OJ found guilty

Who wants to be a millionaire

I confess to loving the Australian version of Who wants to be a millionaire. Eddie McGuire is brilliant in that role.

The HoS has an article on the NZ version, with a contestant saying:

Washington’s criticism wasn’t confined to the questions. She found Hosking “arrogant” and “off-putting”.

Hosking said his role was not to help or hinder any contestant and it was “impossible” for him to be off-putting.

“I ask a question, I give you four options, answer one or not, or use a lifeline or not. What else can I do?”

The fact Hosking is asking the question, answers it. Hosking is a very talented news and current affairs interviewer but a game show host is about empathy and warmth. He has not displayed it to date and I am not sure if it is something you can learn. Watch Eddie McGuire and you see him bond with the contestants, get a bit blokey with them sometimes, chat Aussie Rules of course, and he helps make the show.

The other aspects of the article focus on whether the initial questions are too hard. Again I think they may be. The first five questions should be incredibly easy so everyone gets at least $1,000. People don’t like a show where too many people leave with nothing. The second set of five should be moderately challenging and the final five incredibly challenging.

Katya Paquin

The Herald on Sunday interviews Katya Paquin, partner of Green co-leader Russel Norman, as she battles a brain tumour, first diagnosed in 2005. It is hard to imagine how challenging coping with that must be, and one can only hope that upcoming surgery is as sucessful as it can be.

Paquin and Norman met through the Greens, when she was an intern and Norman a secretary.

Paquin heads up the Green’s advisory unit, and has a law degree and honours in politics.

Her sister Anna Paquin, is of course the famous actress. A new series in the US called True Blood has Anna in the lead role as Sookie Stackhouse and I’ve watched the first couple of episodes. You almost do not recognise Paquin at first as she has long blond hair, and has that Southern US accent down so well. It’s a great TV show, which will get a cult following I predict.

Apart from the personal stuff on Paquin, there are some interesting political points in the interview:

The couple’s combined dedication to the cause goes back to their first meeting at work. Their common aim now, apart from conquering Paquin’s tumour, is to help the Greens get across the 5 per cent vote threshold at the general election.

This is the major challenge for the Greens – to stay in Parliament. As I have said previously I think a different strategy could have them close to 10%, but the polls have them perilously close to 5%.

It’s a campaign that will be run very differently this time around, they say, a campaign which will be strictly independent from Labour. There will be no “Jeanette and Helen limo” shots after Labour’s deal with New Zealand First in 2005.

“I felt she [Clark] sold us down the river,” says Norman. “I think it was a bit of a shock to the party, to all of us.

And if NZ First makes it back, Clark will choose them over the Greens again. Could anyone imagine Helen Clark spending so much political capital on defending Jeanette Fitzsimons or Norman himself?

Based on the polls Labour is “clearly” in trouble and “those polls have been pretty consistent”.

With the Greens now wary of Labour, Norman says they would consider working with National.

“It depends on policy. If we could have an agreement on a public transport system for Auckland, reduce our greenhouse emissions – for us it’s about policy gains so we will work on that basis with whoever, that’s what it’s got to be about.”

I don’t think there is any question that the Greens, if in Parliament, would always vote to have a Labour-led Government over a National-led Government if they are in a position to decide. This is of course why Labour takes them for granted.

However if National can govern without the Greens, but is still willing to negotiate a policy agreement with them in exchange for perhaps an abstention on confidence and supply, then it would be worthwhile to at least try and form an agreement. It might in the end prove impossible, but it would be nice to be able to say “We agree in these areas and will work together”.

September Public Polls Newsletter

I’ve just sent out Curia’s September 2008 Public Polls Newsletter. It has an expanded section this month looking at the Canadian election on 14 October, the US election on 5 November plus of course our election on 8 November.

If you would like to receive future issues go to this website to subscribe yourself.

A slight increase in the vote to 15%, but still not as wide as it was in June and July.

The Greens are trending towards the critical 5% threshold, and NZ First also drops slightly to just over 3%.

