Hamilton

Staying with a friend in Hamilton. The bitch (and I mean that in a loving caring way) sent the kids in to wake me up and play games with me before 7 am, so she could get some more sleep. That would be bad enough at the best of times, but as I had been drinking Black Russians until 3 am it was cruel and unusual punishment.

Spent a couple of hours building forts from cushions with Master Four and Miss Two. Very tiring, especially after four hours sleep. The day before I had to fend them (and a visiting Miss Six) off for over an hour as they launched light sabre attacks on me. What I found amusing is playing the games on Thursday gets you a bit clucky as it is great fun to be a big kid. But then having to do the same again at 7 am the next morning squarely puts me back into the “Thank God I don’t have kids” camp.

Anyway I now know all of Thomas the Tank Engine’s friends off by heart!

Also quite amusing to go outside this morning, and find the rabbit asleep in its rabbit hutch, and the next door neighbour’s cat asleep on top of the hutch. It seems the cat has been trying to have rabbit stew for some days. This would be a very bad thing as they are only babysitting the rabbit for friends.

Oh well, time to start heading up to Auckland for National’s campaign launch. I think it will be a slow day today!

Hooton vs Peters

The Herald on Sunday reports:

A television stoush between New Zealand First leader Winston Peters and a National Party insider got so heated filming was stopped and the show’s lawyer called in.

Matthew blogs he does have some regrets:

He kept calling me a liar.  I kept calling him a liar.  Willie stood up and said “cut” (or words to that effect).  In the discussion about how to proceed after we were no longer recording, I told Winston he was a “fucking cunt” – in retrospect, I accept that I left out the important adjectives “lying” and “corrupt” between the other two appropriate but more Anglo-Saxon words.

Matthew is correct that Winston is a liar. We have a report from the Parliamentary Privileges Committee which says he is. The corruption tag is debatable – certainly knowingly filing false election expenses and donations return (as NZ First appears to have done in 2005 and 2007) is a corrupt practice. But the party secretary, not the party leader, is held liable under the law.  But if the party secretary says they were never made aware of secret monies controlled by the party leader – well you see how it is certainly debatable.

And Matthew feels a bit guilty:

Finally, I am very proud that I have looked Peters in the eye and called him a liar, a crook and a fucking cunt.  He has been a most evil influence on New Zealand politics since he first began telling lies, scaremongering and attacking minorities in the 1980s.  And I also feel a little guilty that I have been able to look him in the eye and tell him the truth when so many other New Zealanders don’t get the same opportunity.

I can’t see much chance of a reconciliation!

Three more interviews

Three more interviews from the blogmobile, from during the week.

This one was interesting, as we did it while driving. Nikki Kaye was down from Auckland to appears in Back Benchers. Her plane was delayed though and we didn’t leave the airport until 8.40 pm, with the live show starting just after 9 pm.

So we did the interview as we drove from the airport. I drove and asked the questions with Nikki in the passenger seat and Cameron standing up holding the camera. Amazingly it came out okay.

Nikki said the economy was the number one issue in Auckland Central and her first election was at school to become Head Prefect. She goes for McCain but diplomatically also praised Obama and Clinton.

In response to the question on what will she do with her tax cuts, Nikki revealed that sadly she has been a full-time candidate so the tax cuts won’t benefit her at all. And in response to Goff vs Cunliffe, she opted for depression if she had to choose 🙂

Then the next day we ran into John Hayes in Wairarapa and interviewed John in front of his vehicle.

We talked about the peacock called Winston and his propensity to shit everywhere. Without hesitation he said the biggest issue in the Wairarapa was Helen Clark, and wanting to get rid of her. John revealed his first election was at Lincoln University for Student Association President, which he won.

On the international front John went for Obama over McCain, saying his head says Obama and his heart McCain. And the final Goff vs Cunliffe question got a response of Shane Jones – definitely a possible contender.

