders with public commitments a lift, if it could be fitted into the schedule. That way there is a level playing field.

Hutt Local Bodies

Hutt News has an article on whether the local candidates support local body amalgamation.

I am an advocate of amalgamation. It does not have to mean less local control, because the best models overseas strengthen the role of community boards with regards to making decisions solely affecting their local community – but allows one regional body to run services across the region.

Sadly all the local candidates have said they do not support any amalgamations. But there was one candidate at least prepared to question the status quo:

The sitting Hutt South MP admits he “sometimes wonders” why the Hutt and Upper Hutt councils remain separate.  “It doesn’t seem that logical to me.”

That is because it isn’t.

But they’re steadily increasing the number of issues they co-operate on anyway, and restructuring can sometimes involve so much “fighting, expense and uncertainty” it’s not worth it.

He notes that constituents don’t come to his electorate clinics clamouring for the two councils to amalgamate.

I give Trevor some marks for at least questioning the status quo, even though in the end he backs it.

The sick health sector

In the 1999/2000 years $6.8 billion was spent on Vote Health. In 2008/2009 Vote Health was forecast to be $12.6 billion. Now some of this is to over inflation and population growth but it is still a huge amount of extra funding. And what has been the result?

The Press editorial notes:

Heart disease is a leading cause of death in New Zealand and there have been longstanding concerns about the level of cardiac surgery services, writes The Press in an editorial. Yesterday’s report into cardiac surgery confirmed that these concerns were justified. The report found that this nation lagged behind comparable nations in heart surgery rates, with Australia’s level of service being 85 per cent higher and that within New Zealand there were significant regional variations.

Australia’s level of service is 85% higher.

And not only is this an election year when the Government must defend its health record, but another critical report, issued by the Ministry of Health yesterday, said that eight patients who died in 2006 and 2007 while awaiting heart surgery at Wellington Hospital had avoidable delays in their treatment.

Eight actual avoidable deaths, as oppossed to Helen’s invented 60 deaths in Iraq.

It is worth noting that a total of 16 people died while waiting for cardiac surgery during those two years, so that figure of eight being preventable represents half of them.

The economy

News that the Reserve Bank of Australia has dropped their official cash rate by a huge 100 basis points gives some inidcation of how weak various economies are.

NZIER released their quarterly survey of business confidence yesterday. On the basis of it they predict the recession will last for at least another two quarters. A net 32% of firms have reported a decline in trading activity and a net 13% expect trading activity to fall further in the next three months.

It is in that context, and the decade of deficits announced by Michael Cullen on Monday, that National have modified their tax package which will be announced later today. This is both necessary and responsible. The public want a tax package that takes account of the last few weeks, let alone the last few months.

The scary thing with the PREFU numbers is they were finalised five weeks or so ago, so do not include the latest shocks from the US. As the Herald says:

Party leader John Key yesterday admitted that the pre-election opening of the books by the Treasury showed a picture that was much worse than he had expected.

“We’d always expected a slowdown, but I don’t think anyone saw deficits for 10 years and such a deterioration in the accounts.”

The economic and fiscal update showed cash deficits forecast to reach $7 billion and budget deficits for the next 10 years. …

No-one at all was expecting it to be that bad.

Also behind the decision is the fact that the forecasts revealed by the Treasury this week do not take into account the tumultuous events of the past month, in which banks have collapsed, the US Government has approved an enormous bail-out deal for Wall Street, and the flow of credit internationally has virtually seized up.

Who knows where it will end. Now this is no reason not to have tax cuts at all – they are important as one factor in lifting economic growth. But some caution around size and timing is essential.

Prime Minister Helen Clark yesterday cast doubts on National’s statement that it had scaled down its tax cut plan.

“I believe they over-promised on their tax package and they are now using the excuse of the books to try and talk down expectations,” she said.

I am tempted to call the PM a moron for that comment, but I know she is not a moron so all I’ll say is she is playing dumb. If she really thinks a decade of deficits is simply an “excuse” then she is in la la land.

