The Kapiti Interviews – Hughes, Guy and Parata

Cameron has put onto You Tube our interviews with some of the candidates. Each video is only around two minutes as they answered our five question quiz. I’ll do three of them here and the others later today. The questions were:

  1. What is the biggest issue for the voters of your electorate?
  2. When did you first stand for election of any sort – was it at school?
  3. McCain/Palin or Obama/Biden?
  4. What will you do with the tax cuts you just got?
  5. Goff or Cunliffe?

Above is Darren Hughes. Darren also answered questions on whether “Gingas” should be given the vote, and he advocated that not only should they be allowed to vote, but that they should be elected in large numbers. It was a fun interview!

His first election was in Standard Four when he won Class Captain in a landslide. He is backing Obama/Biden but was originally a Hillary supporter. His tax cuts have gone towards increasing his mortgage repayments.

For the Goff vs Cunliffe question, Darren just assumed we were talking about Labour Leadership but went on to say the next Leader has yet to be born, but he will happily serve them once they are šŸ™‚

Nathan Guy is above. Nathan’s biggest local issue was infrastructure, including Transmission Gully. At school he was elected Chairman of the Student Council. He backs McCain over Obama and then delivered such a word perfect piece on the importance of tax cuts that I suggested the Chief Whip had written it for him (he is Chief Whip for those who don’t get it). On Goff vs Cunliffe he said he does not care but Clark is gone!

And finally Hekia Parata. Hekia named three big issues of lifting productivity and incomes, access to quality education and roading/infrastructure. Hekia’s first political act was taking her third form class on strike in protest over not being able to read the Little Red Schoolbook. She had no idea what was in it but was offended they were told they could not read it. Hekia also mentioned at the end of the story that the Deputy Principal was her father so one can guess how well that went down! Hekia was also elected President of the Waikato Students’ Union.

Hekia said she is concerned about McCain’s age and Palin’s experience so thinks Obama/Biden is a better choice. Says tax cuts are too little too late and taxes should have been reduced a bit every year – not just once at the end of nine years.And finally she dodged the Goff vs Cunliffe question by choosing Key and English.

Kapiti Meet the Candidates

The Blogmobile had its first official outing to the Kapiti Coast on Sunday. It does take a while to get use to the size and bulk of the vehicle. You do not want to have to slam the brakes on suddenly, so you drive quite cautiously. Mind you, still over took a couple of cars on the way, which surprised them!

I also found no problems working on the laptop while Cameron drove. The Vodafone data card kept a signal the entire trip. And the mat on the table stops the laptop moving about.

Mid afternoon we went to a Waikanae function for Nathan Guy – had 100 or so people there to hear Gerry Brownlee speak. We then had some refreshments at a VWRCNZ farm a few kms north of Waikanae before heading to the Meet the Candidates Meeting in Raumati.

Raumati is actually in Mana electorate, but close to the Otaki boundary so there were candidates there for both electorates. Seven of the candidates (two Nats, one Labour, two ACT, one NZ First and one Progressive) did our five question quiz for the video camera, and I’ll link to their videos later on.

The candidates speaking were:

  1. National – Nathan Guy (Otaki) and Hekia Parata (Mana)
  2. Labour – Winnie Laban (Mana) and Darren Hughes (Otaki)
  3. ACT – Mike Collins (Mana) and Peter McCaffrey (Otaki)
  4. NZ First – David Scott (Otaki)
  5. United Future – Robin Gunston (Mana)
  6. Greens – Michael Gilchrist (Mana)
  7. Progressive – Josie Pagani (Otaki)

Each party had eight minutes (they could split between them) to talk, and the topic was meant to be on making communities safer. After that there was an hour of questions from the floor.

All the candidates got a pretty good reception, but David Scott got heckled a fair bit when he spent too much time talking about how wonderful Winston was, and not enough on the actual topic. We got this a bit in the interview also when David said the most critical issue facing voters is getting Winston back into Parliament! I actually know David as he is the ex-husband of a former National MP!

Nathan and Hekia were both very good. Nathan is one of those MPs who speaks to you, not at you – never speaks down at all. And Hekia was wonderful as she gave some great examples from her own family about the challenges parents can have in having their kids safe. You could feel the connection with some in the audience.