Final interview was Nick Bryant, who was our gracious host on his family vineyard and farm. Nick made some predictions for the parties for the election – NZ First 4%, Maori Party all seven seats and 3%, Greens 7% to 7.5%, Labour 33% to 34%, ACT 2.5% to 3%, National close to 50%.

Nick predicted Obama would romp in, as John looks too much like George. And in response to the traditional Goff vs Cunliffe questions, went for Cunliffe.

The SFO outcome

I am totally unsurprised by the outcome of the Serious Fraud Office inquiries into the Spencer Trust. And the outcome is in no way a clearance or an exoneration. What it says is laws have been broken, but not fraud laws.

NZ First’s failure to obey the electoral laws of New Zealand is what made the investigation occur. Because the public facts were that Bob Jones had stated he had made a $25,000 donation intended for NZ First, through the Spencer Trust, and the NZ First Party had filed a donations return saying it had not received any donations in 2005 of over $10,000. To quote the SFO:

There were two competing explanations for how this could be.

  1. The Spencer Trust never passed the money onto NZ First, which would be possibly fraudalant
  2. The Spencer Trust did pass the money onto NZ First, and NZ First filed a false electoral donations return

No 2 was always far more likely. And thanks to the SFO investigation we now know this is true. In fact we know that NZ First has filed a series of false returns, as has Winston Peters personally, and Peters has lied on multiple occassions about these returns, including giving false information to the Privileges Committee.

This is no case of an accidential omission on a return, due to Mrs Muggins the branch secretary. This was a strategy signed off by the Leader. Let us look at the multiple false returns and statements:

  1. A false donations return for 2005
  2. A false election expenses return for 2005
  3. A false donations return for 2007
  4. A false return on the Register of Pecuniary Interests for 2006 (Payment of debt to Bob Clarkson for Peters)
  5. A false return on the Register of Pecuniary Interest for 2006 (Payment of debt to David Carter for Peters)

Now these are not just mistakes or errors. Only because of the SFO investigation has this come to light. And it gets even worse. Most semi-honest people would, once they had been caught out, would at least reveal all. But no Peters does not.

He was instructed by the House of Representatives to file amended pecuniary interest returns for 2005, 2006 and 2007. And all he did was amend them to include the two donations that had already been publicly forced out (Owen Glenn and Spencer Trust for Clarkson) but he didn’t declare the $13,640.37 the Spencer Trust paid on his benhalf to David Carter in 2006. These are the actions (assuming Weekend Herald is correct) of a pathological liar, not a cleared man.

And on that issue, it sounds like Eye to Eye at 11.30 am on Sunday will be interesting watching as Matthew Hooton is on the panel with Peters as the guest. Quoting Roar Prawn:

TVNZ sources say that Willie Jackson’s Eye to Eye tomorrow will be one of the most fiery TV debating shows ever seen in New Zealand.

Winston fronted up to the Green Room, last night to tape the show that airs on 11.30 on Sunday on TVNZ, thinking he would be up for a cosy chat with his mates Barry Soper and Chris Trotter.

He was high on hearing that the SFO had dropped criminal charges, but he was less than impressed when he realised that Jackson had decided to replace Trotter with Matthew Hooton.

Hooton won’t talk about the encounter but BustedBlonde’s media sources say that Winston tried to bluff his way out of appearing with Hooton, . saying there was no way he was going to be with someone who called him a liar.

Before they even got on air, we understand Hooton then called him a liar, a crook and a lying c***t straight to his face.

Anyway, things didn’t get much better on air, and the air was so blue Jackson had to stop the pair at one stage and re- record the show.

Our sources say that Winston always wins these debates on points but Hooton had him on the ropes more than once refusing to kowtow to the liar (our words)

Our sources say it was one of the most brutal encounters they had ever witnessed on NZ television.

That is very typical of the mischievous Willie Jackson – invite Peters on and then have Hooton on also. Can’t wait to see it.