But here is what is really interesting. We have seen National says “Yes we will modify our plans in wake of the financial crisis” while Labour says it is not going to change anything. Dr Cullen ruled out any change to tax or spending in the PREFU lockup. At most they might delay some of WInston’s new bureaucrats. Labour are happy to have ten years of deficits and debt rising from under 20% to 30% of GDP.

Labour have had it easy for the last nine years. They have never had to make tough decisions, and now the economy is in reecession they have no idea and no plan as to what to do to prevent a decade of deficits. Their biggest problem for the last decade has been what new schemes to dream up to spend our money on – hey lets put a billion more into Working for Families, no no lets buy some trains for a billion, no no let’s give pensioners free bus trips, no no let’s give public servants a pay rise but only if they join the PSA etc etc.

Because the economy, helped by strong commodity prices, has been so strong they have been able to say no to measures that would boost labour productivity and economic growth. Many of these measures (such as RMA reform) will be unpopular with some lobby groups, so why bother to take the heat, when hey we have enough money without such reforms.

But now Labour has run out of money. They are content to run ten years of deficits. They are not willing to take any hard decisions about lifting our economic growth, let alone paring back any of their spending schemes.

We’ll hear later today what National’s plan is. I think it will be measured, significant and popular. It will of course be attacked by Labour and the unions. National could announce the second coming, and Labour and the unions will attack it. Hopefully at some stage, somone may ask Labour what their plan is? Their plan is to not change tax rates and not change spending significantly. Their plan is a decade of deficits.

In case you’ve not seen it

Dim-Post profile of Green Party

As usual, some good humour:

Founded in: 1990 (To be referred to by future New Zealand historians as ‘Year Zero’).

Position on Political Spectrum: Left of Gaia.

Stands For: Social justice; poverty reduction, achieving a progressive economy, restorative justice, making New Zealand a truly equal and egalitarian society. The party remains deeply divided over whether it should also promote environmental policies.

That is so true! The environmental part has alsmost become an add-on!

Major Financial Backers: 1/10th of all donations you give to street vagrants and homeless drug addicts are laundered through the Green parties secret slush funds.

Weaknesses: Mainstream New Zealand voters are still deeply suspicious as to the whereabouts of the second ‘L’ in the Green co-leaders christian name.

Yeah what did happen to that?

Dom Post on Economy

The Dom Post editorial today:

Growth this financial year is expected to be just 0.1 per cent, and unemployment is expected to climb to 5.1 per cent next year. For the first time since 1994, the budget’s operating balance will be in deficit. Prime Minister Helen Clark appears to welcome an election based on the economy. That is unsurprising. She can point to nine good years and to a reluctance to spend more than was flowing in. She would no doubt rather talk about that than the anti-smacking legislation, the chilling effects of her Electoral Finance Act, or why she defended the indefensible actions of NZ First leader Winston Peters.

All good questions.

However, she should not assume the voters will agree that she and Finance Minister Michael Cullen are the best stewards of the economy. Instead, they face questions over whether they have spent the proceeds of the years of plenty wisely.

Government spending has grown strongly during Labour’s years in government, sustained by the ever-growing tax take delivered by good economic growth. However, there are legitimate doubts that the taxpayer has received enough in return when it comes to better health services, better education, and improved infrastructure.

A number of studies have shown that actual improvements in outcomes for what has been a huge amount of money have been marginal.

The spending has been large, but the quality of some of it has been questionable. A relatively minor example offered by National is a 112 per cent increase to 505 in the past six years in the number of public relations, communications, media staff and contractors employed by government departments.

Yep a doubling of the number of comms staff in six years.

Further Kapiti interviews – Scott, McCaffrey, Collins and Pagani

Peter and Mike we did inside the blogmobile, with two cameras. Sadly this means you get to see a bit of me, as well as the candidates. Big kudos to Cameron for providing the gear and getting them trimmed and put onto You Tube.