The Palin-Biden debate

42% more people watched the Vice-Presidental debate than the Presidential debate. How weird is that?

Consensus seems to be Biden did best, but Palin exceeded expectations and held up okay.

However Obama now has a commanding leads in the polls – almost 6% nationally and almost 2:1 in the electoral college.

Mandelson is back

Gordon Brown has just appointed Peter Mandelson to the House of Lords and to the Cabinet as Secretary of State for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform.

Those who do not follow UK politics will not realise how extraordinary this is. Brown and Mandelson have spent a decade hating each other.

Lance Price recaps how their feud almost destroyed the Blair Government.

Mandelson is a very smart political operator, and it is a bold move by Brown to bring him in. It will get the Blairities back on board and strengthen the Cabinet. However Mandelson is hated by many Labour MPs also, so it is a risk.

The right to self defence

Time and time again the Police charge shop keepers who defend themselves against armed invaders. Remember Greg Carvill who was prosecuted for shooting a machete wielding invader. I suppose he should have just handed all his guns over to him.

Now we have Virender Singh who is being prosecuted for using a hockey stick against some armed intruders – they had a knife and fence paling and actually stabbed Singh and his cousin as they were trying to hold him down until Police came.

Store owners in parts of Auckland are terrified of being attacked. An Avondale dairy owner was stabbed in his neck and back yesterday. A nearby owner who has been robbed four times comments:

Mr Lochan, 61, said he had been robbed four times, and he was concerned that shopkeepers were not allowed to protect themselves.

“When we protect ourselves, we get charged – and if we don’t we get stabbed. What do we do?” he asked.

Also later in the story:

While police were investigating the stabbing, they were called to a store in nearby Bremner Ave, Mt Roskill, where two youths threatened a shop owner with a knife.

I think we may need a law change to make the right to self defence more explicit. Shop keepers are being shot and stabbed even if they co-operate.

UPDATE: MacDoctor below makes the point:

I almost choked when Sergeant Pizzini said to the media that Virender Singh should have dial 111. These are the same police who took 45 minutes to gain control of the scene and come to the “rescue” of the dying Navtej Singh, ensuring his death. If Austin Hemmings had smashed his briefcase into the face of his attacker, he may have survived, but would have promptly been arrested by this moron for using “excessive force”.

Sadly I think he may be right.

The quickest signing ever!

Herald on Clark

The NZ Herald does a performance review of Helen Clark:

  • MOTIVATION:As strong as ever, perhaps even stronger.
  • VISION: Improving after a lean patch earlier in current term.
  • LEADERSHIP: Has increasingly polarised the public the longer she has remained in power.
  • JUDGEMENT: Still sound, but occasional lapses.
  • CUSTOMER SATISFACTION: Declining.
  • MANAGERIAL STYLE: Basically unchanged.
  • COMMUNICATION: Still all over the media when it matters – and often when it doesn’t.
  • HUMAN RESOURCES MANAGEMENT: Impressive.
  • OVERALL PERFORMANCE: Still a prime minister very much in her prime, while other long-serving colleagues are starting to fall by the wayside.

I think the NZ Herald is being too generous in a couple of areas. I have always said that Clark is skilled in many areas, but would question their reasoning on leadership and judgement.

The Herald said:

Rating as preferred prime minister remains extraordinarily high for such a long-serving premier – around double the level of Jim Bolger and Jenny Shipley prior to them losing the keys to Premier House.

Not true for Jenny Shipley. One News Colmar Brunton poll had Shipley at 30% on 11 November 1999. Helen Clark incidentally was at 24%. The latest One News Colmar Brunton had Clark at 31% and Key at 40%.

So Clark is at the exact same level Shipley was just before the election. The big difference is the Opposition Leader (Key) is around two thirds higher than Clark was as Opposition Leader in 1999.

The Herald also said:

JUDGMENT

Still sound, but occasional lapses. Cautious and conservative, she always consults widely before making critical decisions.