In Rotorua

I’m in Rotorua and have just had the most wonderful shower. One of those real high pressure ones which will be banned in the very near future. Enjoy them while you can I reckon!

Left Wellington around 3 pm yesterday. Spent most of the trip working on reports for clients or articles for various publications. Generally it is no problem working on the laptop while travelling – however doing so over the Rimutakas yesterday did made me feel a bit sick.

Got a bit of a backlog of videos to link to and summarise, but should catch up today. We had dinner in Bulls and hit Rotorua at 9 pm, where National candidate Todd McClay has kindly provided a superb bed and breakfast service!

Going to cover Todd and John Key out at the markets and then head over to Hamilton later in the day.

Polls Update

Curiablog has details of the two polls out yesterday, both showing the Maori Party would hold the balance of power.

The size and time weighted average still has a National-led Government possible without the Maori Party, but this will change as the older polls with a larger gap get less weighting.

Shane Jones referred to Police for EFA breach

The Electoral Commission has referred Labour MP Shane Jones to the Police over his urging people to vote Labour while a replacement talkback host for an hour.

Yes even talkback hosts can not say what they think on air under the Electoral Finance Act.

A complaint (both laid by John Boscawen) against Winston Peters was not upheld, despite Peters also advocating voting for NZ First.

The difference is Peters did so in response to a question, while Jones advocated unprompted.

The Commission’s reasoning is sound and correct in my opinion. It does show how stupid the law is though when it comes down to this.

Note this ruling is a precedent for all radio staff and talkback hosts. The facts Peters and Jones were MPs was not the issue. If you say on air unprompted whichparty you think should or should not be supported, then you may be facing Police action also – unless your broadcaster clearly gives you authority to do so for editorial purposes. Read the full ruling.

UPDATE: NewstalkZB is also facing a fine of up to $200,000 for breaching the Broadcasting Act, as the talkback may constitute an illegal election broadcast.

Dim-Post on National’s tax package

The Dim-Post announces National’s real tax policies:

  1. $50 per week tax cut for every worker in New Zealand – will be accompanied by $50 per week ‘negative salary rebate’ for all workers, adding to a total transfer of wealth of over $5000 per year!
  2. ‘KiwiSlaver’, a new employers rights package aimed to stimulate the economy by protecting business owners from nuisance law-suits over trivial charges such as kidnapping and aggrivated assault.
  3. Flat tax of 18% to the really hot little red-head who participated in Crosby/Textor market research focus group #5.
  4. 5% GST rebate on Playstation 3 consoles; cost to be offset by privitisation of Stewart Island, population of which become legal property of Dow Industrial Chemicals.
  5. Free small soda at the movies for all working mothers on middle incomes aged between 25 and 45 living in the Otaki and Hamilton West electorates.
  6. Low income earners will be allowed to look behind the couch cushions of John Key’s sofa and keep whatever they find.

Heh I like No 1 and No 3 especially.

Save the time – outcome is pre-determined

The outcome of the Green’s decision making on who to support in Government is as pre-determined as their stance on whether to support the Government’s ETS Bill despite failign to gain any major concessions.

The Greens have got very good at these charades of consultation and deliberation. They’ve learnt the political game well.

I mean it is ludicrous to think they are really going to take several weeks to decide. Of course they are backing Labour, no matter what.  Even if Winston is is Cabinet, they’ll still be happy to be with Labour.

So the choice is between a Labour-Greens-NZ First Government and and a National-led Government, probably with ACT and United Future. The Maori Party is the only genuinely undecided.

I must also give the Greens a black mark for hypocrisy, How dare the party that voted for the ELectoral Finance Act (condemned by the Law Society and even the Electoral Commission for its chilling effects of democracry) says one of their criteria is “Protect democracy and civil rights”.