Winnie and Darren both gave very polished performances also. Darren uses humour very well, and strikes an easy rapport with people. They were both very on message and avoided stuff which turns off people like blaming crime on a budget from 17 years ago.

Gunston and Gilchrist made no blunders and reflected their party stances as expected.

Likewise Peter and Mike from ACT pushed their party’s policies on law and order. They had one negative moment when Peter pushed Sir Roger Douglas and the generally elderly audience reacted as if he had tortured a cat. But during question time it seemed apparent they had some people agreeing with them on law and order policies.

But the real interesting candidate for me (and no not just because I know her) was Josie Pagani. In fact Josie scared me. She sounded like a Tory, while advocating socialist policies. Now this is really dangerous!! A definite wolf in sheep’s clothing!

She managed to defend the anti-smacking law while at the same time condemning the political correct environment that spawned it by talking about how her kids get reflection notes or some bullshit from school now, and what the hell do they mean. So she had all the audience nodding and agreeing with her, and then artfully adds to her story by saying that violence against kids is horrific though and if we need a better law to make it clear, then she is all for it.

One of the questions was on whether the drinking age should be lifted to 20. I resisted identifying myself as a co-ordinator for the Keep it 18 campaign :-). It was interesting how the candidates split.

In favour of 20 was the Greens, Progressive, NZ First United Future and one of the Labour candidates (Laban). Now it is a conscience issue but I found it interesting that you had Greens and Progressive agreeing with the more socially conservative parties.

In favour of 18 was both ACT candidates, both National candidates and Darren Hughes from Labour. Hekia Parata did make the point that she did not support lowering it to 18, but now it is 18 one can’t turn it back.

Afterwards we gave Peter and Mike a lift back to Wellington. They were impressed that we had on board a box of ACT’s 20 point plans – Rodney never misses an opportunity and got them for Cameron.

Herald scores ACT

The Herald continues its party ratings:

Performance rating this term: 4/10

If it weren’t for Rodney Hide’s application to the job this year, the score would be lower. But he has refocused on politics after his appearance on Dancing with the Stars marked a transformation in his life.

That is a rating for the whole term. If one was rating the last six months, I think it would be a lot higher.

Assets and liabilities:

Sir Roger Douglas’s return will be a beacon for up to 7 per cent of voters who have cast their party vote for Act in previous years and his appearance for the first time on Act’s list will almost certainly attract greater funding than it had last time. He may be a turn-off for others, however. The list is very light on women, with only two in the top 10, but mother of five Heather Roy – also known as Private Benjamin for her passion for the Territorials – has not put a foot wrong.

I think Heather is great, and would love to see Heather in Cabinet. She will be a very competent Minister I believe.

Policies to watch for:

Act is putting great store by its law and order policy this election and has appointed Sensible Sentencing Trust legal adviser David Garrett at position No 5 on the party list.

It is also heavily promoting the holding of Government expenditure – as opposed to slashing it – to no more than adjustments for inflation and population growth.

And that is a clever policy. People can relate to keeping expenditure constant – in real per capita terms.

What it needs to do in the campaign:

Reduce the fear factor associated with the “slash and burn” politics linked to Sir Roger Douglas when he was Labour’s reforming finance minister. Convince voters that Act’s policies are aimed at increasing the wealth of working New Zealanders, not just big business.

Convince right-leaning voters that Act could have some impact in a National-led government.

All sensible.

Armstrong on PREFU

John Armstrong does a nice summary:

It was only a few short weeks ago that Bill English was saying he wasn’t going to be spooked by a little bit of red ink in the Government’s accounts.

The Treasury’s pre-election fiscal update bleeds so much of the red stuff that the document looks like the aftermath of Dracula running amok in the blood bank.

The numbers in this horror story are truly awful. It is goodbye to operating surpluses for close to a decade. The forecasts for the separate cash deficit figure nearly double to $6-7 billion for the foreseeable future. Growth slumps. Unemployment jumps. These numbers will almost certainly get worse. The Treasury’s forecasts were done before last week’s maelstrom on Wall Street.

What a legacy to leave behind.