Experience has taught her to hold nerve and avoid panic responses to fleeting crises as the public memory is short.

Politically costly reluctance to heed majority view on anti-smacking legislation was driven by personal wish to pass legislation which might help halt child beatings.

Seeming blind spots on Labour’s pledge card heist and flawed Electoral Finance Bill.

Also got herself in a muddle over Owen Glenn twice in one year. Should have wiped her hands of Phillip Field far earlier but was worried about losing Pacific Islander vote.

More lenient to Winston Peters than his behaviour warranted, but she was wary of the damage he might inflict had she ditched him completely.

I contend that is more than an occassional lapse. On almost every major issue this term Clark has made the wrong call. In the first two terms she had generally sound judgement, but her third term has been misjudgement after misjudgement – the pledge card, attacking the Auditor-General, refusing to pay it back until forced to, the anti-smacking law, the defence of Taito Philip Field and Yes Minister type inquiry designed to find no fault, the Electoral Finance Bill, not ditching Benson-Pope earlier, allowing Winston to get away with lying and false evidence, not delivering tax cuts earlier.

Put it like this, what major issues did she make the right call on?

First blogmobile outings

The blogmobile is now in Wellington and most of the gear on board. Thanks to all those who have sent through details of events – keep them coming. And also thanks to all those who have offered a meal or a bed.

On Sunday we are heading up to Otaki for the day – partly to cover a Meet the Candidates meeting. Otaki is the most marginal seat in NZ and will be hard fought – both Darren Hughes and Nathan Guy are well regarded.

During the week we will be in Wairarapa for a day – again chatting to some locals, testing out some dog toys, interviewing candidates and maybe visit some vineyards!. I should warn James S that the driver has been instructed that if James jumps onto the road, we don’t want any skid marks 🙂

SSC Report into the NZ Immigration Service

The SSC Report is online here. Here are the conclusions of Commissioner Iain Rennie:

Mr Shanks’ report shows that Mary Anne Thompson was involved with six immigration-related procedures relating to members of her family in 2004 and 2005. Although the investigation finds no evidence that Ms Thompson’s family members were seeking preferential treatment, the report is clear that her involvement resulted in them receiving personal benefits that they would not have normally received if she had not held her position in the Department.

A clear statement of fact that there was preferential treatment.

Ms Thompson’s behaviour was wholly inappropriate on two counts. First, it consistently breached the Department’s clearly-stated requirements for staff to disclose potential personal conflicts to their manager before taking any action. Secondly, the long-standing expectation of State servants, outlined most recently in the Code of Conduct for the State Services, is that they are trustworthy. This includes not acting in a way that may improperly benefit our family or friends or groups in which we have a personal interest.

Ouch.

Overall, the Department did not deal with the issue in a timely or effective fashion up to the end of 2007 and because of ineffective investigations Ms Thompson was consequently dealt with in a manner that was too informal and lenient in relation to the conduct she displayed.

In particular, the actions taken by Dr James Buwalda, the Chief Executive of the Department of Labour until May 2007, were not effective in terms of clearly establishing what was happening and dealing with the conflict of interest. Concerns about visa waivers were first raised with Dr Buwalda, in 2005. The informality of Dr Buwalda’s engagement with Ms Thompson around his concerns at that time led her to consider that he thought the issue was of little consequence.

Now that Departmental CEOs are being paid over $500,000 a year salary, we should be expecting much better from them than this.

If you read the report in detail you see that Dr Buwalda deserves most of the criticism. He had numerous reports coming to him from staff concerned about Thompson’s involvement, and he did little to manage the problem or to assert authority.

Thompson made some serious errors of judgement. She did not seek special favours, but should have been aware that her involvement would create problems. If her CEO had been more onto it, then it might have all been sorted at an earlier stage.

Soper on Winston and John Rowles

Barry Soper at Newstalk ZB had an amusing piece of Winston’s upcoming campaign launch with John Rowles:

It was with great fanfare that Luigi Peters vroomed on to the stage on the back of a big Harley through a cloud of dry ice three years ago.