What is also interesting in the Green’s list of 12 policies they will judge against, is none even one of them is to do with economic growth. They have these great wish lists of spending, and don’t value at all whether a party has policies to produce the wealth to pay for these wish lists. A balanced list might be four policies on generating wealth, four on social spending issues and four on environmental issues. But instead their 12 policy areas are designed to guarantee the outcome. Their 12 areas for the record are:

  1. Reduce New Zealand’s oil dependence and climate change emissions
  2. Improve the public transport and the rail system
  3. Clean up waterways
  4. Increase protection of threatened species and ecosystems
  5. Improve local food security, keep the country genetic-engineering free and support organic growing
  6. Reduce child poverty and violence against children
  7. Form a genuine partnership with Maori under the Treaty
  8. Make education free and accessible
  9. Protect our national sovereignty from overseas ownership and keep New Zealand out of foreign wars
  10. Protect public healthcare, and invest in preventative health
  11. Protect workers’ rights and raise the minimum wage
  12. Protect democracy and civil rights

Again, not a single one focused on how to generate the income to pay for the Government’s spending. It’s a sham, with the outcome pre-ordained.

Editorials on Tax Package

The ODT says:

Sensibly, the plan does only minimally reward those already receiving some form of government assistance, particularly Working for Families, who are earning $50,000 or less a year – average wage-earners, for example, will get $36 a week, $4 a week more than from Labour.

National will restore a tax rebate to middle-income earners who are single or who do not have children and who were not included in the Working for Families scheme, which is likely to be a popular, if entirely unjustified, measure. …

A National government would operate a 2 plus 2 scheme, subsidising an equivalent amount of 2% of employees’ contributions, but the subsidy would not rise to 4%.

That decision will be widely criticised as being a disincentive, but the grounds for a government to subsidise personal savings, especially in a scheme which has proved so popular, are weak indeed….

Voters should consider, however, why after 10 years of favourable global economic conditions the country now faces “an ocean of red ink 10 years into the future”, as Mr Key says.

The answer is, of course, twofold but interlinked: the Clark Government decided to spend very large sums on subsidising wages and savings, increasing the bureaucracy and “future-proofing” superannuation, at the same time as a great many wage and salary earners went on a debt-fuelled spending spree.

A pretty balanced editorial.

The Dom Post says:

The  modesty of National’s tax cut plan is smart politics by Mr Key. It is pragmatic and an astute reading of where the election will now be fought, The Dominion Post writes.

As the leaders of the world’s big economies wrestle with how to fend off catastrophe, and as New Zealanders come to terms with the grim news contained in the pre-election economic and fiscal update, the focus has shifted from tax cuts to economic management. That makes its lack of extravagance – it does leave some New Zealanders worse off, rather than borrowing to deliver to all – a virtue rather than a vice. Lavish promises now would be seen as either pre-election rhetoric to be abandoned soon after November 8, or as foolhardy in the extreme.

But will this stop Labour making them?

The package still underlines the fundamental difference in approach between Labour and National when it comes to tax. Mr Key’s philosophy is summed up in his desire to reduce the top tax rate to 33c in the dollar over time. His regret is that circumstances mean he could not now make bigger cuts.

Dr Cullen’s is that he had to make cuts at all.

That is brillant. Key regrets he could not cut tax more, while Cullen regrets he was forced to cut tax at all!!

It is impossible to avoid the conclusion that he offered the reductions in this year’s Budget grudgingly. He is, at heart, a man who regards higher earners as “rich pricks”, and believes those who have succeeded have somehow ripped off their fellow citizens. He and his Labour colleagues believe they know how to spend people’s money better than those who earn it. The “chewing gum” round of cuts promised before the last election and petulantly cancelled afterwards – partly because people had not been grateful enough – is evidence of that.

So true.

Mr Key’s package is modest, credible and affordable. Now it is up to voters to decide whether it is also desirable.

Indeed. And does Labour have an alternative? Are they going to put tax rates up? Are they going to cut spending anywhere?

Save our Showers

The weekly Dispatch from Helengrad is up at NBR, titled “Save our Showers”.