A reminder the questions were:

1. What is the biggest issue for the voters of your electorate?
2. When did you first stand for election of any sort – was it at school?
3. McCain/Palin or Obama/Biden?
4. What will you do with the tax cuts you just got?
5. Goff or Cunliffe?

Peter McCaffrey was our first interview. He cited the economy as the biggest issue. For the question about whether he ever stood for election at school, I checked that Peter had in fact left school 🙂

Peter went for McCain/Palin. He was doubtful about McCain until Palin came along, but agrees with her on economic issues. Peter is not working at the moment so sadly gets no tax cuts. And in the final question he goes for Goff.

Mike Collins was next up. He agrees that the economy is the biggest issue – even more than law and order. On the US bailout he says it is good in the short term but in the long term may lead to more risky behaviour if people think the Government will bail them out.

Mike stood for VUWSA President a few years ago, and says he was lucky to be the only person on his ticket not to get elected. He also plugs for McCain on the basis of his free trade policies and support for NZ getting a real free trade deal.

His tax cuts are good for a dozen beer he reckons and like Peter opts for Goff.

Third up is David Scott, NZ First candidate for Otaki. He says the biggest issue for Otaki voters is to keep Winston and NZ First in Parliament and not leave it to the two big parties.

On the US front he has problems with both candidates for supporting the bailout but finally says “Not McCain”. David’s tax cuts are less than a $1 so he said no big change to his lifestyle. And on Cunliffe vs Goff, he says stay with Helen.

The final interview from the trip is Josie Pagani from Jim Anderton’s Progressives. Josie explains she was happy to have Pagani as her surname as her maiden name of Harbutt saw her called “Hard Butt” all through school 🙂

Josie picks transport as the biggest issue for Otaki voters, and also health. She says she has been unable to get a GP since returning from overseas. Josie also relates how she campaigned at university for a student exec position and finished with “Vote for me, I am more left wing than him” and it worked as she got elected. I suggested it could become the Progressive’s campaign slogan.

Josie surprised no one by going for Obama/Biden. Respects Sarah Palin as a working mum, but she does not have the experience to be VP. Her plans for her tax cuts involve a new pair of shoes, and she said not to tell her husband John. Whoops.

Big thanks to all the candidates for taking part. As you can see we’re not exactly doing hard news, but we do think it is nice to allow voters to see a bit more of their candidates, and give them some opportunities to talk issues. Most of it, we’re enjoying doing it. When you are not getting paid to do something, you only do it if it is fun.

Tauranga likes John

NZPA reports:

The National Party’s newly-announced ‘life means life’ policy for repeat violent criminals won loud approval in Tauranga today.

Party leader John Key got rousing applause when he talked about National’s plans to get tough on crime in an open-air lunch-time address which attracted a crowd of about 300.

The gathering was reminiscent of the signature rallies former Tauranga MP Winston Peters held during his heyday in Tauranga’s Mid-City Mall, known colloquially as Red Square. …

Despite relentless rain, Mr Key was welcomed warmly and seemed to surrounded by supporters. Not an interjection was heard.

Speaking without notes, an upbeat Mr Key pushed all the right buttons.

“Simon (Bridges) is going to be the next MP for Tauranga and he is going to be there for a very long time,” brought claps and cheers.

Further applause greeted each topic the National leader roamed, ranging from boot camps for young criminals to raising wages.

Winston may make 5% but I don’t think he is ever going to be able to say again that he is happy just to be the MP for Tauranga!

Tony Ryall, National MP for Bay of Plenty, was also on the platform and got a mention but it was his son Llewellyn, kitted out in a pin-stripe suit like his father’s, a National Party name badge in place on the lapel, who was the star. He stepped up to the microphone and exhorted: “Vote for National and John Key.”

The confident seven-year-old was no stranger to accompanying his dad on election campaigns but has not committed yet to becoming a politician.

“I think I might be a pilot,” he told NZPA.

What a sensible chap. A pilot is a far better paying job! 🙂

Ban parliamentary advertising in last 90 days

The Herald has the story of how Labour is flooding the country with taxpayer funded “information kits” on what the Government has done for over 60s.

