Progress on copyright

I blogged last week on the new copyright law, and how the provision about ISPs having to terminate Internet access for repeat infringers was causing huge problems.

The good news is the Government seems to be listening. IT Brief reports:

The government has bowed to unprecedented ICT industry pressure, announcing a four-month moratorium on Section 92A of its new Copyright (New Technologies) Amendment Act.

Communications minister David Cunliffe revealed the back-down during the InternetNZ TVNZ7 Internet Debate held on Tuesday night, saying the delay would give the industry and content providers time to come up with an alternative approach to controlling copyright on the internet.

The debate incidentially went really well I thought. Possibly could have been a bit shorter, but we had a good mixture of politics and policy. There was some generally good natured sparring that kept it interesting, but also some useful and interesting policy discussions around broadband, copyright, filtering etc.

From a technical point of view it was pretty seamless as we took questions from journalists, from the studio audience, from the online chat channel and also video questions through Skype. The InternetNZ staff and TVNZ staff and contractors did very well making it happen. Several people said they would like to see more debates with that interactive format.

Damien, Russell and Fran were all good at challenging the MPs, quite aggressively at times.

The funninest part for me was Maurice WIlliamson saying he had no idea why he voted for the new copyright law, as it is such a stupid law. I thought Maurice did very well, but in fact all four MPs did well with strengths in different areas.

You can view the video of the whole thing at debate.net.nz.

Anyway back to copyright. The Dominion Post also reports:

Paul Moreno, a spokesman for Justice Minister Judith Tizard, said a delay to regulations required to put the cut-off clause into force was being considered, and that the delay might be “endless”.

“Judith is of the mind that Internet access is almost a human right now, similar to water and electricity.”

But Ms Tizard then appeared to toughen her stance, stressing that the Government was concerned to protect copyright holders.

And it is important to protect copyright holders. But look at the gap between the possible interpretations:

Ms Tizard would not say whether the intention was that the cut-off threat should apply only to people who had been repeatedly convicted of copyright offences, or to those who had been accused of infringements by bodies such as the Recording Industry Association – indicating it had been left deliberately unclear.

“The intention of this provision is to provide a framework for the ISP industry and rights holders to develop an efficient and effective mechanism that is workable for both parties.”

Telecommunications Carriers Forum chief executive Ralph Chivers said if the former definition was used, that might be one solution.

But Recording Industry Association chief executive Campbell Smith said that would not be acceptable as it would require copyright holders to sue infringers to prove their guilt. “That is just impractical and ridiculous. I don’t think that is what was intended.”

Instead, ISPs should cut off customers who infringed copyright after notifications from rights holders, he said.

Losing your Internet access on the basis of unproven accusations is not a goer for me.

The next Labour attack?

Valedictories

I’ll put some video up later today,, but for now here are four stories on retiring MPs

  1. Katherine Rich
  2. Clem Simich
  3. Margaret Wilson
  4. Mark Blumsky

While totally respecting her decision, I am still really sad and cut up about Katherine leaving. Katherine would have been a superb Minister and she is just one of the neatest people you can ever get to meet. I have absolutely no desire to work in Parliament again, but if I did I would want to work for Katherine if she had stayed on.

Katherine, Clem and Mark are all from the socially liberal “wing” of National. National’s strength is that blend of conservatism and liberalism. There is a healthy acceptance that National needs both. The “liberals” don’t want to turn National into a conservative free zone, and neither do conservatives want to have National without its blend of liberalism.

The challenge for classical liberals like myself is to make sure the liberal wing is not so small as to be ineffective or invisible. But luckily both the 2005 and the likely 2008 intakes have or had reasonable proportions of “social liberals”.

Russell Brown on Peters

Russell Brown is not too happy with Labour on Peters:

The failure of the Labour members of the privileges committee to find with the multi-party majority that Winston Peters had provided “false or misleading information on a return of pecuniary interests” was pathetic, and they know it.

And later on:

I hold no brief for Peters, and I suspect there will be worse to come on his and his party’s affairs. I think Chris Trotter’s comparison of the privileges committee’s action to a lynching (he even has a picture of a man being lynched on his blog) is revolting.