The summary:

  • Best Play of the Week: National gets an A- for its changes to KiwiSaver
  • Worst Play of the Week: Dept of Building and Housing gets an E- for its maximum shower flow regulations
  • Scandal of the Week: The Government gets a D- for the accounts in PREFU
  • EFA breach of the Week: The anti-National protesters get an A for breaking the Electoral Finance Act after having marched in favour of it!
  • Blog Analysis of the Week: Ben Thomas for his analysis of National’s tax cuts

Remember comments and feedback can be made over at NBR.

Google’s 2008 election gadget

Another Winston

We met Winston the peacock when working hard from the blogmobile in the Wairarapa today. They owners told us they got him around 15 years ago and named him Winston because he is:

  1. vain
  2. looks magnificent
  3. is noisy
  4. and shits on everything

Winston was truly a beautiful bird. Very friendly also.

Four more decisions from the Electoral Commission

The Electoral Commision has released four more decisons – all quite interesting.

  1. Display of anti-national banners by Clinton Smith was complained about by Cameron Slater. The Commission found that the banner and associated leaflets were election advertisements under the EFA. Smith claimed to have made a verbal promoter statement of authorisation. The Commission rejected this as being adequate and said tangible items can not have merely verbal authorisation statements. Therefore they found the items contravened s63(2) of the Electoral Finance Act. However they will not ask the Police to investigate Smith for an illegal practice as they found his breach was not wilful as he thought what he had done was necessary. And if does not constitute an illegal practice unless done wilfully.
  2. A Pete Hodgson fundraising letter for Labour. This was found to be an election advertisement in breach of s63(2) of not having an authorisation statement and 65(1) of not having been formally approved by the Labour Party. However once again they found the breach was not wilful and again no referral to the Police as it is not an illegal practice unless done willfuly.
  3. National MP Eric Roy’s advertisments in the Southland Express were complained about by Labour MP Lesley Soper. The EC made said “The Electoral Commission believes it is essential to democratic elections that parties can inform the public of the policies which will be implemented if elected and that, particularly in light of New Zealand Bill of Rights Act considerations, it would not be reasonable to regard mere statements of policy as election advertisements and subject to the restraints of the Electoral Finance Act.” They also said “Therefore the Commission is of the view that items which are accounts or reasoned criticisms of policy, or accounts or reasoned criticisms of actions or inactions, generally are not “reasonably” regarded as election advertisements as they are essential to informed democratic elections.“So what can’t you say? “The Electoral Commission considers that accompanying identification of the proponents of such items does not of itself convert the items into election advertisements, but disproportionate display of photographs, names or logos could do so. Other matters that might bring such items within the definition of an election advertisement include the addition of persuasive content which lack an information base such as party slogans, self promotion or unreasoned criticism of opponents, and exhortations to vote in a particular manner.” They cocnluded that Eric Roy’s advertisements were not election advertisements under the EFA.
  4. National MP Chris Auchinvole’s website was complained about by Oliver Woods. With similiar reasoning to above, the Electoral Commission found the website was not an election advertisement. So National continues to be one of the few parties to have never broken the new law.

In both the first two cases, illegal advertisements were published and the law was broken. But the finding of a lack of intent means no liability for the two individuals concerned.

Also of interest to some may be the news that as Kotahitanga Te Manamotu Hake Tiriti o Waitangi, the New Zealand Liberals, and the South Island Party all failed to register for the election, their $30,000 of broadcasting allocations was redistributed to all the smaller parties

Dollar plummeting

Kill the worm

Steven Price has an excellent piece on why TV3 should not have a worm:

We no longer need to listen to the debates and think about what we’re hearing for ourselves. We have an electronic scorecard. An infallibly scientific one. A fascinating, beguiling one. Instead of thinking to ourselves, “Now, is Helen Clark making any sense?” we think, “How is that going down? Is she winning the game?”