On the stage before him was the mouthy comedian Mike King who’d slagged Head Girl Helen with such venom that the audience was left squirming. So it was with some relief that the Harley thundered on to the stage with its pin up cargo.

This time this Sunday’s campaign launch for the Peters Party promises to be a little more sedate with the old crooner John Rowles agreeing to do the honours.

He’ll have to be careful with his repertoire though. One of his early big hits, If I Only Had Time, may be a little inappropriate in the circumstances. His first hit, The End of The Rainbow, could hold out some hope for Luigi, providing he doesn’t include his second money maker Please Help Me I’m Falling.

It’s going to be difficult not to read too much into what The Rowler will deliver. Forty years ago he hit the British charts with The Night We Called It A Day which came out just before That Lovin’ Feeling which he clearly has for Luigi.

There’s one of his hits that Luigi would relate to though and that’s The Pain Goes On Forever although The Rowler had better not belt out his other chart topper Say Goodbye.

If he croons Hush Not a Word to Mary, she’s bound to be seen as some sort of relation to Owen Glenn.

To take the job in such a heated political environment seems appropriate when you consider another couple of Rowles’ foot tappers, I Must Have Been Out Of My Mind or It Takes A Fool Like Me.

But then for Luigi to make it back into the bear pit the Rowles album of 20 years ago In My Wildest Dreams springs to mind.

But after the November 8 poll Luigi could just be left with a more recent, but popular Rowles album From a Distance.

Barry obviously knows his John Rowles songs!

The Helen toys just get more popular

The Helen toys have broken through the 60% mark as they just get more and more popular. The John Campbell toys are dropping off a bit and the gap between Campbell and Sainsbury is narrowing.

If any readers have purchased a toy just send us the photos of your dog playing with it. We’ll run the best ones.

No Mass Debate

No Mass Debate is the title of this week’s Dispatch from Helengrad.

The summay is:

  • Best Play of the Week: Regulations Review Committee gets a B+ for their report on the Government’s Auckland Airport retrospective regulations
  • Worst Play of the Week: US House of Representatives gets an E
  • Scandal of the Week: Helen and John get a C grade scandal for saying no to the mass debate
  • EFA Breach of the Week: The Electoral Commission gets an A+ for their honest annual report. I wonder if the strength of their criticism of the EFA means their annual report is an election advertisement itself 🙂
  • Blog Analysis of the Week: Fran O’Sullivan gets a B+ for her call for a NZ bipartisan response to the credit crisis

Comments and feedback can be done on NBR.

Winston declares Spencer Trust donation

The Parliament website now records the amended return by Winston Peters for the year to 31 January 2007.

A gift from the Spencer Trust towards his electoral petition costs has been declared.

This would never have come to light if it were not for the SFO. Peters and Henry supplied false evidence to the Privileges Committee about this issue.

Now Peters has officially declared the gift, known to be $40,000, the ball is in the PM’s Court. The Cabinet Manual says:

Ministers who accept gifts worth more than the prescribed value must not only disclose them to the Registrar of Pecuniary Interests of Members of Parliament, but also must relinquish them, unless they obtain the express permission of the Prime Minister to retain them.

Helen Clark must give her “express permission” or Peters is required to relinquish the gift.

Will Clark give her permission for a Minister to keep what was effectively a personal donation of $40,000? That is 80 times greater than the disclosure limit and probably the biggest gift by a magnitude ever received by a Minister.

And is the Prime Minister at all concerned that the ultimate source of the money was almost certainly the Velas? Does she think Cabinet should have been informed of these personal donations to the Minister of Racing, when they accepted his recommendation to spend taxpayer money on bigger prizes for horse races?

My Sky HDi

To go along with the new hi def 42″ flat screen, I figured I should invest in upgrading the My Sky box to My Sky HDi. It was a good investment, as Pat Pilcher states in the Herald.