There is an interesting split occurring on the left. There are those who are disgusted with Labour and willing to say so. And there are those who are hugging Winston closer and closer and trying to turn him into a martyr and a hero.

Russell of course also has a go at John Key, linking to the editorial in today’s Herald about him. I have previously blogged my criticism of the Tranzrail responses, along with my relief that unlike Peters and Clark who never admit they do anything wrong, Key did admit his mistakes.

I have said for some time that this election is National’s, unless they stuff up. This is not an impossibility, to put it mildly. It would be an incredible shame if they do stuff up, and we get a fourth term of Clark and Peters. They say we get the Government we deserve but seriously we’re not that bad are we?

My iPredict portfolio

I am now starting to get quite into iPredict now I have worked it out more fully. My current portfolio is:

  1. Own 49 shares purchased at 78c that Benson-Pope will stand
  2. Own 15 shares purchased at 77c that National will win
  3. Short sold 20 shares at 50c for third quarter inflation at 1c per 0.1%
  4. Short sold 290 shares at 34c that Peters will make it back
  5. Short sold 275 shares at 27c that Peters will not be sacked or resigned

Latest Dog Toys Poll

Helen still has a commanding lead amongst the pooches and Campbell is also beating out Sainsbury.

Sideswipe also has this photo and story:

Jarrod was in an Animates pet store last Saturday, getting the usual supplies for his animals, when suddenly he realised he was being watched … by John Campbell. “In front of the counter was the attached picture. Special-edition ‘Election 08’ chew toys for dogs. I don’t need to explain who is who in the photo – they really are that good. However, there was someone missing , so I asked the staff, ‘Where’s Helen?’ … The staff replied, ‘She’s sold out’.”

Also Stuff had this story on Tuesday regarding the promotion.

Roughan on Bridges

QC backs SFO Director against attacks

QC Jim Farmer has criticised Helen Clark and Michael Cullen for their attacks on the Director of the Serious Fraud Office. Farmer is a past president of the Bar Association.

Jim Farmer said criticism of Mr Liddell’s judgment by Prime Minister Helen Clark and her deputy, Michael Cullen, was wrong and unwarranted.

Mr Liddell’s evidence was uncovered in the SFO investigation and showed that Mr Peters had a $40,000 debt paid for him by the Spencer Trust, contradicting his version that he paid it himself.

Dr Farmer said Mr Liddell had a simple choice: whether it was responsible to “sit on” relevant information, or to hand it over.

And Labour wanted the information supressed, because it reveals that Peters broke the Cabinet Manual and Register of Interests even more blatantly than in the Owen Glenn case.

“He has obviously taken a responsible decision. It is very defensible on its merits and it doesn’t warrant attack from politicians, particularly personal attacks in the form of saying he has poor judgment.”

Dr Farmer may not understand that for Clark and Cullen, a public servant exercises poor judgement if they do not act in the best interests of the Labour Party, as opposed to acting in the public interest. You see they have convinced themselves that nothing is more important for the public good than them remaining in power, so anything that may damage that is automatically poor judgement by the public servant involved.

Dr Farmer said there was no formal requirement for Mr Liddell to consult Crown Law and he had “no idea” why Helen Clark and Dr Cullen were suggesting this.

“In carrying out the investigative duties, the SFO and the director are intended to be independent and operate without influence from anyone,” he said.

“Running off to Crown Law or the Solicitor-General to get advice – or approval, if that’s what Dr Cullen is suggesting – doesn’t seem to be obvious or even right.”

Indeed. And in fact a growing number of Government Departments no longer even use Crown Law for their legal advice or representation in court.

Thank goodness

The ultimate nanny state initiative – the Public Health Bill, is not going to be rammed through before the election.

Thank God. This law would have given massive powers to the Government by treating non-communicable conditions such as obesity the same as SARS or Ebola. Advertisers, shop keepers, even the media could be regulated by Government decree in the interests of “public health”.

If Labour is re-elected they will push this law through unchanged. National has pledged to get rid of the powers around non-communicable diseases so the Government can’t set a maximum size for chocolate bars, dictate how big in store signs can be, instrict shop keepers what food to display and what food to hide etc etc.