It’s politics as pure sport. We are mere spectators. The worm relieves us of the burden of having to work out for ourselves who’s ahead.


But hang on. The worm is simply the electronically summed gut reactions of a bunch of undecided voters twiddling some knobs in a room somewhere. Why take any notice of them? You won’t be told who they are, but you can make some safe assumptions.


First, the great majority of them will not share your political views.


Second, you would find some of them to be complete tossers.


Third, you have no idea what they are reacting to. You’re watching their reactions to the leaders’ ideas – mostly before the leaders have finished expressing them. Some of them are thinking, “Yeah, I’ve been following National’s Treaty of Waitangi policy and it makes good sense to me.” Some are thinking, “Ooh, I like his tie.” Some are thinking, “Damn, I forgot to remind Trish to pick up the sausages.”

So true.

When the worm was first used in 1996, Pam Corkery reckoned it simply went up when the live studio audience applauded. Wellington businessman Michael Gibson observed that the worm dipped whenever Paul Holmes appeared onscreen, no matter who was talking.

Heh.

There was also lots of coverage about how the worm adored Helen Clark. The commentators examined her “empathetic nodding,” her “softer, modulated voice,” her “pained sincerity,” her “ability to project an authoritative presence.” They didn’t examine her policies much.


And that’s why I hate the worm. It’s yet another thing pushing us toward image analysis and horse-race politics, and away from talking about how we’ve been affected by the government’s decisions in the last three years, what the alternatives might have been, and what policies are best for the future. The worm finds this stuff too boring. It doesn’t like long explanations. Nor does it like taxes (though it does like improvements in health and education). It doesn’t like uncomfortable truths being mentioned.

It turns a debate into a game show. No serious broadcaster would use one.

The Rimutakas

There are four of us in the blogmobile crossing the Rimutakas. Whale, myself, Busted Blonde and the Ginga Ninja. We are also playing Horse as we drive. The sun is out at the moment but may not last all day.

We have debated whether a before and after photo of a hoarding would constitute enough proof for convictions. We reckon it may, so will limit ourselves to just taking photos of ones already altered.

Government fucking up our showers

The Plumbing Distributors Association of New Zealand has sent me this PR:

“Having a great shower will be a thing of the past”.
The Plumbing Distributors Association of New Zealand (PDANZ) is very concerned with the Department of Building and Housing’s proposed changes to the flow rates of showers and the effect it will have on New Zealanders.

In the “NZBC H1 Compliance Document for hot water systems and HVAC systems” the DBH propose to have maximum shower flows of 6 litres a minute for gas and electric water heaters when a house is bigger than 150m2. A house with mains pressure water and a quality showerhead would be using 16-19 litres a minute. That is a good quality shower. Under the DBH’s proposal the shower would need to be restricted back to only allow 6 litres per minute. To understand what your shower would be like, knock your shower mixer back by 2/3rds. The small amount of water dribbling out would be what the DBH call a “comfortable and effective shower”. The PDANZ believe this is not acceptable. Having a good quality shower should not be compromised in the name of Kyoto Protocol. Where do we draw the line?

First they came for our light bulbs, and then they came for our showers!!

Is there no limit to nanny state?

New sharemarket terms

Danyl at Dim-Post has a list:

CEO –Chief Embezzlement Officer.

CFO– Corporate Fraud Officer.

BULL MARKET — A random market movement causing an investor to mistake himself for a financial genius.

BEAR MARKET — A 6 to 18 month period when the kids get no allowance, the wife gets no jewelry, and the husband gets no sex.

VALUE INVESTING — The art of buying low and selling lower.

P/E RATIO — The percentage of investors wetting their pants as the market keeps crashing.

BROKER — What my broker has made me.

STANDARD & POOR – Your life in a nutshell.

STOCK ANALYST — Idiot who just downgraded your stock.

STOCK SPLIT — When your ex-wife and her lawyer split your assets equally between themselves.