It has escaped being an election advertisement, because they have been careful not to mention a party’s name. But it is obviously designed to influence voters as it is being circulated after Parliament has been dissolved.

My solution to this is simple. In the 90 days before an election, MPs and parliamentary parties should be unable to spend any of their parliamentary budgets on advertising – except for the most basic stuff such as hours an electorate office is open.

It is important MPs can communicate to their constitutents. But in the final weeks before the election, MPs should not have an unfair advantage over new candidates and be able to bury the electorate in material which doesn’t even count towards their limit.

This is of course what Labour did last time with their illegal pledge card. They have just adopted a more subtle approach this time.

Greens to be conned again

You wonder how many times the Greens will fall for it. Helen has said she wants them in her Government.

The Greens will respond by saying that after long and careful consideration we have decided to back Labour and also want to form a Government with them.

And then after the election, if Labour gets back in, Helen will go with Winston again because she needs him more. She is scared of alienating Winston but isn’t scared at all at alienating the Greens – I mean she has crapped on them for years and they still always faithfully come back for more.

The reality is that Helen Clark did not even try to form a Labour/Jim/Green/Maori Government last time – which would have been a majority. She didn’t even once sit down and try.

She also could have gone for a Labour/Greens Government with Maori, NZ First and United Future abstaining on supply and confidence. Did she even try for that?

But hey I won’t protect the Greens from their own stupidity.

Two TVNZ7 debates

Frontpage (which makes Agenda) has two debates coming up on TVNZ7:

The Swing Seats debates will be in two seats that could be crucial to the outcome of the election- Epsom and the Maori seat of Ikaroa- Rawhiti.

The Maori seat of Ikaroa–Rawhiti, which encompasses most of the East Coast of the North Island will be one of the most hotly contested seats in this election.

Cabinet Minister Parekura Horomia will go head to head with the Maori Party’s Derek Fox.

This debate will be broadcast in front of a live audience in Gisborne on October the 16th

The second debate is taking place in Epsom on October the 23rd where the colourful ACT leader Rodney Hide will be joined by National MP Richard Worth, Green Party MP Keith Locke and Labour’s Kate Sutton.

Hide needs to win this seat again to stay in parliament.

Both programmes will be LIVE-streamed on the TVNZ webite tvnz.co.nz  (key word : SWING SEATS) and will be available on TVNZ ondemand after they have screened.

They will be produced by the team that makes TV One’s “ Agenda” programme and will be fronted by Agenda co-host and TV One reporter Rawdon Christie wth support from Wallace Chapman, presenter of TVNZ7’s “Back Benches” programme.

Christie with support from TVNZ7’s “Back Benches” presenter, Wallace Chapman, will give the candidates in these “swing seats” a chance to tell the audience and viewers why they have the best policies for their constituents.

To join in the debate as part of the audience, people can write or send an email to the show’s producers explaining who they are and what question they would like to ask the candidates.

Emails can be sent to [email protected]
and letters sent to :
Front Page,
P.O Box 90361
Auckland

The blogmobile has been invited to cover the Ikaroa-Rawhiti debate in Gisborne, so we’ll live blog it also.

NZBC on the global financial crisis

NZBC has a good Q&A on the global financial crisis:

The questions are:

  1. Does this crisis represent a failure of free markets, of untrammelled deregulation, and the consequence of unrelenting greed?
  2. But surely it is greed that motivates Wall St, and is behind all these troubles?
  3. Did nobody see this coming?
  4. But don’t these central banking bailouts show that capitalist banking doesn’t work?
  5. If it doesn’t get done?
  6. OK, but isn’t the bailout just going to renew all the moral hazard issues associated with the so-called “Greenspan put”?
  7. So should we feel smug that the New Zealand banking system seems very safe by comparison?
  8. This is all terribly serious, is there nothing to laugh at here?
  9. What does this mean for investors?

Go read the article for the answers. It is very very good.