Listening to the advisors

John Key addressed the PSA conference yesterday. A cap on the number of public servants is probably not the most popular policy there, but one pledge went down well:

“National will expect a high degree of professionalism from the public service, part of which is telling ministers what they are not comfortable hearing,” Mr Key said. “As part of this openness, policy advisers will be able to take part in Cabinet committee discussions where it is appropriate.

“That’s because advisers can exercise better judgment if they have a better understanding of the context in which they are making those judgments.”

Under the previous National government, senior officials sat in on Cabinet committee meetings, but this changed when Labour took power and the officials were made to wait outside, called in only when they were needed.

I wasn’t aware that even the Cabinet Committees had got so politicised that officials were excluded from them.

At Back Benches last night

Further to the the two stories yesterday from lifetime Labour voters who will not vote Labour this time due to Labour’s condoning of Peters’, I had an interesting encounter at the Backbencher last night, after Back Benches.

A gentleman came over to me and asked if I was David Farrar. He was in his 50s I would say. When I responded that I was he said he wanted to tell me something but put it in context.

He told me how he hates the National Party and would never vote for them. In fact his exact words were “I would rather take out a knife, cut off my cock and stuff it down my throat than vote for National”. He also went on to say he does not agree with any of my political views, which he finds repugnant. In fact he joked (I hope he was joking) that if I was crossing a road and he was in a car, he would speed up.

After having got that out of the way, he then went on to say how disgusted he is with Labour over Winston Peters (and ironically Winston was in the room as he had turned up to watch Back Benches), that their tolerance and implicit condoning of his activities verges on corruption, and how they need to be thrown out of office for a couple of terms.

Voting to defend Winston was a step too far even for Jim Anderton. And it seems for a growing number of lifeling Labour voters.

Espiner on the Vote

I missed an update Colin Espiner did on the vote yesterday. It is worth repeating in full:

Labour and NZ First voted against the privileges committee motion to censure, but every other party in Parliament – including independents Philip Field and Gordon Copeland – voted in favour, so the motion passed comfortably.

This was a relief, as it meant Labour and Winston Peters failed to pervert the cause of justice and will of the majority despite the most underhand of tactics. As I’ve said below in this post, Labour’s attempt to politicise the committee and discredit its findings was shameful – amongst the worst things the party has done in the past nine years, in my opinion.

That is really strong language, but justified. This is why lifelong Labour voters are saying they can stomach no more. You had the Attorney-General of New Zealand repeating Winston’s conspiracy theories about how Owen Glenn was coached by his Fay Richwhite supplied lawyer. Yes, seriously. I will blog the Hansard when it is available.

As for Peters, his utter lack of contrition, humility, and failure to show even the slightest respect for the judgment of his peers was nauseous. He has become a parody – a caricature of belligerence, contempt, hubris, and narcissism. His address to Parliament last night was ugly, brutal, and sad. The shame of it all is that if just 5% of New Zealanders either believe him or feel sorry enough to vote for him he will be back triumphant.

It was ugly. There was not even a small fraction of contrition from Winston. Quite the opposite. As MPs such as Russel Norman were making dignified serious to the point speeches, Peters was barracking them almost non stop. It was an insight into how truly ugly this man is. Muldoon was benign by comparison.

Labour have chosen to put all their eggs in with Winston. There is no less deserving person. It wasn’t even that Peters has no respect for the judgment of his peers. He has no respect for anyone but himself. He does not accept in any way he is bound by rules or accountability or obligations. Sadly this is partly because Helen Clark has freed him from all the normal Ministerial obligations such as telling the truth, disclosing interests, following the Cabinet Manual.

Sharples says Labour tried to “pervert the course of justice”

Not only were Labour turning a blind eye to Peters corruption, they were threatening and lobbying other parties to do the same.

NZPA reports:

Maori Party co-leader Pita Sharples says a New Zealand First staffer and Government minister tried to put pressure on his party over how it would vote in yesterday’s censure motion against Winston Peters. …

“I personally had two separate phone calls from a senior minister urging me to vote in favour of Winston, and suggesting that there would be unpleasant repercussions from Maori people if I didn’t,” he said in a statement….

“Both (fellow co-leader) Tariana Turia and myself were disgusted with this kind of activity, aimed at perverting the course of justice and fair play.”