New features include:

  • Movies, Sports and TV3 in high def
  • Dolby Digital Audio
  • HD doubled to 320 GB
  • Four tuners, allowing three to be used for recording and viewing, and the fourth for the programme guide
  • An Ethernet port, allowing downloading from the Internet at some future stage
  • A USB port, which may allow you to add on additional storage one day

Pilcher’s recommendation:

MySKy HDi is more of an evolutionary improvement than just an upgrade to its non-HDMI sibling. HD video, proper surround audio and what appears to be some serious future-proofing makes buying MySky HDi a definite no-brainer.

I agree.

Presidential Voting still open

Dim-Post announces details of leaders debate

The Dim-Post announces new topics for the Leaders Debates to increase theri ratings:

TV3 is defending its controversial move to restrict the topics of their upcoming leaders debate to focus on 80’s popular culture after the decision was met with a storm of criticism.

Mark Jennings is the director of TV3’s News and Current Affairs. He insists that the network was forced into its current position by the two main parties, Labour and National.

‘The leaders have made a political choice,’ Mr Jennings said. ‘They have agreed that the majority of viewers are not likely to watch a debate about domestic and foreign policy so we intend to concentrate on where the party leaders stand on the early career of Madonna and whether Ghostbusters is funnier than The Lost Boys.‘

Ghost Busters is funnier – a classic.

Mr Jennings said today that he stood by the decision.

‘Our market research shows that less than 5% of viewers are interested in watching politicians debate education, taxation or health care but more than 60% will tune in to watch Key and Clark singing Bohemiam Rhapsody together.‘

Helen Clark announced that she looked forward to the debate in which she intended to show that John Key was unprepared to be Prime Minister and that Stevie Nicks was better than Cyndi Lauper. Key responded by challenging Clark to name four songs off the Motley Crue album Girls, Girls, Girls.

‘She cannot because she doesn’t have the facts and because she does not care about the Crue,’ Key told reporters. ‘She doesn’t care about Def Leopard, she doesn’t care about Bon Jovi and quite frankly New Zealanders are sick and tired of it.’

The scary thing is I could almost hear John Key’s voice in my head saying just that, as I read it.

The bulk of the debate will focus on 80’s films. Initial reports sugggest the two leaders are united in their support of The Breakfast Club, Ferris Bueller’s Day Off and The Goonies but bitterly divided on key issues such as whether Labyrinth was better than The Dark Crystal.

They will also square off over the question of ‘Best 80’s Movie of All Time’. While Prime Minister Helen Clark has announced that she will endorse either Tootsie or The Princess Bride, National Leader John Key has indicated that he will argue vigorously for the movie Aliens which he describes as kickass totally awesome.

Labyrinth was better. Alien was better than Aliens and and The Princess Bride rocks.

The coin count

The annual coin totals were:

  1. $2 x 120 = $240
  2. $1 x 168 = $168
  3. 0.50c (old) x 9 = $4.50
  4. 0.50c x 349 = $174.50
  5. 0.20c (old) x 44 = $8.80
  6. 0.20c x 302 = $60.40
  7. 0.10c (old) x 108 = $10.80
  8. 0.10c x 185 = $18.50
  9. 0.05c (old) x 110 = $5.50

Total was 1,395 coins worth $691.00

I knew the old coins were not legal tender at shops but thought banks would still take them. But no BNZ said they no longer accept them. But rather than waste $29.60, I then trotted up to the Reserve Bank to exchange them. Even better they said they can just direct credit my bank account with them so in a geeky sort of way, rather cool to have a Reserve Bank deposit on the bank statement.

Anyway I now have $700 more to spend – Borders awaits!

The Electoral Commission Annual Report

The ELectoral Commission has just published its annual report. This is its official report to Parliament and signed off by the Commissioners.

Some extracts:

The Electoral Finance Act 2007 (supported by amendments to the Broadcasting and Electoral Acts)
made a number of significant changes to the compliance requirements on political parties and
introduced compliance requirements for third parties beyond authorisation statements.