The update is a brutal reality check for parties making big election promises. In the short term, Labour has already gobbled up the allocation for new spending in next year’s Budget. There can be no pre-election bidding wars to buy votes. Post-election negotiations are now going to be hellishly difficult.

Yes – universal student allowances just died yesterday.

If a Labour-Green-NZ First Government was elected, I think they would find it almost impossible to govern without increasing taxes. There is less than $500 million available next year for new initiatives. Even a centre-right Government will find it hard to cope with that. I think it is inevitable there would be a range of new taxes introduced – they will carry through with the legislated tax cuts, but seek to increases taxes elsewhere – maybe even do another envy tax on people earning over $100,000.

In such an atmosphere of restraint, National’s unveiling of its tax cuts tomorrow seem about as tactful as someone cracking open the champagne at a funeral just as the coffin is being lowered into the grave.

The tax cuts needs to countered by savings elsewhere. A significant increase in the operating deficit is not a good idea. However tax cuts are still important as part of a package to life economic growth – higher economic growth is the way to avoid a decade of deficits.

Having slammed National for setting a debt-to-GDP target of 22 per cent, Cullen’s position has been undercut by the current debt ratio being forecast to balloon from 17 per cent to 24 per cent of GDP over the next four years.

And to keep increasing after that to over 30% of GDP.

If National’s tax cuts are reckless, so, by Cullen’s previous definitions, are Labour’s.

Cullen admitted as much by saying that had he known in advance what was going to happen he would have been more cautious about cutting taxes. However, he is refusing to withdraw the second and third phases of Labour’s tax package.

That was actually my question to Dr Cullen – would he have made the tax cuts he did, if he had these forecasts six months ago. He replied that he he would have been more prudent as he leaves recklessness to bloggers šŸ™‚

Cullen is right that he can not directly reverse the tax cuts he has just passed into law. But I just can’t see how a Labour-led Government could live within these fiscal parameters. I suspect there would be a range of new taxes introduced.

That gives National carte blanche to go with its more generous package, which it says will be no more expensive than Labour’s because the extra cost will be funded by transparent savings in government spending.

Yes the key is having the whole package fiscally neutral or very close to it.

The bickering over tax has long made up for the lack of argument over wider economic policy. Yesterday changed everything. The election is no longer about tax. It is about which party can best convince the voters its policies will shorten the length and depth of that recession.

This is absolutely where the debate needs to go. There has to be an real focus on increasing economic growth.

Audrey does Q&A with Rodney

Audrey Young does a Q&A with Rodney Hide. Some extracts:

You have a pledge card of 20 key policies. What are the most important three?

There’s no doubt the economy, no doubt the crime policy – three strikes and you’re out – and no doubt dumping the emissions trading scheme, all of which we differ from National on.

Do you believe in the public health system?

I believe that the state health system has been a failure and that what it does is take our money and then ration health care by queuing us up in pain and agony.

I much prefer that we use the private system and focus the Government’s attention on ensuring that everyone has access.

I believe the Government’s job should be to ensure access, not to be running the hospitals.

Reminder- Debate in Wellington tonight

When: 18:30 – 20:00, Monday, 6 October (tonight!)
Where: Lecture Theatre One, Rutherford House, VUW (just by the railway station)
How much: Gold coin entry
Moot: That we need a centre-right Government

Affirmative:

  • Stephen Franks – National candidate for Wellington Central
  • Christopher Finlayson MP – National List MP and Rongotai candidate
  • Stephen Whittington – champion Victoria student debater

Negative:

  • Grant Robertson – Labour candidate for Wellington Central
  • Sue Kedgley MP – Green candidate for Wellington Central
  • Polly Higbee – champion Victoria student debater

The debate is to be chaired by Sean Plunket

Bad headline and graphic

An unfortunate headline in the Herald:

Key pulling more women than Brash

Bronagh would be most concerned if this was the case šŸ™‚

This makes it look like Labour is way ahead of National amongst women voters, and that this has barely changed since the last election.

You have to read the article very carefully to work out that what this graph shows is what proportion of total support for a party is from female voters. This would be much better represented as a pie graph showing male/female ratios.

For those interested I have reverse engineered the figures to estimate the female support for each party in 2005 and 2008.