Labour First are quite simply a corrupt party, and they should go.

The Prime Minister’s hypocrisy is unmatched on this. She claims the outcome of the Privileges Committee was not credible because of partisan politics, and her own Ministers are trying to heavy and threaten the Maori Party to vote against, despite their belief in the evidence.

The same Prime Minister who has not even read a copy of the Privileges Committee report, yet says there is nothing in it that would casue her to drop Winston.

UPDATE: the full press release from Sharples is over the break

Continue reading »

A Labour voter writes

I have been sent this e-mail, which speaks for itself. It was sent on Tuesday night. I have met the author once or twice (but not for some years) and can testify that he is absolutely who he says he is – this is not some National voter pretending to be a Labour supporter. I suspect he is not alone with his thoughts:

Dear Prime Minister,

Never in 43 years as a registered voter have I ever voted other than for Labour as I suspect was true of my father before me. However, the events of recent weeks in respect of Mr Peters have finally disillusioned me, and I shall not vote Labour again until the passage of time has cleansed the party of those members who are (in my opinion corruptly) responsible for the failure to act on deceit which was obvious to all. I have read and followed closely every piece of news I could find throughout this silly mess, and I have to say that the Labour Party’s position lacks all credibility.

You called for an election based on trust. I am sorry I can no longer extend that to you.

Even the wisest and most sober of media commentators have all but laughed out loud at the preposterous and self-serving rationalisations that have come from senior members of the party.

The hardest political decision of my life will be to vote National for the first time, but you have left me no choice. They now seem to me to be the least of a very poor bunch of evils.

yours in deep sorrow


xxxxx xxxxxx

Maybe National’s campaign slogan should be “Vote for the lesser evil” 🙂

More seriously, the e-mail gives an idea of how tough this decision must have been. The writer voted Labour in 1966, 1969, 1972, 1975, 1978, 1981, 1984, 1987, 1990, 1993, 1996, 1999, 2002 and 2005. That is a party loyalty few could match. But the condoning of Winston’s lies is just too much to ignore.

UPDATE: Deborah, who has voted for Labour in every election except her first, says she will not vote for Labour this time unless they rule out Peters:

I can’t vote for Labour knowing that might lead to the champion of hair splitting hypocrisy returning to government. …

I’ve been thinking more about this over lunch, and I think that what is upsetting me so much is that Labour is inviting me to be complicit in their “courageous corruption.” We all know pollies lie, but rarely is it so obvious, and so self-serving, as has been in the case of Winston Peters. It all stinks to high heaven, and then some. By not ruling him out, and still asking me to vote for them, at best Helen Clark and Labour are asking me to block my nose, to pretend that the stench isn’t there. But more realistically, they are asking me to buy the stink in order to have a Labour government. “That’s just what it costs,” they are telling me.

Quite simply, I refuse to pay the price. I will not collude in returning Winston Peters to influence in any government.

Hat Tip: Homepaddock

Back Benches tonight

Could be fun tonight:

  • Ron Mark New Zealand First
  • Winnie Laban Labour
  • Gordon Copeland Kiwi Party
  • Russel Norman from the Greens.

They’ll be talking Privileges Committee, the trade deal with the United States and Fonterra did they tell soon enough.

If you’re in Wellington, come on down to the Backbencher pub between 8 and 8.30pm… (the show starts just after 9pm); otherwise tune into TVNZ 7 (on Freeview) or on-line at tvnzondemand.co.nz

Short Selling

I didn’t realise this, but you don’t need stock on iPredict to sell it. No seriously. Short selling is legal. You can sell stock you don’t own – you just to have to buy it at some later stage.

This is great – if you think a stock is over-priced, you can short sell it. I may start short selling some Winston.resign stock as nothign short of Peters actually being arrested is going to force Clark to sack him, in my opinion,

Praise for VUWSA

I’ve been critical of VUWSA when members of their executive do stupid or obnoxious things. So it is only fair I should praise them when they do good.

VUWSA has been somewhat dysfunctional for many years – little reliable budgeting and expenditure control. But his year’s executive have done a change proposal they are consulting on.