These changes have presented implementation and administrative challenges to all involved. The meanings of significant sections of the legislation are obscure. This situation has required – and will require – constant legal advice to assist with interpretation.

The commission is not confident that it will be able to reach informed positions on the interpretation of some provisions within the election period, and notes that the situation is exacerbated by the legal reality that it cannot finally determine questions of whether, for instance, an item is an election advertisement.

It is worth remembering that the Commission CEO actually warned the Government about this, before they passed the law.

The new legislation was enacted on 19 December 2007 with commencement the following day, and the regulated period commencing on 1 January 2008. This meant implementation planning and process development had to begin while the shape of the final legislation was unclear. The significant changes to the Bill at select committee, and a lack of time between enactment and commencement also meant that interpretive and practical implications could not be worked through in advance of the law being in force. A lack of broad political consensus through the passage of the bill and since has resulted in difficult law delivered into a litigious environment.

In other words the law change was left too late (Labour delyed it for months while it secretly negotiatedprovisions of it), the changes at select committee needed more time to consider and it was done without even an attempt at political consensus, hence shattering the bipartisan approach to it in the past.

Similarly, parties, candidates and third parties (listed or not) have had to come to terms with the implications of the new legislation also. It is clear that having uncertainty remaining within the regulated period has had a chilling effect on the extent and type of participation in political and campaign activity.

This is what Dr Catt said to a seminar some time ago, but it has more significance when included in the official annual report to Parliament, signed off by the various Judges and Secretary of Justice who make up the Commission along with Dr Catt.

If Labour First are re-elected they will not only keep the Electoral Finance Act, but they will change it to make their taxpayer funded advertising exempt from it.

Garth George on deeds not trust

Garth George writes in the Herald:

Said Helen Clark when she announced the election date: “I think it does come down to who you trust on the basics.” Well, if that is so, Labour is out on its ear.

In spite of vast extra spending, the health service is less effective than it was when Labour came to power in 1999; same goes for the education system, law and order and justice. As for defence, the most sacred of any government’s responsibilities, the less said the better.

And what about fiscal stewardship? Who trusts a Finance Minister who robs the taxpayers blind of untold billions of dollars over eight years then, with an election looming, reluctantly offers insignificant tax cuts. According to figures published in this newspaper this week, even those who get the most from the cuts will receive barely enough to cover the increased cost of filling the tank of the family car.

Sure, I’m grateful for any increase in my pension, but that’s more down to Mr Peters than it is to Michael Cullen.

Nevertheless, according to figures published lately, New Zealanders’ living standards have dropped 24 per cent against Australians’ in the term of this Labour-led Government. …

A matter of trust? I think not. Rather it is, as the Bible puts it, a matter of “By their deeds you shall know them”.

The oldies

Simon Collins reports today on views amongst older NZers, as part of his ongoing series of 600 interviews.

The country’s northernmost publicans have not seen a National Party leader to admire since Sir Robert Muldoon lost power 24 years ago.

Rob’s Mob lives on!

“I didn’t like Don Brash any better. I liked Muldoon back in his day. You need someone strong in those parties. Helen Clark is strong, but she’s led by the Green Party.”

This will be news to the Greens!

But they are concerned about hospital waiting lists. As 65-year-old Trish Brett of New Plymouth put it: “There’s something wrong when people can win $5-6 million in Lotto and on the other side of things people are dying because they’re not getting the proper care.”

This is one of those weird statements. Lotto is nto funded by the Government. Far from it – Lotto raises money for the Government. I call it a stupidity tax 🙂

The Peters affair is driving away some former Labour voters, such as New Plymouth school hostel matron Kay Death, 52.

“I’m thinking of not voting,” she says. “I can’t be bothered with them.”

Former Labour-voting Foxton housewife Betty Cole, about 60, says: “After this Winston Peters debacle it’s definitely time for a change. I hope National will bring stability.”

Good good.