FINANCIAL PLANNER — A guy whose phone has been disconnected.

MARKET CORRECTION — The day after you buy stocks.

CASH FLOW — The movement your money makes as it disappears down the toilet.

YAHOO — What you yell after selling it to some poor sucker for $240 per share.

WINDOWS — What you jump out of when you’re the sucker who bought Yahoo @ $240 per share.

INSTITUTIONAL INVESTOR — Past year investor who’s now locked up in a nuthouse.

PROFIT — An archaic word no longer in use.

Heh.

Whakatane cop’s occupation revealed

The media can now report that the occupation of the Whakatane man convicted of assaulting his wife is a Police sergeant, in fact Adrian Hilterman is the local Police prosecutor.

I’ve known for some time that Hilterman was a ranking Police Officer. No not through Google, and not through his name.

The media described him as a promiment public servant in Whakatane. Now this is the media code for a police officer as there are almost no public servants in Whakatane (or anywhere outside Wellington). So if you ever see that term used, it is almost always a cop.

I presume Mr Hilterman will no longer be a promiment public servant in the near future.

Reaction to Tax Cuts package

In no particular order.

The Herald Editorial compares the parties:

There has been a striking contrast in the response of the two main parties to the disturbing news that after 14 years of budget surpluses the Treasury now calculates the public accounts are set for a decade of deficits. …

Finance Minister Michael Cullen merely congratulated himself again on having saved previous surpluses for a “rainy day” and looked forward to the problems it would cause for National’s intended tax cuts.

There was evidently nothing he thought necessary to change, either in his own programme of reluctant tax cuts that started this month or in the Government’s spending programmes that might have seemed affordable in better times. If Labour’s “rainy day” could last 10 years, as the Treasury forecasts, Dr Cullen and his colleagues seemed strangely relaxed about it.

In other words Labour has no plan at all.

The fiscal crisis is indeed the first real test of the mettle of leader John Key and his team and it is rare that voters get such a measure before an election.

National could have taken the easy option of confirming its previously indicated tax cuts, offering no specific savings in public expenditure and pretending that tax cuts would actually cure the deficit in quick time. Conservative parties are prone to that belief.

Instead, National has faced the need to balance its tax cuts with specified savings, notably the removal of business tax breaks on research and development and employer contributions to KiwiSaver. The wisdom of reducing the incentives to save is questionable but the courage is not.

And National is willing to take the hard decisions, and not pretend that the decade of deficits is acceptable.

Paula Oliver in NZ Herald:

National has risked alienating people who have embraced KiwiSaver, as the party goes into the election with a tax-cut package that would leave more money in the pockets of most earners – but takes away two business tax breaks to pay for it.

Mary Holm says the changes improve KiwiSaver:

The National Party’s proposed changes to KiwiSaver would considerably reduce two of the biggest gripes about the scheme – that some people can’t afford it and that it ties up savings. …

The contributions of anyone earning less than $52,150 would be tripled by employer and government input. And that means three times bigger retirement savings. …

The reduction of the minimum employee contribution from 4 per cent to 2 per cent of pay means it would be easier to afford KiwiSaver, especially after taking tax cuts into account.

John Armstrong says it is a bit of a fizzer:

The door banged shut in Labour’s face following Monday’s mind-numbingly pessimistic economic forecasts. Labour can thank National’s underwhelming tax package for reopening it at least slightly.

Colin Espiner reports on a snap poll:

A snap poll for The Press yesterday showed National may have pitched the package about right.

The poll of 212 people by Futurescape Global found 43% felt the tax cuts matched their expectations, with 34% feeling it fell short. A slim majority of those polled felt the country could afford National’s package, but people were split over whether they were confident in National’s ability to manage the economic crisis, while 55% said the tax package had not altered their vote. The poll has a margin of error of 6.7%.

Brian Fallow sees a shortage of growth:

National claims its tax package will stimulate the economy in the short term and improve incentives and drive growth in the longer term.