I’ll summarise the proposal below. Ironically it aims to solve many of the issues that a group of centre right students (known as the A-Team) unsucessfully campaigned on last year.

  • Orientation costs of up to $180,000 to be reduced, especially in line with falling participation. Students are more interested in events in the CBD which have greater variety. VUWSA could coat-tail on some of these, negotiating ticket prices. Also look to partner with Cuba Street Carnival, Jazz Festival etc.
  • Reinstate Team Victoria MOU between VUIW and VUWSA  to reduce duplication in clubs administration and facilities
  • Relocate IT Support to VUW IT Services
  • All the above are to focus VUWSA on core functions of advocacy
  • Restructure the three full time staff roles of Advertising and Sponsorship Manager, Campus Activities Co-ordinator and Clubs Development Officer
  • Recognise the Executive is not well placed to manage staff due to high turnover
  • Proposed that they convert the latter two staff roles to contractors for specific roles such as an Events Organiser.
  • Turn the Advertising and Sponsorship Manager into a Salient Business Manager
  • Negotiate a SLA with VUW Student Union for clubs support

As I said, I am quite impressed with their analysis of a need to focus on core advocacy, to reduce staffing levels, and use a mixture of contractors and a relationship with VUW itself to provide other services to students.

I understand Sonny Thomas (VUWSA VP and Young Labour VP) was one of those involved in the plan, and is campaign for 2009 VUWSA President on the basis of implementing it (subject to consultation). I saw him at the Internet Debate last night and joked I was going to endorse him on Kiwiblog, this damning his campaign – he looked truly panicked at the possibility.  So I’ll restrict myself to merely endorsing the reform proposal and saying I hope that whoever wins, is willing to implement it.

New electorate and list candidates listing

Thanks to some assistance from readers, the 2008 candidates page has now been expanded. It has:

  1. A spreadsheet with a list of candidates for all 70 electorates from National, Labour, Maori, ACT, NZ First, United, Greens, Progressive, Family, Kiwi and Pacific parties.
  2. A second sheet on the spreadsheet with the party lists for every party that has released one
  3. The current HTML table (with hyperlinks) of the two or three major candidates for each electorate

I hope people find it a good resource. Let me know of any additions as they are known.

Rich and Maharey

Editorials on Peters

The three major editorials are all on Peters today. First the Herald:

It is stating the obvious to say Winston Peters should have resigned as a minister some time ago. And that he should go now, after the censure delivered by Parliament’s privileges committee. He will not, of course, and, the New Zealand First leader may even see a silver lining in that dark cloud. The Prime Minister has said she will not reinstate him as Foreign Minister, but that he will remain a minister without portfolio. As such, Mr Peters is free to hit the campaign trail with the salary and perks of a minister but none of the responsibilities.

All baubles, no work.

The Prime Minister sought to construct one by calling the committee “tainted” and suggesting most of its members were politically motivated. The criticism was tawdry. No representatives on the committee had, out of necessity, a more highly politicised view of Mr Peters than those of Labour.

And she admits she has not even read the report.

Now The Press which has a simple headline of “Sack Peters”:

The seriousness of the report means that Peters should not be reinstated as foreign minister, a position in which the qualities of credibility and trustworthiness are crucial. So why is it that for the next two months or more, until the shape of the next government is known, he is allowed to retain his ministerial salary and the other perks of the job? The only answer is that it is still politically expedient for Labour to let him cling to the baubles of office.

I think they are worried if they take his baubles off him, he will remove their ones.

Peters, after weeks of self-righteous bluster and confusing problems of recollection, reacted in typical fashion. He slammed the committee members who found against him, claiming that they had prejudged the issue for political reasons and applied retrospectively a new interpretation of Parliament’s rules. This, according to Peters, had “echoes of Zimbabwe” and, oddly enough, he was right.

In Zimbabwe, after all, there is a certain political leader whose stock response to any criticism is to clamp down on the news media and to claim that he is the victim of murky conspiracies. And that same leader has exhibited a grim determination to hold on to the trappings of power.

We’re just fortuntate that most of his supporters are too elderly to invade farms!