In 2005 Labour had approximately 44.7% support from women and National 33.9% support.

In 2008 Labour had approximately 37.5% support from women and National 45.4% support. So National is attracting around 8% more support from women than Labour is.

This is based on average party vote in 2005 being 41% Lab, 39% National and in 2008 being 35% Labour and 50% National.

PREFU: Ten years of deficits

The PREFU is far worse than anyone could imagine. Thank God St Ruth and National changed the law in 1994 to force the Government to open the books up before an election – otherwise it would be a repeat of the last time a Labour Government left office – a fiscal mess for the incoming Government.

The Secretary of the Treasury, John Whitehead, did a presentation before we got the books. The room was silent as he wound out the bad news. The problem isn’t our financial markets – they are much better structured than in the US. It is the flow on effects of lower GDP growth and increased spending. So we don’t have a crisis, but we do have a very bleak fiscal situation.

The Crown accounts are going into deficit, and will remain in deficit until 2018 – yes – a decade of deficits on the medium term projections. The deficit is forecast to be $31 million this year and up to $3.2 billion in 2012/13 – returning to surplus only in 2017/18. This is the OBEGAL excluding Super Fund Revenue.

Dr Cullen and Helen Clark are going to be very red faced over debt. Do you recall how they attacked National’s plan to borrow 2% more of GDP for infrastructure as an economic calamity and reckless as it would push debt up to 22% of GDP – 2% in excess of Dr Cullen’s ceiling of 20%

Debt is forecast to peak at 30.1%!!! It will be 24.3% by 2012/13 and 30.1% by 2018/19. After wailing about how the world would end if debt went to 22% of GDP, Dr Cullen is leaving NZ with a forecast rise to 30%.

The cash deficit next year is now forecast to be $6 billion and over five years a cash deficit of 31.7 billion.

Incidentally PREFU was done around five weeks ago so doesn’t take account of the very latest in the US such as the bailout. They do not expect this to change PREFU significantly but it does increase the risk of a sharp slowdown.

Treasury are forecasting close to 0% annual GDP growth until June 2009.

Some changes to the annual predictions are

  • KiwiSaver costs up $280m by 2012
  • Tax take down 900m
  • Benefit costs 500m up
  • Early Childhood Education Costs up 200m
  • Debt servicing up 500m

The annual contingency for extra spending is $1.75 b per annum plus 2% inflation. But most of this is already allocated and for the next four years only $500 to $600 million a year is available for genuine new spending.

So what to do? Well the Treasury Secretary says if one can manage an average real GDP growth of 3%, then the long-term debt (2022/23) will reduce by 10%.

This for me is what the election must now be about. The status quo in terms of economic growth is not acceptable – a decade of deficits must not happen. So voters should ask which party will have the best policies and best people to boost economic growth.

I have previously given Dr Cullen pretty high marks for his fiscal management. Those marks were seriously downgraded today as he leaves us with ten years of deficits forecast and a 50% forecast increase in debt as a percentage of GDP.

There will be some focus on National’s response and their tax plans and infrastructure plans. The tax plans will be credible if they are largely fiscally neutral with reductions elsewhere in expenditure. And a lower tax economy will lead to higher economic growth – which is what it is all about.

The infrastructure plans will add 2% of GDP to gross debt – aĀ small amount now compared to the 10% extra on these projections. The rationale is unchanged for them though – if they will add to economic growth by increasing productivity, then that is a good return on investment. Not all infrastructure investments will lead to higher economic growth, so the focus should be on the quality of the investment.

Bill English is about to inherit what may be the toughest job in New Zealand – turning around a projected ten years of deficits and 50% increase in gross debt as a percentage of GDP.

In the lockup

The latest electoral pendulum

I blogged my informal electoral pendulum a few months back. It calculates on a standard swing what seats would fall to National based on the lead they have in the polls on the electorate vote.

Only One News Colmar Brunton publish results for the electorate vote, and yesterday’s poll gave us National 52% and Labour 35% on the electorate vote.

Now the swing never ever is standard, so these are not predictions. Just a scenario of what will happen if there was a standard swing with National 17% more than Labour on the electorate vote.