The first claim is plausible, the second not so much.

Reducing the top tax rate faster will be better for growth long term, but quite simply the money was no longer there.

James Weir in the Dom Post surveys business opinion:

Business New Zealand also disagreed “pretty seriously” with the decision to drop R&D tax credits but said the planned tax cuts and target to cut personal tax rates to 33 per cent over time rated a “seven out of 10” score overall.

The Press editorial is positive:

Even if tax cuts were not on the agenda, there is a case to argue that the levels set for KiwiSaver were too ambitious from the start. As it stands, some young people entering the scheme and earning the average wage throughout their working lives could end up earning more in retirement, when their National Super entitlements were added to their KiwiSaver earnings, than they did in their lifetime.

Yep, and that is daft. The 4%/4% KiwiSaver forced people on the average wage to save too much, taking money they need during their working life.

Clark has said this election will be one of trust. If this is so, then the question for voters will be who do you trust in the turbulent world we now face? With these tax cuts, and with some detail of its longer-term economic plans, National has placed its cards on the table. It has produced figures to show that its plans are fiscally responsible. Voters must decide whether Key and his colleagues can be trusted to deliver on them, or whether Labour can be trusted to manage difficult times as well as good ones.

Will Labour produce a plan? Or is Labour saying it will run a decade of deficits and not make any changes to tax rates or spending?

Tracy Watkins blogs:

A year ago, Key might have risked over promising and under delivering on those amounts.

But that was a vastly different world..

The failure to deliver more may peel off some soft support among those who were leaning toward National but, because of Working for Families, will not be a whole lot better off.

But the rest will probably agree with Key that it’s a package that’s right for the times.

So is it enough? You’d have to say yes.

And finally NZPA reports that least surprising news of all – that unions and political rivals don’t like it. Some get their facts wrong:

United Future leader Peter Dunne, who is minister of revenue, said it was complicated and would be difficult to administer.

“Superannuitants and low income earners are the big losers,” he said.

Bzzt. Wrong. By 2011 superannuitant couples will get $15 a fortnight more.

Blogmobile Schedule

Okay here is the provisional schedule for the blogmobile. It may change but this is it for now:

  1. Thu 9 Oct – Wairarapa
  2. Fri 10 Oct – Taupo
  3. Sat 11 Oct – Taupo
  4. Sun 12 Oct – Auckland
  5. Mon 13 Oct – Auckland
  6. Tue 14 Oct – Tauranga
  7. Wed 15 Oct – Gisborne
  8. Thu 16 Oct – Gisborne
  9. Fri 17 Oct – Napier
  10. Sat 18 Oct – Hawke’s Bay
  11. Sun 19 Oct – Wairarapa
  12. Mon 20 Oct – Wellington
  13. Tues 21 Oct – Wellington
  14. Wed 22 Oct – Wellington
  15. Thu 23 Oct – Wellington
  16. Fri 24 Oct – New Plymouth
  17. Sat 25 Oct – Wanganui
  18. Sun 26 Oct – Palmerston North
  19. Mon 27 Oct – Wellington
  20. Tue 28 Oct – Wellington
  21. Wed 29 Oct – Auckland
  22. Thu 30 Oct – Auckland
  23. Fri 31 Oct – Kerikeri
  24. Sat 01 Nov – Whangarei
  25. Sun 02 Nov – North Shore
  26. Mon 03 Nov – Wellington
  27. Tue 04 Nov – Hutt
  28. Wed 05 Nov – Wellington
  29. Thu 06 Nov – Wellington
  30. Fri 07 Nov – Auckland
  31. Sat 08 Nov – Auckland

We would love to have been able to visit the South Island but it costs $1,000 to take it on the ferry, and we would have needed two weeks at least to do the South Island properly.

Heaps of people have already kindly offered a bed or meal for the night. They are all being gratefully accepted. Just e-mail me if you can do so.

NZIER tax calculator