The Government has clearly taken a gamble. It believes that Peters will return to Parliament after this year’s election, courtesy of him persuading 5 per cent of voters to believe him, and that with his support in some capacity Labour could lead a fourth consecutive administration. But it is far more likely that voters will be aghast that Peters has not been sacked or stripped of his baubles and judge Labour itself to be guilty by association.

As the saying goes, a vote for Labour is a vote for Winston in Government and a vote for Winston is a vote for a Labour-led Government.

Finally the Dom Post:

Pared back to its essentials, what that means is that the committee did not believe the evidence presented to it by Mr Peters and his lawyer Brian Henry. There is another, shorter, word to describe what the committee made of their testimony.

They lied. Many many times in fact.

The committee was presented with two conflicting versions of events. One was internally consistent and supported in material parts by documentation; the other was subject to frequent revision and unsupported by documents. Mr Peters and his lawyer were given multiple opportunities to come up with a version of events that fitted plausibly with the known facts. Their inability to do so left the majority of the committee with no option but to conclude their evidence was unreliable.

Except for Labour First MPs.

In Mr Peters’ case, Miss Clark has the power to demonstrate that such conduct is not acceptable for ministers in her government. That she has not done so because she harbours the hope that support from NZ First might enable her to form a fourth government after the election is a matter of regret.

You have to wonder if there is any conduct that Clark would sack Peters for. Any at all?

Well done Gordon

It is worth noting that Gordon Copeland also played a very useful role in the decision to censure Peters.

Gordon filed the Privileges Complaint that Peters got caught on. Rodney filed one relating to payment of a debt while Gordon’s was on receiving gift. And in the end it ws Gordon’s complaint that held up.

Now I suspect that even if Gordon’s complaint had not gone in, the Privileges Committee would still have have made the findings they did, as even if the original complaint was under one section of the rules of the Register, they would not ignore a breach under a different rule.

But regardless worth noting Gordon’s useful role in this.

Craccum interviews some candidates

Craccum did some fun interviews with a few candidates this week. Some of the questions they asked are worth repeating here.

Wellington is burning down and you can take only one other MP with you, who would you take and why?

  • Pete Hodgson (Lab) – Rodney Hide because he’s so full of piss, we could use him to put the fire out.
  • Pita Sharples (Maori) – Tariana Turia or she’d haunt me if I left her there.

If you can define your life in terms of isms, what would it be?

  • Aaron Galey-Young (UFNZ) – Antidisestablishmentarianism
  • Pita Sharples – Dreamism
  • Oliver Woods (RAM) – Social democratic left pragmatic nationalism
  • Nikki Kaye (Nat) – Environmentalism, capitalism, compassionism, sportism, wineism

What would be your ultimate campaign song and why?

  • Pita Sharples – ‘What’s the matter you ah shut appa your face’.
  • Oliver Woods – ‘Crush ‘em’ by Megadeth

Greatest New Zealander, Garth George or Owen Glenn?

  • Pete Hodgson – Tim Shadbolt
  • Pita Sharples – Kupe
  • Oliver Woods – The Mad Butcher
  • Nikki Kaye – There are many great kiwis but if I had to choose between the two I would pick Owen Glenn because of his suggestion to hold international volley ball competitions if he became consul to Monaco – that’s gutsy.

If you were Jim Anderton, what would you ban and why?

  • Pete Hodgson – Who Wants to be a Millionaire?
  • Peter Taskhoff (ACT) – I’d ban toxic politics but then Jim Anderton would be left speechless.
  • Aaron Galley-Young: Boy racers in public streets.
  • Pita Sharples – I would ban Jim Anderton.
  • Oliver Woods – Elderly, useless, conservative politicians.
  • Nikki Kaye – If I was Jim Anderton I would need a completely new wardrobe and I would ban myself from wearing short skirts.

A pdf of the Craccum article is here – backpage.

Censured

The House has just voted to censure Winston Peters 62 – 56 as recommended by the Privileges Committee. It has also instructed him to file amended returns for the periods ending 31 January 2006, 31 January 2007 and 31 January 2008.

Anderton abstained and everyone except Labour First voted in favour.

Even Taito Philip Field voted to censure Peters. Now that has to hurt!

This is not an ending. It will be very interesting to see what new gifts he reveals in the amended returns.