Now the pendulum has:

  1. Taupo -2.6%
  2. Rotorua -1.1%
  3. Otaki 0.9%
  4. Hamilton West 3.2%
  5. West Coast-Tasman 4.1%
  6. Palmerston North 13.2%
  7. Auckland Central 14.1%
  8. New Plymouth 14.8%
  9. Waimakariri 16.6%
  10. Port Hills 17.2%
  11. Wellington Central 17.6%
  12. Maungakiekie 22.2%
  13. Hutt South 24.6%
  14. Waitakere 25.8%
  15. Mana 26.6%
  16. Rimutaka 28.8%
  17. Dunedin North 29.2%

Again this does not take into account individual impacts in electorates. The retirements of incumbents in Maungakiekie and Rimutaka may make them more competitive. And Clayton Cosgrove is generally regarded as more popular locally than his party.

If the nine seats above do all fall, along with two more Maori seats to the Maori Party that would reduce Labour to just 20 out fo 70 electorates.

ODT on Labour and energy

The ODT blasts Labour over high power prices:

Management inadequacies have been one of the features of the Clark Government in its leadership of the administration of public services and the guidance of enterprises whose activities have a crucial impact on our daily lives.

Yep.

One of the most obvious of these has been the failure, over most of the period from 1999, to put together as a matter of high priority a comprehensive energy plan for present and predicted demand and ensure it can be met with appropriate infrastructure.

The plan seems to be to hope for rain.

The self-serving Clark Government statement last week, that Contact Energy’s “alarming” 10%-12% planned price increases for its Dunedin consumers could not be justified, underlines the inadequacy of the response to energy supply and pricing issues.

Especially ironic as it comes at the same time they passed the ETS which will send prices up even more.

Nationally, household power prices have increased by an estimated 66% on average since 1999, when the Clark Government was elected, which is a rate way ahead of the rate of inflation.

And further increases to come.

Violent and Sexual Crime rates since 1988

This shows the rate of violent and sexual crime per capita since the current method of recording crime began.

Let us start with the pink line of violent crime. It did increase massively from 1992 to 1994 especially. No doubt the high unemployment was a factor. Sadly you get high unemployment when you inherit a near bankrupt economy with huge debts and deficits, and have to take tough measures to get through it.

But then for four years the violent crime rate stayed stable, and even declined a bit. Yes from 1995 to 1999 it was a slight downwards trend.

Then after 1999, despite the continuation of a fall in unemployment, it increased slowly but steadily for three years, started to very slightly trend down for two years and for the last three years has increased dramatically.

The blue line of sexual crimes has varied a lot, possibly reflecting the smaller number of crimes. From 1990 to 1993 these crimes increased in frequency. But then from 1993 to 1999 there was a massive fall off in sexual crimes – except in one year.

Since 1999 it has been a varied picture. Generally it trended up for the first three years. Then for the next three years after that it fell off to go even lower than in 1999. But again since 2005 it has risen again through to 2007 before what may be the start of a decline in 2008.

The week at iPredict

It has been a week of steady gains at Ipredict for PM.National investors this week. Last Friday they were at 73c, and over the week trades kept edging up in price closing at 76c.

The TV3 poll on Sunday night had no impact on the share price, reflecting it was close to the average of the polls showing a 13% gap.

PM.Labour has been much more volatile, ranging between 21c and 27c. They hit their low of 21c at 7.50 am on Tuesday 30 September – possibly linked to many people first getting the news that the US House of Representatives had voted down the US$700 billion bailout package – an economic meltdown in America would damage all economies, and make it tough for any incumbent Government.

Peters.Resign continues to cruise downwards. A week ago it had fallen to 16c, and over the week dropped to below 11c. Peters filed his amended pecuniary interests returns on Tuesday, revealing that the SFO were right that he had the Spencer Trust pay a $40,000 bill on his behalf. But even that only pushed the stock up to 16c. Most in the market have concluded he is unsackable.

MP.Peters which is effectively how the market rates NZ First’s chances of making it back, finished last week at 36c. It fell to 32c over the weekend but on Tuesday rose again to almost hit 40c – possible this was a result of no further gifts being disclosed in Peters’ amended returns. By late Thursday though they were down to 31c – after it was noticed that Labour were taking credit for many of NZ First’s policies.

A stock not looked at before is Majority.Nat – the price of a share that will pay $1 if National gains a majority of the seats. All week it was between 30c and 33c, but on Thursday some confident investors pushed the price up to 40c briefly.

Finally we look at the new stock released on Wednesday for Wellington Central – WC.Franks and WC.Robertson. The initial offering price was 55.5c for Robertson and 43.5c for Franks. Franks shot up to 60c briefly but then dropped back to 40c. That evening the candidates debated on the TVNZ7 Backbenches show. Franks stock dropped during that show 35c, suggesting viewers thought Robertson did better. WC.Robertson peaked at 70c after float but since then has been around 60c. The debate did push him up from 58c to 62c.

Clark’s logic on tax cuts

The Herald reports:

After campaigning in Otara on Saturday, Helen Clark told the crowd at the Avondale market yesterday to reject, and laugh at National’s tax policy – regardless of the size of cuts.

Good to see she is keeping an open mind. The tax cuts are bad and evil regardless of how big they are or who benefits from them. Pathetic.

“Every $10 to $15 you add on to a tax cut right now means things you can’t do – for our health system, for our old folks, for our children, and for putting more police on the streets.”

So is she saying Labour’s tax cuts of up to $55 a week for the highest income earners means she has removed potential money from the health system, old folks, children and the Police?

Clark is a fraud – trying to con people that tax cuts if done by Labour are wonderful, but tax cuts done by National are evil. You can’t have it both ways.

The registered parties for 2008

Unless a new party pops up to register before Thursday, then there are 21 parties contesting the election, in terms of the party vote. This assumes they will all file a party list, which may not happen.

In 1996 there were 22 registered parties, with 21 of them contesting the election. In 1999 25 registered parties and 22 of them contested the election.

2002 saw just 15 parties registered, and 14 competing. And last time in 2005 all 19 parties made it onto the ballot.

The parties in alphabetical order are

  1. ACT New Zealand
  2. Aotearoa Legalise Cannabis Party
  3. Direct Democracy Party
  4. Jim Anderton’s Progressive
  5. Libertarianz
  6. Māori Party
  7. New World Order
  8. New Zealand First Party
  9. New Zealand Labour Party
  10. New Zealand Pacific Party
  11. RAM – Residents Action Movement
  12. The Alliance
  13. The Bill and Ben Party
  14. The Family Party
  15. The Greens, The Green Party of Aotearoa/New Zealand
  16. The Kiwi Party
  17. The New Zealand Democratic Party for Social Credit
  18. The New Zealand National Party
  19. The Republic of New Zealand Party
  20. UNITED FUTURE NEW ZEALAND
  21. Workers Party of New Zealand

Herald rates the Maori Party

Claire Trevett rates the Maori Party in the Herald:

  • Performance Rating: 7/10
  • Assets and liabilities: co-leaders biggest asset, inexperience of other MPs may be a liability
  • Successes and failures: Has maintained strong discipline, failed to repeal Foreshore & Seabed Act
  • Policies: entrench Maori seats, more Treaty clauses in legislation, no tax on first $25K of income, no GST on food, minimum wage to $15 an hour, company tax lowered to 25% for small businesses
  • Needs to do: Keep explaining explaining why it is keeping options with both major parties open

National to end parole for the worst violent offenders

The Herald reports National is to has announce that a violent offender will not be eligible for parole, if they have previously been convicted of a violent crime and sentenced to five or more years in prison previously.

The “life means life” sentence would have applied to high-profile offenders such as prison-van basher George Charlie Baker, RSA triple-killer William Duane Bell and samurai sword assailant and killer Antonie Dixon.

Great.

It is understood National’s research shows that of the 144 offenders convicted of murder since 2002, 10 would be in this category.

This sounds about right. It is only the worst 5% to 10% of killers who will never be released.

The policy would have a big effect on the full spectrum of violent crime. Repeat robbers, repeat rapists and those who repeatedly commit violence within the home would not get parole.

Those denied parole under this category would also be monitored for a fixed term when they were released, “rather than being left to their own devices”.

It is understood National believes an additional 572 offenders could be in prison by late 2011 because of the policy.

And I think people would be surprised by how many crimes those 572 offenders commit by being let out early.

This would require a new jail, which the party has costed at $314 million, and an extra $43 million a year in prison operating costs.

That is a price I am happy to pay.

Prime Minister Helen Clark this morning described the National policy as vindictive. She said that under current law some prisoners were not released.

“It’s very easy to say lock the door and throw the key away,” she said on TV One’s Breakfast programme.

“A lot of these long-term prisoners, over time start to change their behaviour, some become very religious.

“The National Party’s attitude is they don’t care about that at all, they just want to be vindictive.”

Vindictive against repeat violent offenders. Well if you have to be vindictive, better to target rapists and killers than the Exclusive Brethren.

And I repeat – this only applies to the worst of the worst – those who have already been sentenced to five or more years in jail for a violent crime, and after being released have commited another violent crime.

Ralston on Key and MMP

Bill Ralston writes in the HoS:

National’s John Key thrust home another dagger, dismissing any suggestion he would deal with Peters after the election, saying the New Zealand First leader does not come up to National’s standards.

For someone Labour likes to paint as a political novice still wet behind the ears and who needs to “harden up”, Key is playing a pretty astute pre-election game. …

By deliberately excluding negotiations with New Zealand First, he has painted Peters into a corner.

He sends the message to anyone inclined to vote New Zealand First that a vote for it is also an automatic vote for another Labour-led government. That may not be so attractive to some New Zealand First supporters who incline to National.

At the same time, he signals potential Labour voters who may have tired of Peters’ antics that a vote for Labour will see the return of the beleaguered Minister Without Portfolio.

That trick alone should be worth a couple of percentage points to National at the ballot box.

Indeed. Just remember:

SST on Hide

Sir Douglas Graham on Maori seats and overhang

Sir Douglas writes in the SST about the Maori seats and how they may deliver an disproportional result:

If the Maori Party still receives only 2.1% of the party vote, it will be entitled to three seats again. But if it wins all seven of the Maori seats the overhang will be four and we would temporarily have 124. Now here’s a real problem. Let’s assume one party gets 51% of the party vote, giving it 61 of the fixed 120 seats. This would reflect the wish of the public that it should be able to govern alone. But to its horror it suddenly finds that even though it has a majority of the party vote, it doesn’t have a majority of the seats in parliament. To have that it now need 63 seats, which may make the difference between governing alone and being forced into a deal with another party.

The overhang Maori Party electorate seats would have frustrated the will of the people. In any event, with more than twice the number of seats it should have to reflect proportionality, its influence is now out of all proportion to its degree of public support.

I’ve written about this before. It is one of the reasons that I support the recommendation of the Royal Commission to abolish the seats, but in return lower the threshold for the party vote.

So let’s look at what has happened as we approach the fifth election under MMP. Today with the Maori population at about 14%, we have 22 MPs of Maori descent making up about 19% of the House. On the face of it, if the Maori seats were abolished there would be only 15 MPs of Maori descent making up 13% of the House. But with 220,000 voters moving from the Maori roll to the general roll and now voting in general electorates, we can expect political parties will increase the number of candidates of Maori descent.

I suspect after this election there may be even more Maori MPs. And nothing wrong with that – far from it. But it will raise the issue of whether you need the seats, when there is an over-representaton, not an under-representation.

Blog Bits

Danyl writes:

I can unhestitatingly guarantee that Four Weeks, Three Months and Two days is the best film about getting an abortion in Ceausescu’s Romania you’ll see all year.

Possibly not such a great first date movie.

Heh indeed. That reminds me of a story from a friend. A guy took her to a film festival film on a date. The film basically was about how both the female and male leads were raped, and how it affected their relationship. Eventually the male lead blew his brains out. I think it may have been the worst possible date movie ever!

Aaron B blogs:

Americans have taken to emailing Nigerians warning them that if they get offers to put money into an American bank – don’t do it, because it’s a scam.

Heh.

Homepaddock praises Wotif for finding places to stay. I agree – it is a great site and I use it all the time.

No Minister has a list of false statements made by Joe Biden in the Vice-Presidential debate. I’m waiting to see what Fact Check makes of the claims from both sides.